a tmospheric, o ceanic and s pace s ciences university of michigan daniel j. gershman, james a....

16
ATMOSPHERIC, OCEANIC AND SPACE SCIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson, Haje Korth, and Sean C. Solomon Heavy ions in Mercury’s magnetotail 4 th SERENA – HEWG Meeting Key Largo, FL

Upload: kory-walker

Post on 27-Dec-2015

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

ATMOSPHERIC, OCEANIC

AND SPACE SCIENCESUNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN

Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen,

Brian J. Anderson, Haje Korth, and Sean C. Solomon

Heavy ions in Mercury’s magnetotail

4th SERENA – HEWG MeetingKey Largo, FL

Page 2: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

IntroductionZurbuchen et al., Science, 2011

Central plasma sheet in Mercury’s magnetotail

Page 3: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Introduction

Motivating science questions: How are solar wind ions and planetary ions ‘processed’ differently

in Mercury’s magnetospheric system?

What kind of velocity distribution function is appropriate for describing heavy ions in Mercury’s magnetotail? (e.g., ring, shell, Maxwellian, etc…)

What is the contribution of heavy ions to the pressure and mass density in the plasma sheet?

Page 4: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

FIPS Plasma Parameters

The Fast Imaging Plasma Spectrometer (FIPS) on MESSENGER is a time-of-flight mass spectrometer

FIPS measures ions with E/q between 50eV/e – 13keV/e

Ion species regularly measured by FIPS: Solar wind: H+, He2+, O6++C5+ (i.e., <OC>) Planetary: He+, O+ group (m/q 14-20), Na+ group (m/q 21-30)

Page 5: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

FIPS Plasma Parameters

Limited plasma parameters can be derived from FIPS measurements of partial velocity distribution functions

Raines et al., PSS, 2011

Page 6: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Distribution Function Visualization: H+

Magnetosheath Flank

Plasma Sheet

Page 7: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Distribution Function Visualization: H+

Magnetosheath Flank

Plasma Sheet

Measured Data

Equivalent Isotropic Maxwellian

1 FIPS Event (assuming isotropy)

2 FIPS Events (assuming isotropy)

Page 8: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

FIPS Plasma Parameters

108

104

106

Diff

eren

tial E

nerg

y F

lux

(cm

-2 s

-1 s

r-1 [k

eV/e

]-1)

Page 9: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Example Orbit: 12 Feb 2012 (668)

108

104

106

Diff

eren

tial E

nerg

y F

lux

(cm

-2 s

-1 s

r-1 [k

eV/e

]-1)(a)

(b)

Plasma Sheet Cusp MSHBSMP

Post-midnight Plasma Sheet

Page 10: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Example Orbit: 23 Feb 2012 (691)

108

104

106

Diff

eren

tial E

nerg

y F

lux

(cm

-2 s

-1 s

r-1 [k

eV/e

]-1)

(a)

(b)

MSH Plasma Sheet Cusp MSHBSMPMP

Pre-midnight Plasma Sheet

Na+ group ions are enhanced in the pre-midnight plasma sheet(Zurbuchen et al., Science, 2011; Raines et al., JGR, 2013)

Page 11: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Average Plasma Sheet Properties

We identify the plasma sheet from FIPS: Two ranges encompassing 12-hr ‘hot season’ orbits:

10 Nov 2011 – 5 Dec 2011, 5 Feb 2012 – 2 Mar 2012 > 50 measured proton events per scan Within ±45o magnetic latitude on the nightside

We accumulate all events measured in the plasma sheet during several orbits to examine heavy ion distribution functions

Page 12: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Plasma Sheet: Solar Wind Ions

nMB=0.02 cm-3, TMB=103.75 MK

(c) <OC>(b) He2+

nMB=0.23 cm-3, TMB=30.3 MK

Measured Data

Moment-derived Maxwellian1 FIPS Event

2 FIPS Events

(a) H+

nMB= 11.22 cm-3, TMB= 8.4 MK(with high energy tail)

Pre-midnight Plasma Sheet (10 Nov 2011 – 5 Dec 2011, 5 Feb 2012 – 2 Mar 2012)

Page 13: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Plasma Sheet: Planetary Ions

(a) Na+ group (b) O+ group (c) He+

nMB=0.34 cm-3, TMB=13.6 MK nMB=0.08 cm-3, TMB=12.6 MKnMB=0.03 cm-3, TMB=9.4MK

Measured Data

Moment-derived Maxwellian

1 FIPS Event

2 FIPS Events

Pre-midnight Plasma Sheet (10 Nov 2011 – 5 Dec 2011, 5 Feb 2012 – 2 Mar 2012)

Page 14: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Average Plasma Sheet Properties

Solar wind-like abundances Relative abundances consistent with Raines et al., JGR, 2013

Planetary ions have similar energy distributions

Energization process of planetary ions does not have a strong affect on bulk solar wind ions

Pre-midnight Post-midnight

Plasma Sheet (10 Nov 2011 – 5 Dec 2011, 5 Feb 2012 – 2 Mar 2012)

Page 15: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

How are solar wind ions and planetary ions ‘processed’ differently in Mercury’s magnetospheric system? Solar wind ions maintain expected upstream abundance ratios and experience mass proportional heating across

the subsolar bow shock. These properties are preserved even after the solar wind gains access to Mercury’s magnetosphere through subsolar reconnection.

What kind of velocity distribution function is appropriate for describing heavy ions in Mercury’s magnetosphere? (e.g., ring, shell, Maxwellian, etc…) The measured fluxes of all ion species in the tail are consistent with hot Maxwell-Boltzmann velocity

distributions, more so than energy-localized ring or thin shell distributions. The absence of regularly measured flux at lower energies is most likely a result of the FIPS’ finite sensitivity.

What is the contribution of heavy ions to the pressure and mass density in the plasma sheet? For the average post-midnight plasma sheet, we find that planetary ions contribute ~1% of the total plasma

pressure and ~ 10% of the mass density in the nightside plasma sheet. All heavy ions (including those of solar wind origin) contribute 10% and ~15%, to the plasma pressure and mass density, respectively.

For the average pre-midnight plasma sheet, we find that planetary ions contribute ~5% of the total plasma pressure and ~ 40% of the mass density in the nightside plasma sheet. All heavy ions (including those of solar wind origin) contribute ~15% and ~50%, to the plasma pressure and mass density, respectively.

Do heavy ions at Mercury influence the plasma sheet dynamics?

Conclusions

Page 16: A TMOSPHERIC, O CEANIC AND S PACE S CIENCES UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN Daniel J. Gershman, James A. Slavin, Jim M. Raines, Thomas H. Zurbuchen, Brian J. Anderson,

Questions?

[email protected]