a1.2 what gets counted counts_catherine birken

18
TARGet Kids! Practice Based Primary Care Research Network Catherine S Birken MD, MSc, FRCPC

Upload: aohc-acso

Post on 31-Mar-2016

233 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Prevent More to Treat Less | Public Health and Primary Health Care Together conference - Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

TARGet Kids! Practice Based Primary Care Research Network

Catherine S Birken MD, MSc, FRCPC

Page 2: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Disclosure of Commercial Support CFPC Conflict of Interest

Presenter Disclosure Presenters: Catherine Birken, Richard Birtwhislte, Irfan Dhalla, Ruth Sanderson, Mari Teitelbaum, Karen Tu Relationships with commercial interests: • Grants/Research Support: None • Speakers Bureau/Honoraria: None • Consulting Fees: None • Other: None

Page 3: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Faculty/Presenter Disclosure

• Presenter: Catherine Birken

• Relationships with commercial interests: – None

CFPC CoI Templates: Slide 1

Presenter
Presentation Notes
This slide must be visually presented to the audience AND verbalized by the speaker.
Page 4: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Practice Based Research Network www.targetkids.ca

Page 5: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Practice Embedded Data Collection

LABORATORY SERVICES Mount Sinai Services

DATA MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

Applied Health Research Centre

Secure web-based data management using

Medidata RAVE™ software

Primary Healthcare Practice Age newborn to 5 years

Height, weight, BMI waist circumference,

blood pressure, head circumference,

parent BMI

Questionnaires

Laboratory tests

A research assistant trained in phlebotomy is embedded in each practice site

Page 6: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Village Park Paediatrics Dr. Eddy Lau

Dr. Brian Chisamore Dr. Sharon Naymark

Tarandeep Malhi (RA)

Clairhurst Paediatrics

Dr. Michael Peer Dr. Sheila Jacobson Dr. Carolyn Taylor

Subitha Rajakumaran (RA)

Danforth Paediatrics A

Dr. Patricia Neelands Dr. Janet Saunderson

Dr. Anh Do Laurie Thompson (RA)

Danforth Paediatrics B

Dr. Marty Perlmutar Dr. Karoon Danayan Dr. Alana Rosenthal

Juela Sejdo (RA)

St Michael’s Hospital 410 Sherbourne Family Medicine

Clinic Dr. Susan Shepherd

Nadia Kabir (RA)

Research Leads: Dr. Patricia Parkin

Dr. Catherine Birken Dr. Jonathon Maguire

Research Managers/Coordinators:

Kanthi Kavikondala Matthew D’Ascanio

Steering Committee: Dr. Mark Feldman

Dr. Moshe Ipp Dr. Brian Chisamore Dr. Tony Barozzino

LABORATORY SERVICES Mount Sinai Services

Dr. Azar Azad

DATA MANAGEMENT Applied Health Research Centre

Dr. Muhammad Mamdani Magda Melo Kevin Thorpe

Dr. Gerald Lebovic Yang Chen

St Michael’s Hospital Pediatric Ambulatory

Clinic Dr. Tony Barozzino Dr. Michael Sgro

Dr. Sloane Freeman Tonya D’Amour (RA)

St Michael’s

Hospital 80 Bond Street

Family Medicine Clinic

Dr. Nav Persaud Richa Kukkar (RA)

Humber Paediatrics

Dr Peter Wong Dr Robert Lau

Dr Barbara Smiltnieks Dr Keewai Fung

Dr Michael Dorey

Page 7: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

A Platform for Surveillance of Growth and Behaviour Trajectories

Time Gro

wth

and

Hea

lth B

ehav

iour

s

Page 9: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Instrument Schedule NHQ NS IBQ ECBQ CBQ NDDS ITC PSI

0 weeks

1 month

2 months

4 months

6 months

9 months

12 months

15 months

18 months

2 years

3 years 4 years

5 years

6+ years

Page 10: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

A Platform for Randomized Trials

rand

omize

Group A Group B

Page 11: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Total (N = 5062)

Demographics Frequency (N, %) Median (Range) Child’s age, months 0 - < 1 years 1 - < 3 years 3 - < 6 years

511 (10.1) 2441 (48.3) 2110 (41.7)

25 (0.2 – 72)

Child’s sex, male 2646 (52.3) Mother’s place of birth In Canada Outside of Canada Missing

3144 (62.1) 1707 (33.7) 211 (4.2)

Child Health Child’s zBMI Underweight (z < -1) Normal weight (-1≥ z ≤1)

681 (13.5) 3143 (62.1)

0.1 (-4.7 – 6.2)

Overweight (1> z ≤2) 708 (14.0) Obese (z > 2) 225 (4.4) Missing 305 (6.0)

Breastfeeding duration, months 10 (0 – 48) 0 – 6 months 901 (17.8) 6 – 12 months 2274 (44.9) 12 – 24 months 24 months + Never Missing

1103 (21.8) 149 (2.9) 353 (7.0) 282 (5.6)

Baseline Characteristics of TARGet Kids! Cohort

Page 12: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken
Page 13: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Cardiovascular risk associated with eating behaviours during early childhood

CMAJ, 2013

Page 14: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Intervention: 10 minute ‘doc talk’ at 3 year old visit reduce screen time remove screen from bedroom turn off TV during meals

Page 15: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken
Page 16: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Approaches to Data Collection

Characteristics

Canadian Health Measures Survey

Electronic Medical Records

Practice Based Research Network

Representative National ?RegionalNational LocalRegional National

Sample size Small Large Large

Age Excludes 0-3 All who attends All recruited

Design Cross-sectional Longitudinal Longitudinal

Measure Health outcomes

Yes Limited Yes

Evaluate Interventions

Limited Health system Interventions

Trials

Health behaviours

Yes Limited Yes

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Data from older children may be less representative they have fewer primary care visits than younger children they have fewer visits in which a weight and height are recorded there may be an ascertainment bias whereas physicians only do a weight and height in older children if they appear overweight or this is brought up as a concern strategies such as extending the window of observation, or quality improvement (feedback and audit) or policy initiatives (eg. pay-for-performance measures around BMI screening) may help improve height/weight or BMI documentation at annual visits Conclusions: If scaled up to include a larger sample of primary care EMRs a robust data infrastructure from electronic medical records (EMRALD as a prototype) could be used to efficiently conduct population-based surveillance of child and youth overweight and obesity in Ontario. evaluate the impact of population-based interventions (school or neighbourhood-based) evaluate primary care health systems level interventions (practice based use of dieticians, pay for performance for BMI screening etc) Appoaches to data collection: Clyde herttzman
Page 17: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

• Large sample young children • Embedded data collection and

knowledge translation • Platform for Surveillance and Trials • Scale up to sentinal sites • Complements other data sources

TARGet Kids! Summary

Page 18: A1.2 What Gets Counted Counts_Catherine Birken

Practice Based Research Network www.targetkids.ca