aci 302 120319 dallas minutes - american concrete institute
TRANSCRIPT
Microsoft Word - ACI 302 120319 Dallas minutes.docmGUIDE FOR
CONCRETE FLOOR AND SLAB CONSTRUCTION
Monday, March 19, 2012
Dallas, Texas ______________________________________________________________________________ ATTENDANCE:
Voting Members (attending) - 26 Joseph F. Neuber Jr. (Chair), Patrick Harrison (Vice-Chair), Russell Neudeck (Secretary), Dennis Ahal, Kenneth Beaudoin, Bryan Birdwell, Peter Craig, Allen Face, Barry Foreman, Greg Fricks, Terry Fricks, Jerry Holland, Philip Kopf, Steve Lloyd, Arthur McKinney, Mike McPhee, Scott Metzger, Jeff Miller, Nigel Parkes, William Phelan, John Rohrer, Paul Rouis, Tommy Ruttura, Bruce Suprenant, Scott Tarr, Donald Ytterberg
Voting Members (not attending):7 Robert Anderson, Rick Felder, Edward Finkel, Milan Lipensky, Kevin MacDonald, Scott Niemitalo, Tim Robinson,
TAC Contact Member:
Associate Members See attached Sign In Sheet
Visitors: See attached Sign In Sheet
1.0 Welcome and Introduction.
1.1 Meeting was called to order at 8:30 am. Self introductions were given by all in attendance. Attendance sheets were distributed.
1.2 Please remember to confirm your email address located on the ACI website.
1.3 We have a busy day with a goal to cover chapters 8 and 11.
1.4 A count of the voting member was taken. Initially there were 25, ultimately 26.
1.5 The Chair recognized Bill Phelen for his 50 years of involvement with ACI and Art
McKinney as a Fellow 2.0 Approval of Minutes:
2.1 Motion made and seconded to approve minutes of previous Cincinnati meeting. 3.0 Liaison Reports:
• 117 - Tolerances (Eldon Tipping): Undergoing TAC review, 200 editorial comments.
• 130 - ACI certification (Kevin MacDonald): No update
• 223 - Shrinkage Compensation (John Rohrer): 223 completed in 2010, now back into task groups – getting started.
• 224 - Control of Cracking (???): No report.
• 301 - Specifications for Concrete (Scott Tarr): Started next cycle for 2015 publish date. Sections 10 & 11 balloted. Negatives to be worked on this meeting.
• 329 - Sustainable Design In Concrete (Jay Shilstone): No update
• 330 - Concrete Parking Lots and Site Paving (Tim Cost): Final resolution underway. Progress on industrial pavement.
• 360 - Design of Slabs on Ground (Barry Foreman): Just getting started up again
• 544 – Fiber Reinforced 329 (Mike McPhee): In transition, working on technical notes now.
• 640 – Finisher Certification (Bob Simonelli) No update 4.0 Old Business
• Bill Phelan – Concrete slabs over vapor retarder field testing: Not enough data to make an industry statement. It looks like 0.04% shrinkage on poly is “no problem”. Per Harrison, dominant joints are a big issue and this committee needs to address it. Neuber may have a project that is measureable. McPhee has had recent experience using extended jointing (with steel fibers) at 75 to 100’ with minimal curling.
• Dennis Ahal – Finishing lightweight concrete: Deny provided a summary of finishing problems related to air entrained concrete and cautioned that specifying higher F numbers require enhanced finishing equipment use which may lead to delamination issues.
• Peter Craig – Avoiding moisture related problems: No ongoing research – should be ready within several months
• Pat Harrison – Liquid surface treatment standard: Need to get going ahead with this. Will revitalize it with chair..
5.0 Sub-Committees: Where we are now and where we are headed
• Chapters 1 and 10 – (Alan Face): On hold until next round of revisions.
• Chapter 2 – Classes of floors – (Pat Harrison): Complete and ready to go.
• Chapter 3 – Design Considerations (Wayne Walker/ Mike McPhee): Complete
• Chapter 4 – Site Preparation and Placing Environment (Wayne Walker/ Mike McPhee): Complete. Complete
• Chapter 5 – Materials (Kevin MacDonald): Complete.
• Chapter 6 – Concrete Properties and Consistency (Joe Neuber / Ed Finkel): Complete.
• Chapter 7 – Batching, Mixing and Transporation (Kevin MacDonald): Complete.
• Chapter 8 – Placing, Consolidating and Finishing (Terry Fricks): Complete.
• Chapter 9 – Curing, Protection and Joint Filling (Peter Craig): Complete.
• Chapter 10 – Quality Control Checklist (Alan Face): On hold until next revision.
• Chapter 11 – Causes of Floor and Slab Surface Imperfections (Scott Tarr): Negatives to be discussed and resolved this meeting.
• Chapter 12 – References (Pat Harrison): Will be completed as chapters are completed.
6.0 New Business
6.1 Resolved most of negative votes from recent ballot. The remainder to be done before Toronto.
6.2 Report from Art McKinney on “Sweating Slab” Syndrome. 7.0 Adjournment:
Monday, March 19, 2012
Dallas, Texas ______________________________________________________________________________ ATTENDANCE:
Voting Members (attending) - 26 Joseph F. Neuber Jr. (Chair), Patrick Harrison (Vice-Chair), Russell Neudeck (Secretary), Dennis Ahal, Kenneth Beaudoin, Bryan Birdwell, Peter Craig, Allen Face, Barry Foreman, Greg Fricks, Terry Fricks, Jerry Holland, Philip Kopf, Steve Lloyd, Arthur McKinney, Mike McPhee, Scott Metzger, Jeff Miller, Nigel Parkes, William Phelan, John Rohrer, Paul Rouis, Tommy Ruttura, Bruce Suprenant, Scott Tarr, Donald Ytterberg
Voting Members (not attending):7 Robert Anderson, Rick Felder, Edward Finkel, Milan Lipensky, Kevin MacDonald, Scott Niemitalo, Tim Robinson,
TAC Contact Member:
Associate Members See attached Sign In Sheet
Visitors: See attached Sign In Sheet
1.0 Welcome and Introduction.
1.1 Meeting was called to order at 8:30 am. Self introductions were given by all in attendance. Attendance sheets were distributed.
1.2 Please remember to confirm your email address located on the ACI website.
1.3 We have a busy day with a goal to cover chapters 8 and 11.
1.4 A count of the voting member was taken. Initially there were 25, ultimately 26.
1.5 The Chair recognized Bill Phelen for his 50 years of involvement with ACI and Art
McKinney as a Fellow 2.0 Approval of Minutes:
2.1 Motion made and seconded to approve minutes of previous Cincinnati meeting. 3.0 Liaison Reports:
• 117 - Tolerances (Eldon Tipping): Undergoing TAC review, 200 editorial comments.
• 130 - ACI certification (Kevin MacDonald): No update
• 223 - Shrinkage Compensation (John Rohrer): 223 completed in 2010, now back into task groups – getting started.
• 224 - Control of Cracking (???): No report.
• 301 - Specifications for Concrete (Scott Tarr): Started next cycle for 2015 publish date. Sections 10 & 11 balloted. Negatives to be worked on this meeting.
• 329 - Sustainable Design In Concrete (Jay Shilstone): No update
• 330 - Concrete Parking Lots and Site Paving (Tim Cost): Final resolution underway. Progress on industrial pavement.
• 360 - Design of Slabs on Ground (Barry Foreman): Just getting started up again
• 544 – Fiber Reinforced 329 (Mike McPhee): In transition, working on technical notes now.
• 640 – Finisher Certification (Bob Simonelli) No update 4.0 Old Business
• Bill Phelan – Concrete slabs over vapor retarder field testing: Not enough data to make an industry statement. It looks like 0.04% shrinkage on poly is “no problem”. Per Harrison, dominant joints are a big issue and this committee needs to address it. Neuber may have a project that is measureable. McPhee has had recent experience using extended jointing (with steel fibers) at 75 to 100’ with minimal curling.
• Dennis Ahal – Finishing lightweight concrete: Deny provided a summary of finishing problems related to air entrained concrete and cautioned that specifying higher F numbers require enhanced finishing equipment use which may lead to delamination issues.
• Peter Craig – Avoiding moisture related problems: No ongoing research – should be ready within several months
• Pat Harrison – Liquid surface treatment standard: Need to get going ahead with this. Will revitalize it with chair..
5.0 Sub-Committees: Where we are now and where we are headed
• Chapters 1 and 10 – (Alan Face): On hold until next round of revisions.
• Chapter 2 – Classes of floors – (Pat Harrison): Complete and ready to go.
• Chapter 3 – Design Considerations (Wayne Walker/ Mike McPhee): Complete
• Chapter 4 – Site Preparation and Placing Environment (Wayne Walker/ Mike McPhee): Complete. Complete
• Chapter 5 – Materials (Kevin MacDonald): Complete.
• Chapter 6 – Concrete Properties and Consistency (Joe Neuber / Ed Finkel): Complete.
• Chapter 7 – Batching, Mixing and Transporation (Kevin MacDonald): Complete.
• Chapter 8 – Placing, Consolidating and Finishing (Terry Fricks): Complete.
• Chapter 9 – Curing, Protection and Joint Filling (Peter Craig): Complete.
• Chapter 10 – Quality Control Checklist (Alan Face): On hold until next revision.
• Chapter 11 – Causes of Floor and Slab Surface Imperfections (Scott Tarr): Negatives to be discussed and resolved this meeting.
• Chapter 12 – References (Pat Harrison): Will be completed as chapters are completed.
6.0 New Business
6.1 Resolved most of negative votes from recent ballot. The remainder to be done before Toronto.
6.2 Report from Art McKinney on “Sweating Slab” Syndrome. 7.0 Adjournment: