acknowledgements - bcnpa · 2017. 1. 9. · acknowledgements the bcnpa would like to acknowledge...
TRANSCRIPT
-
Acknowledgements TheBCNPAwouldliketoacknowledgethesupportandcontributionsofnumerouscolleagueswhotookthetimetooffertheirvaluableinsight,expertiseandfeedbackforthisdiscussionpaper.
LeadAuthors:• Dr.NatashaProdan-Bhalla,BScN,MN,NP(A),DNP• LorineScott,BSN,MN,NP(F)
ContributingAuthors:• MichelleBech,BSN,MN,ACNP,NP(A)• LeahChristoff,MSN,NP(F)• Belinda-AnnFurlan,MSN,NP(F)• KathleenFyvie,BSN,ENC(C),MN,NP(F)• CarolGalte,MN,NP(Retired)• AnnalieseHasler,BScN,NP(F)• FionaHutchison,BSN,MSN,NP(F)• JessicaLePage,RN,BSN,MN,NP(F)• KathyLepp,MN,NP(F)• Dr.MinnaMiller,DNP,MSN,NP(F),FAANP• CarrieMurphy,MN,NP(F)• SuePeck,BSN,MSN,NP(F)• BarbRadons,MN,NP(F)• KarenSims,BScN,MN-ACNP,NP(A)• JenWatters,MN,NP(A)
GraphicDesign/Layout:• MichaelHarrison
Editors:• TiffanyBarker,RN• AndreaBurton,MA
-
3
Executive Summary Inover60countriesworldwide,NursePractitioners(NPs)increaseaccessinspecialty1careandimprovebothpatientandsystemoutcomesacrossthecontinuumofcare.NPsinspecialtysettings-acute,ambulatory,andresidential-havedemonstratednotonlyimprovedpatienthealthoutcomesandcontinuityofcare,butalsoimprovementsinteamfunctioningandresourceutilization(AANP,2016;Hiza,Gottschalk,Umpierrez,Bush&Reisman,2015;Collinsetal.,2014;Kapu,Kleinpell&Pilon,2014;Watters,Aaronson,Sobolyeva,&Galte,2014;AANP,2013;Forster,2012;Goldie,Prodan-Bhalla,&MacKay,2012;Fry,2011;&Kilpatricketal.,2010).Despitethis,broadutilizationoftheseNPclinicalleadersinspecialtysettingsinBritishColumbia(B.C.)hasbeenhamperedbynumerousbarriersincludinginconsistentimplementationprocesses,alackofunderstandingand/oravailabilityofspecialtyeducationrequirements,roleclarityissuesandafocusonutilizingNPstostrengthenthedeliveryofprimarycareratherthanspecialtycare(Sangster-Gormley,2012;Bauer,2010).
SpecializedServices:NursePractitionersCollaboratingtoImprovetheContinuumofCareandtheaccompanyingToolkitarecompaniondocumentstoPrimaryCareTransformationinBC:ANewModeltoIntegrateNursePractitioners(BCNPA,2016).ThispaperoutlinesrecommendationsforoptimizingandsustainingexistingNProlesinspecialtycaresettings,andprovidesguidanceforthedevelopmentofaprovincialstrategytotakefulladvantageoftheNPproviderclinicalskillsetandexpertiseinadvancednursingleadership,transitionalcare,andtransformationalpolicydevelopment.NPsprovidecomprehensivecaretopatientswhileinhospital,incorporatinghealthpromotionandpreventionandhealthmanagementcareinrelationtospecificdiseases/chronicconditions.Thisapproachisshowntoimprovecoordinationofappropriatedischargeplanningandtocollaborativelyfacilitatefollow-upcarewithcommunityproviders–ineffectenactinganoftenunrecognizedbutimportanttransitionalmodelofcarethroughthepromotionofadynamicandresponsivemodeofhealthcaredeliveryforthepatient(Bryant-Lukosiusetal.,2016).
TheBritishColumbiaNursePractitionerAssociation(BCNPA)agreeswithandsupportstheMinistryofHealth’s(MOH)emphasisandfocusonpromotingtheintegrationofNPstoimproveaccesstoprimarycareforallBritishColumbians.However,healthcareprovisionhasbecomeincreasinglychallengingaspatientstodayarelivinglongerwithchronic,oftencomplexdiseasesandarefrequentlymovinginandoutofspecializedprogramsastheirhealthstatuschanges.NursePractitionersareexpertsatseamlessandsafetransitionsacrosshealthcareservicesandsettingsalongthecarecontinuumandareintegraltoensuringoptimumpatientexperiencesandarobustandeffectivehealthcaresysteminallsectors.
Today,approximately40percentofNPsinB.C.provideservicesinspecializedsettingsasoutlinedinTable1.Thisisasurprisinglylargenumberconsideringtheprovincialstrategyforimplementationsince2005hasfocusedonutilizingNPstoincreaseaccesstoprimarycare.TheinterestinNPprovidersandemploymentopportunitiesforNPsinspecializedroleshascontinuedtogrow,despitelogisticalchallenges.GiventhenumberofcreativeandresponsiveNProlesinspecialtysettingscurrentlydemonstratingmeaningfuloutcomes,thereisanimpetustoconsiderimprovedwaystostrategicallyplanforandsupportamoredeliberateandstructuredimplementationofNPsinthesesettingsasacomplementtotheircolleaguesinprimarycare.
B.C.hasanopportunitytodeploymoreNPsintoprimarycaresettingsunderanewstrategyasoutlinedinPrimaryCareTransformationinBC:ANewModeltoIntegrateNursePractitioners(BCNPA,2016),whilealsofullyutilizingNPsinspecialtycare,therebyincreasingaccesstocareacrossthehealthcarecontinuum.The______________________________________________________________________________________________1Forthepurposesofthispaper,thetermspecialtywillbeusedtodescribeNPsworkinginAcute,AmbulatoryandResidentialsettingsprovidingsecondary,tertiaryandquaternarycareasopposedtoPrimaryCaresettings.
-
4
BCNPAagreeswithandsupportstheMOHtripleaimsofimprovedhealthcareoutcomes,improvedpatient/providerexperienceandefficientcost-effectivecareasoutlinedinthe2016ServicePlan(B.C.MOH,2016).Thisincludesafocusonmultidisciplinaryteams,collaborativepracticeandcarethatisdevelopedwithand‘wrappedaround’thepatient.IncorporatedwithinthisdiscussionpaperarefundamentalprinciplestoensuresuccessfulNPimplementation/integrationthroughoutspecialtycarethatwillplacetheNPworkforceinastrongpositiontosupportteambasedcareandtheMOH’sgoalswithinarevitalized,coordinatedhealthcaresystem.
Withthisdiscussionpaper,theBCNPAhasprovidedinnovativecollaborativesolutionsandthefoundationalelementsrequiredtoaddressthepersistentbarrierstoeffectiveNPimplementation/integrationinspecialtysettings,andrecommendsthedevelopmentofarobustprovincialvisionandstrategy.TheBCNPArecommendstheMOHworkwiththeHealthAuthority(HA)-ChiefNursingOfficers(CNO),theHA-NPLeads,theCollegeofRegisteredNursesofBritishColumbia(CRNBC),theNursesandNursePractitionersofBC(NNPBC),theMinistryofAdvancedEducationandSkillsDevelopmentandotherkeystakeholderstodevelopasustainablestrategythatwillsupportcomplementaryandalternativerolesforNPswithinspecializedinterdisciplinaryteamswithinbothcommunityandacutecaresystems,suchthatthereisaclearvisionforeffectiveNProlesnow,andinthefuture.
KeyRecommendations1. DevelopaSustainableSalary-BasedNPFundingFramework
2. Develop,AdoptandImplementaQualityAssuranceFramework
3. DevelopaWorkingGrouptoReviewandUpdateNPRemuneration
4. DevelopaHealthHumanResourcesStrategytoNPDeployment
5. EmployNPsandIncreaseEducationalSeatsAccordingtotheHealthHumanResourcesStrategy
6. ReviewandUpdateNPEducationinB.C.toReflectPopulationNeeds
7. DevelopNPPostgraduateFellowshipPrograms
8. AdoptaNPProfessionalPracticeFrameworktoEnableaStandardizedApproach
9. DevelopandImplementanNPRoleClarityCampaign
10. RemoveLegislative,RegulatoryandOrganizationalBarriers
-
5
Key Messages
• Avision,basedonpopulationhealthneeds,isrequiredforallNProlesinspecialtysettings.
• Approximately40percentofNPsworkinginBritishColumbiaarepracticinginspecialtyroles.
• NPsareanunderutilizedprovidergroupthatcansupportincreasedaccesstohighqualityspecializedcareforBritishColumbiansbysupportingtheMOHTripleAimgoals-“improveoutcomes,enhancepatientexperienceandreducecosts.”
• HealthcareisacontinuumandNPshaveenormousimpactwhentheyareenabledtoprovideseamlesstransitionsacrossthatcontinuumandbetweensectors.
• NProlesinspecialtysettingscontributetopositivehealthoutcomes,improvingtheresponsivenessandfunctionofinterdisciplinaryteamsandcomplementexistingphysicianandnursingroles.
• Transformingthecurrenthealthcaresystemtoachievethetripleaimsshouldfocusonmodelsthatarepatient-centred,interdisciplinaryandcollaborative,andappropriatelyutilizetheskillsofallprovidersincludingtheNP.
• ArobuststandardizedframeworkandstrategyforNPimplementationinallroles,includingspecializedpractice,isessentialforthesustainabilityoftheNProleinB.C.
• PolicymakersmustimplementanappropriatefundingmodelforallNPsworkinginB.C.(AfulldiscussionofthismodelcanbefoundintheBCNPADiscussionPaper:PrimaryCareTransformationinBritishColumbia:ANewModeltoIntegrateNursePractitioners,2016).
• FundingmodelsmustrecognizethevalueofthefullpackageofservicesthattheNProlebringstoateam.
• NPremunerationmustrecognizeandreflecttheeducationalpreparation,scopeofpracticeandtheNPsroleasclinicalleaderswithautonomousresponsibilityforpatientcare.
-
6
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements......................................................................................................................................2LeadAuthors:................................................................................................................................................2Editors:..........................................................................................................................................................2
ExecutiveSummary......................................................................................................................................3KeyRecommendations.................................................................................................................................4
KeyMessages...............................................................................................................................................5
Introduction.................................................................................................................................................8
Background................................................................................................................................................10
UnderstandingSpecialtyRolesinB.C.........................................................................................................13AcuteCare...................................................................................................................................................14AmbulatoryCare.........................................................................................................................................15ResidentialCare...........................................................................................................................................16
ClarifyingSystemChallenges......................................................................................................................18StepsTowardaStrategyforNPsWorkinginSpecialtySettings................................................................18ClarifyingSystemPriorities.........................................................................................................................18LackofaSustainableFunding&RemunerationModel.............................................................................19
1.Recommendation:DevelopaSustainableSalary-basedFundingFramework...................................20LackofaQualityAssuranceFramework.....................................................................................................20
2.Recommendation:Develop,AdoptandImplementQualityAssuranceFramework..........................22Out-DatedNPRemuneration......................................................................................................................22
3.Recommendation:DevelopaWorkingGrouptoReviewandUpdateNPRemuneration..................23LackofaHealthHumanResourcesStrategy..............................................................................................24
4.Recommendation:DevelopaHHRStrategytoNPDeployment.........................................................255.Recommendation:EmployNPsandIncreaseEducationalSeatsAccordingtotheHHRStrategy.....25
NPEducationalProgramsNotReflectiveofEmploymentOpportunities..................................................276.Recommendation:ReviewandUpdateEducationinB.C.toReflectPopulationNeeds.....................28
LackofPostgraduateNPEducation............................................................................................................297.Recommendation:DevelopNPPostgraduateFellowshipPrograms..................................................29
LackofaStandardizedProfessionalPracticeFramework..........................................................................308.Recommendation:AdoptaProfessionalPracticeFrameworktoEnableaStandardizedApproach.30
PersistingIssueswithRoleClarity...............................................................................................................319.Recommendation:DevelopandImplementanNPRoleClarityCampaign........................................32
Legislative,RegulatoryandOrganizationalRestrictionstoNPPractice.....................................................3310.Recommendation:RemoveLegislative,RegulatoryandOrganizationalBarriers...........................33
GuidingPrinciples.......................................................................................................................................34Patient-Centred...........................................................................................................................................34InterdisciplinaryandCollaborative.............................................................................................................34NPRepresentation......................................................................................................................................35
SummaryofRecommendations.................................................................................................................36
Summary....................................................................................................................................................37
GlossaryofTerms.......................................................................................................................................38
-
7
AppendixA–NPFundingOptions..............................................................................................................41OptionA-HAEmployed.............................................................................................................................41
AppendixB.................................................................................................................................................42OptionB-HAAffiliated...............................................................................................................................42
AppendixC–EstimatedBudget.................................................................................................................43
AppendixD–QualityAssuranceFramework-Example..............................................................................44
AppendixE–CaseStudy............................................................................................................................45OptionA:HAEmployed..............................................................................................................................45
AppendixF–CaseStudy............................................................................................................................46OptionB:HAAffiliated................................................................................................................................46
References.................................................................................................................................................47
-
8
Introduction NursePractitionersinBritishColumbiacanbefoundacrossthehealthcaresystemtodayinavarietyofrolesinacute,ambulatory,andresidentialcareatsecondary,tertiaryandquaternarylevelsofcareacrossallHealthAuthorities.Inaddition,therearealsoNPsinB.C.workinginindustryandthenon-profitsector.TheserolesplacetheNPoutsideofprimarycare,caringforpatientpopulationswithspecializeddiseases/conditions/needswhohaveincreasinglevelsofcomplexity,suchaspatientslivingwithmentalillness,substanceusedisorder,chronicdisease,andcanceralongwithpopulationswhoaremarginalizedandvulnerable.NProlesoutsideofprimarycaresupportseveralofthegoalslaidoutintheSettingPrioritiesfortheB.C.HealthSystem(B.C.MOH,2014b)policypapers,andshouldbebetterunderstoodandutilizedtosupporttheMOHgoalsandobjectives.NPsinspecialtycareareworkingincomplementaryroles,enhancingtheexistinginterdisciplinaryteammodelandimprovingteamfunctioning.ManyoftheseNPsbringextensiveadvancedpracticespecialtyorsub-specialtyknowledgeandexpertisethatsupportsandaugmentstheexistingcaremodel,increases/improvesaccesstospecialtycare,improvestheacutecaretrajectoryandthepatientexperienceofcarereceivedandfostersseamlesstransitionsbackintothecommunity.AddressingsystempressuresinspecialtycarethroughtheutilizationoftheNPworkforcerequiresthoughtfulplanningandcollaborationamongallstakeholdersincludinggovernment,healthauthorities,academicprograms,NPs,physiciansandothermembersofthehealthcareteam.DespitetheconsiderableworkcompletedrelatedtohealthcarereformandtheimplementationofNPsinBritishColumbiasince2005,severalbarrierstofullutilizationoftheNProlepersist.FocusingNPfundingonprimarycaredeliveryhasdeniedthechallengesandtransitionsthatpatientswithcomplexhealthissuesfaceanddoesnotenableaseamlesssystemofcare.Thesiloeddivisionsbetweenprimary,secondary,tertiaryandquaternarycarehasbecomearbitraryandisnotreflectiveoftoday’shealthcarecontinuum,whichisreflectedinanobjectiverestatedinthe2015PrimaryandCommunityHealthpolicydocumenttosupportseniorstoremainindependentandathomeforaslongaspossible(B.C.MOH,2015a).In2006,theCanadianNursePractitionerInitiative(CNPI)publishedareportwith13recommendationsforsustainableimplementationoftheNPinCanada.Sincethattime,thenumberofNPsinthecountryhasgrownby300percentindicatingthatNPsareinhighdemand(CNPI,2016).TheCNPI:A10YearRetrospectiverecognizesthenumerousimprovementsthathavebeenachievedoverthelastdecadeincludingtitleprotection,andacommonroledescription(CNPI,2016).However,italsohighlightstheneedforfurtherworkinsustainablefundingstrategies,removinglegislativebarrierstopractice,expandingteam-basedmodelsthatincludeNPs,anddevelopingastandardapproachtohealthhumanresourcesplanningandrecruitment(CNPI,2016).
Canadian NP Context (CNA, 2017)
• Approximately4,500NPsarecurrentlypracticinginCanadao 35%ofCanadianNPsworkinprimarycare
o 40%ofCanadianNPsworkinspecialtysettings
o 3%ofCanadianNPsworkinresidentialcare
British Columbia NP Context (BCNPA, 2017)
• Approximately402NPsarecurrentlypracticinginB.C.o 60%workinprimarycare(50%workwithspecializedpopulations)
o 40%workinspecialtysettings
GuidingPrinciples
PatientCentred
Interprofessional
NPRepresentation
-
9
ThebarriersoutlinedinTheCNPI:A10YearRetrospective(CNPI,2016)arecertainlyreflectedintheB.C.context.Inaddition,NPsinB.ChavefaceduniquebarrierstopracticeincludingadisconnectbetweenNPeducationalprogramsandemploymentsettings,andevenmoredetrimentally,alackofaclearvisionandplanfortheimplementationoftheNProleinbothprimaryandspecialtysettings.ThisdocumentoutlinesasetofrecommendationstoensurearobustsustainableplanforexistingNProlesinspecialtycaresettings,andsetsthestageforthedevelopmentofaviableprovincialstrategyandvisionasstakeholdersanticipatethefutureandmoveforwardwithNPsinspecialtycare.BCNPArecognizesthattherecommendationsoutlinedinPrimaryCareTransformationinBritishColumbia:ANewModeltoIntegrateNursePractitioners(BCNPA,2016)areapriorityhowever,ashealthcareplanningisnotstagnant,therecommendationsoutlinedinthisdiscussionpaperarecomplementaryandpromotearesponsive,robust,fulsomehealthcaresystem.
CameraVanBreeman,NP(F),PediatricPalliativeCare,NonProfitSector-Vancouver,B.C.“Asamemberoftheinterdisciplinaryteamofprofessionals–physicians,registerednurses,careaids,socialworkers,counsellors,spiritualcare,expressiveandrecreationaltherapists,Iprovidein-personconsultationsatthehospice,outpatientclinics,in-patientunits,andprovidehomevisitsinthelowermainland.Visitstootherpediatricwards,communityagenciesandtochildren’shomesoutsidethelowermainlandarealsoavailablesothatcareplanningandassessmentcanbedoneifthechild/family’swishistodieintheirhomecommunity.Iprovidetreatmentandcarerelatedtocomplexsymptommanagement,careplanning,advanceddirectivesandcarecoordinationacrosssettings.Inaddition,inmyNProleIprovidepediatricpalliativecareeducationandconsultativesupporttohealthcareproviderssuchaspediatricians,generalproviders,nursingsupportservicesandcontractednursingservices.Thistranslationofspecializedknowledgerelatedtopediatricpalliativecareisnecessarytoensurethatchildrenandfamiliesreceiveappropriatecare.”
-
10
Background EconomicanalyseshavedemonstratedthatwhenNPsworkautonomouslyinavarietyofclinicalsettingstheentirehealthcaresystemisreformed(Bauer,2010).ThepopulationisaginginB.C.,thedemandforskilledmedicalpractitionersinacutecareisontheriseandtheeconomicbenefitoftheNProleinspecialtysettingsiswellestablished(RNAO,2015;Kapu,Kleinpell&Pilon,2014).NPsareprimaryfacilitatorsinimprovingcommunicationbetweenspecialtycareandprimarycareleadingtosignificantimprovementsincontinuity,carecoordinationandtransitionsacrossthespectrumofservicesneeded.
StudieshaveshownthatthespecializedNProleiscosteffective,particularlyindecreasinglengthofstay,andensuringtimelydischarge,whichindirectlydecreaseshospitalcosts(RNAO,2015;Kapu,Kleinpell&Pilon,2014).DecreasedhospitalcostshavealsobeenreportedduetocostsavingssecondarytotheutilizationoffewerresourcesbyNPs(Jennings,Clifford,Fox,O’Connell&Gardner,2015;McDonnelletal.,2015;Kleinpell,2005).Multi-disciplinaryandinterprofessionalteamsthatincludeNPshaveimprovedpatientoutcomes,improvedpatientexperience,improvedprovidersatisfaction/teamfunctioning,increasedcoordinationandarecostefficient(Lietal.,2017;Hiza,Gottschalk,Umpierrez,Bush&Reisman,2015;Jennings,Clifford,Fox,O’Connell&Gardner,2015;McDonnelletal.,2015;Kapu,Kleinpell&Pilon,2014;Collinsetal.,2014;Fry,2011;Kilpatricketal.,2010;).McDonnelletal.,(2015),demonstratedthatNPsworkinginacutecarealsocontributetotheachievementoforganizationalpriorities,targetsandpolicydevelopment.
ThereisanewfrontierinhealthcareinBC;onethatemphasizestheneedforpatientstostayintheirhomesandcommunitieslonger,ratherthaninhospital,oftenresultinginfurtherillnessandreadmission(Lax&Gilbert,2015).NursePractitionersworkinginspecializedsettingsarewellpositionedtoworkincollaborationwithprofessionalsinprimarycaresettingstoensuresmoothtransitionsacrossthespectrumofhealthcarefromhometocommunity,acutecare,ambulatory,residential,palliative,andmoreasoutlinedinFigure1.NPsaremobile,agileandadaptivetomeettheneedsofthepopulationashealthcareneedsandsystemschange.ThebroadskillsetoftheNPincludesexpertiseinclinicalcare,organizationalleadership,policydevelopment,andchangemanagement,whichprovidesastrongfoundationfornavigatingcomplexsystemsandcomplexpatientneeds.WhethertheNPisprovidingservicesincardiacsurgery,orthopedics,trauma,orcancercare,theroleoftheNPensureshighquality,efficientcarethatprovidesasmoothtransitionbackintothecommunity(CNA,2016;Martin-Miseneretal.,2015).
MichelleBech,NP(A),Orthopedics-Surgical-Vancouver,B.C.“AsamemberoftheOrthopedicmulti-disciplinaryteamsince2005,Iwashiredtocomplementtheexistingteamstructure,Iamresponsibleforthecareoffracturepatientsfromadmissionàpre-opàpost-opàoutpatientfollow-up.SinceaddingtheNPtothisspecializedteam17yearsago,ongoingresearchhascontinuedtodemonstratethismodelisyieldingasignificantdecreaseinlengthofstayforhipfracturepatientsbyover30days.
Ourprogramrecentlyreceivedexemplarystatus(AmericanCollegeofSurgeonsNationalSurgicalQualityImprovementProgram,2017),placinginthetop10percentof300-400bedteachinghospitals,demonstratinglowratesintheareasofVenousThromboembolism,readmissions,returntoORandmortality.Theconsensusisthatthe“NProlehasaddedtotheeffectivenessofthissurgicalteamandispositivelycontributingtotheongoingimprovedoutcomesforsurgicalpatients”.
-
11
NPRoleinSpecialtyCare:AFullPackageofServices
• Worksasmemberofaninterdisciplinaryteam,complementingotherteammemberroles.
• Bringsaholisticnursingsciencelens(specializedknowledge,skills/experience)tomedicalcareexpandingtheinterventionsavailabletopatients.
• Providesindependentevidenceinformedassessment/clinicalpracticeconsultation&carecoordinationpre-admission,duringadmission&postdischargeasoutlinedinFigure2.
• Collaborateswithpatient/family,interdisciplinaryteamandothersupportsystemsduringadmissioncoordinatingdischargeplanningneedsincludingsupportrequiredathome
• Considersprimarycareneedsincludinghealthpromotionanddiseasepreventionwhilefocusingonspecializedillness.
• Maintainsafocusontransitionsbetweensectorsofthehealthcaresystemandkeepingpatientsoutofhospital
• Actsaspointofcontacttofacilitatecommunicationacrosssystemsectorsincludingspecialtycareàprimarycareàcommunity/homecare.
• Identifiesservicegaps&strategiestoimproveteamcareandfunctioningworkingtoensureteamresponsiveness.
Bringingaholisticnursingsciencelenstopractice,specializedNPsconsidertheprimaryhealthcareneedsofpatientswhilethepatientisinanacutecaresetting.Forexample,anNPworkingininpatientmentalhealthwillidentifyvulnerabilitiessuchasengaginginhigh-risksexualbehavioursoridentifyingriskfactorsforheartdiseaseandensuringappropriatescreeningandhealthpromotioninterventionsareundertakenorthehealthconditionisalsoaddressedwhileinhospital,issuesthatapsychiatrist,oraddictionsmedicinephysicianmaynotincludeaspartoftheirpractice.AnNPworkingintheemergencyroomwilldiscusspreventionandhealthpromotionstrategieswithpatientstokeepthemfromreturningtotheEDforroutinecareandanNPworkingintraumawillsupportthepatientfromthetimeofinjury,throughouttheacutehospitalstay
andensureanappropriatedischargeandtransition,providingthepatient/familywiththeeducationtheyrequiretomanagetheirhealthissuesbackintothecommunity.
Disappointingly,despiteeffortstodate,NPscontinuetofacechallengesinfullyintegratingintothebroadersystemandsignificantbarrierstoNPpracticeremain.A2012surveyofNPsworkinginB.C.foundmanyemployedNPsexperienceproblemsworkingtofullscopeofpracticeduetopersistinglegislativebarriersandrestrictiveorganizationalstructures.Someotherbarriersidentifiedincludedlackofplanning,roleclarity,arestrictivesalarymodelthatdoesnotacknowledgethescopeofclinicalNPcare,andlackofphysicianandadministrativesupport(Contandriopoulosetal.,2015,Sangster-Gormley,2012).ItistimetodevelopastrategywithaclearvisionandimplementationplantoremovethesebarriersforNPsdeliveringbothprimaryandspecializedcare.
StevenHashimoto,NP(F),MentalHealth–Burnaby,B.C.ImprovingTransitions:Iworkatalargein-patientfacilitythatprovidespsychiatrictreatmentandaddictionmanagementtoadults(19+)whohaveconcurrentdisorders(includingbothpsychiatricandaddictionissues).Asamemberofthemulti-disciplinarymentalhealthteam,Iprovidetheneededprimarycareservicesforclientswhiletheyareadmitted,managingmultipleacuteaswellaschronicconditionssuchascellulitis,STIs,hepatitisC,COPD,diabetesanditscomplicationsinthepresenceofthesubstanceusedisorder.Addictionmedicinecareisprimarilyaresponsibilityforgeneralpractitioners(GPs)ontheteam,howevertheNPprovideslocumcoverageandmanagesacutewithdrawalsymptomsfromalcoholoropioidsandcontinuestoprescribeopioidsfornon-cancerchronicpainandSuboxoneasapartofaddictiontreatment.”
-
12
Figure1.NursePractitionersasMembersofInterdisciplinaryTeams.BCNPA(2017).PleaseNote:TheNPwillbeworkingwithininterdisciplinaryteamsatallofthesetransitionpoints
-
13
Understanding Specialty Roles in B.C. ManyNPspracticinginB.C.todayaremembersofhighlyspecializedmulti-disciplinaryteamssuchascardiology,nephrology,trauma,haematologyandoncologyandareprovidingcareinacutecarehospitalunits,specialtyambulatorycareprogramsandresidentialcaresettingsinprogramsservingadults,seniors,children/youthandneonates.Asdescribedabove,NPsasmembersofspecializedteams,aremostoftencomplementingotherproviderroleswithinexistingteambasedmodelsofcareaddingvaluetotheexistinginterdisciplinaryteambypositivelycontributingtoimprovingaccesstospecialtycare,facilitatingconnectionsacrosssectorsandimprovingpatienthealthoutcomes,teamfunctioningandresponsiveness.Morerecently,therearesomeexamplesinBCofNPsworkingasanalternativeprovidertoaMD.Theseroleshavebeenimplementedwhereappropriate,toaddressspecificpopulationneedsandasonestrategytoaddressprovidershortages.Inallsituations,NPsareprovingtobringvaluetothepatient/family,thehealthcareteamandthesystemofcarethroughthefullpackageofservicestheNPscopeofpracticeaffords.
NPEmploymentBreakdown
Table1:NPEmploymentBreakdown(BCNPA,personalcommunication,July20,2017)
Specialized PrimaryCare
AcuteCare Ambulatory Residential PrimaryCareforSpecificPopulations
PrimaryCare
Total
FraserHealthAuthority
18 11 3 26 22 80
IslandHealthAuthority 3 11 2 28 15 59
VancouverCoastalHealthAuthority 9 5 4 34 2 54
ProvidenceHealthCare 10 4 0 5 0 19
InteriorHealthAuthority 7 3 2 0 44 56
NorthernHealthAuthority
0 0 0 0 29 29
ProvincialHealthServicesAuthority
13 28 0 19 0 60
Total 60 62 11 112 112 357
133 224
-
14
AcuteCareInacutecareinpatientsettings,NPsasmembersofthehealthcareteam,provideafullrangeofservicesthatincludesthedeliveryofexpertclinicalcareandmedicalmanagementinareassuchascardiology,orthopedics,neurosurgery,trauma,NICUandmulti-organtransplant.SpecialtyNPsinthesesettings,workcollaboratively,managingtheday-to-daymedicalcare,buildingdischargeplansandprovidinghealthself-managementeducationforthepatientsontheunit.NPsprovidestabilityandconsistencyforthepatientaswellastheotherhealthcareprofessionals,andoftenprovidethecohesivepiecesneededforrelationalteambasedapproaches.ThisgroupofNPshasdevelopedspecializedclinicalexpertisebeyondthatofageneralpractitionerorNPworkinginprimarycare.Inadditiontoprovidingdirectcomprehensiveclinicalcareandmanagement,theNPprovidesorganizationalvaluethroughenactingalltheelementsoftheNPscopeofpracticeincludingpromotingeducation/knowledgetranslation,contributingtoevidenceinformedpractice/research,recognizingsystemgaps,andinitiatingqualityassurancestrategiestoimprovethesystemofcare.
InCanada,NPsbeganworkinginacutecaresettings(e.g.,neurology,nephrology)inthelate1980s(Kaasalainenetal.,2010).Severallandmarkstudieshaveconsistentlydemonstratedpositiveoutcomesincludingdecreasedlengthofstay,readmissionratesandco-morbidities(Hiza,Gottschalk,Umpierrez,Bush&Reisman,2015;Collinsetal.,2014;Kapu,Kleinpell&Pilon,2014;Fry,2011;Kilpatricketal.,2010).
InB.C.,thereare60NPspracticinginacutecaresettingsininterdisciplinaryteams.Afewhavebeenevaluateddemonstratingimprovedpatientoutcomesandsignificantcostsavingstothehealthcaresystem:
• Regionally,withintheFraserHealthAuthority,aformalevaluationofthespecializedNProleaddedtothecardiacsurgeryprogramatRoyalColumbianHospitalwascompleted.KeyfindingsdemonstratedsuccessfulNProleintegrationandsustainability,highlevelsofpatientsatisfactionaswellaseffectiveandefficienthigh-qualitycareincludingdecreasedlengthofstay,decreasedtransferstohigheracuityunits,decreasedpost-admissioncomorbidities,decreased30-dayreadmissionratesandincreasednumberofdisease-specificindicatedmedicationsinitiatedorrecommendedatdischarge(Watters,Aaronson,Sobolyeva&Galte,2014).
• AstudyevaluatingtheeffectivenessoftheroleoftheNPinthecardiacsurgeryprogramatSt.Paul’sHospitalinVancouver,alsodemonstratedthateventhoughNPsprovidedcareformorecomplicatedcardiacsurgicalpatients,levelsofpatientsatisfactionandsatisfactionwithpainmanagementwerehigherinpatientsintheNPgroup(Goldie,Prodan-Bhalla,&MacKay,2012).
JenWatters,NP(A),CardiacSurgery-NewWestminster,B.C.Mr.S.isawaitingsurgeryonthecardiacward.Iassumeresponsibilityforhismanagement;ensuringhismultiplechronicconditionsarestableandwillnotinterferewithhisrecoveryfromsurgery.Ireviewwithhimandhisfamilywhattoexpectduringandaftersurgeryandhowtostartpreparingforhisreturnhome.Afterheisstabilizedfromhiscomplexheartsurgery,hereturnstothesurgicalunit.Ireassumedailyresponsibilityforhispostoperativecare,ensuringhisrecoveryissmoothandhischronicconditionsareconsidered,therebyhelpingtoachievehistargetlengthofstay.Preparingfordischarge,Iworkwiththemulti-disciplinaryteamtoensurehehasthesupportsathomeandappropriatefollowupwithhiscommunitynursepractitionerandcardiologist.Safedischargeincludescompletingathoroughdischargesummary,whichprovidesaclearfollowupplanwhichiscommunicatedtohisprimarycareprovider,referringhimtotheoutpatientcardiacrehabilitationprogram,ensuringhismedicationsareoptimizedandstableatdischarge,ensuringcompletenessofhistransitionalinformationfromacutecaretoprimarycareandprovidinghimandhisfamilywithtailorededucationdesignedtopreventfurtherhospitalization.”
-
15
• AtSt.Paul’sHospitalinVancouver,theNProleaddedtotheorthopedicsurgeryteamwasevaluated,anddemonstratedasignificantdecreaseinlengthofstayforhipfracturepatientsbyover30daysaftertheimplementationoftheNProle(Forster,2012).
AmbulatoryCareAmbulatorycareisdefinedasmedicalcareoracutecarethatisprovidedonanoutpatientbasisinspecializedoutpatientsettingsorclinics.Ambulatorycaremayincludediagnosis,management,consultation,advancedmedicalinterventions,proceduresorsurgery,observation,rehabilitation,palliationandtelephoneconsultationservices.TheNPinthisroleprovidessecondarylevelspecialtyservicesonanoutpatientbasisinareassuchasheartfunction,atrialfibrillation,nephrology,asthma,diabetes,oroncologyforbothadultsandchildren.
TheliteraturesupportstheutilizationofNPsinAmbulatoryCareinbothcomplementary(addinganNPtoanexistingteam)andinsomecasesasalternativeproviderstospecialists.Martin-Miseneretal.,(2015)reportthatthereisemergingevidenceindicatingthatNPsinacomplementaryproviderrolewithinaspecializedambulatorycareprogramimprovepatientoutcomes,andNPsinalternativeproviderroleshaveequivalentorbetterpatientoutcomesthancomparatorsandarepotentiallycost-saving.AnotherstudyexaminedtheperformanceofNPsworkinginaspecialtydermatologyambulatorycareprogramandfoundthatthelevelofcareprovidedbyanNPintermsofimprovementsinsymptomseverityandqualityoflifeoutcomeswascomparablewiththatprovidedbyadermatologist.Inaddition,theparentsweremoresatisfiedwiththecarethatwasprovidedbyanNP,whichwereattributedtothe“structure” of the NP interventions and the NP consultation time (Schuttelaar,Vermeulen,Drukker,&Coenraads,2010).
Currently,thereare62NPsworkinginambulatorysettingsinB.C.inadult,olderadult,andpediatricprograms,makingthisthelargestgroupofspecialtyNPsasoutlinedinTable1.AmbulatoryNPsprovidediseasespecificexpertisetoawidearrayofBritishColumbiansaspartofhighlyspecializedmultidisciplinaryteams.TheseNPsareoftenthespecialtyteam’spointofcontactforfollow-upambulatoryvisits,freeingupspecialistresourcesforpatientsthatrequiresub-specialistexpertise.Overall,Martin-Miseneretal.,(2015)reportedthatNPsinspecializedambulatorycaresettingshaveequivalentorbetterpatientoutcomesthan
MinnaMiller,NP(F),PediatricAmbulatoryCareClinic:Asthma–Vancouver,B.C.“Asamemberofthemulti-disciplinaryteam,Iprovideinitialconsultationsandfollowupcaretochildrenwithasthma,andtheirfamilies.Myscopeofpracticeincludesdiagnosisandmanagementofasthma,orderingandinterpretingdiagnostictests,prescribingmedications,referringpatientstosubspecialistsandcollaboratingwithothercliniciansandserviceproviders.Patientandfamilyeducationisanimportantpartofeachclientencounter.Mycaseloadisequaltomyphysiciancounterparts(approximately600patients/year),freeingsub-specialiststofocustheirtimeonmorecomplexcases.Inadditiontoclinicappointments,Iprovidetelephoneconsultationasneeded.IhavecontributedtothedevelopmentanddisseminationoftheBCGuidelinesforChildrenwithAsthma,andinitiatedresearch/qualityimprovementprojectsattheclinicrelatedtointerdisciplinaryteamsandpatientoutcomes.Iserveonthehospital’sasthmaadvisorycommittee,andhavecontributedtothedevelopmentofinternal,agencyspecificpoliciesonpediatricasthmacare.”
Belinda-AnnFurlan,NP(F),AtrialFibrillationClinic-Vancouver,B.C.“IenjoyempoweringpatientsbyimprovingtheirunderstandingofAtrialFibrillationincludingalloftheirspecificrelatedcomorbiditiesandhoweachdiseaseorconditionaffectseachotherlinkingthepatientasawholeperson(hypertension,heartfailure,obstructivesleepapnea,stroke/bleedingrisk,diabetes,obesity).Whenapatientandtheirfamilyunderstandstheirhealthdiagnosis,theroleofpharmacology/non-pharmacologytreatmentandlifestylewithinahealthpromotionandpreventionlenstheyareempoweredandmotivatedtocreatechangeandworkcollaborativelywiththeirfamilyandtheirhealthcareteam.Thisresultsinbetterhealth,wellbeingandqualityoflifeforeachpatientaswellasareductionofhealthcaredollarsspentandburdenonouroverloadedhealthcaresystem.”
-
16
theirphysiciancolleagues.
ResidentialCareTheNPinresidentialcareworkscollaborativelywithinthemultidisciplinaryteamtoprovideregularassessment,diagnosisandtreatmentofmedicalconditionsaspartofholisticadvancedpracticenursingcarewithagoaltodecreasingthefrequencyofurgenthealthcrises.Thisisauniquerole,whichprovidesbothprimaryandspecializedsecondarycarewhiletryingtokeepgeriatricpatientsoutofhospital.Incorporatingapalliativephilosophyofcarewithafrailelderlypopulationcontributestolesshospitaltransfers/admissions,reducedpolypharmacy,andimprovedqualityoflifeandend-of-lifecareforresidentsandtheirfamilies(McAineyetal.,2008).Thisisanenhancedprimarycaremodelforaspecializedpopulationwithafocusonillnessprevention,improvedqualityoflifeandongoingcomprehensivemanagementoffrailresidentswithcomplexhealthconcerns.NursePractitionershaveprovidedservicesinlong-termcare/residential(LTC)carehomesintheUnitedStatessincethe1970sandinCanadasince2000(McCaineyetal.,2008;Stoleeetal.,2006;Futrelletal.,2005).Thistrendhashelpedaddresscriticalissuesinresidentialfacilitiessuchastheincreasingproportionoffrailresidentswithcomplexmedicalissues,limitedphysicianservices,inadequatequalityofcareandescalatinghealthcarecosts(Ploegetal.,2013;Jehan&Nelson,2006;Stoleeetal.,2006).SystematicreviewsoftheliteraturesuggestthattheNPapproachimprovesthehealthstatusandqualityoflifeofolderadultsresidinginresidentialcaresettingsandthattheirfamiliesaremoresatisfiedwiththecareresidentsreceive(Donaldetal.,2013).AsurveyofallphysicianmembersoftheAmericanMedicalDirectorsAssociationsfoundahighlevelofsatisfactionwiththeNProleinLTCamongphysicians(90%),residents(87%)andfamilies(85%)(Rosenfeldetal.,2007).Therearecurrently27,000seniorsinB.C.livinginresidentialcaresettings(SeniorsAdvocateofBritishColumbia,2017),andonly11NPsworkinginresidentialcareintheprovince(BCNPA,2017).TheintegrationofNPsinresidentialcaresettingsinB.C.hasbeenlimiteddespitethisbeinganobvioussettingwhereNPcarecanimprovepatienthealthoutcomes,fillsystemwidegapsincareforavulnerablepopulation,improvetransitionsacrossthesystemofcare,improvetimelyaccesstocareandprovideanconsistent,stable,patient/familycentredapproachforaveryfrailspecializedpopulation.Arecentreport,EveryVoiceCounts,emphasizedtheneedforincreasedaccesstoqualityhealthcareandtheimplementationofNPswithinresidentialsettings(SeniorsAdvocateofBritishColumbia,2017).Todate,thefewNPsinB.C.workinginresidentialcareorwiththehomeboundfrailelderlyhavebeenleadersinsettingupcomprehensiveprogramsinseniors/eldercare,alongwithprogramstoassessanddeliverMedicalAssistanceinDying(MAID)sinceitwasintroducedin2016.NPsareaviablechoicefortheMOH,asB.C.plansforthefutureandworkstoaddressthesignificantandgrowingserviceinadequaciesrelatedtoseniors’care.StrategicdeploymentofNPsinresidentialandlong-termcaresettingsmakessense.Itwillsituatetheirexpertknowledge,skillsandapproachwhereseniorslive,bringingneededrelationshipbasedservicestothishighlycomplex,specializedpopulationcreatingamorepositivecareexperienceforresidentsandfamilies.ImmediatebenefitsandimprovedaccesstocareiswithinreachintheB.C.health
BarbaraRadons,NP(F),ResidentialCare–Surrey,B.C.“Irecentlycaredforafrail90-year-oldwoman,livinginoneoftheresidentialcarecentreIprovidePHCservicesin,andassistedherfamilytopreparefortheirmother’sdeclininghealthandherimminentdeathatthecenter.Thispatientsufferedfromadvanceddementiaandmultiplechronichealthconditions.HerfamilyexpressedgratitudefortherelationshipIhaddevelopedwiththeirmother,thetimethatIwasabletospendwiththem,explainingchangesinhercondition,closelymonitoringherchanginghealthstatus,managinghersymptomspromptlyandfacilitatingapalliativecareapproachattheendofherlife.Theystatedthat“theirmotherhadhadthebestpossiblecareandaverypeacefuldeath.”
-
17
carecontext,andtherearemanyNPsactivelysearchingforemploymentopportunitiestodaywithinthesesettings.
-
18
Clarifying System Challenges StepsTowardaStrategyforNPsWorkinginSpecialtySettingsBuildingontherecommendationsputforthintheBCNPA’sdiscussionpaperPrimaryCareTransformationinBritishColumbia:ANewModeltoIntegrateNursePractitioners(BCNPA,2016),developinganeffectiveandlong-termstrategyforthefulsomeinclusionoftheNProleacrossspecialtysettingsshouldbethenextstepinthereachforlong-termsystemwideimprovements,increasingaccesstohealthandend-of-lifecareforallBritishColumbians.
Aftermorethanadecade,NPshaveemergedaswell-placedprovidersthroughoutthehealthcaresystem,complementingexistingmodelsofcare,andimprovingtransitionalcareacrossthesystem.Withsustainablefundingandcohesive,well-plannedimplementation/integrationprocesses,primarycareandspecializedNProlesnotonlycomplementeachother,butcomplementotherinterdisciplinaryteamandphysicianproviderrolessupportingasynergisticapproachacrosstheintegraltransitionsinpatient’slivesfocusingonimprovingwellness/outcomes,supportingtheappropriateandeffectiveutilizationofspecializedacuteservicesandworkingtoimprovepatientqualityoflife.
Figure2.NursePractitionerServiceModel:AcuteIllnessTrajectory(Galte,C.,2015)
ClarifyingSystemPrioritiesAcrossBritishColumbia,arecentenvironmentalscanrevealed182strategiesoutlinedinHAserviceplanstoaddressidentifiedservicegapsandpopulationneeds,yetonlythreespeaktotheinclusionofNPproviders,includingacute,ambulatoryorresidentialcare.RecentMOHpolicypapersmakementionofNPprovidersin
-
19
ageneralsense,howeverthesepaperscontinuetopresentafocusonphysicianproviders,ratherthaninterdisciplinaryteamsandcomplementaryproviderskillmix,andadistinct,concreteprovincialstrategyorframeworkrelatedtotheutilizationofNPsismissing.Furthermore,NPs,asadvancedpracticenursesareseldomservingonleadershipgroupsengagedintheseprocesses,andasaresultthepotentialoftheimpactofNProleisoftennotcaptured.
Regrettably,whiletherehavebeenmanyverysuccessfulNProlescreatedinB.C.withoutconsultationwithNPs,therehavealsobeenmanyunsuccessfulones,damagingcredibilityfortherole.Thishasresultedinfrustrationandoperationalchallengesforallinvolved,fromthepatient,totheNP,toteammembers,totheHAleadership.TheabsenceoftangiblestrategiesreflectsthelandscapeofcompetingprioritiesinwhichNPintegrationexistsandthelackofNPrepresentationatkeypolicyanddecision-makingtablesseverelylimitsthecontributionthisprovidergroupcouldmakeinaddressingmanyHApriorities.
TheBCNPArecommendsthedevelopmentofastrategyandsystematicapproachtotheintegrationofNPs,whichareoutlinedbelow.GiventhecomplexnatureoftheworkrequiredforthesuccessfulintegrationofNPs,aclearconsistentstrategyisthemosteffectivewaytoensuretheNPworkforcecansupporttheMOHandhealthauthorities’strategicobjectives.Increasinglyacrosslarge-scalechangeinitiatives,thereisevidenceofthebenefitofstructuredprojectmanagementapproaches(Locatelli,Mikic,Kovacevic,Brookes,&Ivanisevic,2017)thatincludeprojectcoordination,implementation,monitoringandevaluation.ThesehavelargelybeenappliedtocapitalprojectssuchastheClinicalSystemsTransformationprojectinthelowermainland,butareincreasinglyseenasanopportunityforothertypesoflarge-scalechange.
LackofaSustainableFunding&RemunerationModelThelackoflong-term,fair,flexibleandsustainableNPfundingmodelremainsthemostsignificantbarriertointegratingandsustainingNProlesacrossthehealthcaresysteminBritishColumbia,includingwithinspecialtycaresettings(Sangster-Gormley,2012;Sangster-Gormley,Martin-Misener,Downe-Wamboldt,&DiCenso,2011;Kilpatricketal.,2010).TheapproachtoNPfundingtodatehasbeenblockfundingdeliveredthroughahealthauthority,withagoaltofundNPsinprimarycare.TheseblockshavecomeprimarilyintwowavesandtheBCNPAhasbeenadvocating,forsometime,fortheMOHtomoveawayfromthisrestrictivefundingapproach,itsburdensomereportingmechanismswithdeliverysolelyviaHA,andmovetowardtheimplementationofsustainablesystemwidefundingsolutionsforNProles,nomatterwheretheyareintroduced.
ThecurrentapproachhasledtoseveralchallengesbothforHA’sandcommunities.Firstly,whenfundingcomesinwaves,itrisksinappropriateandunsuccessfulroleimplementation,asthereisoftennotenoughtimeforcomprehensiveroledevelopmentamidtheurgencytosecurethefundingopportunitybeforetheapplicationdeadlineandinsomecases,implementationoccurswhenanotherproviderrole(RegisteredNurse,ClinicalNurseSpecialistorPhysician)mayhavebeenmoreappropriate.Secondly,gapsinfundingwaves(thelastwaveoffundingendedinearly2015)makeitchallengingforHAstobuildonsuccessfulNProles,toimplementcomplementaryNPproviderswithinexitingteamsortocreatenewmodelsofinterdisciplinarycaretoaddressservicegaps.Thirdly,thisfundingstructurehaslimitedflexibility,inthatitplacestheNPstobesolelyemployedwithinHealthAuthoritieswithnooptionsforpart-timeorcontractedwork.Aswell,theemployeerelationshipinmostinstances(reportingthroughProgramManagers)leavestheNPwithlimitedinfluenceinprogramplanningtoaddressidentifiedservicegapsandlimitedflexibilitytomeetthechangingneedsofthepatientpopulationsinthemostsuitablelocations.Furthermore,communitiesneedingservicemustgothroughaHAtosecureNPfundingwhichisoftenlogisticallychallenging.
AsustainableNPfundingmodelcannotberealizedwithoutacommitmentfromtheMOH,andBCNPAisrecommendingan“investtosave”approachandthedevelopmentofasimple,consistent,sustainable
-
20
provincialNPfundingstrategythatwouldallowHA’sand/orcommunities,whetherprimary,acute,ambulatoryorresidentialcaretobenimbleandresponsivetochangingpopulationandserviceneedswhentheyariseenablingtheutilizationoftheNP’scompletebasketofservicestocontributetoimprovedaccesstocareandsystemwideresponsiveness.
1. Recommendation:DevelopaSustainableSalary-basedFundingFrameworkGovernmentandhealthsystemplannersmustconsiderhowtobestmaximizetheNPworkforcebeyondprimarycareandincludestrategiesthatacknowledgethepotentialofNPcareinspecialtypracticeareaswithinspecialtyteams.AsoutlinedinPrimaryCareTransformationinBritishColumbia:ANewModeltoIntegrateNursePractitioners(BCNPA,2016),asustainablesourceoffundingforNPsiscriticaltoensureBritishColumbiansandinterdisciplinaryteamscanrealizethefullbenefitsoftheNProle.
Asimple,consistentsalaryorblendedandvaluesbasedfundingframeworkforNPswouldsupporttheinclusionofNPsacrossthecontinuumofcare,nomatterwhereemploymentoccurs,andthiswouldincludeNPsworkinginacutespecialtycare,ambulatoryandresidentialcare,andwouldalsoprovideoptionsforinnovativecost-effectivecaremodelsinthenon-profithealthsector.Multidisciplinaryteam-basedsalariedmodelsareattractivetonewgraduatesacrossdisciplines,astheyofferastableandpredictableincome,anopportunitytoworkcollaborativelywithotherhealthcareprofessionalsandpositivework/lifebalance.Fundingsourcescouldinclude:
• Fundingwithinanexistinghealthauthority-operatingbudget.
• FundingexternaltothehealthauthorityutilizingtheAPP.
• FundingexternaltothehealthauthorityutilizinganAPP-likeNPmodel.
BCNPArecognizesthatfundingisnotunlimited.RealigningscarcehealthcarefundingdollarprioritieswithinexistingMOHbudgets,whilechallenging,mustbeundertakentobetterreflectthehealthcareneedsofpatientstoday.DiscussionofbudgetsandcostconsiderationscanbefoundindetailinPrimaryHealthCareTransformation:ANewModelforNursePractitioners(BCNPA,2016);thesehavebeenupdatedandincludedinAppendixAandB.NPfundingoptionsinclude:
• OptionA:HA-Employed
• OptionB:HA-Affiliated
ItisBCNPA’spositionthattheseapproacheswouldprovidestable,sustainablefundingforNPsinspecialtycaresettings,wouldnotbechallengingtoadministerandwouldpositiontheNPworkforceasaviablecomplementaryorinsomesituationsalternativeprovidertophysicianswiththepotentialtoyieldsystemwideefficienciesandcostsavingsinadditiontoimprovinghealthcareoutcomes,todayandinthefuture.
LackofaQualityAssuranceFramework Highqualityhealthcareistheoverarchinggoalofallhealthcarepolicy,planningandsystemdelivery.Evaluationandperformancemeasurementhavebecomefamiliarvocabularyinmosthealthcaresettings.TheCanadianInstituteforHealthinformation(CIHI)suggeststhatperformancemeasurementframeworksmustmeettheinformationneedsofthegeneralpublic,policy-makersandhealthsystemmanagers(CIHI,2013).Thepressingquestiontodayishowdohealthcareleadersandplannersensurevalueoutcomesgiventhesubstantialpublicresourcesspentdeliveringhealthcaretoday(Kleinpell,2005).
EvaluationandcontinuousqualityimprovementactivitiesareinplaceacrossHAstoday,andaredesignedtoprovidedatathatsupportstheefficient,effectiveuseofavailablehealthcaredollarsandtodemonstratethattheoverallgoalsoftheMOH,theHA,thecommunityandofcoursethepatientswhoarerecipientsoftheservicesdeliveredareachieved. However, evaluationframeworkstoooftencapturethelowhanging
-
21
fruit,inthatitiseasytounderstandthenumberofpatientvisits,patientsseen,procedurescompleted,infectionrates,births,deaths,bedsavailable,surgicalwaitlists–butdothesenumbersprovideenoughinformationtoensuregoodvalueandhigh-qualitycare?
BCNPAunderstandstheneedtobringcontinuouscriticalreflectiontoallpracticesettings,evaluatingnotonlynumericalstatisticsandservicesutilization,buttolookmorebroadlyatpatientspecificoutcomes/experiences,healthequity,socialdeterminantsofhealthindicators,humanresourcesallocation,systemgaps,systemwaste,andpotentialsolutionsorchangestoaddressthosegapswithafiscalandpatientlens.SeveralevaluationframeworksexisttodaythatwillbeusefulinunderstandingtheimpactofNPpracticeonpatienthealthoutcomes,organizationalpriorities,multidisciplinaryteamfunctioning,andsystemresponsiveness.Bryant-Lukosiusetal.(2016)developedanevaluationframeworkthatholdspromiseasafulsomeevaluationframeworkwithNPsensitiveoutcomesinparticularasshowninFigure3.
Figure3.FrameworkforEvaluatingtheImpactofAdvancedPracticeNursingRoles(Bryant-Lukosiusetal.,2016)
ThisFrameworkforEvaluatingtheImpactofAPNRoles(2016)coupledwiththeCanadianInstituteofHealthInformation’sNewHealthSystemPerformanceMeasurementFramework(2013)wouldallowforthemeasurementofNPspecificoutcomeswithinthecontextofbroaderhealthsystemoutcomemeasuresasoutlinedinFigure4.ThesearejusttwoqualityassuranceframeworksthatcanprovideausefulstartingpointastheprovincelookstoensurethatNPsareaddingvaluetothebroadersystemofcareincludingspecialtyandsubspecialtyprograms(CIHI,2013).
-
22
Figure4.CIHI’sNewHealthSystemPerformanceMeasurementFramework(CIHI,2013)
ExpandingtheNPworkforceinspecialtysettingsorintheprovisionofcareforspecializedpopulations(vulnerable/marginalized)isanexcellentopportunityfortheMOHtoobtainbroaderinnovativehealthoutcomedata,tobettersupportimproveddecisionmakingandworkforcedeploymentbasedonpatientneedandpopulatonhealthoutcomes.
2. Recommendation:Develop,AdoptandImplementQualityAssuranceFrameworkDevelopprogram/teamlogicmodelstomeasureNPspecificoutcomesasaneffectivemeanstosupportconsistencyinevaluationandqualityassuranceactivitiesspecificallyrelatedtoNPcareandthevalueofaddinganNPtoaspecializedcareteam(SeeToolkit).
Developandimplementastandardframeworkdemonstratingalignmentwithagreedupongoalsofcareandpositivepatientoutcomesforeverynewmodelofserviceimplemented.ThequalityassuranceframeworkcouldincludebroadhealthsystemsoutcomesthatareestablishedprovinciallywithininterdisciplinaryteamsalongwithadditionalNPspecificandteam-basedoutcomes.
Out-DatedNPRemunerationNPremunerationisessentiallyunchangedsincetheinitialMOHblockofNPfundingin2005.Thefirstremunerationpackagewassalaryplusnon-salarycompensationthatincludedadministrativesupport,officeequipmentandcontinuingeducationfundsforatotalof$146,000/NPposition.Thesecondblock,NP4BC(2012-2015),providedNPsalarycompensationperpositionatthesamerate(basedon2005levels),butdidnotincludethenon-salarycompensationrequiredforsuccessfulimplementationofanNPposition,leavingHAswithlimitedmechanismstoofferessentialnon-salarysupport,andinmanyinstanceseffectivelydecreasingtheoriginalnon-salarysupportasthesedollarsweredistributedbetweentheoriginallyfunded
-
23
NPsandtheNP4BCfundedNPs.Thissecondroundoftargetedfunding,earmarkedtoincreaseaccesstoprimarycare,hadtheunexpectedoutcomeofimprovingaccesstospecializedhealthcareformanyveryunderservedpopulations,asNPemploymentopportunitieswerecreatedtoprovidearangeofspecializedhealthcareservicesformedicallycomplex,highneedspopulationsbothinprimarycareandacutecarespecializedsettings.
Since2005,NPscopeofpracticeandNProleshaveexpandedandbroadenedtoincludeprescribingofcontrolleddrugsandsubstances,admittinganddischargingpatients,opioidagonisttherapyandtheprovisionofMAiD,enablingNPstofullyparticipateasactivemembersofhighlyspecializedhealthcareteams.Sincethattime,muchhasbeenlearnedaboutthecontributionsthatNPsinspecialtycarehavemadeandcontinuetomakeacrossthesystem.Despitethis,NPremuneration,regardlessofemploymentsettingremainsessentiallyunchangedandhasnotkeptupwith2017compensationpackagesforsimilarprofessionalgroups(e.g.PhysicianandMidwiferyMasterAgreements)nordoesitreflectthecomplexclinicalworkthatNPsareprovidingtodayinspecialtysettings.
WhilethebaserateofremunerationisimportanttoconsiderwhendeterminingamorereflectivesalaryforNPs,itisnottheonlyone.AsthescopeofpracticeofNPshasincreased,sotoohasrecognitionofthecontributionstheNProlehasmadetohealthcareteams.OverthelastseveralyearstherehasbeendiscussionabouttheneedforfundingmechanismsthatallowNPstoparticipateincallgroups,workweekendsandevenings,andhavelocumcoverageavailablewhentheyareawayonvacation.DeterminingappropriatefundingmechanismsandestablishingthebestapproachesthatconsiderallaspectsofNPworkalongsideemployerneedswilltakeaconsiderableamountofdiscussionandstakeholderinvolvement.Approachesandfundingmechanismsmaylookdifferentlycase-by-casedependingontheNPand/oremployer.
AlsoproblematicisthecurrentHealthEmployersAssociationofB.C.(HEABC)noncontractsalarygrid,asitexists.Thisgriddoesnotalignwiththepracticeofacliniciangroup(NPorMD).Designedprimarilyforhealthcaremanagementpersonnel,salariesaretiedtoperformancemeasuresthatreflectmanagerial/administrativeperformanceratherthanclinicalworkperformance.Assuch,performancemeasuresdonotalignwithtypicalNPpracticeandthecontributionsoftheNParelargelyinvisibleorarechallengingfortheNPtoarticulate.ThismismatchleadstomisunderstandingamonghealthcaremanagersanddirectorswhentryingtoevaluateNPperformance,contributestoroleconfusion,andaddstopoorjobsatisfaction.NPsalsoreachthetopofthegridwithinadecade,leavinglittleroomforadvancementandnorecognitionofadditionalexpertisetheNPmayacquire.NPsareuniqueinthattheyprovideaclinicalleadershiprolealongwithaclinicalpracticeroleandthereisnomechanismwithinthecurrentHEABCsalarygridtorecognizeandsupportthisimportantaspectNPscontributetothebroadersystem.
Simplyput,theissueofremunerationforNPswithspecializedpracticesisthreefold:
• Basesalaryhasnotkeptupwiththeincreasedresponsibilityormarketcompetitionandnon-salaryrelatedsupportfundingisinsufficientormissingformanyNPpositions.
• Thecurrentremunerationdoesnotincludecallorlocumcoverageoramechanismtoprovideforthisiftheseservicesarerequiredtomeetpatientneeds.
• BasesalarygridasperHEABCisnotapplicabletoclinicianprovidersanddoesnotreflectleadershipactivitiesoradditionalformallyacquiredexpertise.
3. Recommendation:DevelopaWorkingGrouptoReviewandUpdateNPRemunerationDuetothecomplexityofthisissue,BCNPAsuggeststhedevelopmentofaWorkingGrouptoestablishappropriatevaluesbasedremunerationthatismorereflectiveofthecurrentstateandscopeofNPpractice.TheworkinggroupshouldincluderepresentativesofAdult,PediatricandFamilyNPsworking
-
24
acrossvariedsettings,NPpracticeleadersinthehealthauthorities,NNPBC,CNOs,MOH,theChiefNursingSecretariat,HEABCrepresentativesandexpertsinclinicalcompensationpackages.TheBCNPArecommendsthattheworkinggroup:
1. RevisebaseremunerationpackagesforNPsincludingsalary,benefits,ongoingeducationfunds,andoverheadcosts,andestablishaprocessforregularreviewofremunerationtoensuremarketcompetitiveness.
2. Identifyarealistic,fairremunerationmechanismforNPsprovidingservicesoncall.Unlikeotherclinicianswhohavedependentcontractswiththehealthauthorities,NPsareemployeeswhodonotbillMSP,whichmakesfaircompensationdifficulttosortout.Therearealsodifferenttypesofcall(coveringlabsvs.takingcallsandattendingtopatients)andnumerouswaystoprovidecompensationforcallincludinganincreaseinbasesalary,timeinlieuorovertime,whichareoutlinedinthePhysicianMasterAgreement(B.C.MOH,2014a)andintheMOCAPRedesignPanelReport(B.C.MOH,2013).GiventhattheNPisprovidingsimilarservicesasotherclinicianssuchashospitalistsandmidwives,amasteragreementforsomeNProlesmayalsobeanoptionforconsideration.
3. DevelopanHEABCNon-ContractClinicianSpecificsalarygridincollaborationwithNPsthatbetterreflectstheclinicalworkthattheNPprovidesandwouldallowforimprovedperformancebasedcompensation.ThisrecommendationisnotonlyaboutupdatingthebasesalarybutstrivestoensurethatHAoperationshavethenecessaryfundingtofullymaximizetheutilizationoftheNPgrouptomeetorganizationalpriorities.HealthAuthoritiesmayalsofindthenewsalarygridapplicabletootheremployednon-contractclinicians.
LackofaHealthHumanResourcesStrategyHealthhumanresources(HHR)areoneofthemostimportantcontributorstothefunctioningofthehealthcaresystem.Timelyaccesstohealthcareisdependentontherightmixandvolumeofhealthcareprofessionalsintherightsetting.Thisinturnensurestherightproviderattherighttimefortherightcost,afiscallyresponsibleapproachgiventhelimitationsonhealthcarebudgets.HHRplanninginvolvesplanning,productionandmanagementprocesses.Planningisthemostintegralsteptoidentifyingcurrentandfutureneed,theavailablesupplytomeettheneed,andthedemandonhealthprofessionalswhoaredeliveringcare(Dreeschetal.,2005).Oncethegapbetweenrequirementsandavailablesupplyaredetermined,policiestosupportinitiativestobridgethedividecanbeimplemented(Birchetal.,2007).Unfortunately,thisstepwasmissedwhenNPswerefirstimplementedinB.C.leavingaworkforcethatisnotbeingutilizedtotheirfullpotentialandunlessahumanresourcesstrategyisimplementedimminently,isatriskforfurtherinefficiencies.
IntegratingstrategicdeploymentofNPswithininterdisciplinaryforecastingmodelswouldprovideacompletepictureofwhereNPswouldbebestsituatedaspartofcollaborativeteams,ensuringsuccessfulimplementationinkeypriorityareas.Planningshouldconsiderfactorssuchascurrentwaitlists,predictivemodelsofpopulationhealthneeds,patientcomplexityandprovidercompetenciestoensurepatienthealthneedsandsystemgapsareaddressed.CIHI’span-CanadianNPdatacancontributesubstantiallytoforecastingNPHHRneedinB.C.BCNPArecognizesthatimprovedplanningaroundtherequiredNPworkforceandpriorityareasoverthenextdecadeisanintegralsteptothesustainabilityoftheNProleinB.Cwhichwilleffectivelycontributetoamorefulsome,responsivehealthcaresystem.
-
25
In2006,theCNPIdevelopedaHealthHumanResourcesStrategytoassistprovincesindeterminingcurrentandfuturerequirementsforNPs,componentsofwhichwouldbeusefulindeterminingaprovincialstrategy(CNPI,2006).InadditiontotheCNPIHHRStrategy,twoothermodelsthatholdpromiseforplanningoftheNPworkforceareoutlinedbyBirchetal.,(2007)andDreeschetal.,(2005).TheDreeschModel(Figure5)wasdevelopedasaresponsetotheWorldHealthOrganizationMillenniumDevelopmentGoalsandseekstoalignhumanresourceplanningwithspecificinterventionsandthehealthprofessionalskillsetsrequiredtoachieveaspecifichealthoutcome.ThismodelholdspromiseinthatNPhumanresourceplanningcouldbealignedwiththerequiredskillsandservicesthatareidentifiedtoachieveprovincialgoalsforhealthcarereform.AnexampleofthiswouldbethedevelopmentofanNPstrategichealthhumanresourceplandirectedatmanagementofmentalhealthandsubstanceuse,dementiacareorcareofthefrailelderly.Thegraphicbelowdescribesthelogicandinteractionofthismodel:
Figure5.AnApproachtoEstimatingHumanResourcesRequirementtoAchievetheMillenniumDevelopmentGoals(Dreeschetal.,2005)
4. Recommendation:DevelopaHHRStrategytoNPDeploymentGiventhepredictedchangesinboththedemographicsofhealthcareprovidersandthepopulationinB.C.andCanada,astrategichealthhumanresourceapproachforNPdeploymentshouldbeundertakeninB.C.TheMOHshoulddevelopaclearvisionofdesiredoutcomes,determinethecurrentsupplyofNPsandworktoanticipatethefuturedemandtoensureappropriateresourceallocation/utilizationtomeetMOHgoals.
5. Recommendation:EmployNPsandIncreaseEducationalSeatsAccordingtotheHHRStrategyBasedonarobustHHRplan(above)andthepopulationhealthneedsorsystem/servicegapdefined,systemleaderscanidentifytheinterdisciplinarymixofcliniciansincludingNPsrequiredtobestmeetpatientneed.AppropriatenumbersofAcute,AmbulatoryandResidentialNPscanbeeducatedandemployedinareasofidentifiedneedaccordingly.AcorrespondingincreaseinthenumberofNPgraduatesfromB.C.programswilllikelyberequired,giventherestrictednumberofNPeducationalseatsandNPeducationalprogramsintheprovincetoday.
-
26
HHRPlanningExampleBasedonDreeschModel(Dreeschetal.,2005)
CaseExample-DowntownEastsideinVancouverIdentifyNeedforService-ComprehensiveMentalHealthandSubstanceUseApproach-goaltodecreasefentanyloverdoses
2017-914January-September2017whichis147%increasefrom2016-ifratescontinue-aprojected2,285willrequireservice(MinistryofPublicSafetyandSolicitorGeneral,2017)
IdentifyInterventionsRequired
• PatientMedicalHomeswithwraparoundservicesthatareavailableandbarrierfree
• Housingandemploymentavailability
• SubstanceSpecialtyCarelinkingbothprimaryandacutecaresettingswithfocusonharmreduction,preventionandbuildingtrustingrelationships
•MentalHealthSpecialtyCarelinkingbothprimaryandacutecaresettingswithfocusonharmreduction,preventionandbuildingtrustingrelationships
• Transitionalmodelofcare.
IdentifyTasksandSkillsRequired
• PrimaryCareProviderworkinginanon-FFSmodelwithanequitybasedapproachthatwillincludeworkingwithpatientsandtheircommunityonhousingandemployment
• SubstanceUseSpecialists–trainedinOAT
•MentalHealthSpecialists
IdentifyTimeRequirementsNPstakingcareofverycomplexpopulationswillhavearosterof400-600patients(Martin-Miseneretal.,2015).Ifworkinginawrap-aroundteamwithsocialworkers,GPs,addictionscounsellorsandpharmacists,thenumbercouldbe600-800-onaverage-600.TheNPcouldfollowpatientsfromprimaryhealthcareintoacutecareandbackintocommunitywithinaspecializedrole.
IdentifyOverlap/SynergiesNPsandGPshavesimilarskillsetandwilloverlapinbothsubstanceuseandmentalhealthexpertise-anyHHRplanningwillincludeGPsandroleswillbecomplementary.
EstimateNPFTE4FTEfor2285patients(NPsintegratedintointerdisciplinaryteamswithrosterof600)
EstimatedCost$774,976(AppendixC)
-
27
NPEducationalProgramsNotReflectiveofEmploymentOpportunitiesInB.C.,therearethreeregulatedNPstreamsofpractice–Family,AdultandPediatric(Figure6).Intheadultandpediatricstreams,NPsworkwiththeserespectivepopulationsallowingforamorefocusedareaofexpertise.TheAdultandPediatricNPs’in-deptheducation,skillsandcompetenciespreparethemtoworkwithspecialtypopulationsinacutecareand/orspecialtypracticesettings.However,in2005,tosupporttheMOHfocusonincreasingaccesstoprimarycare,theMinistryofAdvancedEducationandMOHcommittedtofundingFamilyNPprogramsonly,offeredatthreeB.C.universities:UBC,UVICandUNBC.CandidateswishingtoaccessMastersNPeducationinAdultorPediatricsmustseekoutprogramsinotherprovincessuchastheUniversityofAlberta,UniversityofTorontoorintheU.S.suchasTheUniversityofWashington.
Figure6.NPsinB.C.byStream/Category(CRNBC,personalcommunication,March9,2017)
SincetheinitialimplementationoftheNProleinB.C.,therehavebeeninconsistenciesbetweenthenumberofgraduatingFamilyNPsandthecommunity/primarycareemploymentopportunitiesavailable,despitethenumberofBritishColumbianswithoutconsistentaccesstoprimarycare.Thislackofopportunitytopracticeinprimary/communitybasedcare,coupledwiththegapsinacuteandsub-specialtycareprogramshasledmanyFamilyNPstoseekrolesofferedinacutecaresettings.Interestingly,thisphenomenonisoccurringnationally,whereitisreportedthatthenumberofNPsworkingincommunitysettingshasdecreasedsince2005from58percentto32percentandthoseworkinginhospital/acutesettingshasincreasedfrom28percentto40percentdespitethefocusonprimarycareasoutlinedinFigure7(CNPI,2016).TheBCNPArecognizesthatthishasoccurredduetomultiplefactors,however,mostnotablyinB.C.,NPfundingwassolelyprovidedtoHAswhichareexpertandmandatedintheprovisionofacuteandspecialtycareservices,ratherthanprimarycareservices.Furthermore,thedeliveryofprimarycareinB.C.todayresideswithfamilyphysicianprivatepractice,stronglysupportedthroughtheGeneralPracticeServicesCommittee(GPSC)withagoaltofacilitateprimarycaretransformation.NPsintheprovinceareexcludedfromthisprimarycareinitiative.Inaddition,itisdisturbingthattherehasalsobeenareductionofNPsworkinginruralareasoverthelastdecade-from29percentto18percentfurthercompromisinghealthcaredeliveryinruralareas(CNPI,2016).
90%
7%
3%
NPsinB.C.byStream/Category
Family
Adult
Pediatric
-
28
Figure7.PlaceofWorkAmongNPsinCanada,2005and2014(CNPI,2016)
OftheNPsworkinginspecialtyrolesinB.C.today,someareAdultorPediatricNPseducatedinotherjurisdictions,however,themajorityareFamilyNPgraduatesofB.C.universityprograms.ManyoftheseFamilyNPsbringvaluableclinicalskillsandregisterednursingexperiencetothosepracticesettings,howeversomearenewgraduateNPs,withoutpreviousexpertise,whomustacquireadditionaleducation,mentorshipandclinicalexperiencetodevelopthecompetenciesrequiredtoprovidefulsomeclinicalcareinaspecializedNProle.Forexample,aFamilyNPgraduatewhohasseveralyearsoforthopedicexperienceasaRN,willlikelypossesstheadditionalexpertknowledgeandcompetenciesrequiredforaspecializedcareroleaspartofanorthopedicteam,whereasaFamilyNPgraduatelackingthisspecificRNexperiencewillneedadditionaltrainingtoacquirespecializedcompetencies.B.C.ismissinganopportunitytoimproveaccesstoacutecareservicesandtoimproveacutecareservicedeliverybylimitingtheprovincetooneeducationalprogram-MNNP(Family).
Anearlyattemptin2002/2003bytheBritishColumbiaInstituteofTechnology(BCIT)toaddresstheeducationalgapintermsoftheAdultNPstreamofpracticewasnotsustainable.BCIT’sSpecialtyNursingProgramsexploredtheneedforanAdultacutecarefocusedNPprograminresponsetotwokeyevents:TheMinistryofAdvancedEducationgrantedBCITtheprivilegeofofferingAppliedMastersdegreesin2002,andthegovernmentproposedlegislationallowingNPpracticeinB.C.ThefacultyconductedanenvironmentalsurveytodeterminetheneedforanAdultNPpost-master’sprograminB.C.overatwo-yearspan,revealingsolidsupportfrommultiplestakeholders(healthcareagencies,studentgroupsandprofessionalbodies)forthedevelopmentofanAdultNPprogrampreparingNPstopracticeinspecializedsettings.TheprogramwasdevelopedandthefirstcohortofstudentswasadmittedinAugust2005.Unfortunately,theprogramfacedmanychallenges,mostnotablyalackoffundingduetoafocusonFamilyNPeducationprogramsinotherinstitutions,thatthreateneditssustainability.This,alongwithlackofpublicawarenessabouttheBCITprogramandAdultNPstreamofpracticeledtolowenrollmentandsubsequentdismantlingoftheprogram.
6. Recommendation:ReviewandUpdateEducationinB.C.toReflectPopulationNeedsReopendiscussionsregardingestablishingAdultandPediatricNPprogramsintheprovinceas40%ofNPsarepracticingwiththesespecialtypopulations.ItisimportanttonotethattheBCITcurriculumisstillavailableforusebyMOHandMinistryofAdvancedEducationandSkillsTrainingandthereiswillingnessforengagementandparticipationbyoriginalfaculty.
-
29
LackofPostgraduateNPEducationDuetothesmallnumberofAdultandPediatricNPslicensedinB.C.,alargenumberofgraduatingFamilyNPsarebeingactivelyrecruitedandhiredintopositionssupportingdisease-specificspecializedpopulationsinspecialtysettings,oftenwithouttheadditionalexpertisetoprovidethecomprehensivecaretheroledemandsasdescribedabove.ManyNPsworkinginspecialtyroleshavepriornursingexperienceintheseareas,however,thisisnotalwaysthecase.ThisisaconcernraisedregularlybytheNPshiredintopositionsaswellastheHAemployersastheNPseeksexpertiseinadditionalclinicalskills.ThisissueimpactsteamandorganizationalefficiencyandultimatelyhasthepotentialtoimpacttheefficientdeliveryofservicestothepatientaswellasdamagesthecredibilityoftheNProle.
Additionally,thereisalackofstandardizationamongHAswithrespecttotraining/support/mentoringprogramsforNPsworkingonspecialty,acute,andmulti-disciplinaryteams(e.g.,palliative,trauma,HIV,ICU,etc.)andtheCRNBCdoesnotprovideorrecognizespecialtypracticecertificationsforNPs.ThisissueisfurthercomplicatedwhenthefullylicensednoviceNPwhoisprovidedadvancedclinicaltrainingisconfusedwithmedicalresidentsorstudenttraineesratherthanrecognizedasaqualifiedproviderseekingadditionalexpertise.Thesituationoftencontributestoalackofsupportfromotherhealthprofessions(e.g.,hospitalists,orotherspecialists)whomightquestionanNPscompetencetopracticeinaspecialtycarerole.
ManyU.S.authorspointoutthatafellowshipmodelhasbeensuccessfulforphysiciancolleaguesnewtoaspecializedrole(Andrade,2015;Kells,Dunn,Melchiono&Burke,2015;Wojneretal.,2009).Kells,Dunn,MelchionoandBurke(2015)pointoutthatwhilevariableon-the-jobtrainingmaybehelpfultoskilledNPsenteringspecialisedareasofpractice,thisapproachlacksthein-depthstructurethataformalfellowshipprogramwithcertificationcanprovide.
Currentprovincialexamplesofstandalonehospital-basedspecificNPFellowshipmodelsforsub-specialtypracticeexist;mostnotablyforNPsworkingintheICUsettingatAbbotsfordRegionalHospitalandNPsworkinginCardiacSurgeryatRoyalColumbianHospital.BCWomen’sHospitalhasalsorecentlydevelopedaNeonatalNPfellowship,whichwillprepareFamilyandPediatricNPsforclinicalrolesintheNICU.However,thesefellowshipsarelocallybasedanddonotprovideNPswiththerecognizedcredentialstomovefromoneHAtoanother.Ideally,fellowshipmodelsshouldbedevelopedjointlybetweenacademicinstitutionsandaffiliatedhealthauthorityagenciesensuringstandardizedrecognizedcredentialingaswellasportability.
7.Recommendation:DevelopNPPostgraduateFellowshipProgramsProvidingaconsistentstructuredapproachintheformofpostgraduatefellowshipswillallowFamilyNPgraduatestosuccessfullyacquirethecompetenciestoworkinaspecialtysetting,effectivelycontributingtoimprovedhealthoutcomesforthepatientsserved.BCITspecialtyprogramscouldbedevelopedtoensurethedevelopmentandmaintenanceofcompetenciesforFamilyNPs.
Initially,practicalclinicaltrainingcompetencyacquisitionmayneedtoinvolvespecialistphysiciansasmentors/clinicalresources,however,theultimategoaloftheNPFellowshipprocessmustbetohavequalifiedNPsprovidethisadvancedlearning.HAsmusttakealeadershiproleinsupportingthistypeofpostgraduatelearning,withfundingsupportfromtheMOH.
BCNPArecommendsthatpostgraduateNPFellowshipprogramsbeprovincial,credentialedandprovidedinaffiliationwithanaccrediteduniversity.Thistypeofmodelalreadyexistsincertainareas–suchastheFellowshipforNPsattheBCCentreforSubstanceUse,whichisrecognizedprovincially.
-
30
LackofaStandardizedProfessionalPracticeFrameworkTheabsenceofaProfessionalPracticeFrameworkinB.C.,thatincludesastandardizedapproachtoNProledevelopmentandintegrationhasledtoinconsistentimplementationofNProlesacrosstheprovince,roleconfusion,uncertaintyaboutpriorityareasforNProles,failedroles,andsub-optimaloutcomemeasurementmetrics.Schober,GerrishandMcDonnell(2015)examinedpolicydevelopmentforNPsandhowpolicytranslatesintopractice.Theyconcludedthatstrategicplanningutilizingaframeworkwasessentialforfullandseamlessintegration.
TheAmericanNursesCredentialingCenterMagnetApplicationManualdefinesaprofessionalpracticemodelas“theoverarchingconceptualframeworkfornurses,nursingcare,andinter-professionalpatientcare.Itisaschematicdescriptionofasystem,theory,orphenomenonthatdepictshownursespractice,collaborate,communicate,anddevelopprofessionallytoprovidethehighest-qualitycareforthoseservedbytheorganization”(Silverstein&Kowalski,2017,“ProfessionalPracticeModelDefined”).TheinabilitytosuccessfullyintegrateNPsintohealthcareteamsfrequentlyoccurswhenthereisambiguityandnoclearvisionofhowtheroleshouldbeintegratedintoexistingsystems(Elliott&Walden,2014).Becauseofthis,magnethospitalsintheU.S.arerequiredtohaveaprofessionalpracticeframework(Silverstein&Kowalski,2017).
AcursoryliteraturereviewrevealsnumerousProfessionalPracticeFrameworksthatcanbeadaptedtofittheB.C.context(Elliott&Walden,2014;DiCensoetal.,2007;CNPI,2006;Byrant-Lekosius&DiCenso,2004).UtilizingexistingframeworkstoestablishaguidetoamodelofcarefortheNProleinB.C.willimproveconsistency,roleclarityandtheabilitytomeasuresimilaroutcomesacrosstheprovince.Inaddition,itwillfacilitateorganizationalunderstandingaboutthevalueoftheNProle,andwillcontributetoappropriateutilizationoftheNProleinfutureplanning.TheTransformationalAdvancedProfessionalPracticeModel(TAPP)isjustoneexampleofatransformationalNPpracticemodel,whichincludessixprofessionaldevelopmentdomainsandonepatientcaredomainasshowninFigure8(Elliott&Walden,2014).ThisframeworkcouldbecoupledwithprojectmanagementapproachestorealizethebenefitoftheNP.Executionofsuchaframeworkmustreflecttheuniquenatureofregionalandlocalcommunities’characteristics,needsandgoals,andshouldconsidertheintegrationofNPsacrossthecontinuumofcare.TheBCNPAhasdevelopedaToolkitasacompanionpiecetothisdocumentthatwillbeausefulplatformforaprovincialframeworkandarobustroledevelopmentandimplementationstrategy(SeeToolkit).
8.Recommendation:AdoptaProfessionalPracticeFrameworktoEnableaStandardizedApproachDeveloporadoptaprovincialNPprofessionalpracticeframeworkensuringsuccessfulconsistentNProleimplementationorintegrationacrosstheprovince.TheadoptionofaprovincialframeworkwouldprovideHAswithasolidplatformforNProleintegration,andensureroleclaritythatwouldincorporatethelocalcontextandpatientpopulationneeds.AclearframeworkwillalsoimproverecruitmentandretentionofNPsovertime(Robinson,Eck,Keck,&Wells,2013).
-
31
Figure8.TheTransformationalAdvancedProfessionalPracticeModel(Elliot&Walden,2014)
PersistingIssueswithRoleClarityRoleconfusionhasbeenidentifiednumeroustimesasoneofthekeybarrierstothesuccessfulintegrationoftheNPprovider(Sangster-Gormley,2012;Bryant-Lukosiusetal.,2010;DiCensoetal.,2010;Donaldetal.,2010;DiCensoetal.,2007).Despiteavailableeducation,pamphlets,flyers,slidepresentationsandformaladvertisingcampaigns,(e.g.,“It’sAboutTime”Campaign,CNA,2013),therecontinuestobemisunderstandingandmisinformationabouttheNPscopeofpracticebothinternallywithinnursingandexternallyamongotherhealthcaredisciplinesandthepublic.ThiscontributestoincreasingambiguityandcontinuestobeamajorbarriertoeffectiveintegrationofNPsinB.C.
Withinthenursingcommunity,thereisapersistentlackofclarityaboutthetwodistinctAdvancedPracticeNursingroles,theNProleandtheClinicalNurseSpecialist(CNS)role.ThesearecomplementarymasterspreparedroleswithinnursingandwhileNPscopeofpractice,thebroadestinthenursingprofession,doesoverlapwiththepracticeoftheCNS,theNProlefocusesprimarilyonthedeliveryofclinicalcarewhiletheCNSprovidesastrongeremphasisonsystemchangesandbestpractice.TheNPandCNSrolesarecomplementaryandworkwelltogetheraddressinggapsinpatientcarefromthebedsidetothebroadersystemasawhole(McNamara,Lepage,&Boileau,2011;Carteretal.,2010).Unfortunately,thesecomplementaryrolesareoftenhamperedbyalackoffunding,andareoftenconsideredeither/orbyplanners,andconsequentlyarenotoftenfoundtogetherinB.C.resultinginadetrimenttothesystem.
-
32
Withinthebroaderhealthcarecommunity,NPsandPhysicianAssistants(PA)areoftendescribedashavinginterchangeableroleswithsimilarscopesofpractice.However,thisisincorrect.NPsareautonomousproviders,regulatedbytheCRNBC,whodonotrequirephysiciansupervision.NPsmayworkindependentlywithotherNPsorasmembersofmultidisciplinaryteamsprovidingfullservicemedicalcareintegratinganursingsciencelenstotheclinicalcareforpopulationsservedandalsoprovideanursingleadershiprolethatPAsdonot.
TheHospitalistroleandtheClinicalAssociate(CA)rolearetwootherroleswithinB.C.(usuallyfundedthroughthePhysicianMasterAgreement)thatareoftennotwellunderstood,andwhichoverlapwithspecialtyNProles.InB.C.,CAsaretypicallyfullylicensedphysicianswhoaremedicalstaff,butnotthemostresponsibleprovider(MRP).Forexample,aCAmaysupportasurgicalgroupbydoingallin-hospitalconsultsorpostoperativemedicalcareorprovidethedaytodaymedicalcareofneonatesinaNICU.InB.C.,theroleoftheHospitalististoprovidegeneralmedicalcaretopatientswhoareinthehospital.TheygenerallyworkalongsideconsultantstocreateamedicalteamandusuallyfunctionastheMRPduringthehospitalization.BoththeCAandHospitalistrolearecurrentlyfilledbyphysiciansandarethereforefundedthroughthephysicianmasteragreement.ItisimportanttonotethatNPsintheU.S.functionasHospitalistsandtherearesomerecentexamplesofNPsworkinginthiscapacityinB.C(InteriorHealthAuthority).Thisisagoodexampleofidentifyinganorganizationalpriority,patientneed,andaservicegapincaredeliveryandaligninganappropriateprovidertofillthisfunction,regardlessofprofessionaldesignationtoachievethegoalsofcareandimprovesystemresponsiveness.
Theimportanceofroleclaritycannotbeoveremphasized.Overthelastdecade,significantinroadshavebeenmadeandthoseprofessionalswhoworkwithoralongsideNPsfullyunderstandtheclinicalroleNPsprovide.ShiftingthefocustoservicesdeliveredbyaprovidergrouplikeNPsisakeyculturalchangethatmustoccur.Doingawaywithout-datedhealthcarehierarchyiskeyincreatingandfacilitatingopportunitiesforinterdisciplinaryteamstoworkcollaboratively,experiencecomplementaryteammemberskillsets,andbenefitfromtheexpertiseoftheNPwithrespecttothefullrangeofservicestheNPprovidesincludingexpertclinicalcare,advancedknowledge/skills/decision-making,clinicalservicedelivery-strategicevaluationofunmethealthcareandhealthserviceneeds;teamfunctioning,systemdesignandresearch.
9.Recommendation:DevelopandImplementanNPRoleClarityCampaignTheMOHandtheNursingPolicySecretariatshouldestablishapublicroleclaritycampaignthatcouldincludetelevisionadvertising,busstopadvertising,pamphlets,flyers,posters,andasocialmediacampaign.
AdoptroleclarityrecommendationsasdescribedbyDonaldetal.,(2010)including:
• CreateavisionstatementtoarticulatetheroleofNPsacrossallsettings.
LindaYearwood,NP(F),Hospitalist,OlderAdults–Kelowna,B.C.“AsamemberofacollaborativeNP/PhysicianHospitalistservicedeliverymodel,Iprovidedirectcare,includingshort-termandlong-termplanningofpatientcarewithmembersoftheinterdisciplinaryteamandcoordinatethetransitionsincareincludingthedischargefromhospital.Ilookafteradesignatedsub-setofunattached,sub-acuteandalternatelevelofcare(ALC)patientsontheHospitalistServicecensuswhodonothaveafamilypractitionerinthecommunity,ortheirfamilypractitionerdoesnothaveactiveprivilegesinthehospital,ortheyarereceivingtertiarycarefromoutoftown.NPcareincludes7dayaweekcoverageforapproximately15-18patients/day,includingweekendandstatutoryholidays.CommondiagnosesofNPpatientsinclude:heartfailure,dementia,delirium,COPD,fractures,kidneyinjuries(acuteonchronic)andpalliativecare.NPHospitalistsinIHhavebeengrantedactivemedicalprivilegeswithinthehospital.EvaluationexpectationsoftheroleoftheNPHospitalistinclude:improvedcontinuityofcare;enhancedmulti-disciplinaryandinter-professionalteamplanning;decreasedlengthofstay,decreasedadmissionsandreducedhospitalcosts.”
-
33
• Developacommunicationstrategytoeducatehealthcareprofessionals,thepublicandemployersaboutNProles.
• Attendtointer-professionalteamdynamicswhenintroducingNProles.• Addressinter-professionalisminallhealthprofessionaleducationprogramcurricula.
Legislative,RegulatoryandOrganizationalRestrictionstoNPPracticeTheBCNPArecognizesthatmanybarrierstoNPspracticingtofullscopehavebeenremovedoverthelastdecade,however,numerouslegislative,regulatoryandorganizationalbarriersremaininplace,whichimpactNPsabilitytodeliverfullservicepatientcare.LegislativebarriersmaystillincludetheChangeofGenderDesignationformfortransgenderpatientsundergoinggender-affirmingtherapiesandinterventions,thePersonswithMultipleBarriersform,eventhoughthisisaprecursortothePersonswithDisabilitiesformthathasrecentlybeenchangedtoacceptNPsignatures.SomeorganizationalbarriersincluderestrictionsandlimitsonMRIorderingdespitethisbeinglegislatedandregulatedaspartofNPscopeofpracticeandtheMedicalOrdersforScopeofTreatment(MOST)formwhichisacceptedwithanMDsignaturebutnotanNPsignatureinsomebutnotallHAs(dependingonthelegaladviceprovided)eventhoughtheformitselfacceptsanNPsignature.
10.Recommendation:RemoveLegislative,RegulatoryandOrganizationalBarriersTheMOHandHAsshouldworktoremovealllegislative,regulatoryandorganizationalbarriersby:
• CompilingandmaintaininganactivelistofexistinglegislativebarrierswithactionsforremovalwiththislistavailabletoallNPs.
• Bundlingtherequiredlegislativechangestoenableseveraltogothroughthelegislativeprocesswhenabillthatimpacts(orshouldimpact)NPsisbeingchanged.
• ReviewingandregularlyupdatingtheMSPlistofservicesthatanNPcanordertoensurescopeofpracticechangesarecurrentorremovingitaltogether.
• ProvidingprovincialdirectionfororganizationalbarrierssuchasMRIorderingandtheMOSTformsincollaborationwiththeChiefNursingOfficerleadershipgroup.
-
34
Guiding Principles Anylarge-scalestrategythatincludesaclearvisionandobjectivesrequiresguidingprinciplestoenableafoundationalpurposeanddirection.TheBCNPAfeelsthefollowingareintegraltothesuccessfulimplementationoftherecommendationsoutlinedabove.
Patient-CentredHealthcareservicesaredelivered“aroundtheindividual,nottheproviderandadministration”(B.C.MOH,2015b,p.1).
TheBritishColumbiaMinistryofHealthPatient-CentredCareFramework(2015)promotestheconceptofpatientsandfamiliestakinganactiveroleintheirownhealthinpartnershipwiththeirhealthcareprovider(s),andpatientsandfamilymembersareconsideredanintegralpartofthecareandhealingprocess.Feinberg(2014)suggeststhatfamilymembershavetraditionallybeeninvisibletocaregiversandexcludedfromthecareprocess.Asthecultureshiftstopatientandfamilycentredcare,thetherapeuticrelationshipsforallhealthcareprofessionalswillberedefined.Forpatients’andfamilymembersthissimplymeansarespectforthewholepersonandthefamily’svaluesandchoicesforensuringcontinuityofcare(Bisognano,2009).
Groundedinanursingscienceperspective,NPmodelsofcareplacethefocusofcareonthepatient’sexperienceoftheirdisease,conditionorhealthconcernwithinthecontextoftheirwholelife,ratherthanconcentratingsolelyonthediseaseitself.NPshaveanethicalobligationtoensurethatthevoicesanddecisionsofpatientsandfamiliesarereflectedinthedeliveryofhealthcareservicesandtheircareperspectiveplacestheNPinastrongpositiontoofferexpertiseandleadershipasthisnewapproachtohealthcareunfolds.
InterdisciplinaryandCollaborative“Acutecaredeliverymodelswillsupportcollaborative-relationalinter-professionalcareandwillbefocusedondrivinginterprofessionalteamsandfunctionswithbetterlinkagestocommunityhealthcare”(B.C.MOH,2014b,p.5)
MultidisciplinaryorinterdisciplinaryteamsexistinmanyspecialtysettingsinB.C.today,refocusingtheireffortsoncosteffectivepatient/person-centredcare,andlookingtoimproveaccesstospecializedhealthcareservices,creatingenvironmentstousetherightproviderskillsetchosenfromavarietyofqualifiedhealthprofessionalswhocanbestmeetpatientcareneeds.Modelsofferimprovedaccesstospecialtyorsub-specialtycareforurgentconcerns,appropriatespecializedfollow-upandmonitoring,healthprevention/promotion,andpartnershipswithotherservicesectors.Maximizingtheefficienciesthatcanbefoundwithinasystemthatisinclusiveofallhealthcareproviderssuchasregisterednurses,pharmacists,socialworkers,counsellorsandpsychologistsallworkingtofullscopeofpracticeisanessentialcomponentofinterdisciplinaryteams.Numerousprovidersarerequiredtoimprovethehealthofasinglepatientacrosstheirlifespan.Apower-shifttoamoreegalitariananddemocraticstructureiscriticaltosuccessfultransformation.Allhealthcareprofessionalsinvolvedinthedeliveryofhealthcareshouldworktofullscopeofpracticetomaximizeefficienciesandberecognizedforthecareofthatpatient.Movingawayfrompatriarchalapproachesandhierarchy,relationalteamsworktobuildrelationshipswithpatientsandwithintheteamthatfurtherstheunderstandingaboutindividualandpopulationneeds.Scholle,Torda,Peikes,Han,andGenevro,(2010)andotherssuggestthattotrulybepatient-centred,acareteamwouldnotnecessarilybephysician-led,butwouldallowtheleadertobeselectedbytheteam–whetheraphysician,NP,socialworker,psychologistorothers.Thepatientsareattachedtotheteam,ratherthanasingleproviderandtheteamviewsthepatient/communitythroughmultiplelensesversusthesinglelensthatoftenisone-dimensionalandnotholistic.Attentiontorelationalbasedcareisfoundationaltobuildinghighlyeffectiveteamsthathaveasharedvision,purposeandmandate.Caredoesnotrelyonasingleprovidertodirect–ratheronprocessestoensureformalandinformalcollaboration.
-
35
NPRepresentation“As Advanced Practice Nurses, NPs possess competencies in change management, research, leadership, and clinical care, therefore their expertise and input will be included at all levels of decision-making in order to further effectively utilize the NP role in B.C. (CNPI, 2016, p. 39) NursePractitionersareessentialleaderswithinthecurrenthealthcaresystemandcaneffectivelycontributetohealthcarereformandpolicydevelopment.OpportunitiesforclinicalleadershiprolesincludingDirectorsofclinicalprogramsandDepartmentHeadshouldbeopentoNPs.TheabsenceofNPsinleadershiprolesoratdecision-makingtablesisasignificantcontributortothelackofawarenessofadvancedpracticenursingroleswithinhealthcareorganizationsandthepublic.ThislackofunderstandingactsasabarriertosuccessfulimplementationofNProleintegration(Sangster-Gormley,Martin-Misener,Downe-Wamboldt&DiCenso,2011).UtilizingNPexpertiseatalllevels(clinicalcare,leadership,educationandresearch)hasgreatpotentialtopositivelyimpacthealthcaresystemresponsiveness,leadtoimprovedaccesstohealthcareacrossthespectrumofcare–contributetoimprovedcontinuityofcare,healthierpatientpopulationsandcontributetoanimprovedpatientexperienceofthesystemofcare.
Dr.HalSiden,MD,Children’sHospiceMedicalDirector-Vancouver,B.C“TheNursePractitionerroleinapediatricpalliativecareprogramwithprovincialreachhasbeenafoundationalelementindevelopinganoutreachprogram.Supportingfamilieswhomovetheircarebetweenaninpatienthospiceunit,hospitalandcommunityrequiresahighdegreeofskillincoordination.Furthermore,whenwesaycommunitywereallyarereferringtobothservicesthataredistributedincommunitiesacrossprofessionalsandagencies,andtocareprovidedbyfamilydirectlyintheirhome.Thematrixofcareishighlycomplex.
TheNPbringsbothastrongsenseofdevelopingapathwayforfamiliesinthiscomplexenvironment,combinedwiththeabilitytoprovidedirect,hands-oncarethroughassessment,treatment,counselling,problem-solvingandsupport.”ItisnotpossibletoimaginedevelopingandexpandingastrongoutreachmodelwithouttheNProle.”
-
36
Summary of Recommendations 1. DevelopaSustainableSalary-BasedNPFundingFramework
2. Develop,AdoptandImplementaQualityAssuranceFramework
3. DevelopaWorkingGrouptoReviewandUpdateNPRemuneration
4. DevelopaHealthHumanResourcesStrategytoNPDeployment
5. EmployNPsandIncreaseEducationalSeatsAccordingtotheHHRStrategy
6. ReviewandUpdateNPEducationinB.C.toReflectPopulationNeeds
7. DevelopNPPostgraduateFellowshipPrograms
8. AdoptaNPProfessionalPracticeFrameworktoEnableaStandardizedApproach
9. DevelopandImplementanNPRoleClarityCampaign
10. RemoveLegislative,RegulatoryandOrganizationalBarriers
ElizabethLeonardis,NP(F),HomeCare-Vancouver,B.C.“Iamamemberofaninterdisciplinaryspecializedteam,whoprovidehomebasedhealthcareforcomplexfrailseniorswhoarelivingathome.Oneofmypatientsisan89-year-oldmanwithmoderatedementia(newlydiagnosed),severecongestiveheartfailure,significantcoronaryarterydiseaseandchronickidneydiseasehaschosentocontinuetolivingonhisown,inhishome.Hehadnumeroushospitalizationsforsymptomaticheartfailurepriortoourteam’sinvolvement.Thepatientwasveryclearthathewantedtostayinhishomeanddidnotwanttogotoresidentialcare.Iprovidedlongitudinalprimarycare,managingthisfrailseniors’chronicdiseasescompetently,whilesupportinghiswishestoremaininhishomeuntiltheendofhislifetherebypromotinganenhancedqualityofcare.Workinginpartnershipwithhiscommunityhomehealthteamandfamily,myselfalongwiththesupportofmyteam,managedtokeepthepatientoutofhospitalforthelastsixmonthsofhislife,toinstitutepalliativecareandcaregiversinthehomeandeventuallytosupporthistransfertohospicewherehepassedpeacefullyaweeklater.”
-
37
Summary InBritishColumbiatoday,40percentofNPsarepracticingacrossthehealthcaresysteminawiderangeofspecialtyroles.TheseNPshavedemonstratedtheirvaluetotheteam,theirpatientsandthesystematlarge,andyettheyremainlargelyoverlookedbyhealthcaredecision-makers,andtheplanninginfrastructureofboththeMOHandlocalHealthAuthorities.Atthesametime,theliteratureshowsthatspecialtyNPscanprovideenormousbenefitsintermsofimprovedaccesstocareforpatients,increasedeffici