acquisition accelerator - harland clarke · broad portfolio of innovative products and services...
TRANSCRIPT
May 7, 2014
Proprietary and Confidential
© 2014 Harland Clarke. Acquisition Accelerator is a registered trademark of Harland Clarke. First Touch is a trademark of Harland Clarke. All other marks are the property of their respective owners. All rights reserved.
Acquisition Accelerator® Secure Low-Cost Core Deposits Before the Competition Heats Up
Presenters: Erik Kelley, Senior Product Marketing Manager Michael Dorrington, Director of Sales, Mail Innovation
Meeting reference materials will be provided within one week of this webcast
Why Valassis & Harland Clarke
● Harland Clarke acquired Valassis in February 2014
● Combines Harland Clarke’s financial institution marketing expertise with Valassis’s proven ability to effectively, intelligently deliver media campaigns for the country’s largest advertisers and marketers
● Deep and tenured customer relationships with the largest financial, consumer products and retail institutions worldwide, offering clients a broad portfolio of innovative products and services
● Acquisition Accelerator, a checking acquisition solution for financial institutions, uses the Valassis proprietary segmentation clustering product to target potential account holders
2
● Appropriate product focus with upsell strategy
● Targeted and consistent direct mail – top of mind
● One-to-one segmented communication
● Low-cost delivery
● Perceived high-value gift or incentive
● Well-executed account holder referral program
● Mystery Shop & Sales Training provided
● Strategy, not a promotion
3
Key Drivers of a Successful Harland Clarke Program
4
NIM on average combined deposits1 $ 700.82
Average debit card users interchange2 $ 60.00
One NSF per year3 $ 30.00
Total annual value of a checking account4 $ 790.82
Average Cost to Acquire a New Checking Account:
$4425
Value = NIM on Combined Deposits + Interchange on Card Transactions + Fees
The Value of a New Checking Household = $790.82
1 Harland Clarke Industry Database, Average Total Consumer Deposits for Checking Account Holders- $19,096
2 FDIC, Second Quarter Banking Profile, Average NIM- $3.73% 3 Javelin Strategy & Research, Debit Card Average Interchange- $60 4 Moebs Services, Average NSF Fee- $30 5 Callahan *& Associates, Average Cost to Acquire a New Checking Household - $442
Why Checking Household Acquisition?
● Deposit rates will rise soon and, when they do, low-cost deposits will be at a premium
● Money Market balances will likely move to higher yielding vehicles
● CD balances will become more expensive, driving up the cost of funds
● Regulators are stressing banks' deposit bases during examinations and are paying great attention to liquidity and how deposits might behave when rates eventually rise
● Adding new checking households provides additional cross-sell opportunities for our clients to increase their net interest income
5
Checking Acquisition Process
HC/Valassis’ Unique Approach
6
$
7
Identify | the Target Account Holder
2,000 Real World Data Points
Sharpshooters®
8
Examples of Available Resources for Financial Clients
Syndicated data variables identify the best account holders where they live
Identify |
Geographic Alignment:
Radius (3-7 Mile)
Market-Level Coverage
Forced Inclusion/Exclusion
Efficiency Factors
Consumer Behavior/Spending:
Financial Services
Investment Allocation & Methods
Insurance
Other Professional Services
Income/Worth/Demographic Variables:
Median Household Income
Additional HHI Breakout by Age/Ethnicity
Household Net Worth
Home Ownership
Employment Status
Education/Degree Achieved Home Characteristics:
Breakout of Apartments/Single-Family
Median Home Value
Length Lived in Home
Median Age of Homes
Value Scores/Creditworthiness:
Group A – Most Creditworthiness
Group B – Above Average Creditworthiness
Group C – Average Creditworthiness
Group D – Below Average Creditworthiness
Group E – Least Creditworthiness
While syndicated data is extremely useful, we consider client data as the best possible source for building an optimized targeting strategy
● First and only clustering system built at the postal carrier-route level
Facilitates low-cost direct mail
● Emphasizes ethnicity and urbanicity attributes
Clusters more accurately portray differing account holder segments
Provides more advanced targeting and more effective versioning
Achieves better response
● Provides advanced targeting for increased account holder response and distinct competitive advantage
● Connects census to postal geography
Clusters assigned at the CR level
Distributions tabulated for the trade area
Information updated monthly to reflect changes in the boundaries of the trade area
9
Identify | Sharpshooters™
10
Identify | Sharpshooters
Methodology
● Each cluster represents a unique combination of demographics and lifestyle characteristics
Ethnicity
- Dominant Ethnicity
Affluence
- Median HH Income
- Median Home Value
- Median Years of Education
- Occupation
Generation
- Dominant Generation
- Median Age
Life Stage
- Marital Status
- Presence of Children
Environment
- Urbanicity
- Home Ownership
Targeting Application Notes
● Develop targeting plans from a client's account holder files when only the address is available
● Shows multiple buyer groups for a product, brand or retailer to develop versioned targeting plans
● Not recommended for targeting specific clusters by appearance only
● Updated on a quarterly basis
11
Identify | Sharpshooters
12
Geography Trade area, radius around store, etc
Habits, hobbies, etc
Annual spending (HH) estimates for a variety of consumer products and services (e.g., Financial Services, Tires, Auto Service, etc)
Penetration and specific demographics within ethnic segments
Account holder addresses can be used to identify areas of high ACCOUNT HOLDER penetration and also use cluster segmentation based on look-a-likes
Valassis Sharpshooters clusters (look-a-likes)
Nielsen® variables based on age, income, children, # of vehicles, etc
Go
od
B
ett
er
Best
Not all account holder addresses are created equal, nor do they bank equally
Adding balance data allows the process to identify areas of high DEPOSIT penetration
Demographics
Ethnicity
Behavioral
Purchase Potential
Lifestyle
Database-Account Holder Penetration
Database-Sales Penetration
Client Supplied ZIP Rankings
ZIP Priority based on client-defined metrics
Can also use distance/proximity as a key driver
Identify | Targeting Continuum
Identifying a Client’s Target Market Group (TMG) • Client’s address data rolls up to the Postal Carrier Routes (PCRs), where the address resides
• Key Metrics gathered at cluster level from single assignment at PCR level
o Customer Penetration
o Balance Penetration
• Account Holder-level data provides an extra level of validation – being dependent on an action/sale
• TMG identified as clusters that “outperform” the market – client metric used is greater than the market % of HH identified
Account Holder Look A Like Report (Example)–
13
Identify | Sharpshooters
14
Using Sharpshooters as a Targeting Activity Potential (TAP)
• Collection of variables created to target brand-specific account holders across a wide variety of industry categories including financial services
• Each cluster receives a score
• Market Plan can be National, Regionalized or Market-Based
• Includes the value of all cluster HH in the trade area to be counted
● Snapshot displays the score for each of the first 12 clusters vs. identifying clusters as the TMG
● Applies clusters’ index scores to cluster HH within the client’s trade area to build geo score
Identify | Sharpshooters
Locate | Targeting Methodology
15
Map Your Branches
Overlay Your Account Holders
Target the Best Neighborhoods
• Client provides existing checking account holders assigned by branch
• Sharpshooter Potential Index and Account Holder Penetration Index for the defined trade areas
• Account holders are assigned to the closest branch if held by multiple branches
● Pinpoints geographies to target and to exclude
● Shared Mail & Solo Mail combined for efficiencies
Reports and Maps will be provided
Locate | The Final Targeting Output
16
Personalized advertising messages are relevant to individual residential addresses
Customer Andy Eisenberg
would be interested in Mobile Banking
PROSPECT Juanita Smith’s Family
just moved to town and is looking for a
banking partner
Prospect Susan Lutz’s
small business is expanding and
needs more banking help
PROSPECT Diane Johnson
doesn’t like how current bank
treats her
Connect | Personalized Communications
17
18
1
1:1 Messaging is Completely Relevant
2
3
4
Current Account Holders
LOOKALIKES
Small Business Owners @ their homes
Mass Market
“Hey Andy, look at the checking accounts we have with mobile banking for you!”
“Diane, we have a better banking experience waiting for you.”
“Susan, your small business could use a partner like us.”
“Juanita, your checking account would be in good hands with us.”
● Final mailings put through CASS (including DPV) and NCOA process
● List refreshed weekly
● Reporting includes deviations from client-supplied list
Don’t Talk to Everyone the Exact Same Way Connect |
Benefits
• Sales data segmentation analysis identifies high-value households
• Delivery analysis and recommendation refines the target audience
• Database merge/purge eliminates duplication
• Digital printing enhances messaging
Features
• Address with resident name adds personalization
• Personalized variable messaging tailors the message to the resident household
o Look-alikes
o Cross-sell existing account holders
o Small Business
o Client-specific segments
19
Connect | Exclusive: Power Card Plus
Consumer Prospects: Basic Checking ● Broadest appeal
● Drives prospects through the door for upsell ● Measuring stick
Business Prospect: Basic Business Checking ● Cash Management ● Merchant Services ● Credit Cards
Existing Account Holders: Cross-sell ● Debit Card Utilization ● Mobile Banking ● Mortgage ● Thank you
20
Execute | Products to Offer $
21
Power Card
● Personally addresses by name
● 4” x 9” postcard
● 80# cover stock
Power Card Plus
● Variable imaging and messaging (all four pages)
● 10” x 8.5” (folded to 5” x 8.5”)
● 80# cover stock
Connect | Exclusive: Power Card Plus
What We Know About Personalization: 3 Fast Facts
Sources: National Mail It 2009-2011, DMA-Tracking Study; Broudy and Romano, 2009 Digital Printing Council Study
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Jim Smith or Current Resident 1123 Maple Street Columbus, OH, 43215
Connect
22
eRedēm: A Better Way to Offer Incentives
● Choice of incentives, including cash
● Increases program response rates
● No risk - pay as you go incentives in most cases
● Bridges generational gaps with incentives that appeal to multiple segments
● Recipients make selections online from home, your branch or virtually anywhere
● eRedēm is automatically mobile-enabled when accessed by mobile phone
● Eliminates the need for in-branch inventory and allows the recipient to choose where they wish to ship the item
● Lowers acquisition incentive expenses by buying down the costs
● Strongly recommended
23
Execute | Incentives and Fulfillment $
24
Execute | Incentives and Fulfillment $
Messaging Through Multiple Channels ● Automated, custom email communication
● Supports online promotional messaging
Program Activity Aggregation
● Data aggregated into one database for consolidated viewing
● Forms for branch personnel and advocate self-service channels
● On-demand program reporting available online 24/7
● Data easily exports to Excel for easy sorting, detailed review and measurement
● Easily merges data for program snapshot
● Branches no longer required to report daily, or weekly, or forward referral cards to a central location for administration
● Provides for easy program audits
25
Execute | The Referral Program $
● Consumers are in market for a new checking account all year
● Have an offer in hand when the consumer is ready to act
● Frequent communications increase brand awareness and put financial institution in the “selection set” when the consumer is ready to act
● 8 times a year
● 6.5 week cycle
26
Execute | Timing and Frequency $
● Training sessions for checking, as well as sales and services
25 years of coaching and training experience
● Mystery Shopping consists of up to:
10 personal bankers
10 call center reps
Website evaluation
Focus on sales & service
27
Execute | Mystery Shopping & Sales Training $
28
● Results reported post campaign with extensive analysis
Execute | Results Reporting $
● Branch Merchandising
● Card@Once®
● Onboarding
● First TouchTM New Mover
● New Account Research Services
29
Execute | Complimentary Services $
Press *1 on your phone
-or-
use the chat window and send your question to “All Panelists.”
Panelists:
Erik Kelley, Senior Product Marketing Manager
Michael Dorrington, Director of Sales, Mail Innovation [email protected]
30
Thank You
31