admin and public officer

8/10/2019 Admin and Public Officer

1/24

CASE DIGEST IN

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW and LAW ON PUBLIC

OFFICERS

LIST OF CASES

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW1. URC v. LLDA. G.R. No. 191427. May 30, 20112. PEOPLE v. MORALES. G.R. No. 166355. May 30, 20113. LACSON v. EXEC. SEC, ET.AL. G.R. No. 165399. May 30, 20114. GANNAPAO v. CSC. G.R. No. 10141. May 31, 20115. !MPER!AL v. GS!S. G.R. No. 191224. O"#o$%& 4, 20116. O''!CE O' T(E OM)UDSMAN v. RE*ES. G.R. No. 170512. O"#o$%& 5, 2011

PUBLIC OFFICERS1. +APSON v. CSC. G.R. No. 19479. A&- 12, 20112. GS!S v. MA*ORDOMO. G.R. No. 19121. May 31, 20113. GANADEN v. CA. G.R. No. 170510/11. +% 1, 2011

4. O''!CE O' T(E OM)UDSMAN v. ANDUTAN. G.R. No. 164679. +y 27, 20115. MART!NE v. !LLANUEA. G.R. No. 169196. +y 6, 20116. CSC . CRU. G.R. No. 175. A# 9, 20117. COASTAL SA'EA* MAR!NE SER!CES S. ESGUERRA, G.R. No. 15352, A# 10, 2011. PCGG v. SAND!GAN)A*AN. G.R. No. 152500. S%#%8$%& 14, 20119. OP v. CATAU!. G.R. No. 13445. S%#%8$%& 14, 201110. DUMDUMA v. CSC. G.R. No. 12606. O"#o$%& 4, 201111. UARTO v. MARCELO. G.R. No. 169042. O"#o$%& 5, 201112. !N T(E MATTER O' T(E PET!T!ON 'OR T(E R!T O' AMPARO AND (A)EAS DATA !N 'AOR O' NOR!EL (.

RODR!GUE: NOR!EL (. RODR!GUE S. GLOR!A MACAPAGAL/ARRO*O, ET AL., G.R. No. 19105 ; G.R.No. 193160. Nov%8$%& 15, 2011

13. NAPOCOR v. CSC. G.R. No. 152093. +aa&y 24, 201214. ONG v. OP. G.R. No. 14219. +aa&y 30, 201215. REPU)L!C O' T(E P(!L!PP!NES, REPRESENTED )* T(E C!!L SER!CE COMM!SS!ON S. M!NERA M.P.

PAC(ECO, G.R. No. 17021, +aa&y 31, 201216. UN!CAN v. NEA. G.R. No. 17107. +aa&y 331, 2012
http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/august2011/185352.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/august2011/185352.htm


2/24

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

UNIVERSAL ROBINA CORP. (CORN DIVISION), VS. LAGUNA LAKE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,

[G.R. NO. 1914!, MAY "#, #11$

D%&'*+-

T8--#&a#-v% a%"-% #o "a&&y o# #% &o"% - -# #&-"# >-"-a %% =o& -# -

%o< #


3/24

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. LUIS 2. MORALES

[G.R. N%. 133", M5 "#, #11$

D%&'*+-

A ov%&8%#/o@%> o& "o#&o%> "o&o&a#-o 8# $% o@%> $y # - # >%v%o #%> #o #. T -

#- a> !v%#-a#-o )&%a aa-# &%o>%

L- +. Mo&a% Morales, # =o& #%&%> a

a $-" o==-"%

H+0-

No. T $y a %"-a a@ $# @a -"o&o&a#%> >%& #% a> @a &%-#%&%> @-#< # a a ov%&8%#/o@%> o& "o#&o%> "o&o&a#-o. A

ov%&8%#/o@%> o& "o#&o%> "o&o&a#-o 8# $% o@%> $y # - # %8oy%% a&% &-va#% ->-v->a @% #-"#-o o= #-a$aya.


4/24

LACSON VS. E6EC. SEC, ET.AL.

[G.R. NO. 13"99, MAY "#, #11$

D%&'*+-

T )%&a&>o T. -&ay @%&% o/&%->%#-a ao-#%% a>

"a&%%& %&v-"% o==-"-a o= &%o>%# Pav-

@-#< #%> @-#< #"# a>8--#&a#-v% >-"--a&y

&o"%%>- aa-# # $y #- #-8-a o=%#-#-o%& @-#< #%&a#-o. Ta#%> %#-#-o.

I/+-


5/24

GANNAPAO VS. CSC[GR NO. 17#141, MAY "1, #11$

D%&'*+-

T #o a>8--#&a#-v% &o"%%>-,

a oo-#y #o %?a- o%F ->% o& a oo-#y #o %% a &%"o->%&a#-o o= # o=. ! #% &o"%, @ - o# a" o=

&%v-o o#-"% $# #%-a o= # % "o&%, %-%> >% &o"%.

F&'-

P&-va#% &%o>%# )a&-%, %# a a&% #o"%& a> $oa&> 8%8$%& o= U-#%> o&%& T&ao Co&.

@&-v%&,

"o>"#o& a> 8%""#o&, a> #oo ov%& # # a==-&8%> #%-%> a> 8o>-=-%> #%"--o

#o >-8-a =&o8 %&v-"%.

I/+-

1% &o"% - #-=y- # o= #y

o#-=-%> o= #ya&> @-#%> - M%8o&a>8 C-&"a& No. 93/

024 Guidelines in the Application of Penalties in Police Administrative Case)


6/24

IMPERIAL, 2R. V. GSIS[GR NO. 1914, OCTOBER 4, #11$

D%&'*+-

P&o"%>&a >% &o"% - # a oo-#y #o $% $%

-v% $%=o&% >8%# - &%>%&%>. A o a a ay - -v% #%=%> %

"o&%, % &o"% - - #


7/24

OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN VS. REYES

[GR NO. 17051! OCTOBER 5! 011"

D%&'*+-

D% &o"%, a a "o#-##-oa &%"%#, >o% o# a@ay a> - a -#a#-o &%B-&% a #&-a/#y% &o"%%>-.

D% &o"% - a#-=-%> @ o= #-, #


8/24

PUBLIC OFFICERS

2APSON VS. CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION

[GR NO. 1794!9, APRIL 1, #11$

D%&'*+-

D-%=-%> a #-#o-o o= #< - a 8a##%& o= =a"# &%%va# #o o%F o==-"% o&"o%"#%> @-#< #"# - a #&a&%-o o= o8% %#a$- o& >%=--#% &%

o= a"#-o, - a =o&$->>% a"#, - a >%&%-"#-o o= >#y, - @-= - " $y #a#%> O"#o$%& 6, 1999 o=

M-a )aaa, @>% a"#, - a >%&%-"#-o o= >#y, - @-= - ""#

(% ao@%> #8%#. (% @a a@a&% o= @ @a "o8-"-# - #


9/24

GSIS AND WINSTON F. GARCIA VS. ARWIN T. MAYORDOMO

[G.R. NO. 19117, MAY "1, #11$

D%&'*+-

! o&>%& #o $% "o->%&%> a I8-"o>"#,J # $% "o%"#%> @-# a =o&8a a>8--#&a#-v% "o8o

=o& G&av% M-"o>"# a>Ko& Co>"# P&%>-"-a #o #- Mayo&>o8o -#y o= G&av% M-"o>"# a> -8o- o >-Ba-=-"a#-o =&o8 ov%&8%# %&v-"%. (o@%v%& #o@&a>%> # $y #%# - o#

I8-"o>"#.J To "o#-##% 8-"o>"#, #>&%%. T%&%> a#, &%"-%y $%"a% >%a-

@-#< #>&%% - #&-"#y &%%&v%> =o& !TSG %&o% @ ! o&>%& #o $% "o->%&%>

a I8-"o>"#,J # $% "o%"#%> @-#< ##-% a8o#- %-#8--#&a#-o o& @-=, -#%#-oa %%"# o& =a-&% #o >-""# - o==-"% %=--#% a> @%/>%oo> %a 8%a-. )y -=o&8 %a >%=--#-o, -# -

a 8-"o>"# "< a a==%"# o# "< oy a a==%"# -v->a. ! "< "a%, -# a# a #-8%, -# - %"%a&y #o %a&a#% # $% "o%"#%> @-#% o= #


10/24

o& &o %-%"% $y # OM)/L/A/02/0070/), #8a =o> %#-#-o%& Gaa>%, )a#-#a a>

Na&"-o -a$% =o& >- -8o%> o # M-a -a$% =o& >- -8o%> o #%-%> # #-8-a =&o8 # %a&a#% %#-#-o

=o& &%v-%@ $%=o&% #o&%8%

&%B%#- =&o8 TRANSCO #%,

)a#-#a a> Na&"-o a> #%# O- -%> # o&>%&.

I/+-

%"--o o= #-a#%y %?%"#o&y %>- a%a.

H+0-

*%. T =o& >%& S%"#-o 7, R% !!! o= #%> $y A>8--#&a#-v% O&>%& No. 17, >a#%> S%#%8$%& 15, 2003, @%&%> a %& &%v%#-v%

%-o a> # "< o#%& #%# @ a>8--#&a#-v%y -a$% $y #o% o# #ay #


11/24

OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN V. ANDUTAN

[G.R. NO. 1343!9 2ULY !, #11$

D%&'*+-

A>8--#&a#-v% o==%% >o o# &%"&-$%.

T8a "a o o%& -#-##% a a>8--#&a#-v% -= #.

F&'-

P&a# #o #8 >-&%"#- a o/"a&%%& o==-"-a o& # =&o8 ##a, %# a. @a "&-8-ay " $y #- a> !#%-%"% )&%a &&!B o= #8a @-#< E#a=a #-"-a #o #8--#&a#-v% " =&o8 #Ko& &%%8oy8%# - ay $&a"< o

-#&8%#a-#y o= # a%"-% o& "o&o&a#-o.

T a> %# a->% #%"--o o= #8a, &- #% # a=#%& o% y%a& =&o8 # a=#%& A>#aF =o&"%> &%-a#-o

I/+-

1 "#- a a>8--#&a#-v%

-v%#-a#-o a y%a& a=#%& #.

2

%8oy%%, #8--#&a#-v% -v%#-a#-o a=#%& # $%yo> # #a#%> - S%"#-o 205, #8a @a @% @-#-"&%#-o #o "o>"# #8--#&a#-v% -v%#-a#-o.

2 No. T8a "a o o%& -#-##% a a>8--#&a#-v% "a% aa-# A>#a $%"a% #. !# - -&&%%va#, a""o&>- #o #8a, ##a

a&%a>y &%-%> &-o& #o #


12/24

&->-"#-o - #

o S%#%8$%& 1, 1999, %?a"#y o% y%a& a> #@o 8o#


13/24

MARTINE: VS. VILLANUEVA

[G.R. NO. 139193. 2ULY 3, #11$

D%&'*+-

S%"#-o 7> o= R.A. No. 6713 @-&%"#y o&

->-&%"#y, ay -=#, &a#-#y, =avo&, %#%a-8%#, oa o& ay# $y, o& ay #&aa"#-o @ $y #-&%"#y o& ->-&%"#y, ay -=#, &a#-#y, =avo&, %#%a-8%#, 0%* % *5'?*@ %< =%*+'5 0/+ +%* * '?+ &%/+ %< '?+ %


14/24

"o#&a&y #o &%o>%#F a%-o. % =-> # - malum prohibitum. !# - #%=-%> $y

# o# #


15/24

CSC VS. CRU:

[G.R. NO. 17!77 AUGUST 9, #11$

D%&'*+-

!= #8--#&a#-v% o==%% =o> #o - o= %%& &av-#y #


16/24

COASTAL SAFEWAY MARINE SERVICES VS. ESGUERRA

G.R. NO. 17" AUGUST 1#, #11

D%&'*+-

S$#a#-a %v->%"% - "< &%%va# %v->%"% a a &%aoa$% 8-> 8-%Ba#% #o o a

"o"-o, %v% -= o# 8-- - =avo& CSMS!, Mo&"-a a> CMEGT, La$o& A&$-#%& >-8-%> # $#a#-a#%> >%"a&a#-o a&% -==-"-%# #o %#a$-< a "a% $%=o&% Ba-/>-"-a

$o>-% @%"%. O=#% >%"&-$%> a

8o&% # 8-%Ba#% #o o a "o"-o, %v% -= o# 8-%> $y #o"#o&J

>%-#% ,J E%&&a >-> o# &%%# ay %v->%"% #o &ov% #-=-"a#-o =o& %-a#%>


17/24

OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT AND PRESIDENTIAL ANTI8GRAFT COMMISSION VS. CATAUI:[GR NO. 17"44, SEPTEMBER 14, #11$

D%&'*+-

A""o&>-y, #-8-a o= #o% o# =o&%"o% a>8--#&a#-v% a"#-o

aa-# Ca#aB-. (- a$o#-o =&o8 "&-8-a -a$--#y - o# "o"-v% o #% $y #8a "ao# %&v% #o &o#%"# #%# =&o8 =--#&a#-v% &o%"#-o. A "o#&a&y &- @o> $% %##- a -# @o> >%&8-%

#8--#&a#-v% &o"%%>-, # &o=%-oa $% 8aa%8%# -"o8%#%"%. ! a

-v%#-a#-o -#o #%&%> $y S%"&%#a&y Go o= #%#%&8-%>#%# 8ay $% =o> -#y =o& a"# &%>-"-a #o # &%a#-o. !# @a &%"o88%>%> #% a> T% o= Co>"# a> E#o#%> #- a> &%"o88%>a#-o o= PAGC, a> >-8-%> #%#

=&o8 %&v-"%. T%"--o @a a8%>%> $y #8--#&a#-v% a@ #%& a # &%o-$--#y =o& a v-oa#-o

o= ##y o& =o& a @&o= a"# o& o8--o, "< #8--#&a#-v%y

-a$% =o& # "-v- -a$--#y. !#8--#&a#-v% a>

"&-8-a -a$--#y IT-#-"# a> ->%%>%# a#&% o= o% &o"%%>- =&o8 #: a> %"o>, # aa-# #@o o& 8o&% >-#-"# a>

&%a#%> &ov--o o= a@, o& #


18/24

DUMDUMA VS. CSC[GR NO. 173#3, OCTOBER 4, #11$

D%&'*+-

Oy #8a #o

%?a- @ a

>%%%& %o#-

=&%%>o8 =&o8 o@%>% o= "-&"8#a"% @%"% o= o#@a&> a"#.J


19/24

UARTO VS. OMBUDSMAN SIMEON MARCELO[GR NO. 139#4 OCTOBER , #11$

D%&'*+-

Mandamus- #y #o "o8% #8%# a> >-"&%#-o,mandamus8ay oy $% &%o%> #o,

#o "o8% #%# #o #a% a"#-o: -# "ao# $% %> #o >-&%"# # ao8ao #&aa"#-o -vov- #Ko& &""# # # %8oy%% o= # o#-v->a @y $%%=-##%> =&o8 # v-oa#-o o= S%"#-o

3%, RA No. 3019. O #%#%&8-- @%"% #o o a =->- o= &o$a$% "a% a> #%&%% o= a-"-a#-o o= # o& #


20/24

IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION FOR THE WRIT OF AMPARO AND WRIT OF HABEAS DATA INFAVOR OF NORIEL H. RODRIGUE:

[GR NO. 1917#, NOVEMBER 1, #11$

D%&'*+-

T%#-a -88-#y =&o8 -# %?-# oy - "o"&&%"% @-#< #%#F -"8$%"y $# o# $%yo>.

F&'-

P%#-#-o%& No&-% Ro>&-% - a 8%8$%& o=Alansa Dagiti Mannalon !ti Cagaan -agimungan), a %aa#

o&a-a#-o a==--a#%> @-#< ilusang Magbubu/id ng PilipinasMP. (% "a-8 # >-a%a&a"%.

Ro>&-% @a a$>"#%> $y 8--#a&y 8% a> @a #o&%> &%%a#%>y @%&, !%"#-o o= Pa"%, a> P&o>"#-o o= Do"8%# a>

P%&oa P&o%-%. T aa-# =o&8%& P&%. A&&oyo, %# a. T $# #&o%> P&% A&&oyo a ay/&%o>%#, a - ay "a% >&- %# o #%#-a -88-#y =&o8 -#

H+0-

No. A @a - #-=avo& o #%#-a

&-v-%% o= -88-#y, %%"-ay @% #&-%


21/24

NATIONAL POWER CORPORATION VS. CSC AND RODRIGO A. TANFELI6[GR NO. 1#9", 2ANUARY 4, #1$

D%&'*+-

G&av% 8-"o>"# "o-# - a ov%&8%# o==-"-aF >%-$%&a#% v-oa#-o o= a &% o= a@ o& #a>a&> o=

$%%> a &av% @ @&o= % o= #y a> #


22/24

ONG VS. OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT[GR NO. 17419, 2ANUARY "#, #1$

D%&'*+-

T%8o&a&y ao-#8%# a&% 8a>% -= oy #o &%v%# a# a 8o8%# o#-"%. A #o #


23/24

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. PACHECO

[GR NO. 1!7#1 2ANUARY , #1$

D%&'*+-

o, Pa8aa. T%-a#%> a

A-#a# C $%%=-#.

I/+-

-8-%>, a>, # #o $a"@a%

H+0-

*%. T ao# oy #o a 8a?-88 %&-o> o= =-v% 5 y%a&, a> o# = $a" aa&-% =&o8 -8-a #o


24/24

UNITED CLAIMANTS ASSOCIATION OF NEA (UNICAN) VS. NATIONAL ELECTRIFICATIONADMINISTRATION (NEA)

[GR NO. 17!1#! 2ANUARY "1, #1$

D%&'*+-

R%o&a-a#-o -vov% #"#-o o= %&o%, "oo->a#-o o= o==-"%, o& a$o-#-o # &%# - # - a""o&>a"% @-#< PD 269 @%&%> %ay #%&8-a#%> @-#< # #o 8a% #

admin and public officer

Documents