Advanced Partnership Debt Allocations

Advanced Partnership Debt AllocationsHoward E. AbramsApril/May 2014Basic RulesRecourse debt is allocated in accordance with risk of loss, usually based on a hypothetical zero-value sale and liquidation.Nonrecourse debt is allocated according to three tiers:T1: The minimum gain tier.T2: The minimum 704(c) gain tier.T3: The residual (profits interests) tier.Note: There is no third category of partnership debt. If a debt is partially recourse and partially nonrecourse, it is treated as two separate debts.Dynamic Recourse Debt: EX. 1P and Q each contribute $30 to the PQ general partnership in exchange for 50% of profits and losses. The partnership borrows $40 on a fully recourse basis. How is the debt allocated between P and Q?

PQCAOBCAOB30303030-50-50-20----20---Dynamic Recourse Debt: EX. 1Putting the debt into the outside bases as the partners share risk of loss, the books become:

PQCAOBCAOB30303030202030503050Dynamic Recourse Debt: Ex. 1Suppose the partnership now distributes $40 of cash to partner P. The books of the venture become:

PQCAOBCAOB30503050-40-4000-10103050Dynamic recourse debt: Ex. 1But we need to consider the possibility that the distribution works a reallocation of the debt even though the amount of the debt has not changed and loss sharing ratios have not changed.

PQCAOBCAOB-10103050-30-30-40---$ 0---Dynamic recourse debt: Ex 1The debt has thus shifted entirely to P, and so the books actually become:

PQCAOBCAOB-1010305020-20-10303030Even though the distribution was made only to P, each partnersoutside basis declines by $20 from $50 to $30.Dynamic Recourse Debt: Ex. 2X contributes $10 while Y and Z each contribute $100 to the XYZ general partnership. Each partner has a one-third share of profits and losses. The partnership borrows $60 on a fully recourse basis. A zero-value sale and liquidation yields a negative capital account only for X, and so X is allocated all of the debt. The books become:

XYZCAOBCAOBCAOB101010010010010060001070100100100100Dynamic Recourse Debt: Ex. 2Suppose the partnership now distributes $70 to X. That reduces the partnerships cash down to $200, and a zero-value sale and liquidation will leave only X with a capital account deficit. Accordingly, all of the debt remains with X and the books of the venture become:

XYZCAOBCAOBCAOB1070100100100100-70-700000-600100100100100Dynamic Recourse Debt: Ex. 2Now suppose that the partnership distributes $80 to Y. That reduces the partnerships cash down to $120. Prior to any reallocation of the debt, the books become:

XYZCAOBCAOBCAOB-60010010010010000-80-8000-6002020100100Dynamic Recourse Debt: Ex. 2Now lets do a zero-value sale and liquidation. The partnership has $120 of cash, and assuming that falls in value to zero, each partner is allocated $40 of the loss. After the zero-value sale, the books of the venture become:

XYZCAOBCAOBCAOB-60702020100100-40-40-40-100-2060Dynamic Recourse Debt: Ex. 2Because the debt is now allocated 5/6s to X and 1/6 to Y, one-sixth of the debt (that is, $10 of the debt) is shifted to Y. But because Xs outside basis is already zero, that means the cash distribution to Y triggers gain recognition to X.

XYZCAOBCAOBCAOB-6002020100100(10)100-6002030100100Nonrecourse Debt: Depreciation and Book-UpsX contributes $1,000,000 and Y contributes Blackacre to XY-LLC, and Blackacre is worth $1,000,000 with an adjusted basis of $200,000 at the time of contribution. The partnership borrows $2,000,000 and uses its cash of $3,000,000 to improve Blackacre. These improvements can be recovered straight-line over 25 years, and the debt encumbers Blackacre as well as the improvements. On these figures, the property has an initial book value of $4,000,000, an adjusted basis of $3,200,000, and a depreciable basis of $3,000,000. There is depreciation of $120,000 per year for 25 years.Nonrecourse Debt: Depreciation and Book-UpsYearBook ValueAdj. BasisDep. BasisDebt04,000,0003,200,0003,000,0002,000,000162,080,0001,280,0001,080,0002,000,000171,960,0001,160,000960,0002,000,000201,600,000800,000600,0002,000,000YearTier 1Tier 2Tier 3Total0002,000,0002,000,000160720,0001,280,0002,000,0001740,000800,0001,160,0002,000,00020400,000800,000800,0002,000,000Related Party Debt RulesNew related party debt rules were proposed on December 16, 1013, as Prop. Reg. 1.752-4(b). The following discussion is based on these proposed regulations.Related Party Debt RulesLoan from Z to XYPYXZXYRelated Party Debt RulesLoan from Z to XYPYXZXYGuaranteeRelated Party Debt RulesLoan from Z to XYPYXZXYPartial GuaranteePartial saleIf a partner owning a single partnership interest sells a portion of that interest, gain is computed by comparing the amount realized on the sale with a proportionate part of the outside basis.The same rule applies if the partner owns multiple interests in the venture and sells only a part of his ownership interest without regard to how the interests were acquired (no tracing of basis).A partner has a single, unified outside basis.A partner has a single, unified capital account.After the sale, the capital account of the selling partner that is attributable to the interest transferred carries over to the transferee.Partial Sale ExampleT joins the P partnership by contributing cash of $5,000 in exchange for a general partnership interest. Sometime later, T acquires a limited partnership interest for $7,000. Thereafter, when Ts combined outside basis in the two interests is $12,000, T sells one of the interests for its fair market value of $5,000. At the time of the sale, the two interests are worth $15,000.T recognizes a gain of $1,000 on the sale (amount realized of $5,000 less $4,000 allocable portion of adjusted basis).Note that it does not matter which interest is sold or whether that particular interest has increased or decreased in value (no tracing).Partial Sale: Rev. Rul. 84-53If a partner sells a portion of his partnership interest and the selling partner has been allocated a share of the partnerships liabilities, those liabilities not shifting as a result of the sale are removed from the selling partners outside basis immediately prior to the sale for the purpose of computing gain or loss on the sale.Suppose X and Y each own half of the XY partnership, and XY owns Blackacre with inside basis of $400, value of $500, and subject to a debt of $380. Each partner has an outside basis of $200 including each partners $190 share of the debt.Suppose Y sells one-half of her partnership interest to Z for its fair market value of $30.Rev. Rul. 84-53 ExampleIf half of Ys share of the debt shifts to Z, then gain on the sale equals amount realized of $125 (cash received plus debt shifted) less allocable portion of adjusted basis of $100, for a gain of $25.If no part of the debt shifts, then gain on the sale equals amount realized of $30 (cash received) less allocable portion of outside basis with debt removed (that is, one-half of ($200 - $190)) of $5, for a gain of $25.Sale After Deft-Financed DistributionX and Y own 60% and 40% of the profits and losses of XY-LLC. The partnership owns a single, nondepreciable asset with inside basis and book value of $0 but current value of $2,000. Each partner has a capital account and outside basis of $0. The partnership has an election under section 754 in effect and the partnership agreement provides that partnership assets will be booked to fair market value whenever allowable. The partnership borrows $500 on a recourse basis, allocable 60% to X and 40% to Y. The loan proceeds are then distributed in those percentages.Y sells half of her interest to Z for its value of $300.Sale After Deft-Financed DistributionXYZCAOBCAOBCAOB000000030002000012000800000-300-300-200-2000000-300030030090003000300300Sale after debt-financed distribution: Sale of PropertyXYZCOBCAOBCAOB90003000300300012000400040000000-4000-3000-20000900900300200300300