afis ieee sose 22 june 2018sosengineering.org/2018/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/afis... · 2019. 10....
TRANSCRIPT
AFIS Presentation andOverview of French organizations active in SoS An AFIS point of view ,IEEE SoSE conference – 22 June 2018André AYOUNCoordinator of the AFIS Technical Committee 3SAI: System of Systems and Services – Architecture and Engineering
!"#$%&!'()"*!$+!"%&,$()-
!!"#$"!#%&
Disclaimer: There are many entities that are not mentioned here.This presentation is rather a sketch than a panorama
AFIS Presentation 2
French organization for Systems Engineering:qNon profit organization, Affiliated member of
INCOSE, Created in 1999qComposed of members (companies, education and
research) and individual membersqComprising 8 technical committeesEnd of 2017:ü 45 companies and education & research
membersü > 900 individual members
Association Française d’Ingénierie Système (AFIS)= French chapter of INCOSE
IEEE SoSE 22/06/2018
AlainRoussel,PresidentofAFIShttp://www.afis.fr/pages/accueil.aspx
Email: [email protected] Sites:üAFIS: http://www.afis.früAFIS Community http://afis.community/üRobAFIS: http://www.robafis.fr
!"#$%4'()(*+,+-.*
78$%-9:;</40:23-#/<</=%-%/0:-/6>:?3$@:%!
! 7/-6:-?</%:(-3/-38:-6/38-"?"9:0$?%-"29-$291%3($"<-;<"4:(%
! 7/-:"%:- 38:-$2@/<@:0:23-/#-/1(-0:06:(%-3/-38:-)*+,-"?3$@$3$:%
! 7/-$2?(:"%:- 38:-,4%3:0%-A2B$2::($2B-#//3;($23-38(/1B8-9$%%:0$2"3$/2-"29-?/<<:?3$/2-/#--(:B$/2"<-(:31(2%-/#-:C;:($:2?:
D(/B(:%%-/#-38$%-</?"<-9:;</40:23!
! E"31(:!-F??$3"2$:-EG9$3:(("2G:-D4(G2G:%H-I/(9JA%3
! +2-;(/B(:%%!-58K2:J)<;:%H-I/(9JA%3H-+<:-9:-*("2?:
! L1%3-%3"(3$2B-!-I/1@:<<:-)M1$3"$2:H-D).)
A-1%#(&B)!*03).-;B#46-(') %()*+&($-
!"#$%'(B-.*,>%C8,4+(')N
D.6=(>>(!E6-+,-*(
F22-+,*-(
G8H*(I!>4()
D.'5I?)+
&!C!
#>(%5(%"G,*2(
6.../7(7./118298123:
AFIS Presentation 4
Rail transportation Urban transportationAutomobile industryAir transportation
Ener
gy
prod
uctio
n sy
stem
s
Spac
e an
d De
fenc
e sy
stem
s
Tran
spor
tat
ion
syst
ems
Space systems
Wind generator Hydro GeneratorThermal power central
Land based Weapon Systems Combat aircraft Airspace surveillance
Some examples of systems performed by our Members
IEEE SoSE 22/06/2018
AFIS Presentation 5
To promote SE by boosting : SE awareness, SE principles spreading, multidisciplinary approach,etc. in order to help delivering & support successful complex systems :q Foster SE approach & use towards public & private companies and governmental organizationsq Promote SE Education & Training by actions towards University, Engineer Schools, Teachers & Professors,Research Labs,q Encourage Users exchanges, enhance SE knowledge database, act to scale SE methodology & tools (variousdomains, various companiesq Participate to enlarge the national & international visibility of SE Users, by providing relevant information
Mastering Complex Systems is a major challenge for the our future
AFIS aims to play a major role to develop and support S.E. extension, in order to increase collaboration between academicals and industrial actors,
and to help companies to improve their position in a complex systems worldwide environment
AFIS objectives
IEEE SoSE 22/06/2018
AFIS presentation 6
8 Technical committees
1. Competency and Training (CT FC : [email protected])Develop a SE Competency framework, promote Certification process, organize ROBAFIScompetition (promoted towards EMEA & INCOSE), support an education initiative related to SE &SysML towards High Schools, elaborate educational documents, propose SE career path and act toFrench Department of Education labelingOrganization of an annualAcademic & Industry Forum
2. Global processes (CT PG : [email protected])Analyze main SE processes with regards to the whole System Life Cycle activities: Requirements,architecture, development, Verification & Validation, Product-line EngineeringLiaison with PMI : configuration & changes management, risk management, engineeringmanagement, Project management, etc..
3. Safety, Validation and LSI (CT SV2S : [email protected])Work subjects : Safety, maintainability, Verification & Validation, System qualification, System support
4. Human Factors (CT FH : [email protected])Identify & Analyze impact of Human Factors methodologies, how they interfere with systemengineering, and how they are integrated in the Systems Life Cycle activities
IEEE SoSE 22/06/2018
AFIS presentation 7
8 Technical committees
5. SoS & services – Architecture (CT 3S-AI : [email protected])Promote best practices and adherence to new concepts for Services and System of Systems:Architecting principle (e.g. Architecture Frameworks) – Analyze impact of architecture of ServicesEngineering – Work on organizations and systems interoperability – Service LevelAgreement.
6. SE research & Innovation (CT RIIS : [email protected])Detect & promote academic researches, identify mature SE research and their application, promote both academicand industrial research, participate to establish SE solid theoretical foundation, establish AFIS as a key player in SEResearch field
7. System Engineering Management (CT MIS : [email protected])Covering whole System Life Cycle, identify & promote methodology and tools supporting the management of SystemEngineering and the interaction with the Project Management. Propose solutions especially in the context of complexorganizations dealing with multi SE teams.
8. Model Based System Engineering (CT MBSE : [email protected])Promote and improve knowledge and competencies dealing with extensive use of models in the SE processes.Develop a common understanding of MBSE, promote use of System modeling (languages like SysML), identify thedomain impact on models, support the standardization initiatives , collaborate with SoS CT for developing dedicatedSoS modeling
IEEE SoSE 22/06/2018
AFIS presentation
Books and guides : main pieces(available on demand at [email protected])
L’ingénierie Système d’une Ligne de Produit (French) Product-Line Engineering (*) (English)(Elected INCOSE Product of year 2015)Découvrir et comprendre l’ingénierie système (French)[Discover and understand SystemsEngineering]
Livre Blanc - Vision AFIS pour les années 2020-2025 [AFIS vision for 2020-2025] (French)
Introduction au penser Système (2014) (French)[Systems thinking introduction]
Bonnes pratiques en expression du besoin (2014)(French)[User needs elicitation – best practices]
REGAL (RequirementEngineering), AFIS & - INCOSE Product (English)
Bonnes pratiques en ingénierie des exigences (French) [Requirement Engineering – Best practices]
Bonnes pratiques en maîtrise des interfaces (French) [Interfaces Engineering – Best practices] (English)
Bonnes pratiques en prise de décision multicritères[Multi-criteria decision – Best practices] (French)
(*) : available at: Google Playhttps://play.google.com/store/books/details/AFIS_Systems_Product_Line_Engineering_Handbook?id=pmVuCwAAQBAJ
IbookStore d’Apple: https://itunes.apple.com/fr/book/systems-
product-line-engineering/id1076391774?mt=11
IEEE SoSE 22/06/2018
Requirements and Architecture within Modelling Context, published under the coordination of Raphaël Faudou (available on INCOSE bookstore)
Corpus d’introduction et de sensibilisation à l’IS, under the coordination of Florence Lamberet and Daniel Prun[Introduction to Systems Engineering]
Products Services Systems engineering: PSS chapterpublished under the cordination of the 3SAI technial committee
Evolutions de l’ISO 15288 et couverture du CMMI, créé par l’équipe CORNAC (D. Cattan, I. Guivarch, E. Wetzel)[Comparison between ISO 15288 and CMMI]
?H-+H%-P)#<)*+-($:)#+1&(%Q&'%#(")&$'%H-)%()3#3)!()!*03);#%(')#<)H%-P)R0@@@)3#3@)$#(<-+-($-) S TT)UE(-)TVWI!*5'S%!TFUDC..'5-*,+.'%.O%+8(%%!"#$%J(28*-2,>%C.33-++((%V$!#A%$K)+(3%.O%$K)+(3)%,*5%$('=-2()%W !'28-+(2+6'(%,*5%?*B-*(('-*B!"#$%&!'()"*!$+!"%&,$()-
118298123:
Disclaimer: There are many entities that are not mentioned here.This presentation is rather a sketch than a panorama
Published products- Glossary and data model for SoS- Coupling component systems towards SoS, ICSSEA-2007, INCOSE 2008- Tutorial on Complex Systems and SoS, 2009- Services for SoS, definitions, 2010- Organizational interoperability, CIGI-2011- 2012-2014 (lifecycle management and societal responsibility)- 2011, 2013, 2015 – Sustainable system engineering, 20 communications- Service Engineering, INCOSE-2012- Produits-Systèmes-Services (PSS) IPS2 2015- Webinar: lessons learnt in SoS Engineering from SESAR, 2016- Journal « Génie logiciel »: articles (2011 to 2016 editions)- 2016-2017: Systems of services– Service system engineering: PSS - SESE
Tour 2017- Poster Service Engineering, CSDM 2017
X;67/C%>?"+>!F/R(AA+==%%/b7MX6
-10-
6.../7(7./118298123:
Areas of activity- System of Systems Engineering (SoSE)- Service Engineering- Architecture and Architecture Frameworks- Complex Systems engineering- Lifecycles and engineering- Sustainable systems engineering
R(($#+"!=%#/ H'/5//X"#$K/X'()"/ !"# RF!)#%/ @()$>%F
cYT/A%AH%$<
Working groups active in 2018
-[GI07] SoSE , collaborative engineering, multi-lifecycles, organizational issues.
-[GP14] Webinar on service engineering
-[GP16] System of services – operations – Service systems engineering
-[GI17] Analysis of webinars of INCOSE SoSE WG
-[GP19] Promotion of Service Engineering
-[GI21] From value chains to value networks
“Systèmes de Systèmes et Services - Architecture et Ingénierie” [email protected]
R!=%,($+%</(0/($,!"+d!=+("<e($f+",/+"/7'<=%A/(0/7'<=%A</!>=+G+=+%<
3& X>!#%A+!/5/[%<%!$>?/!"#/C$!+"+",/($,!"+d!=+("</ND"+Ga/7>?((F<a/[%<%!$>?/R%"=$%<P
1& X#A+"+<=$!=+("</!"#/<=$)>=)$%#/>(AA)"+=+%</(0/)<%$<b& 6"#)<=$+!F<5/#%G%F(-+",/8/+A-F%A%"=+",/8/(-%$!=+",/7(7Y& 6"#)<=$+!F</5/=((F</#%G%F(-%$</8/G%"#($</0($/7(7/.",+"%%$+",
-11-6.../7(7./118298123:
7(7./+"/;$%">?/X>!#%A+>/+"<=+=)=+("<D"+G%$<+=+%<RQ[75
Q>T9c-U5!N-F5.59HQ>T9c-5U>PN-F780(3-VG80*-U0+,1*)-B*3)(0+31.*Hb@P U>C5-FU.@)??1*/=->*0?6717-0*@-C.*3(.?Y+.880*@-.4-@6*081+-7673)8H
.",+"%%$+",/<>?((F<5C)*3(0?)-5G<`?)+=->(37-)3-U`31)(79;5N>-O0(17N)+,cYU1*)7YN)?)+.8b(.G<)-B5>9-5MO>dPD=-9;5U>=-95N>C>=-d+.?)-@)-?a>1(-e-5G<8`+0b(.G<)-B;5>:-B;5>-N.G?.G7)=fJ-U1*)7-@a>?)7=-@a>?A1M*1LJ-@)-53(07A.G(/=-M*1L @)-Q.((01*)=fJ
:/6"<=+=)=%</(0/[%<%!$>?/!"#/C%>?"(F(,'/N6[CP5/5673)8c FO0(17->()0H501*3-9]G<`(6 FT.(@)0G]->()0H=fJfJ
-12-
6.../7(7./118298123:
System Engineering
Cyber security
ComplexSystem
Management
SOS
Theses Books
7(7./+"/;$%">?/X>!#%A+>/+"<=+=)=+("<NX;67/_%AH%$<P
-13-
6.../7(7./118298123:
Q%=^($f<\ bSP-U>C5-FC;P5H-:--()7)0(+,-1*-@6*081+-7673)87-
+.*3(.?Y+.880*@-0*@-<(.@G+31.*-7673)87\ >BO-O(18)+0-:-+..(@1*03)7-<)@0/./1+-<?034.(87
D"+G%$<+=+%</!"#/<>?((F<\ M*1L)(713` @)-Q.((01*)\ BUN-:-U1*)7-@a>?g7\ B;5>-@)-N.G?.G7)\ B5>9Y5G<0`(.\ b()*.A?)-B;O\ C)*3(0?)-5G<`?)+\ 9;>C-N.G?.G7)\ 9;5N>-O0(17N)+,\ BObO\ Q>>5-N.G?.G7)\ MN-C.8<1g/*)\ 9;5N>-T()30/*)\ 9;5N>-O0(17N)+,\ 95NB>X"#/\ C9>\ BPN-5673)8c\ BPN-501*3-9]G<`(6
_!<=%$/+"/R(A-F%E/7'<=%A<\ M*1L)(713`-O0(17-50+?06\ M*1L)(713`-@)-Q.((01*)\ M*1L)(713`-@)-T.(@)0G]\ M*1L)(713`-@)-;0*3)7\ M*1L)(713`-O0(17Y973-C(`3)1?\ M*1L)(713`-@)-N)+,*.?./1)-@)-C.8<1g/*)\ M*1L)(713`-@)-P)**)7-\ B;5>-@)-P)**)7\ M*1L)(713`-@)-Q6.*\ M*1L)(713`-@a>*/)(7\ M*1L)(713`-50L.1)YU.*3YT?0*+\ M*1L)(713`-T()30/*)-5G@Y M*1L)(713`-
C03,.?1WG)-@)-?aDG)73Y M*1L)(713`-@a>*/)(7\ M*1L)(713`-@)-N.G?.*\ M*1L)(713`-@)-'(0*+,)-C.83`\ B;O-N.G?.G7)-\ B;5>-@)-N.G?.G7)\ B*7313G3-U1*)7-N)?)+.8\ M*1L)(713`-@)-O1+0(@1)\ 9+.?)-C)*3(0?)-U0(7)1??)\ B;5>-@)-P.G)*\ M*1L)(713`-@)-N)+,*.?./1)-@)-N(.6)7
_!<=%$/+"/6"#)<=$+!F/.",+"%%$+",\ M*1L)(713`-@)-53(07A.G(/\ M*1L)(713`-@)-53-\931)**)-Y 9;B59\ M*1L)(713`-@)-SG*R)(WG)\ M*1L)(713`-O0(17Y;0*3)(()\ 9+.?)-C)*3(0?)-Q6.*\ 9+.?)-C)*3(0?)-;0*3)7\ b()*.A?)-B;O-\ M*1L)(713`-b()*.A?)->?<)7\ B;5>-N.G?.G7)\ M*1L)(713`-@a>81)*7\ M*1L)(713`-@a>(3.17\ M*1L)(713`-O0(17Y973-U0(*)-?0-L0??`)\ M*1L)(713`-O0(17Y50+?06\ MO9C\ 9;B-U)32
7(7./+"/;$%">?/X#A+"+<=$!=+("</!"#>(AA)"+=+%</(0/)<%$<
U\X/N;$%">?/_(UP5/h i.1*3-C.880*@-B*4.(8031.*-5673)8-F5B>Hh ')@)(031.*-.4-3,)-Q0*@-C.8A03-5673)8-F5CDPOBD;H
h 'G3G()-C.8A03->1(-5673)8=fh ;0L0?-C.8A03-5673)8h T0??1731+-U1771?)-S)4)*+)h # ;031.*0?-0*@-;>ND-7673)87
RQ.7h 5<0+)-7673)87-.4-7673)87h # C..<)(031.*-I13,-95>
7A!$=/>+=+%<h b(0*@-O>PB5-N(0*7<.(3031.*-7673)8-.4-7673)87
h b(0*@-QjD;-14-
6.../7(7./118298123:
@!$=+>+-!=+("/=(/.)$(-%!"/@$(,$!AA%</N;@4a/g1212P5/h X+$/=$!00+>/_!"!,%A%"=/595>P-
9G(.<)0*-O(./(088)
h [!+F :-5,143!P01?h \F(H!F/"!G+,!=+("/<%$G+>%/b0?1?).h .F%>=$+>/Q%=^($f</+"=%$>(""%>=+("h 6"=%$>(""%>=+("/(0/0F)G+!F/<'<=%A<h CMX[.X/7(7a/UXQR.a/RS_@X77a/
[(!#17(7a/h [(!#1R@7a/@F!=0($A<YR@7h S=?%$5/@(F+>%a/7%>)$+='a/h h
7(7./!##$%<<%#/H'/;$%">?/6"#)<=$+!F<5/#%G%F(-+",/8/+A-F%A%"=+",/8/(-%$!=+",/7(7
h X[.WX/a/;[X_XCS_. :-*G+?)0(-<?0*3-7673)87h X6[VD7/5/C1L1?10*- F503)??13)- +.*73)??031.*7H-0*@-U1?130(6-5.5 FA.(@)(-7G(L)1??0*+)=-30+31+0?-*)3I.(R7H
h X$+!"%\$()-5/Q0G*+,-7)(L1+)7h X=(< :-71/*0??1*/- 0*@-+.*3(.?-4. (01?-7673)87=-5+,)*/)*h R!-/\%A+"+/5/P01?=-;0L0?=-C6A)(fJh RM7/B/7(-$!5/ U1?130(6-i.1*3-B*4.(8031.*-7673)87h .Q.U67/i/.U;/8/[C.:-9?)+3(1+-O.I)(-F+.H/)*)(031.*"-@173(1AG31.*-"-80*0/)8)*3
h QXWXI/\[SD@/5/U1?130(6-0*@-C1L1?10*- ;0L0?-7673)87-F)J/J-U0(1318)-7G(L)1??0*+)k-5)0(+,-0*@-()7+G)H
h [.QXDIC/5/>G3.8.31L)-1*@G73(6-=-+.**)+3)@-+0(7h C?!F%</5/C1L1?10*-F>1(-N(0441+-C.*3(.?=-780(3-+131)7=-(01?I06-71/*0??1*/=-fH-0*@-U1?130(6-5.5 F>1(-D<)(031.*7=-T0??1731+- U1771?)-S)4)*+)H
h 7X;[XQ/5/ B*4.(8031.*-7673)87-4.(-<.?1+)-0*@-41()8)*h C.RgQ6@/;_R/5/D1?- 1*@G73(6h h
-15-6.../7(7./118298123:
NATO MoDs
ATC National
Naval transport
Terrestrialtransport
etc…
SpaceEnergy
EDAEU
7(7./!##$%<<%#/H'/;$%">?/6"#)<=$+!F<5/=((F</#%G%F(-%$</8/G%"#($</0($/7(7/.",+"%%$+",
h XFFYC%>?/5/UT59-UT5>-3..?7=-504)36->(+,13)+3
h X[CXI/5/C0<)??0l-0(+,13)+3G()-8.@)??1*/-3..?=-CBNPM5-FBXX-80*0/)8)*3H
h U!<<!)F=/7'<=%A<5/_S-9]<)(1)*+)-7G13)-F0+WG1()@-Q(_!,+>:-C08).H
h .76/\$()-5/X1(3G0?-3I1*7
h \%%,F%% 5/>(+,13)+3G()-)]<?.(031.*-"-+.8<0(17.*-3..?=-
h j"(^F%#,%/ 6"<+#%5/0(mB3)+3
h _.\X/5/>(+,13)+3G()-8.@)??1*/-3..?-FU9b>n7G13)n4.(n;>'H
h SH%( 5/C0<)??0-@173(1AG31.*-F@)L)?.<)@-A6-3,)-o+?0(136p-+.88G*136H
h 7(#+)<5/US[.(RA)*+,=-59-C.??0A
i/;$%">?/<)H<+#+!$+%</(0/6"=%$"!=+("!F/R(A-!"+%<5
h X@7k7/5/5BU'B>- F704)36-0*0?6717-3..?H
X"#/A!"'/A($%h
-16-
6.../7(7./118298123:
Architecture Modelling
tools
Multi disciplinary simulation
tools
Comparison tools
Safety analysis
Evolution towards Collaborative Tools
6.../7(7./118298123:
7'<=%A/(0/7'<=%A<
.",+"%%$+",V)<+"%<</A(#%F<
@$(#)>=<7'<=%A</7%$G+>%<
7%$G+>%/.",+"%%$+",
7=$!=%,+>/A!"!,%A%"=
R'H%$/@?'<+>!F/7'<=%A<
X$%!</!##$%<<%#/H'/;$%">?/($,!"+d!=+("<
P,M,T, collaborative
SE…
Issue of Specification
Issue of Integration
Issue of Validation / revalidation
Issue of being only
reactive
Issue of not in Time-to-
Market