AAGGEENNDDAA OOFF TTHHEE 8800TTHH RREEGGUULLAARR SSEESSSSIIOONN OOFF TTHHEE 1177TTHH CCIITTYY CCOOUUNNCCIILL ((SSAANNGGGGUUNNIIAANNGG PPAANNLLUUNNGGSSOODD)) OOFF CCAAGGAAYYAANN DDEE OORROO OONN

MMOONNDDAAYY,, 1166 MMAARRCCHH 22001155

PAGE 1 OF 4 OF THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA

OOrrddeerr o f B u s i n e s s

A. CALL TO ORDER BY THE HONORABLE CHAIRMAN AND PRESIDING OFFICER

B. INVOCATION BY COUNCILOR ALDEN D. BACAL

C. SINGING OF THE LUPANG HINIRANG

D. ROLL CALL AND DETERMINATION OF QUORUM BY THE CITY COUNCIL SECRETARY

E. READING, CORRECTIONS, IF ANY, AND APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS REGULAR SESSION ON MARCH 09, 2015

(SEE APPENDIX “A”) F. SPECIAL REPORT/S:

- Councilor Roger G. Abaday - Councilor Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang - Councilor President D. Elipe

G. AGENDA PROPER:

[1.] A] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015-98 –– returning to the Barangay

Council of Barangay No. 25, this City, its Ordinance No. 1, series of 2015, covering its Annual Budget for Calendar Year 2015, with the information that said Ordinance is in order and therefore the same may be given force and effect as of the date fixed for its effectivity.

B] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015-99 –– returning to the Barangay

Council of Barangay No. 26, this City, its Ordinance No. 001-2015, series of 2015, covering its Annual Budget for Calendar Year 2015, with the information that said Ordinance is in order and therefore the same may be given force and effect as of the date fixed for its effectivity.

(SEE APPENDIX “B”) Document/s on file:

- Indorsements from the City Budget Office - Technical Review Analysis Sheets by the LFC - Ordinance No. 1, series of 2015, of Barangay No. 25 - Ordinance No. 001-2015, series of 2015, of Barangay No. 26 COMMITTEE SPONSOR/S: COMMITTEE ON BARANGAY AFFAIRS - COUNCILOR YAN LAM LIM, CHAIR - COUNCILOR DOMETILO C. ACENAS, JR., V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR EDNA M. DAHINO, MEMBER

AGENDA OF THE 80TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL, 16 MARCH 2015

PAGE 2 OF 4 OF THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA

COMMITTEE ON LAWS AND RULES - COUNCILOR RAMON G. TABOR, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, MEMBER - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., MEMBER

[2.] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015-100 –– accrediting the Zone 2 Riverside

Landless and Neighborhood Association, Inc., for purposes of its membership in the Local Special Bodies, pursuant to DILG Memorandum Circular No. 2013-70 and Article 64, Rule XIII of the Rules and Regulations implementing the 1991 Local Government Code, or funding its project from the City or other sources as required under the COA circular related thereto.

(SEE APPENDIX “C”) Document/s on file:

- Letter from CPDO - Letter from the Association President - Resolution No. 0011-2014 - Treasurer’s Certification - Balance Sheet - Statement of Receipts and Disbursement - Statement of Cash Flow - Statement of Fund Balance - Notes to Financial Statements - General Information Sheet - By-Laws - Financial Report - Certification - Appraisal Report - 1st Indorsement dated October 24, 2014 from - Shelter and Housing Multi-Sectoral Task Force COMMITTEE SPONSOR/S: COMMITTEE ON URBAN AND RURAL POOR - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, MEMBER

COMMITTEE ON LAWS AND RULES - COUNCILOR RAMON G. TABOR, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, MEMBER - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., MEMBER

[3.] PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2015-19 –– approving the application for simple

subdivision project of Sonia Dangaso, represented by Ms. Nelia E. Feliza, covering Lot 21, Block 17, Psd-10-000939, with an area of 374 square meters, containing 3 lots, located at Barangay Canitoan, this City.

(SEE APPENDIX “D”) Document/s on file: - 1st Indorsement dated February 20, 2015 from CMO – CDO Housing Board - 2nd Indorsement dated February 2,2015 from CPDO - Final Recommendation for Subdivision Approval - Official Receipt - Special Power of Attorney - Declaration of Real Property - Transfer Certificate of Title -Vicinity Map

COMMITTEE SPONSOR/S: COMMITTEE ON SUBDIVISION & LANDED ESTATE - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALDEN D. BACAL, V- CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, MEMBER - COUNCILOR DOMETILO C. ACENAS, JR., MEMBER

COMMITTEE ON LAWS AND RULES - COUNCILOR RAMON G. TABOR, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, MEMBER - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., MEMBER

AGENDA OF THE 80TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL, 16 MARCH 2015

PAGE 3 OF 4 OF THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA

[4.] PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2015-20 –– approving the application for simple subdivision project of Mr. Alfred C. Bokingkito, covering Lot 16, Block 11, (LRC) Psd-131075, with an area of 323 square meters, containing 2 lots, located at Barangay Bugo, this City.

(SEE APPENDIX “E”) Document/s on file: - 1st Indorsement dated February 20, 2015 from CMO – CDO Housing Board - 2nd Indorsement dated February 2,2 015 from CPDO - Final Recommendation for Subdivision Approval - Official Receipt - Real Property Tax - Transfer Certificate of Title -Vicinity Map

COMMITTEE SPONSOR/S: COMMITTEE ON SUBDIVISION & LANDED ESTATE - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALDEN D. BACAL, V- CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, MEMBER - COUNCILOR DOMETILO C. ACENAS, JR., MEMBER

COMMITTEE ON LAWS AND RULES - COUNCILOR RAMON G. TABOR, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, MEMBER - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., MEMBER

[5.] PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2015-21 –– approving the Application of the

National Housing Authority represented by its Regional Manager, Engr. Judy A. Fernandez, for Development Permit of City Urban Homeowners Association, Inc., with an area of 42,584 square meters, more or less, containing 266 subdivided lots, located at Barangay Carmen, this City.

(SEE APPENDIX “F”) Document/s on file: - 1st Indorsement from Cagayan de Oro Housing Board - 2nd Indorsement dated December 9, 2014 from CPDO - Final Recommendation for Development Permit - Letter from Judy A. Fernandez, Regional Director – NHA - Request for Development Permit for NHA on-site project under LTAP - Plans and other pertinent documents

COMMITTEE SPONSOR/S: COMMITTEE ON SUBDIVISION & LANDED ESTATE - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, CHAIR - COUNCILOR DOMETILO C. ACENAS, JR., MEMBER

COMMITTEE ON LAWS AND RULES - COUNCILOR RAMON G. TABOR, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, MEMBER - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., MEMBER

[6.] PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 2015-22 –– authorizing the Honorable City Mayor

to enter into and sign the Memorandum of Agreement with Gawad Kalinga Community Development Foundation, Inc. (GKCFI) covering the implementation of Socialized Housing Project for Typhoon Sendong Victims at Barangay Balubal, this

AGENDA OF THE 80TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL, 16 MARCH 2015

PAGE 4 OF 4 OF THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA

City, under the terms and conditions specified in the proposed MOA submitted to this Body.

(SEE APPENDIX “G”) Document/s on file: - Memorandum of Agreement - 1st indorsement dated October 14, 2013 from the CLO - Motion No. 180-2013 - 1st Indorsement dated September 16, 2013 from Task Force on Shelter and Housing Development -Program of Works/Budget Cost (Revised POW Final) - Site Development Map

COMMITTEE SPONSOR/S: COMMITTEE ON SUBDIVISION & LANDED ESTATE - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, MEMBER - COUNCILOR TEODULFO E. LAO, JR., EX-OFFICIO

COMMITTEE ON LAWS AND RULES - COUNCILOR RAMON G. TABOR, CHAIR - COUNCILOR ADRIAN L. BARBA, V-CHAIR - COUNCILOR ALEXANDER S. DACER, MEMBER - COUNCILOR LEON D. M. GAN, JR., MEMBER

Republic of the Philippines CITY OF CAGAYAN DE ORO

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

March 13, 2015 THE HONORABLE MEMBERS CITY COUNCIL CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY Gentlemen/Madam:

Please be informed that the 80TH Regular Session of the 17TH City Council of Cagayan de Oro will be on Monday, March 16, 2015 at 2:30 PM. at the Session Hall. Thank you very much.

Very truly yours,

ARTURO S. DE SAN MIGUEL

CITY COUNCIL SECRETARY

THE HONORABLE MEMBERS CITY COUNCIL CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY

HON. CAESAR IAN E. ACENAS CITY VICE MAYOR

First District Second District

HON. LOURDES CANDY R. DARIMBANG CITY COUNCILOR

HON. RAMON G. TABOR CITY COUNCILOR

HON. ZALDY O. OCON

CITY COUNCILOR HON. NADYA EMANO-ELIPE

CITY COUNCILOR

HON. ANNIE Y. DABA

CITY COUNCILOR HON. TEODULFO E. LAO, JR.

CITY COUNCILOR

HON. EDNA M. DAHINO

CITY COUNCILOR HON. LEON D. M. GAN, JR.

CITY COUNCILOR

HON. ROGER G. ABADAY

CITY COUNCILOR HON. DOMETILO C. ACENAS, JR.

CITY COUNCILOR

HON. DANTE B. PAJO

CITY COUNCILOR HON. ENRICO D. SALCEDO

CITY COUNCILOR

HON. ALDEN D. BACAL

CITY COUNCILOR HON. ALEXANDER S. DACER

CITY COUNCILOR

HON. ADRIAN L. BARBA

CITY COUNCILOR HON. PRESIDENT D. ELIPE

CITY COUNCILOR Ex-officio Members

HON. YAN LAM LIM

CITY COUNCILOR, LIGA NG MGA BARANGAY PRESIDENT

`

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (088) 857-2258; 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-4032

PAGE 1 OF 7 MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

MMIINNUUTTEESS OOFF TTHHEE 7799TTHH RREEGGUULLAARR SSEESSSSIIOONN OOFF TTHHEE 1177TTHH CCIITTYY CCOOUUNNCCIILL ((SSAANNGGGGUUNNIIAANNGG PPAANNLLUUNNGGSSOODD)) OOFF CCAAGGAAYYAANN DDEE OORROO,, MMOONNDDAAYY,, 99 MMAARRCCHH 22001155

Pursuant to Memorandum No. 08-2015 of City Vice-Mayor Caesar Ian E. Acenas, City Councilor

RAMON G. TABOR, Presiding Officer-Protempore, called the session to order at exactly 3:20 PM. The members present were the following:

First District: - City Councilor LOURDES CANDY R. DARIMBANG - City Councilor ANNIE Y. DABA - City Councilor EDNA M. DAHINO - City Councilor ROGER G. ABADAY, ASSISTANT MINORITY FLOOR LEADER - City Councilor ALDEN D. BACAL - City Councilor ADRIAN L. BARBA, MAJORITY FLOOR LEADER Second District: - City Councilor RAMON G. TABOR, PRESIDING OFFICER PROTEMPORE - City Councilor NADYA EMANO- ELIPE - City Councilor LEON DU M. GAN, JR., ASSISTANT MAJORITY FLOOR LEADER - City Councilor DOMETILO C. ACENAS, JR. - City Councilor ENRICO D. SALCEDO - City Councilor PRESIDENT D. ELIPE Ex-Officio: - City Councilor YAN LAM LIM, (President, Liga Ng Mga Barangay) On Official Business: - City Vice Mayor CAESAR IAN E. ACENAS - City Councilor DANTE B. PAJO Absent: - City Councilor ZALDY O. OCON - City Councilor TEODULFO E. LAO, JR., MINORITY FLOOR LEADER - City Councilor ALEXANDER S. DACER

After determining that a quorum existed, the City Council proceeded to do business.

AA.. OONN MMIINNUUTTEESS OOFF TTHHEE 7788TTHH RREEGGUULLAARR SSEESSSSIIOONN OONN MMAARRCCHH 0022,, 22001155

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887733--22001155

MOTION TO DISPENSE WITH THE READING OF THE MINUTES OF THE 78TH REGULAR SESSION ON MARCH 02, 2015 AND TO CONSIDER THE FURNISHING OF THE COPIES THEREOF TO EACH MEMBER AS THE READING ITSELF Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal & Edna M. Dahino, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

PAGE 2 OF 7 OF THE MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887744--22001155 MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE 78TH REGULAR SESSION ON MARCH 02, 2015

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal & Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

BB.. SSPPEECCIIAALL RREEPPOORRTT//SS::

i. Councilor President D. Elipe reported that the Executive Department has not acted on the

resolutions passed by the Sanggunian and asked the Body to authorize the Committee on Finance to make a formal follow-up of the same, inviting for the purpose heads of concerned departments, among other things.

Action taken: The Body adopted MMoottiioonn NNoo.. 2211887755--22001155

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887755--22001155

MOTION TO AUTHORIZE THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCE TO INVITE THE DIFFERENT DEPARTMENT HEADS CONCERNED TO FOLLOW-UP THE STATUS OF THE PERTINENT RESOLUTIONS PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL

Moved by Councilor President D. Elipe, duly seconded by Councilor Edna M. Dahino,

UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

ii. Councilor Adrian L. Barba reported about the Joint Motion to Dismiss filed by Ajinomoto and the City Government of Cagayan de Oro, represented by City Mayor Oscar S. Moreno through Atty. Raymond Villablanca, Assistant City Legal Officer, petitioner and respondent, respectively, in Civil Case No. 2014-093 filed by Ajinomoto Corporation against the City Government of Cagayan de Oro, as well as on the Settlement/Compromise Agreement entered into by and between Ajinomoto Corporation and the City Government of Cagayan de Oro, represented by Mayor Oscar S. Moreno through the OIC-City Treasurer Glenn Bañez, which provides for the reduction of the tax assessment for Ajinomoto from P2.9 Million to P300,000.00 following mediation thereof, considering that the Sanggunian had never enacted an ordinance for the purpose

Action taken: The Body adopted Resolution Nos. 11982-2015 and 11983-2015.

CC.. OONN MMIINNUUTTEESS OOFF TTHHEE 7799TTHH RREEGGUULLAARR SSEESSSSIIOONN OONN MMAARRCCHH 0099,, 22001155

At this juncture, Councilor Leon D. M. Gan, Jr. was out of the Session Hall. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

RESOLUTION NO. 11975-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF BARANGAY NO. 8, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 01, SERIES OF 2015, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

PAGE 3 OF 7 OF THE MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino & Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11976-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF BARANGAY NO. 11, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 01, SERIES OF 2015, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino

& Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11977-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF BARANGAY NO. 24, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 001, SERIES OF 2015, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino

& Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11978-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF BAIKINGON, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 001-2015, SERIES OF 2015, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino & Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11979-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF INDAHAG, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 001-2015, SERIES OF 2015, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino & Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11980-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF NAZARETH, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 04, SERIES OF 2014, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

PAGE 4 OF 7 OF THE MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino & Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11981-2015

RESOLUTION RETURNING TO THE BARANGAY COUNCIL OF PUNTOD, THIS CITY, ITS ORDINANCE NO. 001, SERIES OF 2015, COVERING ITS ANNUAL BUDGET FOR CALENDAR YEAR 2015, WITH THE INFORMATION THAT SAID ORDINANCE IS IN ORDER AND THEREFORE THE SAME MAY BE GIVEN FORCE AND EFFECT AS OF THE DATE FIXED FOR ITS EFFECTIVITY

Moved by Councilor Yan Lam Lim, duly seconded by Councilors Alden D. Bacal, Edna M. Dahino & Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr., UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887766--22001155 MOTION TO DISPENSE WITH THE SECOND AND FINAL READING OF RESOLUTION NOS.11975-2015, 11976-2015, 11977-2015, 11978-2015, 11979-2015, 11980-2015 AND 11981-2015

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, severally seconded by Councilors Annie Y. Daba & Alden D. Bacal, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887777--22001155 MOTION TO INCLUDE IN TODAY’S REGULAR AGENDA THE FOLLOWING AS ITEMS: [[22..]] AA]] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015 - 94 – requesting the Office of the Ombudsman-

Mindanao and the Department of Justice (DOJ) to look into the legality of the Joint Motion to dismiss filed by Ajinomoto Phils. Corporation and the city government of Cagayan de Oro, represented by City Mayor Oscar S. Moreno through Atty. Raymond Villablanca, Assistant City Legal Officer, petitioner and respondent, respectively, in Civil Case No. 2014-093, for review/seeking relief of the local business tax assessment, considering that the Sangguniang Panlungsod had never enacted an ordinance for the purpose; and to take appropriate action to correct the same, consistent with the provisions of the local government code and other applicable laws

BB]] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015 - 95 – requesting the Commission on Audit and the Bureau of Local Government Finance to look into the legality of the Settlement/Compromise Agreement entered into by and between Ajinomoto Phils. Corp. and the city government of Cagayan de Oro, represented by Mayor Oscar S. Moreno through the OIC-City Treasurer, in relation to Civil Case No. 2014-093, for review/seeking relief of the local business tax assessment, with Ajinomoto as petitioner, which provides for the reduction of the tax assessment for ajinomoto from p2.9 million to P300,000.00 following mediation thereof, considering that the Sanggunian had never enacted an ordinance for the purpose; and to take appropriate action to correct the same, consistent with the provisions of the local government code and other applicable laws

Proponent: - Councilor Adrian L. Barba [[33..]] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015 - 96 – expressing the City’s deepest sympathy and

condolences to Mr. Manny Agustero and family, for the untimely demise of his father, Mr. Rosello Agustero.

Proponents: - Councilor Adrian L. Barba - All Members - Councilor President D. Elipe

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

PAGE 5 OF 7 OF THE MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

[[44..]] PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2015 - 97 – expressing the City’s deepest sympathy and

condolences to Councilor Teodulfo E. Lao, Jr. and family, for the untimely demise of his mother-in-law, Mrs. Lilia Doong.

Proponents: - Councilor Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang - All Members

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, duly seconded by Councilor Edna M. Dahino, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

At this juncture, Councilor Leon D. M. Gan, Jr. returned to the Session Hall. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

RESOLUTION NO. 11982-2015

RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN-MINDANAO AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE (DOJ) TO LOOK INTO THE LEGALITY OF THE JOINT MOTION TO DISMISS FILED BY AJINOMOTO PHILS. CORPORATION AND THE CITY GOVERNMENT OF CAGAYAN DE ORO, REPRESENTED BY CITY MAYOR OSCAR S. MORENO THROUGH ATTY. RAYMOND VILLABLANCA, ASSISTANT CITY LEGAL OFFICER, PETITIONER AND RESPONDENT, RESPECTIVELY, IN CIVIL CASE NO. 2014-093, FOR REVIEW/SEEKING RELIEF OF THE LOCAL BUSINESS TAX ASSESSMENT, CONSIDERING THAT THE SANGGUNIANG PANLUNGSOD HAD NEVER ENACTED AN ORDINANCE FOR THE PURPOSE; AND TO TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION TO CORRECT THE SAME, CONSISTENT WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE AND OTHER APPLICABLE LAWS Proponent: - Councilor Adrian L. Barba

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, duly seconded by Councilor Edna M. Dahino, CARRIED BY MAJORITY.

Infavor

1ST District: - Councilor Annie Y. Daba - Councilor Edna M. Dahino - Councilor Alden D. Bacal - Councilor Adrian L. Barba 2nd District: - Councilor Nadya Emano- Elipe - Councilor Leon D. M. Gan, Jr. - Councilor Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr. - Councilor President D. Elipe Ex-Officio Member: - Councilor Yan Lam Lim, Liga Ng Mga Barangay President

Against - Councilor Roger G. Abaday

Abstained: - Councilor Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang - Councilor Enrico D. Salcedo On Official Business: - Vice Mayor Caesar Ian E. Acenas - Councilor Dante B. Pajo Absent: - Councilor Zaldy O. Ocon - Councilor Teodulfo E. Lao, Jr. - Councilor Alexander S. Dacer

RESOLUTION NO. 11983-2015

RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE COMMISSION ON AUDIT AND THE BUREAU OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT FINANCE TO LOOK INTO THE LEGALITY OF THE SETTLEMENT/COMPROMISE AGREEMENT ENTERED INTO BY AND BETWEEN AJINOMOTO PHILS. CORP. AND THE CITY GOVERNMENT OF CAGAYAN DE ORO, REPRESENTED BY MAYOR OSCAR S. MORENO THROUGH THE OIC-CITY TREASURER, IN RELATION TO CIVIL CASE NO. 2014-093, FOR REVIEW/SEEKING RELIEF OF THE LOCAL BUSINESS TAX

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

PAGE 6 OF 7 OF THE MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

ASSESSMENT, WITH AJINOMOTO AS PETITIONER, WHICH PROVIDES FOR THE REDUCTION OF THE TAX ASSESSMENT FOR AJINOMOTO FROM P2.9 MILLION TO P300,000.00 FOLLOWING MEDIATION THEREOF, CONSIDERING THAT THE SANGGUNIAN HAD NEVER ENACTED AN ORDINANCE FOR THE PURPOSE; AND TO TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION TO CORRECT THE SAME, CONSISTENT WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE AND OTHER APPLICABLE LAWS Proponent: - Councilor Adrian L. Barba

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, duly seconded by Councilor Edna M. Dahino, CARRIED BY MAJORITY.

Infavor

1ST District: - Councilor Annie Y. Daba - Councilor Edna M. Dahino - Councilor Alden D. Bacal - Councilor Adrian L. Barba 2nd District: - Councilor Nadya Emano- Elipe - Councilor Leon D. M. Gan, Jr. - Councilor Dometilo C. Acenas, Jr. - Councilor President D. Elipe Ex-Officio Member: - Councilor Yan Lam Lim, Liga Ng Mga Barangay President

Against - Councilor Roger G. Abaday

Abstained: - Councilor Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang - Councilor Enrico D. Salcedo

On Official Business: - Vice Mayor Caesar Ian E. Acenas - Councilor Dante B. Pajo

Absent: - Councilor Zaldy O. Ocon - Councilor Teodulfo E. Lao, Jr. - Councilor Alexander S. Dacer

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887788--22001155

MOTION TO DISPENSE WITH THE SECOND AND FINAL READING OF RESOLUTION NOS. 11982-2015 AND 11983-2015

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, duly seconded by Councilors Annie Y. Daba & Edna M. Dahino, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

RESOLUTION NO. 11984-2015

RESOLUTION EXPRESSING THE CITY’S DEEPEST SYMPATHY AND CONDOLENCES TO MR. MANNY AGUSTERO AND FAMILY, FOR THE UNTIMELY DEMISE OF HIS FATHER, MR. ROSELLO AGUSTERO Proponents: - Councilor Adrian L. Barba - All Members - Councilor President D. Elipe

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, severally seconded by the members present, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211887799--22001155

MOTION TO DISPENSE WITH THE SECOND AND FINAL READING OF RESOLUTION NO. 11984-2015

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, severally seconded by the members present, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

Republic of the Philippines City of Cagayan de Oro

OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL (08822) 724854; (088) 857-4029; 857-4035; 857-2048

PAGE 7 OF 7 OF THE MINUTES OF THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL

RESOLUTION NO. 11985-2015

RESOLUTION EXPRESSING THE CITY’S DEEPEST SYMPATHY AND CONDOLENCES TO COUNCILOR TEODULFO E. LAO, JR. AND FAMILY, FOR THE UNTIMELY DEMISE OF HIS MOTHER-IN-LAW, MRS. LILIA DOONG Proponents: - Councilor Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang - All Members

Moved by Councilor Lourdes Candy R. Darimbang, severally seconded by the members present, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211888800--22001155

MOTION TO DISPENSE WITH THE SECOND AND FINAL READING OF RESOLUTION NO. 11985-2015

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, severally seconded by the members present, UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED.

MMOOTTIIOONN NNOO.. 2211888811--22001155

MOTION TO ADJOURN THE 79TH REGULAR SESSION OF THE 17TH CITY COUNCIL (SANGGUNIANG PANLUNGSOD) OF CAGAYAN DE ORO HELD ON MARCH 09, 2015

Moved by Councilor Adrian L. Barba, severally seconded by the members present,

UNANIMOUSLY CARRIED. The session adjourned at 4:45 PM, March 09, 2015. I hereby certify to the correctness of the foregoing Minutes.

ARTURO S. DE SAN MIGUEL CITY COUNCIL SECRETARY

Attested as correct:

RAMON G. TABOR CITY COUNCILOR

PRESIDING OFFICER PROTEMPORE