agrarian law_case digests

8/12/2019 Agrarian Law_Case Digests

1/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

./ )0#123 45/ "#0*1+ 6)#23714"4 /54 6789:;

? @A 9BBB

8!)-*9

C?DEDE5>?F 1GHE>5 !5FI=J KGL G MGFN?FOP?>?MEQEGFR =>S?F DT? ,I?FGDE5> +G>S

0FG>LM?F CF5UFGN 5M DT? &?IGFDN?>D 5M 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN4 V? KGL ELL=?S G !?FDEMEQGD?5M +G>S 0FG>LM?F 5H?F DK5 IGFQ?WL 5M GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>S4 )> 5FS?F D5 IGR M5F DT?

T5LIEDGWEJGDE5> 5M TEL KEM?A T? N5FDUGU?S DT? L=PX?QD WG>S E> MGH5F 5M (EFUE>EG S?+?5>4 YT?> DT? Q5>DFGQD ?ZIEF?SA T? GUGE> N5FDUGU?S ED D5 F?LI5>S?>D VEWGFEG

1F5LI? M5F G I?FE5S 5M M5=F R?GFL4 0T? IGFDE?L ?Z?Q=D?S G Q5>DFGQDA KTEQT GWW5K?S DT?

F?LI5>S?>DL D5 Q=WDEHGD? DT? WG>S S=FE>U DT? S=FGDE5> 5M DT? N5FDUGU? 5F =>DEW&?Q?NP?F B8A 6::B4

!5FI=J L=PL?[=?>DWR E>LDED=D?S G Q5NIWGE>D KTEQT GWW?U?S DTGD DT? 1F5LI?\L TGS

?>D?F?S DT? SELI=D?S WG>S PR M5FQ? G>S S?LDF5R?S DT? IGWGR DTGD T? TGS IWG>D?S 5> ED4V5K?H?F GQQ5FSE>U D5 DT? 1F5LI?LA !5FI=J TGS GWF?GSR ?Z?Q=D?S G ]KGEH?F 5M FEUTDL\5H?F DT? WG>ST5WSE>U E> MGH5F 5M DT? LI5=L?L E> Q5>LES?FGDE5> 5M 8^_4

C'"'3 GSX=SEQGD5F *F>?LD5 0GPGF F=W?S DTGD !5FI=J GPG>S5>?S G>S L=FF?>S?F?SDT? WG>ST5WSE>U D5 DT? -GNGTG>U /GR5> 5M /=?HG *QEXG4 -GES -GNGTG>U /GR5> ?H?>

IGLL?S "?L5W=DE5> /54 6` G>S 9; F?Q5NN?>SE>U DT? F?GWW5QGDE5> 5M LGES W5DL D5 DT?1F5LI?LA KT5 K?F? DT? N5LD [=GWEME?S MGFN?FLOP?>?MEQEGFE?L4 &'"'3 G>S !'

GMMEFN?S DT? S?QELE5>

$**2+*9

64YT?DT?F 5F >5D DT? \KGEH?F 5M FEUTDL\ EL Q5>DFGFR D5 GUFGFEG> WGK94 YT?DT?F 5F >5D !5FI=J TGS GPG>S5>?S TEL WG>ST5WSE>U74 YT?DT?F 5F >5D !5FI=J TGS H5W=>DGFEWR L=FF?>S?F?S TEL WG>ST5WSE>U

:+',9

64 a?L4 0T? LGW? 5F DFG>LM?F 5M FEUTDL 5H?F G IF5I?FDR Q5H?F?S PR G Q?FDEMEQGD? 5M WG>S

DFG>LM?F EL H5ES ?ZQ?ID KT?> DT? GWE?>GDE5> EL NGS? E> MGH5F 5M DT? U5H?F>N?>D 5FDTF5=UT T?F?SEDGFR L=QQ?LLE5>4 0TEL F=WE>U EL E>D?>S?S D5 IF?H?>D G F?H?FLE5> D5 DT?

5WS M?=SGW LRLD?N E> KTEQT DT? WG>S5K>?FL F?GQ[=EF? HGLD DFGQD 5M WG>S DT=LA

>?UGDE>U DT? U5H?F>N?>D\L IF5UFGN 5M MF??E>U DT? D?>G>D MF5N DT? P5>SGU? 5M DT?L5EW4

94 /54 !5FI=Jb L=FF?>S?F?S 5M I5LL?LLE5> SES >5D GN5=>D D5 G> GPG>S5>N?>D

P?QG=L? DT?F? KGL G> 5PWEUGDE5> 5> DT? IGFD 5M DT? 1F5LI?\L D5 F?D=F> DT? I5LL?LLE5>

5M DT? WG>ST5WSE>U =I5> M=WW IGRN?>D 5M DT? W5G>4 0T?F? KGL >5 QW?GFA GPL5W=D? 5FEFF?H5QGPW? E>D?>DE5> D5 GPG>S5>4

74 a?L4 !5FI=J\ E>D?>DE5> D5 L=FF?>S?F DT? WG>ST5WSE>U KGL QW?GF G>S =>?[=EH5QGW4 V?

LEU>?S TEL Q5>Q=FF?>Q? D5 DT? -GNGTG>U /GR5> "?L5W=DE5>L4 VEL H5W=>DGFR


2/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

L=FF?>S?F D5 DT? LGNGTG>U >GR5> [=GWEME?L GL G L=FF?>S?F 5F DFG>LM?F D5 DT?

U5H?F>N?>D P?QG=L? L=QT GQDE5> M5FNL IGFD 5M DT? N?QTG>ELN M5F DT? SELI5LEDE5>G>S F?GWW5QGDE5> 5M 5M MGFNT5WSE>UL 5M D?>G>D MGFN?FL KT5 F?M=L? D5 P?Q5N?

P?>?MEQEGFE?L 5M IS 9;4

;/ +*-0'!* 45/ U D5 F?LI5>S?>DA DT?F? KGL 5>WR G H?FPGWN5FDUGU?c KTEW? GQQ5FSE>U D5 I?DEDE5>?FA G LGW? TGS DG_?> IWGQ?4 'QDE>U 5> DT?

DFG>LM?FA DT? &'" 5MMEQEGWL E> -DG4 2GFEGA CG>UGLE>G> G=DT5FEJ?S DT? L=FH?R G>SELL=G>Q? 5M G> *NG>QEIGDE5> CGD?>DA W?GSE>U D5 DT? ELL=G>Q? 5M G 0FG>LM?F !?FDEMEQGD?

5M 0EDW? E> MGH5F 5M DT? I?DEDE5>?F4 "?LI5>S?>D MEW?S G !5NIWGE>D GUGE>LD DT?

I?DEDE5>?F F?S??NE>U DT? L=PX?QD WG>S G>S DT? QGL? KGL F?M?FF?S D5 DT? &?IGFDN?>D5M 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN4

,> 5DT?F E>H?LDEUGDE5> KGL Q5>S=QD?S 5> DT? NGDD?F KTEQT W?S D5 DT? ,FS?F SGD?S2GFQT :A 6:@:A ELL=?S PR &'" "?UE5>GW &EF?QD5F '>D5>E5 24 /=?LG4 )> DT? LGES

,FS?FA DT? &'" M5=>S DT? GQD 5M F?LI5>S?>D E> L=FF?>S?FE>U DT? L=PX?QD WG>S E> MGH5F

5M I?DEDE5>?F GL Q5>LDED=DE>U GPG>S5>N?>D DT?F?5MA G>S S?>E?S F?LI5>S?>DbL IFGR?FM5F F?S?NIDE5> 5M DT? L=PX?QD WG>S4

!' F=W?Sd 0T? DFG>LM?F 5M DT? L=PX?QD WG>S D5 I?DEDE5>?F EL H5ESc ED LT5=WS P? F?D=F>?S

D5 F?LI5>S?>D4 "?LI5>S?>D TGS >5D ?MM?QDEH?WR GPG>S5>?S DT? IF5I?FDRA P?QG=L? T?DFE?S D5 F?S??N ED E> 6:@6 G>S 6:@74

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D F?LI5>S?>D GPG>S5>?S DT? L=PX?QD IF5I?FDRA DT?F?PR NG_E>U EDGHGEWGPW? D5 5DT?F [=GWEME?S MGFN?FOUFG>D??Le

:+',9

0T?F? KGL >5 GPG>S5>N?>D G>S ?H?> EM DT?F? KGL ED Q5=WS >5D P? DFG>LM?FF?S D5

G>R5>? 5DT?F DTG> DT? 15H?F>N?>D4 C& 9; LI?QEMEQGWWR IF5HES?L DTGD DEDW? D5 WG>SGQ[=EF?S I=FL=G>D D5 EDL NG>SGD? 5F D5 DTGD 5M DT? +G>S "?M5FN CF5UFGN 5M DT?

U5H?F>N?>D LTGWW >5D P? DFG>LM?FGPW? ?ZQ?ID D5 DT? UFG>D??bL T?EFL PR T?F?SEDGFR


3/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

L=QQ?LLE5>A 5F PGQ_ D5 DT? U5H?F>N?>D PR 5DT?F W?UGW N?G>L4 0T? WGK EL QW?GF G>S

W?GH?L >5 F55N M5F E>D?FIF?DGDE5>4

f5F GPG>S5>N?>D D5 ?ZELDA DT? M5WW5KE>U F?[=ELED?L N=LD P? IF5H?>d gGh G QW?GF G>S

GPL5W=D? E>D?>DE5> D5 F?>5=>Q? G FEUTD 5F QWGEN 5F D5 S?L?FD G FEUTD 5F IF5I?FDR G>SgPh G> ?ZD?F>GW GQD PR KTEQT DTGD E>D?>DE5> EL ?ZIF?LL?S 5F QGFFE?S E>D5 ?MM?QD4 0T?F?

N=LD P? G> GQD=GWA >5D N?F?WR G IF5X?QD?SA F?WE>[=ELTN?>Dc 5DT?FKEL?A DT? FEUTD 5FQWGEN EL >5D HGQGD?S 5F KGEH?S G>SA DT=LA L=LQ?IDEPW? 5M P?E>U GIIF5IFEGD?S PR

G>5DT?F4 'SNE>ELDFGDEH? ,FS?F /54 9A ELL=?S 5> 2GFQT ;A 6::^A S?ME>?L GPG>S5>N?>D

5F >?UW?QD GL G iKEWWM=W MGEW=F? 5M DT? GUFGFEG> F?M5FN P?>?MEQEGFRA D5U?DT?F KEDT TELMGFN T5=L?T5WSA D5 Q=WDEHGD?A DEWW 5F S?H?W5I TEL WG>S D5 IF5S=Q? G>R QF5IA 5F D5 =L?

DT? WG>S M5F G>R LI?QEMEQ ?Q5>5NEQ I=FI5L? Q5>DE>=5=LWR M5F G I?FE5S 5M DK5

QGW?>SGF R?GFL4j )> DT? IF?L?>D QGL?A >5 L=QT iKEWWM=W MGEW=F?j TGL P??>S?N5>LDFGD?S4 k=ED? DT? Q5>DFGFRA F?LI5>S?>D TGL Q5>DE>=?S D5 QWGEN S5NE>E5>

5H?F DT? WG>S4

C?DEDE5>?F QG>>5DA PR TENL?WMA DG_? 5H?F G MGFN?FOP?>?MEQEGFRbL WG>ST5WSE>UA GWW?U?SWR5> DT? UF5=>S DTGD ED KGL GPG>S5>?S4 0T? IF5I?F IF5Q?S=F? M5F F?GWW5QGDE5> N=LD

P? M5WW5K?S D5 ?>L=F? DTGD DT?F? KGL E>S??S G> GPG>S5>N?>DA G>S DTGD DT?L=PL?[=?>D P?>?MEQEGFR EL G [=GWEME?S MGFN?FOD?>G>D GL IF5HES?S PR WGK4

?/ ):!>+3 45/ 12='$) +*-!-+ !2-:0#$-@ 6,+'0* *!%-0*7"/#/ %A/ .??;BC

DEFG HI ;CC;

8!)-*9

0T? U5H?F>N?>D DTF5=UT DT? !5NNELLE5>?F 5M C=PWEQ VEUTKGRL LEU>?S G Q5>DFGQD

KEDT DT? !5>LDF=QDE5> G>S &?H?W5IN?>D !5FI5FGDE5> 5M DT? CTEWEIIE>?L g!&!Ch D5F?QWGEN Q?FDGE> M5F?LT5F? G>S 5MMLT5F? GF?GL 5M 2G>EWG 3GR4 0T? Q5>DFGQD GWL5

E>QW=S?S DT? Q5>LDF=QDE5> 5M CTGL?L ) G>S )) 5M DT? 2G>EWGO!GHED? !5GLDGW "5GS4 !&!C5PWEUGD?S EDL?WM D5 QGFFR 5=D GWW DT? K5F_L E> Q5>LES?FGDE5> 5M MEMDR I?FQ?>D 5M DT? D5DGW

F?QWGEN?S WG>S4 ' M?K R?GFL GMD?FA DT? C*' ?>D?F?S E>D5 G D (?>D=F? 'UF??N?>DgD?F?S E>D5

DTF5=UT >?U5DEGDE5> KEDT5=D I=PWEQ PESSE>U4

0T? -?>GD? !5NNEDD?? 5> 15H?F>N?>D !5FI5FGDE5>L G>S C=PWEQ *>D?FIFEL?LA G>S DT?

!5NNEDD?? 5> 'QQ5=>DGPEWEDR 5M C=PWEQ ,MMEQ?FL G>S )>H?LDEUGDE5>LA Q5>S=QD?S G X5E>D

E>H?LDEUGDE5>4 'N5>U DT? Q5>QW=LE5> GF?d DTGD DT? F?QWGEN?S WG>SL C*' L??_L D5

DFG>LM?F D5 '2'") =>S?F DT? >5D GWE?>GD?DT?L? WG>SLA DT? Q?FDEMEQGD?L 5M DT? DEDW? Q5H?FE>U DT? fF??S5N )LWG>SL GF? DT=L H5ESA

G>S DT? ?F GL DGZIGR?F MEW?S DT? E>LDG>D I?DEDE5> M5F NG>SGN=L

KEDT IFGR?F M5F DT? ELL=G>Q? 5M G KFED 5M IF?WENE>GFR E>X=>QDE5> G>S 0",4 C?DEDE5>?FQ5>D?>SL DT? U5H?F>N?>D LDG>SL D5 W5L? PEWWE5>L 5M I?L5L E> DT? LGW? PR C*' 5M DT?


4/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

F?QWGEN?S WG>SL D5 '2'")4 C?DEDE5>?F IFGRL DTGD C*' I=PWEQWR SELQW5L? DT? D?FNL 5M

G>R F?>?U5DEGDE5> 5M DT? LDED=DE5>

IF5TEPEDE>U DT? LGW? 5M GWE?>GPW? WG>SL 5M DT? I=PWEQ S5NGE> D5 IFEHGD? Q5FI5FGDE5>L4

C?DEDE5>?F GLL?FD DTGD T? L??_L D5 ?>X5E> DT? W5LL 5M PEWWE5>L 5M I?L5L E> IF5I?FDE?L 5MDT? -DGD? DTGD GF? 5M I=PWEQ S5NE>E5>4

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D '2'")A G IFEHGD? Q5FI5FGDE5>A QG> GQ[=EF? G>S 5K> DT? WG>SL =>S?F

DT? GN?>S?S X5E>D H?>D=F? GUF??N?>D TGHE>U 7`;48 T?QDGF?L L4 5M F?QWGEN?SM5F?LT5F? G>S L=PN?FU?S GF?G E> 2G>EWG 3GR E> HE?K 5M -?QDE5>L 9 m 7A 'FD4 69 5M DT?

!5>LDED=DE5>4

:+',9

0T? -=IF?N? !5=FD GMMEFN?S DTGD DT? 68;4@^ T?QDGF?L 5M F?QWGEN?S WG>SL Q5NIFELE>UDT? fF??S5N )LWG>SLA >5K Q5H?F?S PR Q?FDEMEQGD?L 5M DEDW? E> DT? >GN? 5M C*'A GF?

GWE?>GPW? WG>SL 5M DT? I=PWEQ S5NGE>4 0T? 8:9468 T?QDGF?L 5M L=PN?FU?S GF?GL 5M

2G>EWG 3GR F?NGE> E>GWE?>GPW? >GD=FGW F?L5=FQ?L 5M DT? I=PWEQ S5NGE>4 -E>Q? DT?'N?>S?S D (?>D=F? 'UF??N?>D L??_L D5 DFG>LM?F D5 '2'")A G IFEHGD?

Q5FI5FGDE5>A 5K>?FLTEI 5M ;;47^ T?QDGF?L 5M DT? fF??S5N )LWG>SLA L=QT DFG>LM?F ELH5ES M5F P?E>U Q5>DFGFR D5 -?QDE5> 7A 'FDEQW? l)) 5M DT? 6:@; !5>LDED=DE5> KTEQT

IF5TEPEDL IFEHGD? Q5FI5FGDE5>L MF5N GQ[=EFE>U G>R _E>S 5M GWE?>GPW? WG>S 5M DT?

I=PWEQ S5NGE>4 f=FDT?FN5F?A LE>Q? DT? 'N?>S?S LDED=DE5> KTEQT

IF5TEPEDL DT? GWE?>GDE5> 5M >GD=FGW F?L5=FQ?L 5DT?F DTG> GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SL 5M DT?

I=PWEQ S5NGE>4

0T? C5>Q? !GL?L K?F? S?QES?S =>S?F DT? 6:78 !5>LDED=DE5> KTEQT GWW5K?S IFEHGD?

Q5FI5FGDE5>L D5 GQ[=EF? GWE?>GPW? WG>SL 5M DT? I=PWEQ S5NGE>4 V5K?H?FA DT? 6:;7

!5>LDED=DE5> IF5TEPED?S IFEHGD? Q5FI5FGDE5>L MF5N GQ[=EFE>U GWE?>GPW? WG>SL 5M DT?I=PWEQ S5NGE>A G>S DT? 6:@; !5>LDED=DE5> F?ED?FGD?S DTEL IF5TEPEDE5>4 ,PHE5=LWRA DT?

C5>Q? !GL?L QG>>5D L?FH? GL G=DT5FEDR M5F G IFEHGD? Q5FI5FGDE5> D5 GQ[=EF? GWE?>GPW?

I=PWEQ WG>SLA N=QT W?LL L=PN?FU?S WG>SLA LE>Q? =>S?F DT? IF?L?>D !5>LDED=DE5> GIFEHGD? Q5FI5FGDE5> WE_? 'NGFE EL PGFF?S MF5N GQ[=EFE>U GWE?>GPW? WG>SL 5M DT? I=PWEQ

S5NGE>4

J/ '23 8!#


5/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

"=W?L G>S 1=ES?WE>?L IF5N=WUGD?S E> GQQ5FSG>Q? DT?F?KEDTA P? S?QWGF?S

=>Q5>LDED=DE5>GW M5F P?E>U F?I=U>G>D D5 DT? S=? IF5Q?LL QWG=L?4 -?QDE5>L 67 G>S 79SEF?QD?S ]Q5FI5FGD? MGFNL]A KTEQT E>QW=S?S WEH?LD5Q_ G>S I5=WDFR FGEL?FL D5 ?Z?Q=D?

G>S ENIW?N?>D ]IF5S=QDE5>OLTGFE>U IWG>L] gI?>SE>U ME>GW F?SELDFEP=DE5> 5M DT?EF

WG>ST5WSE>ULh DTGD K5=WS SELDFEP=D? MF5N DTF?? I?FQ?>D g7nh 5M DT?EF UF5LL LGW?L G>SD?> I?FQ?>D g6Bnh 5M DT?EF >?D IF5MEDL D5 DT?EF K5F_?FL GL GSSEDE5>GW Q5NI?>LGDE5>4

+=J fGFNL GWL5 GFU=?S DTGD WEH?LD5Q_ 5F I5=WDFR FGELE>U KGL >5D LENEWGF D5 QF5I 5FDF?? MGFNE>Uc ED KGL >5D DT? IFENGFR F?L5=FQ? E> DTEL =>S?FDG_E>U G>S F?IF?L?>D?S

>5 N5F? DTG> MEH? I?FQ?>D g8nh 5M DT? D5DGW E>H?LDN?>D 5M Q5NN?FQEGW WEH?LD5Q_ G>S

I5=WDFR FGEL?FL4 0T=LA DT?R N=LD >5D P? Q5H?F?S PR DT? WGK4 ,> DT? 5DT?F TG>SA &'"Q5NN?>D?S DTGD WEH?LD5Q_ G>S I5=WDFR FGELE>U K?F? ?NPFGQ?S E> DT? D?FN

]GUFEQ=WD=F?] PGL?S 5> Y?PLD?F\L )>D?F>GDE5>GW &EQDE5>GFRbL S?ME>EDE5>4 0T? !5=FDA

DT?>A D55_ Q5U>EJG>Q? 5M DT? QGL?A GL ED GLLGEW?S DT? Q5>LDED=DE5>GWEDR 5M DT? WGK4

$**2+9

Y,/ DT? Q5>D?LD?S IF5HELE5>L G>S ENIW?N?>DE>U F=W?LA KTEQT Q5H?F?S WEH?LD5Q_ G>S

I5=WDFR E>S=LDFR =>S?F GUFGFEG> F?M5FNA K?F? =>Q5>LDED=DE5>GW4

:+',9

a?L4 0T? DFG>LQFEIDL 5M DT? S?WEP?FGDE5>L 5M DT? !5>LDED=DE5>GW !5NNELLE5> 5M 6:@`5> DT? N?G>E>U 5M DT? K5FS ]GUFEQ=WD=FGW] QW?GFWR LT5K?S DTGD ED KGL >?H?F DT?

E>D?>DE5> 5M DT? MFGN?FL 5M DT? !5>LDED=DE5> D5 E>QW=S? WEH?LD5Q_ G>S I5=WDFR E>S=LDFR

E> DT? Q5H?FGU? 5M DT? Q5>LDED=DE5>GWWRONG>SGD?S GUFGFEG> F?M5FN IF5UFGN 5M DT?15H?F>N?>D4 25F?5H?FA DT? !5NNEDD?? GS5ID?S DT? S?ME>EDE5> 5M ]GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>S]

GL S?ME>?S =>S?F -?QDE5> 6`` 5M "4'4 7@^^A GL WG=S S?H5D?S D5 G>R UF5KDTA E>QW=SE>U

P=D >5D WENED?S D5 QF5I WG>SLA LGWDP?SLA MELTI5>SLA ESW? G>S GPG>S5>?S WG>S4 -ENIWRA

DT? LGES IF5HELE5>L G>S F=W?L K?F? HE5WGDEH? 5M DT? !5>LDED=DE5>4

K/ 1:$'$11$%+ %!-$0%!' #!$'(!@* !"/ :0%/ >!'+#$!%0 !/

,+' >!''+ 6'!3!#0714"4 /54 +O9:7@6-?ID?NP?F 7BA 6:`:

8!)-*9

C/"A G U5H?F>N?>DO5K>?S Q5FI5FGDE5>A EL DT? F?UELD?F?S 5K>?F 5M DTF?? g7h LDFEIL

5M WG>S KEDT G =>EM5FN KESDT 5M 7B N?D?FL GSX5E>E>U 5>? G>5DT?F W5>UED=SE>GWWRADT? LGN? P?E>U IGFD 5M EDL FGEWF5GS FEUTD 5M KGR F=>>E>U MF5N 2G>EWG D5 +?UGJIE4

0T?L? LDFEIL 5M WG>S WE? KEDTE> DT? N=>EQEIGWEDE?L 5M ,GL G>S C5WG>U=EA CF5HE>Q? 5M

'WPGR4 'D DT? Q?>D?F DT?F?5M EL G DFGQ_ N?GL=FE>U D?> g6Bh D5 DK?WH? g69h N?D?FL E>KESDT KT?F? FGEWF5GS DE?L GF? IWGQ?S G>S FGEWL P=EWD M5F F=>>E>U W5Q5N5DEH?L4 ,>

P5DT LES?L 5M DT? DFGQ_A 5F GP5=D DK5 g9h D5 MEH? g8h N?D?FL GKGR MF5N DT??NPG>_N?>D 5M DT? DFGQ_A GF? D?W?UFGIT G>S D?W?IT5>? I5LDL MEMDR g8Bh N?D?FL

GIGFD MF5N ?GQT 5DT?FA KTEQT NGE>DGE> Q5NN=>EQGDE5> KEF?L >?Q?LLGFR E> DT?

5I?FGDE5> 5M C/" DFGE>L4 C/" SFGKL ?GFDT MF5N DT?L? LES?L D5 MEWW =I DT? FGEWF5GS


6/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

DFGQ_ KT?>?H?F ED EL S?LDF5R?S PR KGD?F S=FE>U FGE>R SGRLc G>S =L?L DT?N GL

S?I5LED5FR 5M FGEWF5GS NGD?FEGWL M5F DT? F?IGEF 5M S?LDF5R?S WE>?LA I5LDLA PFESU?LS=FE>U KGLT5=DL4 5F 5DT?F SGNGU?S IGFDL 5M DT? WE>? 5QQGLE5>?S PR S?FGEWN?>DL 5F

5DT?F QGWGNEDE?L4

0T? I5FDE5>L 5M DT?L? WG>SL >5D GQD=GWWR 5QQ=IE?S PR DT? FGEWF5GS DFGQ_ TGS P??> G

L5=FQ? 5M DF5=PW?4 C?5IW? 5QQ=IE?S DT?Nc DT?R F?GI IF5MEDL DT?F?MF5N4 &ELI=D?L

GN5>U DT5L? S?LEFE>U D5 5QQ=IR DT?N QF5II?S =I4 )D EL 5> DT? MGQ? 5M GWW DT?L? DTGDAKEDT GS?[=GD? IF5HELE5>L D5 LGM?U=GFS FGEWF5GS 5I?FGDE5>LA C/" GS5ID?S D?NI5FGFR

F=W?L G>S F?U=WGDE5>L4

-5N?DEN? E> 6:`7A C/" GKGFS?S DT? I5FDE5>L 5M DT? DTF?? LDFEIL 5M WG>S

GM5F?N?>DE5>?S KTEQT GF? 5> P5DT LES?L 5M DT? DFGQ_A GMD?F G Q5NI?DEDEH? I=PWEQPESSE>UA D5 I?DEDE5>?F CG>DGW?5> 3E>UGPE>U M5F G I?FE5S 5M DTF?? g7h R?GFL4 ' QEHEW WGK

W?GL? Q5>DFGQD E> IFE>D?S M5FN KGLA 5> 'IFEW 68A 6:`7A ?>D?F?S E>D5 PR G>S P?DK??>

C/" G>S 3E>UGPE>U4 0TGD Q5>DFGQD ?ZIF?LLWR LDEI=WGD?L DTGD 3E>UGPE>U KGL ]D55QQ=IR G>S =L? DT? IF5I?FDR 4 4 4 !"#$%&'&()*M5F GUFEQ=WD=F?4] 3E>UGPE>UA T5K?H?FA

MGEW?S D5 DG_? I5LL?LLE5> P?QG=L? F?LI5>S?>D CGNIEW5 &5WDJ KGL 5QQ=IRE>U DT? WG>SATGS G T5=L? DT?F?5>4 &5WDJ QWGENL D5 P? G D?>G>D 5M IF?HE5=L GKGFS??LA G>S WGD?FA 5M

3E>UGPE>U TENL?WM4

$**2+*9

./ YT?DT?F 5F >5D LDFEIL 5M WG>S 5K>?S PR CTEWEIIE>? /GDE5>GW "GEWKGRL gC/"h

KTEQT GF? 5> P5DT LES?L 5M EDL FGEWF5GS DFGQ_A G>S GF? IGFD 5M EDL FEUTD 5M KGR M5F EDL

FGEWF5GS 5I?FGDE5>L P=D D?NI5FGFEWR W?GL?SA GF? GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SL KEDTE> DT?I=FHE?K 5M DT? 'UFEQ=WD=FGW 0?>G>QR 'QD G>S DT? 'UFEQ=WD=FGW +G>S "?M5FN !5S?A

L=QT GL K5=WS Q5N? KEDTE> DT? X=FELSEQDE5> 5M DT? !5=FD 5M 'UFGFEG> "?WGDE5>L4

;/ Y,/ !'" TGL X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F DT? IF?L?>D QGL?4

:+',9

0T? G>LK?F D5 P5DT ELL=?L EL >54

'QQ5FSE>U D5 -?QDE5> 7 5M DT?+,&(-.)!.&') 0"1'1-* +-!A ]oGpUFEQ=WD=FGW D?>G>QR EL DT?ITRLEQGW I5LL?LLE5> PR G I?FL5> 5M WG>S 2"3%!"2 !% ',&(-.)!.&" P?W5>UE>U D5A 5F

W?UGWWR I5LL?LL?S PRA G>5DT?F M5F DT? I=FI5L? 5M IF5S=QDE5> DTF5=UT DT? WGP5F 5M DT?

M5FN?F G>S 5M DT? N?NP?FL 5M TEL ENN?SEGD? MGFN T5=L?T5WSA E> Q5>LES?FGDE5> 5M

KTEQT DT? M5FN?F GUF??L D5 LTGF? DT? TGFH?LD KEDT DT? WGDD?FA 5F D5 IGR G IFEQ?Q?FDGE> 5F GLQ?FDGE>GPW?A ?EDT?F E> IF5S=Q? 5F E> N5>?RA 5F E> P5DT4] 0T? D?FN]GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>S] GL =>S?FLD55S PR DT?+,&(-.)!.&') 4'12 5"6% 7%2" EL >5D GL

PF5GS E> N?G>E>U GL ED EL _>5K> E> DT? Q5>LDED=DE5>GW L?>L?4 0T? ITFGL? ]GUFEQ=WD=FGW

WG>SA] Q5>LDED=DE5>GWWR LI?G_E>UA E>QW=S?L GWW WG>SL DTGD GF? >?EDT?F NE>?FGW >5FDENP?F WG>SL G>S ?NPFGQ?L KEDTE> EDL KES? LK??I >5D 5>WR WG>SL LDFEQDWR GUFEQ=WD=FGW

5F S?H5D?S D5 Q=WDEHGDE5> M5F GUFEQ=WD=FGW I=FI5L?L P=D GWL5 Q5NN?FQEGWA E>S=LDFEGWAF?LES?>DEGW WG>SL G>S WG>SL M5F 5DT?F I=FI5L?L4 ,> DT? 5DT?F TG>SA PR -?QDE5> 6``g6h


7/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

5M DT?+,&(-.)!.&') 4'12 5"6% 7%2"A] \oGpUFEQ=WD=FGW +G>S N?G>L WG>S 2"3%!"2 !%

'1* ,&%8!9A E>QW=SE>U P=D >5D WENED?S D5 QF5I WG>SLA LGWD P?SLA MELTI5>SLA ESW? WG>SG>S GPG>S5>?S WG>S GL S?ME>?S E> IGFGUFGITL 6@ G>S 6: 5M DTEL L?QDE5>A

F?LI?QDEH?WR4]

)D EL 5PHE5=L DT?> DTGD =>S?F DT? WGKA DT? WG>S T?F? E> Q5>DF5H?FLR S5?L >5D MED E>D5

DT? Q5>Q?ID 5M GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>S4 C/" QG>>5D S?H5D? ED D5 GUFEQ=WD=F? P?QG=L? PR EDL5K> QTGFD?FA "?I=PWEQ 'QD 68`A C/" QG>>5D ?>UGU? E> GUFEQ=WD=F?4

0T? ?>DEF? KESDT 5M 7B N?D?FL EL ENI5FDG>D D5 C/"\L FGEWF5GS 5I?FGDE5>L KTEQT

LT5=WS >5D P? TGNI?F?S4 '>SA Q5NN=>EQGDE5> WE>?L N=LD >5D P? SELD=FP?S4 3=EWSE>UL

LT5=WS >5D P? Q5>LDF=QD?S L5 QW5L? D5 DT? DFGQ_4 3?QG=L?A ED EL >5D L5 ?GLR D5 IF?H?>DI?5IW? MF5N KGW_E>U GW5>U DT? DFGQ_c G>ENGWLA D55A NGR LDFGR E>D5 DT? GF?Gc

5PLDF=QDE5>L DT?F? Q5=WS P? GW5>U DT? DFGQ_ EDL?WM KTEQT NEUTD QG=L? S?FGEWN?>D4 'WW5M DT?L? Q5=WS IF?H?>D DT? W5Q5N5DEH? ?>UE>??F MF5N DG_E>U DT? >?Q?LLGFR

IF?QG=DE5>L 5> DEN? D5 GH?FD GQQES?>DL KTEQT NGR QG=L? SGNGU? D5 DT? DFGE>LA E>X=FR

D5 EDL IGLL?>U?FLA G>S ?H?> W5LL 5M WEM?4

0T? =L? 5M DT? LDFEIL 5M WG>S 5> P5DT LES?L 5M DT? DFGQ_ E> FGEWF5GS 5I?FGDE5> ELE>Q5>LELD?>D KEDT GUFEQ=WD=FGW GQDEHEDE?L4 0T? Q5>DFGQD 5M W?GL? G=DT5FEJ?L DT? FGEWF5GS

Q5NIG>R D5 ?>D?F =I5> DT? IF?NEL?L D5 NG_? F?IGEFLA IWGQ? EDL NGD?FEGWL 5> DT? WG>S4

)D NGR ?H?> DG_? L5EW MF5N DT? WG>S D5 MEWW =I G>R IGFD 5M DT? FGEWF5GS DFGQ_ S?LDF5R?SPR KGD?F S=FE>U FGE>R SGRL4 YTGD EM C/" LT5=WS S?QES? D5 Q5>LDF=QD G>5DT?F IGFGWW?W

DFGQ_ 5> DT? WG>S W?GL?Se 0T? 5QQ=IG>D 5M DT? WG>S QG>>5D IF?H?>D 5F LD5I C/" MF5NS5E>U G>R 5M DT?L?4 -?Q=FEDR 5M D?>=F? L5 ENI5FDG>D E> WG>SW5FSOD?>G>D F?WGDE5>LTEI

NGR >5D DT=L P? GDDGE>?S4

)> G> ?X?QDN?>D L=ED PF5=UTD PR DT? WG>S5K>?F GUGE>LD LGES DTEFS I?FL5> E> DT? !'"A

DTEL !5=FD T?WS DTGD DT? !'" TGS >5 X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F DT? QGL? P?QG=L? >5 D?>G>QRF?WGDE5>LTEI ?ZELD?S P?DK??> DT? IGFDE?LA GL DT? DTEFS I?FL5> KGLA E> F?GWEDRA G>

=>WGKM=W L[=GDD?F 5F E>DF=S?F4 !5FF?WGDE>U :';.


8/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

2GRA 6:^8A T? L5=UTD D5 GQQ5NIWELT LGES F?UELDFGDE5> P=D KGL S?>E?S PR DT? F?UELD?F

5M S??SL 5M 2G>EWG 5> DT? UF5=>S DTGDA P?E>U G> GWE?>A T? QG>>5D GQ[=EF? WG>S E> DTELX=FELSEQDE5>4 qFEH?>_5 DT?> PF5=UTD DT? QGL? D5 DT? M5=FDT PFG>QT 5M DT? !5=FD 5M

fEFLD )>LDG>Q? 5M 2G>EWG PR N?G>L 5M G Q5>L=WDGA G>S DTGD Q5=FD F?>S?F?S X=SUN?>D

L=LDGE>E>U DT? F?M=LGW 5M DT? F?UELD?F 5M S??SL4

$**2+9

Y,/ G> GWE?> NGR 5K> IFEHGD? WG>SL E> DT? CTEWEIIE>?L4

:+',9

/54 ]C=PWEQ GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SL]r N?>DE5>?S E> -?Q4 6A 'FD4 l))) 5M DT? 6:78

!5>LDED=DE5>A E>QW=S? F?LES?>DEGWA Q5NN?FQEGW G>S E>S=LDFEGW WG>SLA DT? !5=FD LDGD?Sd

/GD=FGW F?L5=FQ?LA KEDT DT? ?ZQ?IDE5> 5M I=PWEQ GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SA LTGWW >5D P?GWE?>GD?SAs G>S KEDT F?LI?QD D5 I=PWEQ GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SLA DT?EF GWE?>GDE5> EL WENED?S D5

fEWEIE>5 QEDEJ?>L4 3=D DTEL Q5>LDED=DE5>GW I=FI5L? Q5>L?FHE>U GUFEQ=WD=FGW F?L5=FQ?LE> DT? TG>SL 5M fEWEIE>5 QEDEJ?>L NGR ?GLEWR P? S?M?GD?S PR DT? fEWEIE>5 QEDEJ?>L

DT?NL?WH?L KT5 NGR GWE?>GD? DT?EF GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SL E> MGH5F 5M GWE?>L4 0T=L -?QDE5>

8A 'FDEQW? l))) IF5HES?Ld -GH? E> QGL?L 5M T?F?SEDGFR L=QQ?LLE5>A >5 IFEHGD?GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>SL KEWW P? DFG>LM?FF?S 5F GLLEU>?S ?ZQ?ID D5 E>SEHES=GWLA Q5FI5FGDE5>L

5F GLL5QEGDE5>L [=GWEME?S D5 GQ[=EF? 5F T5WS WG>SL 5M DT? I=PWEQ S5NGE> E> DT?CTEWEIIE>?L4

N/ #0O!* P )0/I $%)/ 45/ )! 6 G>S EL DT? F?UELD?F?S 5K>?F 5MDTF?? TGQE?>SGLA >GN?WRA VGQE?>SGL CGWEQ5A 3G>EWGS G>S !GRWGKGRA GWW W5QGD?S E> DT?

2=>EQEIGWEDR 5M /GL=UP=A 3GDG>UGL4 0T? ?H?>DL 5M DTEL QGL? 5QQ=FF?S S=FE>U DT?E>Q=NP?>QR 5M DT?> CF?LES?>D !5FGJ5> !4 '[=E>5 KT5 ELL=?S CF5QWGNGDE5> /54 7

IF5N=WUGDE>U G CF5HELE5>GW !5>LDED=DE5>4 3?M5F? DT? WGKbL ?MM?QDEHEDRA I?DEDE5>?F MEW?S

KEDT F?LI5>S?>D &'" G H5W=>DGFR 5MM?F D5 L?WW VGQE?>SG !GRWGKGR I=FL=G>D D5 DT?IF5HELE5>L 5M *4,4 /54 99:4 VGQE?>SGL CGWEQ5 G>S 3G>EWGS K?F? WGD?F IWGQ?S =>S?F

Q5NI=WL5FR GQ[=ELEDE5> PR F?LI5>S?>D &'" E> GQQ5FSG>Q? KEDT DT? "?I=PWEQ 'QD /54

``8;A DT? !5NIF?T?>LEH? 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN +GK 5M 6:@@g!'"+h4

)> G W?DD?FA F?LI5>S?>D &'" -?QF?DGFR E>M5FN?S I?DEDE5>?F DTGD G F?QWGLLEMEQGDE5> 5MDT? WG>S K5=WS >5D ?Z?NID ED MF5N GUFGFEG> F?M5FN4 "?LI5>S?>D -?QF?DGFR GWL5

S?>E?S I?DEDE5>?FbL KEDTSFGKGW 5M DT? (5W=>DGFR ,MM?F D5 -?WW g(,-h 5> DT? UF5=>S

DTGD KEDTSFGKGW Q5=WS 5>WR P? PGL?S 5> LI?QEMEQ UF5=>SL L=QT GL =>L=EDGPEWEDR 5M DT?L5EW M5F GUFEQ=WD=F?A 5F EM DT? LW5I? 5M DT? WG>S EL 5H?F 6@ S?UF??L G>S DTGD DT? WG>S EL

=>S?H?W5I?S4 &?LIED? DT? S?>EGW 5M DT? (,- KEDTSFGKGW 5M VGQE?>SG !GRWGKGRAI?DEDE5>?F MEW?S EDL GIIWEQGDE5> M5F Q5>H?FLE5> 5M P5DT VGQE?>SGL CGWEQ5 G>S 3G>EWGS4


9/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

I?DEDE5>?FA DTF5=UT EDL CF?LES?>DA *S=GFS5 "5ZGLA F?ED?FGD?S EDL F?[=?LD D5 KEDTSFGK

DT? (,- 5H?F VGQE?>SG !GRWGKGR

C?DEDE5>?F E>LDED=D?S !GL? KEDT F?LI5>S?>D &'" 'SX=SEQGDE5> 35GFS g&'"'3h

IFGRE>U M5F DT? QG>Q?WWGDE5> 5M DT? !+,'bL ELL=?S PR F?LI5>S?>D &'" E> DT? >GN? 5ML?H?FGW I?FL5>L4 C?DEDE5>?F GWW?U?S DTGD DT? TGQE?>SGL TGS P??> S?QWGF?S G D5=FELD

J5>?A EL >5D L=EDGPW? M5F GUFEQ=WD=FGW IF5S=QDE5>4 &'"'3 T?WS DTGD DT? QGL? E>H5WH?SDT? IF?X=SEQEGW [=?LDE5> 5M KT?DT?F DT? IF5I?FDR KGL L=PX?QD D5 GUFGFEG> F?M5FNA

T?>Q?A DTEL [=?LDE5> LT5=WS P? L=PNEDD?S D5 DT? ,MMEQ? 5M DT? -?QF?DGFR 5M 'UFGFEG>

"?M5FN M5F S?D?FNE>GDE5>4 C?DEDE5>?F MEW?S KEDT DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL4 )D [=?LDE5>?SDT? ?ZIF5IFEGDE5> 5M EDL IF5I?FDE?L =>S?F DT? !'"+ G>S DT? S?>EGW 5M S=? IF5Q?LL E>

DT? GQ[=ELEDE5> 5M EDL WG>ST5WSE>UL4

2?G>KTEW?A DT? I?DEDE5> M5F Q5>H?FLE5> 5M DT? DTF?? TGQE?>SGL KGL S?>E?S PR DT?

2'",4 C?DEDE5>?FbL I?DEDE5> KGL SELNELL?S PR DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL4 C?DEDE5>?FN5H?S M5F F?Q5>LES?FGDE5> P=D DT? N5DE5> KGL S?>E?S PR Q5=FD 5M 'II?GWL4

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D DT? &'" 5PL?FH?L S=? IF5Q?LL 5M DT? IF5Q??SE>UL 5H?F DT? DTF??

TGQE?>SGL

:+',9

0T? GQ[=ELEDE5> IF5Q??SE>UL 5H?F DT? DTF?? TGQE?>SGL GF? >=WWEME?S M5F F?LI5>S?>D&'"\L MGEW=F? D5 5PL?FH? S=? IF5Q?LL DT?F?E>4 )> GQQ5FSG>Q? KEDT DT? U=ES?WE>?L L?D

M5FDT E> DTEL S?QELE5> G>S DT? GIIWEQGPW? GSNE>ELDFGDEH? IF5Q?S=F?A DT? QGL? EL T?F?PR

F?NG>S?S D5 F?LI5>S?>D &'" M5F IF5I?F GQ[=ELEDE5> IF5Q??SE>UL G>S S?D?FNE>GDE5>

5M I?DEDE5>?F\L GIIWEQGDE5> M5F Q5>H?FLE5>4 MGEW=F? 5M F?LI5>S?>D &'" D5 Q5NIWR KEDTDT? F?[=ELED?L 5M S=? IF5Q?LL E> DT? GQ[=ELEDE5> IF5Q??SE>UL S5?L >5D UEH? DTEL !5=FDDT? I5K?F D5 >=WWEMR DT? !+,'bL GWF?GSR ELL=?S D5 DT? MGFN?F P?>?MEQEGFE?L4 05

GLL=N? DT? I5K?F EL D5 LT5FDOQEFQ=ED DT? GSNE>ELDFGDEH? IF5Q?LLA KTEQT TGL R?D D5

F=> EDL F?U=WGF Q5=FL?4 "?LI5>S?>D &'" N=LD P? UEH?> DT? QTG>Q? D5 Q5FF?QD EDLIF5Q?S=FGW WGIL?L E> DT? GQ[=ELEDE5> IF5Q??SE>UL4 )> VGQE?>SG CGWEQ5 GW5>?A !+,'\L

K?F? ELL=?S D5 6;; MGFN?F P?>?MEQEGFE?L E> 6::74 -E>Q? DT?> =>DEW DT? IF?L?>DA DT?L?

MGFN?FL TGH? P??> Q=WDEHGDE>U DT?EF WG>SL4 )D U5?L GUGE>LD DT? PGLEQ IF?Q?IDL 5MX=LDEQ?A MGEF>?LL G>S ?[=EDR D5 S?IFEH? DT?L? I?5IW?A DTF5=UT >5 MG=WD 5M DT?EF 5K>A 5M

DT? WG>S DT?R DEWW4

H/ */ 0))$,+%-!' 6#0


10/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

IWG>DL4 ,QQES?>DGW QWGEN?S DTGD T? KGL G D?>G>D 5M DT? GQD=GW 5K>?F 5M DT? WG>SA

G 3GFGQWG>A G>S DTGD 25FDG G>S CGSEWWG K?F? >5D GQD=GWWR DT? 5K>?FL 5M DT?WG>S E> [=?LDE5>4 0T? DFEGW Q5=FD F=W?S E> MGH5F 5M 25FDG G>S CGSEWWG4 ,QQES?>DGWA ?D GW4

GII?GW?SA Q5>D?>SE>U DTGD DT? QGL? KGL Q5U>EJGPW? PR DT? &'" 'SX=SEQGD5FR 35GFS

g&'"'3h4 0T=LA DT? "0! F?H?FL?S DT? W5K?F Q5=FD G>S F=W?S E> MGH5F 5M ,QQES?>DGWALDGDE>U DTGD DT? QGL? EL G D?>G>QROF?WGD?S IF5PW?N KTEQT MGWWL =>S?F DT? ?ZQW=LEH?

X=FELSEQDE5> 5M &'"'34 0T? !' GMMEFN?S DT? "0!4

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D DT? QGL?L GF? IF5I?FWR Q5U>EJGPW? PR DT? &'"'34

:+',9

/,4 -E>Q? DT?F? EL G SELI=D? GL D5 KT5 EL DT? FEUTDM=W 5K>?F 5M DT? WG>SA DT? ELL=? ELQW?GFWR 5=DLES? &'"'3bL X=FELSEQDE5>4 YTGD?H?F ME>SE>UL NGS? PR DT? &'"'3

F?UGFSE>U DT? 5K>?FLTEI 5M DT? WG>S GF? >5D Q5>QW=LEH? D5 L?DDW? DT? NGDD?F4 'D G>RFGD?A KT5?H?F EL S?QWGF?S D5 P? DT? FEUTDM=W 5K>?F 5M DT? WG>SA DT? QGL? QG>>5D P?

Q5>LES?F?S D?>G>QROF?WGD?S M5F ED LDEWW MGEWL D5 Q5NIWR KEDT DT? 5DT?F F?[=EF?N?>DL4

'LL=NE>U GFU=?>S5 DTGD G EL DT? 5K>?FA DT?> DT? QGL? EL >5D P?DK??> DT?WG>S5K>?F G>S D?>G>D4 )MA T5K?H?FA 25FDG EL DT? WG>S5K>?FA ,QQES?>DGW QG>>5D QWGEN

DTGD DT?F? EL Q5>L?>D D5 G WG>S5K>?FOD?>G>D F?WGDE5>LTEI P?DK??> TEN G>S 25FDG40T=LA M5F MGEW=F? D5 Q5NIWR KEDT DT? F?[=ELED?LA DT? ELL=? E>H5WH?S EL >5D D?>G>QRO

F?WGD?S Q5U>EJGPW? PR DT? &'"'34

f5F &'"'3 D5 TGH? X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F G QGL?A DT?F? N=LD ?ZELD G D?>G>QR F?WGDE5>LTEI

P?DK??> DT? IGFDE?L4 )> 5FS?F M5F G D?>G>QR GUF??N?>D D5 DG_? T5WS 5H?F G SELI=D?A ED

K5=WS P? ?LL?>DEGW D5 ?LDGPWELT GWW EDL E>SELI?>LGPW? ?W?N?>DLA D5 KEDd

64 0TGD DT? IGFDE?L GF? DT? WG>S5K>?F G>S DT? D?>G>D 5F GUFEQ=WD=FGW W?LL??c94 0T? L=PX?QD NGDD?F 5M DT? F?WGDE5>LTEI EL G> GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>Sc

74 0TGD DT?F? EL Q5>L?>D P?DK??> DT? IGFDE?L D5 DT? F?WGDE5>LTEIc

^4 0TGD DT? I=FI5L? 5M DT? F?WGDE5>LTEI EL D5 PFE>U GP5=D GUFEQ=WD=FGWIF5S=QDE5>c

84 0TGD DT?F? EL I?FL5>GW Q=WDEHGDE5> 5> DT? IGFD 5M DT? D?>G>D 5F GUFEQ=WD=FGW

W?LL??c G>S`4 0TGD DT? TGFH?LD EL LTGF?S P?DK??> DT? WG>S5K>?F G>S DT? D?>G>D 5F

GUFEQ=WD=FGW W?LL??4

.C/ >,! ,+ -!%"2= 45/ )! 6-$=2#)$07#&q /,4 :@`^

&?Q?NP?F 7A 6::B

8!)-*9

"=ME>G 0G>U=P G>S T?F T=LPG>SA '>SF?LA >5K S?Q?GL?SA MEW?S KEDT DT? "0! 5M +G>G5S?W /5FD?A G> GUFGFEG> QGL? M5F SGNGU?L PR F?GL5> 5M DT?EF =>WGKM=W SELI5LL?LLE5> E>

KTEQT DT?R K?F? D?>G>DL MF5N DT? WG>ST5WSE>U 5K>?S PR DT? -I5=L?L &5NE>U5 G>S


11/22


12/22


13/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

FEUTD 5M F?S?NIDE5>4j

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D DT? I?DEDE5>?FL K?F? D?>G>DL 5M DT? "5N?F5 LI5=L?L gF?LI5>S?>DLh

GL D5 ?>DEDW? DT?N D5 DT? FEUTD 5M F?S?NIDE5>4

:+',9

0T? Q5=FD GMMEFN?S DT? S?QELE5> 5M C'"'34 0T? C'"'3 S?QWGF?S DT? I?DEDE5>?FL D5 P?

D?>G>DL 5> DT? PGLEL 5M DT? M5WW5KE>U ?HES?>Q?d

Gh Q?FDEMEQGDE5> 5M 9@ I?FL5>L D5 DT? ?MM?QD DTGD LI5=L?L ED? TGS P??> K5F_E>U 5>

DT? WG>S GL D?>G>DLc

Ph E> DT? S??S 5M GPL5W=D? LGW? LEU>?S PR *SEWP?FD5 "5N?F5 GL H?>S5FA T? LDGD?S DTGDLI5=L?L ED? K?F? TEL D?>G>DLc

Qh DT? LI5=L?L ED? TGS P??> E> I5LL?LLE5> G>S Q=WDEHGDE>U DT? WG>S LE>Q? 6:`:4

YEDT5=D G>R ?HES?>Q? D5 L=II5FD EDL ME>SE>UA DT? &'"'3 F?H?FL?S DT? ME>SE>U 5M DT?

C'"'3 G>S M5=>S DTGD I?DEDE5>?F ED?L K?F? >5D D?>G>DL P?QG=L? DT?R MGEW?S D5L=PNED ?HES?>Q? DTGD DT?R K?F? LTGFE>U DT? TGFH?LDL 5M DT? KEDT DT? WG>S5K>?FLA

F?LI5>S?>D "5N?F5 LI5=L?L4 -! GUF??S KEDT DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL DTGD DT? ?LL?>DEGWF?[=ELED?L 5M G D?>G>QR F?WGDE5>LTEI GF?d

g6h DT? IGFDE?L GF? DT? WG>S5K>?F G>S DT? D?>G>Dc

g9h DT? L=PX?QD EL GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>Scg7h DT?F? EL Q5>L?>Dc

g^h DT? I=FI5L? EL GUFEQ=WD=FGW IF5S=QDE5>c

g8h DT?F? EL I?FL5>GW Q=WDEHGDE5>c G>S

g`h DT?F? EL LTGFE>U 5M TGFH?LDL4

'WW DT?L? F?[=ELED?L N=LD Q5>Q=F E> 5FS?F D5 QF?GD? G D?>G>QR F?WGDE5>LTEI P?DK??>

DT? IGFDE?L4 0T? GPL?>Q? 5M 5>? S5?L >5D NG_? G> 5QQ=IG>D 5M G IGFQ?W 5M WG>SA 5F G

Q=WDEHGD5F DT?F?5MA 5F G IWG>D?F DT?F?5>A G 2" A.&"D?>G>D4 #>W?LL G I?FL5> TGL?LDGPWELT?S TEL LDGD=L GL G 2"A.&"D?>G>DA T? EL >5D ?>DEDW?S D5 L?Q=FEDR 5M D?>=F? >5F EL

T? Q5H?F?S PR DT? +G>S "?M5FN CF5UFGN 5M DT? U5H?F>N?>D =>S?F ?ZELDE>U D?>G>QR

WGKL4

3=D >5D? DTGD MF5N DT? DEN? 5M DT? WG>S5K>?FLb GSNELLE5> DTGD I?DEDE5>?FL K?F?D?>G>DL 5> DT? L=PX?QD WG>ST5WSE>UA DT? ?W?N?>D 5M iLTGFE>U TGFH?LDj EL GLL=N?S GL G

MGQD=GW ?W?N?>D E> DTGD GSNELLE5>4

.;/ :0%/ !%-0%$0 2GR 98A 6:;9A DT?> -?QF?DGFR 5M 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN ELL=?S G> i,FS?F 5M 'KGFSj E>MGH5F 5M S E> 3=?>GHELDG *LDGD?A


14/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

-G> )WS?M5>L5A 3=WGQG>A Q5H?FE>U 6Â^:` G>S 6:A@B@ L[=GF? N?D?FLA F?LI?QDEH?WRA

=>S?F DT? M5WW5KE>U Q5>SEDE5>Ld- YEDTE> ` N5>DTLA T? LTGWW I?FL5>GWWR Q=WDEHGD? GD W?GLD t 5M DT? GF?Gc 5F

- ,QQ=IR G>S Q5>LDF=QD TELuT?F T5=L? E> QGL? 5M F?LES?>DEGW W5D G>S IGR GD W?GLD

DT? MEFLD E>LDGWWN?>D

)> >5 QGL? LTGWW G> GUF??N?>D D5 L?WW 5F S??S 5M LGW? P? ELL=?S E> MGH5F 5M DT?

Q5H?FE>U DT? W5DL KEDT5=D G Q?FDEMEQGDE5> ELL=?S PR DT? +G>S "?M5FN CF5X?QD 0?GN

+?GS?F 5M +G>S -?DDW?N?>D -=I?FE>D?>S?>D DTGD DT? GKGFS??gLh TGLuTGH? S?H?W5I?S5F S?H5D?S D5 L5N? IF5S=QDEH? ?>D?FIFEL? GD W?GLD 5>?OTGWM 5M DT? GF?G DT?F?5MA 5F

Q5>LDF=QD?S TELuT?FuDT?EF T5=L? DT?F?E> E> QGL? 5M F?LES?>DEGW WG>S4

'MD?F DK?>DRO5>? R?GFLA IFEHGD? F?LI5>S?>D MEW?S G> GIIWEQGDE5> KEDT DT? "?UE5>GW

,MMEQ? 5M DT? &?IGFDN?>D 5M 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN M5F DT? I=FQTGL? 5M LGES W5DL QWGENE>UDTGD T? TGS Q5NIWE?S KEDT DT? Q5>SEDE5>L L?D M5FDT E> DT? ,FS?F4 "?LDED=D5 "EH?FGA

T?F?E> I?DEDE5>?FA MEW?S G W?DD?F 5M IF5D?LD GUGE>LD IFEHGD? F?LI5>S?>D QWGENE>U DTGDQ5>DFGFR D5 DT? NG>EM?LDGDE5> 5M IFEHGD? F?LI5>S?>DA ED EL I?DEDE5>?F KT5 TGS P??> E>

I5LL?LLE5> 5M DT? WG>S G>S TGS P??> Q=WDEHGDE>U DT? LGN?4 C?DEDE5>?F TGS MEW?S TEL

5K> GIIWEQGDE5> M5F LGES IGFQ?WL E> 5II5LEDE5> D5 DTGD 5M IFEHGD? F?LI5>S?>D4

,> &?Q?NP?F 9;A 6::7A G F?IF?L?>DGDEH? 5M DT? &?IGFDN?>D 5M 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN"?UE5>GW ,MMEQ? =>S?FD55_ G> E>H?LDEUGDE5> G>S M5=>S DTGD DT? L=PX?QD W5DL K?F?

IF?HE5=LWR D?>G>D?S PR 5DT?F I?FL5>L G>S ED EL QW?GF DTGD S Q5>SEDE5>L 5M DT? ,FS?F 5M 'KGFS ELL=?S E> TEL MGH5F4

,> =GFR 9Â 6::Â I?DEDE5>?FA DT? "?UE5>GW &EF?QD5F 5M &'"A '>D5>E5 24 /=?LGA

IF5N=WUGD?S G> ,FS?FA QG>Q?WWE>U ,FS?F 5M 'KGFS ELL=?S E> MGH5F 5M S UEHE>U "?LDED=D5 "EH?FG DT? 5II5FD=>EDR D5 I=FQTGL? LGES W5DL4

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL ?FF?S E> S?>RE>U I?DEDE5>?FLb QWGEN DTGD E> DTEL

QGL?A DT? 35GFS g&'"'3h GQD?S E> UFGH? GP=L? 5M SELQF?DE5> DG>DGN5=>D D5 WGQ_ 5F?ZQ?LL 5M EDL X=FELSEQDE5>

:+',9

a?L DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL ?FF?S E> T5WSE>U DTGD DT? &'"'3 G>S EDL 5MMEQEGWL TGH? >5D

Q5NNEDD?S UFGH? GP=L? 5M SELQF?DE5> DG>DGN5=>D D5 ?ZQ?LL 5F WGQ_ 5M X=FELSEQDE5>4

0T? QGL? E>H5WH?L DT? LDFEQD GSNE>ELDFGDEH? ENIW?N?>DGDE5> G>S GKGFS 5M W5DL4 0T?NGDD?F MGWWL =>S?F DT? ?ZQW=LEH? X=FELSEQDE5> G>S GSNE>ELDFGDEH? Q5NI?D?>Q? 5M DT?

&'" g"?UE5>GW &EF?QD5F G>S &?IGFDN?>D -?QF?DGFRh G>S >5D 5M DT? &'"'3 gE>QW=SE>UDT? CF5HE>QEGW 'SX=SEQGD5F G>S DT? CF5HE>QEGW 'SX=SEQGDE5> 35GFS EDL?WMh4

7"1!"1% 3 7"1!"1%A iDT? &'" EL H?LD?S KEDT DT? IFENGFR X=FELSEQDE5> D5 S?D?FNE>?G>S GSX=SEQGD? GUFGFEG> F?M5FN NGDD?FL G>S LTGWW TGH? DT? ?ZQW=LEH? X=FELSEQDE5>

5H?F GWW NGDD?FL E>H5WHE>U DT? ENIW?N?>DGDE5> 5M DT? GUFGFEG> F?M5FN IF5UFGN4j 0T?


15/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

&'"'3 TGL IFENGFRA 5FEUE>GW G>S GII?WWGD? X=FELSEQDE5> iD5 S?D?FNE>? G>S

GSX=SEQGD? GWW ',&'&('1 2(S?F "4'4 ``8;A *4,4 /5L4 99:A 99@ G>S 69:O'A "4'4 7@^^ GL GN?>S?S PR "4'4 `7@:A

C4&4 /54 9; G>S 5DT?F GUFGFEG> WGKL G>S DT?EF ENIW?N?>DE>U F=W?L G>S F?U=WGDE5>L4j

#>S?F -?QDE5> 7gSh 5M "4'4 ``8; g!'"C +GKhA iGUFGFEG> SELI=D?j EL S?ME>?S D5 E>QW=S?igSh 444G>R Q5>DF5H?FLR F?WGDE>U D5 D?>=FEGW GFFG>U?N?>DLA KT?DT?F W?GL?T5WSA

D?>G>QRA LD?KGFSLTEI 5F 5DT?FKEL? 5H?F WG>SL S?H5D?S D5 GUFEQ=WD=F?A E>QW=SE>U

SELI=D?L Q5>Q?F>E>U MGFNK5F_?FL GLL5QEGDE5>L 5F F?IF?L?>DGDE5> 5M I?FL5>L E>>?U5DEGDE>UA MEZE>UA NGE>DGE>E>UA QTG>UE>U 5F L??_E>U D5 GFFG>U? D?FNL 5F Q5>SEDE5>L

5M L=QT D?>=FEGW GFFG>U?N?>DL4 )D E>QW=S?L G>R Q5>DF5H?FLR F?WGDE>U D5 Q5NI?>LGDE5>

5M WG>SL GQ[=EF?S =>S?F DTEL 'QD G>S 5DT?F D?FNL G>S Q5>SEDE5>L 5M DFG>LM?F 5M5K>?FLTEI MF5N WG>S5K>?FL D5 MGFNK5F_?FLA D?>G>DL G>S 5DT?F GUFGFEG> F?M5FN

P?>?MEQEGFE?LA KT?DT?F DT? SELI=DG>DL LDG>S E> DT? IF5ZENGD? F?WGDE5> 5M MGFN5I?FGD5F G>S P?>?MEQEGFRA WG>S5K>?F G>S D?>G>DA 5F W?LL5F G>S W?LL??4j

.?/ !'S

W5QGD?S GD -G> (EQ?>D?A '>UGSG>G>A )LGP?WG PR DT? DT?> /GDE5>GW "?L?DDW?N?>D G>S"?TGPEWEDGDE5> 'SNE>ELDFGDE5> g/'""'h 5> 2GFQT 98A 6:8;4 -E>Q? DT?>A 'WN=?D? G>S

TEL MGNEWR MGFN?S DT? L=PX?QD IF5I?FDR I?GQ?M=WWR G>S ?ZQW=LEH?WR4 V5K?H?FA

=>_>5K> D5 I?DEDE5>?FA G> 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN 0?QT>5W5UELD PR DT? >GN? 5M +?DEQEG1FGUGLE> 5> '=U=LD 6;A 6:;: MEW?S MGWL? F?I5FDL NG_E>U ED GII?GF DTGD 'WN=?D? TGL

KGEH?S TEL FEUTD GL GKGFS?? G>S NGS? ED GII?GF DTGD 5>? 2GFQ?W5 '>SF?L KGL DT?

GQD=GW 5QQ=IG>D 5M DT? WG>S MF5N 6:`; D5 SGD?4

!5>L?[=?>DWRA &'" ELL=?S ,!0 /54 CO89896 E> DT? >GN? 5M F?LI5>S?>D KT5A E> D=F>A

GQQ5NIG>E?S PR D?> I?FL5>L GFN?S KEDT P5W5LA ENN?SEGD?WR ?>D?F?S DT? L=PX?QD

IF5I?FDR QWGENE>U ?ZQW=LEH? FEUTD 5M 5K>?FLTEI G>S I5LL?LLE5>4 'WN=?D? Q5NIWGE>?SD5 DT? &'" G>S KGLD?S >5 DEN? E> MEWE>U G> GQDE5> M5F F?Q5>H?RG>Q? G>S F?Q5H?FR 5M

I5LL?LLE5> GUGE>LD 2GFQ?W5 '>SF?L KEDT DT? "0! 5M !G=GRG>A )LGP?WG4 0T? 0FEGW !5=FD

F?>S?F?S G &?QELE5> E> MGH5F 5M 'WN=?D? KTEQT P?QGN? ME>GW G>S ?Z?Q=D5FR =I5>

2GFQ?W5 '>SF?L\L MGEW=F? D5 GII?GW4 0T? WGDD?F MEW?S G I?DEDE5> M5F Q?FDE5FGFE D5IF?H?>D DT? ENIW?N?>DGDE5> 5M DT? KFED 5M ?Z?Q=DE5> KTEQT KGL ?>D?FDGE>?S PR DT?!5=FD 5M 'II?GWL4 V?>Q?A DTEL C?DEDE5>4

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D DTEL QGL? EL Q5>LES?F?S G> GUFGFEG> SELI=D?4

YT?DT?F 5F >5D F?U=WGF Q5=FDL TGH? X=FELSEQDE5>4


16/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

:+',9

0T? -=IF?N? !5=FD F?H?FL?S DT? S?QELE5> 5M DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL G>S LGES DTGDEDUFGH?WR ?FF?S KT?> ED UFG>D?S DT? I?DEDE5> M5F Q?FDE5FGFE G>S T?WS DTGD DT? DFEGW Q5=FD

TGS >5 X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F DT? L=PX?QD NGDD?F 5M DT? GQDE5> P?DK??> I?DEDE5>?FL G>S

F?LI5>S?>D4 0T? GQDE5> MEW?S PR I?DEDE5>?FL KGL Q5U>EJGPW? PR DT? F?U=WGF Q5=FDL40T? -=IF?N? !5=FD T?WS DTGD DTEL QGL? EL >5D 5M G> GUFGFEG> SELI=D?4 '> GUFGFEG>

SELI=D? EL F?M?FL D5 G>R Q5>DF5H?FLR F?WGDE>U D5 D?>=FEGW GFFG>U?N?>DLA KT?DT?FW?GL?T5WSA D?>G>QRA LD?KGFSLTEI 5F 5DT?FKEL?A 5H?F WG>SL S?H5D?S D5 GUFEQ=WD=F?A

E>QW=SE>U SELI=D?L Q5>Q?F>E>U MGFN K5F_?FL GLL5QEGDE5>L 5F F?IF?L?>DGDE5> 5M

I?FL5>L E> >?U5DEGDE>UA MEZE>UA NGE>DGE>E>UA QTG>UE>U 5F L??_E>U D5 GFFG>U? D?FNL 5FQ5>SEDE5>L 5M L=QT D?>=FEGW GFFG>U?N?>DL4 )D E>QW=S?L G>R Q5>DF5H?FLR F?WGDE>U D5

Q5NI?>LGDE5> 5M WG>SL GQ[=EF?S =>S?F DTEL 'QD G>S 5DT?F D?FNL G>S Q5>SEDE5>L 5M

DFG>LM?F 5M 5K>?FLTEI MF5N WG>S5K>?FL D5 MGFNK5F_?FLA D?>G>DL G>S 5DT?F GUFGFEG>F?M5FN P?>?MEQEGFE?LA KT?DT?F DT? SELI=DG>DL LDG>S E> DT? IF5ZENGD? F?WGDE5> 5M MGFN

5I?FGD5F G>S P?>?MEQEGFRA WG>S5K>?F G>S D?>G>DA 5F W?LL5F G>S W?LL??4

)> DTEL QGL? >5 X=FESEQGW DE? 5M WG>S5K>?F G>S D?>G>D KGL GWW?U?S P?DK??> I?DEDE5>?FL

G>S F?LI5>S?>DA W?D GW5>? DTGD KTEQT K5=WS L5 QTGFGQD?FEJ? DT? F?WGDE5>LTEI GL G>GUFGFEG> SELI=D?4 )> MGQDA I?DEDE5>?F G>S F?LI5>S?>D K?F? Q5>D?>SE>U IGFDE?L M5F DT?

5K>?FLTEI 5M DT? LGN? IGFQ?W 5M WG>S4 0T? GQDE5> MEW?S PR I?DEDE5>?FL P?M5F? DT? DFEGWQ5=FD KGL M5F F?Q5H?FR 5M I5LL?LLE5> G>S F?Q5>H?RG>Q? 5M DEDW?d DT?F? EL >5 ]GUFGFEG>

SELI=D?] E>H5WHE>U D?>G>QR F?WGDE5>LTEI P?DK??> DT? IGFDE?L DTGD DT? ELL=? LT5=WS

MGWW KEDTE> DT? X=FELSEQDE5> 5M DT? &'"'34

.J/ *102*+* !-2+' +- !' 45/ *102*+* >!',+3 6"!-!)+'0714"4 /54 67:8`6

? 6BA 9BB7

8!)-*9

"?LI5>S?>DL MEW?S G Q5NIWGE>D M5F F?Q5H?FR 5M I5LL?LLE5> KEDT SGNGU?L KEDT DT?

&?IGFDN?>D 5M 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN 'SX=SEQGDE5> 35GFS g&'"'3h E> 2GWGRPGWGRA3=_ES>5>4 0T?R GLLGEW?S DT? S?QELE5> 5M DT? 2=>EQEIGW 'UFGFEG> "?M5FN ,MMEQ?

g2'",h KTEQT 5FS?F?S DT? L?UF?UGDE5> 5M DT? L=PX?QD W5D MF5N DT? WG>S 5M

F?LI5>S?>DL G>S GKGFSE>U DT? LGN? D5 I?DEDE5>?FL4 0T? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL GMMEFN?SDT? S?QELE5> 5M DT? &'"'3 KTEQT F?H?FL?S DT? S?QELE5> 5M DT? 2'",4 'MD?F G F?HE?K

5M DT? ELL=?L FGEL?SA DT? [=?LDE5> EL KT?DT?F DT? &'"'3 TGL X=FELSEQDE5> D5 F?L5WH?

DT? Q5>DF5H?FLR4

$**2+9

Y,/ &'"'3 TGL X=FELSEQDE5> D5 DFR G>S T?GF DTEL QGL?4

:+',9

/54 0T? -=IF?N? !5=FD F=W?S DTGD DT? &'"'3 TGL >5 X=FELSEQDE5> D5 DG_? Q5U>EJG>Q?

5M DT? F?LI5>S?>DL\ Q5NIWGE>D M5F F?Q5H?FR 5M I5LL?LLE5> 5M DT? L=PX?QD W5D4 0T5=UT

DT? IGFDE?L SES >5D QTGWW?>U? DT? X=FELSEQDE5> 5M DT? &'"'3A DT? !5=FD NGR N5D=


17/22


18/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

$**2+9

YT?DT?F 5F >5D DT? I?DEDE5>?FL P? I?FNEDD?S D5 ENI=U> M5F DT? MEFLD DEN? DT?X=FELSEQDE5> 5M DT? CF5HE>QEGW 'SX=SEQGD5F GD DTEL LDGU? 5M DT? QGL?e

:+',90T? K?WWO?>DF?>QT?S F=W? EL DTGD X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F DT? L=PX?QD NGDD?F EL S?D?FNE>?S

?ZQW=LEH?WR PR DT? !5>LDED=DE5> G>S DT? WGK4 )D QG>>5D P? Q5>M?FF?S PR DT? H5W=>DGFRGQD 5F GUF??N?>D 5M DT? IGFDE?Lc ED QG>>5D P? GQ[=EF?S DTF5=UTA 5F KGEH?S 5F

?>WGFU?S 5F SENE>ELT?S PRA DT?EF GQD 5F 5NELLE5>c >?EDT?F EL ED Q5>M?FF?S PR

GQ[=E?LQ?>Q? 5M DT? Q5=FD4 Y?WW D5 ?NITGLEJ?A ED EL >?EDT?F M5F DT? Q5=FDL >5F DT?IGFDE?L D5 HE5WGD? 5F SELF?UGFS DT? F=W?A DTEL NGDD?F P?E>U W?UELWGDEH? E> QTGFGQD?F4

'> ?FF5F E> X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F DT? L=PX?QD NGDD?F QG> P? 5PX?QD?S D5 GD G>R E>LDG>Q?A GL

DT? WGQ_ 5M ED GMM?QDL DT? H?FR G=DT5FEDR 5M DT? Q5=FD D5 DG_? Q5U>EJG>Q? 5M DT? GQDE5>40TEL _E>S 5M S?M?>L? QG> P? E>H5_?S ?H?> M5F DT? MEFLD DEN? 5> GII?GW 5F GMD?F ME>GW

X=SUN?>D4 -=QT EL =>S?FLDG>SGPW? GL DTEL _E>S 5M X=FELSEQDE5>A D5 LDF?LLA EL LDGD=D5FEWRS?D?FNE>?S40TEL F=W? 5> DENE>UA T5K?H?FA EL >5D GPL5W=D?4 )> TEUTWR N?FED5FE5=L G>S

?ZQ?IDE5>GW QEFQ=NLDG>Q?LA ?LD5II?W 5F KGEH?F NGR 5I?FGD? GL G LTE?WS D5 IF?H?>D G

IGFDR MF5N P?WGD?SWR F?L5FDE>U D5 DTEL M5FN 5M S?M?>L?4 0T=LA K? TGH? T?WS E> DT?W?GSE>U QGL? 5M 0EXGN H4 -EP5>UTG>5R DTGD G IGFDR NGR P? PGFF?S PR ?LD5II?W PR

WGQT?L MF5N E>H5_E>U DTEL IW?G M5F DT? MEFLD DEN? 5> GII?GW M5F DT? I=FI5L? 5MG>>=WWE>U ?H?FRDTE>U S5>? E> DT? QGL? KEDT DT? GQDEH? IGFDEQEIGDE5> 5M LGES IGFDR

E>H5_E>U DT? IW?G4 Y? S?ME>?S WGQT?L GL B6'().&" %& 1",)"-! 6%& '1 .1&"' H! (< 1",)(,"1-" %& %#(R LDGU? 5M DT? IF5Q??SE>Ud KT?DT?F E> DT? CF5HE>QEGW,MMEQ? W?H?WA DT? &'"'3A 5F DT? !5=FD 5M 'II?GWL4 /5DKEDTLDG>SE>U DT? IF?L?>Q? 5M

>=N?F5=L 5II5FD=>EDE?L E> DT? HGFE5=L LDGU?L 5M DTEL QGL? D5 Q5>D?LD DT?

GSX=SEQGD5F\L ?Z?FQEL? 5M X=FELSEQDE5>A >5D 5>Q? SES DT?R F?UELD?F G TE>D 5M IF5D?LD4/?EDT?F QG> DT?R QWGEN DTGD DT?R K?F? IF?H?>D?S MF5N Q5>D?LDE>U EDL X=FELSEQDE5>

S=FE>U DT? ?EUTD R?GFL DTEL QGL? KGL =>S?F WEDEUGDE5>4

0T? ?>SL 5M X=LDEQ? G>S ?[=EDR F?[=EF? DTGD I?DEDE5>?FL LT5=WS >5D P? GWW5K?S D5S?M?GD DT? D?>G>D\L FEUTD PR P?WGD?SWR FGELE>U DT? ELL=? 5M X=FELSEQDE5>4 C?FNEDDE>U

I?DEDE5>?FL D5 GLLGEW DT? X=FELSEQDE5> 5M DT? CF5HE>QEGW 'SX=SEQGD5F GD DTEL WGD? LDGU? 5M

DT? QGL? K5=WS N?G> F?>S?FE>U =L?W?LL GWW DT? IF5Q??SE>UL T?WS P?W5K4 ' UF?GD S?GW5M DEN?A ?MM5FD G>S F?L5=FQ?L K5=WS P? I=D D5 KGLD? P5DT 5> DT? IGFD 5M DT? WEDEUG>DL

G>S 5M DT? -DGD?4 0TEL EL ?LI?QEGWWR 5IIF?LLEH? M5F DT? F?LI5>S?>DA G D?>G>D KT5QG>>5D GMM5FS DT? SELQ5NM5FDL 5M G IF5DFGQD?S WEDEUGDE5>4


19/22


20/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

GN?>S?S PR "?I=PWEQ 'QD /54 `7@:A CF?LES?>DEGW &?QF?? /54 9; G>S 5DT?F GUFGFEG>

WGKL G>S DT?EF ENIW?N?>DE>U F=W?L G>S F?U=WGDE5>L4

'> GUFGFEG> SELI=D? F?M?FL D5 G>R Q5>DF5H?FLR F?WGDE>U D5 D?>=FEGW GFFG>U?N?>DLAKT?DT?F W?GL?T5WSA D?>G>QRA LD?KGFSLTEI 5F 5DT?FKEL?A 5H?F WG>SL S?H5D?S D5

GUFEQ=WD=F?A E>QW=SE>U SELI=D?L Q5>Q?F>E>U MGFNK5F_?FL GLL5QEGDE5>L 5F

F?IF?L?>DGDE5> 5M I?FL5>L E> >?U5DEGDE>UA MEZE>UA NGE>DGE>E>UA QTG>UE>U 5F L??_E>U D5GFFG>U? D?FNL 5F Q5>SEDE5>L 5M L=QT D?>=FEGW GFFG>U?N?>DL4 )D E>QW=S?L G>R

Q5>DF5H?FLR F?WGDE>U D5 Q5NI?>LGDE5> 5M WG>SL GQ[=EF?S =>S?F "?I=PWEQ 'QD /54``8; G>S 5DT?F D?FNL G>S Q5>SEDE5>L 5M DFG>LM?F 5M 5K>?FLTEI MF5N WG>S5K>?FL D5

MGFNK5F_?FLA D?>G>DL G>S 5DT?F GUFGFEG> F?M5FN P?>?MEQEGFE?LA KT?DT?F DT?

SELI=DG>DL LDG>S E> DT? IF5ZENGD? F?WGDE5> 5M MGFN 5I?FGD5F G>S P?>?MEQEGFRAWG>S5K>?F G>S D?>G>DA 5F W?LL5F G>S W?LL??4

)D EL EFF?M=DGPW? (1 !9" -'?L GUFEQ=WD=FGW GQDEHEDR GL DT? Q=WDEHGDE5> 5M DT? L5EWA IWG>DE>U 5M QF5ILA UF5KE>U

5M MF=ED DF??LA FGELE>U 5M WEH?LD5Q_A I5=WDFR 5F MELTA E>QW=SE>U DT? TGFH?LDE>U 5M L=QT

MGFN IF5S=QDLA G>S 5DT?F MGFN GQDEHEDE?LA G>S IFGQDEQ?L I?FM5FN?S PR G MGFN?F E>Q5>X=>QDE5> KEDT L=QT MGFNE>U 5I?FGDE5>L S5>? PR I?FL5>L KT?DT?F >GD=FGW 5F

X=FESEQGW4

3=D G QGL? E>H5WHE>U G> GUFEQ=WD=FGW WG>S S5?L >5D G=D5NGDEQGWWR NG_? L=QT QGL? G>

GUFGFEG> SELI=D? =I5> KTEQT DT? &'"'3 TGL X=FELSEQDE5>4 0T? N?F? MGQD DTGD DT? WG>SEL GUFEQ=WD=FGW S5?L >5D ($


21/22


22/22

!"#!#$!% '!( )!*+ ,$"+*-*

!"#$%&'()&%&*+,- -'/0,-%1'0'!*+,%)-2'*+%+'$'",2*&)/'%2,/0*-%2,/$,/%",2'/,%0)3#"!),

Y,/ DTGD DT? IWGE>DEMMbL E>X=>QDE5> P5>S KGL GIIF5H?S PR F?LI5>S?>D U G Q5IR D5 DT? Q5NIWGE>G>D G>S DT? N5DE5> 5M ELL=G>Q? 5M L?EJ=F? 5FS?FKGL >5D L?FH?S F?L=WDE>U E> G HE5WGDE5> 5M S=? IF5Q?LL4

Y,/ DT? Q5NIWGE>G>DL K?F? 5FS?F?S D5 W?GH? DT? WG>S P?QG=L? DT?R KEWW Q?FDGE>WRW5L? DT? QGL?

Y,/ DT? LT?FEMM L?EJ?S GWW DT? IGWGR TGFH?LD?S KEDT5=D ELL=E>U G F?Q?EIDA S?LIED?

S?NG>S DT?F?M5FA G>S S?WEH?F?S DT? IGWGR D5 DT? IWGE>DEMM4

:+',9

0T? QGL? KGL SELNELL?S4 0T? Q5=FD T?WS DTGD ED EL G PGLEQ F=W? DTGD DT? NGD?FEGW

GH?FN?>DL E> DT? Q5NIWGE>DA KTEQT E> DTEL QGL? EL M5F ?X?QDN?>DA S?D?FNE>? DT?X=FELSEQDE5> 5M DT? Q5=FD4 '>SA X=FELIF=S?>Q? SEQDGD?L DTGD DT? Q5=FD S5?L >5D W5L? EDL

X=FELSEQDE5> 5H?F G> ?X?QDN?>D QGL? PR DT? LENIW? ?ZI?SE?>D 5M G IGFDR FGELE>U GL GS?M?>L? DT?F?E> DT? GWW?U?S ?ZELD?>Q? 5M G D?>G>QR F?WGDE5>LTEI P?DK??> DT? IGFDE?L4j

)D EL DT? S=DR 5M DT? Q5=FD D5 F?Q?EH? ?HES?>Q? D5 S?D?FNE>? DT? H?FGQEDR 5M GWW?UGDE5>L

5M D?>G>QR4 )> G> ,FS?F 5M F?LI5>S?>D LES?FE>U DT? ?HES?>Q? IF?L?>D?SA DT? WG>S E> [=?LDE5> EL G> EFFEUGD?S

FEQ?WG>SA P=D >5D D?>G>D?S4

0T? F?Q5FSL P?WE? DT? QWGEN 5M Q5NIWGE>G>D DTGD DT? YFED 5M CF?WENE>GFR )>X=>QDE5>

KGL >5D L?FH?S D5 DT? S?M?>SG>DL4 "?Q5FSL LT5K DTGD LGES KFED KGL L?FH?S D5 DT?S?M?>SG>DL 5> f?PF=GFR 6`A 6::` GD DT?EF F?LES?>Q? P=D GWW F?M=L?S D5 GQ_>5KW?SU?

F?Q?EID DT?F?M5F?A >?H?FDT?W?LL DT? ?Z?Q=DE>U -T?FEMM W?MD ?GQT G Q5IR D5 DT?

S?M?>SG>DL4

'L D5 DT? GWW?UGDE5> DTGD DT? X=SU? KGL I?FL=GS?S KEDT N5>?R G>S D5WS DT?Q5NIWGE>G>DL D5 W?GH? DT? WG>S K?F? >5D L=II5FD?S PR ?HES?>Q? GIGFD MF5N DT? L?WMO

L?FHE>U LDGD?N?>DL NGS? PR Q5NIWGE>G>D4 0T? Q5=FD EL >5D I?FL=GS?S PR LGES

GQQ=LGDE5>L T=FW?S PR Q5NIWGE>G>D LENIWR P?QG=L? DT?F? EL >5 ?HES?>Q? DT?F?5> D5ENIWEQGD? DT? F?LI5>S?>D HE>Q?S DTGD F?LI5>S?>D -T?FEMM KGL F?NELL E> TEL S=DR D5 ELL=? GF?Q?EID M5F DT? IGWGR T? L?EJ?S4 'SNEDD?SWRA T? SES >5D ELL=? DT? F?Q?EID 5> DT? LI5DA

P=D K? GQQ?ID DT? F?GL5> LDGD?S ?GFWE?F M5F ELL=E>U ED KT?> DT? IGWGR KGL GWF?GSRQW?G>?S G>S N?GL=F?SA >?ZD SGR4 fF5N DT? F?Q5FSA Q5NIWGE>G>D NGS? >5 GH?FN?>D

DTGD F?LI5>S?>D -T?FEMM S?FEH?S I?Q=>EGFR P?>?MED E> >5D ENN?SEGD?WR UEHE>UQ5NIWGE>G>D G F?Q?EID4 )D KGL F?GL5>GPW? D5 PFE?MWR KGED =>DEW N?GL=F?N?>D Q5=WS P?NGS? GL D5 DT? H5W=N? 5M DT? IGWGR GMD?F P?E>U QW?G>?S G>S DTF?LT?S P?M5F? ELL=G>Q?

5M DT? F?Q?EID4 )> DT? GPL?>Q? 5M Q5>DFGFR ?HES?>Q?A DT? IF?L=NIDE5> IF?HGEWL DTGDDT? LT?FEMM TGL F?U=WGFWR I?FM5FN?S TEL 5MMEQEGW S=DR4

agrarian law_case digests

Documents