ai regulatory challenges - oecd · 2020-02-26 · 5 key ai challenges for policy makers. challenge...

23
AI Regulatory Challenges Theo doros Evgeniou Professor Decision Sciences and Technology Management, INSEAD [email protected] [Presentation available on LinkedIn ]

Upload: others

Post on 20-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 2: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

All previous technologies were at best decision support tools

AI can take increasingly complex decisions

It is essential to align the regulation with key characteristics of the underlying technology (AI).

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 3: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Experience + Learning (Human) Intelligence

Experience for Humans = (Big) Data for Machines

(Big) Data + Machine Learning Artificial Intelligence

Learning is at the Core of Intelligence

Big Data vs Machine Learning vs AI

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 4: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers

Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI”

Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values Built in Data”

Challenge 3: Managing AI Trade-offs

Challenge 4: Managing Uneven AI Innovation and Adoption

Challenge 5: Playing Catch-up with Rapid Technological Innovation

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 5: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Challenge 1

“Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI”

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 6: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI”

Page 7: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI”

Page 8: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Challenge 2

“Values Built in AI” vs “Values Built in Data”

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 9: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values Built in Data”

Emphasis on “AI based on European values” and call for EU to “export its values across the world.”

European Commission White Paper on AI,February 19, 2020

Page 10: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Traditional Tech: People Write the Rules/Programs

Computer Output

ComputerData

Output Program

(Adopted from Domingos, 2017)

AI Tech: Machines Write the Rules/Programs

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

DataProgram

Page 11: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values Built in Data”

AI is the Mirror of Data,Data is the Mirror of the Culture

Page 12: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Challenge 3

Managing AI Trade-offs

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 13: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 3: Managing AI Trade-offs

Balancing:- AI Performance - Explainability (What?)- Fairness (many versions)- Privacy- Security- IP- Incentives- …

“The Price of Values”?

Page 14: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

The “AI Polanyi’s Paradox”?

Machines, like humans, know more than they can tell

Explainable AI?

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 15: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Challenge 4

Managing Uneven AI Innovation and Adoption

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 16: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 4: Managing Uneven AI Innovation and Adoption

AI Sticky Factors:- Data- Skills- Culture- Context

Page 17: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 18: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Challenge 5

Playing Catch-up with Rapid Technological Innovation

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 19: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Challenge 5: Playing Catch-up with Rapid Technological Innovation

Federated Learning

Privacy Preserving AI

Quantum Computing

Small Data Learning

Encryption and AI

Adversarial Attacks

30%!

Multi-Task Learning

Page 20: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

…AI requires a Holistic Approach…

…hence a (Urgent) Need for Interdisciplinary Work…

There is a Lot to Do...

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 21: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

Data Engineering and Quality Management

Machine Learning and Analytics

Project Management

IT infrastructure and Management

Organizational Change

Industry Transformation

Regulation

Principles and Philosophy (e.g., Ethics)

A Final Key Message: AI requires a Holistic Approach

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD

Page 22: AI Regulatory Challenges - OECD · 2020-02-26 · 5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers. Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI” Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values

5 Key AI Challenges for Policy Makers

Challenge 1: “Buying AI” vs “Hiring AI”

Challenge 2: “Values Built in AI” vs “Values Built in Data”

Challenge 3: Managing AI Trade-offs

Challenge 4: Managing Uneven AI Innovation and Adoption

Challenge 5: Playing Catch-up with Rapid Technological Innovation

© T. Evgeniou, INSEAD