aiaa applied aerodynamics technical committee apa … aerodynamics... · aiaa applied aerodynamics...

AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Technical Committee APA-TC Minutes

Summer 2010 APA Meeting Chicago, IL

June 27, 2010

Committee Officers Chairman: Rob Vermeland, Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Past-Chairman: Frank Coton, Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Secretary: Martiqua Post, U.S. Air Force Academy Treasurer: Rob Vermeland, Lockheed Martin Aeronautics

Dinner Dinner served: 6:10pm Meeting opened: 6:25pm

Attendance 33 of 41 members of the APA TC were present for the main TC meeting.

Introduction and Welcome (Rob Vermeland) The meeting was called to order by the Chair, Rob Vermeland. Joao Azevedo made a motion to approve the minutes from the 2010 ASM meeting in Orlando. Steve Morris seconded the motion. Treasurer’s report was given by Rob Vermeland. Rob announced that at the next ASM conference in Orlando we will meet as a TC for most of the meeting, as opposed to spending much of the time in subcommittee meetings. This “Sand Pit” meeting will be organized by Frank Coton, Past-Chairman. John Benek gave a report back on the Shock Boundary Layer Interaction Workshop from the ASM 2010 Meeting. See attached powerpoint slides. Tom Ramsey, Liaison from FD, wants to survey APA regarding: What do we want undergrads to know in CFD? He is seeking support of APA. Betty Guille, AIAA Technical Activities Liaison staff, introduced herself and gifted TC members a laser pointer/pen. She also has available XL Technical Activities shirts. The TC heard speeches from the two nominees for Chairman-Elect, Joao Azevedo and Jim Guglielmo. Congratulations to APA’s new Chairman-Elect: Jim Guglielmo. Notes regarding agenda item are as follows. Powerpoint presentations follow in order after the minutes.

2

APA Social Event Jim Guglielmo The TC will go to the Cubs vs Pittsburgh Pirates baseball game at Wrigley Field on 28 June 2010.

Status of APA TC Meetings & Workshops 2010, Chicago, Jim Guglielmo See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

2011, Orlando, Jim DeSpirito See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

2011, Hawaii, Jim Debonis See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

2012, Nashville, Siva Nadarajah

2012, New Orleans, Steve Morris

Admin Subcommittee Reports

Education – Brian McGrath See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented. See also Design, Build, Fly Competition slides.

Honors & Awards - Jim DeSpirito The Honors & Awards requests nominations for individuals for the Aerodynamics Awards. He’ll send out guidelines via e-mail, please respond to him within the next month with nominees. Please only nominate worthy papers, not presentations, for the Best Paper Award. See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

Membership and Nominations – James Canino Long into Sharepoint and edit your personal information. See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

Planning - Joao Luiz Azevedo Reply to Joao’s email with venue selections for future summer meetings. Support for Technical Chairs is on the Sharepoint site. See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

3

Publicity & Publications-Jim Guglielmo (for Kelly Stewart) The TC has a new logo which is used on the website and in TC publications. Please provide ideas for the Year-In-Review article by 20 August. Ideas not used in the article may be used for a TC Newsletter to be posted to the website. A review of the TC Sharepoint Site was given. See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

Liaisons –Steve Morris See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

Technical Subcommittee Reports Aerodynamic Design – Siva Nadarajah

Aerodynamic Phenomena – Hui Hu

A new subcommittee chair was decided at this conference.

Vehicle Aerodynamics – Jim Guglielmo and Jim DeSpirito There is a special working group by Bob Tramel and Stephen McParlin. The subcommittee plans to have a special session in Hawaii about Ground Test. A suggestion was made to have an engineering predictive methods special session in Orlando 2012.

High Lift Workshop – Bob Stuever See powerpoint presentation for complete slides presented.

New Business Group Picture was taken and is attached. The new treasurer will be Martiqua Post. Rob Vermeland reminded members that our 2011 APA meeting is Monday afternoon/evening instead of Sunday afternoon/evening to coincide with 2011 ASM meeting. The dates are Tues, January 4 – Friday, January 7, 2011 and were shifted my one day to accommodate the New Year’s holiday.

Adjournment

A motion was made by Joao Azevedo, seconded by Kenrick Waithe, and unanimously passed to adjourn the meeting at 8:45pm.

2010 AIAA Shock Boundary Layer Interaction WorkshopInteraction Workshop

John A Benek PhDJohn A. Benek, PhDDirector, Computational Sciences Center

Air Force Research Laboratory, Air Vehicles Directorate

Workshop Organizers

Holger Babinsky Cambridge University UFASTJohn Benek Air Force Research Lab CCASJames Debonis NASA Glenn Research CntrCharles Hirsch Numeca UFASTJames Luckring NASA Langley Research CntrJames Luckring NASA Langley Research CntrJon Tinapple Air Force Research Lab CCAS

UFAST – European Union SBLI projectCCAS Ai F C ll b ti C tCCAS – Air Force Collaborative Center

SponsorsAIAA Technical CommitteesAIAA Technical Committees

Applied Aero Standards subcommittee for CFD V&V

Contributors

Baurle NASA GRC Larcheveque Baurle NASA GRC Blaisdell NASA GRC Bhagwandin ARL

LarchevequeUFAST/IUSTI

Oberkampf WLO Consulting Olsen NASA GRC

Dahm CCAS/UM Debonis NASA GRC Despirito ARL

Olsen NASA GRC Park NASA LaRC Rumsey NASA LaRCp

Dussage UFAST/IUSTI Edwards NC State U Georiadis NASA GRC

Troia Northrop Grumman Tapee Northrop Grumman Subbaredy U of Minn.

Georiadis NASA GRC Jammalamadka

CCAS/MSU

Vyas NASA GRC

15 papers from 10 groups15 papers from 10 groups55+ attendees

Workshop Simulations

Number of simulations for each challenger problemCASE 1 2 3 4

Number of 7 11 9 7Number of simulations

7 11 9 7

Number of simulations for each turbulence modelRANS LES

SA k- k- SST Other8 2 2 7 4 5

June 2010: 28th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference – Social EventAerodynamics Conference Social Event

Jim Guglielmo28th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, APA TC MeetingChicago, ILg27 June 2010

APA Social Event

What Chicago C bs s • What: Chicago Cubs vs. Pittsburgh Pirates Baseball GameBaseball Game

• Where: Wrigley Field• When: Tuesday June 29th• When: Tuesday, June 29th

• Transportation: Charter Bus Arrives At Hyatt Bus Arrives At Hyatt (Outside Lobby) At 5:30 pm

2

p• Two Tickets Still Available

3 4

June 2010: 28th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference – StatusAerodynamics Conference Status

Jim Guglielmo28th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, APA TC MeetingChicago, ILg27 June 2010

General Information• Location: Chicago, Illinois (Go Bears!!!)• Dates: June 28th – July 1st, 2010• Co-Located With:

27th Aerodynamic Measurement Technology & Ground Testing Conference27 Aerodynamic Measurement Technology & Ground Testing Conference5th Flow Control Conference40th Fluid Dynamics Conference41st Plasmadynamics & Lasers Conference41 Plasmadynamics & Lasers Conference10th AIAA/ASME Joint Thermophysics & Heat Transfer Conference

• General Chair: Nicholas J Georgiadis (NASA Glenn Research Center)Nicholas J. Georgiadis (NASA Glenn Research Center)

• APA Technical Chairs:Jim Guglielmo – Chair (Boeing)

2

Holger Babinsky – Co-Chair (University of Cambridge)Robert Tramel – Co-Chair (Digital Fusion)

Abstract Status

• 244 Abstracts Submitted• 244 Abstracts Submitted• Topic Areas Divided Up Among Co-Chairs• 3 Reviewers / Abstract3 Reviewers / Abstract• ~15 Abstracts / Reviewer – Thanks For Your Hard Work!!• Acceptance Rate – 84%• Rejection Letters

Email Sent To Each Author With An Abstract RejectedP id d Additi l F db k O R j ti Wh I i d B Provided Additional Feedback On Rejections When Inquired By Author

3

APA Summer Conference Abstract Statistics

APA Summer Conference Abstract Submittal RatesAPA Summer Conference Abstract Submittal Rates

350

400

Hawaii

250

300

Orlando

San Francisco

Chicago

150

200

Toronto

Miami

San Antonio

0

50

100St. Louis

Providence San Antonio

4

02002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

Regular Sessions• CFD Applications in Aerodynamics I, II, & III• Wind Tunnel and Flight Testing Aerodynamics I & II• Flow Control - Applied Aerodynamics• High Lift and High Angle of Attack Aerodynamics• Flight in Nature and Micro Air Vehicles I, II, & III• Transonic, Supersonic and Hypersonic Aerodynamics• Unsteady Aerodynamics I & II• Weapons Aerodynamics and Store Separation• Rotorcraft Aerodynamics I & II• Wind Turbine Aerodynamics• Aerodynamic Design Methodologies and Optimization Techniques I & II• Airfoil/Wing/Configuration Aerodynamics• Innovative Aerodynamic Concepts and Applications

5

• Icing Effects on Vehicle Aerodynamics• Aerodynamic-Structural Dynamics Interaction

Special Sessions & Workshop

• Environmentally Friendly and Efficient Aerodynamics and Enabling • Environmentally Friendly and Efficient Aerodynamics and Enabling Technology

• Advanced Transport Aircraft for 2030 and Beyond (Invited) I & IIp y ( )

• Shock Wave Boundary Layer Interaction Prediction Workshop: Results

• Fluid Dynamic Challenges in Flight Mechanicsu d y a c C a e ges g t ec a cs

• 4th CFD Drag Prediction Workshop (DPW) Results I, II, & II

• Ares Launch Vehicle AeroelasticityAres Launch Vehicle Aeroelasticity

• Stability and Control Prediction Methods for NATO Air and Sea Vehicles I, II, & III

6• CFD High-Lift Prediction Workshop (HiLiftPW-1) – Prior To Conference

Session Information

M P P S i• 35 Total Sessions

21 6-Paper Sessions Mon Tue Wed ThuAM 6 6 6 8

Max Papers Per Session

14 8-Paper SessionsTotal: 238 Paper Slots

AM 6 6 6 8PM 8 6 8 --

• For Reference, 25 Total Sessions For June 2009

APA Sessions Per Day

Mon Tue Wed ThuAPA Conference AM 5 5 5 2

PM 6 6 6 --

7

APA Awards Lecture – Dr. Thomas Corke

• Date/Time: Wednesday, June 30th, 2010; 8 am to 9 am

• Location: Regency CDE

• Title of Talk: “Dielectric Barrier Discharge Plasma Actuators for Enhanced Aerodynamics”

8

Important Dates: Timeline• Call For Papers Appears In Aerospace America Bulletin 06/09• Stand Alone Call For Papers Sent 07/02/09• Electronic Abstract Submittals Accepted Through AIAA Web Site 07/01/09• Electronic Abstract Submittal Deadline 11/05/09• Completed Conference Program Content Due In CAS 01/15/10• Completed Conference Program Content Due In CAS 01/15/10• Letters Of Acceptance & Author Instructions E-mailed 02/05/10• Preliminary Program Live On AIAA Web Site 02/27/10• On-line Registration Opens 03/01/10g p• Preliminary Program In Issue Of The Aerospace America Bulletin 03/10• Stand Alone Preliminary Program Mailed 03/31/10• Get Room Assignments From General Chair 04/1/10• All Corrections/Changes For Final Program Due In CAS 05/26/10• Early Bird Registration Deadline 06/01/10• Online Proceedings Open 06/14/10• Final Manuscripts Due To Technical Papers Specialist 06/14/10

9

• Final Manuscripts Due To Technical Papers Specialist 06/14/10• Dates Of Conference 28 June-1 July 2010

Contact Information & Misc.

• Session Chair/Co-Chair Contact Information:Jim Guglielmo: 636-578-6718H l B bi k 937 626 9413Holger Babinsky: 937-626-9413Bob Tramel: n/a

• Misc• Misc.FDCinFM Session Chair (Wednesday Morning, June 30th)Speaker’s BreakfastsSpeaker s BreakfastsSession Forms & Best Paper Nomination

10

Lessons-Learned

• Last Time Using CAS System Not As Bad As I Had Anticipated• Last Time Using CAS System – Not As Bad As I Had Anticipated• AIAA Staff Was A Huge Help• Session Co-Chairs Are A Great Idea!!• Template For Abstract Assignments• Send Out A Note To Reviewers That Includes Which Co-Chair Is Responsible

For Each Topic Area• Meetings With Other Chairs At ASM Conference For Joint Sessions &

Abstract Transfers Worked Well• Fairly Generic Rejection Letter Approach Worked Welly j pp• Workload Comes In Spurts• Room Reservations For Workshops Need To Be Coordinated With AIAA More

Than One Year Out. Process Being Established.

11

Than One Year Out. Process Being Established.• Overall, A Very Good Experience!!

Thanks For Everyone’s Help!!

12

Backup Slides (For Reference)

13

Abstract Topic Areas• Applied CFD & Validation Against Experimental Datapp g p• Aerodynamic Testing: Flight & Wind Tunnel• Flow Control (Active & Passive): Computational & Experimental Results• High Lift Aerodynamics• High Angle-of-Attack Aerodynamics & Vortical/Vortex Flows• Low Reynolds Number & Micro Air Vehicle Aerodynamics• Transonic, Supersonic, & Hypersonic Aerodynamics• Unsteady Aerodynamics• Unsteady Aerodynamics• Weapons Aerodynamics & Store Separation: Missile/Projectile/Guided-Munitions• Rotorcraft/Propeller/Wind Turbine Aerodynamics• Aerodynamic Design: Analysis, Methodologies, & Optimization Techniques• Airfoil/Wing/Configuration Aerodynamics• Innovative Aerodynamic Concepts & Designs• Icing Effects on Vehicle Aerodynamics

A d i St t l D i I t ti

14

• Aerodynamic-Structural Dynamics Interaction• Other Topics in Applied Aerodynamics (Catch-All Category)

Abstract StatisticsTopic Area # Submitted # Accepted # Rejected % Accepted % Rejected # Assigned # Completed % Complete

Abstract Reviews

Applied CFD & validation against experimental data 25 19 6 76% 24% 114 109 96%

Aerodynamic testing: flight & wind tunnel 18 12 6 67% 33% 57 57 100%

Flow control (active & passive): computational & experimental results 7 6 1 86% 14% 33 33 100%

High lift aerodynamics 8 7 1 88% 13% 15 15 100%

High angle-of-attack aerodynamics & vortical/vortex flows 0 0 0 n/a n/a 12 12 100%

Low Reynolds number & micro air vehicle aerodynamics 25 22 3 88% 12% 53 42 79%

Transonic, supersonic, & hypersonic aerodynamics 6 5 1 83% 17% 21 21 100%

Unsteady aerodynamics 13 11 2 85% 15% 45 30 67%

Weapons aerodynamics & store separation: missile/projectile/guided-munitions 6 5 1 83% 17% 18 18 100%

Rotorcraft/propeller/wind turbine aerodynamics 21 18 3 86% 14% 54 49 91%

Aerodynamic design: analysis, methodologies, & optimization techniques 21 13 8 62% 38% 60 58 97%

Airfoil/wing/configuration aerodynamics 8 5 3 63% 38% 21 20 95%Airfoil/wing/configuration aerodynamics 8 5 3 63% 38% 21 20 95%

Innovative aerodynamic concepts & designs 8 8 0 100% 0% 12 12 100%

Icing effects on vehicle aerodynamics 6 6 0 100% 0% 18 12 67%

Aerodynamic-structural dynamics interaction 11 10 1 91% 9% 27 26 96%

Other topics in applied aerodynamics 34 32 2 94% 6% 23 8 35%

Aerodynamics of biological flight 0 0 0 n/a n/a 15 15 100%

Sports aerodynamics 1 0 1 0% 100% 3 3 100%

Aerodynamic design for environmentally friendly and efficient aircraft 8 8 0 100% 0% 6 6 100%

CFD Drag Prediction Workshop results 18 18 0 100% 0% 51 50 98%

Aerodynamics at low Reynolds number 0 0 0 n/a n/a 0 0 n/a

Total 244 205 39 84% 16% 658 596 91%

15

Note: The Accepted/Rejected Statistics Listed Above Are After Abstracts Were Swapped With The Other TC's At The Conference (Fluids, Plasma, Etc) Or After Being Combined With Other Topic Areas As Sessions Were Built

Historical APA Abstract Submission Statistics

Submitted Topic 2006 - San Francisco 2007 - Miami 2008 - Hawaii 2009 - San Antonio Keep, Delete, Combine?

# of Abstracts

Active & Passive Aerodynamic Flow Control: Computational & Experimental Results 7 23 18 9 Keep

Aerodynamic Design: Analysis, Methodologies, & Optimization Techniques 18 42 34 15 Keep

Airfoil/Wing/Configuration Aerodynamics 20 6 12 15 Keep

Application of Artificial Intelligence Techniques to Aerodynamic Problems 6 0 0 5 Delete

Applied CFD and Validation Against Experimental Data 57 24 72 19 Keep

Boundary Layer Transition and Drag Prediction 6 0 4 2 Delete

High Lift, High Angle-of-Attack Aerodynamics 8 1 2 1 Keep, Separate High Lift

Icing Effects on Vehicle Aerodynamics (Includes CFD for Icing in 2007) 8 57 1 5 Keep

Innovative Aerodynamic Concepts & Designs 14 9 18 13 Keep

Low Reynolds Number Aerodynamics and Testing 9 5 2 17 KeepLow Reynolds Number Aerodynamics and Testing 9 5 2 17 Keep

Rotorcraft/Propeller/Wind Turbine Aerodynamics 14 13 18 14 Keep

Transonic, Supersonic, & Hypersonic Aerodynamics (Includes "Subsonic" for 2006 & 2009) 21 8 17 15 Keep

Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Aerodynamics: Design & Test 12 6 2 1 Delete

Unsteady Aerodynamics 21 11 7 17 Keep

Vortical/Vortex Flows 16 10 2 9 Keep, Combine w/ High Vortical/Vortex Flows 16 10 2 9 p, gAOA

Weapons Aerodynamics: Missile/Projectile/Guided-Munition 1 18 10 5 Keep

Weapon Carriage and Store Separation Aerodynamics (Includes 'Weapons Bay Aero" for 2008) 1 0 2 1 Combine w/ Weapon Aero

Aerodynamic Testing: Flight & Wind Tunnel 23 18 27 15 Keep

Other Topics in Applied Aerodynamics 0 8 20 0 Keep

16

Micro Air Vehicle Aerodynamics: Design & Test 0 0 20 0 Combine w/ Low RN

Applied Aerodynamics for Surface Vehicles 0 0 7 0 Delete

Aerodynamic-Structural Dynamics Interaction 19 6 12 0 Keep

Total 281 265 307 178

17

AIAA 49th ASM – Orlando, January 2011Applied Aerodynamics Technical Sessionspp y

Organizers:gJim DeSpiritoAaron AltmanSteve Morris4-7 January 2011, Orlando World Center Marriott, Orlando, Florida

Paper Submissions

• Total Submissions: 20948 special and invited session submissions161 general session submissions (± 2 or 3)

Ab t t t i 18 J 2010• Abstracts to reviewers 18 June 2010Special session abstracts not distributedReviews requested to be returned by 9 July 2010Reviews requested to be returned by 9 July 2010

• Session ChairsWill use your topic area preferences as basis to select session chairssession chairs.Please let us know if you already know you won’t be available to act as session chair.Special sessionsSpecial sessions

– Will ask organizers to provide session chairs.

Special/Invited Sessions (6 Topics)

• Aerodynamic Characterization of Ares I Launch Vehicley29 abstracts in 5 sessionsOrganizer: Khalid Abdol-Hamid, NASA, Langley

CREATE AV• CREATE-AV12 abstracts in 2 sessionsOrganizer: Nathan Hariharan, HPCMO – CREATE-AVPossible joint with Computer Systems

• Experimental Difficulties & Challenges in Low Reynolds Number AerodynamicsNumber Aerodynamics

7 (or 8) abstracts in 1 sessionOrganizer: Ming ChangJoint with GTTC and FDTC

Special/Invited Sessions (6 Topics)

• HiLiftPW 1 (Summary/Review Session)( y )12 slots in 2 sessionsOrganizer: Jeff Slotnick, Boeing

Fl id D i Ch ll i Fli ht M h i• Fluid Dynamics Challenges in Flight Mechanics Working Group Special Session

1 session allotted—No contact from organizer yetOrganizer: Steve McParlinJoint with FDTC and AFMTC

• NASA Common Research Model Wind Tunnel Data• NASA Common Research Model Wind Tunnel Data for the Drag Prediction Workshop

6 abstracts in 1 sessionOrganizer: Rich WahlsJoint with GTTC (GTTC lead, abstracts submitted to GTTC)

APA Sessions

• Tentatively have 29 sessions for APATentatively have 29 sessions for APABased on last two years

• Will be coordinating with other TCs toWill be coordinating with other TCs to minimize same topic area conflicts.

• Remember, conference starts on Tuesday!, y

Max Papers/Session Tentative APA Sessions/day

Tue Wed Thur Fri

AM 8 6 6 6

Tue Wed Thur Fri

AM 3 3 4 5

PM 6 6 6 8 PM 3 3 4 4

Timeline• 9 July 2010

Complete reviews of submitted abstractsComplete reviews of submitted abstracts• 23 July 2010

Conference program due to conference organizer• 9 Aug 20109 Aug 2010

Completed conference program due in CAS• 18 Aug 2010

Session Chair letters sent by AIAAy• 19 Aug 2010

Decision notices to authors sent by AIAAProgram Live on AIAA website

• 9 Sep 2010Manuscript Central Invitations e-mailed to Session Chairs & Accepted Authors

• 13 Dec 2010Manuscript Deadline

• 20 Dec 2010Proceedings Live on AIAA website

New Conference Administration System (CAS)

• The new CAS is called ScholarOne• Thoughts so far

Improvement over the old system, but still could use p ysome improvements (at least for organizers).Very easy to access abstracts submitted to other TCs and view their sessions etcand view their sessions, etc.

– In my experience with old system (AFM 2006), could not access other TC information to help plan conference.

TC conference organizers working together– To transfer abstracts uploaded to inappropriate topic areas

(primarily from reviewer comment—let us know early).(p y y)– Will attempt to reduce similar topic area conflicts in the program.

Would like reviewer’s feed back on new CAS.

Thanks for your support in reviewingfor your support in reviewing abstracts and chairing sessions!

Status of the29th Applied Aerodynamics Conference29 Applied Aerodynamics Conference

Honolulu, Hawaii

Jim DeBonis

NASA Glenn Research Center

[email protected]

PeoplePeopleConference General Chair

Paschall MassengillPaschall Massengill

Applied Aero Conference

Technical ChairJim DeBonis

NASA Glenn Research [email protected]

Technical Co‐ChairsM i P K ll SMartiqua Post Kelly StewartU.S. Air Force Academy Eglin Air Force [email protected] [email protected]

StatusStatus

• Call for Papers is completeCall for Papers is complete

• Special session lined up4 t i– 4 topics

– 4‐8 sessions

• First planning meeting tomorrow

Call for PapersCall for Papers

Special SessionsSpecial Sessions

• Low boom and drag predictions– Kenrick Waithe– Based on NASA/Gulfstream work on low sonic boom and drag

predictions• Aerodynamic efficiency and laminar flow• Aerodynamic efficiency and laminar flow

– Gary Dale– Session to include Northrop Grumman swept wing natural laminar

flow flight test and Boeing SensorCraft work.g g• Experimental Difficulties & Challenges Low Reynolds Number

Aerodynamics– Ming Chang & Michael Selig

• Aerodynamic Characterization of the Orion Crew Vehicle– Eric Walker, NASA Langley– Would like up to 4 or 5 sessions

Honors and Awards Subcommittee

28th Applied Aerodynamics ConferenceChicago, Illinois

27 June 2010

Subcommittee Members

• Michael Amitay• Michael Amitay• Holger Babinsky• Thomas Chyczewski

Technical SC Representation:• Thomas Chyczewski

• James DeBonis• Jim DeSpirito

Representation:Aerodynamic Phenomena Disciplines (2)Jim DeSpirito

• Anthony Farina• Steven Krist

Disciplines (2)Aerodynamic Design Disciplines (6)VehicleSteven Krist

• Martiqua Post• Willy Toledo

Vehicle Aerodynamics Disciplines (1)y

Aerodynamics Award 2010 Recipient

• Thomas C. CorkeThomas C. CorkeClark Chair Professor Aerospace & Mechanical Engineering, University of Notre Dame“For strong commitment to academic and researchacademic and research achievement, consistent record of superior technical accomplishment,

d i t l dand numerous experimental and computational contributions to aerodynamics”

Aerodynamics Award 2011

• Nomination packages due to AIAA 1 OctoberNomination packages due to AIAA 1 OctoberWe need minimum of 2 new nominations.Several TC members had potential candidate ideas pin Orlando 2010—time to consider nominations.

– Need time to prepare resume and garner referencesPlan to summarize procedure and put on APATCPlan to summarize procedure and put on APATC website.

• Flyers distributed in Orlando and ChicagoFlyers distributed in Orlando and ChicagoThanks Kelly

• APATC website now has list of past recipientsp pThanks Jim G.

APA Best Paper Award

• 2010 Recipient2010 RecipientProfessor Mark Drela, MITAIAA-2009-3762, “Power Balance in Aerodynamic Flows”To be presented at Tuesday Awards Luncheon

• 2011 paper reviews begin after this conference• Session Chairs• Session Chairs

Please fill out your session chair forms and return to AIAA registration desk.PLEASE k itt i l f t i h iPLEASE make sure written paper is also factor in your choice—this is the only basis the review committee will have.

• If you don’t feel that there is a worthy nomination from your session, then leave blank.

But please nominate all worthy papers!

Membership & Nominations SubcommitteeSubcommittee

28th Applied Aerodynamics ConferenceChicago, IL June 2010

Subcommittee Overview

Purposes:Purposes:1. Manage TC membership2 S li it did t t TC b2. Solicit candidates to serve as TC members3. Nominate appropriate candidates for TC posts4. Help upgrade members to AIAA Associate

Fellows, Fellows, or Honorary Fellows, , y

2

Current TC Membership

• Total Members: 41• US Members (not including associate): 33

Academia: 5Industry: 16Industry: 16Government: 12

• Foreign Members: 6gBrazil: 1Canada: 1Germany: 1Germany: 1UK: 3

• Associate US Members: 2 (1 Industry, 1 Government)

3

New TC Members Rotating On 5/1/2010 (7+1+4)

• Nathan Hariharan Chenega Federal SystemsH i H I S U i i• Hui Hu Iowa State University

• Douglas Lacy Boeing (Seattle)• Sam Lee ASRC Aerospace (NASA GRC contractor)• Larry Lijewski US Air Force Research Lab (Eglin AFB)• Larry Lijewski US Air Force Research Lab (Eglin AFB)• Jonathan Murray * Sandia National Laboratory• Carl Tilmann Air Force Research Laboratory

• New 1 year termAndrew McComis * Analytical Methods, Inc

• N 3 t• New 3 year termsMartiqua Post US Air Force AcademyStanley Ferguson BoeingWily Fritz EADS (Germany)

4

Joao Luiz Azevedo Instituto de Aeronautica e Espaco (Brazil)

* Associate Member

17 Members Rotating Off 4/30/2010 (14 US, 1 Inter, 2 Assoc )• Michael Amitay Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute• William Anderson Simulation and Design Center• William Anderson Simulation and Design Center• James Canino The Aerospace Corporation• Mark Chaffin Cessna Aero• Frank Coton University of Glasgow• James DeSpirito US Army Research Laboratory• James DeSpirito US Army Research Laboratory• Anthony Farina US Army ARDEC• James Guglielmo Boeing• John Martel Jacobs Engineering• Andrew McComis Analytical Methods Inc*• Andrew McComis Analytical Methods, Inc• Brian McGarth Johns Hopkins University• Steven Morris Engineering Systems Inc• Jonathan Murray Sandia National Labs *• Chunhua Sheng University of Toledo• Chunhua Sheng University of Toledo• Rebert Stuever Hawker Beechcraft Corp• Robert Tramel Kord Technologies• Kenrick Waithe Gulfstream• Extension required due to ongoing APA TC responsibilities (Conf technical chair etc )

5

• Extension required due to ongoing APA TC responsibilities (Conf technical chair, etc.)• ?* Associate Member

TC Membership After 2010 Retirements

• 24 Members24 Members19 US (maximum allowable: 35)– 2 Academia– 2 Academia– 9 Government– 8 Industryy5 International (no limit)– Canada (1)( )– Germany (1)– Brazil (1)

6

– UK (2)0 Associate US Members

Membership & Nominations Subcommittee Issues

• Members rotating off the TC in 2011gSelect replacement and ask them to apply

– send me an e-mailReplacement recommendation is a strong consideration in Replacement recommendation is a strong consideration in evaluating candidates

• Past application problems/suggestionsNo indication of AIAA membership (TC member must be a No indication of AIAA membership (TC member must be a member with 45 days of appointment)No organizational endorsementDid t i l d éDid not include resumé

– Resumé are invaluable and encouraged but not required– Update to include latest experience

Include current/previous AIAA involvement (local/national)

7

– Include current/previous AIAA involvement (local/national)


• APA TC has historically had very few (often no) APA TC has historically had very few (often no) associate members (currently have 2)

Subcommittee emphasis - increase associate membership – Members encourage young engineers within and beyond their

organizations to apply for APA TC membership Official AIAA policy calls for a minimum of 2 associate Official AIAA policy calls for a minimum of 2 associate membersLength of service is one year with review:

– Associate member can be rejected, upgraded to full member, or extended as an AM for one extra year

– This is automatic and doesn’t require reapplyingq pp y gOften times the decision to classify someone as an AM is a numbers game

Membership Selection Process

Aug 15 (Nomination forms received by TC)

Aug-Oct (Solicit for prospective new candidates)

Nov 1 (Deadline for nomination packages)

Nov-Dec (Subcommittee votes on new members)

J ASMJan ASM (Acceptance of new members at APA TC)

Mar-Apr (New members get notice of acceptance)

9

Mar Apr (New members get notice of acceptance)


• Candidates who are rejected do NOT receive Candidates who are rejected do NOT receive any official notification from AIAA

• A “rejection” form letter was drafted by the A rejection form letter was drafted by the membership subcommittee chair and reviewed by the APA TC chair and sent to each rejected y jcandidate by the APA TC chair after the membership selection process

Letter encourages them to update application and resumé and reapply

11

Planning Subcommittee

Joao Luiz Azevedo

28th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference – Chicago, June 2010

Agenda

• Upcoming Conferences and Technical ChairsUpcoming Conferences and Technical Chairs• Conference Statistics Update Summer ConferencesSummer Conferences Winter Conferences

• Technical Co-chairs for Conferences• Technical Co-chairs for Conferences• Conference General Chair• Next Summer Meetings• Next Summer Meetings• 1st AIAA CFD High-Lift Prediction Workshop

Oth S bj t2

• Other Subjects

Chicago 2010 Jim Guglielmo

Upcoming Conferences and Technical Chairs

Chicago 2010 Jim Guglielmo

Orlando 2011 James DeSpirito

Hawaii 2011 Jim DeBonis

Nashville 2012 Siva Nadarajah

New Orleans 2012 Steven Morris

Grapevine 2013 Lamar Aumanp

San Diego 2013Potomac (DC) 2014

3

Winter - Orlando 2015, San Diego 2016, Grapevine 2017, Orlando 2018.

Summer Conference Abstracts and Acceptance Rates

Conference Statistics Update: Summer Conferences

p

300

350

80,00

90,00

250

300

ived 60,00

70,00

ate

Orlando S

a

Toront

Provide

St L

oui H

150

200

bstra

cts

Rece

i

40,00

50,00

Acc

epta

nce

Ra

an Francisco

Miam

i

toence

is

Haw

aii

S

Chica g

50

100

Ab

10,00

20,00

30,00 A

AbstractsAcceptance rate

o i an Antonio

go

40

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 20100,00

,o

Winter Conference Abstracts and Acceptance Rates

Conference Statistics Update: Winter Conferences

300

90

100

200

250

ved 70

80

e %S

ta

150

stra

cts

Rece

iv

40

50

60

cept

ance

Rat

e

Ab t t

art AS

M in

50

100Abs

20

30 AccAbstracts

Acceptance rate

n Orlando

502001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

0

10

Technical Co-chairs for Conferences

• We started to have Technical Co-chairs for Orlando 2010.We started to have Technical Co chairs for Orlando 2010.• Idea is to have somebody to help the Technical Chair in terms of

organizing sessions, paper approval process, etc.organizing sessions, paper approval process, etc.• Preliminary step to become full Technical Chair.• Chicago 2010: Robert Tramel and Holger Babinsky• Chicago 2010: Robert Tramel and Holger Babinsky.• Orlando 2011 (Winter): Steven Morris and Aaron Altman.

H ii 2011 (S ) K ll St t d M ti P t• Hawaii 2011 (Summer): Kelly Stewart and Martiqua Post.• Nashville 2012 (Winter): Aaron Altman and Ming Chang.

6

• New Orleans 2012: Kenrick Waithe and Brian McGrath• Need volunteers for Grapevine 2013 (Winter).

Conference General Chair (1/2)

• The Applied Aerodynamics TC will have the General Chair position in the Summer of 2011.p

• Conference will be in Honolulu (Hawaii).• Paschall Massengill has accepted to do the work• Paschall Massengill has accepted to do the work.• Paschall was Technical Chair for Miami 2007.• Next opportunity for APA-TC to provide the General

Chair for the Summer Conferences will be in 2017.

7

Conference General Chair (2/2)

Rotation of the General Chair for Summer Conferences:Rotation of the General Chair for Summer Conferences:• 2010 Fluid Dynamics• 2011 Applied Aero• 2012 AMT/GT• 2013 ASE (Atmospheric Space Environments)

2014 Pl d i d L• 2014 Plasmadynamics and Lasers• 2015 Thermophysics• 2016 Fluid Dynamics• 2016 Fluid Dynamics• 2017 Applied Aero• 2018 AMT/GT

8• 2019 ASE• 2020 Plasmadynamics and Lasers

Previous Fluids Summer Conference Locations

• 2000 Denver 2008 Seattle2000 Denver 2008 Seattle• 2001 Anaheim 2009 San Antonio• 2002 St Louis 2010 Chicago• 2002 St. Louis 2010 Chicago• 2003 Orlando

2004 P tl d• 2004 Portland• 2005 Toronto• 2006 San Francisco• 2007 Miami

9

Future Years - Confirmed

• 2011 Hawaii 27-30 June • 2011 Hawaii 27 30 June City View $ 175 Mountain View $ 221 Mountain View $ 221 Ocean View $ 230

2012 N O l 25 28 J ($ 195)• 2012 New Orleans 25-28 June ($ 195)• 2013 San Diego 24-27 June ($ 222 / 242)

All cities offer 30% of block (150) at Government rates.10

( )

Options for the Future 2014

• Atlanta $ 189• Atlanta $ 189• Naples, FL $ 179

O l d $ 149• Orlando $ 149• Jacksonville, FL $ 129

Room rates are still in the negotiation phase Room rates are still in the negotiation phase. Prices listed are for reference when make decisions

11

decisions.


• Hollywood, CA $ 229Mil k $ 179• Milwaukee $ 179

• Minneapolis $ 199• Boston $ 249

12


• San Francisco $ 229• Portland $ 148Portland $ 148• Phoenix $ 165

13

1st AIAA CFD High-Lift Prediction Workshop

• Applied Aero TC has had a leading role in the • Applied Aero TC has had a leading role in the creation of several workshops.

• HiLiftPW 1 took place here in Chicago over the • HiLiftPW-1 took place here in Chicago over the weekend (26-27 June 2010).W b it i htt //hilift l• Website is http://hiliftpw.larc.nasa.gov

• Jeffrey Slotnick was in the Organizing Committee.• Workshop had a total of 72 registered participants.• Format was similar to the well-known DPW’s (CFD

14

Format was similar to the well known DPW s (CFD Drag Prediction Workshops).

Other Subjects

• New conference administration software• New conference administration software. AIAA has started using the new software for Orlando 2011.

Support for Technical Chairs on website• Support for Technical Chairs on website. Jim Guglielmo has prepared (and uploaded into the website)

a few documents that might help Technical Chairsa few documents that might help Technical Chairs. These include an Abstract Review Template, an Abstract

Statistics Template and an Abstract Topic HistoryStatistics Template and an Abstract Topic History. Website also has a Conference Planning Manual and an

Abstract Rating Guide15

Abstract Rating Guide.• Reminder: ASM 2011 from Tuesday to Friday. 16

Publicity & Publications – June 2010 Status

Jim Guglielmo (for Kelly Stewart)Jim Guglielmo (for Kelly Stewart)28th AIAA APA Conference, APA TC MeetingChicago, IL27 June 201027 June 2010

Outline

• Membershipp• Old Business• Logo Recommendation• Brochure• Year-In-Review Article• Newsletter• SharePoint / Website• Misc• Misc.

2

Membership

• Kelly Stewart - Chair• Mark Calvert• Jim Guglielmo• Steve LeDoux• Andrew McComas• Carl Tilmann• Rob Vermeland

3

Old Business

• Flyer for APA awardFlyer for APA award Updated for 2011, working file uploaded to website Includes excerpt of previous winner (Dr. Jubaraj Sahu )p p ( j )

• TC Brochure Pinged membership on public release images that can be

incorporated into brochure– Thanks to Aaron Altman, Joao Azevedo, and Jim Guglielmo

Added information on High Lift Prediction Workshop Added information on High-Lift Prediction Workshop Added pitch for APA award Working *.doc uploaded to TC website

4

Working .doc uploaded to TC website

Logo Recommendation

5

Brochure

6

Brochure (Cont.)

7

Year-In-Review Article

Editors Andre McComas Ste e LeDo• Editors: Andrew McComas, Steve LeDoux• Submissions From TC Members To Editors Due

August 20thAugust 20th

• Final Version Submittal Deadline: September 24th

APA Li it 600 W d With O I• APA Limits: 600-Words With One Image• Sign-Up Sheet Going Around For Topic Ideas

8

Newsletter (Proposal)

• Take Extra Material From Year-In-Review Submissions Take Extra Material From Year In Review Submissions For A More Detailed Article / Newsletter

• Post on APA SharePoint

9

SharePoint Background & Recent Updates

• BackgroundBackground APA SharePoint Also Serves As APA Website APA SharePoint Site Has Limited-Access Areas For APA Members, As

Well As Open Areas For Public Access

• Updates Steering Committee Document Library Added APA Awards Section Added Survey Capability Exercised (Cubs Game Feedback)

• First-Time Login Userid: Your email address Password: Welcome123@

Misc SharePoint Notes: Misc SharePoint Notes: •• When Modifying Files, Use The “CheckWhen Modifying Files, Use The “Check--

Out” & CheckOut” & Check--In” OptionsIn” OptionsSh P i t F t W k B t U iSh P i t F t W k B t U i

10

Password: Welcome123@ •• SharePoint Features Work Best Using SharePoint Features Work Best Using Microsoft Internet ExplorerMicrosoft Internet Explorer

APA Member Look & Feel – Home Page Snapshot

Private DocumentsDocuments Now Visible

11

SharePoint Restricted Areas• Areas Restricted To APA TC Are

Only Visible When The TC Member Is Logged In Administrative Files: Orientation Administrative Files: Orientation

Material, TC Manuals, etc. Conference Planning Files Member Bios Member Bios Sub-Committee Working Files

• Working Groups• Working Groups HiLiftPW – Limited Access FDCinFM – Limited Access

12

• Survey

SharePoint Future Plans

H A Th APA TC D W W T U Th Sh P i • How, As The APA TC, Do We Want To Use The SharePoint Site? Post Presentations For Meetings For Easier Access Post Presentations For Meetings For Easier Access Collaboration On Working Files (Highlights Article, Best Paper,

Membership, etc) 1/2 Membership Roster (Excel Format)

Sub-Committee Working Files 1/2 Technical Program Chair Working Files 1/2 Technical Program Chair Working Files 1/2 Surveys – Approve Meeting Minutes Before Next Conference? Various Levels Of Access Restrictions Are Available

13

Others… (Need Inputs From TC)

SharePoint Summary

• APA SharePoint Site Continues To Evolve & Improve• SharePoint Structure Offers Many Benefits

D ’t N d T E il Fil B k & F th J t P i t T L ti Of Fil Don’t Need To Email Files Back & Forth – Just Point To Location Of File On SharePoint In Email

Version Control: Most Up-To-Date Version of Files Always On SharePoint Sit I t d Of TC M b ’ H d D iSite Instead Of TC Member’s Hard Drive

Historical Set Of Working Files For Conference Planning – Excellent Resource For Future Tech Chairs

• Feedback & Suggestions For Improvements To APA SharePoint – Send To Jim Guglielmo

14

• Web Address: https://info.aiaa.org/tac/ASG/APATC/default.aspx

15

Liaison Subcommittee

Applied Aerodynamics Meeting

Chicago IL 27 June 2010Chicago, IL 27 June 2010

S b itt M b hiSubcommittee Membership• Aerodynamic Measurements Technology T C – Aaron AltmanAerodynamic Measurements Technology T.C. Aaron Altman• Atmospheric Flight Mechanics T.C. – James DeSpirito• Ground Testing T.C. – Jim Guglielmo• European Space Institute/European Community – Frank Cotonp p p y• Meshing, Visualization, Computational Environments – Kyle Anderson• Thermophysics T.C. – (Vacant)• Fluid Dynamics T.C. – Aaron Altman• Powered Lift T.C. – (Vacant)• Brazilian Society of Mechanical Engineering and Sciences – J. Azevedo• SAE Aircraft Icing Technology Committee – Steve Morris

H TASP TC R b V l d• HyTASP TC – Rob Vermeland• Standing DBF Committee – Mark Chaffin• Propulsion T.C. – Brian McGrath• Aeroacoustics T C Tom Chyczewski

2

• Aeroacoustics T.C. – Tom Chyczewski

Purpose of the Liaison Subcommittee

1. To report on key activities of other Technical Committees and AIAA OrganizationsCommittees and AIAA Organizations.

2. To keep Applied Aero. T.C. members aware of th AIAA ti iti f i t tother AIAA activities of interest.

3. To maintain a dialogue/point of contact with other AIAA Committees and Organizations.

3

More Participation in the Liaison Subcommittee

• There are now 66 technical committees in AIAAAIAA.

• There is room for APA-TC members to link up ith th TC th t f i t t d twith other TCs that are of interest and act as

liaisons.

• Anyone interested in acting as a Liaison should contact me ([email protected]).

4

5

CFD High Lift Prediction Workshop

1st AIAA CFD High Lift Prediction WorkshopChicago, Illinois26-27 June 2010

Jeffrey SlotnickThe Boeing Company

HiLiftPW-1Introduction & Opening Remarks

AIAA HiLiftPW-1 — Chicago, IL June 2010 Slide 2 of 16


Overview

• Organizing Committee• Objectives• Background• Test Cases• Agenda

– Participant Guidelines & Information

• Participant Statistics• AIAA Special Sessions• Acknowledgments



• Jeffrey Slotnick and Tony SclafaniThe Boeing Company

• Rob LotzCD-adapco

• Mark Chaffin and David Levy*Cessna Aircraft Company

• Ralf RudnikDLR – German Aerospace Center

• Thomas WaymanGulfstream Aerospace Corporation

• Bob Stuever and Chittur “Venkat” VenkatasubbanHawker Beechcraft Corporation

• Judi Hannon and Chris RumseyNASA Langley Research Center

• Dimitri Mavriplis*University of Wyoming

* DPW organizing committee member

Organizing Committee



Objectives

• Assess the numerical prediction capability (meshing, numerics, turbulence modeling, high-performance computing requirements, etc.) of current-generation CFD technology/codes for swept, medium/high-aspect ratio wings in landing/take-off (high-lift) configurations

• Develop practical modeling guidelines for CFD prediction of high-lift flowfields

• Advance the understanding of high-lift flow physics toenable development of more accurate prediction methods and tools

• Enhance CFD prediction capability to enable practical high-lift aerodynamic design and optimization



Background

• 1998-1999 – First series of Trap Wing experiments in NASA LaRC14x22 WT and NASA ARC 12 Foot PWT

• 2002-2003 – Additional Trap Wing data collected in 14x22 WT• 2004-2006 – Preliminary discussion of a CFD High-Lift prediction

workshop based on Trap Wing datasets– External support (e.g. Boeing, etc.) grows during this timeframe– Initial thought is to have workshop organized and administered by

NASA• 2006-2007 – Idea of having the workshop organized through AIAA

(specifically APA) gains traction, and high-level discussions are held within the APA Vehicle Aerodynamics technical subcommittee

• Late 2008 – Support for workshop through AIAA is obtained from NASA and key external organizations

• Orlando 2009 – Official kick-off of workshop and formation of organizing committee

• Chicago 2010 – HiLiftPW-1



Test Cases

• Test Case 1 – Grid Convergence Study– Trap Wing “Config 1” (Slat 30, Flap 25)– Mach = 0.2, � = 13°, 28°– Re = 4.3M (based on MAC)– Tinf = 520°R– Coarse, Medium, Fine, Extra-Fine grids

• Test Case 2 – Alpha Sweep, Flap Increments– Trap Wing “Config 1” (Slat 30, Flap 25)– Trap Wing “Config 8” (Slat 30, Flap 20)– Mach = 0.2, � = 6°, 13°, 21°, 28°, 32°, 34°, 37°– Medium Grid

• Test Case 3 – Slat/Flap Support Effects – Trap Wing “Config 1” (Slat 30, Flap 25)– Mach = 0.2, � = 13°, 28°– Medium Grid

OPTIONAL



Agenda (Day 1)

DAY 1 — Saturday, June 26, 2010120 7:00 9:00 Registration (Coffee/Pasteries Provided)

Session 1: Introduction Slotnick15 9:00 AM 9:15 AM Wecome/Introduction Slotnick45 9:15 AM 10:00 AM Geometry/Experimental Data Summary Hannon30 10:00 AM 10:30 AM Grid System Overview Chaffin30 10:30 AM 11:00 AM BREAK

Session 2: Participant Presentations Levy20 11:00 AM 11:20 AM NASA LaRC CFL3D and FUN3D Contributions to HiLiftPW-1 Lee-Rausch20 11:20 AM 11:40 AM ONERA Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Wiart20 11:40 AM 12:00 PM JAXA Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Murayama90 12:00 PM 1:30 PM LUNCH (Not Provided)

Session 3: Participant Presentations Venkatasubban20 1:30 PM 1:50 PM CFS Engineering and RUAG Aviation Contribution to the Hift-Lift Prediction Workshop Vos20 1:50 PM 2:10 PM ANSYS, Inc. Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Steed

20 2:10 PM 2:30 PMOVERFLOW Analysis of the NASA Trap Wing Model Performed at Boeing, Huntington Beach, CA Sclafani

20 2:30 PM 2:50 PM NASA Ames Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Pulliam40 2:50 PM 3:30 PM BREAK (Refreshments Provided)

Session 4: Participant Presentations Mavriplis20 3:30 PM 3:50 PM Metacomp Technologies and CRL Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Goldberg20 3:50 PM 4:10 PM SWIFT and BETA CAE Systems Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Peddiraju/Luo20 4:10 PM 4:30 PM DLR Contribution to the first High Lift Workshop Rudnik20 4:30 PM 4:50 PM Numerical Aspects of NASA Trap-Wing Computations using the DLR TAU Code Crippa10 4:50 PM 5:00 PM Wrap-Up: DAY 1 Slotnick600



Agenda (Day 2)

DAY 2 — Sunday, June 27, 201060 8:00 AM 9:00 AM Coffee/Pasteries10 9:00 AM 9:10 AM Day 2 Intro/Announcements Slotnick

Session 5: Participant Presentations Rudnik20 9:10 AM 9:30 AM University of Wyoming Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Long20 9:30 AM 9:50 AM Unstructured Grid High Lift Aerodynamic Prediction Venkatasubban20 9:50 AM 10:10 AM FUN3D and NSU3D Comparisons for the HiLiftPW-1 Chaffin20 10:10 AM 10:30 AM Output-Based Grid Adaptation Applied to the HiLiftPW-1 Park30 10:30 AM 11:00 AM BREAK

Session 6: Participant Presentations Wayman20 11:00 AM 11:20 AM CFD High Lift Calculations using USM3D Abdol-Hamid20 11:20 AM 11:40 AM Participation in the 1st AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Reyes20 11:40 AM 12:00 PM FOI Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Eliasson80 12:00 PM 1:30 PM LUNCH (Not Provided)

Session 7: Participant Presentations Stuever

20 1:30 PM 1:50 PMParticipation of the Indian Institute of Science in the 1st AIAA CFD High Lift Prediction Workshop Mani

20 1:50 PM 2:10 PM Exa Contribution to HiLiftPW-1 Noelting

20 2:10 PM 2:30 PMAssessment of Grid-Induced Errors in HiLiftPW-1 Predictions Using Error Transport Equations Cavallo

30 2:30 PM 3:00 PM BREAK (Refreshments Provided)

Session 8: Workshop Data Summary & Open Forum Rumsey60 3:00 PM 4:00 PM Workshop Summary Rumsey45 4:00 PM 4:45 PM Panel Session Rumsey/Slotnick15 4:45 PM 5:00 PM Adjourn Slotnick530



Participant Guidelines & Information

• All participant presentations will be 15 minutes with 5 minutes Q/A (please wait until speaker is finished to ask questions)

• Presentations will be uploaded to the HiLiftPWwebsite (http://hiliftpw.larc.nasa.gov) after the workshop

• Updates (if desired) to the datasets will be collected after the workshop –Due date: September 6th



Participant Statistics

• 21 total presentations (32 initially registered on website)• 18 individual organizations from 8 countries• ~40% non-US participation



Participant Statistics (2)

• Broad participation from aerospace community




• 35 total datasets• Most participants used committee-generated grid

systems




• Most participants used unstructured mesh CFD tools and processes



Workshop Registration

• 66 total paid (on-line) registrants from 9 countries



AIAA Special Sessions

• Two special sessions have been reserved at the Aerospace Sciences Meeting (ASM) in Orlando 2011– HiLiftPW-1 overview and summary papers (with one-hour

presentations) are planned– Nine 30-minute time slots are reserved for participant presentations– One 30-minute slot is being reserved for an open forum

• Several additional participants would also like to publish their findings – Possible additional special session planned for the summer meeting in Hawaii 2011 (…Organizing committee to pursue this with APATC)– Potentially share more detailed technical analysis of HiLiftPW-1

datasets and results



Acknowledgments

• Trap Wing Test/CFD ExpertsPaul Johnson, Paul Meredith, Tony Washburn, Meelan Choudhari, Philippe Spalart, Anutosh Moitra

• Workshop Planning Advisory BoardJohn Vassberg, Neil Pfeiffer, Rich Wahls, Deepak Om, Doug Ball

• NASA Fundamental Aeronautics Subsonic Fixed Wing (SFW) Aerodynamics Technical Working Group (TWG)Mike Rogers, Greg Gatlin

• AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Technical CommitteeJim Guglielmo, Frank Coton, Rob Vermeland, Jim Despirito

• AIAA Conference Planning Staff Jean Riley, KC Neidermeyr