alazan lofts crm el paso street at s colorado street san

50
Alazan Lofts CRM El Paso Street at S Colorado Street San Antonio, TX Date Pictures Taken: February 13-14, 2020 Terracon Project No. 90197716 Responsive Resourceful Reliable Photo 17. BHT 3: North profile Photo 18. BHT3: Mixed mid to late 20 th century colorless, patinated colorless, and brown glass with modern trash (duct tape roll, plastic lid, aluminum screw tops) from upper foot of excavation, can tab (ca. 1965-1975), and machine-cut bone Photo 19. BHT 4 Overview: Facing northeast Photo 20. BHT 4: (left) east profile overview; (right) south trench profile

Upload: others

Post on 02-Dec-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Alazan Lofts CRM ■ El Paso Street at S Colorado Street San Antonio, TX Date Pictures Taken: February 13-14, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

Photo 17. BHT 3: North profile

Photo 18. BHT3: Mixed mid to late 20th century colorless, patinated colorless, and brown glass with modern trash (duct tape roll, plastic lid, aluminum screw tops) from upper foot of excavation, can tab (ca. 1965-1975), and machine-cut

bone

Photo 19. BHT 4 Overview: Facing northeast Photo 20. BHT 4: (left) east profile overview; (right) south trench profile

Alazan Lofts CRM ■ El Paso Street at S Colorado Street San Antonio, TX Date Pictures Taken: February 13-14, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

Photo 21. BHT 5 Overview, facing east Photo 22. BHT 5: south profile overview

Photo 23. BHT 5 Artifacts: Mid to late 20th century materials including machine made brick (post 1880s), hand-made brick (up until early 20th), one “D’hanis CBMA” brick, machine-cut bone, colorless glass, and glass

bottle

Photo 24. BHT 5 Artifacts; Close-up of glass bottle that reads “Mellins Infant’s Food Doliber-Goodal Co. Boston”; Mellin’s infant’s food was first manufactured

in the late 1860s

Alazan Lofts CRM ■ El Paso Street at S Colorado Street San Antonio, TX Date Pictures Taken: February 13-14, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

Photo 25. BHT 6 Overview, facing southwest Photo 26. BHT 6: south profile overview

Photo 27. BHT 6 Artifacts: Mid to late 20th c. brick, mortar, colorless and bright green bottle glass, white ware fragments from upper foot of

excavation Photo 28. KM01 overview; (right) colorless and green glass (c. 19th c. -present)

Alazan Lofts CRM ■ El Paso Street at S Colorado Street San Antonio, TX Date Pictures Taken: February 13-14, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

Photo 29. KM04 Overview Photo 30. KM04 Artifacts: Mix of mid-late 20th c. fragmented glass, metal, brick,

machine-cut bone, wire nails, and one decal ware sherd

Photo 31. VP01 Overview; (right) colorless glass shard Photo 32. VP02 Overview; (right) Fragmented mid-late 20th c. materials from

below road base that made up the upper ~25cm

Alazan Lofts CRM ■ El Paso Street at S Colorado Street San Antonio, TX Date Pictures Taken: February 13-14, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

Photo 33. VP03 Overview of more developed, deeper soil than seen in other tests

Photo 34. Example of patchy asphalt and ground cover that was present within Parcels 2,4, and 5

Photo 35. Sediment build up on Parcel 2 which has covered and begun to bury the sidewalk

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

APPENDIX C

Backhoe Trench Descriptions

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

Backhoe trench descriptions

BHT #

Zone Thickness

(cm) Munsell Consistence Texture

Pedogenic Structure and

Boundary Notes

1

1 15 10YR 2/1

Black Friable Clay loam

Weak fine blocky with clear wavy lower boundary

One white stoneware sherd observed in back dirt

2 80

10YR 3/2-4/2 Very

dark grayish brown-dark

grayish brown

Friable Gravelly

clay

No structure observed; clear

wavy lower boundary

Clay observed on clasts; poorly sorted subrounded gravels 1cm to

7cm in diameter

3 85 10 YR 8/1

White Moderate firm-firm

Clay loam

Weak medium-coarse blocky; no lower boundary

observed

Chalky white sediment mottled with subrounded gravels and 10YR 8/6

clay

2

1 60-90 10 YR 2/2 Very dark

brown Friable Clay loam

Weak fine blocky with clear wavy lower boundary

Subrounded cobbles and pebbles dispersed throughout, mid to late

20th century artifacts (metal, ceramic, glass) dispersed

throughout; a clay utility pipe runs southwest through the northern 6ft of trench; flecked rust, charcoal, and

other mottle inclusions observed throughout matrix, indicating heavy

disturbance

1a 8-10 10YR 8/1

White Friable --

No structure; distinct

boundaries in both profiles

Thin lens of white chalky material with approximately 30-40% rounded pebbles (2-6cm) which is present in both profiles; artifacts are present

above and below this feature

2 50-75

10YR 4/4 Dark

yellowish brown

Moderate firm

Gravelly clay

Weak medium-coarse blocky; clear irregular

lower boundary

Approximately 75% cherty cobbles and pebbles, mostly clast-on-clast

but some clay is observed between clasts; clasts are generally poorly

sorted; this zone is not present in to the same extent in the northeast

profile

2a ~25cm 10YR 2/1

Black Firm Clay

Moderate fine-coarse blocky

structure; distinct boundary

Small pocket of black clay wedged under Zone I, south of Zone II, and

above Zone III

3 45-80 10YR 8/1

White Moderate

friable-firm

No structure observed; no

lower boundary observed

Chalky white sediment mottled with poorly sorted subrounded gravels

(1-8cm diameter) and 10YR 8/6 clay on and between clasts

3 1 42 10 YR 2/2 Very dark

brown

Moderately friable

Clay loam

Weak fine-medium blocky

with clear, smooth-wavy

lower boundary

Modern debris intermixed with sediment matrix; 2 wires from wall

but no other infrastructure or residential/domestic features

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

BHT #

Zone Thickness

(cm) Munsell Consistence Texture

Pedogenic Structure and

Boundary Notes

2 38

10YR 4/2 Dark

grayish brown

-- Gravelly

clay

No structure observed;

gradual-smooth lower boundary

Similarly, gravelly deposit observed elsewhere on site, different from deposit below in having slightly

more and darker fine matrix

3 60

10 YR 4/4 Dark

yellowish brown

-- Gravelly

clay

No structure observed; no

lower boundary observed

Gravelly subsoil; no artifacts or other debris observed

4

1 50 10 YR 2/2 Very dark

brown Loose Clay loam

Weak fine-coarse blocky; gradual, smooth lower

boundary

Topsoil with approximately 25% subrounded gravels dispersed

throughout

2 70 10 YR 5/4 Yellowish

brown Very firm

Gravelly clay

Moderate fine-coarse blocky

structure; diffuse lower boundary

Rounded-subrounded poorly sorted, matrix-supported pebbles to

cobbles (1cm-15cm)

3 55 10 YR 8/1

White Moderately friable-firm

Gravelly clay

No structure observed; no

lower boundary observed

Gravelly subsoil; no artifacts or other debris observed

5

1 20 10 YR 3/1 Very dark

gray Friable Clay

Weak medium blocky with clear

smooth lower boundary

Developed topsoil with bricks

2 35 10 YR 3/1 Very dark

gray

Moderately friable

Clay

Moderate medium blocky

with gradual smooth lower

boundary

Few bone, whiteware, colorless "Mellins infant's food" bottle; white

ware and bone were in profile at approximately 25cmbs

3 55 10 YR 4/3

Brown Firm Clay

Strong coarse blocky with

gradual smooth lower boundary

Very firm calcareous clay with few carbonate nodules

4 20 10 YR 7/3 Very pale

brown Firm Clay

Strong coarse blocky with clear

smooth lower boundary

Very firm calcareous clay with common carbonate nodules and

coats

5 30 10 YR 7/3 Very pale

brown --

Gravelly clay

No structure observed; no

lower boundary observed

Very firm calcareous clay with common carbonate nodules and coats; approximately 50% coarse

fragments

6

1 30 10 YR 8/2-8/3 Very

pale brown Firm-friable

Road base

No structure; distinct smooth lower boundary

Compacted gravel road base

2 20 10 YR 2/2 Very dark

brown Friable Clay loam

Weak fine-coarse blocky; gradual, smooth lower

boundary

Approximately 40% matrix supported, poorly sorted

subrounded pebbles to cobbles (2-6cm diameter); few mid to late 20th

c. artifacts

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

BHT #

Zone Thickness

(cm) Munsell Consistence Texture

Pedogenic Structure and

Boundary Notes

3 140

10 YR 5/4-4/4

Yellowish brown to

Dark yellowish

brown

Moderately firm

Gravelly clay loam

No structure observed; clear smooth lower

boundary

Approximately 70% matrix supported, poorly sorted

subrounded pebbles to cobbles (2-6cm diameter)

4 10 10YR 8/1

White Friable-firm

Gravelly chalky

sediment/bedrock

No structure observed; no

lower boundary observed

Chalky white sediment mottled with poorly sorted subround gravels (1-8cm diameter) and <5%10YR 8/6

clay on and between clasts

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

APPENDIX D

Shovel Test Log

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

ST# Depth (cmbs)

+ / -

Ground Cover

Munsell Color Texture Inclusions Comments

KM01 0-20 + <5% 10YR 2/1 Black Clay

Very Many (>50%)

Extremely compact clay with abundant poorly sorted gravels; glass and brick frags in upper 10cm; large chunks of limestone; roots

near surface

20-25 - -- 10YR 2/1 Black Clay -- Terminated at compact

KM02 0-20 - <5% 10YR 4/2 Dark grayish brown

Clay loam

Very Many (>50%)

Very compact gravelly clay loam, abundant poorly sorted gravels with high % pea gravel;

one brick fragment in upper 10cm; roots abundant at surface; terminated at compact

KM03

0-20 _ <5% 10YR 2/1 Black Clay Very Many

(>50%)

Compact very gravelly clay; gravels poorly sorted; roots abundant at surface; 10-

20cmbs is 10YR 2/1 Black with mottles of 2.5Y 6/6 Olive yellow & 6/3 Light yellowish

brown; large chunks of rock

20-30 _ -- Terminated at compact

KM04

0-20 + <5% 10YR 2/1 Black Clay Very Many

(>50%)

Very compact clay; roots at surface; abundant poorly sorted gravels; abundant glass and less abundant metal, bone, and

ceramics; mottled with white clay below ~ 15 cmbs; 7.5YR 2.5/1 Black mottles

20-30 + -- -- -- -- Terminated at rock

KM05 0-15 _ <5% 10YR 2/1 Black Clay Very Many

(>50%)

Very compact clay; gravel so abundant and poorly sorted; terminated at impassible

gravel

VP01 0-20 + 80-90%

10YR 3/2 Very dark grayish brown to 3/3 Dark brown

Clay loam

Very Many (>50%)

SW of BHT2; very gravelly at surface but some topsoil development; very very gravelly

at ~ 10cmbs with little soil; terminated at concrete

VP02

0-10 - 60-80% 10YR 6/2 Light brownish gray

Sandy silt

Very Many (>50%)

ROAD BASE; some topsoil development; angular gravel

10-25 - -- 10YR 8/2 Very

pale brown Silt

Very Many (>50%)

Chalky angular gravel and some round gravel

25-30 + -- 10YR 3/2 Very dark grayish

brown

Clay loam

Very Many (>50%)

Some darker clay appearing but very cobbly, pebbly; terminated at impassible gravel

VP03

0-10 - 90+% 10YR 4/1 Dark

gray Clay loam

Many (>20%)

Ap with gravelly fill, mostly round-subround

10-45 - -- 10YR 2/1 Black Clay loam

Common (2-20%)

Very compact hard clay loam; ~ 10% round cobbles and pebbles; minor ~ 2% CaCO3;

terminated at compact

Archaeological Survey Report

Alazan Lofts Project ■ San Antonio, Texas

March 17, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 90197716

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable

APPENDIX E

Deed Records

1

Peters, Jennifer T

From: Pagano, Victoria CSent: Monday, May 18, 2020 12:17 PMTo: Peters, Jennifer TCc: Yelacic, David MSubject: FW: Project Review: 202011997

Hot off the press, we’ve got our concurrence for Alazan.

Victoria C. Pagano, M.A., RPA18103

Staff Archaeologist | Field ScientistNatural Cultural Resources | Environmental

Terracon6911 Blanco Road I San Antonio, TX 78216D (210) 641 2112 I O (210) 714 2096 I M (210) 844 [email protected] I terracon.com

From: [email protected] <[email protected]>Sent: Monday, May 18, 2020 12:15 PMTo: Pagano, Victoria C <[email protected]>; [email protected]: Project Review: 202011997

Re: Project Review under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and/or the Antiquities Code of TexasPermit 9277THC Tracking #202011997Alazan Lofts ProjectEl Paso and S. Colorado StreetsSan Antonio,TX

Dear Victoria C. Pagano:Thank you for your submittal regarding the above-referenced project. This response represents the comments of theState Historic Preservation Officer, the Executive Director of the Texas Historical Commission (THC), pursuant to reviewunder Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the Antiquities Code of Texas.

The review staff led by Emily Dylla and Charles Peveto has completed its review and has made the followingdeterminations based on the information submitted for review:

Above-Ground Resources

2

• No historic properties are present or affected by the project as proposed. However, if historic properties arediscovered or unanticipated effects on historic properties are found, work should cease in the immediate area;work can continue where no historic properties are present. Please contact the THC's History Programs Divisionat 512-463-5853 to consult on further actions that may be necessary to protect historic properties.

Archeology Comments• No effect on archeological sites. However, if buried cultural materials are encountered during construction ordisturbance activities, work should cease in the immediate area; work can continue where no cultural materialsare present. Please contact the THC's Archeology Division at 512-463-6096 to consult on further actions thatmay be necessary to protect the cultural remains.• THC/SHPO concurs with information provided.• Draft report acceptable. Please submit another copy as a final report along with shapefiles showing the areawhere the archeological work was conducted. Shapefiles should be submitted electronically [email protected].

We look forward to further consultation with your office and hope to maintain a partnership that will foster effectivehistoric preservation. Thank you for your cooperation in this review process, and for your efforts to preserve theirreplaceable heritage of Texas. If you have any questions concerning our review or if we can be of further assistance,please email the following reviewers: [email protected], [email protected]

This response has been sent through the electronic THC review and compliance system (eTRAC). Submitting your projectvia eTRAC eliminates mailing delays and allows you to check the status of the review, receive an electronic response,and generate reports on your submissions. For more information, visit http://thc.texas.gov/etrac-system.

Sincerely,

For Mark Wolfe, State Historic Preservation OfficerExecutive Director, Texas Historical Commission

Please do not respond to this email.

1

Peters, Jennifer T

From: Yelacic, David MSent: Friday, April 17, 2020 9:05 AMTo: Gary Dillard; Mike ZelenkofskeCc: Pagano, Victoria C; Peters, Jennifer TSubject: FW: [EXTERNAL] Alazan report revision

Hi Gary and Mike,

Please see the e-mails below from OHP; they have provided a conditional approval of our report, and they have clearedthe hold on the plat application. We will get their additional revisions addressed as quickly as we are able.

Thank you,DY

David M. Yelacic, RPA 990286Archaeologist, Principal Investigator

Terracon Consultants, Inc.6911 Blanco Road I San Antonio, TX 78216P [210] 714-2131 I F [210] 641 2124

CLICK ON THE LOGO TO LEARN MORE

From: Matthew Elverson (OHP) <[email protected]>Sent: Friday, April 17, 2020 9:01 AMTo: Yelacic, David M <[email protected]>Cc: Pagano, Victoria C <[email protected]>; Shawn Marceaux (OHP) <[email protected]>Subject: RE: [EXTERNAL] Alazan report revision

Hi David,

Yes—the plat has been approved and I have communicated the approval status to my contact for the plat (Jesse Valdez,MBC Engineers).

Best,

Matthew

Matthew T. Elverson, M.A., R.P.A.City Archaeologist

2

City of San Antonio · Office of Historic Preservation1901 South AlamoSan Antonio, Texas [email protected]: 210-207-5421 · Office: 210-207-0035

How are we doing? Please take our short customer service survey.

Archaeology supports the CORE VALUESTeamwork - Integrity - Innovation - Professionalism

From: Yelacic, David M <[email protected]>Sent: Friday, April 17, 2020 8:58 AMTo: Matthew Elverson (OHP) <[email protected]>Cc: Pagano, Victoria C <[email protected]>; Shawn Marceaux (OHP) <[email protected]>Subject: RE: [EXTERNAL] Alazan report revision

Hi Matthew,

Thanks for your speedy attention! Do I understand that this conditional approval will clear the hold on their plat?

We will get the revisions addressed as quickly as we are able.

DYDavid M. Yelacic, RPA 990286Archaeologist, Principal Investigator

Terracon Consultants, Inc.6911 Blanco Road I San Antonio, TX 78216P [210] 714-2131 I F [210] 641 2124

CLICK ON THE LOGO TO LEARN MORE

From: Matthew Elverson (OHP) <[email protected]>Sent: Friday, April 17, 2020 8:47 AMTo: Yelacic, David M <[email protected]>Cc: Pagano, Victoria C <[email protected]>; Shawn Marceaux (OHP) <[email protected]>Subject: RE: [EXTERNAL] Alazan report revision

3

Hi David,

Thank you for making the requested revisions. The report is conditionally approved with the following stipulations:

Please correct the APE on the 1886 figure (Fig. 11). The APE boundaries are not correctly plotted.Please review the text referencing the 1886 figure (top of page 16). Buildings are present within the APE on thefigure.Since this is subject to the NRHP, please ensure you are using APE throughout and not Project Area.

Thanks!

Matthew T. Elverson, M.A., R.P.A.City Archaeologist

City of San Antonio · Office of Historic Preservation1901 South AlamoSan Antonio, Texas [email protected]: 210-207-5421 · Office: 210-207-0035

How are we doing? Please take our short customer service survey.

Archaeology supports the CORE VALUESTeamwork - Integrity - Innovation - Professionalism

From: Yelacic, David M <[email protected]>Sent: Thursday, April 16, 2020 4:32 PMTo: Matthew Elverson (OHP) <[email protected]>Cc: Pagano, Victoria C <[email protected]>; Shawn Marceaux (OHP) <[email protected]>Subject: [EXTERNAL] Alazan report revision

Hi Matthew,

Please find our revised draft for archaeological investigations at Alazan. The developer needs to have the plat approvedand recorded by April 20th at noon in order to meet their closing deadline. Please let me or Tori know if you havequestions or concerns.

Best regards,DY

David M. Yelacic, RPA 990286Archaeologist, Principal Investigator

Terracon Consultants, Inc.

4

6911 Blanco Road I San Antonio, TX 78216 andP [210] 714-2131 I F [210] 641 2124

CLICK ON THE LOGO TO LEARN MORE

Terracon provides environmental, facilities, geotechnical, and materials consulting engineering services delivered withresponsiveness, resourcefulness, and reliability.

Private and confidential as detailed here (www.terracon.com/disclaimer). If you cannot access the hyperlink, please e-mailsender.

**THIS EMAIL IS FROM AN EXTERNAL SENDER OUTSIDE OF THE CITY.**

Be cautious before clicking links or opening attachments from unknown sources. Do not provide personal or confidentialinformation.

**THIS EMAIL IS FROM AN EXTERNAL SENDER OUTSIDE OF THE CITY.**

Be cautious before clicking links or opening attachments from unknown sources. Do not provide personal or

confidential information.

1901 S. ALAMO ST, SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS 78204

210.207.7991 • Fax: 210.207.0199 • [email protected] • www.sanantonio.gov/historic

March 18, 2020

Mr. Charles M. Peveto, Historian Texas Historical Commission P.O. Box 12276 Austin, TX 78711-2276

Re: Historical significance of multiple properties included in the Alazan Lofts Project, San Antonio, Bexar Co., TX City of San Antonio Neighborhood & Housing Services Department

Dear Mr. Peveto:

The above referenced properties included in the Alazan Lofts Project, San Antonio, TX, are located inside the original 36-Square Mile Survey area, and have been surveyed by the Office of Historic Preservation.

There is only one standing structure included in the request for review, 1021 El Paso Street. OHP staff reviewed a request to demolish the structure at that address and approved the request by Certificate of Appropriateness on October 23, 2019. All other parcels are vacant.

The properties are not eligible for individual historic designation.

Sincerely,

jenny hay, Ph.D. Special Projects Manager Office of Historic Preservation

April 1, 2020

Victoria Pagano Terracon Consultants, Inc. 6911 Blanco Road San Antonio, Texas 78216 Re: Project Review under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the Antiquities Code of Texas, Alazan Lofts Project, Bexar County, Texas (THC Tracking No. 202010117) Dear Ms. Pagano: Thank you for your submittal regarding the above-referenced project. This response represents the comments of the State Historic Preservation Officer, the Executive Director of the Texas Historical Commission (THC), pursuant to review under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the Antiquities Code of Texas. The review staff, led by Emily Dylla and Charles Peveto, has completed its review and has made the following determinations based on the information submitted for review: Above-Ground Resources: No historic properties are present or affected by the project as proposed. However, if historic properties are discovered or unanticipated effects on historic properties are found, work should cease in the immediate area; work can continue where no historic properties are present. Please contact the THC's History Programs Division at 512-463-5853 to consult on further actions that may be necessary to protect historic properties. Archeology: The THC concurs with your recommendation that 41BX2343 is ineligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places or as a State Antiquities Landmark due to a lack of integrity and lack of affiliation with persons or events important to history. However, we have comments that should be addressed before we can accept it. Please address the comments provided on the following page and submit a revised report to this agency. We look forward to further consultation with your office and hope to maintain a partnership that will foster effective historic preservation. Thank you for your cooperation in this review process, and for your efforts to preserve the irreplaceable heritage of Texas. If you have any questions concerning our review or if we can be of further assistance, please email the following reviewers: [email protected] and [email protected]. Sincerely, for Mark Wolfe, State Historic Preservation Officer Executive Director, Texas Historical Commission MW/ed

Victoria Pagano Page 2 of 2

Please make the following changes to the report prior to submitting the final.

Regulatory Comments:

1. Curation (or in this case, the alternative to curation) should be addressed in the abstract and body of the report (introduction and in a separate section towards the end).

2. Introduction should include discussion of COSA’s oversight on this project due to the UDC. 3. As per CTA reporting guidelines (3.4), the results section should include a discussion/quantification

of artifacts encountered during the fieldwork. 4. A report-only curation plan for a negative-survey must include reproductions of all the materials you

would normally curate with a facility (scanned field notes, shovel test logs, photographs, photologs, etc.) as an appendix in your report. Please also be aware some curatorial facilities have existing requirements for no-find survey curation in reports. Please check with your proposed repository to ensure you prepare your materials for curation as an appendix to those requirements.

Editorial Comments:

1. Section 4.2 repeatedly misuses the term ‘historic’, please correct. 2. Section 6.1 is titled ‘Pedestrian Survey’ but only describes shovel testing, please correct. 3. Appendix 7 Photo 7 is missing the direction in which the photograph was taken. 4. Please confirm Photo 26 is not actually missing from Appendix B (appeared to be missing during

review). 5. Multiple typographical errors were noted throughout, so please perform an additional copy edit of

the entire document.

Laura Salinas-MartinezDigitally signed by Laura Salinas-Martinez

Date: 2020.03.20 11:07:36 -05'00'

1400 South Flores, San Antonio, TX 78204 www.sanantonio.gov/nhsd (210) 207-6459

 

February 18, 2020  Bryant Celestine, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer Alabama‐Coushatta Tribe of Texas 571 State Park Road 56 Livingston, TX 77351  Re:  Alazan Lofts (multiple addresses on 18 tracts of land along El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado), San Antonio, Texas  Dear Mr. Celestine,  The City of San Antonio is considering funding the project listed above with federal funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).  Under HUD regulation 24 CFR 58.4, the City of San Antonio has assumed HUD’s environmental  review  responsibilities  for  the project,  including  tribal consultation  related  to  historic  properties.    Historic  properties  include  archeological  sites,  burial grounds,  sacred  landscapes or  features,  ceremonial  areas,  traditional  cultural places  and  landscapes, plant and animal communities, and buildings and structures with significant tribal association.  The City of San Antonio is conducting a review of this project to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and its implementing regulations 36 CFR Part 800.  The City would respectfully invite the tribe to be a consulting party  in this review to help  identify historic properties  in the project area that may have religious and cultural significance to the tribe, and  if such properties exist, to help assess how the project might affect them.  If the project might have an adverse effect, we would like to discuss possible ways to avoid, minimize or mitigate potential adverse effects.   If the tribe would like to be a consulting party on this project, to meet project timeframes, please let us know of the tribe’s  interest within 30 days.   If there are  initial concerns with  impacts of the project on religious or cultural properties, please note them in your response.  The project consists of the following scope of work:  constructing an 88‐unit multifamily rental housing development, consisting of two buildings. The development will include one four story building with 70 units and the other will be three stories and include 18 units, as well as a fitness center, activity room, community kitchen, business center, and associated parking areas. Up to ten percent of the units will be rented at  the going market  rate, and  the  remainder will  include either public housing or  the monthly rate will be capped at 60 percent or less of the area median income.  The HOME Investment Partnership Program  provides  funds  for  the  construction  of  affordable  housing,  increasing  the  availability  of affordable housing in cities and states where a deficit exists.  Enclosed are maps that show the project area.  In preparation of  this project, an archaeological  survey,  including a 100‐percent  systematic and intensive pedestrian survey and mechanical prospection, was conducted the week of February 10, 2020.  

HUD’s process  for tribal consultation under Section 106  is described  in HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006.   HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006 can be viewed at this web address: http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=env_notice_tribe_con.pdf  For more information on the Section 106 review process the following link is available: https://www.onecpd.info/resource/2813/historic‐preservation‐basics/  If  the  tribe  does  not wish  to  consult  on  this  project,  please  feel  free  to  contact my  office  via  email at [email protected] or by letter.  If the tribe does wish to consult, the City respectfully requests a written response  including the name and contact  information for the tribe’s principal representative for the consultation.    The City of San Antonio values the tribe’s assistance and looks forward to consulting further if there are historic properties of religious and cultural significance that may be affected by this project.      Sincerely,  

 Laura Salinas Martinez Grants Administrator San Antonio Certifying Officer  Attachments

Date:      February 6, 2020  Project:    Alazan Lofts ‐ Multi Family Rental Development   Project Location:  Multiple Addresses on El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado Street   HUD Funds:    CDBG Funds 

 Project Description 

 Alazan Lofts  is a new construction 88‐unit multifamily development  located at scattered sites on El Paso Street, Torreon Street and S. Colorado Street in Council District 5.  Alazan Lofts will offer 1, 2 and 3 bedroom units to families and  individuals earning 30%, 50% and 60% of AMI.  Market  rate  units  will  also  be  offered.    Square  footage  will  range  from  687SF  for  a  one bedroom/one bath to 1,204SF for a three bedroom/two bath unit. 

1400 South Flores, San Antonio, TX 78204 www.sanantonio.gov/nhsd (210) 207-6459

 

February 18, 2020  Nita Battise, Chairperson Alabama‐Coushatta Tribe of Texas 571 State Park Road 56 Livingston, TX 77351  Re:  Alazan Lofts (multiple addresses on 18 tracts of land along El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado), San Antonio, Texas  Dear Ms. Battise,  The City of San Antonio is considering funding the project listed above with federal funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).  Under HUD regulation 24 CFR 58.4, the City of San Antonio has assumed HUD’s environmental  review  responsibilities  for  the project,  including  tribal consultation  related  to  historic  properties.    Historic  properties  include  archeological  sites,  burial grounds,  sacred  landscapes or  features,  ceremonial  areas,  traditional  cultural places  and  landscapes, plant and animal communities, and buildings and structures with significant tribal association.  The City of San Antonio is conducting a review of this project to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and its implementing regulations 36 CFR Part 800.  The City would respectfully invite the tribe to be a consulting party  in this review to help  identify historic properties  in the project area that may have religious and cultural significance to the tribe, and  if such properties exist, to help assess how the project might affect them.  If the project might have an adverse effect, we would like to discuss possible ways to avoid, minimize or mitigate potential adverse effects.   If the tribe would like to be a consulting party on this project, to meet project timeframes, please let us know of the tribe’s  interest within 30 days.   If there are  initial concerns with  impacts of the project on religious or cultural properties, please note them in your response.  The project consists of the following scope of work:  constructing an 88‐unit multifamily rental housing development, consisting of two buildings. The development will include one four story building with 70 units and the other will be three stories and include 18 units, as well as a fitness center, activity room, community kitchen, business center, and associated parking areas. Up to ten percent of the units will be rented at  the going market  rate, and  the  remainder will  include either public housing or  the monthly rate will be capped at 60 percent or less of the area median income.  The HOME Investment Partnership Program  provides  funds  for  the  construction  of  affordable  housing,  increasing  the  availability  of affordable housing in cities and states where a deficit exists.  Enclosed are maps that show the project area.  In preparation of  this project, an archaeological  survey,  including a 100‐percent  systematic and intensive pedestrian survey and mechanical prospection, was conducted the week of February 10, 2020.  

HUD’s process  for tribal consultation under Section 106  is described  in HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006.   HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006 can be viewed at this web address: http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=env_notice_tribe_con.pdf  For more information on the Section 106 review process the following link is available: https://www.onecpd.info/resource/2813/historic‐preservation‐basics/  If  the  tribe  does  not wish  to  consult  on  this  project,  please  feel  free  to  contact my  office  via  email at [email protected] or by letter.  If the tribe does wish to consult, the City respectfully requests a written response  including the name and contact  information for the tribe’s principal representative for the consultation.    The City of San Antonio values the tribe’s assistance and looks forward to consulting further if there are historic properties of religious and cultural significance that may be affected by this project.      Sincerely,  

 Laura Salinas Martinez Grants Administrator San Antonio Certifying Officer  Attachments

Date:      February 6, 2020  Project:    Alazan Lofts ‐ Multi Family Rental Development   Project Location:  Multiple Addresses on El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado Street   HUD Funds:    CDBG Funds 

 Project Description 

 Alazan Lofts  is a new construction 88‐unit multifamily development  located at scattered sites on El Paso Street, Torreon Street and S. Colorado Street in Council District 5.  Alazan Lofts will offer 1, 2 and 3 bedroom units to families and  individuals earning 30%, 50% and 60% of AMI.  Market  rate  units  will  also  be  offered.    Square  footage  will  range  from  687SF  for  a  one bedroom/one bath to 1,204SF for a three bedroom/two bath unit. 

1400 South Flores, San Antonio, TX 78204 www.sanantonio.gov/nhsd (210) 207-6459

 

February 18, 2020  Bob Komardley, Chairman Apache Tribe of Oklahoma PO Box 1330 Anadarko, OK 73005  Re:  Alazan Lofts (multiple addresses on 18 tracts of land along El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado), San Antonio, Texas  Dear Mr. Komardley,  The City of San Antonio is considering funding the project listed above with federal funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).  Under HUD regulation 24 CFR 58.4, the City of San Antonio has assumed HUD’s environmental  review  responsibilities  for  the project,  including  tribal consultation  related  to  historic  properties.    Historic  properties  include  archeological  sites,  burial grounds,  sacred  landscapes or  features,  ceremonial  areas,  traditional  cultural places  and  landscapes, plant and animal communities, and buildings and structures with significant tribal association.  The City of San Antonio is conducting a review of this project to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and its implementing regulations 36 CFR Part 800.  The City would respectfully invite the tribe to be a consulting party  in this review to help  identify historic properties  in the project area that may have religious and cultural significance to the tribe, and  if such properties exist, to help assess how the project might affect them.  If the project might have an adverse effect, we would like to discuss possible ways to avoid, minimize or mitigate potential adverse effects.   If the tribe would like to be a consulting party on this project, to meet project timeframes, please let us know of the tribe’s  interest within 30 days.   If there are  initial concerns with  impacts of the project on religious or cultural properties, please note them in your response.  The project consists of the following scope of work:  constructing an 88‐unit multifamily rental housing development, consisting of two buildings. The development will include one four story building with 70 units and the other will be three stories and include 18 units, as well as a fitness center, activity room, community kitchen, business center, and associated parking areas. Up to ten percent of the units will be rented at  the going market  rate, and  the  remainder will  include either public housing or  the monthly rate will be capped at 60 percent or less of the area median income.  The HOME Investment Partnership Program  provides  funds  for  the  construction  of  affordable  housing,  increasing  the  availability  of affordable housing in cities and states where a deficit exists.  Enclosed are maps that show the project area.  In preparation of  this project, an archaeological  survey,  including a 100‐percent  systematic and intensive pedestrian survey and mechanical prospection, was conducted the week of February 10, 2020.  

HUD’s process  for tribal consultation under Section 106  is described  in HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006.   HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006 can be viewed at this web address: http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=env_notice_tribe_con.pdf  For more information on the Section 106 review process the following link is available: https://www.onecpd.info/resource/2813/historic‐preservation‐basics/  If  the  tribe  does  not wish  to  consult  on  this  project,  please  feel  free  to  contact my  office  via  email at [email protected] or by letter.  If the tribe does wish to consult, the City respectfully requests a written response  including the name and contact  information for the tribe’s principal representative for the consultation.    The City of San Antonio values the tribe’s assistance and looks forward to consulting further if there are historic properties of religious and cultural significance that may be affected by this project.      Sincerely,  

 Laura Salinas Martinez Grants Administrator San Antonio Certifying Officer  Attachments

Date:      February 6, 2020  Project:    Alazan Lofts ‐ Multi Family Rental Development   Project Location:  Multiple Addresses on El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado Street   HUD Funds:    CDBG Funds 

 Project Description 

 Alazan Lofts  is a new construction 88‐unit multifamily development  located at scattered sites on El Paso Street, Torreon Street and S. Colorado Street in Council District 5.  Alazan Lofts will offer 1, 2 and 3 bedroom units to families and  individuals earning 30%, 50% and 60% of AMI.  Market  rate  units  will  also  be  offered.    Square  footage  will  range  from  687SF  for  a  one bedroom/one bath to 1,204SF for a three bedroom/two bath unit. 

1400 South Flores, San Antonio, TX 78204 www.sanantonio.gov/nhsd (210) 207-6459

 

February 18, 2020  Martina Minthorn, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer Comanche Nation, Oklahoma 6 SW D Avenue Lawton, OK 73502  Re:  Alazan Lofts (multiple addresses on 18 tracts of land along El Paso, Torreon and S. Colorado), San Antonio, Texas  Dear Mrs. Minthorn,  The City of San Antonio is considering funding the project listed above with federal funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).  Under HUD regulation 24 CFR 58.4, the City of San Antonio has assumed HUD’s environmental  review  responsibilities  for  the project,  including  tribal consultation  related  to  historic  properties.    Historic  properties  include  archeological  sites,  burial grounds,  sacred  landscapes or  features,  ceremonial  areas,  traditional  cultural places  and  landscapes, plant and animal communities, and buildings and structures with significant tribal association.  The City of San Antonio is conducting a review of this project to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and its implementing regulations 36 CFR Part 800.  The City would respectfully invite the tribe to be a consulting party  in this review to help  identify historic properties  in the project area that may have religious and cultural significance to the tribe, and  if such properties exist, to help assess how the project might affect them.  If the project might have an adverse effect, we would like to discuss possible ways to avoid, minimize or mitigate potential adverse effects.   If the tribe would like to be a consulting party on this project, to meet project timeframes, please let us know of the tribe’s  interest within 30 days.   If there are  initial concerns with  impacts of the project on religious or cultural properties, please note them in your response.  The project consists of the following scope of work:  constructing an 88‐unit multifamily rental housing development, consisting of two buildings. The development will include one four story building with 70 units and the other will be three stories and include 18 units, as well as a fitness center, activity room, community kitchen, business center, and associated parking areas. Up to ten percent of the units will be rented at  the going market  rate, and  the  remainder will  include either public housing or  the monthly rate will be capped at 60 percent or less of the area median income.  The HOME Investment Partnership Program  provides  funds  for  the  construction  of  affordable  housing,  increasing  the  availability  of affordable housing in cities and states where a deficit exists.  Enclosed are maps that show the project area.  In preparation of  this project, an archaeological  survey,  including a 100‐percent  systematic and intensive pedestrian survey and mechanical prospection, was conducted the week of February 10, 2020.  

HUD’s process  for tribal consultation under Section 106  is described  in HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006.   HUD Notice CPD‐12‐006 can be viewed at this web address: http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=env_notice_tribe_con.pdf  For more information on the Section 106 review process the following link is available: https://www.onecpd.info/resource/2813/historic‐preservation‐basics/  If  the  tribe  does  not wish  to  consult  on  this  project,  please  feel  free  to  contact my  office  via  email at [email protected] or by letter.  If the tribe does wish to consult, the City respectfully requests a written response  including the name and contact  information for the tribe’s principal representative for the consultation.    The City of San Antonio values the tribe’s assistance and looks forward to consulting further if there are historic properties of religious and cultural significance that may be affected by this project.      Sincerely,  

 Laura Salinas Martinez Grants Administrator San Antonio Certifying Officer  Attachments