allen, thomas w._the text of the odyssey_pbsr, 5, 1_1910!3!85
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
1/84
British School at Rome is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Papers of the British School at
Rome.
http://www.jstor.org
The Text of the OdysseyAuthor(s): Thomas W. Allen
Source: Papers of the British School at Rome, Vol. 5, No. 1 (1910), pp. 3-85Published by: British School at RomeStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40310264Accessed: 15-03-2015 19:32 UTC
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available athttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=bsrhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40310264http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40310264http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=bsrhttp://www.jstor.org/
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
2/84
THE TEXT
OF
THE
ODYSSEY.
I HAVE to thank
the
Director
for
giving
this article
a
place
in
the
Annual.
The
Italian
collections
far
outweigh
hose
of the
rest
of
Europe
on the subject of Homer; and the opportunityf collating the Vatican
Odysseys
I
owe
equally
to
the
self-sacrificing
indness
of
Father
Ehrle,
the
good
offices
f
my
old
friendWilliam
Bliss,
who died
early
n
1909,
and
the
enviable
quarters
Augusto
mense
f the British
School at
Rome.
I.
The
Manuscripts.
The
Odyssey
s
contained
so far
as
is known
in the
following
manuscripts
the
descriptions
re
my
own,
except
where the
contrary
s
stated.
Berlin.
1.
Be
=
Berlin,
codices
Phillipici,
No. 182
(
=
Phillips
1585,
Meermann
307).
Membr.
263
x
163
mm.,
f.
203,
s. xv.
At
the end
¡larOaiov
akfucpov
rxo-avcws.1
This
book
was
collated
by
an
anonymous,
Classical
Journal,
xxxii.
178,
xxxvi.
251.
I
have not
seen it.
Cf.
below
g.
Brussels.
2.
Br
=
Brussels,
Bibliothéque Royale
11
290
=
73^
Chart.
288x208
mm.,
if.
417,
s. xvi.
Hyp. per.
tit.
(often
omitted);
paraphrase
and
interlin.
notes
in
red
marginal
scholia
;
very
abundant
v. 11.
withyp. Other later correctionsby a sixteenth entury wner. Signs a single
bracket
on
the left
hand,
y
232-8,
244-6, £
275-88,
k
368-72,
A.
8-43,
v
320-3,
333-8, p
150-165.
At
beginning
verses
(1)
tfrvyuv
oWo-cvs,
2)
fxó9ows
TroSpas,
(3)
c£
wpat
/xóx^ots.
Two series
of lines
misplaced, 1)
t
132,
134,
136,
138,
140,
T42, 144,
146,
148,
150,
133,
135,
137, 139,
141,
143, 145,
147, 149
(renumbered
1
This
description
s taken from
Die
Handschriften-V
rzeichnisse
er
Kóniglichen
ibliothek
zu
Berlin,
vol.
xi.
1
90-
1897.
2
Catalogue
des
Manuscrits
recs
de
la
Bibhotheque
oyale
de
Bruxelles,
ar
Henri
Omont,
1885, p.
25,
U
*
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
3/84
4
The
British
School
at Rome.
by
another
hand)
(ii)
after k
556
vv.
547,
549, 551, 553,
555
are
repeated
(for
the
renumbering
ee
p.
81)
;
whence
it
follows
that the
archetype
was
in
double
columns,
the
sense
running
cross,
a
usage
common
n
s.
xiii.1
See
under e.
Cesena.2
3.
C
=
Biblioteca
Malatestiana
27.
11
('
i*
Fila,
xxvii0
lúteo,
ii°
in
ordine').
Membr.
275
x
210.
ff.
02,
a.
1311,
Tit.,
no
hyp. per.
schol.
Some
glosses
and
paraphrases
much
corrected
by
late hands.
At
beginning
f.
v.
2 in
a small
S.
xiv.
hand,
irpó\oyos ¿yKtufJuacrriKos
¿s
rrjv
oSvcro-ctav ov
b¡xr¡pov.
hia
Ppa\€TaTos.
4
Journal
of
Theological
tudies.
1904, p. 44
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
4/84
The Text of the
Odyssey.
5
óñvo'creia
áva\
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
5/84
6
The
British
School
at
Rome.
question
whetherHeinsius saw
the codex
Vespasiani
north f
the
Alps,
or
in
Italy
on
either
of
his
two
ourneys 1646
and
165
1),
Heinsius' own MS.
of
the
Odyssey,
R
12,
has no
connection
with
J.
A
related
MS.,
not,
however,
dentical,
s
U8.
See
infra
h.
Cracow}
10. K
=
Cracow
543.
Written
y
Demetrius Triboles of
Sparta
in
1469.
See
infra
e.
Florence,
Biblioteca
Laurenziana?
11.
Li
=
Laur.
32.
4
('
L
'
ap.
Ludwich.).
Membr. 400x225, if. 476, s. xv. cont. Iliad, Odyssey (if. 270-445;,
Batrachomyomachia,
Hymns, Epigrams.
Tit.
per.
hyp.
occasional
corrections
no notes.
See
infra
.
12. L2
=
Laur.
32.
6.
Membr.
330x195,
if.
400,
a.
1465.
Tit.
per.
hyp.;
no scholia. Variants.
At end
irektiwOrj j
tov
bfjuqpov
Súcrtrcta lol
X€LP°$
M0^
iváwov
Trpea-^vrepov
tíxrov
tov
Kprjrbs
v €T€t
&v&$e&
irjvbs
oefifipiov pírrj
v
fioviovía.
See
infra
d.
13. L3
=
Laur.
32.
23.
Chart. 210x140, if. 296, s. xv. Tit. per. hyp. ; no scholia; corrections and
v.
11.
here and
there
by
text-hand and
another. At
end
t
f¡
/3£/3\o$
vrrj
payKÍo-Kov
tov
...¿\cf>ov
o-rlv
con
Se kolI
w
j/
lvtov
.
t
(partly erased).
See
infra
14.
L4
=
Laur.
32.
24
('G' ap. Ludwich).
Membr. 200
x
150,
if.
234,
s.
x-xi. Tit.
per.
hyp.;
no
scholia;
glosses,
etc.
by
several
hands,
all
considerably
ater than
the
original
scribe.
Signs,
correctly
given by
Molhuysen,p.
4,
are
non-criticalwith
the
exception
of five small
crosses
(equivalent
to
asterisks)
97-102.
A
companion
book to Laur.
32.
15
(D)
of
the
Iliad,
which
it much
resembles.
The
oldest
MS.
of
the
Odyssey.
Collated
by
Molhuysen
de tribus
Homeri
Odysseae
codicibus
ntiquissimis,
89^,
to
which
owe
the
readings.See
infra
k.
15.
L5
=
Laur.
32. 30.
Chart.
285
x
190,
if.
192,
s.
xv.
Hyp.; spaces
left for
per.
tit.
and
initials.
A
few
corrections
y
the first
and.
1
I
have
not
been
able to
find
printed
atalogue
f
the
Cracow
ibrary
the
description
s
taken from
udwich,
praef.p.
xi.
2
Handini,
Catalogas
codicum
bibl.Mediceae
aurenlianae,
1764,
i.
126
sqq.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
6/84
The Text of
the
Odyssey.
7
16.
L6
=
Laur.
32. 39.
Membr.
s.
xv.
185
x
130,
ff.
73.
Tit.
;
no
per.
hyp. grammatical
otes
on
a
and
parts
of
ft,
y.
17. L7=Laur.
91 sup.
2.1
'
N'
ap.
Ludwich).
Bomb.
s.
xiii. 260
x
190,
ff.
16. Tit.
per.
hyp.
in
some
books
not written
n).
No
scholia,
v.
11.,
nor
signs.
A
few
exegetical
notes.
Cont.
Iliad
and
(ff.
67-216)
Odyssey
a-£ 422).
See
infra
a.
18. L8
=
Laur. conventi
oppressi
2
(giá
Badia
2763)
*
(
=
*
F
'
ap.
Ludwich).
Membr.
240x190,
s.
xi,
if.
296.
Tit.;
no
hyp.
per.
(these
added
by
a
late hand) nor scholia. Signs correctly ivenbyMolhuysen,p. 7 ; they re non-
critical
except
a set
of
diplae
to
#c
32-40,
244-7
(these
come from the
first,
ot
the second
hand).
Marginalia
sparingly
n
first
hand,
more
abundant
in later
hands.
Collated
by
Molhuysen,
p.
cit.
See
infra
g.
19. L9
=
Riccardiana
78.2
s.
xv.
205
x
135;
cont.
inter
alia
'0
169-177,
20S-11, 408,
9, 479-8i,
1
27,
28,
34,
5,
etc.
usque
ad
versus t
328-34/
20. Lio
=
Magliabecchiana
g,2
s. xvi.-xvii. cont.
a
1-267,
nvP-Per-
Milan,
Biblioteca
Ambrosiana?
21. Mi=A 77 inf. [ = 800].
Chart.
285x195,
if.
302,
a.
1468.
Tit.
per.
hyp.
No
scholia;
corrections
and
v.
11.
both
by
Rhosus and a
later
hand.
Contains
Odyssey
a
384
-
end
(the
first
uire
is
lost).
Subscr.
¿reXciatfi?
j
7rapov
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
7/84
8
The
British
School
at
Rome.
text and adds
interlinear
. 11..
Largely
restored
by
a
fifteenth
entury
hand
(e.g.
on
ff.
,
2,
13,
14,
18,
23,
24,
70,
79,
87-102)
:
these
readings
are indicated
by
M
(3).
See
infra
m,
24. M4
=
Q
88
sup.
[688]
(^'Q*
ap.
Ludwich).
Chart.
290x210,
ff.
77
and
viii
blank,
s.
xv.
Tit.
hyp.,
no
per.
scholia.1
Signs
a
single
bracket,
to the left
of
the
text,
at
y
232,
244,
£
275,
v
320,
333,
S
5O3,
P
150,
475»
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
8/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
9
Oxford.
30.
O
=
Bodleian
Library,
Canonici
graec.
79.1
Chart.
310
x
220,
ff.
70
+
2,
s. xv. Tit.
hyp.
per.
(often
omitted)
occasional
scholia.
Extensive
corrections
by
another
hand.
At
end
(1)
rov
7roXvTrXdKrov
(2)
€J>vylov
8v
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
9/84
io
The
British School
at
Rome.
36.
P6
=
grec
2894
('S'
ap.
Ludwich).
Bomb.
255
x
175,
if.
338,
s.
xiii.
Cont.
misc.
and
(if.
209-333
r>)
Odyssey.
In
two
columns,
text
running
across. Tit.
per.
(often
omitted).
Scholia
and
paraphrase
s
far s
y
48.1
No v.
11.
r
corrections.
See
infra
.
37.
P7
=
supplement
grec
164.2
Chart.
217
x
155,
if.
183,
s. xvi.
Cont.
misc.
and
(if.
5-116)
Od.
(ol-k).
See
infra
k.
38.
P8
=
supplement
rec
100
1.
Membr. 275x255, 1 sheet (
=
ff.13,14),
s.
xv. F.
13
contains
752-101,
f.
14
r.
y
425-434,
f.
14
v. 8
1-24
Has been
used
as a
binding.
39.
Pal.
=
Heidelberg,
Palatinus
45.
8
Membr. 222x160
mm.,
f.
234,
a.
1201,
1202.
Hyp.
per.
Scholia
to a-
rj.
Cont.
if.
1-224
Odyssey,
225-9
Batrachomyomachia
n
four
contemporary
ands,
of which
the
first lludes
to himself
n
the words
x€tP*
rakaydvov
lov
TrcAcyptVov
KOfti^ros
ov airo
t^s i$povar]s.
See
infra
b.
40.
Pe
=
Perugia,
Biblioteca
comunale,
D
67.
Chart.
285
x
195,
if.
298,
s.
xv. Cont.
(1-260)
Odyssey;
tit.
hyp.
per.
No
corrections, cholia,
or v. 11.
A
few
notes.
At end
(1)
tov
roXvirXáyKTov2) vyu)v
ooWítcvs.
See
infra
d.
Rome.
41.
Ri=Vat.
graec.
24.
Membr.
290
x
195,
ff.
61,
s.
xv. Tit.
per. hyp. (collected
at
beginning
and
end).
No
scholia;
few
corrections
nd v.
11. At end
inside
cover
emptus
b
argyropulo
na
cum aliis
xi
similiter
ignatis
b.
manfredus.
On
this
celebrated
sale
see
Voigt
Wiederbelebungi
.
369.
See
infra
.
1
On
these f.
Ludwich
Progr. Regimont. 889,
1,
p.
1.
2
F4
r.
we find
ive ines
n
different-coloured
nks
fioicifiiov
od
fi4\apos black).
Sonlfxiov
od
fiap(lou
(brown).
BoKÍfxiou
ov
irpaaívov
green).
doictfiiov
rjs
Kivafidpcws
red).
SokI/jliov
od KovhtXlov
black).
Cf.
Esténse
245
(iii.
G.I2)
doKÍfiiov
ov kov$i\(ov
koí
rod
¡mcXavíov
cal
rod
x€P€^ov
0"
K0^
T°v
X&pTtov
xov.
8
This
description,
nd also
the
readings
f the
MS.,
are
derived,
rom . C.
Molhuysen
De tribus
Homeri
Odysseae
odicibus
ntiquissi/nis,
896,
pp.
8
sq.
Cf.
also
Ludwich,
Progr.
Regimont.
888
i.,
Schrader,
orphyrii
uaest.
Od.
pp.
1635^.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
10/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
i i
42.
K.2
=
Vat.
graec. 25.
Chart.
395
x
210,
ff.
85,
s.
xv.
Hyp.,
but
per.
and
tit.
usually
omitted. No
scholia,
or
v. 11.
Carelessly
written at end
+
crcActwefy
1a
x€LP°$
fw>3
wqrpiov
tov
¿avOoTTovkov.
See
infra
/.
43.
R3
=
Vat.
graec.
906.
Membr.
180
x
120,
ff.
78,
a.
1422.
Tit.
per. hyp.
Corrected
throughout
y
a
contemporary
and
v.
11.
nd
glosses
here
and
there abundant.
No
scholia,
or
signs.
Gilded
and illuminated.
At
end
in
red
(faint)
+
ÍTe\entiOr¡
o
irapov
íifiXíov
iá
\€ipbs
jiov
Sicucóvov
ccopyibu
ov
^pvaroKOKicrj
¿V TU$ ¿ ^¿ X" MVLOKTofipítovS. € .
See
infra
e.
44.
R4
=
Vat.
graec.
915.
Bomb.
260x170,
if.
238,
s.
xiii.
(schol.
A.
quotes
Tzetzes).
Cont.
misc.
(Theogn. Phocyl.
Hes.,
etc.),
if.
48-141
Iliad,
142-177
Odyssey.
Tit.
per.
hyp.
Constant
glosses;
in
places paraphrase;
abundant
scholia,
entirely
ut vid.
exegetical.
Many
v.
11.with
yp.,
omitted
ines
added
in
margin
with
«Sc,
in
the
text
AciW
In
double
columns,
the
text
reading
across.
No
signs
one
passage
{y
232-8)
marked
with
vertical
ine.
See
infra
a,
45. R5
=
Vat.
graec. 1302.
Bomb.
300x230,
if.
218,
s.
xiii.-xiv.
Misc.,
being
several books
bound
together:
if.
169-192
cont.
Od.
(a-f 285)
in
double
columns,
text
reading
across.
No
per.
tit.
hyp.
or scholia a
few
glosses,
corrections,
nd
v.
11.
See
infra
p.
46.
R6
=
Vat.
graec. 1320.1
Chart.
300
x
225,
if.
202,
s.
xv.
Hyp.,
no
per.
tit.
Exegetical
scholia
to
a-8
and
\¡/,
)
glosses
a
few
v.
11.
The
scholiast
(contemp.)
corrects
and
adds lines
where
here
re scholia. At
beginning
íifiXíov
j
$v
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
11/84
12
The
British
School
at
Rome.
KprjTos
to
ycvos
ava\á»jxa
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
12/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
13
54.
Ri4
=
Vat.
Urbin.
136.
Membr.
310
x
170,
if.
435,
s.
xv. Tit.
per.,
no
hyp.
No scholia.
See
infra
g.
55.
Ri5
=
Barberini
31.
Chart.
170
x
no,
if.
34,
s.
xvi.
?)
Cont.
a
36-/3
n
Greek
and
Latin. At
beginning
Caroli Strozzae
ThomaefilL
56.
Ri6
=
Barberini
93,
Chart.
215
x
140,
if.
30,
s. xv.-xvi.
Cont.
a-fi 19,
with some v.
11.
In
the
same
book
are
A
and
the
Catalogue
(dated
1548).
57. Ri7 = Barberini , 153.
Chart.
240x170,
if.
61,
s. xv.-xvi.
Cont.
y-e
102,
portions
of
6
and
1.
No
hyp.
tit.
per.
or scholia.
Regular
v. 11.
See
infra
g
58.
T
=
Hamburg,
Stadtbibliothek,
5.1
Bomb.
278x180,
if.
228,
s.
xiv.
Cont.
a-£
67.
Collated
by
Ludwich.
See
infra
p.
59.
Ui
=
Venice,
Marc.
456.a
Chart.
375
x
255,
if.
541,
s.
xv.
Cont.
Iliad,
Quintus
Calaber
(ff.
41-504),
Odyssey,Hymns, Batr. Tit. per., no hyp.
nor scholia.
Frequent
corrections
by
the
scribe,
Rhosus.
See
infra
g.
60.
U2
=
Marc.
457.
Chart.
285
x
190,
ff.
191,
s. xv.
Tit.
per.,
no
hyp.,
scholia,
or
notes.
Corrected
throughout
y
m.p
See
infra
c.
61.
U3
=
Marc.
610.
Chart.
312
x
250,
if.
190,
s.
xv.
Tit.
hyp. per. collected
at
end)
:
no
scholia,
a
few
marginalia
n
red.
Frequent
corrections
oth
by
m.
p.
and
a later
hand.
See
infra
d.
62.
Ü4
=
Marc. 611.
Chart.
280
x
195,
if.
244,
s. xv.
Tit.
per. hyp.
No scholia
except
on
first
ew
lines.
Text
much corrected
both
by
first
nd
later
hands.
Cont.
1-45
Plut. vit
Horn.,
46-244
Od.
At the
end verses
1)
rov rokvirXaKrov
2)
^vytov
Svo-o-cvs.
See
infra
d.
1
H.
Omont,
Centralblatt
ür
Bibliothekswesen,
ii.
p.
358.
a
Graeca
D.
Marci bibliotheca
odicum
mstorum,
740,
pp.
245 sqq.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
13/84
i4
The
British School
at
Rome.
63-
Ü5
=
Marc.
613
('M'
ap. Ludwich).1
Bomb.
270
x
185,
ff.
96,
s.
xiii.
Cont.
ir.
monocondylion,
2r.
id.,
4-7
Batrachomyomachia,
end
Odyssey. Hyp. per.
(these
by
a
later
hand),
tit.,
scholia.
Hands
:
the
text
nd
original
cholia are
all
by
the same hand.
A
smaller
nd
blacker
hand has
mended
a
number
of
pages
with
paper,
and rewritten
he
lines
thus covered
faithfully
s
may
still
be seen.
This
hand
is
not
much later than
the
first,
nd
certainly
of s.
xiv.
This hand
also adds scholia.
The text is
exhaustively
orrected
by
both these
hands,
one over
the
other,
and also
by
a
third,
thin
pider-like
lack
hand,
also not
very
ate,
about
s.
xiv-xv.
The
scholia
are
attached
by
numerals
and
by
conventional
signs.
The
Aristarchean igns which appear have no relation o the scholia and are sporadic.
They
consist
of
obeli,
antisigmas,
nd
asterisks.2
Scholia
and
variants
get
some-
what
thintowards he
end.
In one
place
allusion
is
made to
*
another
opy
:
a
93, 94
add.
in
marg.
man.
2,
with
ovk
larlvv
ctc/dcd
Ji/JAtco
í
o-tC\oi.
At
the
end,
verses
(1)
irov&v
toywv
2) fióOovs
TroSpas3)
o-tl^ol
tov
rtjirtpv
avOtapoi
/cal
iravrq
áfi€\¿TrjroL
ara T€ tov
(TKvkir^q
koX
yptjyopiov
tov
/?ao-iA.iKov
ypafifLOLTioTov
. .
inc. ¿k tw
Tpayío'KiúV
vk
0/xcA.ycTai
áAa, expl.
tis
yap Tpayio"Kü>v
cu
AcoVtwv
j
ftax7/
-0
m*
s«
xv*
T0^ iro\vir\áKTOV.
64.
U6
=
Marc. cl.
ix.
No.
4
(giá dcxlvii).
Consists
of two
books
:
(a)
U
(6)
chart.
260
x
165,
if.
47,
s.
xv.
Cont.
ff.
,
2
wpóXoyos
y/oü/xtaoriKÓs
(as C)
;
3
sq.
Odyssey
a-f 190.
Tit.
per.
hyp.
interlinear
losses.
See infra .
{b)
U6
bomb.
255
x
170,
ff.
8-142,
s. xiii.
Cont.
1541-0).
Tit.,
no
hyp.
or
per.
Abundant
scholia,
mainly
mythological.
Corrections
by
m.
p.
Signs
one
set
of
obeli,
p
1
50
sq.
See
infra
h
and/.
65-
U7
=
Marc.
cl. ix. No. 21
(Nani
289).
Chart.
282
x
215,
ff.
80,
s.
xvi
(?).
Tit.
per. hyp.,
glosses.
Corrections
n an
exhaustive cale
by
m.p.
and
a
later
hand. Cont.
Iliad and
(f.
270
sq.)
Odyssey
(a-ij/
41).
Portions
lso of
Synesius
and
Quintus
Smyrnaeus.
See
infra.
66.
U8
=
Marc. cl. ix.
No.
29.
Chart.
295x225,
ff.
320,
s. xvi.
Tit.,
no
per.
hyp.
nor scholia. A .few
corrections. The
signs
ff
and
=are used as
paragraphi.
Latin
paraphrase
and
1
See
Ludwich,
Progr.
Regimont.
87
,
Schrader,
orph.qu.
Od,
pp.
153 sq.
*
They
are
-
antisigmas
214-223
m.p.
obeli
7232-8,
17251-8,
A
38, 39, 435-442,
/*
76-388,
I 174-184,
503-6, 078-85,
1T247,
249-51-
asterisks
nd
obeli
6
564-7.
asterisks
dotted)
430-3,
160-4.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
14/84
The
Text
of
the
Odyssev.
15
notes. This
book
was
bought
in
1823
of
Carlo
Michiel,
and is
in
the same hand
as
cl.
ix.
No.
2
(U9
of the
Iliad),
which
came from
S.
Giovanni
in
Verdara at
Padua.
See
infra
h.
67.
Ü9
=
Marc.
el. ix.
No.
34.
Chart,
s. xv.
265x190,
if.
365.
Tit.
hyp.
per.;
glosses;
scholia.
Signs:
brackets
y
199,
200,
8
159-163,
dots v
333-338»
crosses
p 150
sq
,
475
sq.
At
beginning
rancisci
Attaris
Cyprii
/cat w
€povtrapnr\x¡v
#cTá8a|
$T€i
g
¿0
H
[1300J.
The
hand Eeems
archaistic,
n
whichcase
the
subscription
s
copied
from
he
original.
Cf.
Ludwich,
Progr.
Regimont.
888,
i.
p.
1.
(Nessel,
ib.
p.
36.)
See
infra
b.
7L
V4
=
philol.
133 ('
X'
ap.
Ludwich).
Bomb.
s.
xiii.,
250
x
170,
if.
146.
Cont.
c
45-w 59.
Tit.
hyp.
per. glosses;
v.
11.,
ll
in
one
hand. Scholia
opposite
the
text,
in
a
parallel
column
(not
continuous).
Signs: („)
k
368-372,
A.
8-43,
(*)
t
4-12.
(Nessel,
ib.
p. 77.)
Cf. Ludwich, Progr. Regimont.1889, I. pp. 5 sq., Schrader, Porph. qu. Od.,
pp.
1445^.
See
infra
tn.
72.
V5=
philol.
307.
Chart,
s.
xvi.,
195
x
145,
if.
90.
Cont.
miscell.
rT.
1-90
Odyssey
(a-£).
Per.
glosses.
(Nessel,
ib.
p.
147.)
See
infrag.
1
Catalogus
. .
Bibl.
Caesareae
Vindobonensis
. . ed.
Daniel de
Nessel,
1690.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
15/84
i6 The
British
School
at
Rome.
Breslau.1
73.
Wi
=
Breslau,
Stadtbibliothek
8
('W
ap.
Ludwich).
Chart.
262x196,
ff.
221,
s.
xv.
Tit.
per.,
no
hyp.
nor
scholia. Collated
for
Ernesti,
d.
vol. V.
add.
p.
23.
See
infra/.
74.
W2=/tf.
29.
Membr.
350
x
255,
ff.
77,
s. xv.
Cont.
Batrachomyomachia,
liad
(A-Z 356),
(ff.
51-174)
Odyssey.
Tit.
per. hyp.
no scholia.
This
MS.
has not been collated.
(Known as
*
Vrat. a
'
for he Iliad).
75.
Z
=
Stuttgartensis.
S.
xvi.
Collated
by
Rieckher,
Die
zweisprdchige
tuttgarter
andschrift
tc.,
Heilbronn,
1864.
See
infra
g.
The 'codex
Mori1
(not
to be
confounded
with the
'codex
Mori'
of
the
Iliad,
which
Walter
Leaf has identified
with
the
MS.
Trin.
Coll.
Camb.
983
=
Ri6.35)
on
the
authority
of which
Barnes added
0
295
to
his
text,
is
no
manuscript,
ut the edition
of
Estienne
(1566)
numbered
Nn.
v.
17
in
the
Cambridge
University
Library.
Before
formingpart
of the
library
of Edward Moore, Bishop of Ely, it had belonged to
Casaubon,
who
has left a considerable
number
of
marginalia
on it.
On
the
page
containing
0
294,
296
he
says
:
Deest
hie versus
vide
Cpa£.
viii.
The
ed.
Hervagiana
(1541),
which
lso
belonged
to
Moore
(numbered
Nn. vi.
4),
in the same
Library
has
no note
on the
passage.
I
owe
the
suggestion
that
'
codex
'
here meant a
printed
book to
the
perspicacity
of
Dr.
Montagu
James,
Provost
of
King's
College,
and the
identification
of the volume to the
energy
of
Mr.
J.
W.
Clark.
Of
these
MSS.
I have
not
seen
Be,
J,
K,
L9,
Lio,
Matritensis,
Moscoviensis,
Pal.,
T,
W2,
Z.
Of
these
L9,
Lio,
Matritensis,
nd
W2 have not been collated at all. The Moscow MS. was collated
by
Matthaei,
but the
readings
have
not
been
published Heyne,
Iliad
iii.
92).
In
the case
of
the others
have
printed
the
extant
collations.
Further,
owe
the
readings
of
L4
and
L8
(as
well
as
Pal.)
to
Molhuysen,
nd
of
H3
Li
(*/-o>),
on.
and
Pi
to
Ludwich,
whose
edition
I
have taken
as
my
basis.
1
Cat. Codd.
Graecorum
ui
in
bibliothecarbica Vratislavicnsidservantur .
.
1889.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
16/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
17
II
Families.
These
seventy-six
MSS.
fall
into the
following
seventeen families.
The
classification
as arrived
t,
as in
the
case of the
Iliad,
by
a
process
of
noting
all
cases
of variants
presented
by
ten
or
less
than
ten
MSS.,
and
casting
them
up.
The
MSS.
which
agree
most
often
in
presenting
such variantshave a claim to the titleof family. I may say that such an
arithmetical
ystem
s in
my
udgment
the
only
one
by
which
families
of
MSS.
can
be
made out.
The
possession
in
common
of a
striking
ariant
here and
a
striking
variant
there is
found
to be
casual. The
reader will
hardly
wish
to have
these
calculations
displayed
in
full on
the
other
hand
he
may
demand
specimens.
The
relationships
re
generally
very
clear
the
single
MSS.
fall
into their
groups
inter
conferendutn.
a
=
C
L7
R4
b
=
Pal.
H2
OP3
V3
c
=
H3, M(3) R7
Río
R12
V2 V
(6)d =
H4
L2 Mi Mo Mon. m.2,
P3
P4 Pe
R5
U3
U4
U7
e
=
Us
Br
K
M4
R3
R8
U9
/
=
Li
L3
P2
Wi
g
=
L8 Be
Ca
L6 Ri R6
R9
Rn
R14
R17
Ui
Z
ed.
pr.
Hi P5
R7
U7
m.
2)
h
=
J
U6 U8
i
=
M2
Ri
j
=
Hi
P5
P6
R7
U6
U7
k
=
L4
L5
Mon.
P7,
yp.
R12
/
=
Pi
R2
m
=
M3
V4
0
=
c-
H3
(se.
R7
Río
R12U2U
(6))
p
=
e-\J$ (sc. BrK M4 R3 R8 U9)
q
=
g-
L8
(sc.
Be Ca L16 Ri R6
R9
Rn
R14
R17
Ui
Z)
r
=
^-Pal.
(sc.
H3
O
P3 V3)
The MSS.
which
esist
lassification
re P8
R5
R13
R15
R16 T.
I
give
first
pecimens
f
agreement
etween
he
members
f each
family,
ufficient
o
show he
relationship
then
he
characteristics
f
the
family
hus onstituted.
or
the latter
use
the
method
pplied
to
the
Iliad,
C.R.
1899,
n,
viz.
that of
dividing
he
peculiar
readings
f
each
C
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
17/84
1
The British
School
at
Rome.
family
nder
our
eads
(i)
Alexandrian,
2)
ancient
ut
non-Alexandrian,
(3)
coincidences ith
ustathius
r
withvariants
yp.
tc.)
n
other
MSS.,
(4) unguaranteed
ut
noteworthy.
a
=
C
L7
R4
Specimens
of
Agreement.
a
7
avTol
L7 R4
avT(úv ex
w
UV.
52
ókoóp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
18/84
The Text of the
Odyssey.
19
iv.
Noteworthy
*
"73
Xtvovs
c
a
146
cVwrav
common
e.g.
if,
5)
82
om-
dispensable)
2OI
rcXWAu
l87
*™«
P
II 8
wcs
se.
Ápyai,
m.
iroSas,
s
295
*™8cs
ex
7rai8o'0€i/
irc&tfcv)
p 62)
303 r^v ^
(implied
in
drivers)
KTev¿u>i¿€v
P2)
8
82
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
19/84
2o
The
British
School
at
Rome.
Class
IV
do not
yield
much
/3
1
preserves
digamma,
152 Uhriv
avoids
the
neglect
of
one
and is
probably right.
The omissions
z>333
W477
are
interesting,
ut
it
is
disappointing
hat
after
o
good
a start
in
a,
#,
the novelties
ail
off.
¿
=
Pal.
H2OP3
Vi
V3.
Specimens
f
Agreements.
a
47
6\(X)olto
al.
O
P3
Vi
93
¿ 8 Pal.
OP3
Vi
(
+
Br)
95 í\WwPal. O P3 Vi ( + k)
186
fáOpu
Pal.
Vi
192
cvTcPal. O
P3
Vi
(
+
a)
214
KdTaXtfa
al.
OP3
Vi
(+
H3
L7
al.)
329
a
hab. Pal.
Vi
p
54
iOíXrjvi
al.
O
P3
151
iroWa
Pal.
O
P3
Vi
(
+
k)
l66
€(7O-€T
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
20/84
The
Text
of
the
Odyssey.
21
Pal.
being
dated 1201
and the
othermembers
f
the
family
o the
xvth
century
the
archetype,
owever,
f
V3
would be dated
1300,
f
we
regard
he
subscription
s
copied
and
thehand s
archaistic),
herelation
between
al.
and
H2
O
P3
Vi
V3
is
one of
descent.
This
descent,
s the
examples
iven
bove
prove,
s
genuine
but,
ike most cases of the
sort,
it
is broken.
The collation
which
Pal.
received
roduced
ariants
hich
altered
he
stock
the
resulting
ffspringwhich
we call
r)
are an
object-
lesson
n the
formation
f
tradition,
nd show
how,
s
in the
case of
c e
g¡
a
given
amily
s
often
he
product
f the
lterationf the
archetype
ut
of
the train. Whenwe onsider hat he rchetypetselfs, t s legitimateo
assume,
he
result
f a
similar
rocess,
t is
plain
that thevalue
of
one
family
gainst
nother
epends
pon
external
vidence
nd
arithmetic.
Examples
of
r
correctedut
of
b.
s ,x
_
,
¿"
-
w
30
a
ins.
Pal.
m.
2,
pace
for lineVi
a
47
yp.
airoW,
,x
PaL
,
m.
2,
oW>
O
™oX(W(n
PaL
in
ras.
0
P3
87
W.
«f
t^rat
Pal.
m.
2,
«k
ucqr*
(^«Wv
Pal.
H2
Vi)
~
W\>
Y ^/ irx
I0°
p8»/*wv
/\
Pal. in
ras.,
/Wov
*
O
P3
91
junpmNMrir
Pal.
corr.,
O(
/
+
irx
K)
I0°
p8»/*wv
/\
p™*
R
*
as.,
y^\
/Wov
*
158/
f
Pal.
corr.,
O
P3
Vi
(
+
Br
L5
120
™T
Pal.
™*
corr.
j
"*
O
V
P3
v
i
,
„
/
'
°
x
°
120
fir¡A
316
oTot
Pal.
corr.,
Vi
T
v
y
371
av/l/mv
Pal.,
aoi&iv
Vi,
áotSV
O
308
tj/acAÍc
al.,
^cXyc
cet.
P
55
í/A€T€povs
al.
corr.,
O
P3
Vi
?r
53
amos
Pal.,
avnov
Pal.
corr.,
(cr
fort,
dd.)
(
+
L4)
O
P3
181
8c
rot
Pal.
corr.,
OP3(
+
M2)
72 airaiwavQai
Pal.,
airafivvao-Oai
al.
tv
corr
OP'?
J
334
¿^eAXct
Pal,
64*\Xcu
O
P3
e
corr
J
€
332
t£ao7C€
al.
corr., ?£ao7C€
i,
¿ao-zcc
74
/x.77
iv
Pal.,
/xéVciv
H2 s
.
,
H2
v
i
356
fjTis
$iv
toSc1
Pal.,
t/tis
aiv€Tai
£ 38 yp.
£
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
21/84
22
The
British School
at
Rome.
Characteristics.
The
family,
hat
s
to
say
Pal.,
whether ollowed
r
not
by
his
children
has
the
following
eculiar
eadings.
The
readings
f the
children,
hich
it
wouldbe
misleading
o
give
here,
willbe found
nder
.
i.
Alexandrian
None.
ii.
Ancient :
a
329a
c£
ttoo-Iv
fi
t ftavla
rptSaKTvXos
i¿j€a¿vOri
ap. Julian.
t
518
iravSapeo)p.
schol.
v 66
iii.
Eust.
yp.
etc.:
1
455 oXeOpov
ust.
o 266
KaraAcfoj
yp.
H3
V4
Br)
K
399
Kaváxt¿c
ust.
w
5
p'
¿y*
yp-Us)
iv.
Noteworthy
a
70
00
(a
simple
error,
orrected
by
m.
2)
195 om. (dispensable)
£148
om.
(?
dispensable
?
owing
to irk-
T€
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
22/84
The
Text
of
the
Odyssey.
23
O
454
TTOLTpOS
S
141,
h.
VÍ.
I3)
503
Slol
kraipoi
7T
107 rj
avTov
[
=
Trj&]
alev
160
ov
yap
for
ovS*
pa
198
TraAatóv or
yipovra
279
Trapao-TaSov
possible)
^313
avris
(possible,
before
€107;)
330
aVwyc
p 415
w
for
80s
cr 286
tos
/c'
t
584
toÍ5to
vórjfia
85 Ply
for
J3(rp.
194
avTws
+
U6),
as
Bothe
14
vT*v;/Aa>
ex
u
210)
These readingsgive¿ a goodplace amongthefamilies fMSS. Putting
aside
00 a
70
as an
accident,
b
alone
preserves
what
appears
to
be the true
tradition
with
XrfXéar
rom Xavvco
j
86.
The
otherforms
for
which see
critical
note)
are
produced by regular
reciprocal
contamination
fromthe
readings
XrjXéar9,
prjpéSar,
\rj\aTcu
6,95,
113.
On
all
three
ines
there
are
monsters,
hich show the
process.
(W
284
we see
the
reverse
process,
ipripéSarai,
prjpáSarcu,prjpéarat.)
That
i\rj\éaTy
s
a
conjecture
s
less
ikely»
Pal.
also has
remarkable
missions a
195,
0
148,
8
75,
€402, 77
154,
6
435,
436,
k
18,
all
or
nearly
ll
possible.
The
reading
eVl
e
349
allows
for he
F
in
oipo7ra
other
variants
re
due
to
association,
he commonest
principle
n
the Homer MS. (8 342,1 559,k 206, 502a, o 186, yfr41, co112,407, 429) ;
ea>9
r
315
shows
us
the
process
of
metrifying
co?.
The
11.
in,
it
279
have claims to
consideration
n
the
ground
of sense.
£=H3
M(3)
R7
Río
R12
U2
U(6).
Here
again
one
member,
H3,
is
of
the
xiiith
century,
he
rest are
01
the
xvth
century
R7
and
R12 were
written
y
the same
scribe,
Rhosus.
Specimens
f
Agreement.
a
1 irávrtúv
3
R7
Río
U2
U(6)
( + LiPe)
P
230
cV
¿pco-iv
3
R7
Río
U2
U(6)
392
avrrjv
3,
yp. U(6)
411
CVH3
RioU(6)
(+0)
y
7
ir€VTr¡K0VTa
3 U(6)
9
2/O70I/-H3
7
Río
U2
U(6)
83
om.
H3
R7
Rio
109
8'&reiT
H3
Ü2Ü(6)(
+
fl)
185
¿ai/awv
3
Río
U2
U(6)
y
280
^cAco-tv
3
Río
U2
U(6)
336 Oacro-áfieu3 R7
8
54
XPV^
H3
R7
251
ávrjp(úT€OV3
R7
252
Xoéov
H3 R7
467
evSodi
H3
R7
(
+
a
Mon.)
788
norrios
H3
Rio
(
+
Br
P6
R3
R8)
€
163
iv 8'
fccpia
H3
Río
U2
U(6)
(
+
«)
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
23/84
24
The
British
School
at
Rome.
ib.
lv
airrj
H3
R7
Río
U2
U(6)
(
+
«)
347
KdKOV
3
RlO
376
pa
H3
Rio
£
75
KaréOrjKav3
Río
#584
7T€7rwfi€va3
Río
Ü2
t
138
€7TiK€A.o-avT€s
3
Río
uv.
223
roía-Lv
ifjLcXycv
3
M(3)
(
+
/)
242
o^Kr¡(r€Lav
H3
Río
(
+
k)
k
43
ráS'
H3
Río
U2
(
+
¿)
123
ávopüW'H3
Río
LJ2
A.128 k^V^V 3 RIO> fort- 7
206
avwy«
H3
R7
Río
(
+
n)
530
cmTcAAcv
3
Río
604
om.
H3
U2
fi
53
K€\€v
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
24/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
25
8 12
iXivrjs 3
corr.,
R7
383
aKuafxtvov
3
corr.,
U2
132
¿KtKpaaTo 3
corr.,
Rio
ir
233
8' av
H3
m.
2,
R12
U2
197
k€
H3
m.
2,
R7
•
/»\ XT t>
¿
,,
,
TT
t> P
10-13
signs
(
»\
,
)
H3
T
m.
2,
R7
>
462
c^páo-o-aTO
,
,
yp.
H3,
T
R7
> ^
10-13
signs
W
)
500
i&áfiao-crevp.
H3,
R7
25 virqoívq
H3
m.
2,
rjirrjOLVY}
l2
526
8c
y
cts
H3
m.
2,
R7
U2
538
k
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
25/84
26
The
British
School
at
Rome.
e\7re¿
T
¡xkv
cet),
and the
linguistic evelopment
of
Homer
continued
even
down to the
Renaissance. The
peculiarities
of
o will be found
pp.
54
sg.
¿=H4
L2M1M0
Mon.
m.2,
N
P4
Pe
U3
U4
U7
V2.
Specimensof
Agreement,
a
15
o-ttcWi
2
Mo N Pe
U3
U4
328
tol
yc
U3,
yp.
Mi
P4,
ss.
Mo
P4
234
€pa\ovro
Mo
N
P4
Pe
U4
305
airwv L2 Mo N
P4
Pe
U4
yp.
Srj
n Mo
P4
U4
(
+
P3)
Mon.
400
u/a^i/Jc/^kt/
2 Mo
Ml
P4
(
+
R5)
P 41
7/ycipc
2 N Pe SS.
516
/i€ycíXü>9
l P4 U3 U4
(
+ 0)
336
50'
ot
L2 Mi
N
P4
U3
U4
775
™ Mi
P4 U4
(
+
Pi)
407
post
408
L2
Mo
N
U3
(
+
Pi)
c
29
om.
H4
Mi
Mo
P4
U3
U4
V2
408
om.
Mi
P4
173 yc
H4
L2 Mi N
U3
U4
(
+
0)
421
om.
Mi
Mo N
Pe
P4
U3
U4
189
xp™
H4
Mi
P4
U3
U4
(
+
0
P3)
y
87
Xvypóv
XtOpov
2 Ml N
P4
U3 230
apyifaov
H4
L2
Ml
N
U4
U4(
+
r)
(
+
xM3Pi)
230
rrjXtfiaxos
2
Mi Mon.
m.
2,
N
240
-iripi
rj\a
H4
L2
Mi
P4
U4
P4
Pe
281
¿5
otc
pun*
H4
L2
Mi
N
P4
U3
266
KXirrat^o-rpa
Mi
P4
U3
U4
U4(
+
Pi)
(
+
P3)
365
fr«sH4MiP4U3U4(
+
P3U7)
216
airoríarj
2
P4 U4 (
+
»/) 409 Kv/xa4 P4 U3 U4 (
+
///
3 R2)
278
aO-qvituv
2 Mi Mo N Pe
P4
447
t om.
H4
Mi
P4
U3
U4
(
+
M3
(
+
0)
Pi
P3)
8
63
y'om.
Mi
P4
U4
(
+
r)
o
27
yc
H4
Mi N
P4
U3
U4
(
+
Ri
118
cao-ci
Vt/xv.
2 Mo
N
O
Pe
Ü2
U7)
(
+
Pi) 33
¿«x«
H4
N
P4
Pe
U3
U4
141
Tot
L2 Mi Mo
Pe
U3
U4
(
+
U7)
276
ctTTCT2
N
P4
U3
(
+
0)
in
^pecriv
o-ti/
4M1N
Pe
P4
U3
293
om.
Mo N
U
4
(
+
0)
U4
(U7)
This
plebeian
family,
he
second
largest
(of
12
members,
while
g
has
13),
consists
entirely
f
xvth or
xvith
century opies,
without
n
ancestor.
Three, H4 L2 Mi, were written y Rhosus, L2 in 1465 in Bologna, Mi
in
1468
V2
by
Antonio
Damila,
P4
by
Caesar
Strategus
traces of
Rhosus
seem
to
appear
in the
periochae
and
headings
of
Mo,
P4,
V4
;
but
the
eye
is
liable
to err n
identificationf
a
few
words
here and
there. An
archetype
must
have been
extant
at the
Renaissance,
which has
now
perished,
which
produced
this
progeny.
The
circumstances
resemble
those
of the
'Paris1
group
of the
MSS.
of
the
Homeric
Hymns
(cf.
the
Macmillan
edition,
p.
xxxiv).
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
26/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
27
These
MSS.
are
very
faithful
o
each
other.
The
second hand
of
Mon.
s.
xv-xvi.)
ltered
Mon.
n'
heir
ense,
nd
the
younger
members
f
b
(especially
P3)
are
close
to
them.
Peculiar
eadings
f
d.
i. Alexandrian
:
8
545
n-cipav
?
¿s)
for
Trcipa
ttcds
€H2
rjvúyciv
At.
7°7
^cri
for
ov8c
ti
(a
question)
6
494
8o'Xo>
ristoph.
Ar.
727
¿¿XX™
with
hiatus)
k 160
&)v
Zen.
€
29
om.
(dispensable)
X
364
iroXXaZen.
281
¿«>ós
(cum
Pi)
365 €¿cdsor cws
ii.
Ancient:
^
22I
xav0a
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
27/84
28
The
British
School
at
Rome.
Ill
rjariv
or
oycriv
1
07
roícn
c for
r¡(nv
221
cft/foivov,
s 1
103
*2i6
TrciTpósr¡v
ixofxevoLo
ex
T17,
1
9
:
238
aAAov
dinero
for AAwv
kcto
obliterates
/)
363
ovv€k'
p'
avrrj
orowcKa
fi
avn)
311
T€TA.a/x€v
or
TerAa/xcv,
s
Wolff
451
om.
(dispensable)
317
atctfor
allv
477
or
ap
for
ore
877
cf.
363
387
KaravTiKpv
or
/caí*'
vrrja-TLV
gloss)
7T
19
om.
(dispensable)
$ 125 /¿«> 17
or
/xcV
xiv
*i28
8c
/¿c
or
SiJ
x€
position given
by
150
c/crctwcrc
or
vr
ftc
cf.Ei 1
8,
O47
8 8c
ró£ov
ulg.)
174
ravvo-ovo-t
or
Tavvovcri
184
$U>p
74,
co
70
were
adopted,
presumably
through
H4,
the
British
Museum
copy,
by
Barnes,
and
his
successors d
therefore
upplanted
to some
extent
g (see
pp. 63 sq.) as the textusreceptus.
The
linguistic
contributionon
the
other
hand
is
not
strong
the
observanceof the
digamma
at e
34
is
the best
detail.
U3
sol.
6
382
avhp&v
KM.
1
For
similar
hanges
apparently
o
produce
metre,
f.
Ti&áovra-ts
446,
Í1
604,
Kóov
H
255,
KOfióovras
8
7, yoóovras
k
209,
arpopdaaBai
for
arpaxpaffdai
463,
TpoirÁa
Kv**
for
Kvrj
A
639,
Sriióotcv
226.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
28/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
29
¿=U5
Br
K
M4R3
R8
U9.
Specimens
f
Agreement.
a
19
oh
kr¿poi(Ti
5
Br
M4
R3
R8
U9
¡x
11
Ivff
U5
M4
R3
R8
(L6 T)
(
+ r
L5) 331
9
5tl
U5
M4
R3
R8
( +g)
21
Z8co-05 M4 R3 R8 U9
(
+
C)
310
fi€T€xova-Lv
5
R8
U9
(
+
J)
/3 5 /xcyápoto
5
Br K
M4
R3
R8
U9
466
avwyei
5
M4
R8
U9
(
+
k)
(
+
A)
p 36 /ft)
'
Uvai
U5
R8
( +g)
[not
U9]
37
S1 cVl
U5
Br K
M4
R3
R8
U9
158 ^
¿poW
U5
R8
(
+
JT)
[not U9]
(
+
J)
199 Ovfirjph
5
M4
R8
U9
72
¿pt&v
U5
uv. Br
R3
R8
U9
237
cpctVas
U5
R8
yp.
K
(
+
L2)
(
+
L5
Río)
ipvo-as
U9
168
aXXa
Kal ovtol
U5
Br
M4
R3
R8
o*
242
ovS*
otttttj
í
vóo-ros
Us
M4
R3
U9
R8(
+
J)
240
av€
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
29/84
3o
The
British
School
at
Rome.
°r
XpZ°v
11.
•
Ancient
•
j.
:
252
,
nA
2
95
Tepir(úfÁ€va
\
1 10
idvas
(
=
idvrp
Plutarch)
435
^^
(
+
Lj)
598
cVctra SáTrcSov
:
iirl
Sa^oVSc
^
K¿Wov
(
+
L5;
ex €
383
as
the
Ar.
Rhet.
1411b
33
same yl [n
other
MSS
g
go)
r
163
icrrí,
p.
lex.
Sext.
Empir.
¿
^
K(£XAos
or
^
(with
Tohy
)
iii.
Eust.
yp.:
V
3X4
^ov
for
yw
cf.
r
70)
8 284 U^cVous,ust.1490.10 ° 394 fcp^O'
$
26
^Xov
tc'kos,
Eust.
1936.
39
l
X34
«17
with
á/xav
cVei^)
/c
209
yooovras,
cf.
p.
46.
iv.
Noteworthy:
^
77
^^5
for
/Sporo's (to
avoid
a*
2 1
ihivQai
(f
neglected)
tautology
?)
*II3
Trpwros
'
t8c
/¿/.) 417
ÍK-7r\rjro
or
cv
-
401
ayx¿áA.a>
or
afiiá\
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
30/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
31.
£
89
tol
for
t¿,
re
(correct)
216 kuvov for
kclOl
? iv)
o
201
xp۟>i>
or
xp€w
283
¿f«v
488
Z€vs
n
fin.
(?
iOrj
Zcvs
/
«reí
y')
x
305
/xot
or
rot
497
¿s
for
cts
374
vixj/ew
or
vi'fctv
537
/«aa
for
for
¿Xa
P34)
„
(
£}
7o
ir
for
ya.v
as ,
314)
,«
^
„
¿
(
^
197
olfor
w
,
.
,
,
r
,
,/,
o
31
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
31/84
32
The
British
School
at
Rome.
Ludwich,
A.H.T. i.
p.
530,
and
Schrader,
Hermes,
xxii.
p.
365.
U9
has
small
single
half-brackets ne to
each
line
(8 159-163):
the
ordinary
half-
bracket to
7
199-200
a
pair
of
small dots
to the first and last line
(v
333-338)
:
a
cross to the
first
ine
p
150,
p
475.
The dots
are
borrowed
from
ordinary
cribes1
ractice.
In otherfamilies vertical ine in lieu of
the
half-bracket
s
found as
early
as
R4
(s. xiii)
to
7
232-8,
and in Hi
to
X
454-6,
v
333-338
(Hi
also has
a
dotted
asterisk o
6
564-572),
R12
has
a
wavy
line
against
0
399-401.
U6
(s.
xiii)
has
one
set
of
obeli to
p
150-166.
There is
no
parallel
to
this
development
n
the
MSS.
of
the
Iliad, which have sporadic signs not unfrequently, ut the correct
Alexandrian
types.
These
signs
have an historical
mportance,
nasmuch
as
they
reinforce
our
deficient cholia
this will be seen from he
table
I
append.
Scholia
Us
Br
M4
R8
U9
7
199,
2OO to.
-
(
(
(
(
232-238
to. obeli
(
(
(
-
(
I
R4)
244-246
to.
-
1
(
( (
-
€
157
~ - - -
(
-
(
275-288
to.
-
( (
(
-
'
33,
33«,
34
- ~
-
(2
- ~
«368-372
- -
(
-
-
-
(,,P3V4;vers.om.V5R8.)(
(, V4
;
J
is said to have
*
38-43
60. obeli
38, 39)
(
-
- -
1
obeli.
The
margin
of.
[
R8
is
covered.)
v
320-3
a0.
-
(
( (
-
333-338
to.
(
(
-
{a^g333}(8tndghtl¡neHi.)
I
5o3-5o6
to. obeli
(2
504-6)
-
-
(the
margin
f
R8
s
covered.)
p
150-166
to.
-
(
(
(
-
(obeli
U6
except
o
151.)
475-480
to.
- -
(
(
-
°
330-332
to.
-
-
( (
-
U5
has
other
signs
which
are
not
reproduced
in
its
descendants
(seep. 14).
R8's
witness
against
e
157
and
M4/S
against
1
33
sq.
are
striking,but R8 may have used his bracket as a scribe's sign. The
margin
f
R8
is
covered
by
a
guard
at
v
333,
£ 503.
The crosses
that
U9
appicts
to the
first ine of
p
150
sq.
and
p
475
sq.
are
merely
chiamate
to
the scholia.
The
brackets
in
p
are
evidence for
the
existence
of
ancient obeli
or
asterisks
on
7
244-9,
K 275-288,
X
38-43>
v
320-3, 333-8,
p
150-65,
1
There
are no
obeli
n
U5,
as Dindorf
tates.
2
Not
obeli,
as Dindorf.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
32/84
The
Text
of
the
Odyssey.
33
475-80,
r
30-2,
nd
probably
or n
Alexandrian thetesis
f
e
137,
33
sq.
k
368
q.
The
infidelity
f/
to
V5
and the
disagreement
f the members
among
hemselves
onfirmheir oose
dependence
pon
V5,
a conclusion
arrived t
from
he
readings. They
must
have
used another
copy
provided
ith
beli, tc.,
where
V5
omits hem.
The survival
f
the
Alexandrian
igns
s a
curious
ubject. Originally
meant
s
referenceso the
Alexandrian
irofivrffiara
nd
avyypdfiara
hey
ceased
to
be
necessary
with
the
coming
n of scholia.
In
theVen. A
of
the liad
they
re
adapted
o
refer
o the
scholia
hemselves,
ut
as
a rule
scholiawere ttached othetextbynumbers r arbitrary arks,nd the
critical
igns
herefore
trophied.
Eustathius
otices
few n his
Odyssey
MSS.
(#564,
253,
7t28i,
butwith
f>aa¿y
4);
in
the
second
and third
passage
hey
have
disappeared
n our
MSS.
/=Li
L3
P2
W.
Agreements.
4L
124 irav
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
33/84
34
The
British
School
at
Rome.
(The
collation
of
L3
was not carried
further
han was
necessary
to
establish
ts
relationship.)
This
family
consists
of
four xvth
century
MSS.,
without
scholia,
though
possessing
occasional
corrections.
Their
fidelity
s
obvious,
and
it
was
unnecessary
o
recollate
W,
which rests
on Ernesti's evidence.
Peculiar
Readings.
i.
Alexandrian:
204a
add.
(
=
€83, 157)
y
461
7pÓv
C7T¿
533
€S
€VKTlfl€VOV
or
€VKTLfl€VOV
8.
I
415,
the
same variant
P41,
* 66
137
:
(pre-
98 injuria
for
vrjfi€fyr¿m
m.p.)
sumably
Aóxov
was
meant)
l66
€pV$€L
or
ipVKOL 56O
8c
flOLpaV
füY 8' «TI
flolpOLV
pOS-
189
tKct or
¿/coi
sible)
1
This
reading
was
omitted
y
error
n
my
dition.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
34/84
The Text of
the
Odyssey.
35
561
¿AAa
Sevpo
for ¿XV
aye
Stvpo
o
1 2
Aa/Jc
eras
for
ScVas
Aa/Jc
(?
m.
p.)
173 fieWova-L
neut.,
post-Homeric)
592
ras
8*
v€fxos
or
Tas
(prob.
right)
198
óvijcm
or
vijcrci
629
ndpOSTTCp
or
7TpOO"0€V
IT l8l
VCOV
t>dv€S
or
(f)OLV€S
¿OV
¡jl
36
afJLtifitTO
or
TrpocrrjvSa
256 //.cp/x^pifas
or
fJLfpfxrjpL^at
68
flvcAAa
or
flvcAAat
274
aTifid
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
35/84
36
The
British
School
at
Rome.
y
146
ota
L8
Be
R14
v
56
Otios
8
L6
Be
R9
Rn
(
+
L9)
151
€taVa/x€V
8 Be
R14
(
+
Pal.)
98
vTTOTreirrqviai
8 L6
Be
Rll
Z
314
8' L8
Be
R14
(
+
Pal.)
129
fioi
L8
L6
Rn
Ui
358
fl-curccrftu8 Be
R14
Ui
132
air-qvpa
8
L6 Rll
Z
490
aWav L8
Be
R14
(
+
Uy)
193
nvqarrrjpo-iv
8
L6
R9
Rn
Ui
Z
8 60 8'
afjL
8
Be R
14
f
203
itfatya/cco-crtv
8
R9
Rn
Ui
90
yap
L8
Be
R14
(
+
L4)
212
¿s
L8
Be
R14
o
27
roí
t¿
Ittos
L8
Ri
R9
(
+
Mon.
278
cratpov?
8
R14
U5)
376
a L8
Be
234
ivl L8 Ri
R9
(
+
Mon.
Hi)
463
re
as
ixprjv
8
Be
R9 R14
246
ov&oL8 Be
R9
(
+
Hi)
535 ¿s cty€8 Be R14 it 13 ttcW L8 Ri R9 Rn ( + Mon.
€
195
tvOa
KaOrjcrro
8
R14
U6)
224
y€V€
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
36/84
The Text
of
the
Odyssey.
37
X
109 OdXafjLov
m. 8' L8
Ca
R6
R9
Ui
x
3°3
OopQvres
8
Ca
L6
R9
Ui
Z
Z
(
+
R3
M4)
330
áAvo7ca£€
8
Ca
Ri
R6
Ui
Z
116
áfjLvvaaOai
8
Ca Ui
Z
333
n€pfir¡pi£cv
8
Ca
R6
Ui
Z
(4- O)
130
8c oí
L8
Ri
Ui
8'
olrj
n
ras.
Ca
334
/xcyáAoio
8
Ca
R6
Ui
138
kcu
k
eh
L8
Ca
R6
Ui
Z
348
irtp
ci'Sciv 8
Ca
R6
Ui
140
evOcv
8
Ca
Ri
R6
Ui
Z
351
es
cóv
L8
Ca
Ri
R6
Ui
(yp.
U5)
144
tvOa
8v(ó8€Ka 8
Ca
R9
Z
(
+
J
373
aMots
L8
Ca
Ri
R6
Ui
Z
R3
R8)
377
Zp*
' L8
Ca
Ri R6
Ui
Z
186
8c
XikwToL8
Ca
Z
(
+
1,5)
381 paOvv
ó>ov
L8
Ca
Ri R6
Ui
Z
195 /xáXa
rctyxu
m.
L8
Ca
R6
Ui,
392-4
om.
L8
Ca
R6
Ui
Z
in
ras.
Ri
401
v€Kveo-(
€urT ¿'
Ui
t
367
olvtíov
;v8a
L8
R14,
y¡p\^o
fivOw
a
175 Mein,
>
L8,
jufcircio-i
'
Ui
t
L8>
hab
RlI
Ux
225
xp«o
L8
Rii,xp«o)
L8 corr.
Ui
Z
2 Qm Lg
^
add
Lg m
2^
234
ipokovro
8
Ri,
epovkovTo
8
R1R11R14.
corr. 11
Ui
Z
gg
?
,
¿
w L8 R Dl ávTtW
279-292
om.
L8,
add L8 m.
a,
hab.
gg
?
^^8
¿
w
m.
a,
L8
R.
R
Ri 1
R7R11R14U1
,t
346
0ov¿íi
8,
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
37/84
38
The
British School
at
Rome.
e
.
ir' u>
8
608
KCKXiWat
L8,
kckXcWqi
Be
R7
t
233
¿irrjkOtv fjiiav
L8,
€7n/X0€v
tt'
w-
R14
fiwv
Ri R11 Z
rj
106
/¿afccSn}?
8,
¿¿ajceSan}?
Be
* J6i
Kara
kvtjcttlv
8
corr.
Rn
Ui
era
X
585 aAXfl
8,
a\\r¡v
8 corr.
Rn
Ui
188
Saivvfxcvoi
8,
8au™rá>€vot
9
0 2g2 ol
L8,
ov
yp.
L8,
hab.
Be
R9
ot
Ri 1
197
KaraKXw^s
L8,
ko.t¿k\íúOoi
9
,.
T o ,x T o _> ^
o
*
to* to T>
°"
35°
D
V€Xw
,.
L8,
o
ycXwv
,x T
L8
corr.
Ri
>
Rq
y
258
ov7T
Be
OD
5°
'
'
y
"D "D 7
Ui
Z(
t
356
óXiyrpreXáovo-a
8
Ui,
oXiyr;
7rcp
eoxxraL8
corr.
R9
But in most cases the process of creating he newfamily annot be
traced
as is
only
natural when we
are
dealing
with
a
period
of
300
years.
The
peculiar readings
of
the
family,
whether f
L8
only
or
L8
with
its
descendants,
re
these
i.
Alexandrian
316
roi for
xoi
Nitzsch
bjected
o
a
27
¿vl
fifjL€ydpoL(nvristoph.
(schol.
fJ-oi)
ft
338)
346
Tt
t'
ap'
av for
ti T
apa
1
387
cxoi/Tcs
r.
sec. Eust.
367
ovriov
yvSa
k
324
fi€ to-o-o/xeviy
ristoph.
4l9
om-
dispensable)
X
597 KparaC
s
Ptol. Ascal.
439>
44°
om.
(hardlydispensable)
ii.
Ancient
^
4 om.
(dispensable)
31
/XaOoLTO
C
122
afey^ Apoll.
lex.
2S1
^
¿Tl^
(tVl
perhaps
from
"'S^^
466
ó€7raHerodian
^ in
igature)
o
466
ó€7raHerodian
„
™
„
«•/> o> tt j- xt
3°°
*>
«vovras
*
47
1
«•
>
«ecodian
t j-
N
t
79i
^^^
r
203
?s
cum
C
V4)
as
the
V;L
in
Dio°-
Hal.)
v
435 pvTTóVra
3
6o
3>
^
(
=
g^
p 305 /x^ov 90 yhip ()r^
°"
59
om.
2I2
¿sforgs
*r 5
V
278
iraipovs
for
apiVrovs
X
418
^Xm'Scs
37g
€,
for ot
co
318
p^tva
for
^vaS
445 typpnhy
8'
iv.
Noticeable
:
463
T€
s
ixpty
for tco
ere
xp^?
a
175
ficOtirri
yp.
H3)
535
¿>s
ctyc
for
¿s
Tts
T€
276
fiáyapov
€
77
avTÓv
for
avrr;v
a
314
tÓv
8'
avT€
wpoo-€€L7T€
97
lywyc
for
cyw
rot
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
38/84
The
Text
of
the
Odyssey.
39
€
123
¿s forecos A
432
cpy'
ctSvtafor
Xvyp'
ciSvía
130
eyuiy
for
cycov
438
owcxa
for
cíí>e#ca
195
KaOrja-To
or
áviarr)
510
f3ov\r¡v
293
8'
¿V
V€jj.a(n
or
es
8
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
39/84
4O
The
British School
at
Rome.
p
479
cpwywcr'
?
=
cpcvyoxr')
or
cpvcnrüKr'
v
374
^€¿Vw
or
^ctvots
525
írpó^w
Kv\iv8óft€vos
or
irpoirpo-
5Ó ijpct
for
¿pec (right
?)
KvXivSo/xcvos
1
1 1
f¿
{úp-qo-i
or
/xvvqo-i?)
o*
24
av#t?
€(T(o
JL€ydpJtovs
17 KdTaOtiofJLtvorKarafciofuu 68 twv8' avTwvfor tcüv 1 avTov
57
OpTJws-rjev
or
^p^vvv-iyKcv
84
Trcppiprj$€Ís
or
-17s
as
it
were
a
72
t)
oti
rot
pvirapa
Kara
xpol
tifiara
participle,
like
á
ex 377
130
avros
x
for
avro)s
214
x
r r
v
etc 1
131
€/XOt
or
€>»7
.
/
1
r «
/
,
5>N
v
227 pvTrotvra
for
pu7roü)VTa
/
150
CVSc
>N
for €1/
T€
227 pvTrotvra
/
r
/
188
Q
^
for
v
295
¿aovlor Troo-tv
188
Q
ore
Tts
for
otis
v
f267
vctpas
for
Y«pwv (unmetrical)
»3°4 ^ f
^^^ ,>♦/•,•
.
4v
/
?
«pwv
/
/^
,
x
^310
ucW ot€
for
¿í
>♦/•,•
ov
(? right)
4v
274
7rav
/) r
for
Kpca
wo-0tov
/»
o w
v
/
1
1- r\
Kpca
^J/>
57»
8
7TOT6
for
T0T€
(neglecting
1
/)
\
^J/>
57»
Considering
he
great
number f
these
variants,
here
s
little
good
in»
them. The
omissions
re
nearly lways
explicable
on
graphical rounds.
This content downloaded from 132.248.9.8 on Sun, 15 Mar 2015 19:32:13 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/9/2019 Allen, Thomas W._the Text of the Odyssey_PBSR, 5, 1_1910!3!85
40/84
The
Text
of
the
Odyssey.
41
We have instancesof the
process
of
filling
digamma-hiatuses
t v
42,
348,
a
simple
neglect,
448.
Digamma
is
apparently
bserved
p
177
r
341
:
jjpet,
(j>
6
seems correct
or
Homer,
$