am v5 series 4

Upload: kharis-mochammad-nur

Post on 04-Jun-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    1/13

    OCTOBER 2002 VOLUME 5, ISSUE 10 PLEASE COPY OR POST

    Ideas for Treatment Improvement

    Cultural Competence Issues

    Northwest Frontier

    Addiction Technology

    Transfer Center

    3414 Cherry Ave NE, Suite 100Salem OR 97303

    Phone: (503) 373-1322

    FAX: (503) 373-7348

    A project of

    Oregon Health &Science University

    Steve Gallon, Ph.D.,Project Director

    Mary Ann e Bryan, [email protected]

    Be sure to check out

    our web page at:

    http://www.open.org/nfatc

    Unifying science,

    education and

    services to

    transform lives

    Our most basic common l ink is

    that we all inhabit thi s planet. We

    all breathe the same air . We all

    cheri sh our children s futur e. And

    we are all mor tal.

    John F . Kennedy (1917-1963)

    The next three issues of the Addic-

    tion Messenger will focus on

    information regarding cultural

    competency issues for counselors and

    treatment organizations. As a substance

    abuse professional the client population ofyour agency is probably representative of

    demographics of our society. Society

    today is both multi-ethnic and

    multicultural. You may have questions

    about your clients culture and how you

    can become more culturally sensitive or

    how your agency can develop cultural

    competency. This series of articles will

    address these questions.

    Ethnic and cultural disparities exist in

    many aspects of our society includinghealth care. Culture influences the way

    clients respond to health care provision

    and can impact the delivery of those

    services. In order to better respond to

    client needs, treatment programs and

    substance abuse professionals can foster

    their understanding of diversity and

    further their appreciation and acknowledg-

    ment of the differences in their clientele.

    The following paragraphs will provide

    definitions for terminology related to

    culture. Cross, T. (1989) gives the

    following definitions:

    Cultur al Knowledge

    Familiarization with selected cultural

    characteristics, history, values, belief

    systems, and behaviors of the members of

    another ethnic group

    Cul tural Awareness

    Development of a sensitivity and under-

    standing of another ethnic group. This

    involves internal changes in attitudes and

    values and refers to qualities of openness

    and flexibility in relation to others. Cul-tural awareness must be supplemented

    with cultural knowledge.

    Cul tur al Sensitivity

    Knowing that cultural differences as well

    as similarities exist, without assigning

    values (better or worse, right or wrong) to

    those cultural differences.

    Cul tur al Competence

    A set of congruent behaviors, attitudes

    and policies in an agency that enable that

    agency to work effectively in cross-

    cultural situations. Culture implies the

    integrated pattern of human thoughts,

    communications, actions, customs,

    beliefs, values, and institutions of a racial,

    ethnic, religious or social group. Compe-

    tence implies having a capacity to

    function effectively. Cultural compe-

    tency emphasizes the idea of effectively

    operating in different cultural contexts

    while cultural knowledge, awareness and

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    2/13

    NFATTC ADDICTION MESSENGER OCTOBER 20022PAGEsensitivity do not include this

    concept.

    Culture

    A groups shared conception of

    reality, created by members of the

    group living together over genera-tions, through their language,

    institutions, arts, values, beliefs,

    experiences, work and play.

    Sub-Culture

    A group of people within a larger

    sociopolitical structure who share

    cultural characteristics which are

    distinctive enough to distinguish it

    from the others.

    EthnicityThe way in which groups of people

    retain and practice customs,

    language, and social views of their

    group.

    Cultivating Cultural

    Competence

    On an individual level within your

    agency there are several things that

    can be done to cultivate cultural

    competence:Value diversity by considering

    differences as strengths rather than

    interact. Individuals may not feel

    in their comfort zones but it should

    not cause division.

    Institutionalize cultural knowl-

    edge through the encouragement of

    the agencys administration.

    Adapt the delivery of services to

    reflect an understanding of cultural

    diversity through making changes

    to meet the needs of your clients.

    Models of Cultural Com-

    petence

    A culturally competent model of

    treatment acknowledges the

    cultural strengths, values and

    experiences of the client whileencouraging behavioral and

    attitudinal changes. Characteristics

    of culturally responsive services

    include:

    Staff knowledge of the native

    language of the client,

    Staff sensitivity to the cultural

    nuances of the client population,

    Staff that is representative of the

    population,

    Treatment services that reflect

    cultural values and treatment needsof the client population, and

    Representation of the client

    population in decision making and

    policy implementation within the

    agency.

    The culturally competent agency

    should implement cultural compe-

    tence at various levels within the

    agency, such as attitude, practice,

    policy and procedure.

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote (2002),

    Ph.D., RN, wrote an article titled

    The Process of Cultural Compe-tence in the Delivery of Healthcare

    Services which describes a new

    model of cultural competence.

    The key points of this model

    include five constructs of cultural

    competence:

    Cul tural Awareness the process

    of conducting a self-examination of

    biases of other cultures and an in-

    depth exploration of ones cultural

    and professional background.Cultur al Knowledge process of

    seeking cultural information as well

    as biological variations among

    specific ethnic groups.

    Cultural Skill ability to conduct

    a cultural assessment to collect

    relevant cultural data regarding

    clients concerns as well as con-

    ducting a culturally-based physical

    assessment.

    Cultur al Encounter the process

    which encourages the counselor todirectly engage in face-to-face

    cultural interactions in order to

    modify their existing beliefs about a

    particular group to prevent stereo-

    typing.

    Cultur al Desir e- the motivation

    to want to engage in the process

    of becoming culturally aware,

    knowledgeable, skillful and capable

    of seeking cultural encounters.

    Campinha-Bacote notes thatcultural desire is the pivotal

    construct of cultural competence

    that provides the energy source and

    foundation for the journey towards

    cultural competency.

    Another model of cultural compe-

    tence, offered by Dr. Terry Cross

    (1989) at the University of Port-

    land, Portland, Oregon, includes

    cultural destructiveness as the

    Diversity Patterns in Our Region

    AK HI ID OR WA

    Indian/Alaskan 15.6% .3% 1.4% 1.3% 1.6%

    Asian .4% 41.6% .9% 2.9% 5.5%

    African American 3.5% 1.8% .4% 1.6% 3.2%

    Hispanic 4.1% 7.2% 7.9% 8% 7.5%

    Hawaiian/Pacific Islander .5 % 9.4% .1% .2% .4%

    tolerating them.

    Conduct a cultural self-assess-

    ment.

    Be awareness of dynamics when

    people from different cultures

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    3/13

    NFATTC ADDICTION MESSENGER OCTOBER 2002

    Sources:

    3PAGE

    Cultural Competence:

    Agency Awareness

    Next I ssue:

    lowest level of competency and

    advanced competence as the

    highest. The definitions are summa-

    rized below.

    Cultur al Proficiency engaging in

    research about cultural variety and

    differences.

    Cul tur al competence accepting,

    appreciating and accommodating

    cultural differences. Including in-

    formation for trainings that acknowl-

    edges and values differences.

    Pre-competence recognizing own

    deficiencies in cultural awareness

    and the importance of cultural

    differences and awareness. Having

    the commitment to correct the

    deficiencies.

    Cultur al blindness those individu-

    als stating they are color blind and

    dont see color.

    Cultur al i ncapacity individuals

    unable to accept or respond to

    cultural diversity existing in a group.Cul tur al destructi veness relating

    to culture in an anti-cultural way

    through negative relationships with

    other cultures or attempting to

    eliminate them.

    The Myth of Cultural Com-

    petence?

    In an article written by Ruth G.

    Dean (2001) titled The Myth of

    You Can Receive the Addiction Messenger Via E-M ail !

    Do you already receive the AM via mail? You can help us cut printing costs by changing to e-mail.

    Please fill out the following information, copy this page and FAX it back to us at 503-373-7348

    You will begin receiving the AM via e-mail only. Thank you !

    Name:_______________________________________________________________________________________

    E-Mail Address:(Please print)____________________________________________________________________

    Mailing Address: _____________________________________________________________________________

    Phone: ______________________________________________________________________________________

    Cross-Cultural Competence takes

    a different view of cultural compe-

    tence. The authors main concern

    is how does a person become com-

    petent at something (culture) that is

    continually changing, and how do

    we develop a focus that includes

    ourselves as having differences,

    beliefs, and biases that are inevita-

    bly active? Dean concludes that

    people working in cross-cultural

    situations consider a model in

    which maintaining an awarenessof ones lack of competence is the

    goal rather than the establishment

    of competence. With lack of

    competence as the focus, a dif-

    ferent view of practicing across

    cultures emerges. She suggests

    that reading about other cultures,

    becoming informed of ones own

    cultural baggage and trying to be-

    come aware of when it interferes

    with the ability to understand

    anothers point of view is helpful

    but that we must recognize how

    difficult it is to separate ourselves

    from our own cultural baggage.

    Keeping that awareness in our

    conscience will hopefully limit its

    impact on our work.

    Improving Patient Care (2000).

    Cul tur al Competence. Retrieved

    September 16, 2002, from

    World Wide Web:

    http://www.aafp.org/fpm/20001000/5&cult

    Center for Substance Abuse Treatment

    (1999). Cul tur al I ssues in Substance

    Abuse Tr eatment. Rockville, Maryland

    Transcultural Care (2002). The

    Process of Cu ltu ral Competence in

    the H ealth care Services. Retrieved

    September 16, 2002, from

    World Wide Web:

    http://www.transculturalcare.net

    Dean, Ruth, G. (2001) The Myth of

    Cross-Cultural Competence Famili es in

    Society: The Journal of Contemporary

    Human Services, Vol. 82, No. 6, pp.

    623-630 .

    Cross, T. et al (1989). Towards a

    Culturally Competent System of Care

    Vol. 1, Washington, D.C.: Georgetown

    University Child Development Center,

    CASSP Technical Assistance Center

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    4/13

    2 Continuing Education hours for $25

    Earn 2Continui ng Education Hours - NAADAC Approvedby reading a series of three Addiction Messengers (AM)

    If you wish to receive continuing education hours for reading the AM just fill out the registration form below

    complete the pre-test on the reverse side of this page, and return both to NFATTC with a feepayment of $25 (make

    checks payable to: NFATTC, please). We will send you a free copy of the main source of material information. Youmust then read the three monthly issues of the Addiction Messenger and the reference material for the series. The las

    issue in the series will have a post-test in it. You will need to complete the post-test (along wi th a 100 word shor

    essay question regarding your reaction to the mater ial )and return it to the NFATTC. You will receive, by return

    mail, a certificate stating that you have completed 2 Continuing Education hours. Four continuing education series

    are offered each year. Completing a series of three issues will earn you 2 CE hours (or a total of 8 if you do all four

    series in 2002). You may complete as many series as you wish.

    Series 1includes Vol. 4, Issues 1-3 Evidence-Based Treatment Approaches

    Series 2includes Vol. 4, Issues 4-6 What Works for Offenders?

    Series 3includes Vol. 4, Issues 7-9 Manual-Based Group Skills

    Series 4includes Vol. 4, Issues 10-12 Preparing Clients for Change, What Is A Woman Sensitive

    Program? and Naltrexone Facts

    Series 5 includes Vol. 5, Issues 1-3 Methamphetamine: Myths & Facts

    Series 6 includes Vol. 5, Issues 4-6 Co-Occurring Disorders

    Series 7 includes Vol. 5, Issues 7-9 Trauma Issues

    ______________________________________________________________________________

    Registration Form for Series 8 - Cultural Competency Issues

    Name______________________________________________________________

    Address____________________________________________________________

    City/State/Zip_______________________________________________________

    Phone______________________________________________________________

    What is your highest degree status? (check one)

    ____ No high school diploma or equivalent ____ Associates degree ____ Masters degree

    ____ High school diploma or equivalent ____ Bachelors degree ____ Doctoral degree/equivalent

    ____ Some college, but no degree ____ Other (specify)______________________________________

    What is your discipline or profession? (check all that apply)

    ____ Addictions Counseling ____ Other Counseling ____ Education

    ____ Vocational Rehabilitation ____ Criminal Justice ____ Psychology

    ____ Social Work/Human Services ____ Physician Assistant ____Medicine: Primary Care

    ____ Medicine: Psychiatry ____ Medicine: Other ____ Nurse____ Nurse Practitioner ____ Administration ____ None, unemployed

    ____ None, student ____ Other (please specify)________________________________

    Please indicate your primary work setting.(check one)

    ____ Criminal justice ____ Educational institution ____ Inpatient facility ____ Outpatient

    ____ Outreach ____ Private practice ____ Residential facility ____ Student

    ____ Other (please specify)________________________________________________________________________

    Return your pre-test by mail or FAX at (503) 373-7348

    Northwest Frontier ATTC

    3414 Cherry Ave. NE, Suite 100, Salem, OR 97303

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    5/13

    Pre-TestSeries 8

    Cir cle the corr ect answer for each question

    #1

    A set of congruent behaviors, attitudes and policies that

    enable an agency to work effectively in cross-culturalsituations defines:a. Cultural awareness

    b. Cultural competence

    c. Cultural knowledge

    d. Cultural sensitivity

    e. None of the above

    #2

    A definition of ethnicity would include the way in which

    groups of people retain and practice customs, language, and

    social views of their group.

    True False

    #3

    Characteristics of providing culturally responsive services

    would include:

    a. sensitivity to cultural nuances of the client population.

    b. having staff that is representative of the population.

    c. providing services that dont reflect cultural values.

    d. none of the above

    e. a and b

    #4

    Cultural competence:

    a. does not influence the development of a treatment plan.b. does not facilitate the acccuracy of a diagnosis

    c. allows the provider to obtain more specific and complete

    information

    d. b and c

    e. all of the above

    #5

    Cultural competence:

    a. improves the overall communication and clinical interac-

    tions between client and provider.

    b. leads to improved diagnosis and treatment plans.

    c. does not lead to greater client compliance.

    d. a and be. b and c

    #6

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote describes a new model of

    cultural competence that includes only the following:cultural awareness, cultural sensitivity, and cultural skills.

    True False

    #7

    In Ruth G. Deans article, The Myth of Cross-Cultural

    Competence, she suggests :

    a. maintaining an awareness of ones lack of cultural

    competence is a goal.

    b. that people dont have cultural bggage.

    c. that it is difficult to become competent at something

    (culture) that is continually changing.

    d. a and b

    e. a and c

    #8

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote notes that the pivotal construct of

    cultural competence that provides the energy source and

    foundation for the journey towards cultural competence

    comes from:

    a. cultural encounters

    b. cultural desire

    c. cultural knowledge

    d. a and b

    e. none of the above

    #9

    A culturally competent agency should implement cultural

    competence at various levels such as:

    a. agency attitudes

    b. agency practices

    c. agency policies and procedures

    d. a and b

    e. all of the above

    #10

    Becoming a culturally sensitive and responsive counselor is

    best conceptualized as a process.

    True False

    Mail or FAX your completed test to NFATTC

    Northwest Frontier ATTC, 3414 Cherry Ave. NE, Suite 100, Salem, OR 97303

    FAX: (503) 373-7348

    You can still register for continuing education hours forSer ies 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 or 7

    Contact Mary Anne Br yan at (503) 373-1322 ext. 224

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    6/13

    NOVEMBER 2002 VOLUME 5, ISSUE 11 PLEASE COPY OR POST

    Ideas for Treatment Improvement

    Northwest Frontier

    Addiction Technology

    Transfer Center

    3414 Cherry Ave NE, Suite 100Salem OR 97303

    Phone: (503) 373-1322

    FAX: (503) 373-7348

    A project of

    Oregon Health &Science University

    Steve Gallon, Ph.D.,Project Director

    Mary Ann e Bryan, [email protected]

    Be sure to check out

    our web page at:

    http://www.open.org/nfatc

    Unifying science,

    education and

    services to

    transform lives

    Cultu ral competence is the

    process of becoming;

    not a state of being...

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote, Ph.D.

    This issue of the Addiction Messen-

    ger focuses on issues that can be

    important to increasing cultural

    competence in substance abuse treatment

    organizations. Since todays society is

    becoming increasingly both multi-ethnic

    and multicultural there is a need for

    everyone to continue their growth ofknowledge in this area. A key aspect of

    becoming culturally competent is to be

    aware of the great diversity among

    individuals, even in the smallest cultural

    group. Populations include people from

    different races, cultures, ethnic back-

    grounds, religions, ages, genders, sexual

    orientations as well as physical and mental

    abilities.

    Why Is Cultural Competence

    Needed?

    The National Center for Cultural Compe-

    tence (NCCC) at Georgetown University

    (1999) notes that the incorporation of

    culturally competent approaches within

    heath care systems remains a great

    challenge for many states and communi-

    ties. Organizations and programs are

    struggling with how best to respond to the

    needs of diverse groups. The need for

    Cultural Competence: Agency Action

    cultural competence in health care sys-

    tems, according to NCCC, includes but is

    not limited to the following observations:

    * The perception of illness and diseaseand their causes varies by culture,

    * Diverse belief systems exist related to

    health, healing, and wellness,

    * Culture influences help seeking behav-

    iors and attitudes toward health care

    providers,

    * Individual preferences affect traditional

    and non-traditional approaches to health

    care,

    * Patients must overcome personalexperiences of bias within health care

    systems, and

    * Health care providers from culturally

    and linguistically diverse groups are under-

    represented in the current service delivery

    system.

    These issues substantiate the need for

    health care programs to develop policies,

    practices and procedures that support the

    delivery of culturally competent services.

    The National Center for Cultural Compe-

    tence has developed and outlined thefollowing six key reasons for the incorpo-

    ration of cultural competence in organiza-

    tions:

    1. To Respond to Curr ent and Projected

    Demographi c Changes in the United

    States.

    Data from the 2000 census notes that the

    number of people who speak a language

    other than English grew 48% during the

    previous ten years. Within this group

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    7/13

    NFATTC ADDICTION MESSENGER NOVEMBER 20022PAGE21.3 million report having trouble

    speaking English (an increase of

    52% since 1990). Currently the

    foreign-born population of the

    United States is larger than it has

    been in the last five decades and

    the trend is expected to continue.

    2. To El imi nate Long-Standing

    Dispariti es in the Health Status of

    People of Diverse Racial, E thni c,

    and Cul tural Backgrounds.

    The divisions of race, ethnicity and

    culture are sharply drawn with

    regard to health in the United

    States. There continues to be

    disparities in the incidence of illness

    and death among diverse groups.

    Six areas of health status have been

    targeted by the Federal govern-

    ment: cancer, cardiovascular

    disease, infant mortality, diabetes,

    HIV/AIDS, and child and adult

    immunizations.

    3. To Improve the Quali ty of

    Services and H ealth Outcomes.

    Differences among people can

    stem from nationality, ethnicity,

    and culture as well as family

    background and personal experi-

    ences. These differences affect

    beliefs and behaviors related to

    health issues of both clients and

    providers. The provision of

    culturally competent health care

    services includes understanding of:

    * Beliefs, values, traditions and

    practices of a culture;

    * Culturally-defined, health-related

    needs of individuals, families andcommunities;

    * Culturally-based belief systems

    related to the etiology of illness and

    disease and to health and healing;

    and

    * Attitudes towards seeking help

    from health care providers.

    4. To Meet Legislative, Regula-

    tory and Accreditation M andates.

    Organizations and programs have

    multiple responsibilities to comply

    with Federal, state and local

    regulations in the delivery of health

    services. The Healthy People Year

    2000/2010 Objectives, among

    other national efforts, includes an

    emphasis on cultural competency

    as an integral component of health

    service delivery.

    5. To Gain a Competi tive Edge

    I n the Market Place.

    Culturally appropriate treatment

    services can increase retention and

    access to care, expand recruitment

    and increase the satisfaction of

    consumers. Reaching these

    outcomes can include integrating

    culturally competent policies,

    structures and practices within

    agencies.

    6. To Decrease the Likelihood of

    Li abil ity/Malpractice Claims.

    A lack of awareness about cultural

    differences could result in liability.

    Communicating with clients may

    be even more challenging when

    there are cultural and linguistic

    barriers present.

    The NCCC notes that there are a

    lack of policies, planning proce-

    dures and institutional structures in

    many organizations that support

    culturally competent practices. A

    cultural competency framework

    used by NCCC is based on the

    following beliefs:

    * There is a defined set of values,

    principles, structures, attitudes and

    practices inherent in a culturally

    competent system of care;

    * Cultural competence at both the

    organizational and individual levels

    is an ongoing developmental

    process; and

    * Cultural competence must be

    systematically incorporated at

    every level of an organization,

    including the policy making,

    administrative, practice and

    consumer/family levels.

    Avoid Stereotyping

    While there are many similarities

    among people from the same

    cultural background we also need

    to be aware of the differences and

    variabilities that exist within a

    cultural group. In other words,

    what may be true for most or some

    individuals from a particular region

    or culture may not be true for all

    the people of that group. Diversity

    exists within all groups of people.

    This knowledge will lessen the

    possible creation or reinforcement

    of a cultural stereotype.

    All people have unique personal

    histories, belief systems, andcommunication styles. Ones

    development is impacted by accul-

    turation (merging of cultures that

    occurs through prolonged contact)

    and assimilation (responding to

    new situations in conformity). Your

    agency may have clients who have

    recently immigrated to the United

    States and others who have been

    here and still identify with their

    culture of origin.

    Some other questions that contrib-

    ute to differences within groups

    include:

    * People from rural areas may be

    living a more traditional lifestyle

    than people who emigrate to the

    United States from urban areas.

    * Economic status and education

    can vary greatly among people

    from the same country.

    * People from the same country

    may have migrated to the United

    States for very different reasons,

    including seeking economic

    opportunities, escaping religious or

    ethnic persecution, fleeing civil

    strife, or joining relatives in

    America.

    * There are important intra-region

    and intra-group variations among

    people from the same country, and

    cultural variations may be marked

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    8/13

    NFATTC ADDICTION MESSENGER NOVEMBER 2002

    Source:

    Levin, et al (2000). Appendix: Useful Clinical

    Interviewing Mnemonics. Patient Care Specia

    Issue, Caring for Diverse Populations: Breaking

    Down Barriers

    The Providers Guide to Quality & Culture (2000).

    Avoi di ng St ero ty pes . Retrieved 10/21/02 from

    World Wide Web:

    http://erc.msh.org/

    National Center for Cultural Competence (2000).

    Rational for Cultural Competence in Primary

    Health Care. Retrieved10/18/02 from

    World Wide Web:

    www.georgetown.edu/research/

    3PAGE

    Cultural Competence:

    Counselor Approaches

    Next Issue:

    You Can Receive the Addiction Messenger Via E-M ail !

    Do you already receive the AM via mail? You can help us cut printing costs by changing to e-mail.

    Please fill out the following information, copy this page and FAX it back to us at 503-373-7348

    You will begin receiving the AM via e-mail only. Thank you !

    Name:_______________________________________________________________________________________

    E-Mail Address:(Please print)____________________________________________________________________

    Mailing Address: _____________________________________________________________________________

    Phone: ______________________________________________________________________________________

    between generations.

    Traditional Healing IssuesYour agency may have some

    clients who choose to use familiar

    folk or traditional cultural treatment

    practices in conjunction with your

    organizations treatment strategy.

    It is important to show tolerance of

    and respect for this issue to fully

    understand the client and provide

    appropriate treatment.

    Discussing client beliefs about the

    possible causes of an illness and

    the remedies tried previously can

    be helpful in developing a treat-

    ment plan. It is also important to

    ask whether the strategy developed

    to assist the client conflicts in some

    way with personal beliefs and

    traditional practices.

    The mnemonic framework ETH-

    NIC created by Levin, et al

    (2000) is a tool that can be used by

    care providers who work with

    clients who use folk or traditional

    practices to provide culturally

    competent care. A summary of

    questions and issues within the

    framework include:

    Explanation:

    What do you think may be the

    reason you have this problem?

    What do friends, family, and others

    say about your symptoms? Do

    you know anyone else who has

    had or who now has this kind of

    problem? Have you heard about/

    read about/seen it on TV/radio/

    newspaper? If clients cannot offer

    an explanation ask what most

    concerns them about their problem.

    Treatment:

    What kinds of medicines, home

    remedies, or other treatments have

    you tried for this illness? Is there

    anything you eat, drink, or do (oravoid) on a regular basis to stay

    healthy? Tell me about it. What

    kind of treatment are you seeking

    from me?

    Healers:Have you sought any advice from

    alternative or folk healers, friends,

    or other people who are not

    doctors on help with your prob-

    lems? Tell me about it.

    Negotiate:Try to find options that will be

    mutually acceptable to you and the

    client that incorporate the clients

    beliefs, rather than contradicting

    them.

    Intervention:Determine an intervention with

    your client that may incorporate

    alternative treatments, spirituality,

    traditional healers, science-based

    alternatives and other cultural

    practices.

    Collaboration:Collaborate with the client, family

    members, other health care team

    members, healers, and community

    resources.

    The standard for addiction treat-

    ment should be inclusive of these

    cultural considerations. When they

    are seen as an essential part of

    treatment planning, only then do

    we begin to truly individualize care.

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    9/13

    DECEMBER 2002 VOLUME 5, ISSUE 12 PLEASE COPY OR POST

    Ideas for Treatment Improvement

    Cultural Competence: Counselor Approaches

    Northwest Frontier

    Addiction Technology

    Transfer Center

    3414 Cherry Ave NE, Suite 100Salem OR 97303

    Phone: (503) 373-1322

    FAX: (503) 373-7348

    A project of

    Oregon Health &Science University

    Steve Gallon, Ph.D.,Project Director

    Mary Ann e Bryan, [email protected]

    Be sure to check out

    our web page at:

    http://www.nfattc.com

    Unifying science,

    education and

    services to

    transform lives

    Recogni ze dif ferences; but bui ld

    on simi lari ties...

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote, Ph.D.

    This final article in our cultural compe-

    tency series will provide information

    on working with clients from several

    cultural backgrounds. General concerns, strat-

    egies, challenges, and suggestions for devel-

    oping an effective therapeutic relationship will

    be addressed. While numerous cultural groups

    are represented in our society, this issue fo-

    cuses on four of the largest: African Ameri-

    cans, American Indian/Alaskan Natives, His-

    panic Americans, and Asian American/PacificIslanders. Hopefully, the ideas that appear in

    the following paragraphs will inspire creative

    and culturally sensitive approaches to treat-

    ment planning and delivery.

    It is important to keep in mind that diversity

    exists within all groups of people. What may

    be true for most of the individuals from a par-

    ticular cultural group will probably not be ac-

    curate for all. Approaching each person as

    unique will facilitate your own flexibility and

    creativity, and will help you develop a treat-

    ment plan that is truly sensitive to the indi-vidual needs of the client.

    Cultural Issues in Substance Abuse Treat-

    ment (Center for Substance Abuse Treatment

    , 1999) was used as a major resource for the

    following information. Due to space limita-

    tions, the discussion is brief and meant to

    stimulate your thinking. For more detailed in-

    formation you may order a copy from the Na-

    tional Clearinghouse for Alcohol and Drug

    Information (NCADI) at (800) 729-6686.

    African AmericanThe vast majority of African Americans do not

    engage in substance abuse. For those who do,

    the patterns vary by age with many tending not

    to begin use until after age 21. Initially mari-

    juana is one of the most commonly used sub-stances. There appears to be a tendency to

    progress from marijuana to heroin.

    Health and Social I ssuesAfrican Americans have higher rates of alco-

    hol related medical problems than their white

    counterparts even though whites have a higher

    rate of alcohol use and abuse. HIV infection

    is the fourth leading cause of death in African

    Americans. HIV/AIDS disproportionately af-

    fect African Americans in general and espec-

    ially injection drug users. Social repercus-

    sions are serious with an estimated half ofAfrican American men in prison serving drug-

    related sentences.

    Tr eatment ConcernsIssues of trust are the core to service delivery

    problems. If a non-African American counse-

    lor does not possess a cultural knowledge base,

    negative attributions and stereotypes may be

    perceived and/or influence the interactions

    with clients. For example, many women who

    are heads of households have been categorized

    as dysfunctional. Such families often prac-

    tice a communal form of child rearing. Ex-

    tended families are often referred to as a kin-

    ship network. The African proverb, It takes a

    whole village to raise a child reflects this tra-

    dition.

    Stereotyping and institutional racism have pro-

    found effects on treatm ent access and comple-

    tion. Negative experiences with welfare and

    social system s have caused m any of these

    fam ilies and individuals to be hesitant in pro-

    viding personal inform ation. Questions m ay

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    10/13

    NFATTC ADDICTION MESSENGER DECEMBER 20022PAGE

    Cultural Competency Websites

    DHHS Initiative to Eliminate Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health

    http:www.raceandhealth.hhs.gov

    ETHNOMED

    http:www.hslib.washington.edu/clinical/ethnomed/index.html

    DIVERSITYRX

    http:www.diversityrx.org

    Cross Cultural Health Care

    http:www.xculture.org

    Transcultural Care Associates

    http:www.transculturalcare.net

    National Center for Cultural Competence

    http:www.georgetown.edu/research/gucdc

    be viewed as prying if an attempt at

    building trust with your client has not

    been established. Church affiliation

    can be a valuable resource to the cli-

    ent. Participation in church activities

    can improve a persons recovery and

    decrease the chance of relapse.

    Some treatment programs develop an

    Afrocentric approach, which combines

    best practices with an African value

    system. Such programs emphasize

    oneness of spirit between people and

    nature. African proverbs can be used

    to enhance treatment through increas-

    ing insight and broadening perspectives

    and thinking styles. Examples of prov-

    erbs are:

    The ruin of a nation begins in the

    homes of its people (Ashanti)

    He who conceals his disease cannot

    expect to be cured (Ethiopia)

    Even an ant may harm an elephant

    (Zululand)

    American Indian/AlaskanNativeWith over 400 American Indian tribes,

    it is important that they not be placed

    into a large melting pot. Each has its

    own beliefs, ceremonies, and tradi-tions. Alcohol is the drug most fre-

    quently used by American Indians.

    They tend to begin using alcohol and

    illicit drugs at an earlier age than other

    cultural groups. Youth frequently

    abuse inhalants.

    Health and Social I ssues

    The negative health and social conse-

    quences that American Indians suffer

    because of substance abuse are both

    quantitatively and qualitatively higher

    than other cultural groups. Health

    problems include: heart disease, can-

    cer, diabetes, injuries and death. More

    die from suicide, homicide and alco-

    hol-related injuries than any other

    group. Women tend to die at higher

    rates due to alcohol-involved causes

    than women in other cultural groups.

    Treatment Concerns

    Using culturally sensitive approaches

    that incorporate and reinforce tradi-

    tional lifestyles increases retention

    rates among Alaskan Natives, for whom

    binge drinking is a common pattern.

    The main barrier affecting treatment is

    the lack of social services. Clients liv-

    ing in remote areas often resist leav-

    ing their communities to seek treat-

    ment. Confrontational methods (even

    direct eye contact) with this group are

    both ineffective and potentially dam-

    aging. Situational role modeling and

    practice have been found to be useful

    and effective relapse prevention tech-

    niques.

    The use of counseling, psychotherapy

    and referral to 12-Step programs, while

    effective in the mainstream, may not

    appeal to American Indian clients who

    often take a long time to disclose per-

    sonal information about their lives.

    Being aware of historic issues sur-

    rounding trust is important while es-

    tablishing a therapeutic relationship

    with the client. It is important to use a

    holistic approach that integrates the useof traditional ceremonies, beliefs, val-

    ues and practices in treatment. A cul-

    turally competent treatment plan would

    include contact with immediate and ex-

    tended family members and collabo-

    ration with and referral to community

    organizations. Traditional practices

    that can be used in treatment for

    American Indians include:

    Talking Circle

    The Talking Circle or Talking Stick is a

    group activity in which group membersare seated in a circle. The group leader

    introduces the Talking Stick and passes

    it around the circle. As each member

    receives the stick they have the oppor-

    tunity to speak freely without fear of

    rejection or interruption.

    Sweat L odge

    The Sweat Lodge is a small dome-

    shaped structure with heated rocks in

    the center and participants sitting in a

    circle around the edge of the lodge.

    Water is poured over the rocks to cre-ate steam and prayers are said. The pur-

    pose of the Sweat Lodge is to bring par-

    ticipants closer to the Creator.

    The Good Way

    The Good Way promotes spiritual heal-

    ing through using traditional culture in

    interpreting the 12-Step program. An

    example would be - Step 2: I believe

    that a greater spirit can help me to re-

    gain my responsibilities and model the

    life of my forefathers (ancestors).

    Hispanic AmericansHispanics tend to use cocaine at higher

    rates than African Americans and

    Whites. With regard to gender differ-

    ences, Hispanic women have lower

    substance abuse rates than their male

    counterparts. Acculturation may play

    a role in this because the longer women

    have been in the U.S. culture the more

    their use patterns mirror the patterns

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    11/13

    NFATTC ADDICTION MESSENGER DECEMBER 2002

    Sources:

    3PAGE

    Treatment Engagement

    Issues

    Next I ssue:

    You Can Receive the Addiction Messenger Via E-M ail !

    Do you already receive the AM via mail? You can help us cut printing costs by changing to e-mail.

    Please fill out the following information, copy this page and FAX it back to us at 503-373-7348

    You will begin receiving the AM via e-mail only. Thank you !

    Name:_______________________________________________________________________________________

    E-Mail Address:(Please print)____________________________________________________________________

    Mailing Address: _____________________________________________________________________________

    Phone:______________________________________________________________________________________

    Center for Substance Abuse Treatment(1999). Cul tur al I ssues in Substance

    Abuse Tr eatment. Rockville, Maryland

    of women in the general population.

    Health and Social I ssuesHispanic Americans have a higher per-

    centage of AIDS cases related to in-

    jection drug use than the general popu-

    lation. Tuberculosis in this group of-

    ten parallels injection drug use and HIV

    infection in the community.

    Tr eatment ConcernsHispanic clients will benefit from

    treatment programs that address the

    following:

    * Language, socioeconomic, cultural

    and geographic barriers,

    * Immigration status (legal versus

    illegal),

    * Level of acculturation, and

    * Service integration.

    Underutilization of treatment pro-

    grams by Hispanics can also be linked

    to lack of bilingual or bicultural staff.

    The Hispanic culture values an empha-

    sis on respect and the development of

    trust in relationships. Confrontational

    approaches used in some programs are

    degrading to Hispanic clients and are

    destructive to their self-esteem. Treat-ment that focuses on a holistic ap-

    proach which integrates traditional val-

    ues and beliefs and attends to the de-

    velopment of a continuing care plan

    that reintegrates the client back into

    their community will be beneficial to

    tend to have a lower prevalence of sub-

    stance abuse than other cultural groups.

    For those who do use, abuse patterns

    and the drug of choice vary across sub-groups. A clients personal migratory

    experience and level of acculturation

    can add a unique dimension when con-

    sidering their substance abuse history

    and appropriate treatment plan.

    Health and Social I ssuesSubstance abuse problems are on the

    rise with Asian Americans and Pacific

    Islanders. The relationship between

    substance abuse and crime has been

    consistently strong as with other cul-

    tural groups. It has been noted that ad-aptation to Western culture has

    changed the once hierarchical family

    structure, family member interdepen-

    dence and self-identity of this groups

    youth. This may be a factor in sub-

    stance abuse predisposition for them.

    Treatment ConcernsThe diversity of Asian Americans and

    Pacific Islanders has made providing

    culturally competent services to this

    group a complex issue. The acknow-

    ledgement of a substance abuse prob-lem often leads to a considerable loss

    of face and feelings of shame for both

    the client and their family. Substance

    abuse behaviors may be under reported.

    Treatment interventions that exclude or

    separate the client from their family

    may be resisted. Strategies that appear

    to decrease powerful family relation-

    ships or that blame the parent will not

    be advantageous to treatment. Seek-

    ing assistance from a treatment pro-

    gram is usually viewed as a last resort

    by the family and goes outside of nor-

    mal acceptable parameters of a culture

    that prefers to handle problems withinthe family.

    It is important for treatment providers

    to be aware of multiple losses, stress-

    related issues and adaptation difficul-

    ties for many members of all these

    cultural groups. Using interventions

    such as psycho-education, role-mod-

    eling and practice, and development of

    coping skills can be productive strate-

    gies that demonstrate respect and an ap-

    preciation for cultural differences.

    Maintaining an awareness of cultureand developing appropriate treatment

    approaches are never ending challenges

    for us and can be consistent sources

    of satisfaction for both the provider and

    the client.

    the therapeutic relationship.

    Asian American/Pacific

    IslandersAsian Americans and Pacific Islanders

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    12/13

    Post-TestSeries 8

    Cir cle the corr ect answer for each question

    #1

    A set of congruent behaviors, attitudes and policies that

    enable an agency to work effectively in cross-cultural

    situations defines:a. Cultural awareness

    b. Cultural competence

    c. Cultural knowledge

    d. Cultural sensitivity

    e. None of the above

    #2

    A definition of ethnicity would include the way in which

    groups of people retain and practice customs, language, and

    social views of their group.

    True False

    #3

    Characteristics of providing culturally responsive services

    would include:

    a. sensitivity to cultural nuances of the client population.

    b. having staff that is representative of the population.

    c. providing services that dont reflect cultural values.

    d. none of the above

    e. a and b

    #4

    Cultural competence:

    a. does not influence the development of a treatment plan.

    b. does not facilitate the acccuracy of a diagnosisc. allows the provider to obtain more specific and complete

    information

    d. b and c

    e. all of the above

    #5

    Cultural competence:

    a. improves the overall communication and clinical interac-

    tions between client and provider.

    b. leads to improved diagnosis and treatment plans.

    c. does not lead to greater client compliance.

    d. a and b

    e. b and c

    #6

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote describes a new model of

    cultural competence that includes only the following:

    cultural awareness, cultural sensitivity, and cultural skills. True False

    #7

    In Ruth G. Deans article, The Myth of Cross-Cultural

    Competence, she suggests :

    a. maintaining an awareness of ones lack of cultural

    competence is a goal.

    b. that people dont have cultural bggage.

    c. that it is difficult to become competent at something

    (culture) that is continually changing.

    d. a and b

    e. a and c

    #8

    Josepha Campinha-Bacote notes that the pivotal construct of

    cultural competence that provides the energy source and

    foundation for the journey towards cultural competence

    comes from:

    a. cultural encounters

    b. cultural desire

    c. cultural knowledge

    d. a and b

    e. none of the above

    #9

    A culturally competent agency should implement culturalcompetence at various levels such as:

    a. agency attitudes

    b. agency practices

    c. agency policies and procedures

    d. a and b

    e. all of the above

    #10

    Is cultural competency a goal of your agency?

    True False

    FAX: (503) 373-7348

    You can still register for continuing education hours forSer ies 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 or 7

    Contact Mary Anne Br yan at (503) 373-1322 ext. 224

    Mail or FAX your completed test to NFATTC

    Northwest Frontier ATTC, 3414 Cherry Ave. NE, Suite 100, Salem, OR 97303

  • 8/14/2019 AM v5 Series 4

    13/13

    We are interestted in your reactions to the information provided in Series 8of the Addiction

    Messenger. As part of your 2 continuing education hours we request that you write a short

    response, approximately100 words, regarding Series 8. The following list gives you some sugges-

    tions but should not limit your response.

    What was your reaction to the concepts presented in Series 8?

    How did you react to the amount of information provided?

    How will you use this information?Have you shared this information with co-workers?

    What information would have liked more detailabout?

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________