amman chs exchange · amman chs exchange 2019 1 one hundred participants from more than 15...
TRANSCRIPT
MAKING AID WORK BETTER FOR PEOPLE
AMMAN CHS EXCHANGE CONFERENCE REPORT 2-3 July 2019
TABLE OF CONTENT
Introduction 1
Exploring the key Humanitarian Issues in the Region 2
The role of the CHS in the MENA region 4
OrganisationalperspectivesonusingtheCHStodrivechange 5
FindingsolutionstomeetthemostchallengingCHSCommitments 7
Commitment 3 - Humanitarian response strengthens local capacities and avoids negative effects 7
Commitment 4 - Humanitarian response is based on n communication, participation and feedback 10
Commitment 5 - Complaints are welcomed and addressed 12
Commitment 8 - Staff are supported to do their job effectively, and are treated fairly and equitably 14
Closing remarks 16
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
1Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Onehundredparticipantsfrommorethan15countriesgatheredinJordanon2-3July2019 for a conference dedicated to exploring how the Core Humanitarian Standard onQualityandAccountability(CHS)canmakeaidworkbetterforpeopleincrisis.
The Amman CHS Exchange, hosted by the CHS Alliance and Islamic Relief Worldwide, broughttogetherrepresentativesfrom50nationalandinternationalhumanitarianordevelopmentorganisationsworkingintheregionandgloballytodiscusshowtheCoreHumanitarianStandardis“ADriverofChange”.
Organisationsrepresentedincluded22CHSAlliancemembers.Amongthem,eightorganisationsarecertifiedagainsttheCHS(IslamicRelief,Tearfund,DanishRefugeeCouncil, Dan Church Aid, Norwegian Church Aid, Finn Church Aid, Oxfam, Medair), oneisindependentlyverifiedorganisation(ActionAid),and11areself-assessed(ACTED,ActionAidKenya,CAREInternational,IRC,IRW,Medair,Diakomia,Malteser,Johanniter,Oxfam,PlanInternational).
TheAmmanCHSExchangewasdesignedforlearningandtosharegoodpracticeonapplyingtheCHS.Whenweusetheninecommitments,webetterassistpeoplewhohavebeenaffectedbycrisis.
Weacknowledgetheexcellentsupportofthesteeringcommittee,withrepresentativesfromCHSAlliance,IslamicReliefWorldwide/JordanandDisasterEmergencyCommittee.Thisreportsummarisesthemaintakeawaysoftheevent.
INTRODUCTION
2 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
EXPLORING THE KEY HUMANITARIAN ISSUES IN THE REGION
“It has never been more important than now to apply the CHS Standard” – Panos Moumtsiz
ParticipantswerewelcomedbyIslamicReliefJordanCountryDirector,Elsadig Elnour Kabbashi,whohighlightedtheopportunityprovidedbythislearningevent.“Together,wewillsharethoughtsonhowthesestandardscandrivechangeatdifferentlevelsintermsofqualityofhumanitarianaiddelivery,andwhatwecollectivelycandotomeettheCHSCommitments”hesaid.
Panos Moumtzis,UnitedNationsAssistantSecretary-General,RegionalHumanitarianCoordinatorfortheSyriacrisis,deliveredaninspiringkeynotespeechthatmadethelink between the humanitarian principles the CHS embodies and the importance of bringingthestandarddowntofieldlevel.
Elsadig Elnour Kabbashi, Opening Session | © Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
3Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Heremindedtheparticipantsthathumanitarianworkisaquestionofdignityandrespect,andthattheCHSisthe“benchmark”forthis.HehighlightedtheneedtotakeprotectionextremelyseriouslyandtakeactionbyensuringCodeofConductandcomplaintsmechanismsareinplace.Staffmustbeawareofandtrainedonthese.
“Today’sgatheringismusictomyearsandIamproudtobepartofthemovementthattriestoshapeaid,”saidMoumtzis.“Weareheretobringforwardinthebestpossiblewaystheaidtoaffectedpopulation.TheCHSStandardsshouldbeappliedbyeveryoneinthesector.
“‘HowdowebringtheCHStothefield?’Therearetechnicalstandards,likeinwaterandsanitation,oreconomicsecurity.Butweshouldalsorememberaboutthemoralstandards,whichareoftenaboutourvalues.
“CHShastobelikeaguidebook,oneveryone’sdeskandusedbyall.That’stheminimumwewanttoadhereto.It’sthepracticalpartthathelpstoguidetheassistanceweareplanningandeachclustershouldtakeownershipforit”.
Tanya Wood,ExecutiveDirector of the CHS Alliance, closed the session by challengingeveryoneintheroom to work together to keepraisingthestandard.“None of this happens by accident.Itcomesfromputtinginplaceaccountabilityprocessesatanorganizationallevel.TheCHSisthetooltodothis.”
Panos Moumtsiz, Opening Session | © Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
Tanya Wood, Opening Session | © Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
4 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
How well do we know the Core Humanitarian Standard?Aninitialpolloftheparticipantsrevealedthat77%ofrespondentssaidtheirorganisationhasworkedwiththeCoreHumanitarianStandard,forexampledoingaverificationorsomethingelserelatedtoimplementingthestandard.Morethanhalf(59%)havebeeninvolvedindividuallywiththeCHSAlliance,forexample,participatingintraining,webinarsorevents.
TheresponsestoaCHSquizdemonstratedanimpressivelevelofawarenessaboutthestandardamongparticipants.
THE ROLE OF THE CHS IN THE MENA REGION
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
5Amman CHS Exchange 2019
ORGANISATIONAL PERSPECTIVES ON USING THE CHS TO DRIVE CHANGE
How can the Core Humanitarian Standard (CHS) drive change in the region?
A panel, facilitated by Bonaventure Sokpoh,HeadofPolicy,AdvocacyandLearning,CHSAlliance,discussedtherolestandardscanplayinimprovingaiddeliveryfororganisations.
The panellists were:
• Mindy Abraham,DeputyCountryDirector,MedairLebanon,wholeadtheMédaircertificationprocessatcountrylevel
• Shabel Firuz,ProgrammeImpact&LearningManager,IslamicReliefWorldwide,wholeadtheircertificationprocessattheheadquarters
• Amani Salah,HeadofHumanitarianFinancingUnitOCHAJordan,whoisresponsiblefortheCountry-BasedPoolFundinJordan.
ThespeakershighlightedthealignmentoftheCHSwiththeirorganisationalvalues,suchasdignityandaccountability.TheydiscussedtheimportanceofengagingseniorstafftodemonstratehowaidorganisationscanleadthedrivetosupporttheCHS.
ShabelFiruzsaid:“Commonunderstandingofexpectedstandardsisimportant…Thedrivetowardqualityandaccountabilityisunderpinnedbytheorganisationalvaluesandbackedupbyfullbuy-infromtheseniormanagement.”
“TheCHShastriggeredawake-upcalltobemoreintentionaloncommunicatingpolicieswithstaff,”saidMindyAbraham.
OntheissueofCHSverification,anumberofadvantageswerehighlightedtoorganisationswhohavegonethroughoneoftheprocesses.Theseincludedbetterconnectionbetweentheheadquarters,countryprogrammesandpartners;thecollectionofgoodpractices;andthesystematicapplicationofpoliciesontheground.
Mandatedbyhumanitarianprinciples,OCHAiscommittedtoensurethatitspartnersapplytheCHSsaidAmaniSalah.
6 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Participantsraisedanddiscussedtheimportanceof:
• theadherenceofthedonorstotheCHStoencourageitsapplicationwhilemakingsurethatthestandardtrulyservespeopleincrisis(inotherwordskeeping the CHS from becoming just another compliance check)
• thelearningandimprovementaspect
• thechallengesofcertificationagainsttheCHSinpartnerships
• thechallengesofgettingnationalandlocalactorstoapplytheCHS.
Mindy Abraham, Bonaventure Sokpoh, Amani Salah and Shabel Firuz, Panel Discussion © Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
7Amman CHS Exchange 2019
FINDING SOLUTIONS TO MEET THE MOST CHALLENGING CHS COMMITMENTS
Commitment 3 - Humanitarian response strengthens local capacities and avoids negative effects
Thissessionexaminedcommitment3-humanitarianresponsestrengthenslocalcapacitiesandavoidsnegativeeffects.ItwasfacilitatedbyKatyBobbin,DisasterEmergencyCommittee(DEC)andTanyaWood,CHSAlliance.
Toaidbetterunderstandingofthecommitment,thesessionstartedwithabriefpresentationontheorganisationalresponsibilitiesandkeyactionsrelatedtoit,andhowweasasectorarereachingthem.
Threetablediscussionstookplacearoundthefollowinggoodpracticeexamples:
Thegroupcrowdsourcedwhichindicatorsofthecommitment3theywouldliketodiscussinmoredepthtocollectivelyexploresomeofthemainchallengesintheregion.Asummaryofthesediscussionsfollows.
Organisation name Presenters Title
Medair MargieDavisCash for Health in refugees
in Jordan
IRC KathrynHoeflichPartnershipExcellenceforEqualityandResultsSystem
Tearfund MattBrimbleWorkingwithanational
partnerwhoisCHScertified
8 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
3.8 Systems in place to safeguard personal data collected from communities and people affected by crisis that can put them at risk.
Thereareanumberofpracticalimplementationchallengesforhowpersonaldataiscollectedandhandled.Forexample,itiscommonpractice(whenworkinginareaslikeCox’sBazaar)thatlistsofbeneficiariesarepassedarounddifferentaidworkers.OneorganisationsharedhowtheirCHSauditpickedthisupandissuedacorrectiveactionrelatingtoindicator3.8.Dataprotectionanddatasharingwereidentifiedascriticalissuesforaidagenciesthisyear.
Proposedsolutionsincludedraisinggeneralawarenessaboutdataprotection,althoughthiswasacknowledgedtobe“adouble-edgedsword”withthepotentialtoscarepeopleifnothandledsensitively.Othersolutionsincludedimplementingadataprotectionpolicy,andusingcustomerrelationsmanagementsoftware.Itwas also noted that employees must be trained on using complaints and feedback mechanisms.
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
9Amman CHS Exchange 2019
3.5 Design and implement programmes that promote early disaster recovery and benefit the local economy.
Fivemainchallengeswereidentified:1)workingwithgovernments,2)workingwithlocalpartnersorcommunities&families,3)senseofcompetitionbetweenINGOs,4)abilitytodevelopacomprehensiveearlyrecoveryplan,and5)unintended,negativeeffectsonthelocalcommunityofhumanitarianaction.
Theimportanceofbuildinglongtermrelationshipswasstressedasasolution,alongwithincreasinglocalpeople’sparticipationandcapacitybuilding.Localprocurementand working to restore farms or factories or schools were also proposed for resilience-building.
3.4 Plan a transition or exit strategy in the early stages of the humanitarian programme that ensures longer-term positive effects and reduces the risk of dependency.
Aiddeliverybeing“toodonordriven”wasseenasachallenge,alongwithlackofcollaborationbetweendifferentactors,andnocleartimelines.Therewasanobservationthatthe“CHSverificationprocesscanbetooidealistic”.
Solutionstotackletheseissuesincluded:
• morecoordinationbetweenreliefanddevelopmentactors• abetterunderstandingofpeople’sneeds
• contingencyplanningandconstantevaluations
• takingthelong-termviewinstrategy(diversifyingdonors)
• buildinganexitstrategyintoresponseplanningfromthebeginning.
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
10 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Commitment 4 - Humanitarian response is based on n communication, participation and feedback
This session looked at the CHS commitment 4 – Humanitarian responseisbasedoncommunication,participationandfeedback.ThesessionwasfacilitatedbyBonaventureSokpoh,CHSAllianceandGenevièveCyvoct,CHSAlliance.
Commitment4isthesecondmostchallengingcommitmentbasedontheaveragescoresfromtheCHSverificationdata.TheCHSindicator4.1relatedtoprovidinginformationtocommunitiesandpeopleaffectedbycrisishasthelowestscoreamongtheindicatorsofthiscommitment.Theparticipationandengagementofcommunities(indicator4.3)andwelcomingfeedback(indicator4.4)arefairlylowtoo.Wearedoingbetteronpoliciesthanpractices.
Ourperceptionsofhowwearedoingcanbeverydifferentfromthoseofthepeopleweareserving.ThiswasshownbyafieldsurveyconductedinChadbyGroundTruthSolutionsin2018where60%ofcommunitymembersfeltinformedaboutservicesavailabletothemand90%ofstafffeltthatcommunitywerewellinformed.WeallcommittedourselvestotheGrandBargainParticipationRevolution,butweareall—organisationsanddonors—strugglingtomakeitareality.
Threegoodpracticeswherepresentedanddiscussedwiththeparticipants.
Organisation name Presenters Title
ActionAidClareBleasdale
William GrayAccountability in
Emergencies Resource book
Islamic Relief Hadeel HassounMobile Education Bus
Project
InternationalRescueCommittee
Walaa AlshalanIRC Jordan office’s client responsiveness practices
11Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Thegoodpracticessharedrevealedonthegroundofactivitiesthatimprovethelevelof commitment 4, including:
• Radioshowsandtheatreproductionstoprovideinformationtocommunitiesandpeopleincrisisandcollectfeedback(indicator4.1)
• Workingwithcommunitiestodesigntheprojectandsharinginformationabouttheactivities,includingbudgets(indicator4.3)
• Doingregularvisitswithwomenandyouthtoundertakereflectioncyclesandconductingimpact/satisfaction/exitsurveystocapturebeneficiaries’feedback(indicator4.4)
Themostimportantremainingchallengesandpossiblesolutionsdiscussedwere:
• Dynamicdisplacementofpeople.Participantsidentifiedtheuseoffocalpoints,communityleadersand/orcommunity-basedorganisationstoupdateinformation.Theyalsosuggestedtheuseofdiversechannelsforexampleradioortheatre(fortwo-waycommunication)
• Resistancefromstaffandstaffturnover.Totacklethischallenge,participantssuggestedmoreuseofonlinetraining.Organisationscandomoreworkwithfrontlinestaffonhowtoreflectfeedbackintheirorganisation’spractices.
• Childfriendlyfeedbackmechanism.Participantssharedexamplesregardingusingrecordedobservationsonchildrenfromthestarttotheendoftheproject.
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
12 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Commitment 5 - Complaints are welcomed and addressed
Awell-attendedsessiononcommitment5–complaintsarewelcomedandaddressed–wasfacilitatedbyKarenGlissonandRosaArgentbothoftheCHSAlliance.
FivediversepresentationsofgoodpracticerelatingtothismostchallengingcommitmentoftheCHSweresharedwiththegroup.Thiswasfollowedbytablediscussionsondifferenttopics.
Thegoodpracticessharedrevealedhoworganisationsintheregionareapproachingkeyissuessuchasconsultationwithcommunities,complaintsmanagementandreferrals,throughdevelopingstrongprocessesandmechanismsforfollowingupwiththecomplaints.
Importantremainingchallengesandpossiblesolutionsdiscussed(byindicator)are:
5.1 Consult with communities and people affected by crisis on the design, implementation and monitoring of complaints-handling processes.
Challengestomeaningfulconsultationwithcommunitiesincludedculturalbarriers,fearofretaliationfromaffectedindividualsandalsosurveyfatigue.Solutionstoaddresstheseincludedmovingfromaprojecttoaprogrammebasedapproach,asthiswillreducethenumberofconsultations.Anotheractionwasbriefingthecommunityfromtheoutsetaboutthecomplaintsmechanismandhowtouseit.
Organisation name Presenters Title
CARE MoiezAhmedNew guidance on feedback
and complaints mechanisms
ACTED Claudia Tromboni Complaints mechanism
NRCChristiandeLuca Hadeel Al Omari
Jordan child-friendly complaints mechanism
World Vision Reem Mahmoud Almasri Complaints mechanism
InternationalMedicalCorps Michael GallCommunity-based feedback
& response mechanism global guidelines
13Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Challengestomeaningfulconsultationwithcommunitiesincludedculturalbarriers,fearofretaliationfromaffectedindividualsandalsosurveyfatigue.Solutionstoaddresstheseincludedmovingfromaprojecttoaprogrammebasedapproach,asthiswillreducethenumberofconsultations.Anotheractionwasbriefingthecommunityfromtheoutsetaboutthecomplaintsmechanismandhowtouseit.
5.3 Managing complaints in a timely and fair manner that prioritises the safety of the complainant at all stages
Identifyingthemostappropriatechannel(s)forreceivingcomplaintsandfeedbackwasdiscussed.Thisisnotalwaysobvious.Communityconsultationassiststhedesignofthemechanism.Theabilitytoprocess,takedecisions,respondandclosecomplaintswasalsoconsideredamajorchallenge.Usingappropriatetechnologyanassistwiththis,alongwithdedicatedresources.
5.4 The complaints-handling process is documented and in place (including PSEA) & 5.5 Establishing an organisational culture in which complaints are taken seriously and acted upon according to defined policies and processes
ChallengesforhandingPSEAcomplaintswerediscussed,includinginplaceswherealackofpoliciesleadtoadhocprocesses,orprocessesthatwereverycomplicated.Itwasalsonotedthatthereissometimesabreakdownincommunicationbetweenpolicymakersandoperationalstaff,whichcausesimplementationchallenges.Specificsolutionsproposedincludedtranslatingpoliciesintolocallanguagesandsharingwithpartnersontheground.Involvinglocalstaffinpolicydevelopmentwasrecommended.Standardisingandsimplifyingprocesseswerealsosuggested.
Itwasacknowledgedthatthehandlingofsensitivecomplaintsisnotalwayseasytogetright.Waystoaddressthesechallengesincludebuildingapositivestaffculture(includingrunningCodeofConducttrainingsessions),improvingthestaffratioformajorcomplaintshandling,andputtingconfidentialsystemsandprocessesinplace.
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
14 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Commitment 8 - Staff are supported to do their job effectively, and are treated fairly and equitably
Thesessionlookedatcommitment8—staffaresupportedtodotheirjobeffectively,andaretreatedfairlyandequitably.ItwasfacilitatedbyGozelBaltaeva,CHSAllianceandMayumiFuchi,IslamicReliefWorldwide.
Goodpracticeexamplesweresharedanddiscussedfurther:
Someofthemainchallengesfacingorganisationswererecruitmentandretention(staffturnover),workingwithpartners,takingasystematicapproachtotraining,havingtheresourcestoimplementtrainingschemesandfocusingonstaffwellbeinginemergencysituations.
Organisation name Presenters Title
Islamic Relief Worldwide Mayumi FuchiIRW’s revision of the Code of
Conduct in preparation for CHS Audit
Tearfund MattBrimble
ReviewofPartnerAssessmentprocess&developmentofa
‘Disaster Management Capacity Assessment’ tool in reply to
CorrectiveActionRequest8.4:“Tearfund does not ensure asystematicassessment
andfollowupofitsstaffandpartners”.
Norwegian Church Aid (NCA) SwatiAbida
Meetingcommitment8obligations:introductionof4
pillars (security risk assessment, mitigationefforts,information,training)aroundstaffsecurity
andriskmanagement.
15Amman CHS Exchange 2019
Potentialsolutionsoractionstotakeforward(byCHSindicator)include:
8.3 Staff develop and use the necessary personal, technical and management competencies to fulfil their role and understand how the organisation can support them.
Solutionsincludestrengtheningonboarding,increasingthequalityofjobdescriptions,andunderstandingstaffmotivationsforstaying.
8.4 The organisation has the management and staff capacity and capability to deliver its programs).
Sharingpracticestogetandkeeptherightpeopleisonesolution.Othersincludeinvestinginapartner’scapacitybuilding,andbeingflexibletoadapttocontinuouschanges.
8.9 Policies are in place for the security and the wellbeing of staff.
Actionstoaddressthisincludedrunningemployeeassistanceprogrammesonlineandinhouseforcounsellingandotherservices.Ongoingtrainingsandinvolvingpartnerswhendevelopingandreviewingsecurityplanswerealsoproposed.
Overall,theCHSAlliancecanhelpwithanumberofthesechallengesthroughencouragingitsmemberstosharetheirgoodpractices(toolsandresources)onstaffmanagementanddevelopment.
Havingacodeofconductisinplacethatestablishes,ataminimum,theobligationofstaffnottoexploit,abuseorotherwisediscriminateagainstpeople(8.7)alsofaceschallenges.Theseincludehowtointegratethevaluesinthedocumentintodailylife,howpartnersandcontractorsalignwithanorganisation’scodeofconduct,anddifferentculturalnorms.Theriskofabusersslippingthroughgapswasraised.
SomeideastoaddresstheseincludedhavingstaffundertakeE-learning/testingpriortotakingacontract,havingrandominternalstaffaudits,andmorethoroughandconsistentbackgroundandreferralchecks.TheCHSAlliancecansupportmembersthroughgatheringandsharingbestpracticetools,resourcesandlessonslearnt.
© Isalmic Relief Worldwide/CHS Alliance
16 Amman CHS Exchange 2019
TheconferenceclosedwithElsadigElnourKabbashi,IslamicReliefJordan’sCountryDirector,thankingparticipantsforbringingtheir“tremendousknowledge”totheCHSExchange.Whileacknowledgingthatchallengesremain,hesaid:“Itishightimeforallorganisationstocometogethertostandardiseourtoolsforpeopleaffectedandfordonors.”
AcriticalstandardtoachievethisistheCoreHumanitarianStandard.
TanyaWood,ExecutiveDirectoroftheCHSAlliance,endedwitharallyingcalltoaction.“AsweapproachfiveyearsoftheCoreHumanitarianStandard,wehavecomealongway.TheCHSAlliancehas155membersandwidespreadendorsementfrommembersanddonors.Wearenowatacriticaljuncture—movingfrombabystepstoadulthood—asweenterthisphaseofmaturity.Wehopeyouwillmaintainandstrengthenyourcollaborationwithusonthisjourneytomakeaidworkbetterforpeopleincrisis.”
Participants’ feedback
Resultsofanonlinesurveyshowedthattheparticipants:
• Found the opening session inspiring
• valuedtheopportunityofnetworking/exchangeofknowledgebetweenparticipants,thegoodvarietyofparticipants(fromheadquarters,regionsandcountries) and presenters
• Enjoyedtheparallelsessionsandtablediscussionswheregoodpracticeswereshared and discussed
• LikedthefocusonthemorechallengingCHScommitments
Participantssuggestedthefollowingimprovementforfuturelearningevents:
• Moreandsmallerbreakoutsessionswithoptimalnumberofselectedpresenters
• Morepracticalexamples/practicaltoolsandresourcestosharewithparticipants
• Moreinteractivepaneldiscussion
• Bringinmorelocalpartners,governmentbodiesanddonorsandmorefocusonthelocalcontext.
CLOSING REMARKS