1 chromium plating replacement at sikorsky aircraft robert guillemette john bartalotta materials and...

1

CHROMIUM PLATING REPLACEMENT AT

SIKORSKY AIRCRAFTROBERT GUILLEMETTE

JOHN BARTALOTTA

MATERIALS AND PROCESSES ENGINEERING

APRIL 26, 2001

2

OUTLINE

• I. Current chrome plating applications

• II. Past & current efforts with thermal spray coatings

• III. Methodology for qualification of thermal spray coated components

3

US ARMY US NAVY

US AIR FORCE US MARINES

4

Current Applications for Chromium Plate

• Airframe

• Drive System

• Rotors

• Flight Controls

5

H-60 Airframe Chromium Plate Replacement

AXLE

6

H-60 Drive System Chromium Plate Replacement

7

H-60 Main Gearbox Chromium Plate Replacement

SEAL SLEEVE, MAIN ROTOR SHAFT

8

H-60 Intermediate Gearbox Chromium Plate Replacement

9

H-60 Tail Gear Box Chromium Plate Replacement

INBOARD RETENTION PLATE SLEEVE

OUTPUT GEAR

TORQUE WASHER

INPUT

10

H-60 Main Rotor Head Chromium Plate Replacement

11

Flight Controls Chromium Plate Replacement: non-hydraulic and hydraulic components

Boost Servos

Primary Servos

12

Base Metals Plated With Chromium

• Steels– 4340 (150-280 ksi)

– 300M (280 ksi)

• Stainless Steels– 17-4

– 15-5

– PH13-8Mo

• Aluminum– 7075-T73

• Titanium– None

• Carburized Steels– None

13

PRIMARY ALTERNATIVES

DETONATION GUN

SUPER DETONATION GUN

PLASMA

HVOF

14

Detonation Gun

• Over 35 years experience with detonation gun thermal spray coating

• Excellent track record

• Specified for difficult, critical applications

• Chromium replacement primarily done for improved performance, now environmental driven

15

Current Super DGun Technology

• Several applications on S-92 and RAH-66 Comanche

• Implemented reduced weight designs by taking advantage of improved fatigue strength of DGun over chromium electroplate

• Comparison testing shows Super DGun has superior fatigue properties to HVOF

16

HVOF Coating Evaluated at Sikorsky Aircraft

• Diamond Jet– Aluminum Silicon– tungsten carbide

• JP5000 Tungsten Carbide

• Jet Kote tungsten carbide

17

Base metals coated with thermal spray coatings

18

Detonation Gun Tungsten Carbide reduces fretting fatigue at bearing journals (implemented 1987)

Thermal Spray Tungsten Carbide Results in Substantial (6x) Life Improvement for H-60 Main Rotor Shaft

19

HVOF Aluminum Silicon for Rework of Magnesium Transmission Housings (implemented 1992)

20

21

SH-60 DAMPER

•IMPROVEMENTS

– ZERO LEAKAGE FROM THE STATIC SEAL AREA HAS BEEN ACHIEVED SINCE THE INCORPORATION OF THE TUNGSTEN CARBIDE COATING.

– THE TRIBALOY AND TUNGSTEN CARBIDE COATINGS ARE SHOWING A GREAT IMPROVEMENT OVER THE CHROME AT 750 HOURS.

•ISSUES

– DAMPER BENCH TEST STOPPED AT ~750 HOURS DUE TO LEAKAGE FROM DYNAMIC END OF DAMPER AND FAILURE OF THE NON-METALLIC BUSHING.

– AWAITING STRONGER NON-METALLIC BUSHING FROM SUPPLIER. THE BUSHINGS ARE EXPECTED TO BE DELIVERED LATE MARCH 2001.

22

Tail Landing Gear Piston

23

SH-60B Tail Landing Gear Piston, Cleveland Pneumatic PN 2012C4, Base Metal: 300M Steel, Coated with SDG2057 tungsten carbide chromium

Qualification Test matrix for Navy H-60 Tail Gear Piston

• Coating adhesion• Tensile• Fatigue (HCF)• Fatigue (LCF)• Cyclic stress/strain• Metallurgical• Wear test (bench

scale)

• Drop test (full scale)• Corrosion

– open section

– crevice testing

• First article destructive evaluation/validation

• NAVAIR review• Lead-the-fleet testing

25

UH-60 Tail Landing Gear Fork

UH-60 TAIL LANDING GEAR

Fork

Qualification Test Matrix for UH-60 tail landing gear fork

• Adhesion (coupon)• Metallurgical (coupon &

full scale)– hardness– porosity/uniformity– heat/mechanical effect on

substrate

• Fatigue (coupon)• Fatigue after exposure to

salt fog (coupon)

• Wear test (data from Garlock)

• Corrosion testing (full scale)

• Army AMCOM review

• Lead-the-fleet testing

28

Guidelines for qualification of components with chrome plate

replacement• Parts have frozen process planning. Change of supplier

may require full scale testing• Difficulty exist with across-the-board substitution by

similarity qualification• Lead-the-fleet (actual service operations) often needed

as part of qualification• Flight Safety parts to be addressed by Flight Safety

Change Board

29

CONCLUSION

• Chromium replacement for multi-service helicopters is a continuing effort at Sikorsky Aircraft

• Criteria for qualification is a major challenge