1 wipo national workshop on intellectual property for diplomats sanaa, republic of yemen 20-21 march...

1

WIPO National Workshop onIntellectual Property for Diplomats

Sana’a, Republic of Yemen20-21 March 2007

The TRIPS Agreement

- Overview -

Roger Kampf

WTO Secretariat

2

Structure of the Presentation

• Basic IPR Concepts and Principles• TRIPS Negotiating Background• Overview of the TRIPS Agreement• IP under Doha Work Programme• TRIPS Council:

– Structure– Current work

• Cooperation With Other IGOs• Role of FTAs• Conclusions

3

Basic IPR Concepts and Principles (1)

• IPRs = rights given to persons over the creation of their minds, at certain conditions

• IPRs = exclusive negative right to prevent others from using the creation without authorisation, generally for a limited period of time⇒ no automatic marketing approval for

regulated products• IPRs = intangible property• IPRs = private rights• Principle of territoriality

4

Basic IPR Concepts and Principles (2)

• Objectives:– stimulate innovation and creativity– encourage investment and technology

transfer– ensure fair competition– protect consumers

• Permanent search for balance of rights and obligations:– long-term interest in promoting

creativity and the short term social interests in maximizing access

– interests of generators and users of IP

5

TRIPS Negotiating Background (1)

• Few IP provisions in the GATT:– national treatment– general exception– distinctive regional / geographical names

• Work on trade in counterfeit goods• Punta del Este mandate 1986:

– establish multilateral rules to deal with international trade in counterfeit goods

• Work of Uruguay Round Negotiating Group: are IPRs trade-related ?

6

TRIPS Negotiating Background (2)

• IP protection not new for most countries, incl. DCs: – WIPO Conventions and Treaties– pre-TRIPS national legislation

• Why Did Developing Countries Accept TRIPS ?– Uruguay Round trade-offs (agriculture, textiles)– balance and flexibility in the TRIPS Agreement– multilateral rule of law in the area of intellectual

property– consistency with move to more open and

market-based economic policies

7

Sources of Protection

• In country of origin: domestic law• In other countries: international

agreements extending the application of domestic laws to foreigners and providing minimum level of protection– multilateral agreements:

• WTO• WIPO

– free trade agreements and other international agreements

⇒ need to implement / direct applicability

8

The TRIPS Agreement

• TRIPS = Annex 1C of the WTO Agreement

• Minimum level of protection, subject to certain specific provisions for DCs and LDCs

• Most complete international treaty on IPRs

• Subject to multilateral dispute settlement

9

Structure of the Agreement

• Coverage• General Provisions, Basic principles• Minimum standards for each

category of IPRs• Enforcement• Dispute settlement• Transitional arrangements• Institutional mechanism

10

General Provisions• Minimum rights agreement• Freedom to determine appropriate method

of implementation• Incorporation of existing conventions• Non-discrimination:

– national treatment– most-favoured-nation treatment

• Exhaustion of rights• Objectives and Principles

– technology transfer– mutual advantage, welfare and balance– measures to protect public health consistent

with TRIPS / against abuse

11

• Keep non-controversial elements of existing conventions

• Avoid re-opening of existing texts

• Negotiate only "plus" elements

• Arrive at short, coherent and comprehensive text

"Incorporation" Technique

BerneParis

IPICRome

12

Areas Covered by TRIPS

Copyright • Artistic works• Literary works

[computer software and data bases]

Related (neighbouring) rights

• Performers• Phonogram producers• Broadcasters

Industrial property• Trademarks• Geographical indications • Industrial designs• Patents• Plant varieties protection• Topographies of int. circ.• Undisclosed information

(e.g. trade secrets; test data)

13

• Reference to the incorporated treaty, if any

• Whenever possible, definition of the subject-matter

• Conditions for protection

• Exclusive rights; limitations and exceptions

• Term of protection

• Other provisions

Substantive Standards: Typical Structure of Each Section

14

• Objective: legal security and predictability

• Principles:

• multilateral vs. Unilateral

• uniform application to all WTO Agreements

• Function: preserve rights and obligations of all Members

WTO Dispute Settlementand TRIPS (1)

15

WTO Dispute Settlementand TRIPS (2)

• 25 complaints, relating to 20 separate matters– 13 settlements– 9 panel and appellate body reports– 3 inactive cases

• Represents 7.3% of 341 complaints• Developing countries as respondents

– reports concerning 3 complaints from 1996-1998

– settlements concerning 4 complaints from 1996-2000

16

1996 2000 2005 2013 2016_______________________________ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓

Industrialised DCs and DCs LDCs 1) LDCsCountries Economies products · general · pharma

in not (patents &Transition1) previously test

data) patented · EMRs waived

1) National treatment and MFN treatment obligations apply as of 1996

Transition Periods

17

IP as part of Doha Work Programme

• Single Undertaking– multilateral register for geographical

indications for wines and spirits

• Outstanding implementation issues– extension of protection for geographical

indications– disclosure proposal

• Other– non-violation complaints– technology transfer

• Note: TRIPS/public health not part of DDA negotiations

18

Work Under the Doha Round• GC Decision of 1st August 2004:

– takes note of TRIPS Council / Special Session report– requests continuation of work on outstanding

implementation-related issues– extends moratorium for non-violation complaints

• Hong Kong, China MC, 2005:– requests to intensify negotiations on multilateral GI

register– requests to intensify consultative process on GI

extension and TRIPS-CBD relationship; progress review by July 2006

– extends moratorium for non-violation complaints– welcomes extension of LDC transition period

• 27-28 July 2006: GC supports DG recommendation to suspend Doha Round negotiations

• February 2007: full resumption of negotiations

19

Overall Structure

Neg Group onM arket Access

Neg Groupon Rules

SpecialSessions

Trade Negotiating Com m itte e Councils/Com m ittees

General Council

M inisterial Conference

20

TRIPS Council: Regular Session and Special Session

TRIPS COUNCIL

REGULAR SESSION,Review of legislation,

public health, biotech/TK/biodiversity,

etc.

SPECIAL SESSIONNegotiations on multilat. system

of notification & registrationof GIs for wines and spirits

⇒ plus: Consultative Process led by Deputy DG:GI extension and disclosure of origin proposal

21

• Notifications by Members under various provisions

• Notifications under Article 63.2 (laws, regulations and practices)

• Review of national legislation (laws, regulations and practices), including process of questions-replies, presentations in the meeting, follow-up questions-replies⇒ Merits of the process in general: transparency (dispute prevention effect); valuable source of information; right of all Members to pose questions

TRIPS Council:Regular Session (1)

22

• (Public health)

• GIs "extension" (until end of 2002)

• Biotechnology/traditional knowledge/biodiversity

• (Enforcement – not a permanent agenda item)

• Technology transfer

• Non-violation

• Technical cooperation

TRIPS Council:Regular Session (2)

23

IPRs and Development

• Possible impact on domestic actors– belief that enhanced IP protections promote

domestic creativity and inventiveness– element in moving towards higher value-added

production– property rights, including IPRs, important part

in move towards more open, market-based policies

• Evidence of an increasing use of patent and other IP systems by some developing countries

• Optimal balance?

24

Transfer of Technology

• Two aspects:– disclosure of knowledge– impact on trade, FDI, licensing

• Under TRIPS:– recognized as an objective under Art.7– proactive measures for the benefit of LDCs

under Art. 66.2– monitoring mechanism

• Other factors:– infrastructure, human resources– market seize– dual use products, etc.

• WTO Working Group on TT

25

Cooperation With Other IGOs

• Cooperation WTO-WIPO:– 1995 Agreement– Joint Initiatives for DCs/LDCs

• WHO – public health• CBD – bio issues• UNCTAD - various• World Bank - various• OECD – various; project regarding

measuring counterfeiting and piracy• Interpol – IPR enforcement• G8 – access to medicines; IPR

enforcement

26

Role of Free Trade Agreements

• Art.1.1 TRIPS: freedom to implement more extensive protection

• Development of standards through “TRIPS plus” elements

• Non-discrimination rules generally apply:– national treatment– MFN treatment

⇒ application of higher standards to all WTO Members

• Comparison of US and EU approach• Role of WTO

27

Concluding Remarks• IP = value added to human activities and

the products / services resulting therefrom• IP = permanent attempt to strike a balance

between various interests• TRIPS = most comprehensive multilateral

IP treaty• Increased recognition of TRIPS flexibilities

– Need to implement and use flexibilities

⇒ Doha Declaration on TRIPS

and Public Health

• Special provisions for LDCs and DCs