alpsp conference, jankowski, enhanced journal article

The Enhanced Journal Article: Illustrations of Web-based

Innovations

Association of Learned and Professional Society PublishersALPSP International Conference

9-11 September 2009

Nicholas W. JankowskiVisiting Fellow

Virtual Knowledge Studio for the Humanities & Social Sciences (VKS)Amsterdam, the Netherlands

nickjan@xs4all.nl

2Jankowski, ALPSP conference

Overview of Presentation

• I. F. Stone’s Weekly

• Illustrations: – contemporary scholarly journals– enhancement– radical enhancement

• Concluding reflections

3Jankowski, ALPSP conference

D.D. Guttenplan, American Radical: The Life and Times of I.F. Stone (Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2009)

(video & interview transcript with Guttenplan)

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 4

Illustrations: Contemporary scholarly journal publishing

Contemporary• Sage Online• Internet & Higher Education • International Journal of Internet Science• First MondayInnovative• In Media Res• Scientific American• Vectors, Journal of Culture and Technology in a Dynamic VernacularRadical• International Journal of Learning and Media• Article of the Future (Elsevier / Cell Press)

5Jankowski, ALPSP conference

6Jankowski, ALPSP conference

7Jankowski, ALPSP conference

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 8

First Monday

9Jankowski, ALPSP conference

In Media Res

10Jankowski, ALPSP conference

Scientific American

11Jankowski, ALPSP conference

Vectors, Journal of Culture and Technology in a Dynamic Vernacular

12Jankowski, ALPSP conference

International Journal of Learning and Media (IJLM)

13Jankowski, ALPSP conference

International Journal of Learning and Media

14Jankowski, ALPSP conference

Article of the Future: Prototype 1

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 15

Article of the Future: 2

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 16

Article of the Future: 3 (Prototype 2)

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 17

Article of the Future: 4

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 18

Reactions to the Prototypes• Nothing new• Underestimation of editorial investment• Underestimation of author willingness• Misguided estimation of reader interest

Illustrations of comments in blogsphere• Online Journalism Blog• the scholarly kitchen• ReadWriteWeb• Ptsefton• nature network

Jankowski, ALPSP conference 19

Concluding Remarks• Disciplinary variance; no single route to

enhancement• Enhancement: a community endeavor• Needed: willingness to experiment• Enhancement: more than surface deep• Undetermined: role / place of social media

I.F. Stone’s Weekly in the Internet Age:enhanced, but serving the argument….

20Jankowski, ALPSP conference