elt voices indiaeltvoices.in/volume4/issue_2/evi_42_3.pdf · 2014. 4. 29. · elt voices – india...
Post on 14-Sep-2020
2 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
ELT VOICES – INDIA
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR TEACHERS OF ENGLISH
APRIL 2014 | VOLUME 4, ISSUE 2 | ISSN 2230-9136 (PRINT) 2321-7170 (ONLINE)
The Effect of Using Short Stories as a Fictional Source on Vocabulary Learning of Iranian EFL Learners AMIR REZA NEMAT TABRIZI (Ph.D.)1, SAEEDEH MAHDAVINIA2 (Corresponding)
ABSTRACT
Fictional materials, as an effective teaching tool, could be employed to enrich
the second language vocabulary of the EFL learners. The present study is an
attempt to investigate the effect of fictional stories on vocabulary development
of EFL learners in an Iranian context. To do so, an experimental study was
designed in which sixty homogeneous upper intermediate EFL learners
attending a conversation course in Rayen Language House in Kerman were
divided into two experimental and control groups. Following the PET language
proficiency test, for the purpose of selecting homogeneous learners, the
participants were given the Intermediate Cambridge Vocabulary Test prior to
the treatment as the pre-test to ensure if they enjoyed similar vocabulary
knowledge before the treatment. The experimental group received vocabulary
training through being exposed to fictional stories (four genres of science
fiction, fantasy, humour, and crime) for eight weeks (sixteen sessions) as well
as the conversation course book which was Touch Stone series book two, while
the control group experienced the course book and its instructions. Following
the treatment all participants were given the post test of vocabulary
(Intermediate Cambridge Vocabulary Test). The data was analyzed using SPSS
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
21|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
version 20 and the findings revealed that the experimental group learners
working with fictional stories outperformed the control group learners,
confirming that inviting fictions to the EFL classroom has positive impacts on
the vocabulary development of the learners as there is a strong link between
reading fictional stories and acquiring second language vocabulary. Teaching
vocabulary through fictional stories and similar contents are then suggested as
valuable tools helping the learners develop second language vocabulary.
Key words: fiction, vocabulary, vocabulary learning, short stories, EFL
classroom
1. Department of English Language, Payam-e-Nour University, Tehran, Iran.
2. Department of English Language, Payam-e-Nour University, Qeshm, Iran.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
22|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
1. Introduction
Literature is currently considered promising incase it is used as medium for language learning
purposes. Different literary genres such as novel, drama, poetry, and short story, have been
employed in the ELT environments in various ways (Khatib, Rezaei & Derakhshan, 2011).
Various advantages of using literature in EFL/ESL classes as: being authentic, increasing
motivation, developing cultural/intercultural awareness and globalization, providing
intensive/extensive reading practice, developing sociolinguistic/pragmatic knowledge,
promoting grammar and vocabulary knowledge, reinforcing language skills, increasing
emotional intelligence (EQ), and fostering critical thinking have proposed and researched in
the field(Eren, 2004; Javid, 2013; Khatib & Faruji, 2012; Matsuoka & Hirsh, 2010;
Mihara,2011; Tsai, 2012; Webb, 2010).
Among various fictional texts, short stories have been of great concern by a number of
researchers (Egan, 1995; Eren, 2004; Erkaya, 2005; Strodt-Lopez, 1996). Short story is a work
of prose fiction which is shorter than the short novel, more restricted in characters and
situations (Chang, 2006). A short story is usually concerned with not more than a few effects,
problems or themes. In terms of character development, generally, a single aspect of a
character’s personality undergoes change or is revealed as a result of some incidents,
confrontation or conflict. Short stories seem to be the unique literary works can be used in
language teaching due to their practical implementation, compact nature and readability in one
sitting. They are not broad in scope and have a single effect on the readers (Alagözlü, 2011).
Tsai (2012) believes that most EFL learners have their primary contact with the target language
in the classroom; therefore, what is introduced in the class decides for the most part what they
may utilize in the out-of-class context. It is thus important to “empower foreign language
students to make effective use of the potential language-learning materials that exist around
them” (Maley, 1989, p. 15), to help find out prospectively motivating resources that the
students can use when the EFL courses end. As short stories are neatly organized most of the
time, and include specific vocabularies presented orderly and include themes which could be
discussed in the classroom fairly well, they could be employed by language learners to improve
their second language vocabulary knowledge (Khatib & Faruji, 2012). Appel and Richter
(2004) also argue the significance of presenting the fictional world of the narrative in the ELT
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
23|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
classes reasoning that such literary texts partly replace the real world while the learners are
reading and help them experience both the target language and life concepts.
Babaii and Yazdanpanah (2010) also discuss the positive impact of presenting fictional
oriented reading materials and telling stories on the EFL learners’ narrative ability and
vocabulary development. The present study aimed at investigating the effect of fictional source
on vocabulary learning of Iranian upper-intermediate EFL learners.
To fulfil the purpose of the study, the following research question was raised:
RQ: Does the use of short stories have any significant effect on vocabulary learning of Iranian
upper-intermediate EFL learners?
In order to investigate the above mentioned research question, the following null hypothesis
was formulated:
NH: Using short stories has no significant effect on vocabulary learning of Iranian intermediate
EFL learners.
Iranian learners of English deal with the so-called second language almost seven years and in
many a case the formal English education at schools is approximately barren. The private
institutes therefore have tried to fill the gap and compensate for the lack of a well-designed
second language education. Though the course books employed in the formal settings at
schools are mostly reading based, the direct vocabulary instruction which has recorded well in
the ELT literature (Ellis, 1995; Nation, 1993; Watanabe, 1997) plays a significant role in the
Iranian context, which is frequently referred to as an EFL one. The impact of general and
specific vocabulary knowledge on reading and listening comprehension have also been
investigated (Mehrpour & Rahimi, 2010). The impact of vocabulary knowledge on the
development of reading comprehension of literary texts has been researched as well (Beglar,
Hunt, & Kite, 2012).
In most EFL contexts, particularly in Asian countries like Iran, repetition and memorization of
unknown words is the main type of vocabulary acquisition (Nation, 1982; Yang & Dai, 2011).
Students read from a list of new words and their native language equivalents many times for
retention. However, these types of rote learning and decontextualized vocabulary practices are
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
24|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
not proved as being helpful and students cannot recognize the words and their meanings unless
they are presented within the same contexts (Cortazzi & Jin, 1994; Yang & Dai, 2011). Above
all, the impact of reading on vocabulary learning has raised some concerns because studies
addressing this issue have reported small vocabulary gains (Cho & Krashen, 1994). Thus, the
effect of reading materials in general and fiction type of reading in particular on vocabulary
learning is still open to question.
2. Review of the Related Literature
2.1 Using fictions to develop second language vocabulary
Learning vocabulary is a continuous task and it is an essential part of language learning/
teaching. That’s why there has been a renewed interest in learning and teaching vocabulary in
the past two decades (Maftoon, Hamidi & Najafi, 2012). Contextualized vocabulary learning is
considered significant in the EFL and ESL classrooms and fictions could be considered rich as
a source of second language vocabulary of the learners (Wajnryb, 2005). Covering short stories
is an educative linguistic activity in that because it allows individuals to develop their second
language reading comprehension and vocabulary knowledge simultaneously (Khatib & Faruji,
2012). Though the classroom discussion usually taking place following the presence of short
stories in the language classrooms, learners share their personal understanding with others;
thereby creating negotiated transactions (Egan, 1995 & 1999). Using short stories could pave
the grounds for the learners to develop critical thinking, self-monitoring, strategic flexibility,
and fruitful peer interaction as well as getting familiar with novel vocabularies, expressions,
and lexical items (Strodt-Lopez, 1996).
Increasing second language learners’ cultural literacy and higher-order thinking capacity could
be pursued through presenting short stories in the ELT classroom and as Erkaya (2005) asserts
benefits of short stories should be clarified for the learners so as to encourage them employ
fictions to improve their vocabulary knowledge. However, Erkaya (2005) warns the novice
instructors against ignoring the EFL classes’ real needs which urge implication of authentic
texts based on the learners’ levels of understanding in terms of grammatical and complexity
and lexical novelty.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
25|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
Good short stories which could be employed for instructional purposes as Greene (1996)
presents should enjoy the characteristics such as a) a clearly-defined single theme to reduce the
complexity of the context, facilitating the reading story process, b) a well-developed plot, c)
sound grammatical structures accompanied with authentic vocabulary and lexical items, d)
pleasing sounds and rhythm which are more attractive to the children or teenagers, e)
believable characters, f) dramatic appeal with a perfectly safe edge of fear and sadness, and g)
appropriate for the learners’ level in terms of concepts, characters, and ideas presented.
However, Maley (1989) and Eren (2004) argued that there is no strict rule to determine the
length of short-stories. It is the teacher’s duty to choose a story short enough to handle within
course hours. In this regard, Yazdanpanah (2012) believes that the shortness of the text is
important because it makes the learners feel they can read, understand and finish something in
English, and it will create a sense of achievement and self-confidence.
Hill (1994, p. 15) points out some other basic criteria to be kept in mind while choosing a
literary text for instructional purposes including: a) the needs and abilities of the students, b)
the linguistic and stylistic level of the text, and c) the amount of background information
required for a true.
As Marsh, Butler, and Umanath (2012) argue fictional sources such as short stories will
encourage students to connect information together and this way their interests in the course
content will be promoted. When students are more interested in learning, they spend more time
to study and it leads to longer retention of materials and better grades (McDaniel & Butler,
2010). To increase learning of course materials, fiction is a powerful tool for engaging
students and teaching content, even if it has potential to transmit false knowledge (Horst,
(2009).
Considering differences between fictional and non-fictional sources Marsh, et al (2012)
express that the content of fiction is a double-edged sword as “although some fiction is
completely divorced from reality, most of it contains a blend of true and false information”.
(p.450) Fictional stories are often taking palaces in the real world and make reference to actual
people, places, and events. Indeed, educators who want to incorporate fiction into their courses
have numerous options from which to choose. A wide variety of novels, films, comic books,
and video games are available to help students understand and learn course content.
Nevertheless, there is a potential downside to learning from fiction. McDaniel and Butler
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
26|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
(2010) also argue that unlike non-fiction sources that are generally held to a high standard of
accuracy, fiction, by its very nature, contains false information. Although much of this false
information is trivial, sometimes works of fiction contain major errors or inaccuracies that
contradict the true state of the world. If students are learning content from fiction, then there is
a risk that they will acquire false knowledge about the world. To be sure, educators sometimes
select inaccurate works of fiction on purpose, so that students can learn how to critique
secondary sources of information. Nevertheless, many studies have found that students have a
difficult time questioning fiction even though they know that it contains errors and
inaccuracies, and instead take fictional content at face value (Gerrig & Prentice, 1991, Horst,
2005; Shokouhi & Maniati, 2009; Wajnryb, 2005).
2.2 Structure of Fiction
Beyond content differences, fictional and non-fictional sources differ in form. Fictional sources
such as novels and movies tend to have narrative structures as they tell stories using a structure
familiar even to young children. In contrast, textbooks tend to be expository in form, directly
stating and conveying information to the reader in a logical structure (Appel & Richter, 2004).
Research has revealed that narratives and expository texts naturally use different kinds of
processing and this framework is called material-appropriate processing (McDaniel & Butler,
2010). When people read narratives, they naturally link across pieces of the text (relational
processing), whereas expository texts encourage readers to focus on individual items without
connecting them to one another. This process is called item-specific processing (Marsh, et al,
2012).
As Gerrig and Prentice (1991) present fiction is a literary work based on the imagination and
not necessarily on facts. Fiction comes in the form of different types such as a) Dystopia, a
work of fiction describing an imaginary place where life is extremely bad because of
deprivation or oppression or terror, b) Novel, an extended fictional work in prose; usually in
the form of a story, c) fantasy, a fiction type with a large amount of imagination, d) Story, a
piece of fiction that narrates a chain of related events, e) Utopia, a work of fiction describing a
utopia detective novel, mystery novel in which the reader is challenged to solve a puzzle before
the detective explains it at the end, f) Dime novel, penny dreadful, a melodramatic paperback
novel, g) Science fiction, literary fantasy involving the imagined impact of science on society,
h)Novelette(novella), a short novel, i) Roman a clef , a novel in which actual persons and
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
27|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
events are disguised as fictional characters, j) Romance, a novel dealing with idealized events
remote from everyday life, k) Roman fleuve, a French novel in the form of a long chronicle of
a family or other social group, l) adventure story(heroic tale), a story of an adventure, m)
Mystery (whodunit), a story about a crime (usually murder) presented as a novel or play or
movie, n) Love story, a story dealing with love, o)Fable(legend), a story about mythical or
supernatural beings or events, p)Short story, a prose narrative shorter than a novel, q)Allegory
(apologue), a short moral story (often with animal characters), r) Myth, a traditional story
accepted as history; serves to explain the world view of a people, s) Parable, (New Testament)
any of the stories told by Jesus to convey his religious message, and t)Plot, the story that is told
in a novel or play or movie etc.
Second / foreign language teachers; therefore, can manage the classroom the way in which
language sub-skills could be enriched through different types of fiction (Alavi &
Keyvanshekouh, 2012), and as the concern of the present study is vocabulary development of
the EFL learners, examining fictions applicable to the SL classroom is crucial.
2.3 Vocabulary learning strategies
The investigations on vocabulary learning strategies are vast (Horst, 2005): Meanwhile, as
Schmitt (2010) asserts changes in vocabulary learning strategies should be taken into
consideration to see how these changes are related to vocabulary development. Stoffer’s (1995)
questionnaire developed to measure vocabulary learning strategies could be considered
significant as she demonstrated the most frequent strategies concerning vocabulary learning as
follows:
1. Strategies involving authentic language use
2. Strategies used for self-motivation
3. Strategies used to organized words
4. Strategies used to create mental linkages
5. Memory strategies
6. Strategies involving creative activities
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
28|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
7. Strategies involving physical action
8. Strategies used to overcome anxiety
9. Auditory strategies
Schmitt (1997) also proposed taxonomy of vocabulary learning strategies, arguing that
determination strategies are used when learners determine the meaning of new words as they
first encounter them. Social strategies are used to understand a word by asking someone who
knows it, and memory strategies are approaches which relate new materials to the existing
knowledge. As Schmitt (2010) presents, using bilingual dictionaries was the most popular
strategy while imaging a word’s meaning, using cognates, imagining word form, skipping or
passing a new word, and the key word method were perceived as less helpful strategies in a
study conducted on 600 Japanese high school students.
Oxford (2011) argues that strategies change over time and Schmitt’s (1997) research asserts
that as participants become older, they use strategies which are less popular with younger
learners. The strategies becoming more popular among older people are those which require
deeper mental processing such as keyword method, connecting the target words to a personal
experience, and word association (Kudo, 1999).Some learning strategies are more beneficial at
certain ages than others, and learners naturally mature in using different strategies, so learners’
cognitive maturity and language proficiency should be taken in to account when
recommending strategies (Schmitt, 1997).
Different studies have been conducted concerning “fictional sources” and its role in second
language learning. Students reading a traditional historical fiction learn more than the students
reading a traditional textbook (Smith, 1993). Students in the historical fiction classroom not
only read the materials but also discuss them and integrate them with other activities such as
role play and consequently spend more time on the materials than do students in the classroom
using the text.
Another research focusing on experimental approaches for studying learning from fiction
including learning from short stories and from films was conducted by Marsh, et al (2012) and
confirmed the benefits of using fiction to help students learn accurate information about the
world. Other scholars have confirmed the positive effect of novel and short story instruction on
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
29|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
learning English: Babai and Yazdanpanah’s (2010) investigation supported the effect of
explicit teaching of story structures on EFL learners’ narrative ability in speaking, while
Shokouhi and Maniati’s (2009) study relying on an analysis of the lexical differences between
narrative and expository reading materials revealed that using narrative texts help students use
greater amount of highly frequent words.
Hosseini Fatemi (2010) asserted that fictional narratives can be used as instructional materials
for boosting learner’s language skills. In her study she found the superiority of narrative over
expository source in enhancing learner’s reading skills. Wajnryb (2005) argued the ways
teachers could employ to motivate a class of students by introducing to stories them. Her
ultimate aim was to provide activities that teachers can use to develop their students’ identities
through producing their own stories. This approach could help the learners build confidence.
3. Method
3.1 Participants
The participants of the study were 60 homogeneous male and female Iranian upper-
intermediate EFL learners with the age range of 15 to 27 at an English institute named Rayen
Language House in Kerman, who were selected from among 90 learners. The participants
selected for the study were the ones whose scores on the standardized language proficiency test
was one standard deviation below and above the mean. These participants were assigned to two
experimental and control groups. Tables 3.1and 3.2 below represents the descriptive statistics
of the subject selection procedure.
Table 3.1: Descriptive Statistics of subject selection
N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation
PET 90 23.0 50.0 41.42 2.20
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
30|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
Table 3.2: Descriptive Statistics PET by Groups
Group N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Mean
Experimental 30 42.03 2.327 .425
Control 30 42.13 2.209 .403
3.2 Materials
A) A Standard Version of Preliminary English Test (PET) as the placement test which was
administered before the instruction to select the main participants and make sure that they were
homogenous.
B) Four short stories in the form of four genres as follows:
B1: Gideon (humour story) by Wells Hastings
B2: Birthday gift (fantasy) by Surakshith
B3: The mysteries of ghost diary (crime) by Harshit Juneja
B4: The ultimate life (science fiction) by Paul Anobile
C) Intermediate Cambridge Vocabulary Test used as pre and post-test.
3.3 Procedures
To accomplish the purpose of this study, the researchers carried out the following procedures:
At first a PET test was administered to the learners in order to homogenize them. Sixty
students whose scores fell one standard deviation below and above the mean were selected and
divided into two experimental and control groups. In order to control the teacher variable, both
groups were taught by the same teacher. After that a pre-test of multiple choice vocabulary
items (Intermediate Cambridge Vocabulary Test) which was firstly piloted was administered to
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
31|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
both the experimental and control groups. The reliability of the test was calculated through
KR-21 formula (r = 0.76) which is an acceptable reliability.
Then an 8-session course of instruction began. This course lasted for a month (two sessions per
week). For the best use of the allocated time, the students in both groups had to read the text
before the class meeting. In this study 8 short stories were used by the researcher, and each
short story was practiced within 45 minute classroom period. The researcher tried to select
short stories which seemed to be interesting to the learners and had enough length to be
covered during the time limit of the class sessions. One sample of the short stories used by the
researcher is provided in the Appendices of this paper (Appendix A and Appendix B).
The experimental group received vocabulary training through being exposed to fictional stories
(four genres of science fiction, fantasy, humour, and crime) as well as the conversation course
book which was Touch Stone series book two, while the control group experienced the course
book and its instructions. Following the treatment all participants were given the post test of
vocabulary (Intermediate Cambridge Vocabulary Test). Measures of independent t-test was
then run to compare the experimental and control groups’ mean scores on the post-test of
vocabulary in order to probe the effect of fictional texts on the learners’ vocabulary
development.
4. Data Analysis
A. Pilot study of Pre and Post-test of Vocabulary
Intermediate Cambridge Vocabulary Test which was employed as both pre and post-test
piloted among 30 students with similar characteristics (age, gender, level) to the students of the
main study for the purpose of calculating the reliability of the test. The mean of the test was
calculated as13.5 and the SD was 1.61.The reliability of the test was also calculated as 0.74
based on Kr-21 method which is an acceptable reliability. Table 4.1 below best reports the
statistics related to the piloting process of pre/post-test.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
32|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
Table 4.1: Calculations of pilot study of pre/post test
Results:
Total Numbers: 30
Mean (Average): 13.5
Standard deviation: 1.61352
Variance(Standard deviation): 2.60345
Reliability based on KR-21 0.74
B. Pre-test of Vocabulary
An independent t-test was run to compare the experimental and control groups’ mean scores on
the pre-test of vocabulary in order to prove that both groups enjoyed the same level of
vocabulary knowledge prior to the administration of the treatment. As displayed in Table 4.2
the experimental (M = 12.33, SD = 2.59) and control (M = 12.10, SD = 2.19) groups showed
almost the same means on the pre-test of vocabulary.
Table 4.2: Descriptive Statistics Pre-test of vocabulary by Groups
Group N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Mean
Experimental 30 12.33 2.591 .473
Control 30 12.10 2.187 .399
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
33|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
The results of the independent t-test (t (58) = .377, P > .05, R = .049 representing a weak effect
size) (Table 4.3) indicated that there was not any significant difference between the
experimental and control groups’ mean scores on the pre-test of vocabulary. Thus it can be
concluded that they enjoyed the same level of vocabulary knowledge prior to the
administration of the treatment.
Table 4.3: Independent t-test Pre-test of vocabulary by Groups
Levene's Test for
Equality of Variances
t-test for Equality of Means
F Sig. t Df Sig. (2-
tailed)
Mean
Difference
Std. Error
Difference
Equal variances
assumed
.561 .457 .377 58 .708 .233 .619
Equal variances
not assumed
.377 56.410 .708 .233 .619
It should be noted that the assumption of homogeneity of variances was met (Levene’s F =
.561, P > .05). That is why the first row of Table 4.3, i.e. “Equal variances not assumed” was
reported.
C. Investigating the null hypothesis
The null hypothesis was set as; “using short stories has no significant effect on vocabulary
learning of Iranian intermediate EFL learners”. An independent t-test was run to compare the
experimental and control groups’ mean scores on the posttest of vocabulary in order to probe
the effect of short stories as fictional texts on the learners’ development of the vocabulary as
measured on the posttest. As displayed in Table 4.4 the experimental (M = 16.63, SD = 2.07)
outperformed the control (M = 13, SD = 2.19) groups on the post-test of vocabulary.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
34|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
Table 4.4: Descriptive Statistics Post-test of Idioms by Groups
Group N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Mean
Experimental 30 16.63 2.076 .379
Control 30 13.00 2.181 .398
The results of the independent t-test (t (58) = 6.60, P < .05, R = .65, representing a large effect
size) (Table 4.5) indicated that there was a significant difference between the experimental and
control groups’ mean scores on the posttest of vocabulary. Thus the null-hypothesis as using
short stories has no significant effect on vocabulary learning of Iranian intermediate EFL
learners was rejected. The experimental group after receiving fictional vocabulary treatment
outperformed the control group on the posttest of vocabulary.
Table 4.5: Independent t-test Post-test of vocabulary by Groups
Levene's Test for Equality of
Variances
t-test for Equality of Means
F Sig. T Df Sig. (2-
tailed)
Mean
Difference
Equal variances
assumed
.501 .482 6.609 58 .000 3.633
Equal variances not
assumed
6.609 57.858 .000 3.633
It should be noted that the assumption of homogeneity of variances was met (Levene’s F =
.501, P > .05). That is why the first row of Table 4.5, i.e. “Equal variances not assumed” was
reported.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
35|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
D. Testing Assumptions
Four assumptions should be met before one decides to run parametric tests (Field, 2009). The
data should be measured on an interval scale. The subjects should be independent that is to say
their performance on the test is not affected by the performance of other students. The data
should enjoy normal distribution and finally the groups should have homogeneous variances.
The present data were measured on an interval scale and the subjects’ perform independently
on the tests. The assumption of normality was also met. As displayed in table 4.6, the ratios of
skewness and kurtosis over their respective standard errors were within the ranges of +/- 1.96
(Filed, 2009).
Table 4.6: Normality Tests
Group N Skewness Kurtosis
Statistic Statistic Std.
Error
Ratio Statistic Std.
Error
Ratio
Experimental
PET 30 .221 .427 0.518 -.711 .833 -0.854
Pre-test 30 -.267 .427 -0.625 -.743 .833 -0.892
Post-test 30 -.587 .427 -1.375 -.652 .833 -0.783
Control
PET 30 .334 .427 0.782 -.658 .833 -0.790
Pre-test 30 -.370 .427 -0.867 -1.081 .833 -1.298
Post-test 30 -.427 .427 -1.000 -1.325 .833 -1.591
The assumption of homogeneity of variance was discussed when reporting the results of the
independent t-test.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
36|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
E. Criterion Referenced Validity
The Pearson correlation coefficients between the PET, Pretest, and posttest of vocabulary were
computed as the criterion referenced validity indices of the latter tests. As displayed in table
4.7, the pretest (r (58) = .96, P < .05, representing a large effect size), and the posttest (r (58) =
.73, P < .05, representing a large effect size) enjoyed significant criterion referenced validity
indices.
Table 4.7: Criterion Referenced Validity
PET
Pre-test
Pearson Correlation .963**
Sig. (2-tailed) .000
N 60
Post-test
Pearson Correlation .733**
Sig. (2-tailed) .000
N 60
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
37|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
F. K-R21 Reliability
The reliability indices of the tests are displayed in Table 4.8 below.
Table 4.8: K-R21 Reliability Indices
N Mean Variance K-R21
PET 90 41.42 27.23 .75
Pre-test 60 12.22 5.664 .17
Post-test 60 14.82 7.813 .54
5. Discussions and conclusion
The findings of the present study firstly revealed that receiving short stories as fictional texts
significantly affects EFL learners’ vocabulary knowledge as the experimental group receiving
fictional texts outperformed the control group on the posttest of vocabulary. Secondly, the
results revealed that learners’ perceived vocabulary learning strategies is enriched through
focusing on the short stories. Findings of the present study are in line with the findings of other
researchers recorded in the literature. Appel & Richter (2004) stress the positive impact of
fictional texts in the ESL classrooms in providing an atmosphere in which learners improve
their second language skills eagerly in a cooperative mode. Employing word identification and
code-breaking to facilitate retention of vocabulary items by EFL university students, Horst,
(2009) comes to know that training SL learners through authentic literary texts is more apt to
facilitate the process of learning lexical items. Marsh, et al (2012) also support the positive
impact of employing fictional sources in the classroom and learners’ mentality growth within
the cognitive psychology framework Yazdanpanah (2012),in line with the previous research,
argues that explicit teaching of story structure affects the EFL learners’ use of communication
strategies. Beglar et al, (2012) argue that reading for pleasure increases the vocabulary
knowledge of the Japanese university EFL learners. Analyzing the authentic literature using a
short story telling activity, Eren (2004) stresses the effectiveness of this method on the
learners’ development in cultivating cooperative learning as well as piecing together the class
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
38|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
room discussions and developing an acceptable level of second language vocabulary
knowledge, especially idiomatic expressions.
Teaching short stories in the EFL classroom makes students think of short stories as literary
texts that are argumentative in nature. The novel contextualized expressions, idioms, and
collocations appearing in the short stories can help students develop a good command of
second language vocabulary (Alagözlü, 2011). According to Matsuoka and Hirsh (2010), the
use of short stories as fictional texts in the ELT classrooms might be effectively conducive to
second language vocabulary development.
Incidental vocabulary learning occurs “when the learners are required to perform a task
involving the processing of some information without being told in advance that they will be
tested afterwards on their recall of the information” (Laufer & Hulstijn , 2001, p. 10).Using
fictional texts in the language classes is great importance to enhance the learners' incidental
vocabulary learning. This way incidental learning of vocabulary occurs when the students
focus on comprehending the text.
It seems that students in the experimental group get more involved in vocabulary learning than
the students in the control group. Also there are less opportunities for negotiation of meaning
among them the learners in the control group. On the other hand, in the experimental group
learners work with stories and understand them, therefore they learn more vocabularies
compared to the learners in the control group. Therefore, as the results of this study showed,
greater amount of incidental learning of vocabulary occurred in the learners in the experimental
group.
To sum up, it can be concluded that employing fictional texts in teaching vocabulary items to
the EFL students in the Iranian context proved positively effective and it also supported the
fruitful and rewarding effect of focusing on short stories in learners’ perceived vocabulary
learning strategies.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
39|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
References
[1] Alagözlü, N. (2011). Infusing graphic organizers and short stories in language teaching.
Retrieved March 20, 2014, from dergiler.ankara.edu.tr/deriler/755/9626.pdf
[2] Alavi, S., & Keyvanshekouh, A. (2012). Using the Moodle Reader as an Extensive Reading
Tool and its Effect on Iranian EFL Students’ Incidental Vocabulary Learning. English
Language Teaching, 5(6), p135.
[3] Appel, M., & Richter, T. (2004).Persuasive effects of fictional narratives increase
over time. Media Psychology. Retrieved March 20, 2014, from WWW.cms.uni-Kassel.du
[4] Babaii, E., & Yazdanpanah, Z. (2010). Towards self-expression in L2 classrooms:
The effect of explicit teaching of story structures on EFL learners’ narrative ability. Asian EFL
Journal, 44, 4-19.
[5] Baleghizadeh, S., & Ashoori, A. (2010). The effect of keyword and wordlist methods on
immediate vocabulary retention of EFL learners. Pakistan Journal of Sciences (PJSS), 3(2),
251-261.
[6] Beglar, D., Hunt, A., & Kite, Y. (2012). The effect of pleasure reading on Japanese
university EFL learners’ reading rates. Language Learning, 62(3), 665-703.
[7] Chang, Y. (2006). Visual organizers as scaffolds in teaching English as a foreign language.
Retrieved March 20, 2014, from
www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/recordDetail?accno=ED494210
[8] Cho, K-S., & Krashen, S. (1994). Acquisition of vocabulary from the Sweet Valley Kids
Series. Adult ESL acquisition. Journal of Reading, 37, 662-667.
[9] Cortazzi, M., & Jin, L.X. (1994). Changes in learning English vocabulary in China. In H.
Coleman, & L.Cameron (Eds.), Changes and Language (pp. 153-165). Clevedon: British
Association for Applied Linguistics in association with Multilingual Matters.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
40|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
[10] Egan, K. (1995). Narrative and learning: A voyage of implications. In H. Mc Ewan & K.
Egan (Eds). Narrative in teaching, learning, and research. (pp.116-125). NY: Teachers
College Press.
[11] Egan, K. (1999). Children's minds: Talking rabbits and clockwork oranges. NY: Teachers
College Press.
[12] Ellis, R. (1995). Modified oral input and the acquisition of word meaning. Applied
Linguistics, 16, 409-441.
[13] Eren, Z. (2004). The use of short story in teaching English to the students of public high
schools. Hacettepe Universitesi Egitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 26, 41-47
[14] Erkaya,O.R (2005).Benefits of using short stories in the EFL context. Asian EFL
Journals, 8,38-49.
[15] Field, A. (2009). Discovering statistics using SPSS (3rd ed.). London: SAGE.
[16] Gerrig, R.J., &Prentice, D.A. (1991). The representation of fictional information.
Psychological Science, 2,336-340
[17] Greene, E. (1996). Storytelling: Art and technique (3rd ed.). Newjersey: Bowker.
[18] Hill, J. (1994). Using literature in language teaching. London: Macmillan.
[19] Horst, M. (2005). Learning L2 vocabulary through extensive reading: A
measurement study. Canadian Modern Language Review/La Revue Canadienne des
Langues Vivantes, 61(3), 355-382. Retrieved February, 2013, from www.utp
Journals.metapress.com
[20] Horst, M. (2009). Developing definitional vocabulary knowledge and lexical
access speed through extensive reading. In Z. Han & N. Anderson (Eds.), Second
language reading: Research and instruction (pp. 40–64). Ann Arbor, MI: University
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
41|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
of Michigan Press.
[21] Hosseini Fatemi, A. (2010).Boosting reading skills, narrative intelligence & moral
reasoning through fictional narrative-based reading instruction: a comparative study of
text genres. Journal of Mathematics, 6, 121-136.
[22] Javid, M. (2013). Does RAS-based Instruction Make a Difference? An Investigation of the
Effect on Vocabulary Learning. International Journal of English Language Education, 1(3),
pp-271-281.
[23] Khatib, M., Rezaei, S., Derakhshan, A. (2011). Literature in EFL/ESL Classroom. English
Language Teaching Journal, 4(1), 201-208.
[24] Khatib, M., & Faruji, L. F. (2012). The impact of using story maps as graphic organizers
on development of vocabulary learning of EFL learners. Journal of Language Teaching and
Research, 3(6), 1114-1121.
[25] Kudo,Y. (1999). L2 vocabulary learning strategies. Unpublished M.A. thesis, University
of Hawai’I, Honolulu.
[26] Landers, A. (2010). An examination of genre differences. Doctoral dissertation,
University of Minnesoto. Retrieved January, 2013, from www.Proquest.com
[27] Laufer, B., & Hulstijn, J. (2001). Incidental vocabulary acquisition in a second language:
The construct of task induced involvement. Applied Linguistics, 22(1), 1-26.
[28] Maftoon, P., Hamidi, H., & Sarem, S. N. (2012). The effects of CALL on vocabulary
learning: A case of Iranian intermediate EFL learners. Broad Research in Artificial Intelligence
and Neuroscience, 3 (4), 19-30.
[29] Maley, A. (1989). Down from the pedestal: Literature as resource. Retrieved March 20,
2014, from worldsciencepublisher.org/journals/index.php/ADMM/article.
[30] J. Brumfit (Eds.), Literature and the learner: Methodological approaches (pp. 10-24).
Basingstoke, London: Modern English Publications.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
42|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
[31] Marsh, E. J., Butler, A. C., & Umanath, S. (2012). Using fictional sources in the
classroom: Applications from cognitive psychology. Educational Psychology
Review, 24(3), 449-469.
[32] Matsuoka, W., & Hirsh, D. (2010). Vocabulary learning through reading: Does an ELT
course book provide good opportunities. Reading in a foreign language, 22(1), 56-70.
[33] McDaniel, M. A., & Butler, A. C. (2010). A contextual framework for
understanding when difficulties are desirable. Successful remembering and successful
forgetting: Essays in honor of Robert A. Bjork, 175-199.
[34] Mehrpour, S., & Rahimi, M. (2010). The impact of general and specific vocabulary
knowledge on reading and listening comprehension: A case of Iranian EFL
learners. System, 38(2), 292-300.
[35] Mehrpour, S., Razmjoo, S. A., & Kian, P. (2011). The relationship between depth and
breadth of vocabulary knowledge and reading comprehension among Iranian EFL
learners. Journal of English Language Teaching and Learning,53(222), 97-127.
[36] Mihara, K. (2011). Effects of pre-reading strategies on EFL/ESL reading
comprehension. TESL Canada Journal, 28(2), 51.
[37] Nation, I. S. P. (1982). Beginning to learn foreign vocabulary: A review of the research.
RECL Journal, 13(1), 14-36.
[38] Nation, I.S.P. (1993). Using dictionaries to estimate vocabulary size: Essential, but rarely
followed, procedures. Language Testing, 10 (1), 27–40.
[39] Oxford, R. L. (2011). Teaching and researching language learning strategies. Harlow,
UK: Longman.
[40] Schmitt, N. (1997).Vocabulary learning strategies. Vocabulary: description,
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
43|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
acquisition & pedagogy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
[41] Schmitt, N. (2010). Researching vocabulary: A vocabulary research manual. Palgrave
Macmillan.
[42] Shokouhi, H., & Maniati, M. (2009).Learner’s incidental vocabulary acquisition:
A case on narrative and expository texts. English Language Teaching, 2(1), 13-23.
[43] Smith,J. A. (1993). Content learning: A third reason for using literature in
teaching reading. Reading, Research, and Instruction , 32, 64-71.
[44] Stoffer, I. (1995).University foreign language student’s choice of vocabulary
learning strategies as related to individual difference variables. Unpublished doctoral
dissertation, University of Alabama, Alabama: U.S.A.
[45] Strodt-Lopez, B. (1996). Using stories to develop interpretive processes. ELT Journal,
50(1), 35- 42.
[46] Tsai, C. H. (2012). Students’ perceptions of using a novel as main material in the EFL
reading course. English Language Teaching, 5(8), 103-112.
[47] Wajnryb, R. (2005). Stories: Narrative activities in the language
classroom. Reading in a Foreign Language, 17(2). Retrieved January 2013, from
http://www.cambridge.org
[48] Watanabe, Y. (1997). Input, intake, and retention: Effects of increased processing on
incidental learning of foreign language vocabulary. Studies in Second Language Acquisition,
19, 287-308.
[49] Webb, S. (2010). Pre-learning low-frequency vocabulary in second language television
programs. Language Teaching Research, 14(4), 501-515.
ELT VOICES – INDIA April 2014 | Volume 4, Issue 2
44|ELT Voices – India International Journal|ISSN 2230-9136 (Print) 2321-7170 (Online)
[50] Yang, W., & Dai, W. (2011). Rote memorization of vocabulary and vocabulary
development. English Language Teaching, 4(4), 61-64.
[51] Yazdanpanah, Z. (2012). The effect of explicit teaching of story structure on EFL
learners’ use of communication strategy. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 32,
391-398.
top related