div class=ts-pagebuttonPage 1button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page1jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 1: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails1jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 2button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page2jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 2: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails2jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 3button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page3jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 3: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails3jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 4button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page4jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 4: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails4jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 5button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page5jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 5: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails5jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 6button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page6jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 6: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails6jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 7button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page7jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 7: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails7jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 8button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page8jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 8: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails8jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 9button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page9jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 9: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails9jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 10button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page10jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 10: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails10jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 11button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page11jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 11: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails11jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 12button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page12jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 12: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails12jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 13button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page13jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 13: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails13jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 14button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page14jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 14: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails14jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 15button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page15jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 15: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails15jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 16button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page16jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 16: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails16jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 17button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page17jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 17: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails17jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 18button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page18jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 18: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails18jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 19button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page19jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 19: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails19jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 20button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page20jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 20: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails20jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 21button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page21jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 21: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails21jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 22button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page22jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 22: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails22jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 23button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page23jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 23: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails23jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 24button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page24jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 24: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails24jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 25button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page25jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 25: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails25jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 26button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page26jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 26: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails26jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 27button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page27jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 27: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails27jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 28button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page28jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 28: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails28jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 29button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page29jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 29: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails29jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 30button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page30jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 30: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails30jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 31button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page31jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 31: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails31jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdivdiv class=ts-pagebuttonPage 32button div class=ts-image a href=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5page32jpg target=_blank amp-img class=ts-thumb alt=Page 32: Horizon Handout 12_2… · MDL No 2179 SECTION: J JUDGE BARBIER MAGISTRATE SHUSHAN MOTION FOR ADVERSE INFERENCES FROM PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE Brian H Barr LEVIN PAPANTONIO src=https:reader030vdocumentsnetreader030viewer20220309165b64ecf87f8b9af5448dfa83html5thumbnails32jpg width=142 height=106 layout=responsive amp-imga divdiv