insights from hydroeconomic modeling - world...

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 1 / 25

Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014

Insights from

Hydroeconomic Modeling

James Booker

Siena College

Loudonville, NY

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 2 / 25

Outline

1. Examples of hydroeconomic models.

2. Model estimates, baselines, and benefit-cost

analysis.

3. Implicit single factor productivity estimates

4. Towards TFP

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 3 / 25

Systems approach

focusing on interdependencies

source: Cai, McKinney, and

Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 4 / 25

source: Cai, McKinney, and

Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 5 / 25

source: Booker & Young,

JEEM, 1994

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 6 / 25

source: Cai, McKinney, and

Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 7 / 25

A hydroeconomic model is a system-wide

maximization of net benefits

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 8 / 25

Water demand functions for each user

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 9 / 25

System-wide solution I:

allocation by non-economic rule

where value V is used to force allocation between users

according to purely non-economic priorities.

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 10 / 25

System-wide solution I:allocation by maximizing net benefits

Objective function based purely on economic benefits

net of explicit costs:

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 11 / 25

Estimating marginal values of the irrigation water input

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 12 / 25

Residual imputation for

estimating irrigation water demand

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 13 / 25

Deficit irrigation / direct crop response may be added

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 14 / 25

Ultimately …

Use mathematical programming techniques

to estimate farm / regional benefits as total

irrigation water supply is varied.

Fit these results to a convenient functional

form, and each regional user then has a

water demand function.

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 15 / 25

Water demand functions for each user

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 16 / 25

source: Cai, McKinney, and

Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 17 / 25

Model solution

maximize selected measure of net benefits

subject to

• hydrologic constraints

• acreage constraints

• technology constraints

• institutional / operations constraints

• other

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 18 / 25

Hydroeconomic model optimization provides

accounting of diversions, instream flows, and

multisectoral use impacts

source: Cai, McKinney, and

Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003And – implicitly includes water

opportunity costs / nonpriced

impacts on other users.

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 19 / 25

Explicit baseline typically defined

source: Cai, McKinney, and

Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 20 / 25

One interpretation: this a NPV estimate

source: Cai, McKinney, and Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

NPV of moving from standard operating criteria

to those maximizing quantified net benefits is

3.76 – 2.86 = 0.90 billion USD . But –unique BCR difficult :

treatment of nonpriced

opportunity costs ?

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 21 / 25

A second interpretation: this a “crop per drop”

change

source: Cai, McKinney, and Lasdon, JWRPM, 2003

Baseline: “Crop per drop” = (3570*0.74)/51.8 = 51;

Full-optimize: “Crop per drop” = (3570*0.89)/45.6 = 64;

=> Increase of 25% .

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 22 / 25

Their text: full optimization (FOP) vs. baseline

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 23 / 25

Continuing with Cai, McKinney, and Lasdon, 2003:

If we look just at local water withdrawal “crop per drop,” then this

increases by 70% to 120% (holding yield impacts constant).

c.f. a full basin increase of just 25% .

Water delivery efficiency Irrigation efficiency Total change

before after before after before after

0.5 0.7 0.5 0.8 0.25 0.56

0.6 0.8 0.65 0.85 0.39 0.68

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 24 / 25

Hydroeconomic modeling easily provides

single factor productivity

• Basin wide measures will be very different

from local / regional productivity measures

• Consumptive use versus withdrawals

matters:

– productivity will differ

– changes in productivity will differ

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 25 / 25

Towards TFP measures from

hydroeconomic modeling

• Are there conceptual issues preventing comparison of

TFP between scenarios?

(e.g. treatment of scarcity costs as an input?)

• What are the practical challenges?

• What interpretations add value to our understanding of

– Hydroeconomic modeling estimates

– Traditional TFP estimates abstracting from hydrologic and

geographic details

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 26 / 25

J. Booker, Siena College Going Beyond Agricultural Water Productivity, World Bank Workshop, 8 Dec., 2014 page 27 / 25