interoperability between cc licenses & odc-by and the uk open govt license

Sarah Hinchliff Pearson

Senior Counsel, Creative Commons

October 22, 2011

*

Why legal interoperability alone is

inadequate to create a commons

**

*

*1. legal

*2. practical

Ask: Is it possible to comply

simultaneously?

Ask: Is it possible to violate and

comply simultaneously?

*

*1. sui generis database rights

*

©

SGDR

license

Public domain

*

©

SGDR

license

Public domain

*

*2. license scope

*

©

SGDR

license

Public domain

*

*3. extra restrictions

*

*1. misrepresentation

*2. privacy

*

*1. attribution requirements

*2. license subject matter

*

*1. ODC-BY: © and SGDR

*2. OGL: © and SGDR

*3. CC BY (EU ports): © and SGDR

*4. CC BY (unported): ©

*

*1. CC BY: ©

*2. OGL: ©

*3. ODC BY: © + via contract

+ SGDR

+ SGDR

When to attribute?

*

*1. OGL: flexible

*2. CC BY:

*3. ODC BY:

License notices, otherwise

reasonable manner

© + SGDR + license notices

How to attribute?

*

*CC BY/OGL

*OGL + {misrepresentation}

Any extras?

{privacy}

+ {non-endorsement}

*

*CC BY

*1. attribution

*2. ID derivatives

*ODC BY

*1. attribution

*OGL

*1. attribution

*2. no misrepresentation

*3. non-endorsement

*4. no privacy breach

*3. non-endorsement

CC BY

other

*

*

*

*

CC BY

ODC-BY

© and SGDR

© only

ODC- BY

CC-BY

no restrictions

for public

domain

via contract

OGL

CC-BY

ID

derivatives, h

onor moral

rights

misrepresentation

clause

*

Sarah Hinchliff Pearson

October 22, 2011

slideshow licensed CC BY international 3.0