mallory jones complaint 06.27.13 (with exhibits)
Post on 03-Apr-2018
235 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
1/26
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
MACON DIVISION
MALLORY C. JONES,
Plaintiff,
v.
MACON-BIBB COUNTY BOARD OF
ELECTIONS AND VOTER
REGISTRATION; JEANETTA
WATSON, in her official capacity asExecutive Director of the Bibb County
Board of Elections and Voter Registration,
and MACON-BIBB COUNTY BOARD
OF COMMISSIONERS,
Defendants.
:
:
::
:
:
:
:
:
::
:
:
:
:
::
CIVIL ACTION FIL
NO.: ____________
EMERGENCY RELIEF R
VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR
DECLARATORY, INJUNCTIVE, AND OTHER RELIE
COME NOW Mallory C. Jones, the Plaintiff in the above styled
(Plaintiff), and submits this Verified Complaint for Declaratory, Inju
other Relief (Complaint), based on the following allegations:
N t f th C
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
2/26
state law (Ga. L. 2012, p. 5595 and amended by S.B. 25), the election
officials to serve in the newly created consolidated government for
Macon and Bibb County, Georgia (County) was to occur, via majori
non-partisan elections, on July 16, 2013 (the Election). A copy
(hereinafter the Bill) which provides for these elections is attache
Exhibit A.
2.
On or about June 1, 2013, the Defendant Board of Elections an
was unilaterally delaying the Election because pre-clearance by the U
Department of Justice (DOJ) of the voting changes contained in the
yet been obtained pursuant to Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act (
copy of the Submission is attached as Exhibit B.
3.
On June 25, 2013, the United States Supreme Court held Secti
Voting Rights Act (42 U.S.C. 1973e) (VRA) unconstitutional. She
v. Holder, et al., ___ U.S. ___, 2013 WL 3,184,629. The effect of this
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
3/26
4.
Plaintiff seeks a declaratory judgment holding that the Bill i
enforceable and requires Defendants to conduct the Election on July 16
that cannot be done, at the earliest possible lawful date without the re
candidate qualification or any other alteration to the electoral process
the Bill. Plaintiff further requests the Court issue appropriate injunct
enforce the declaratory judgment and to award Plaintiffs counsel
attorneys fees.
Statement of Jurisdiction
5.
This action is brought under 42 U.S.C. 1983 and 1973. This a
relief pursuant to Article 4, 2, the Fourteenth Amendment to the Con
the United States, Article I, I, II of the Constitution of the State
(Constitution), and the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
6.
This Court has original jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
4/26
7.
Plaintiff has complied with O.C.G.A. 21-2-32(g) by providing
this Complaint to the Chair of the Georgia State Election Board via U
Postal Service Certified Mail, though compliance with said statute is
required for actions brought in this Court.
Parties
8.
Plaintiff Mallory C. Jones (Jones) is a resident and elector of B
Georgia, and a candidate in the upcoming Election. He desires and
participate in the electoral and political processes of the consolidated M
County government as evidenced by his decision to qualify as a ca
Commissioner in District Four (4) of the consolidated government.
9.
Defendant Macon-Bibb County Board of Elections and Voter R
(BOE) is the Elections Superintendent for Macon-Bibb County, G
such, the Board is responsible for conducting all City, County and
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
5/26
to prepare and publish all notices and advertisements in connectio
conduct of elections; to transmit to the Secretary of State a copy of any
in which a call for an election is issued; to prepare, equip and furnish
places; to count all ballots; and to certify the results of all elections as
by law. Service of the Summons and Complaint is being acknow
Counsel for the BOE.
10.
Defendant Jeanetta Watson (Watson) is the current Executive
the Board located at 2445 Pio Nono Avenue, Macon, Georgia, 31
Defendant is subject to the jurisdiction of this Court. Service of the Su
Complaint is being acknowledged by Counsel for Watson.
11.
Defendant Macon-Bibb County Board of Commissioners (Comm
the governing authority for Bibb County and participates in the call
setting of the date for the Election. Service of the Summons and C
expected to be acknowledged by Counsel for the Commission.
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
6/26
party Defendants for purposes that include enjoining them from (a) app
new candidate qualifications for elected positions within the c
government; and (b) further delaying the Election since the Bill estab
consolidated government and the election schedule to populate its elec
is no longer required to be pre-cleared by the DOJ and should be im
immediately. Defendants actions in unilaterally delaying the Election
the scope of their lawful authority and must be enjoined.
Facts
13.
During the 2012 session, the Georgia General Assembly pass
which proposed consolidation of the City and County governments
approval by voter referendum. Consolidation was approved by the vo
31, 2012.
14.
On February 8, 2013, the BOE submitted the Bill to the DO
clearance. See Exhibit B.
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
7/26
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
8/26
19.
The Election was scheduled by law for July 16, 2013. On or ab
2013, the BOE announced it was putting the Election on hold followin
the DOJs letter of May 24, 2013, seeking additional information. Exhi
20.
Neither pre-clearance nor an objection by the DOJ was forthcom
the decision by the United States Supreme Court on June 25, 2013, in
County case. This decision invalidated Section 4 of the VRA and there
the pre-clearance requirements of Section 5 as applied to the Bill and ot
changes.
21.
Since the decision in Shelby County, the Defendants have refused
the Election on the date set forth in the Bill, citing the delay in the elect
created by its decision to stay the Election.
22.
A genuine controversy exists between Plaintiff Jones and the De
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
9/26
harm if candidate qualifying is reopened and the election is further d
the injury will continue until the electoral process proposed by the BOE
to be unconstitutional as a product of the unconstitutionality of Secti
VRA.
COUNT ONE: VIOLATION OF EQUAL PROTECTION
DUE PROCESS, AND THE VRA
23.
Plaintiff incorporates by reference all previous allegations conta
Complaint.
24.
Pursuant to the United States Constitution and federal statute,
vote is a fundamental right guaranteed to U.S. citizens. It is a right tha
arbitrarily manipulated or denied by Defendants.
25.
The Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution,
that: No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the p
i iti f iti f th U it d St t h ll t t d i
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
10/26
26.
42 U.S.C. 1983 provides, in relevant part, as follows:
Every person who, under color of any statue, ordinance,
regulation, custom, or usage, of any State or Territory of
the District of Columbia, subjects, or causes to besubjected any citizen of the United States or other
person within the jurisdiction thereof to the deprivation
of any rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the
Constitution and laws, shall be liable to the party injured
in an action at law, suit in equity, or other proper
proceeding for redress. . . .
27.
Defendants are person[s] and Plaintiff is a citizen of the Un
within the meaning of 42 U.S.C. 1983.
28.
Under the First and Fourteenth Amendments, it is unlawful for a
to refuse to conduct elections under the terms provided for by law.
29.
Plaintiff intends and desires to participate in the electoral an
processes of the City of Macon and Bibb County, Georgia.
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
11/26
through their failure and refusal to conduct the Election for the new c
government according to law.
31.
There is no adequate remedy at law for the irreparable harm P
suffer. The Defendants refusal to conduct the Election denies Plaintiff
vote and to seek public office.
32.
Accordingly, Plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunctive and
relief declaring the unilateral delay of the elections unconstitutional an
the Election to be held at the earliest feasible date.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully prays that this Court
following relief:
A) Assume jurisdiction of this case;
B) Enter a declaratory judgment holding that the Defen
comply with the Bill and conduct the Election on July 16, 2013,
thereafter as legally possible;
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
12/26
F) Award Plaintiff all other relief which the Court deems ne
proper.
/s/ A. Lee ParksA. Lee Parks
Georgia Bar No. 563750
lparks@pcwlawfirm.com
/s/ David F. Walbert
David F. WalbertGeorgia Bar No. 730450
dwalbert@pcwlawfirm.com
PARKS, CHESIN & WALBERT, P.C.
75 Fourteenth Street, 26th
Floor
Atlanta, GA 30309
(404) 873-8000 Telephone
(404) 873-8050 Facsimile
Counsel for Plaintiff
/s/ Harlan S. Miller
Harlan S. Miller
Georgia Bar No. 506709hmiller@pcwlawfirm.com
OF COUNSEL:
PARKS, CHESIN & WALBERT, P.C.
3646 Vi ill A
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
13/26
V E R I F I C A T I O N
I , Mallory C. Jones, make this verification under oath and statePlaintiff in this matter; that I have read the foregoing Verified CDeclaratory, Injunctive and other Relief and that I hereby verify that thof fact contained in said Complaint are true and correct and that as Plaction, I w i l l suffer irreparable injury i f the injunctive relief requgranted.
This 2 7 day of June, 2013.
Sworn to and subscribed before methis day of June, 2013.NOTARY PUBLIC /
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
14/26
O F F ~ C E OF SECRETARY OF STATEJ) /Jn:an P Jlmp 5ecf'etaf'lJ' o/State o/ he State o
{jeorr;ia, do hef'eb'I cef'tih thatthe four pages of photocopied matter hereto attached contains atrue and correct copy of an Act approved by the Governor onFebruary 14, 2013 humbered Act No. 3, Senate Bill. No. 25; all assame appear of file and record in this office.
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
15/26
ENROLLMENT
This /3t!::: day of F'ihrt.A.AJ 2013Approved
Governor
S.B. No. __ __ Act No. _3GENERAL ASSEMB
ANACTTo amend an Act entitled "An Act torestructuring of the government ofthe CitCity of Payne City, ap.d Bibb County," ap2012 (Ga L, 201'2, p. 5595), so as to providelections of the mayor and commissionerpurposes.
Read !"timeRead 2d timeRead 3n1 timeAnd
Yeas 34
Read 1 1 timeRea.d 2nd timeRead 3'dtlmeAnd
IN SENATEJan. 15, 2013
J ~ ) . 1 . 29,2013Passed
IN HOUSEJart. 30, 20 t jJan, 3I, 2013Feb. 12, 2013Passed
Nays
y , ~ ~
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
16/26
...
AN ACT
To amend an Act entitled "An Act to provide for the restructuringof he government of theCity ofMacon, the City of Payne City, and Bibb County," approved April 20, 2012 (Ga. L.2012, p. 5595), so as to provide for nonpartisan elections of he mayor and commissioners;to repeal conflicting laws; and for other purposes.
BE IT ENACIB[l BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF GEORGIA:
SECTION 1.An Act entitled ''An Act to provide for the restructuring of the. government ofthe City ofMacon, the City ofPayne City, and Bibb County," approved April 20, 2012 (Ga. L. 2012, p.5595), is amended by revising subsection (c) of Section 9 to read ?S follows:"(c) The comri1ission sha:ll consist of nine members. The initial comrriissioriers shall beelected at a noilpartisan election held ori thethifd Tuesday In July,,2Ql3, for tenns of threeyears and until their successors are duly elected and qualified. Their successors shall beelected in nonpartisan elections for tenns offour years and shall take office on the.first dayof January imniediately following the date of the election. The members .shall be electedfrom the nine districts specified in subsection (a) of this section by a majority Of electorsvoting in such election from such distriet. All members of the cofillnission shall be fullvoting members of the coimniSsion. The mayor shall be the presiding officer of thecommission but shall not be a voting membei' of the commission; provl.ded, however; thatthe mayor may cast a vote on any matter before the comrnl.ssion to break a tie. The mayormay propose ordinances ih. the same manner as a commissioner/
SECTION2.Said Act is furtlwr amended by revising subsections (b) and (d) of Section 10 to read asfollows:H(b) The initial mayor shall be elected in a nonpartisan election to be held on the thirdTuesday in July, 2013. Candidates shall be elected by majority vote as provided in thissection. The person elected as mayor atsuch electionshall take f f i c e o n t h e s ~ c i o n d Tuesday
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
17/26
expiration of a tenn of office, shall take office on the first day of January imntediatelyfollowing the date of the election, and shall have. a term ofoffice of four years and until asuccessor is elected and qualified. The mayor shall be elected by a majority vote on acounty-wide basis by the electors of he entire county.""(d) Except as otherwise provided in ihis section, all elections for the mayor and membersof he commission shall be in accordance with theprovisions ofChapter 2 ofTitle 21 of heO.C.G.A., the 1GeorgiaElection Code,t as now or hereaftel' amended. Any person who is aregistered voter of Macon-Bibb County shall be eligible to vote in atiy election undet thissection."
SECTiON3.All laws and parts of aws in conflict with this Act are repealed.
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
18/26
! ;:;;'.>tt'1.:L: : : t ' ) / ~ ! ~ : ! . ; : ; ~ ; ; / t ' .;: ?,;!';'.':
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
19/26
VIRGIL L. ADAMSD. JAMES JORDANCAROLINE W. HERRINGTONDAWN MAYNOR LEWISCEDRIC B. DAVIS*
*Of Counsel
ADAMS &JORDANATTORNEYS AT LAWAPROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONFickling &Co. Building577Mulbe11y Street, Suite 1250Post Office Box 928Macon, Georgia 31202-0928
Telephone (478) 743-2159Toll Free (866) 743-88'14Telecopier (478) 743-4938Writer's Email: vadams@adamsjordan.comFebruary 18, 2013
VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS OVERNIGHTTRACKING NUMBER 7947 7251 3130
M'.illedgev.ille115 E. McinPost Office BMilledgevillTelephone (Toll Free (8Telecopier (
SUBMISSION UNDER SECTION 5 OF THE VOTING RIGHTS ACChief, Voting SectionCivil Rights. DivisionRoom 7254-NWBUnited States Department of Justice1800 G Street, NWWashington, DC 20006
RE: Submission of Preclearanc.e for Non-Partisan Elections for Macon-Bibb Consolidated Government Elections pursuant Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 as amendedDear S.ir/Madam:
In my capacity as County Attorney for Bibb County, (3eorgia, I hereby spre-clearance non-partisans elections for the newly created consolidated govbe known as Macon-Bibb County, Georgia, pursuant to the Voting Rights Actas amended (42 U.S.C. 1973 c).
Pursuant to the requirements of 28 C.F.R. 51.27, I hereby submit thewith respect to this request:
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
20/26
Chief, Voting SectionFebruary 18, 2013Page Two
restructuring of the governments of City of Macon, City of PayneBibb County, approved April 20, 2012 (Ga. L 2012, p. 5595), soprovide for non-partisan rather than partisan elections of the macommissioners;
(b) .A copy of any ordinance, enactment order, or regulation emthe voting practice that is proposed to be repealed, amendeotherwise changed.See Exhibit "2 " attached hereto and incorporated herein by ref
(c) If the change affecting voting either is no t readily apparentface of the documents provided under paragraphs (a) and (section or is not embodied in a document, a clear statemenchange explaining the difference between the submitted chthe prior law or practice, or explanatory materials adequatedisclose to the Attorney General the difference between theproposed situation With respect to voting.The change, is readily apparent on the face of the document in (of this section. Exhibit "2" is the existing charter Which was apthe General Assembly on April 20, 2012, and approved by the velection on July 31, 2012. This charter provided for partisan elethe mayor and nine (9) commissioners for the new government Macon-Bibb County 13nd Exhibit "1" under section (a) above amcharter to now provide for non-partisan e.lections of the mayor acommissioners for the new government known as Macon-Bibb C
(d) The name, title., address, and telephone number of the persmaking the submission.Virgil L. AdamsBibb County Attorney
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
21/26
Chief, Voting SectionFebruary 18, 2013Page Three
(e) The name of the submitting authority and the name of thejurisdiction responsible for the change, i f differentThe submitting authority is the County Attorney for Bibb Countyand the Georgia General Assembly is the jurisdiction responsibchange.
(f) If the submission is not from a State or county, the name ocounty and State in which the submitting authority is locatNot applicable.
(g) Identification of the person or body responsible fo r makingchange and the mode of decision ( e ~ g . , act of State legislatordinance of city council, administrative decision by regist
(h)
The body responsible for making the change is the Georgia GeAssembly and the mode of decision is an act of the State legislA statementidentifying the s t a t u ~ o r y or other authority undthe jurisdiction undertakes the change and a descripticm oprocedures the jurisdiction was required to follow in decidundertake the change.To the best of my knowledge, Act No.3, Senate Bill No. 25, waspursuant to ~ u t h o r i t y granted the General Assembly by the 198Constitution of the State of Georgia, Art. Ill, Sec. V.
(i) The date of adoption of the change affecting voting.Act. No. 3, Senate Bill No. 25 Was passed by the Georgia GeneAssembly on February 13, 2013, and was approved by GovernDeal on February 14, 2013. (See Exhibit "1").
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
22/26
Chief, Voting SectionFebruary 18, 2013Page Four
(k) A statement that the change has not yet been enforced oradministered, or an explanation of why such a statement cmade.The proposed change has not yet been enforced or administerehowever, it is the purpose of this Act to provide for the non-partelections for mayor arid nine (9) commissioners of the newly cogovernment of Macon-Bibb County. The change will take effecJuly, 2013 elections as contemplated in the Act.
(I) Where the change will affect less than the entire jurisdictioexplanation of he scope of the change.The entire jurisdiction will be affected.
(m) A statement of the reasons for the change.To the best of my knowledge, the proposed change to non:-partelections results :from a decision ofthe General Assembly initiatBibb County local legislative delegation. .
{n) A .statement of the anticipated effect of the change on memracial or language minority groups.The proposed ch13nge is not anticipated to have a major effect omembers of racial minority groups.
(o) A statement identifying any past or pending litigation concchange or related voting practices.To the best of my knowledge, there is no past or pending litigatconcerning the change.
(p) A statement that the prior practice has been precleared (wi
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
23/26
Chief, Voting SectionFebruary 18, 2013Page Five
The prior practice was pre-cleared on October 3, 2012. (See Eand refer to DOJ File No. 2012-2935.(q) For redistrict ings and annexations: the items listed under(a)(1) and (b)(1); for annexations only: the items listed und51.28 (c)(3).
(r)Not applicable.Other information that the Attorney General determines is fo r an evaluation of the purpose or effect of the change. Suinformation may include items listed in 51.28 and is mostbe needed with respect to redistrictings, annexations,. andcomplex changes. hi the interest of time such informationfurnished with the initial submission relating to voting chathis type. When such information is required, but not proviAtto.rney General shall notify the submitting authority in thprovided in 51.37.Please see additional information provided below.
Pursuant to .28 C.F.R. 51.28, the following additional information is s(a) Demographic information.
Please refer to previous pre-clearance submissions under DOJ2012-1990 and DOJ File No. 2012-2935 for all relevant demoginformation.(b) Maps
Please refer to previous p r e - c l ~ a r a n c e submissions under DOJ2012-1990 and DOJ File No. 2012-2935 for all maps of the prenewly created commission districts.
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
24/26
Chief, Voting SectionFebruary 18, 2013Page Six
(d) Election returns.To the. best of my knowledge, there are no election returns relevaction; however election returns from the July 31, 2012 primary the referendum to apprbve Act. No. 625 (House Bill 1171) 2012 provided fo r the consolidation of the governments of Macon, Paand Bibb County were previously submitted on August 9, 2012 uFile NO. 2012-2935.
(e) Language use.To the best of my knowledge, the change does not affectthe uslanguage of a minority group in the elective process.
(f) Publicity and Participation.Notice of intention to introduce local legislation wi:;is published inTelegraph which is the o f f i c i ~ I organ of Bibb County, Georgia onDecember6, 2012. A certification evidencing this fact is attacheExhibit i 1 " ~ There was media coverage concerning proposed leto change to non-partisc:m elections, including articles in The Teprior to the legislature's vote on and passage of the Act.
(g) Availability of the submission.Copies of th.is submission are available to the public throl!gh thethe Bibb County Board of Commissioners, the Clerk of the City and this submission will be advertised by a legal advertisementMacon Telegraph, the legal organ for Bibb County, Georgia.
(h) Minority group contacts.1. The Honorable Nikki RandallRepresentative, District 138
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
25/26
Chief, Voting SectionFebruary 18, 2013Page Seven
2. The Honorable James BeverlyRepresentative, District 139Post Office Box 13451Macon, GA 31208(404) 656-0220 (Capitol phone)(478) 803-0001 (District phone)
3. The Honorable David LucasSenator, District 262594 Saratoga DriveMacon, GA 31211(404) 65.6-5035 (Capitol phone)(478) 254-7600 (District phone)
On the basis of the foregoing, I respectfully request approval and precthis action. Please feel free to contact me should you hcwe any questions or additional information concerning this submission.
VLA/abpEnclosures
Sincerely,
Virgil L AdamsCounty Attorney
cc: Representative Nikki Randall, Chairperson, Bibb County Legislative DSamuel F. Hart, Sr., Chairman, Bibb County Board of CommissionersRobert A.B. Reichert, Mayor, City of MaconMs. Jeanetta Watson, Macon-Bibb County Elections Supervisor
-
7/28/2019 Mallory Jones Complaint 06.27.13 (With Exhibits)
26/26
EXHIBIT
C
top related