maria romani final meeting meeting ravenna 27 march 2008 lessons learned from the emilia-romagna...

Maria Romani

Fin

al M

eet

i ng

Me e

t i ng

Ra v

enna

27

Ma r

c h 2

0 08

Lessons learned from theEmilia-Romagna Pilot Project (WP4):

PROPOSAL OF SPATIAL PLAN ACCORDING TO ICZM PRINCIPLES

• Implementation of Regional ICZM Guidelines at provincial scale

• Ferrara Coast• DG Environmental

and DG Spatial Planning• first application 2006-2008• implementation Provincial

and Municipal Plans:

Plan objectives and alternatives

defining indicator and monitoring system

to assess Plan effects

Basic Facts about the pilot project

Pilot project steps

The analysis of the state in different sectors aimed at identifying and defining specific problems and criticality relating to different thematic profiles

The drawing up of a document (Stocktake) describing the state of environmental, territorial and infrastructure resources by “sensitive/significant topics” to the territorial planningAn integrated assessment of the different levels of criticality

Adoption of the plan’s objectives

Evaluation of criticality in relation to these objectives in order to identify preliminary criteria, directions and conditions related to the feasibility of the plan’s possible actions

PTCP (Provincial Territorial Plan)

PTCP (Provincial Territorial Plan)

First measure to reduce negative environmental

effects

First measure to reduce negative environmental

effects

PSC (Municipal Structural Plan)

COGNITIVE FRAME DRAFT

IMPLEMENTATION REGIONAL ICZM

GUIDELINES

IMPLEMENTATION REGIONAL ICZM

GUIDELINES

pilo

t p

roje

ct

acti

vite

sim

ple

me

nta

tio

n:

the

Pla

ns

Interaction between spatial planning and

ICZM topics

Interaction between spatial planning and

ICZM topics

Ho

w c

an

be

imp

lem

en

ted

Re

gio

na

l IC

ZM

Gu

idel

ines

same measure to reduce environmental problems linked with

coastal system

same measure to reduce environmental problems linked with

coastal system

Pla

nn

ing

an

d a

sse

ssm

ent

pro

ces

s

Consulting procedures and

adoption/ approbation

Preliminary assessment

Preliminary documents of the

plan

Planning Performance

Planning process Assessment process

Planning conference

Plan’s project

General objectives

Specific objectives

Preliminary document of the plan

Identify planning strategies

Planning Policies

Screening

Evaluation of preliminary strategy

External coherence

Performance assessment

Assessment of alternative options

Environmental report vs monitoring

Analysis of public objection

Monitoring and reviewPlan’s administration

Corrective action

Adoption / Approbationof the Plan

Scoping

Internal coherence

Kon

w how

---- Public co

nsulting

Environ

men

tal assestmen

t

Phases

Pla

nn

ing

co

nfe

ren

ce

Mobility systemInfrastructure system

Urban Settlement system

Topic 9

Topic 1:Physical coastal system, risk factors and defence

strategies

Topic 2:Pollution, water resource

management and monitoring Topic 3:Ports, ship wastage

and sea transport risk

Topic 4:Habitat, biodiversity

and landscape

Topic 5:Tourism

Topic 6:Fishing and aquiculture

Topic 7:Agriculture

Topic 8: Energy policies

Interaction between spatial planning and ICZM topics

Delta townTerritorial Contexts Areas included

1 Town centre A place of connectionsComacchio,Portogaribaldi, LidoEstensi

2 The changingperiphery

A place of renewal Scacchi, Pomposa, SanGiuseppe

3 Non-urbanised coastA place of indecision PortoGaribaldi north –Scacchi south

4 Urban peninsulas andislands

A place of leisure Spina, Nazioni, Volano

5, 6 Natural coastline A place of difference Spina, Bellocchi,Nazioni, Volano, ValleBertuzzi…

7 Woodland and riverA place of history Po di Volano, Po diGoro, Canal Bianco,Bosco della Mesola

8 Inlet and flatmarshland

A place of production Sacca di Goro, Scannosandbank and the sanddunes of Gorino, Valli diComacchio

Environmental vulnerability: High for Salt water intrusion into aquifers;

medium/high for sea ingression

Interaction matrix

Context 1:Town centre

Interaction matrix

Context 1:Town centre

Interaction matrix

Context 1:Town centre

Public Institutions improve an integrated Knowledge system to assess and monitore coastal system and plan‘s effects

IMSP have to be developed not only when needed but always like an ordinary activity of Public Institutions

Discussion pointsComparing the PlanCoast Handbook messages vs

spatial planning

Thanks for your attention!Thanks for your attention!