methodology of international religious demographyarchive.gordonconwell.edu/ockenga/research/...islam...

+

Methodology of International Religious Demography

Gina A. Zurlo Boston University

American Academy of Religion November 21–26, 2013

Baltimore, MD

+Three unique features

! International

! Interdisciplinary

! Chronological

+Religion

!  Self-identification

!  Tracking affiliation, not beliefs, attitudes, or practices

!  World religion: size, history, global spread

How many religions? Which ones?

Indigenous religions Judaism Christianity Islam Hinduism Buddhism East Asian religions

Christianity Islam Hinduism Agnosticism Buddhism Chinese folk-religion Ethnoreligions Atheism New religions Sikhism Judaism Spiritism Confucianism Daoism Baha’i Jainism Shinto Zoroastrianism

Christianity Islam Unaffiliated Hinduism Buddhism Folk religion Judaism Other religions

Christianity Confucianism Hinduism Buddhism Yoruba religion Judaism Daoism Atheism

+Double-affiliation

!  Religious categories are not mutually exclusive

!  Multiple religious belonging

+Non-affiliation

!  IRD includes religionists and non-religionists

+Major sources

!  Censuses

!  Surveys & polls

!  Data collected from religious communities

+Census: Religion

Scotland, 2011

Ireland, 2011

Britain, 2011

+Census: Ethnicity

USA, 2010

New Zealand, 2006

+Limitations of censuses

!  Honest response

!  Who is counted?

!  Selecting responses from a set list

!  Ethnicity & religion assumptions

+Surveys & polls

!  Demographic surveys

!  General population surveys

World Values Survey, 2005

+Limitations of surveys & polls

!  Small sample size

!  Non-response

!  Response bias

World Values Survey, 2005–08

+Data from religious communities

!  Births, deaths, baptisms, personnel, finance, etc.

+Limitations of data from religious communities

!  Definition of “membership”

!  Risk of inflation

+Asking the question

!  One-step census approach vs. two-step survey approach

+One-step approach 2001 Bulgarian census

[One Step – choose one] Faith: 1. Orthodox 2. Catholic 3. Protestant 4. Sunni Muslim 5. Shi’a Muslim 6. Other ________ 99. None given

+Two-step approach 1999 Bulgaria European Values Survey

[Step 2 – if Yes – Show Card 23]

23 Which one? Orthodox 1 Muslim 2 Catholic 3 Protestant 4 Other _______ 5

[Step 1] Do you have a religious affiliation?

A Yes → go to question 23 B No → go to question 24a

+Results Different methods yield different results

Census&2001& EVS&2008&

83&

59&

4&27&

Bulgaria:)Census)vs)Survey)Orthodox& &Not&stated&;&Not&applicable&

EVS  1999  

+

Census&2001& EVS&2008& Census&2011&pct&of&answered&

83&

59&76&

4&27&

7&

Bulgaria:)Census)vs)Survey)Orthodox& &Not&stated;&Not&applicable&;&Not&stated&

Further complication 2011 Bulgarian census results

EVS  1999  

+Dynamics of religious change

!  Births and deaths

!  Converts to and converts from

!  Immigration and emigration

+Case study Number of Coptic Christians in Egypt

!  Census: Christians are declining over past 100 years !  Latest census: 5% Christian

!  Church estimates: Consistently 15%

!  Issues to consider !  Church overestimation? !  Social pressure on Christians? !  Reporting of ex-pats? !  Egypt’s high governmental restrictions on religion !  Egypt’s high social hostilities involving religion

!  WRD: 10% Christian (8.1 million; 7.5 million are Orthodox)