oman academic accreditation authority report of an audit ... college report final to print.pdf ·...
Post on 13-Sep-2019
8 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Oman Academic
Accreditation Authority
Report of an Audit of
Bayan College
August 2013
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
Audit Report Number 35
©2013 Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
P.O. Box 1255
P.C. 133
Al-Khuwair
Sultanate of Oman
Ph +968 2412 1600
Fax +968 2412 1231
http://www.oaaa.gov.om
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 1 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
CO�TE�TS
Overview of the Quality Audit Process..................................................................................................... 3
How to Read This Report........................................................................................................................... 4
Conclusions.................................................................................................................................................. 5
Executive Summary of Findings ............................................................................................................. 5
Summary of Commendations .................................................................................................................. 7
Summary of Affirmations........................................................................................................................ 7
1 Governance and Management............................................................................................................ 10
1.1 Mission, Vision and Values ........................................................................................................ 10
1.2 Governance................................................................................................................................. 11
1.3 Management ............................................................................................................................... 12
1.4 Institutional Affiliations for Programs and Quality Assurance................................................... 13
1.5 Strategic Plan.............................................................................................................................. 14
1.6 Operational Planning.................................................................................................................. 14
1.7 Financial Management ............................................................................................................... 15
1.8 Risk Management....................................................................................................................... 15
1.9 Policy Management.................................................................................................................... 16
1.10 Entity and Activity Review Systems .......................................................................................... 16
1.11 Student Grievance Process ......................................................................................................... 17
1.12 Health and Safety ....................................................................................................................... 17
1.13 Oversight of Associated Entities (e.g. owned companies) ......................................................... 17
2 Student Learning by Coursework Programs.................................................................................... 18
2.1 Graduate Attributes and Student Learning Objectives ............................................................... 18
2.2 Curriculum ................................................................................................................................. 18
2.3 Student Entry Standards ............................................................................................................. 20
2.4 Foundation Program................................................................................................................... 20
2.5 Teaching Quality ........................................................................................................................ 21
2.6 Plagiarism................................................................................................................................... 21
2.7 Student Placements..................................................................................................................... 22
2.8 Assessment Methods, Standards and Moderation ...................................................................... 22
2.9 Academic Security and Invigilation ........................................................................................... 23
2.10 Student Retention and Progression............................................................................................. 23
2.11 Graduate Destinations and Employability.................................................................................. 23
3 Student Learning by Research Programs ......................................................................................... 24
4 Staff Research and Consultancy ........................................................................................................ 25
5 Industry and Community Engagement ............................................................................................. 26
5.1 Industry and Community Engagement Planning & Management.............................................. 26
5.2 Relationships with Industry and Employers............................................................................... 27
5.3 Relationships with Professions................................................................................................... 27
5.4 Relationships with Other Education Providers........................................................................... 27
5.5 Relationships with Alumni ......................................................................................................... 27
5.6 Relationships with the Community at Large .............................................................................. 28
6 Academic Support Services ................................................................................................................ 29
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 2 of 48
6.1 Academic Support Services Planning & Management............................................................... 29
6.2 Registry (Enrolment and Student Records) ................................................................................ 29
6.3 Library ........................................................................................................................................ 30
6.4 Information and Learning Technology Services......................................................................... 31
6.5 Academic Advising .................................................................................................................... 31
6.6 Student Learning Support ........................................................................................................... 32
6.7 Teaching Resources .................................................................................................................... 32
7 Students and Student Support Services............................................................................................. 33
7.1 Students and Student Support Services Planning & Management ............................................. 33
7.2 Student Profile ............................................................................................................................ 33
7.3 Student Satisfaction and Climate................................................................................................ 34
7.4 Student Behaviour ...................................................................................................................... 34
7.5 Career and Employment Services............................................................................................... 34
7.6 Student Finances......................................................................................................................... 35
7.7 Accommodation, Catering and Transport................................................................................... 35
7.8 Medical and Counselling Facilities ............................................................................................ 35
7.9 International Student Services .................................................................................................... 36
7.10 Social and Recreational Services and Facilities ......................................................................... 36
8 Staff and Staff Support Services......................................................................................................... 37
8.1 Human Resources Planning & Management.............................................................................. 37
8.2 Staff Profile................................................................................................................................. 37
8.3 Recruitment and Selection.......................................................................................................... 38
8.4 Induction..................................................................................................................................... 38
8.5 Professional Development.......................................................................................................... 39
8.6 Performance Planning and Review............................................................................................. 39
8.7 Promotion and Other Incentives ................................................................................................. 40
8.8 Severance.................................................................................................................................... 40
8.9 Staff Organisational Climate and Retention ............................................................................... 40
8.10 Omanisation................................................................................................................................ 41
9 General Support Services and Facilities............................................................................................ 42
9.1 General Support Services and Facilities Planning & Management ............................................ 42
9.2 Public Relations and Marketing ................................................................................................. 42
9.3 Communication Services............................................................................................................ 43
9.4 Facilities Management................................................................................................................ 43
Appendix A. Audit Panel ...................................................................................................................... 44
Appendix B. Abbreviations, Acronyms and Terms............................................................................ 45
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 3 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
OVERVIEW OF THE QUALITY AUDIT PROCESS
This Quality Audit Report (the ‘Report’) documents the findings of a Quality Audit by the Oman
Academic Accreditation Authority (OAAA – formerly the Oman Accreditation Council) of Bayan
College. It comments on Bayan College’s Mission and Vision, and the appropriateness and effectiveness
of its systems for achieving that Mission and Vision. Quality Audit is the first stage in Oman’s
institutional accreditation process. It is designed to provide a level of assurance to the public about the
quality of Bayan College’s activities, and constructive feedback to Bayan College to assist with its
ongoing improvement efforts.
The Quality Audit commenced with Bayan College undertaking a self study of its Mission, Vision and
systems. The results were summarized in its Quality Audit Portfolio (the ‘Portfolio’). This document
was submitted to the OAAA by the due date of 23 October 2012.
The OAAA appointed an external Audit Panel (the ‘Panel’), comprising suitably qualified and
experienced local and international reviewers, to conduct the Quality Audit. For membership of the Panel
see Appendix A. The Panel met (international members by telephone) on 18 December 2012 to consider
Bayan College’s Portfolio. Following this, the Audit Panel Chairperson’s representative and the
Executive Officer undertook a planning visit on behalf of the Panel to Bayan College on 5 January 2013
to clarify certain matters, request additional information and make arrangements for the Panel’s audit
visit.
Prior to the audit visit, the Panel invited submissions from the public about the quality of Bayan College’s
activities. Three submissions were received and considered.
The audit visit took place over 17-20 February 2013. During this time, the Panel spoke with 75 people,
including representatives of the governing authorities, staff, students and external stakeholders. It also
visited a selection of venues and reviewed a range of additional materials.
No information provided after 20 February 2013 (being the last day of the audit visit) was taken into
consideration for the purposes of this audit, other than 13 pre-existing items specifically requested by the
Panel in advance.
The Report contains a summary of the Panel’s findings, together with formal commendations where good
practices have been confirmed, affirmations where Bayan College’s ongoing quality improvement efforts
merit support, and recommendations where there are significant opportunities or improvement not yet
being adequately addressed. The Report provides a balanced set of observations, but does not comment
on every system in place at Bayan College.
The Panel’s audit activities and preparation of this Report were governed by regulations set by the OAAA
Board. This Report was approved for release by the OAAA Board on 29 August 2013.
The OAAA was established by Royal Decree No. 54/2010 to replace the Oman Accreditation Council.
Its responsibilities include conducting quality audits of higher education institutions (HEIs) in the
Sultanate of Oman. For further information, visit the OAAA website (http://www.oaaa.gov.om). Full
details of the quality audit process are available in OAAA’s HEI Quality Audit Manual (available from
http://www.oaaa.gov.om/Institution.aspx#Inst_Quality).
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 4 of 48
HOW TO READ THIS REPORT
Each OAAA Audit Report is written primarily for the institution being audited. The Report is specifically
designed to provide feedback to help that institution better understand its own strengths and opportunities
for improvement. The feedback is structured according to nine broad areas of activity and presented as
formal Commendations, Affirmations and Recommendations, or as informal suggestions, each
accompanied with explanatory paragraphs. It is expected that the institution will act upon this feedback
as part of its continuous efforts to provide the best possible education to students.
The Report is made public because it also may be of interest to students and potential students, their
families, employers, Government, other higher education institutions in Oman and abroad, and other
audiences. Students, in particular, may find this Report interesting because it provides some independent
comment on the learning environment at this institution (particularly Chapters 2, 6 and 7). However,
prospective students should still undertake their own investigations when deciding which higher
education institution will best serve their particular learning needs.
Quality Audit is the first stage in Oman’s two-stage process for institutional accreditation. Its focus is
formative (developmental) rather than summative. In other words, although the audit addresses nine
areas of activity which are common to all institutions, it does not measure the institution against
externally set standards of performance in those nine areas. Instead, it considers how well the institution
is attending to those areas in accordance with its own Mission and Vision and in the context of relevant
legal regulations. Therefore, Quality Audit recognises that each institution has a unique purpose and
profile; it does not directly compare one institution with all the other institutions in Oman.
For these reasons, a Quality Audit does not result in a pass or fail; nor does it provide any sort of grade or
score. It should also be noted that the precise number of Commendations, Affirmations and
Recommendations that an institution receives in its Audit Report is not as important as the substance of
those conclusions. For example, some Recommendations may focus on critical issues such as assessment
of student learning, whereas others may focus on issues such as the maintenance of teaching equipment in
classrooms which, while important, is clearly less critical. Therefore, it is neither significant nor
appropriate to compare the Audit Reports of different HEIs solely on the numbers of Commendations,
Affirmations and Recommendations.
The second stage in the institutional accreditation process is Standards Assessment. This stage, which
will take place about four years after the Quality Audit, does provide a summative assessment against
external standards in the same nine areas of activity. It should be noted that Oman also operates a system
of accreditation/recognition for academic programs, separately from the institutional accreditation
process. For more information on Oman’s System of Quality Assurance in Higher Education, please visit
www.oaaa.gov.om.
This Report contains a number of references to source evidence considered by the Audit Panel. These
references are for the HEI’s benefit in further addressing the issues raised. In most cases this evidence is
not in the public domain.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 5 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
CO�CLUSIO�S
This section summarises the main findings and lists the Commendations, Affirmations and
Recommendations. They are listed in the order in which they appear in the Report, and are not
prioritised. It should be noted that other favourable comments and suggestions for improvement are
mentioned throughout the text of the Report.
Executive Summary of Findings
Established in 2006, Bayan College (BC) was the first private higher education institution to offer Media
Studies in Oman. It is affiliated with Purdue University Calumet (PUC), USA and is supervised by the
Ministry of Higher Education (MoHE). The College is governed by a Board of Directors (BoD) and a
Board of Trustees (BoT). It is headed by a Dean who is supported by an Assistant Dean and a Head of
Department (HoD) for each academic and non-academic department. Offering Diplomas and Bachelor
degrees, the College hosts three main academic units: the Foundation Program, the Media Studies
Department and English Studies Department. The Media Studies Department offers majors in Journalism,
Broadcasting, Public Relations and Advertising, and the English Department offers English Literature and
English Professional Writing. Due to low enrollment rates in Advertising, it is being merged with Public
Relations into a new major called Business Communication, and there are plans to replace English
Professional Writing with Translation. The Foundation Program teaches English, Math, and Computing to
students requiring tuition in these areas before enrolling on their higher education programs. The
language of instruction is English for all courses. As of Fall 2011, there were 346 students enrolled at the
College, with over 75% females. The Media Studies Department has the highest number of enrollees
followed by the Foundation Program and then the English Studies Department. There are seven non-
academic departments including Admission and Registration; Student Affairs; Finance; Human
Resources; Quality Assurance Unit; Learning Resources; and Marketing and Public Relations. Whilst the
HoDs of all academic and non-academic departments are members of the College Council, only HoDs of
academic departments have membership in the Academic Council (along with the Quality Assurance
head). The Dean and Assistant Dean are members of both Councils. .
In the Portfolio, the College asserted that the preparation of the self-study was a collaborative, inclusive
and transparent process, which started in 2010/2011. In 2010, Bayan College undertook a comprehensive
review taking into consideration its own policies, and the MoHE and PUC reports. Significant changes
took place in 2010, including hiring new management and staff, shifting to a new campus, writing a new
Strategic Plan and establishing a Quality Assurance Unit. The College also devised a new Mission and
core values statement but kept the original Vision and goals and objectives. While the Portfolio provided
an overview of BC’s activities, the Panel found it that it lacked detail in some areas and that specific data
was missing (for example, the number of students or faculty members who took part in a survey). The
use of different terminology in referring to the College’s activities and lack of editing and proofreading of
its Portfolio undermined the College’s attempts to provide evidence of a comprehensive self-review.
BC’s Vision is to “make a major contribution” to human capital in Oman by providing “skilled, trained
and responsible graduates” in specialized programs. Despite a clear Vision and Mission statement, with
related values, the College needs to find ways to align and translate its strategic aims into practice more
effectively. The governance structure at the College, consisting of a BoD and BoT, can provide support
for this, although filling the current vacancies on the Boards is a matter of priority. It is also important for
BC to review the effectiveness of governance and management structures in order to clarify roles and
responsibilities. The relationship with PUC is long standing, crucial and defined by an affiliation
agreement between the two institutions. However, BC and PUC need to clarify their mutual expectations
and obligations and ensure that where the responsibility for assuring academic standards lies is made
clear.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 6 of 48
Planning at the College also requires attention through the proper implementation of the Strategic Plan
using operational plans and key performance indicators. Financial planning and management at the
College also requires attention through the development of budgeting mechanisms and the mitigation
against financial risk. Other risks at BC need to be identified as part of deploying the College’s risk
management strategy. Although the College has a number of relevant policies, the Panel found a lack
awareness of these amongst staff and students and urges the College to communicate these to the
community, ensuring that they are applied consistently and regularly reviewed to monitor effectiveness.
The College is urged to fully implement its entity review and quality assurance system in order to ensure
that quality loops are closed and that a systematic approach to continuous quality improvement is
supported. This quality cycle includes developing and implementing action plans in response to issues
raised in the reports from PUC.
PUC provides the curricula for the courses taught at BC and the academic programs are based on those
delivered at PUC. The College has recognized the need to contextualize the PUC curricula to Oman and
the Panel supports its efforts in this regard. The curricula also needs to be reviewed on a regular basis,
with input from PUC as well as other stakeholders, including industry and employers, and more practical
elements needs to be introduced considering the specialized nature of Media programs. The College has
introduced a comprehensive system for maintain course files that has created a repository of teaching
materials. However, the College does not have a full set of graduate attributes that are integrated into the
curricula. These need to be established. One of the ways in which BC promotes teaching quality is
through peer lesson observations, which provides a useful tool for staff teaching evaluation and reflection.
One area which is still lacking, however, is moderation of student achievement. The College is urged to
fully implement its moderation policy and put mechanisms in place, such as external input from PUC or
the use of external examiners, in order to ensure that academic standards are being met.
The College has included a research objective in its Strategic Plan. While the Panel recognises the
importance of research, BC is urged to reconsider the appropriateness of having a research objective at
this stage of its development; if the research objective is retained then related plans and policies will need
to be developed in support of this.
Despite its central location and specialized programs, BC has not yet implemented a strategy for
managing industry and community engagement and partnerships. This impinges on the provision of
internship and placement opportunities for students, as well as more general interaction with industry
within the scope of the programs, and requires action. BC provides a range of academic support services
to students, albeit in an ad hoc manner. A more coordinated, planned approach is required so that
students have access to relevant services and resources. The College has already identified the need to
improve its registry services and is working on deploying an integrated student registration system. The
Panel supports its efforts in this area. In terms of academic support services, BC is urged to review its
current Library and IT provision to ensure that the student learning environment is fully supported and
needs of students and staff are met. Several student support services are available to students at BC,
although a coordinated approach to managing these is lacking. The College survey shows that students
have expressed dissatisfaction with several different support services, and this needs to be acted on by
BC. The Panel also urges the College to take proactive steps to engage with employers in order to provide
input into curriculum development, explore job opportunities for graduates and assist students with
developing their job search skills.
The Panel found it commendable that the students at the College were producing the Bayan Post, an
entirely student-driven publication which is distributed internally and externally. As such, the Bayan Post
is a useful communication tool used to keep a range of stakeholders informed about events and activities
at the College.
The College is relatively small in terms of staff numbers and over the past few years it has experienced a
significant staff turnover. The College is encouraged to investigate the reasons for this. One of the causes
may be a lack of a comprehensive human resources strategy, supported by professional development
opportunities and a formal performance management system. BC needs to address these important issues
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 7 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
urgently to increase staff retention and satisfaction. Although BC is actively working on developing a
purpose-built campus, there have been delays and progress has been slow. The College needs to take
proactive steps to ensure that the current buildings are well maintained and kept fit for purpose until the
new campus is ready. A purpose-built campus may also lead to higher student enrollments, although the
College requires a marketing plan with recruitment targets to ensure future growth and financial
sustainability.
This Report recognizes College practices that are commendable, acknowledges positive change in
response to BC’s recognition of areas where improvement is needed and provides Recommendations in
areas that need to be improved. The Recommendations indicate areas that BC needs to address as part of
its development; however, it is the College’s responsibility to find ways to implement changes in these
areas.
Summary of Commendations
A formal Commendation recognises an instance of particularly good practice.
1. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority commends Bayan College for producing the
Bayan Post, which has resulted in a successful student-driven in-house publication. ..................... 43
Summary of Affirmations
A formal Affirmation recognizes an instance in which Bayan College has accurately identified a
significant opportunity for improvement and has demonstrated appropriate commitment to addressing the
matter.
1. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority agrees that Bayan College needs improve its
registry services and supports its effort to do this through the development and deployment
of an integrated student registration system. .................................................................................... 30
Summary of Recommendations
A Recommendation draws attention to a significant opportunity for improvement that Bayan College has
either not yet accurately identified or to which it is not yet adequately attending.
1. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College devise and
implement a systematic, inclusive and comprehensive process for aligning its Vision, Mission
and Core Values with practice. ............................................................................................................ 11
2. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College review its
governance structure in order to ensure its effectiveness and fill the vacant positions on the
Board of Trustees as a matter of priority.............................................................................................. 12
3. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College review its
management structure and ensure that roles and responsibilities are clarified. ................................... 13
4. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College, in conjunction
with its affiliate Purdue University Calumet, review the affiliation agreement to include clear
performance expectations and mutual obligations and clarify where the responsibility for
assuring academic standards lies.......................................................................................................... 14
5. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College ensure effective
implementation of its Strategic Plan through comprehensive operational planning in all
departments, and monitor the achievement of strategic and operational objectives against key
performance indicators......................................................................................................................... 15
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 8 of 48
6. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement an effective and transparent system of financial planning, budgeting and
management. ........................................................................................................................................ 15
7. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College implement its
risk management policy to ensure that potential risks are identified, managed and monitored
effectively............................................................................................................................................. 16
8. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College ensure
widespread communication, consistent application as well as systematic and regular review of
its policies and policy management system.......................................................................................... 16
9. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College ensure that its
activity and entity review cycles are fully implemented, such as taking action in response to
issues raised in affiliate reports, in order to support continuous quality improvement. ....................... 17
10. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College ensure that its
formal approach to the student grievance process is fully implemented, communicated to all
stakeholders and its effectiveness reviewed. ........................................................................................ 17
11. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College review and
refine its graduate attributes, and ensure that they are understood by staff and students;
integrated into the curriculum and the achievement of them is assessed. ............................................ 18
12. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement a consistent approach to the contextualization and localization of its curriculum as
well as a mechanism to evaluate the effectiveness of its approach. ..................................................... 19
13. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement a formal, clear and consistent process for the regular review and revision of the
curricula across all its academic programs which incorporates feedback from its academic
affiliate, Purdue University Calumet, as well as from students, employers and other relevant
stakeholders, in order to ensure that the curriculum remains current, and relevant to the labour
market and is delivered consistently. ................................................................................................... 20
14. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College review its
current entry standards to ensure that they align with level stipulated in the affiliation
agreement with Purdue University Calumet......................................................................................... 20
15. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College maximize
placement opportunities for students to gain practical training experience and improve
students’ learning experience. .............................................................................................................. 22
16. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College ensure that its
moderation policy is implemented and that there are mechanisms in place to assure academic
standards, such as through external review from its affiliate. .............................................................. 23
17. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College review its
strategic approach to developing its research profile either through reconsidering the
appropriateness of having a research objective at this stage in the College’s development or
through the development and implementation of related plans and policies to support the
achievement of this objective. .............................................................................................................. 25
18. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement a strategy for effectively coordinating, expanding and managing industry and
community engagement, which includes relevant key performance indicators to measure its
success.................................................................................................................................................. 26
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 9 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
19. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College improve and
upgrade the Library provision as a matter of priority to ensure that it meets the needs of the
students, and staff and supports the academic programs...................................................................... 30
20. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College review its
current IT provision to ensure that it fully supports the student learning environment and
implements a robust IT back-up system............................................................................................... 31
21. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement a system to regularly collect and monitor student satisfaction with services; analyse
results and develop action plans to deal with issues raised; and inform students of changes
made in response to their feedback. ..................................................................................................... 34
22. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College actively engage
with employers to maximize opportunities for employment and formally provide students with
relevant job search skills. ..................................................................................................................... 35
23. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College adopt a
comprehensive, fully-resourced, long term approach to the planning, recruitment and retention
of staff. ................................................................................................................................................. 37
24. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College provide
systematic professional development opportunities for staff, linked to enhancing performance. ....... 39
25. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement a formal performance management system for teaching and administrative staff
which is linked to professional development opportunities. ................................................................ 40
26. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College regularly and
systematically monitor staff satisfaction; respond to issues that are identified; and inform staff
of changes made in response to their feedback. ................................................................................... 41
27. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College ensure there is
a transition strategy in place to keep the current buildings and maintenance of facilities fit for
purpose while the plans for the new site are being developed. ............................................................ 42
28. The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan College develop and
implement a marketing plan to support the strategic goals of the College in this area. ....................... 43
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 10 of 48
1 GOVER�A�CE A�D MA�AGEME�T
Bayan College (BC) is a private higher education institution in Muscat which was established in
2006. It is formally classified as a “College” by the Ministry of Higher Education (MoHE),
through which it is licensed to operate. It is the first College in Oman to specialize in Media
Studies. The College is affiliated with Purdue University Calumet (PUC) in the USA.
This Chapter reports on the Panel’s findings in relation to overall governance and management at
the College and specifically covers the following topics: Mission, Vision and Values;
governance; management; institutional affiliations for programs and quality assurance; strategic
plan; operational planning; financial management; risk management; policy management; entity
and activity review systems; and student grievance processes.
1.1 Mission, Vision and Values
The College states its Vision as follows:
To be a key part of the higher education infrastructure in Oman and to make a
major contribution to the development of human resources in the Sultanate and
the region. We aim to create students who are renowned for their ability to think,
achieve and excel. (Portfolio, p.9)
The Vision is reflected in the following Mission statement:
• To create an academic environment highly conducive to quality education and the
pursuit of excellence.
• To provide skilled, trained and responsible graduates.
• To integrate with and serve the local community. (Portfolio, p.10)
The Core Values of the College are:
• Excellence in Teaching, Learning & Facilities: Delivering excellent teaching and
learning experience coupled with modern facilities to ensure that graduates are well
prepared for the world of work.
• Loyalty: Dedicated to meeting our commitments and obligations.
• Social responsibility: Dedicated to improving the lives of others through professional and
community services
• Accountability & Transparency: We assume and demonstrate responsibility for our
decisions & actions. (Portfolio, p.10)
The Vision, Mission and Values have been embedded into the College’s Strategic Plan (pp.4-5).
While the Vision and Mission stated in the Portfolio are the same as those stated in BC’s
Strategic Plan, the College’s website and on display at the College, the Mission statement differs
from the Mission of the College in the College Bylaws. This indicates an inconsistency related to
document management and updates. The College states that the Vision, Mission and Values are
“frequently revisited” (Portfolio, p.11) and there is evidence of changes being made to the
Mission and Values since they were initially developed by a consultant prior to 2006. During a
comprehensive review in 2010, modifications were made to the Mission statement and the
College’s Values; however the Vision remained unchanged (Portfolio, p.9). Furthermore, the
Strategic Plan includes an additional statement on the Core Values that addresses the College’s
work with partners.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 11 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
While the Panel acknowledges the College’s efforts to review and update its Vision, Mission and
Values, it stresses the importance of a systematic and comprehensive approach so that all
pertaining documents are consistent, updated and fit for purpose. Furthermore, the
implementation of the College’s Core Values with regards to excellence in teaching and learning;
the skills of its graduates; the integration with the local community; and accountability and
transparency were not evident to the Panel during the audit visit. There was no evidence to show
that the College monitors whether or not these Values are applied systematically in practice
through policies and processes on a systematic basis. Examples of this mismatch between what is
stated in documents in relation to the Vision, Mission and Values and what is practiced at BC can
be found in subsequent sections of this report and related recommendations. The College needs to
ensure a more adequate integration of its aspirations with its practices in order to achieve its
goals.
Recommendation 1
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College devise and implement a systematic, inclusive and comprehensive
process for aligning its Vision, Mission and Core Values with practice.
1.2 Governance
The College states that it is governed by the Board of Directors (BoD), the Board of Trustees
(BoT), and the Executive Committee (EC) (Portfolio, p.12). The BoD consists of the investors,
and has full authority to oversee the management of the College in fulfillment of BC’s objectives,
including the establishment of the Vision and the Mission, the review and approval of the annual
budget, the appointment of the Dean and other key personnel, and the power to establish
operational, financial and administrative policies (Portfolio, p.12).
The BoT is an entity of seven members representing the owners of the College, the Dean, one
delegate of the College faculty, as well as “social dignitaries” who are experts in the fields
offered in the College programs (Portfolio, p.13). The responsibilities of the BoT include the
identification and assessment of strategic aims and educational policies, the appointment,
appraisal and dismissal of the Dean, the approval of College policies and regulations, the
identification of admission requirements, tuition fees, academic programs, and the
recommendation of annual revenue and expenditure estimates (Portfolio, p.13). The BoT
Chairman is chosen by the College Council (see Section 1.3). The EC is a sub-committee of the
BoT which consists of selected BoD members and monitors the College’s financial and academic
performance; selects key executives; reviews and recommends the budget; monitors income and
expenditures against the budget; and reviews staff appeals (Portfolio, p.13). The EC is chaired by
a Managing Director, selected by the BoD to support its work.
The Bylaws of the College consist of a number of separate documents, and are supplemented
with “Revisions and Continuous Upgrades to Policies and Bylaws”. The Panel noted that the
practice of changing and adding Bylaws does not conform to the Bylaws’ own stipulations on
how they can be changed. This may be one of the causes for what the Panel found to be a lack of
clarity concerning the overall governance of the College. Furthermore, the Panel identified a
number of overlaps in the duties between governing bodies as both the BoD and the BoT have
responsibilities to appoint or dismiss the Dean, or to approve College policies and regulations.
The Panel also noticed variations across a number of documents, both in the definition of
responsibilities of entities and in the terminology used that may have an impact on the College’s
goal achievement. This is an area the College is urged to review.
In its review of the current governance and management structures, the Panel was concerned
about the governing bodies’ ability to fulfill their responsibilities. The College highlights the
importance of communication through meetings and their minutes (Portfolio, p.13), and the
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 12 of 48
Bylaws stipulate that the BoD should meet at least four times per year. The supporting evidence
and the Panel’s observations suggest infrequent and unstructured communication, mainly reliant
on personal ad hoc communication between the Dean and the Managing Director, who then
communicates with individual members of the BoD and BoT. The Panel heard that the EC had
not met in two years. Furthermore, the Panel was informed of changes in both the BoD and BoT
composition resulting in significant vacancies on these governing boards, particularly on the BoT.
Because of these changes, the Panel has concerns that the core governing bodies of the College
may be impaired in their ability to provide effective direction and support at the strategic level.
The College is urged to review the structure, performance and relationships between its
governing bodies to ensure their effectiveness.
Recommendation 2
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College review its governance structure in order to ensure its effectiveness
and fill the vacant positions on the Board of Trustees as a matter of priority.
1.3 Management
The College states that the Dean has a core function (Portfolio, p.14). He is accountable to the EC
and the BoD, and he is responsible for the overall day-to-day management of the College
(Portfolio, p.14). The Dean receives support from the College Council (CC), consisting of the
Dean, the Assistant Dean, and the Heads of Department (HoDs) for both academic and non-
academic departments, and the Academic Council (AC), which consists of the Dean, the
Assistant Dean, and the HoDs of the academic departments and the QA Officer (Portfolio, p.17).
The CC, meets once per week, manages day-to-day operations together with the AC (Portfolio,
p.7), and it is tasked with monitoring the implementation of operational plans of departments
(Portfolio, p. 20). The Assistant Dean who also serves as the HoD for the English Department,
according to the Portfolio (p.17), has the function of a Deputy Dean (i.e. to fulfill the Dean’s
function in his absence). The HoDs manage their own departments based on the College’s
policies and regulations, to some extent in consultation with departmental members during
department meetings. Furthermore, the College has established a number of committees including
the Examination Committee, the Academic Advising Committee, the Textbook and References
Committee, the Purchase Committee, the Disciplinary Committee, the Quality Assurance
Committee, the Curriculum Development Committee, and the Health and Safety Committee,
amongst others. The College states that staff and senior management are monitored and assessed
systematically (Portfolio, pp.17-18).
The Panel acknowledges that the College has set up an organizational structure in which it can
deploy all necessary management activities. At the same time, the Panel noted that the large
number of committees is disproportionate to the number of staff and has a significant impact on
their workload. For instance, by virtue of his position, the Assistant Dean is a member of at least
eight committees in addition to his function on the CC and AC.
In relation to the management structure, the Panel noted in interviews with staff members that
there was a lack of clarity concerning staff members’ roles and responsibilities with many staff
members holding multiple roles within the organization, resulting in significant workloads. This
further raises questions about the management of different roles and responsibilities to ensure that
they are being executed effectively. The Panel found little evidence of a systematic assessment of
the performance of individual staff members or a mechanism to evaluate the effectiveness of the
management structure thus impeding the College’s ability to monitor and improve management
processes. This is an area that needs to be addressed.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 13 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
Recommendation 3
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College review its management structure and ensure that roles and
responsibilities are clarified.
The Panel received positive feedback about the responsiveness of the Dean in regard to staff
requests and staff members often approach the Dean directly. However, the Panel has concerns in
relation to the Dean’s centrality in many operational aspects of the College’s management. While
convenient for students and employees, the Panel is of the opinion that the level of his personal
involvement is not in line with good management practices. An approach to the Dean’s
delegation of authority needs to be developed and implemented.
1.4 Institutional Affiliations for Programs and Quality Assurance
The College is affiliated with PUC, USA. The relationship is governed by an International
Affiliation Agreement that was first signed in 2005, renewed as an Academic Consultation
Agreement in 2010, and supplemented by an Articulation Agreement in 2011. In the preamble to
the 2010 Agreement, PUC commits to enhance its contributions to the College’s growth and
academic quality. In detail, this agreement outlines PUC’s responsibilities including biannual site
visits, five-year program review visits, sharing of course materials (course descriptions, course
syllabi, sample examinations), criteria for faculty hiring, review of BC materials including
student examinations and the signing of awards. The Panel reviewed the 2010 and 2011 annual
site visit reports. There was no 2012 report available at the time of the visit. While the College
states that it takes the annual reports seriously and it forwards them to the Ministry of Higher
Education (MoHE) (Portfolio, p.18), the Panel did not find any evidence to indicate that the
College responds to the issues raised in the site visit reports as part of a continuous improvement
process.(see Recommendation 9). Although the affiliation agreement indicates that there will be
interaction between the libraries at BC and PUC, there was no evidence in support of this (see
Section 6.3).
The Panel acknowledges the nature of the affiliation with PUC and the existence of a valid
agreement and annual site visit reports. However, the Panel observed that there is no shared
understanding between PUC and the College on some key details of the agreement, both in terms
of the type and the depth of the affiliates’ responsibilities. For instance, the 2010 Agreement does
not clarify how communication between the two institutions is structured operationally, such as
between BC and PUC staff members for the purpose of delivering courses and quality assurance
processes. Furthermore, after the review of information from PUC and the College, the Panel
concluded that both institutions are unclear of PUC’s role in the localization and
contextualization of courses and programs. The Panel was unable to find evidence to show that
PUC is monitoring entry standards of BC students, moderating exams, or monitoring learning
outcomes. BC awards state that the degree is conferred “according to the Curriculum established
under the guidance and recognition of Department of Communication and Creative Arts Purdue
University Calumet”. The degree certificate issued to students is signed by a representative of
PUC, who could be the Head of the relevant department, the Dean of the School, or the Vice
Chancellor of PUC. The Panel noted that there was a lack of clarity amongst internal and external
stakeholders as to who awards the qualifications and some interviewees understood that the
award was equivalent to PUC’s own undergraduate degree. PUC’s position was that the
statement on the award simply acknowledges the affiliation between the two institutions, and that
the degree is a guarantee of completion, but not necessarily of equivalency. This needs to be
clarified for all stakeholders.
The College is urged to review its affiliation agreement with PUC in order to ensure that both
institutions have a shared understanding of their responsibilities and that these are implemented
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 14 of 48
and reviewed on a regular basis. This will need to include clarity on who is responsible for
assuring academic standards and how this is managed.
Recommendation 4
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College, in conjunction with its affiliate Purdue University Calumet, review
the affiliation agreement to include clear performance expectations and
mutual obligations and clarify where the responsibility for assuring
academic standards lies.
1.5 Strategic Plan
The College states that its 2011-2015 Strategic Plan was developed by a committee and approved
by the BoT in 2010. It is based on the College’s Vision, Mission and Values. The College states
that the Strategic Plan was emailed to all faculty members and HoDs of non-academic
departments (Portfolio, p.19). BC also states that all departments are responsible for monitoring
their own progress in line with the Strategic Plan. Overall monitoring is the responsibility of the
CC, under the QA Officer, who is expected to regularly submit reports on the progress in meeting
the targets of the Strategic Plan (Portfolio, p.19). The College also has a Quality Monitoring Plan,
which consists of a list of monitoring activities designed to record and review performance (see
also Section 1.10) but this does not align with the Strategic Plan.
The Panel found the Strategic Plan to be comprehensive although some of the targets are
expressed in qualitative terms and are vague. The College is encouraged to additionally refine
these targets. Despite the BoT having the mandate to develop the Strategic Plan, the Panel heard
that the responsibility for strategic planning lies primarily with the Dean. The Panel was informed
that the College management was satisfied with strategic goal achievement, although there is no
evidence of the continuous and systematic monitoring of the Strategic Plan. For instance, while
the College states that most actions of the Strategic Plan Area no. 1 have been completed
(Portfolio, p.19), the Panel found no evidence of this. The Panel considers that better
communication of the Strategic Plan is necessary to ensure the full support of staff members in
the achievement of its goals. This may be achieved through effective operational planning (see
Section 1.6).
1.6 Operational Planning
Objective 5.1 of the Strategic Plan states that the College aims to “develop a culture of planning
and evaluation”. In detail, it stipulates the creation of action plans, the development of
benchmarking indicators, and faculty and staff evaluations. The College states that all
departments are required to write their Operational Plans in alignment with the Strategic Plan
(Portfolio, p.20). The Panel reviewed a number of department Operational Plans and found that
while some plans align with the Strategic Plan and outline measurable objectives, the plans for
other departments show no apparent links with the Strategic Plan and are less comprehensive.
Other than those stated in the Portfolio (p.20), there are no clearly defined and consistently
monitored key performance indicators (KPIs) for any of the operational goals, and the timelines
and resources needed for the various plans are only very broadly defined.
The Quality Monitoring Plan outlines certain documentation and reporting activities, but it is
unclear how they relate to, or bridge between, strategic and operational planning. The Panel noted
that the awareness of the value of operational planning in general and the level of depth in
particular need to be improved. Of particular concern to the Panel was the fact that several of the
non-academic departments, including Marketing, Human Resources, Learning Resources, and the
Career Guidance Centre had no formal Operational Plans. As a result there is no systematic
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 15 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
monitoring of operational objectives or KPIs. The Panel considers this lack of comprehensive
operational planning to be a barrier to the College reaching its strategic objectives.
Recommendation 5
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College ensure effective implementation of its Strategic Plan through
comprehensive operational planning in all departments, and monitor the
achievement of strategic and operational objectives against key performance
indicators.
1.7 Financial Management
The College depends entirely on tuition fee revenue for its operational budget. Achieving
financial stability is, therefore, an important goal for the College in its Strategic Plan. The
Strategic Plan calls for training of HoDs in financial matters, the establishment of departmental
budgets, and the exploration of new funding opportunities. As indicated in the Portfolio (p. 20),
the finances of the College are managed by the Financial Department, which reports to the Dean
who must also approve all spending requests. The review and approval of the annual budget is the
responsibility of the BoD while the EC monitors financial performance and tracks income and
expenditures against the budget. However, as the EC has not met in two years (see Section 1.2),
the Panel found no evidence to show that the financial performance is monitored by this body.
The College states that the income from tuition fees does not meet budget expectations (Portfolio,
p.20) although during the audit visit, the Panel was informed that the level of student enrollment
was satisfactory. Notwithstanding the College’s satisfaction with enrollment goal achievement,
the Panel was concerned to learn that the Marketing Department of the College did not have clear
enrollment targets to support financial planning at the College. The Panel also received
conflicting information as to the availability of funds to make purchases including information
technology and learning resources such as textbooks. While some staff members claimed that
they have all necessary resources, others mentioned lack of adequate resources.
The Panel also did not receive any clear evidence that the College’s finances are adequately
monitored. For instance, the College states that weekly and monthly statements are prepared for
risk management purposes (Portfolio, p.20), but this was not supported by documentation
submitted to the Panel. The Panel concluded that the College must engage in longer term
planning and more frequent and detailed short-term reporting in order to mitigate financial risks
and ensure that adequate resources are provided in order to support the College’s strategic
objectives.
Recommendation 6
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement an effective and transparent system of
financial planning, budgeting and management.
1.8 Risk Management
The College has adopted a formal Risk Management Policy that identifies the CC and the HoDs
as bearing the responsibility for the College’s risk management. The College also states that it has
taken out insurance for the mitigation of “almost all” physical risks (Portfolio, p.21). Despite the
College’s statement that the maintenance of a risk-free environment is a top priority (Portfolio,
p.22), the Panel found little evidence for the implementation of BC’s Risk Management Policy.
For instance, the policy requires the College to have a system of risk management controls that
include the identification and monitoring of key risk indicators and an annual review of the risk
management system, neither of which were available. Furthermore, the Panel had concerns about
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 16 of 48
how the results of existing internal and external reports are used so that proper management of
the College’s risks is assured. Based on the Panel’s observation, several areas are of particular
concern as potential risks including campus facilities (see Recommendation 27); the addition of
new programs; vacancies in the governance structure (see Recommendation 2); marketing and
student recruitment targets (see Recommendation 28); finance (see Recommendation 6); Human
Resources (see Recommendation 23); IT; and admissions and registration. The College reported
“instability due to financial difficulties and vagueness of recruitment policy” as weaknesses in its
SWOT in the Strategic Plan and in regard to exploring new sources of funding has set this as a
strategic goal.
Recommendation 7
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College implement its risk management policy to ensure that potential risks
are identified, managed and monitored effectively.
1.9 Policy Management
The College states that it has various materials, including student handbooks in Arabic and
English and staff handbooks, which include all policies and related processes at the College and
that these are provided to new students and employees (Portfolio, p.22). Furthermore, the College
states that its policies are based on the principles of transparency, fairness, partnership, and
agreement with national policies and regulations, and that it continuously upgrades its policies
(Portfolio, p.22).
The Panel acknowledges the large number of existing policies the College has in place. Many
policies have only been formally included in the College’s governing documents in the second
half of 2012 and consequently, staff awareness of certain policies is still low with little evidence
of their complete implementation. For instance, although there is a Performance Evaluation Form,
employees are generally not aware of how their performance is evaluated. Furthermore, there is
little evidence of the consistent application of a systematic process for reviewing and changing
policies. The Panel found a low level of ownership of College policies, possibly because they
were written by an external consultant. The Panel feels that the College would benefit from a
thorough review of its policy development and management system, followed by an adaptation of
relevant practices, where necessary, which are clearly communicated to the College community.
Recommendation 8
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College ensure widespread communication, consistent application as well as
systematic and regular review of its policies and policy management system.
1.10 Entity and Activity Review Systems
Objective 5.1 of the Strategic Plan states that the College aims to “develop a culture of planning
and evaluation” and to “enhance a continuous evaluation culture”. The College also states that
committees and departments are empowered to review, monitor, and propose changes to policies
or the curriculum (Portfolio, p.22). It further states that data reviews are based on the Strategic
Plan and department Operational Plans. The Panel acknowledges that a number of important
elements of a review system exist, including the Affiliation Agreement with PUC; the Curriculum
Development Committee; the Quality Monitoring Plan and a Quality Officer function; an
Employer Satisfaction Form; a Student Satisfaction Survey; and Annual Department Reports, as
well as regular – required and voluntary – reports to the MoHE.
In its review of the College activities in this area, the Panel found that many of the elements of
the review system had only been implemented recently or inconsistently, with the relevant
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 17 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
stakeholders indicating that they had not been involved in the development of the stated
processes. The Panel also noted a lack of systematic integration of these elements into the
practices at the College. For instance, the Quality Monitoring Plan only outlines the times at
which certain data are collected, but does not always outline the process of analyzing, interpreting
and using these elements in improving practices. Most importantly, the potential for high quality
reviews stated in the Affiliation Agreement with PUC is only realized in a rudimentary manner.
As outlined in Section 1.4 above, there is no comprehensive or detailed understanding between
the College and PUC about their respective roles and responsibilities with regard to the provision
of different types and formats of data and other information, or about how site reports are utilized
and follow-up activities are monitored.
Although there are ad hoc initiatives carried out at BC to review specific activities, the Panel
concluded that the College has not yet developed a quality culture in which review activities are
carefully planned, implemented, results are obtained and analyzed, and, most importantly,
improvements are systematically identified and integrated. BC has identified the lack of staff as
an impediment to an effective review system (Portfolio, p.23), but no concrete actions have been
taken to address this gap.
Recommendation 9
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College ensure that its activity and entity review cycles are fully
implemented, such as taking action in response to issues raised in affiliate
reports, in order to support continuous quality improvement.
1.11 Student Grievance Process
The College claims that it considers student complaints as an element in confidence-building and
in students’ participation in the life of the College (Portfolio, p.23). It has implemented a formal
Student Grievance Process for academic or non-academic student complaints and, in addition,
provides suggestion boxes. In its review of this area, the Panel learned that students frequently
bypass the formal grievance process by approaching the Dean, Assistant Dean or HoDs directly,
which suggests that the College’s formal approach is not being implemented. The College itself
recognizes this (Portfolio, p.23) but nothing has been done to address it yet.
Recommendation 10
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College ensure that its formal approach to the student grievance process is
fully implemented, communicated to all stakeholders and its effectiveness
reviewed.
1.12 Health and Safety
The College states that it has formed a College Safety and Security Committee and that it carries
out a number of health and safety-related activities (Portfolio, p.23). The Panel was pleased to
note that the Committee was formally instituted in 2012. The College is now encouraged to
develop this initiative further in order to ensure that a consistent approach to addressing the area
of health and safety is implemented.
1.13 Oversight of Associated Entities (e.g. owned companies)
The College states that it neither owns nor controls any company or entity (Portfolio, p.24).
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 18 of 48
2 STUDE�T LEAR�I�G BY COURSEWORK PROGRAMS
Bayan College (BC) offers five Diploma and Bachelor programs housed in two departments,
namely Media Studies (Journalism, Broadcasting and Public Relations) and English Studies
(English Literature and English Professional Writing). There are plans to introduce a degree in
Translation, but this has not yet been implemented. BC’s programs are developed in affiliation
with Purdue University Calumet (PUC) (Portfolio, p.5).
This Chapter considers key areas in relation to student learning by coursework, including
graduate attributes; curriculum; student entry standards; the foundation program; teaching
quality; plagiarism; student placements; assessment methods and moderation; academic security
and invigilation; student retention and progression; and graduate employability.
2.1 Graduate Attributes and Student Learning Objectives
The College has identified graduate attributes, under the categories of generic and discipline-
specific attributes (the latter are also referred to as “graduate professional attributes”) (Portfolio,
p.25). Objective 1.3 in the College’s Strategic Plan is to ensure that these graduate attributes are
linked to the labour market. Some examples of generic attributes are given in the Portfolio, as
well as lists of discipline-specific attributes for each academic department (p.25). The latter are
quite specific in nature and resemble course or program objectives rather than graduate attributes.
While the College states that teachers have been asked to align their plans to the graduate
attributes (Portfolio, p.11), during the audit visit the Panel found that academic staff were unclear
as to what the graduate attributes were. The course outlines considered by the Panel indicated
course objectives but made no mention of graduate attributes. The College described the
mechanisms for assessing student achievement of graduate attributes, including course grades,
rubrics, coursework and surveys (Portfolio, p.25). Sample data are quoted from course
evaluations and the graduate satisfaction survey (Portfolio, pp.25-26). However, the learning
outcomes referred to in these data are not well- aligned with the graduate attributes. Taking these
factors into account and based on views heard during the audit visit, the Panel established that
assessment is focused on course objectives rather than on broader graduate attributes. The Panel
concluded that the graduate attributes at BC have not yet been clearly defined or communicated
to academic staff and are not clearly considered as part of the assessment process.
Recommendation 11
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College review and refine its graduate attributes, and ensure that they are
understood by staff and students; integrated into the curriculum and the
achievement of them is assessed.
2.2 Curriculum
According to the College, its curriculum is based upon the curriculum of its affiliate, PUC, with
modifications approved by PUC “to suit local conditions” (Portfolio, p.26). BC further states that
courses are reviewed at College, department and committee levels using feedback from course
appraisals by teachers and from student surveys (Portfolio, p.27). The Strategic Plan includes
objectives of ensuring that curricula prepare students for the labour market and that all
courses/programs are competency-based.
BC has implemented a system for maintaining ‘Course Files’, to keep syllabi and materials, and
‘Semester Files’ which also include appraisals and modifications by teachers. The Panel was
informed that these files provide information that can be stored about the courses that have been
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 19 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
taught, which is especially important bearing in mind BC’s high turnover of staff (see
Recommendation 23). Evidence considered by the Panel indicated that instructors were
maintaining the system of Course and Semester Files. The files are reviewed by the Head of
Department and made available to all teaching staff. The Panel recognises the development of the
Course File system as a positive development in the College as it provides a comprehensive
repository of course information and teaching materials.
The Panel encourages the College to maximize the benefits from the Course and Semester Files
in the future by, for example, using feedback from instructors to inform course development and
improve teaching quality.
BC states that it has made some efforts to modify its curriculum to the Omani context (Portfolio
p.26). This has included cultural localization (for example with the provision of the course
History and Society of Oman and reviewing the content of courses for culturally inappropriate
topics) and linguistic localization (for example the Arabic Language course requirement, and
input on Arabic scriptwriting in one semester). BC has also made efforts to provide locally
relevant professional topics such as Audio Production. Nevertheless, the Panel saw no evidence
of efforts to evaluate or review these changes, or to gather data to inform further improvement in
this area. The Panel urges the College to adopt a systematic approach to the process for
contextualizing the curriculum from PUC and ensure that learning objectives are locally relevant.
Recommendation 12
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement a consistent approach to the
contextualization and localization of its curriculum as well as a mechanism
to evaluate the effectiveness of its approach.
The College has a Curriculum Development Committee, whose tasks include “discussion/
analysis of all surveys conducted by the College” and “using data from college surveys to
improve existing courses” (Portfolio, p.27). The College presented data gathered from a student
survey just before the formation of this Committee, which indicated that less than half of students
were satisfied that “the content of the courses in my major is valuable” or that “instructors help to
set goals toward my career” (Portfolio, p.28). The Panel saw evidence of such survey results
being made available to academic departments and urges the College to make use of the findings
to inform decisions by the departments and the Curriculum Development Committee.
During the audit visit, the Panel heard that students had been affected by changes in course
availability due to low staff retention (see Recommendation 23) as well as by changes in study
plans for majors. As a result, some students had taken a number of electives but not been able to
fulfill the requirements for their program. Also relevant to the area of course review and
development is feedback from employers; the Panel saw limited evidence of this feedback being
gathered in a systematic way. Partially completed employer feedback forms about graduates
were submitted to the Panel for consideration, but the Panel found no evidence of completion of
the survey by the employers interviewed or action based on review of this data.
Decisions to change majors offered at the College were mentioned in evidence of BC discussions
with PUC in 2010 and in other documentation (including a comparison of existing and projected
majors). However, the Panel found no evidence of these changes being based upon feedback
from students, employers or other stakeholders. Overall, although some actions have been made
to collect data about the extent to which College curricula are reaching their goals, this has not to
date been conducted consistently or systematically, and the College has not yet engaged with the
data collected in a way likely to achieve its objectives of improving the long-term quality of the
curricula.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 20 of 48
Recommendation 13
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement a formal, clear and consistent process for
the regular review and revision of the curricula across all its academic
programs which incorporates feedback from its academic affiliate, Purdue
University Calumet, as well as from students, employers and other relevant
stakeholders, in order to ensure that the curriculum remains current, and
relevant to the labour market and is delivered consistently.
2.3 Student Entry Standards
Entry requirements to the College include achievement of the Oman General Education Diploma.
The College uses an Open Source placement test as the basis for placing students into levels of
the Foundation Program or directly into their major (Portfolio, p.28). Entry requirements are
communicated to students with College publicity materials, and applied strictly to entrants. A
system for credit transfer is in place. During the audit visit, the Panel found that students and
staff were familiar with the entry requirements.
The Panel notes a discrepancy between the English entry requirements in the College’s agreement
with PUC (550 TOEFL or 6.5 IELTS) and the entry requirements in the Student Handbook (500
TOEFL or 5 IELTS); during the audit visit, the Panel found that this discrepancy was highlighted
by concerned parties, and considers that this should be addressed in collaboration with PUC.
Furthermore, while the College states that the placement test is “adequate and […] reliable”
(Portfolio (p.29), the Panel could not find evidence to show how the effectiveness of the
placement test is evaluated. The Panel advises BC to review its placement test and ensure that
entry standards as per the agreement with PUC are being applied.
Recommendation 14
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College review its current entry standards to ensure that they align with
level stipulated in the affiliation agreement with Purdue University Calumet.
2.4 Foundation Program
The College’s Foundation Program comprises three levels: beginner, low intermediate and high
intermediate. Each level may be completed in one 16 week semester or in an 8-week intensive
summer program (Portfolio, p.5). The College states that the Foundation curriculum is aligned
with the Oman Academic Standards for General Foundation Programs, and includes grammar,
writing, listening and oral skills, as well as IT, Math and Study Skills (Portfolio, p.28). The Panel
considered documentation to show that Foundation students’ progress is monitored with the
intention of comparing successive cohorts.
The Panel was informed that the standard of English competence was improving but students still
need to develop their skills in their major. For entry into the major programs, the College is
encouraged to consider supplementing the grammar and sentence-reading based placement test
with a proficiency test of skills to make it more comparable to the IELTS or TOEFL, as well as
ensuring its alignment with Oman’s Academic Standards for General Foundation Programs.
Among other advantages, this would enable the College to review the entry standards for its
majors in line with those required by affiliate institution, PUC. This issue has been raised by PUC
in their visit reports (see Recommendation 14).
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 21 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
2.5 Teaching Quality
The College states that it selects teaching staff according to academic qualifications and
experience as outlined in its recruitment policy (Portfolio, p.29). The College aims to encourage
teaching practices such as active learning and prompt feedback, and to support new teaching staff
through orientation and mentoring during their three-month probationary period. Lesson
observation has been introduced on a regular basis (Portfolio, p.30), with the target of a formal
observation of each teacher by the Head of Department (HoD) and a teaching colleague once per
semester. Student evaluation surveys include feedback on the quality of teaching; the College
also hopes to deal effectively with specific student grievances (Portfolio, p.30). The Panel was
informed that teachers sometimes attend external events related to teaching development.
The Panel was informed that some teachers are promoting active learning and class participation
by students, as well as discussion and critical thinking. Lesson and course plans provided in
semester files indicated that learning objectives are referred to in the planning process
A peer observation system has been instituted in the College, including a regular observation of
each teaching staff member by their HoD with a teaching colleague. An appropriate feedback
form is used for this purpose, and both affirmative and critical comments are provided on various
areas of teaching. The Panel encourages the College to maximize the benefits from this system in
the future by ensuring that comments are provided for each section of the lesson observation
report and linking this to a performance monitoring system (see Recommendation 25). The
College may wish to consider the possibility of separating developmental peer observation of, or
by a teaching colleague (for example during the probation period) from the observation by the
HoD which is considered a performance evaluation (Portfolio, p.29).
Data already gathered in student evaluations of courses is also potentially useful for stimulating
and guiding improvements in teaching; although the College has not yet engaged with this data
by following up on student feedback to check that improvements in teaching occur. The College
has a problem with retention of suitably qualified and experienced staff (see Recommendation
23), which may have an unfavorable impact on teaching quality.
2.6 Plagiarism
The College has policies on plagiarism for students and staff, which are summarized in the
relevant handbooks. Students receive input on this as part of the Foundation Study Skills
program, and are encouraged to refer to the work of others with proper acknowledgement.
Relevant information is included in course outlines, combining information about plagiarism with
information about citing sources to help avoid plagiarism (Portfolio, p.31). Penalties for
plagiarism and repeated plagiarism are specified, with a five-step process for escalating such
cases.
During the audit visit, the Panel found that faculty and students were reasonably informed about
the nature of plagiarism, and that faculty felt capable of detecting and dealing with cases of
plagiarism. The Panel also noted that the College keeps copies of plagiarized work for future
reference. The procedure for responding to plagiarism has been implemented in particular cases,
although escalation of any case through all five steps had not been required by the time of the
audit.
The College states that it has assigned a teacher to develop a college-wide approach for
referencing, presented in a booklet (Portfolio, p.32). The College is encouraged to review whether
plagiarism is being detected and penalized according to its policies; this could be aided by using
online submission tools which detect possible plagiarism (such as Turnitin or SafeAssign).
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 22 of 48
2.7 Student Placements
BC claims that it emphasizes the importance of practical experience and skills for graduates, and
the link between these and employability (Portfolio, p.32). BC also highlights learning outcomes
and existing courses of relevance to this area (Portfolio, p.34). The College’s Internship and
Training Policy (ITP) lays out the requirements and responsibilities involved in internships, as
well as the potential benefits of the internship. Extracurricular activities, as well as courses with
practical potential such as Interpersonal Skills and Script Writing, are also highlighted as
contributing to the practical element of the curriculum (Portfolio, p.34). The potential benefits of
these activities include students applying practical skills in a realistic context, and becoming
familiar with aspects of their future career (see Section 2.11).
The Panel was informed that students who take internships benefit from this experience, and the
College has a system to gather feedback from both employer and student on the internship
process. The Panel found that these internship opportunities are not at present realized for a
significant number of students. Internships are limited in number and restricted to students with a
GPA of 2.7 or higher. According to the College (Portfolio, p.43), around 25% of graduates (year
unspecified) have taken an internship, even though the ITP states that “an internship is an integral
part of a student's total program of study”. During the audit visit, the Panel was informed that
the practical elements of courses are often de-emphasized, because of a combination of factors
including the teaching approaches adopted (focusing on theory rather than practice), a shortage of
suitably skilled staff (to teach courses such as Audio Production or to handle equipment such as
cameras) and a lack of equipment.
The College is encouraged to review, evaluate and develop the practical element in its
curriculum, including supporting students more effectively in contacting employers for
internships (at present the ITP states that this responsibility is the student) and by providing more
systematic training and debriefing. The Career Guidance Centre may be an avenue to provide this
training in the future, and the College’s location in Muscat, near key media employers, may be
leveraged to facilitate wider availability of placements and internships.
Recommendation 15
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College maximize placement opportunities for students to gain practical
training experience and improve students’ learning experience.
2.8 Assessment Methods, Standards and Moderation
The College states that it uses a range of assessment methods including written assignments,
group presentations, class participation, attendance, homework and exams (Portfolio, p.34). BC
aims to moderate all assessment, based on its moderation policy. This policy sets out the
College’s expectations that assessments will be learning outcome based, valid and reliable. The
policy includes procedures and specifications for pre-exam moderation of content and format, as
well as measures such as double marking to support reliability in certain circumstances (Portfolio,
p.35). Post-exam moderation is outlined, involving review of overall grade patterns as well as of
sample individual papers (Portfolio, p.35).
The Panel considered evidence of pre-exam moderation in terms of validity and fairness of the
exam questions. However, there was no evidence of systematic moderation during or post-
assessment for non-exam assessment elements; and evidence of post-assessment moderation in
general was lacking. In order to monitor and maintain the standard of academic work and to
“know that students have learned what we teach them” (Portfolio, p.34), the College is urged to
ensure that the assessment tasks are of a consistent and appropriate level, and review the level of
students’ responses to these tasks. The College’s existing moderation policy could be more
systematically implemented in terms of second marking and providing evidence of moderation in
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 23 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
course files. In addition, the College is encouraged to consider monitoring the trends in student
performance over different semesters, and benchmarking this work against external standards, for
example involving expertise from the College’s affiliate, PUC, or other external input.
Recommendation 16
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College ensure that its moderation policy is implemented and that there are
mechanisms in place to assure academic standards, such as through external
review from its affiliate.
2.9 Academic Security and Invigilation
The College aims for a clear well-conducted final exam process, with instructions circulated to
staff and students; and exams prepared in good time and kept securely at all times (Portfolio,
p.36). Invigilation procedures are included in exam instructions and are kept as secure as
possible, including checking of students’ identity and a process for recording incidents. During
the audit visit, the Panel found that staff members were well-informed of security and invigilation
procedures. The College is encouraged to monitor the implementation of its policy of employing
students on campus in order to ensure that it does not compromise the security of academic
information such as student records or exams.
2.10 Student Retention and Progression
The College emphasizes the importance of student retention and progression in relation to its
Mission, Vision and Strategic Plan (Portfolio, p.37), and aims in its Strategic Plan to improve
retention of students. Students with a GPA of less than 2.0 are placed on probation, and academic
advisors aim to inform and facilitate students’ academic decisions and progress. The number of
students on probation has decreased over the last two years, and the College has recently
proposed a Success Program for at-risk students, comprising special tutoring and study skills
training in addition to an active advisor role (see Section 6.5).
2.11 Graduate Destinations and Employability
The College expresses its commitment to preparing students for the labour market (Portfolio,
p.38). Teachers are advised to run extracurricular activities to promote this aim, and the newly
established Careers Guidance Centre and Alumni Association are intended to facilitate it. The
College is also trying to develop relationships with employers to facilitate placement of students
and graduates. The Panel considered evidence that indicated that approximately 40% of BC’s
graduates are now in employment. The College is urged to develop and implement a formal
mechanism to seek feedback from employers on the performance of its graduates (see Section
5.2).
During the audit visit, the Panel found that some existing relationships between the College and
employers have the potential for enhancing the employability of graduates. Despite this, there is
no system in place for exploiting this potential and the Panel found that the onus is on students to
approach employers directly for employment opportunities. The development of the practical
elements of the College curriculum (see Recommendation 13) may contribute to the
employability of future graduates. The College is encouraged to formalise its relationships with
employers (see Recommendation 22).
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 24 of 48
3 STUDE�T LEAR�I�G BY RESEARCH PROGRAMS
At the time of the quality audit, Bayan College did not offer any research programs per se so this
section is not addressed in this Report.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 25 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
4 STAFF RESEARCH A�D CO�SULTA�CY
Bayan College, though not required by OAAA’s Requirements of Oman’s System of Quality
Assurance (ROSQA) to carry out research activity, recognizes the connection between research
and teaching as well as academic excellence. The College's Strategic Plan, under Strategic Goal 2
(Work for academic excellence), Objective 2.3 states "develop research and consultancy
activities”, and under this objective, Strategy 2.3.1 calls upon the College to "encourage research
in fields related to college interests”.
The BC Annual Report for 2010-2011 states:
As it is believed that research and teaching are strongly woven to produce high
quality programs, the college is focusing attention on the area of research and
consultancy. Research usually strengthens the programs, provides resources to
support students, and improves the effectiveness of teaching. (Annual Report,
p.3)
Despite BC’s claims in its Annual Report, the Panel found no evidence of widespread research
activity or research production at the College. The Panel noted that the faculty members have a
teaching load of 18 to 23 teaching hours per week while also being responsible for many other
activities, including membership of multiple committees, in addition to their daily preparation for
classes (Portfolio, p.63). Therefore, the amount of time that could be devoted to research and
scholarly activities is minimal. Only a couple of faculty members engage in research based on
their own personal initiative. The Panel heard about plans to host an international conference on
digital media and society, but these did not materialize due to funding restrictions.
The fact that the College's ties with other higher education institutions and professional bodies are
limited further jeopardizes opportunities for collaborative research with external academics. The
inadequacy of the Library which does not carry journals that could support research and is under-
stocked in terms of books and references, is an additional impediment to the achievement of
Objective 2.3 in the Strategic Plan. Since the College has explicitly stated a research objective in
its Strategic Plan, the Panel urges the College to develop related initiatives and policies to achieve
this objective and promote research activities by staff which can be used to support teaching and
learning.
Recommendation 17
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College review its strategic approach to developing its research profile either
through reconsidering the appropriateness of having a research objective at
this stage in the College’s development or through the development and
implementation of related plans and policies to support the achievement of
this objective.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 26 of 48
5 I�DUSTRY A�D COMMU�ITY E�GAGEME�T
The importance placed on industry and community engagement at Bayan College (BC) emanates
from its Vision to "cultivate students who are renowned for their ability to think, achieve and
excel, thereby contribute [sic] to the development of human resources in the region" (Portfolio,
p.40).
This Chapter reports on the Panel’s findings in relation to BC’s planning and management of its
engagement with industry and the community; and comments specifically on the College’s
relationships with industry and employers, the professions, other education providers, alumni and
the community at large.
5.1 Industry and Community Engagement Planning & Management
Strategic Goal 3 of the College's Strategic Plan calls for strengthening of partnerships with the
community. BC states that the College Council (CC) and all College departments and units are
engaged in planning and managing this very important activity (Portfolio, p.40). It adds that the
CC suggests plans "to develop partnerships with public and private sectors, develop student
career skills, develop communication with outside stakeholders and higher education provider
[sic]" (Portfolio, p.40), and that it is the responsibility of departments and units to translate the
plans into action. While the Panel concurs that it is important everyone in the College
understands the importance of taking part in industry and community outreach, it believes the
College’s efforts in this area need to be more systematically planned and coordinated. The Panel
found some evidence of community involvement, especially by Media Department staff
members, but the objectives for such activities were not clearly stated nor what has or has not
been achieved. The activities mainly involve inviting guest lecturers or reporters, going on field
trips and taking part in various community-based activities. Moreover, it is the teachers who are
asked to monitor events that take place in Muscat and to integrate these in their teaching plans at
the beginning of every semester. There is no overall plan for such activities. Inadequate planning
and coordination can limit the value and achievement of these activities.
There is also little evidence of how industry and community stakeholders are recognized in
appreciation for their services to the College. This is important to ensure continuity of their
collaboration with the College. Although there is evidence that some feedback is sought from
stakeholders on some of the training sessions provided by the College, there is little evidence that
this is done consistently and systematically. Hence, the College’s statement "feedback is regularly
collected from different stakeholders to assess how well our services are received" (Portfolio,
p.40) could not be verified. In addition, little evidence exists to show that industry and
community stakeholders play a role in informing or improving the curriculum (see Section 2.2).
The Career Guidance Centre and the Alumni Association are given the task of bridging the gap
between the College graduates and industry in general. While the Panel found that the two
entities have involved students and graduates in some events, workshops and activities, these are
limited. In addition, these activities, again, lack effective planning and coordination. The
Marketing and Public Relations Department, while involved in touring schools, ministries and
other agencies, does this without clear plans and objectives.
Recommendation 18
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement a strategy for effectively coordinating,
expanding and managing industry and community engagement, which
includes relevant key performance indicators to measure its success.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 27 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
5.2 Relationships with Industry and Employers
BC states that it aims to identify the skills most required by the industry and employers and there
is a realization that the College's relationship with industry and employers needs to be developed
and enhanced to offer "real world experience" to students (Portfolio, p.40). This view is
supported by key external stakeholders and stated in the Strategic Plan as Objective 3.2 Develop
Communication with Outside Stakeholders. The College states that the Board of Trustees (BoT)
is carefully chosen to enhance this relationship (Portfolio, p.39); however, the Panel found no
evidence that this Board is functioning at the time of the audit (see Recommendation 2). Hence,
the role of the BoT in supporting the interface with industry, employers and the general public
was not evident during the audit.
The Panel noted the College's efforts in inviting speakers and trainers from the industry and its
participation in some exhibitions and fairs, but it was not evident to the Panel that these are well-
planned and coordinated efforts due to the absence of a body responsible for such activities. The
College's relationship with industry and employers remains limited and in need of expansion with
proactive, effective planning and coordination (see Recommendation 18).
While the College has developed an employer survey to seek feedback on its graduates, the Panel
noted that this survey had been primarily used to evaluate students who were placed in
internships. The Panel found no evidence of a mechanism in place to evaluate BC’s relationship
with employers or industry, despite the specialized nature of the courses offered at the College.
This is, once again, a reflection of the need for proactive and reflective system of continuous
quality improvement by ensuring that data and feedback are collected, analysed and used to make
enhancements at the College (see Recommendation 9), including the curriculum (see
Recommendation 11). The need to formalise relationships with employers is addressed in
Recommendation 22.
5.3 Relationships with Professions
While the College states that it understands the value of having a connection with professional
bodies (Portfolio, p.42), it currently does not have relationships with any of them. One of the
strategies in the Strategic Plan involves developing relations with higher education providers and
bodies. The Research and Studies Committee is given the task to establish these relationships, but
the Panel found no evidence that this committee has taken any steps in this matter. Considering
the media programs offered by BC, the Panel believes that relationships with professional bodies,
such as the Oman Journalists Association, are important and needs to be pursued.
5.4 Relationships with Other Education Providers
Bayan College's relationships with other education providers are quite limited. The College
mentions (Portfolio, p.42) relationships with Mazoon College (which had previously been based
on its holding 25% of the College's shares), Purdue University Calumet and AMIDEAST. The
College states that "[it] explores the possibilities for further coordination and collaboration with
other higher education providers within and outside the Sultanate" (Portfolio, p.43). There is no
evidence that there is a plan in place to pursue and manage relationships with higher education
providers inside or outside Oman.
5.5 Relationships with Alumni
BC realizes that its graduates "are the college's ambassadors to the society" (Portfolio, p.43) and
is keen to develop links with its alumni. Hence, it has established an Alumni Association which
aims to link the College with its graduates and to help them find employment. The Association
has taken initial steps to make contact with graduates and involve them in College events. There
is also an Alumni page on the BC website. While the Panel notes these activities, there is no
evidence that they are planned, coordinated or supported by relevant documents. The College
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 28 of 48
mentions a graduate survey (Portfolio, p.43) that is "regularly conducted to assess relations with
them and also to further develop services provided to these graduates". The Panel found no
evidence to support the claim of "regular" data collection from alumni. BC acknowledges that
alumni activities “have to be more organized and documented” (Portfolio, p.43) and the Panel
urges the College to take practical steps in this regard.
5.6 Relationships with the Community at Large
BC's 2010-2011 Annual Report states that "The College is seeking a better and more organized
form of community service through well-planned activities aimed at providing the community
with productive services" (Annual Report, p.3). One of the strengths that the College has
identified in its Strategic Plan SWOT analysis is “social responsibility and service to the
community”. While the Panel noted that the College invited a number of guest speakers from the
community to speak about such important topics as traffic safety and drug awareness, organized
blood donation campaigns, and offered a few training courses to the community, the opportunities
for engagement with the community at large on a broader scale are limited. In addition, the Panel
found no evidence that the services offered by the College to the community were planned and
managed systematically.
While the College mentions that it has "kept strong ties with several non-government
organisations (NGOs) like Omani Women Association" (Portfolio, p.43), Tawasal, Dar al-Atta
and Rakaz, there is no evidence that these ties serve any objectives related to the curriculum
offered or the broader objectives of engaging with the community. It was not clear to the Panel
what skills the students practice and how they benefited from their participation in the activities
organized by those NGOs. The College's plan to link graduation with community service
(Portfolio, p.44) has not yet been realized and the Panel encourages the College to pursue this
initiative as it develops plans in this area (see Recommendation 18).
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 29 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
6 ACADEMIC SUPPORT SERVICES
Academic support services are intended to provide “academic support, special advising and
related services to all students enrolled in the College” (Portfolio, p.45). These services are
provided at BC by a number of different departments and committees.
This Chapter reports on the Panel’s findings on BC’s academic support services overall and on
the following specific areas: planning and management of academic support services; the
registry; the Library; information and learning technology services; academic advising; student
learning support; and teaching resources.
6.1 Academic Support Services Planning & Management
Academic support services are provided by the Admission and Registration Department (ARD),
the Learning Resource Department (LRD), the Career Guidance Centre (CGC), the Student
Affairs Department (SAD) and Academic Advising Committee (AAC). According to the College,
“coordination and cooperation are constantly enhanced among departments and units involved in
the academic support services to achieve better consistency” (Portfolio, p.46).
The College’s 2011-2015 Strategic Plan includes an objective related to providing a student-
centred learning environment and associated strategies for achieving this, such as periodically
evaluating the quality of services provided to students and benchmarking these locally and
internationally in order to ensure that all services meet the needs of students. This objective is
reiterated in the College’s 2010-2011 Operational Plan. The Panel also reviewed the operational
plans for the Language Resources Centre (LRC) and the ARD, which restate the objective and
strategies from the Strategic Plan, but do not contain any specific information about the
achievement of these.
Although the College states that it “continuously upgrades and develops its academic services
provided to the students depending on the feedback from them” (Portfolio, p.46), the Panel did
not find evidence that this was being carried out using a planned, systematic approach. While a
survey has been used to collect satisfaction data, the data has not been used to review and
enhance the provision of academic support services or to systematically inform planning in this
area (see Recommendation 21). Action in this regard is by individual departments on a day-to-
day basis and largely reactive without co-ordination and collaboration. The results of this ad hoc
approach are evident in the levels of satisfaction heard by the Panel in interviews and reported by
the College (Portfolio, p.47). The Panel urges BC to adopt a coordinated, proactive and long
term planned approach to the provision of academic support services (see Recommendation 5).
6.2 Registry (Enrolment and Student Records)
The College reports that ARD works with faculty and other academic administrators on
developing, explaining and enforcing academic polices (Portfolio, p.47). ARD is responsible for
students’ records, enrollment and registration, progression data, student transcripts and
graduation. There is an online registration system, which is not currently available for academic
advising purposes (Portfolio, p.47). Academic advisors must approach ARD staff in order to
access students’ records.
Student satisfaction with ARD services is low (Portfolio, p.48), with only 30% of students
reporting that they are satisfied or very satisfied with the ease of registration processes. This
result is a reflection of the lack of coordinated planning in the provision of ARD services. Despite
claims that the ARD functions effectively (Portfolio, p.47), there was no evidence forthcoming to
substantiate this and the Panel found that the department carries out day-to-day operations in a
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 30 of 48
reactive manner. There was no support provided in the form of a comprehensive plan for
managing and monitoring goals and related processes, policies and activities. Furthermore, while
the Panel heard that student data is stored using password protected software and access is limited
to ARD staff.
The College states that it seeks to “improve [ARD] services through developing its registry
system” (Portfolio, p.48). To this end, the College signed an agreement with a software
development company to build a system that would “automate the College’s internal work of the
registration and financial department” (Portfolio, p.21 and p.47). This agreement includes a back-
up plan for securing admission and registration data. At the time of the audit visit, the system had
not been implemented and it was learned that the original agreement had been superseded by a
new one with a different company. However, the Panel is pleased to see concrete efforts being
taken to make improvements in this area.
Affirmation 1
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority agrees that Bayan College
needs improve its registry services and supports its effort to do this through
the development and deployment of an integrated student registration
system.
6.3 Library
According to the College (Portfolio, p.49), the Library has a policy covering its activities, and
caters to the needs of the students with a diverse collection of books. The Library Policy viewed
by the Panel consisted of the library rules and regulations. The PUC report from 2011 indicates
that the Library is “inadequate and requires urgent attention” and that “funds must be found for
major investment”. This view is also supported in a report by the Ministry of Higher Education
(MoHE) for the academic year 2011/2012 which states that the Library does not offer sufficient
books to students and that students rely on Wikipedia as a resource. The Panel also heard that
books for the Library are mainly sourced from book fairs and that students are expected to
recommend books for the Library to purchase. All acquisitions have to be approved by the Dean.
The LRC plan considered by the Panel did not contain specific goals, related strategies or KPIs to
develop the Library facilities. Furthermore, the agreement with PUC stipulates that the Library is
one of the areas in which PUC faculty and staff will offer their services to BC but this has not
been implemented. The Panel found no evidence of a connection or interaction between the BC
and PUC libraries.
During the audit visit, the Panel found the Library space to be small and not located in an easily
accessible area of the campus conducive to frequent use. The provision of books is very limited
and the Panel heard from students that it did not meet their needs and requirements. There is also
a lack of online journals and databases. None of the staff employed at the Library have formal
qualifications in Library Sciences, nor do they receive any professional development. BC states
in its Portfolio that “library services are always under development, responding to remarks from
students” (p.46). Indeed, the Panel confirmed that the satisfaction levels with the Library amongst
the students are low (Portfolio, p.73). There was no evidence of any improvements in response to
these low ratings and the College’s claim that the Library is “well managed” (Portfolio, p.49)
could not be verified by the Panel in the absence of a proper plan, and related policies and
procedures to support the development of the Library.
Recommendation 19
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College improve and upgrade the Library provision as a matter of priority
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 31 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
to ensure that it meets the needs of the students, and staff and supports the
academic programs.
6.4 Information and Learning Technology Services
The College claims that the LRD “provides students and staff with all the necessary IT services
and resources that facilitates [sic] the teaching and learning process” (Portfolio, p.49). These
services are outlined by the Strategic Plan - Strategy 1.2.2 “Modern technology to facilitate
student learning” and supported by an LRD plan, which is limited in scope and content. The
Panel heard that staff members inform the IT staff about their software needs before classes begin
and the IT staff do their best to make these available.
There are three labs at the College and all staff members have access to a computer. During the
audit visit, the Panel found that the computer labs are often fully booked for classes, rendering
them almost inaccessible to students for general study purposes. Feedback on student satisfaction
data indicated that nearly a third of students considered "access to computer labs" to be poor
(Portfolio, p.73). Students expressed dissatisfaction with the speed of the network and internet
access, as well as the maintenance of computers and printers. Survey results presented by the
College indicated that nearly 40% of students found email and internet provision either poor or
very poor; nearly 40% of students found that access to IT facilities to be poor or very poor
(Portfolio, p.50). The College states that it has a “well-managed backup system of all records”
and a “five level back up plan” (Portfolio, p.50). The Panel did not find evidence of such a plan.
Back-ups are stored on a portable hard disk and on two PCs. The Panel is concerned by the lack
of a robust back-up plan and system at the College, including off-site storage. Despite claims that
“computer services was [...] being developed” (Portfolio, p.46), the IT facilities at the College
require proper planning and management, supported by appropriate polices, tools and documents.
Recommendation 20
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College review its current IT provision to ensure that it fully supports the
student learning environment and implements a robust IT back-up system.
6.5 Academic Advising
According to the College, “academic advising at BC aspires to be a dynamic network that leads
the college in high quality teaching and learning experience and collaborative commitment to
student success” (Portfolio, p.51). There is an Academic Advising Committee and policy, which
spells out the responsibilities of advisors and students. “Strengthening academic advising” is
listed as a strategy in BC’s Strategic Plan.
When they join BC, students are initially advised by the ARD or the Head of Department (HoD)
of the Foundation Program in their first semester. At the end of the first semester, they are
assigned to an academic advisor, who is also a faculty member. The Panel found that each faculty
member usually has between 20 and 35 students to advise. Students are required to meet their
academic advisor before registering for courses, and at least once each semester. The College also
holds an Academic Advising Day each semester. Although current faculty members received
some guidance in relation to the academic advising process during an Advising Day held in
October 2012, the Panel found no evidence of a regular formal training program in place or a
mechanism for monitoring of the effectiveness of training in this area. According to the College,
special attention is paid to “at risk students” and a proposal for a “Success Program” for these
students has been put forward by the College (Portfolio, p.52) but it had not yet been
implemented at the time of the audit visit.
Student satisfaction with the academic advising system is generally good. This is supported by
the results of student surveys (Portfolio, p.52) and interviews with students during the audit visit.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 32 of 48
However, no formal reviews of academic advising have been carried out by the College to
determine its effectiveness and success with student retention and “at-risk students”.
6.6 Student Learning Support
BC indicates that it is “keen on the advancement of student learning” (Portfolio, p.52) and
believes that it achieves this through the provision of orientation, office hours, reviewing learning
resources, and other activities. Although the College indicates that it has held a number of
workshops (Portfolio, p.53), none of these relate to learning support. It was not clear to the Panel
who is responsible for the planning and provision of learning support services or how these are
consistently provided to students who require assistance with their learning. The Panel believes
that this needs to be addressed and resourced appropriately, in line with other academic support
services (see Recommendation 19).
6.7 Teaching Resources
BC states that it has various teaching resources for “efficient and effective learning and teaching”,
including specialized media studios and equipment, multimedia and English labs, as well as
general teaching resources in classrooms (Portfolio, p.53). The Panel reviewed the media studios
and equipment and heard that while specialized resources were available to staff and students,
they were considered to be insufficient and inadequate to meet their needs. The Panel was
informed that on some occasions, students and staff brought their own equipment (such as
cameras) as it was better suited to their purposes than the equipment provided at the College.
General teaching equipment and resources (such as whiteboards and overhead projectors) are
readily available to staff. The College states that it plans to introduce e-learning (Portfolio, p.53)
and the Panel supports this plan, provided that appropriate actions are taken to upgrade the
relevant IT equipment and services (see Recommendation 20) and develop an appropriate e-
learning pedagogical framework. The Panel found no formal evaluation of the adequacy of
teaching resources and students’ satisfaction with them. This is an area that needs to be addressed
(see Recommendation 21).
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 33 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
7 STUDE�TS A�D STUDE�T SUPPORT SERVICES
Student support services are under the remit of the Admission and Registration Department
(ARD), the Career Guidance Centre (CGC) and the Student Affairs Department (SAD) at Bayan
College (BC), in addition to individual departments.
This Chapter reports on the general planning and management of student support services at BC
and specifically comments on the following: student profile; student satisfaction and climate;
student behaviour; career and employment services; student finances; accommodation catering
and transport; medical and counselling facilities; international student services; and social and
recreational services and facilities.
7.1 Students and Student Support Services Planning & Management
The College’s Strategic Plan includes a goal to “support students so that they achieve their
educational goals, plan their careers, and provide leadership to the community”. According to the
College, student input comes from the SAD through the Student Council (Portfolio, p.54). The
Panel heard that the Student Council initiated several activities and events for students, and
received the support of the SAD and the Dean for these.
While a number of activities for students are organized on a regular basis (College Annual
Report), these are not the result of a planned and coordinated approach, nor are they evaluated
and reviewed for the purposes of feedback and improvement. The Panel also found that
participation in the activities was sporadic and at times, low. As BC develops and grows, this area
needs to be considered. The development of an operational plan for student support services,
based on long term strategic goals, is necessary to ensure that students’ needs are met (see
Recommendation 5).
7.2 Student Profile
Information about students is maintained by the ARD and it is used by the College for planning
purposes (Portfolio, p.54) although the Panel did not find any formal planning processes in place
to support this claim. Being the first private college in Oman to offer media programs, Bayan
College aims to attract students who intend to pursue careers in journalism, Public Relations (PR)
and Broadcasting, amongst others. The College had 346 students as of September 2011
(Portfolio, p.54), with this number increasing to about 400 in September 2012, according to
interviews conducted by the Panel. Almost 40% of the students are in the Foundation Program.
Of the remaining 60%, the majority of students (almost 40%) are studying PR and Broadcasting,
with only small numbers (less than 5%) enrolled in Journalism. Enrollments at the College are
relatively small reflecting its specialised programs and the fact it was recently established in
2006. Due to the low enrollment in Advertising and Professional Writing programs, the Panel
was informed that BC is planning to merge PR and Advertising into a Business Communication
degree and replace Professional Writing with a Translation course. These proposals were with
MoHE awaiting approval at the time of the audit.
The majority of students at the College are female (more than 75%) which has been taken into
account in allocating campus facilities and resources (for example, providing more female
restrooms). The Panel encourages the College to conduct a more detailed and in depth analysis of
its student profile and related needs, which would be helpful in enrollment management, the
provision of better support for students, and evaluating student support services.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 34 of 48
7.3 Student Satisfaction and Climate
The College claims to be “pro-active” in the area of student satisfaction by using a number of
approaches, including surveys, a suggestion box, and direct interaction with academic advisors,
HoDs and the Dean in order to “disseminate culture of constructive criticism” (Portfolio, p.56).
The Panel viewed several surveys related to student and graduates’ satisfaction and data from
these were reported throughout the Portfolio. However, most of the data on student satisfaction
was from the academic year 2010/2011, while other data from previous years and the most recent
one (2011/2012) were not available. This suggests that students are not surveyed on a regular
basis and there are no longitudinal data available to support planning and improvements to
quality. Furthermore, there is no formal process in place which is used to administer surveys and
analyse the data collected so that it can be used in planning and monitoring.
Staff members are informed by e-mail when data are available in a shared folder and asked to
review it. No systematic follow up is carried out afterwards to ensure that the data collected is
used to make changes and students are not informed about the actions taken. During interviews,
the Panel found that the level of awareness amongst staff members about student satisfaction
surveys and data was low, and that they relied mainly on verbal complaints to address issues.
Although students reported that staff members were approachable and willing to help, the lack of
formal mechanisms to measure students’ satisfaction and climate is an area of concern that
requires urgent attention.
Recommendation 21
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement a system to regularly collect and monitor
student satisfaction with services; analyse results and develop action plans to
deal with issues raised; and inform students of changes made in response to
their feedback.
7.4 Student Behaviour
The College states that it has a Code of Conduct which is in line with MoHE requirements and
that it is communicated to students using a range of channels, including the Student Handbook,
orientation, and in meetings with academic advisors (Portfolio, p.57). The Student Handbook
contains brief information about the expected behavior of students, while the Academic Affairs
Policy document from 2006 has more detailed information about the expected social conduct of
students. The Panel also considered documents showing how disciplinary cases are handled at the
College. This is the remit of the Disciplinary Committee which dealt with 13 cases in 2011/2012
(Portfolio, p.58). The Disciplinary Committee is also responsible for reviewing the Student Code
of Conduct, but the Panel found no evidence of this taking place. The College states that it
should conduct surveys to determine the levels of awareness amongst students about the rules and
regulations (Portfolio, p.57). The Panel shares this view and also encourages the College to
extend this further to include a review of the Code of Conduct, as required.
7.5 Career and Employment Services
There is a Career Guidance Centre (CGC) at the College which was recently established with the
aim to “maximise the employment opportunities available to BC’s graduates” (Portfolio, p.58).
The CGC is supported by a policy which outlines its role and responsibilities. The responsibility
for alumni also lies with the CGC (Portfolio, p.32). The CGC is staffed by an acting head who
has multiple roles at the College, including quality assurance and teaching responsibilities. The
CGC has held some workshops for students on an ad hoc basis and students are also “exposed to
career advice in general as part of their classroom lectures” (Portfolio, p.58). The Panel viewed
evidence that showed 40% of students were now in employment.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 35 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
The exact role of the CGC in supporting students with internship and work placement
opportunities is unclear (see Section 2.7). In addition, due to the limited industry engagement
initiatives by the College (see Recommendation 18), students do not have sufficient access or
exposure to prospective employers, in spite of the College’s location near media employers in
Muscat.
Setting up the CGC is an important step in developing graduates’ employability skills and career
prospects; however, significant additional steps are required to develop a planned approach to
employer engagement in order to maximize career opportunities, and to create a comprehensive
training program that will provide students with the right skills to secure jobs.
Recommendation 22
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College actively engage with employers to maximize opportunities for
employment and formally provide students with relevant job search skills.
7.6 Student Finances
BC has a scheme in place for providing financial assistance to students (Portfolio, p.58). The
Panel viewed requests by students to the Dean for financial assistance, based on academic
performance. The College stated that 40% of the students at the College received some form of
financial assistance in 2011/2012 (Portfolio, p.59). This is in addition to scholarships given to
students directly by the MoHE. Scholarships were also offered to students via letters sent by BC
to embassies and other external entities (Portfolio, p.59), although these are not part of a regular
formal scholarship program at the College, but ad hoc initiatives to attract students.
The Panel did not explore this area in detail, but nevertheless appreciates the College’s intent to
expand support for students with financial difficulties through means including the establishment
of a student aid fund for needy students, additional scholarship sponsors for outstanding students
and the provision of paid work placement opportunities for low income students (Portfolio, p.58).
7.7 Accommodation, Catering and Transport
The College maintains two hostels: one for male and one for female students (Portfolio, p.59).
The former is managed by BC, while the management of the latter has been outsourced to a
private company. Transport is provided between the hostels and the College. There is a cafeteria
on campus, privately owned and managed, but a Cafeteria Committee set up by BC acts as a
liaison between the College and the cafeteria management.
The Panel heard that the female hostels are inadequate due to overcrowding, lack of facilities,
supervision and poor maintenance. This needs to be looked into by the College. Satisfaction with
the cafeteria is also low, with more than a third of students dissatisfied with the services
(Portfolio, p.59 and p.73). The Panel urges the College to review the catering services provided
on campus to improve student satisfaction (see Recommendation 21).
7.8 Medical and Counselling Facilities
BC does not provide on campus medical or counselling facilities, although first aid kits are
available and local clinics/hospitals are in close proximity to the College (Portfolio, p.60).
Counselling is provided to students on an informal basis by teachers and academic advisors but
this is of concern since there is no proper training provided to staff members to develop
counselling skills. The College states that it is considering providing First Aid training to students
and staff (Portfolio, p.60) and the Panel supports this initiative, and urges BC to also look into
ways in which it can provide professional counselling support and services to students.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 36 of 48
7.9 International Student Services
BC has only 14 international students representing 4% of the total student population (Portfolio,
p.60). There are no special services provided to these students since they are all from expatriate
families based in Oman. The students have opportunities to engage in cultural activities during
Open Day celebrations at the campus. Should BC pursue a strategy to attract more students from
outside Oman in the future, this area will need to be developed.
7.10 Social and Recreational Services and Facilities
The SAD is responsible for providing social and recreational facilities on campus, together with
the Student Council (Portfolio, p.60). A number of ad hoc activities have been organised for
students according to the Annual Report, including field trips and events such as National Day
celebrations. However, there is limited space on the current campus to offer a full range of social
and recreational activities. The Panel heard that additional activities are needed, especially those
that are relevant to the programs offered at BC. The Panel believes that BC could benefit from
gathering students’ feedback about the social and recreational activities which enable the College
to plan the provision of these services accordingly (see Recommendation 5).
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 37 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
8 STAFF A�D STAFF SUPPORT SERVICES
Human Resources Department (HR) is part of the Finance and Administration Department at
Bayan College (BC). The function is performed by the HR Officer mainly consists of staff
recruitment.
This Chapter considers the planning and management of HR at BC and reports on the Panel’s
findings in areas such as: HR planning; staff profiles; recruitment and selection; induction;
professional development and training; performance planning and review; promotion and other
incentives; staff organizational climate and retention; severance and Omanisation.
8.1 Human Resources Planning & Management
One of the College’s strategic goals is to “Recruit and retain competent faculty and staff”, which
is the responsibility of the HR Department (Portfolio, p.61). The College has a staff recruitment
policy, Personal [sic] Policy, which aims to attract “the best available talent”, and gives
“preference for employment to suitably qualified Omanis” (Strategic Plan 2011-2015). The
policy itself is a comprehensive staff manual which includes all the information an employee
requires. The sections include such matters as recruitment, employment contract, code of
conduct, salaries and benefits, working hours, leave, performance appraisal and complaints
handling. This policy document provides a sound basis for staff management but this has not
been used effectively. The teaching staff requirements are identified by the Heads of Department
(HoDs) and are linked to student demand and course offerings. This is frequently just in time for
the semester commencement and there is no formal long term needs analysis.
Whilst BC has made strong efforts to find suitably qualified teaching staff, it states that the low
retention rate has “not affected the functioning of the College” (Portfolio, p.68). However, at the
time of the audit, the Panel was informed that the HoD of Media Department, who also teaches
courses, was leaving BC. This will result in a new staff member needing to be recruited mid-
semester. The Panel was informed that there have been cases where courses have been cancelled
with students directed to take an “equivalent” course if a suitable replacement could not be found.
This is of concern as it may have a negative impact on the ability of students to complete a major
satisfactorily, as well as affect the teaching quality and continuity of the courses (see Section 2.5).
There has been some attempt to identify the reasons for the loss of staff, and these have been
identified as including external factors such as competition from other institutions in Oman and
internally, low salary levels, heavy workloads, including committee commitments, and lack of
opportunity to engage in research. As part of an HR strategy, the College needs to find ways to
address these reasons and take steps to ensure the long term stability of staffing through effective
HR planning and management, which has not been achieved as yet. Furthermore, since the Dean
has a key role in almost all of the College’s activities, it is important that attention be given to
succession planning as a means of risk mitigation.
Recommendation 23
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College adopt a comprehensive, fully-resourced, long term approach to the
planning, recruitment and retention of staff.
8.2 Staff Profile
The College reported that there are 13 academic staff and 17 administrative staff members
(Portfolio, p.62). However, in the updated list of staff which includes appointment dates, the
ongoing staff members include just 10 academic staff and 12 administrative staff. An analysis of
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 38 of 48
the length of time each former staff member spent at BC reveals that 45% served one year or less,
further demonstrating the problem of staff retention. The majority worked at BC for between one
and a half and two years. Of the ongoing staff, the longest serving member has been at BC for six
years, the next longest is four years. Whilst this is of concern to the Panel, it is worth mentioning
that the majority of the ongoing staff members were appointed in 2010 or 2011 following BC’s
comprehensive review in 2010 (see Section 1.1).
The College states that BC employs a number of teaching staff who are well-qualified to teach at
Foundation and Bachelor level, but that it has proven difficult to find suitably qualified Omanis
(Portfolio, p.62). While there is a good balance of male and female staff across the staff profile in
general, the majority of senior personnel are male. There are four faculty members with doctoral
qualifications and the teaching experience of the faculty members ranges from five years to 34
years. The Panel was informed that some staff may be teaching in areas in which they are not
expert, which, along with issues of staff retention, may further affect the quality of teaching at the
College.
8.3 Recruitment and Selection
The recruitment and selection process is managed by the HR Department (Portfolio, p.64) and is
guided by the Personal [sic] Policy (see Section 8.1). The College states that attention is given to
ensuring appropriate personnel approvals, including those by the Ministry of Higher Education
(Portfolio, p.64). The Panel found that the HR Department is very small and has a role limited to
placing the advertisements for staff. BC also maintains a CV database to assist with filling
vacancies and the Panel heard that this is often required when staff leave mid-semester.
According to the terms of the Purdue University Calumet (PUC) Affiliation Agreement, PUC will
provide criteria for the recruitment of staff, but ultimately it is the responsibility of the College to
find suitable faculty. The Panel found no monitoring system in place to ensure that qualified and
experienced faculty members are recruited for teaching positions.
The inability to identify and appoint appropriate staff is a concern which BC has identified and
which the Panel confirmed during interviews. The Strategic Plan refers to “instability due to
financial difficulties and vagueness of recruitment policy” (p.6) as a weakness. Subsequently,
developing “an effective plan for recruitment” has been identified as a strategy in the Strategic
Plan. Based on the evidence viewed, the Panel did not find that the College had “well designed
procedures…in place for recruitment” (Portfolio, p.61). This opportunity for improvement needs
to be addressed as a matter of urgency by developing and implementing the recruitment plan,
especially in light of the high staff turnover at the College (see Recommendation 23).
8.4 Induction
The College states that appropriate induction is required in order to ensure that staff members are
acquainted with expectations of their performance at BC (Portfolio, p.65). All staff members
receive formal and informal induction (Portfolio, p.65). The Employee Handbook includes
information such as BC expectations of staff, information on working in Oman and at BC,
including values, a code of conduct, employment conditions, college structure and committees.
Staff members reported to the Panel that they were given adequate induction, both through a
personal welcome from the Dean and a more specific induction from the HoD. Information is
also provided via the College’s website. BC encourages a friendly atmosphere (Portfolio, p.65)
and much informal assistance is available from peers. New staff members are also given a copy
of the Student Handbook. There is continuous attention to communication and responsiveness.
The Course and Semester Files are made available to teaching staff, and these provide
information required for delivery, such as course outlines, teaching materials, sample assignments
and assessment details (see Section 2.2). Although BC has conducted an employee satisfaction
survey, there are no questions about staff induction. However, 75% agreed or strongly agreed
with the survey item (4) “I am kept well informed of matters relevant to faculty/staff.”
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 39 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
Staff induction at the College appears to be working well due to the small size of the College,
enabling new staff members to integrate quickly and easily, with support from their peers and the
College management. Despite this, a more formal process for providing, monitoring and
reviewing staff induction would be appropriate in order to ensure its continued success.
8.5 Professional Development
BC has identified the importance of professional development in the Strategic Plan, including the
need for a plan and allocation of a budget. There is no target or time frame indicated and this goal
has not been achieved. Although the College states that it is committed to providing professional
development, the actual number of opportunities for staff in 2011/2012 is low and provided on an
ad hoc basis, including through learning from others and on the job learning (Portfolio, p.66).
According to the College, only 13 activities were supported by BC (Portfolio, p.67). The Panel
heard that English classes are made available to some administrative staff. The College
acknowledges the need to provide more opportunities for professional development (Portfolio,
p.66), but it will require careful allocation of budget and time release to enable this to occur.
Furthermore, the Panel found no evidence of reviewing of professional development at BC and
for improving professional development opportunities, despite low staff satisfaction in this area
indicated in the staff survey – only 45% of staff said BC supports their career development and
39% said opportunities for advancement are adequate.
In order for the professional development to be of maximum benefit to the College, the students
and staff, opportunities need to be linked to staff performance. This is acknowledged as an area
for improvement (Portfolio, p.67). Provision of professional development opportunities is an
important matter which requires attention. In order to ensure that course content is relevant and
current, and pedagogy is well-informed, teaching staff should have opportunities to maintain
contact with external professional colleagues and current discipline research findings through
meetings and conferences. Similarly, administrative staff members need the chance to meet with
peers from other institutions, to broaden their understandings. This is particularly important in a
small college with a small number of staff in each area.
A good example of the need for professional development is BC’s intention to move to blended
or online learning (Portfolio, p.53). Teaching staff will need to understand instructional design,
the way students learn online and how to manage student expectations. Technical staff members
need to understand the infrastructure required, provision of access and the ongoing support which
will be needed, and Library staff will need to develop and manage online resources to support
learning. The affiliation with PUC may also offer opportunities for two way exchange
arrangements. To ensure well-targeted strategies and relevant professional development, it is also
important to link the opportunities with staff performance management.
Recommendation 24
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College provide systematic professional development opportunities for staff,
linked to enhancing performance.
8.6 Performance Planning and Review
In its Strategic Plan, BC states that it intends to develop an effective performance evaluation
system. The target date was September 2011, but this has not yet been achieved. Staff reported
that they have frequent interaction with their line manager and faculty members have periodic
peer reviews. These reviews consist of two staff members observing a class at a pre-arranged
time, followed by discussion with the staff member and a report to the Dean. However, there was
little evidence of a more formal system of evaluation against an agreed plan and systematic
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 40 of 48
feedback. To be effective, performance planning and review need to be linked to opportunities for
targeted professional development (see Recommendation 24).
The performance management process needs to be more formal than is presently the case at BC.
For example, a performance management system could be developed which requires staff to
reflect on their achievements, challenges and professional development needs. It may also be
helpful to include a formal report to the staff member, clearly stating the outcomes, including
affirmation of good performance. BC has stated that there is a “need to study the possibility of
connecting staff performance with professional development” (Portfolio, p.67). The Panel urges
BC to act on this as a matter of urgency.
Recommendation 25
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement a formal performance management system
for teaching and administrative staff which is linked to professional
development opportunities.
8.7 Promotion and Other Incentives
BC states that “promotions and incentives are clearly stated” and that they are given on the basis
of “quality and period of service” (Portfolio, p.67). The Panel heard that there are small annual
increments paid to all staff, based on their qualification level. This is not linked to performance
and is not seen as promotion. In a survey of staff satisfaction, only 40% of staff said they were
satisfied with their pay (Portfolio, p.67). The Panel confirmed this low satisfaction in interviews
with staff members. In order for a promotion policy to work, staff would need to be at the
College for a longer period of time than is the case at present (see Section 8.2). BC has
acknowledged that it “plans to introduce promotions in order to encourage staff performance”
(Portfolio, p.67). BC is urged to reflect on the overall satisfaction of staff and explore promotion
and other incentives which might assist in a better retention rate.
8.8 Severance
Staff members are appointed initially with a three-month probation period, during which time
their performance is observed. This provides the opportunity for BC to discontinue employment
if performance is not satisfactory. The Panel heard that this policy had been applied in at least
one case. Only 40% of staff members felt that their job was safe (Portfolio, p.68). A number of
staff members have left BC since its inception, but there have been no formal exit interviews to
ascertain reasons for leaving. It is suggested that BC introduce exit interviews as a way of
determining the cause(s) for the high turnover of staff, thus providing a risk mitigation
opportunity.
8.9 Staff Organisational Climate and Retention
According to its Strategic Plan, BC aims to “provide a stimulating work environment for faculty
and staff”. It states that it has consciously worked to develop a collegial and friendly atmosphere
which was reiterated to the Panel in interviews with staff. This was also evident in staff
satisfaction surveys, with 80% of staff stating that they trust people they work with and 75%
saying the environment was cooperative and productive (Portfolio, p.68). Despite these results,
the rate of staff retention at the College is low. Furthermore, some of the survey results were
quite concerning. For example, over 36% of staff would not recommend BC to a friend. The
Panel found no triggers for flagging such a result for remedial action. BC needs to address every
possible reason for staff loss (see also Section 8.1), as staff instability means, not only an
interruption to operations, but also a loss of institutional memory. Staff satisfaction also needs to
be monitored regularly on a range of issues to ensure that any issues are addressed and action is
taken to meet the needs of staff members.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 41 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
Recommendation 26
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College regularly and systematically monitor staff satisfaction; respond to
issues that are identified; and inform staff of changes made in response to
their feedback.
8.10 Omanisation
BC is committed to recruiting Omani staff but this is limited by the availability of suitably
qualified applicants for academic positions (Portfolio, p.69). While more than half of the
administrative staff members are Omanis, only one academic staff member is an Omani national
(Portfolio, p.69). The College attributes the low rate of Omanisation to a lack of Omanis working
in the areas of Media and English literature.
There is clearly an intention to employ more Omani staff but there are no strategies in place to
improve the current situation. The Panel recognises the difficulty in recruiting suitable Omani
academic staff, but the College is urged to continue to explore additional strategies to increase the
proportion of Omani faculty.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 42 of 48
9 GE�ERAL SUPPORT SERVICES A�D FACILITIES
The provision of general support services and facilities is important in order to ensure a suitable
learning environment for students and work environment for staff.
This Chapter reports on the Panel’s findings in relation to general services and facilities planning
and management; public relations and marketing; communications services; and facilities
management.
9.1 General Support Services and Facilities Planning & Management
Bayan College (BC) is committed to the provision of high quality facilities (Strategic Plan,
Objective 6.1) through the provision of an attractive new campus. At present, there is no
dedicated unit responsible for achieving this objective. Instead, the planning and management of
general support services and facilities is carried out by the Human Resources (HR) and Finance
Departments, with support from other departments (Portfolio, p.70).
BC moved from its original site to its present location to “meet the increased number of students
and also to provide a better environment for students and faculty” (Portfolio, p.70). The College
operates from a set of rented residential villas (Portfolio, p.70). This is an interim arrangement, as
BC has plans to build on a new site. Although the Portfolio states that construction is underway,
this was not the case at the time of the audit visit as there have been delays in proceeding with
building plans. This situation has placed restrictions on expenditure on the existing buildings but
BC informed the Panel that it has strived to maintain a range of on-campus services and facilities.
There is little space on campus for recreational activities.
Although a number of those interviewed expressed their desire to move to better facilities, the
Panel was informed that there are adequate classrooms and specialty areas at the present campus
for the current and projected student numbers. The available space is well-used, although some
areas require maintenance and renovation. Given the delays in the completion of the new
campus, the need to continue to maintain the existing buildings and facilities in good order is
essential to the quality of the student and faculty experience. It was also evident to the Panel that
there is no master plan in place for the current and on-going management of general support
services and facilities. The current campus is quite small, and while the provision of general
maintenance and facilities is manageable, it is still done in a reactive manner and requires the co-
ordination of multiple departments. This situation needs to be reviewed, particularly in relation to
the development of the proposed purpose-built campus.
Recommendation 27
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College ensure there is a transition strategy in place to keep the current
buildings and maintenance of facilities fit for purpose while the plans for the
new site are being developed.
9.2 Public Relations and Marketing
BC “feels that its marketing activities are reasonable and effective” (Portfolio, p.71). The Panel
viewed a comprehensive list of marketing and public relations activities which included
marketing and student recruitment initiatives, events to raise the College’s profile in the
community, scholarships and sponsorships, and media coverage. There is a marketing plan
which is written in Arabic and consists of proposed advertising channels and marketing activities.
The Panel saw no clear targets for student intake by numbers, quality or award. Some financial
statements indicate the expenditure on promotional activities.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 43 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
BC has enrolled a modest number of students at present but will need to ensure that the plans and
targets are developed to recruit higher student numbers in order to mitigate financial risk (see
Section 1.7) and achieve the strategic goals of the College.
The Panel also found no evidence of systematic evaluation of its public relations and marketing
efforts and although the College has identified this as an opportunity for improvement, no
tangible steps have been taken as yet. The College would benefit from developing a marketing
plan to include medium and long-term projection, strategies to achieve these and measures to
gauge success. These projections should include overall targets, and targets for specific programs.
Recommendation 28
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority recommends that Bayan
College develop and implement a marketing plan to support the strategic
goals of the College in this area.
9.3 Communication Services
According to Strategic Goal 5, BC is committed to providing effective communication among
stakeholders in the interests of maintaining transparency and accountability. The College has in
place a number of means of communicating with the students and faculty. These include regular
staff meetings at College and department level, a range of committees, notice boards and TV
screens, and the Bayan Post. All faculty members are provided with a computer with internet
connection and SMS is used to keep students informed. The Panel heard that occasionally these
messages are in Arabic and not all students can read this. The Panel found that staff and students
were satisfied with the level of communication within the College. In particular, the ease of
access to the Dean was frequently mentioned.
The Bayan Post is an ambitious and successful project. It is currently an in-house publication, run
entirely by students, mostly from the Journalism program. The Head of Media Department
appoints an editorial committee and the students take responsibility for the masthead, design, logo
and articles. This is not a formal part of the program, and provides, not only communication
within the College, but is also a valuable learning experience.
Commendation 1
The Oman Academic Accreditation Authority commends Bayan College for
producing the Bayan Post, which has resulted in a successful student-driven
in-house publication.
9.4 Facilities Management
Facilities management is provided by Finance and HR Departments. Most services are provided
in-house, but cleaning has been outsourced. There is accommodation available for students off
campus, but this is a private operation (see Section 7.7). Given that the College will be on the
current campus, possibly for several more years, it is important to ensure that the facilities are
maintained at the highest possible level. This will involve maintaining the building in a good
state, but also ensuring that laboratories and studios are kept at an appropriate level (see
Recommendation 27). The College has surveyed graduates on their satisfaction with facilities
(Portfolio, p.73). Almost half the respondents were not satisfied with the quality of the facilities,
but this survey was dated 2010/2011 and the Panel was informed that some improvements have
occurred since then. It is important that the College remains responsive to staff and student
satisfaction with facilities throughout the transition period to ensure the quality of the learning
environment is maintained.
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 44 of 48
APPE�DIX A. AUDIT PA�EL
Dr Rahma Al Mahrooqi (Panel Chairperson)
Assistant Professor
College of Arts and Sciences
SQU
Dr Bilal Al Omari
Deputy Dean
Gulf College
Oman
Professor Barbara van Ernst
Education Consultant
Professor Emeritus, Swinburne University of Technology
Australia
Dr David Palfreyman
Associate Professor
Zayed University
Dubai, UAE
Dr Gerhard Apfelthaler
Professor, School of Business
California Lutheran University
USA
Dr Lejla Vrazalic (Executive Officer)
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 45 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
APPE�DIX B. ABBREVIATIO�S, ACRO�YMS A�D TERMS
The following abbreviations, acronyms and terms are used in this Report. As necessary, they are
explained in context. In some cases, URLs are provided to facilitate further enquiries about these
acronyms and terms.
AAC............................................... Academic Advising Committee
ADRI ............................................. A four step, cyclical model for analysing a topic, comprising:
Approach → Deployment → Results → Improvement.
Approach ....................................... The first dimension of the ADRI cycle, which focuses on evaluating
what a HEI aims to achieve for a given topic and how it proposes to
achieve it.
ARD............................................... Admission and Registration Department
BC.................................................. Bayan College http://www.bayancollege.edu.om/
BoD................................................ Board of Directors
BoT ................................................ Board of Trustees
CC.................................................. College Council
CGC............................................... Career Guidance Centre
CV.................................................. Curriculum Vitae
Deployment ................................... The second dimension of the ADRI cycle, which focuses on whether a
HEI’s plans for a given topic are being followed in practice, and if not,
why not.
EC .................................................. Executive Committee; a subcommittee of the BoD
Executive Officer........................... An professional appointed by the OAAA assigned to an Audit Panel to
provide professional guidance and support.
External Reviewer ......................... A Member of the OAAA Register of External Reviewers; a person
approved by the OAAA Board to participate as a member of the
OAAA’s various external review panels.
GPA................................................ Grade Point Average
HEI................................................. Higher Education Institution (also known as HEP – Higher Education
Provider)
HoD ............................................... Head of Department
HR.................................................. Human Resources
IELTS............................................. International English Language Testing System
Improvement.................................. The fourth dimension of the ADRI cycle, which focuses on how
effectively an organisation is improving its approach and deployment
for any given topic in order to achieve better results.
ITP ................................................. Internship and Training Policy
KPI................................................. Key Performance Indicator
LRD ............................................... Learning Resource Department
MoHE ............................................ Ministry of Higher Education (www.mohe.gov.om)
NGO............................................... Non-government organisation
OAAA............................................ Oman Academic Accreditation Authority (www.oaaa.gov.om)
OAAA Board ................................. The governing body of the Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
OAC............................................... Oman Accreditation Council (became OAAA in 2010)
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 46 of 48
OFI................................................. Opportunity for improvement.
OQF ............................................... Oman Qualifications Framework.
Panel Chairperson .......................... The Chairperson of the Audit Panel.
Panel Member ................................ An OAAA External Reviewer who is a member of an Audit Panel.
Portfolio ......................................... see Quality Audit Portfolio.
PUC................................................ Purdue University Calumet http://www.purduecal.edu/
QA.................................................. Quality Assurance
Quality Assurance .......................... The combination of policies and processes for ensuring that stated
intentions are met.
Quality Audit.................................. An independent evaluation of the effectiveness of the system and
processes by which a HEI sets, pursues and achieves its mission and
vision.
Quality Audit Portfolio .................. The report produced as the result of a self study. Also forms the main
submission made to the OAAA by the HEI being audited.
Quality Audit Report...................... A public report published by the OAAA which presents the findings
and conclusions of the Audit Panel’s External Review of a HEI.
Quality Enhancement..................... The combination of policies and processes for improving upon
existing approach, deployment and results.
Results............................................ The third dimension of the ADRI cycle, which focuses on the
evidence of the outputs and outcomes of a topic’s approach and
deployment.
SAD ............................................... Student Affairs Department
sic ................................................... Quoted as in the original text
SWOT analysis .............................. Analysis of an organisation’s Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities
and Threats
System............................................ In this Report, system refers to plans, policies, processes and results
that are integrated towards the fulfilment of a common purpose.
Bayan College HEI Quality Audit Report
Page 47 of 48 © Oman Academic Accreditation Authority
�OTES
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
HEI Quality Audit Report Bayan College
© Oman Academic Accreditation Authority Page 48 of 48
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
top related