pmprb framework modernization and events/speeches... · 2018-01-08 · following pre-publication,...

PMPRB

Framework Moder nization

16th Annual Market Access Summit

November 2017

30 years ago

2

Canada enacted a two-fold reform of its drug patent regime in 1987 (Bill C-22) that sought to balance competing industrial and social policy objectives:

• Incentivize R&D expenditure through stronger patent protection; • Mitigate the economic impact of stronger patent protection on the

health system.

The PMPRB was conceived as C-22’s “consumer protection pillar”, to ensure that prices of patented drugs remain “reasonable” and “affordable”.

The intent was to double R&D in Canada (to 10% of revenues) while keeping prices in line with high R&D countries (the “PMPRB7”*) on the assumption we would come to emulate them. *Countries in the PMPRB7 are France, Germany, Italy, Sweden, Switzerland, the UK and the US.

Today The policy objectives sought by Bill C-22 have not been met:

3

R&D is at historic low: 4.4% Canadian prices are very high: (3rd in OECD)

PMPRB regulatory role in context

4

The PMPRB is part of a complex regulatory and reimbursement ecosystem

Drug Life Cycle

Health Canada

PMPRB

Private Drug Plans

CADTH

Provinces

R&D Patented Generic

Review for Safety, Efficacy

and Quality Post market surveillance

Excessive Price Monitoring and Investigation

Reimburse

CDR / pCODR

pCPA Reimburse

CADTH: Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health CDR: Common Drug Review

pCODR: pan-Canadian Oncology Drug Review pCPA: Pan-Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance

PMPRB regulatory framework

5

The PMPRB’s authority to regulate patented drug prices reposes on three legal instruments:

Sections 79-103 of the Patent Act Excessivity factors, mandate, jurisdiction,

structure and powers of the Board.

Patented Medicines Regulations Comparator countries, information

required of patentees on identity, prices of medicines and R&D investment.

Compendium of Policies, Guidelines and Procedures

(“Guidelines”): Scientific and price review

process, price tests for new and existing drugs.

How PMPRB staff sets ceiling prices

6

New patented drugs are assessed for level of therapeutic benefit relative to existing therapies and assigned a ceiling price that is based on either:

1. The median international price;

2. The highest price in the domestic therapeutic class, or;

3. Some combination of the two.

After entering the market, the price of a drug can increase in keeping with CPI but never to the point of becoming highest of the PMPRB7.

Where PMPRB staff and a patentee disagree about whether a new or existing drug is excessively priced, a hearing may be held before PMPRB Board Members.

If Members decide a drug is excessively priced, they can order the patentee to reduce its price and/or pay back excess revenues.

Problems identified by stakeholders with current approach

7

Our basket of comparators is made up of premium priced countries and includes the US, an international outlier.

Our system focuses on rewarding therapeutic benefit (not the job of a price regulator) instead of policing the risk of abuse/excessive pricing.

All drugs are subject to the same level of regulatory scrutiny, regardless of price/cost and market dynamics.

Our only absolute ceiling for existing drugs is highest international price.

Me-too drugs can be priced at the top of the domestic therapeutic class.

It is based on publicly available list prices, which are increasingly divorced from the true price net of confidential rebates/discounts.

It is not working: prices are high and R&D is low.

8

Canadian drug prices are high

Average Foreign-to-Canadian Price Ratios, Patented Drugs, OECD, 2016

Source: PMPRB Annual Report, 2016 Data Sources: MIDAS™ database, 2005-2016, IMS AG. All rights reserved.

Number of high-cost drugs is rising

9 Source: PMPRB Annual Report, 2016 Data Sources: PMPRB & QuintilesIMS, Private Drug Plan Direct Drug Plan Database, 2006-2016

Between 2006 and 2016 the number of medicines in Canada with an annual per beneficiary cost of at least $10K increased by over 200% and now account for 40% of patented drug sales.

Pressure building for reform

10

Canada, like many countries, faces rising health care costs as payers struggle to reconcile finite budgets with patient access to costly new health technologies.

In addition to relatively high utilization, Canada pays among the highest prices in the world for patented and generic drugs.

A surge in high-cost drugs has growth in drug spending expenditures outstripping that on hospitals and physicians and is accounting for a disproportionate share of total pharmaceutical spending in Canada.

Making prescription drugs more accessible/affordable is a shared FPT priority.

Framework modernization is one of the PMPRB’s 2015-2018 strategic priorities.

Acces/affordability an FPT priority

11

“A Liberal government’s… priorities for a new Health Accord will include: We will consult with industry and review the rules used by the Patented Medicine Prices Review Board to ensure value for the money governments and individual Canadians spend on brand name drugs.”

Framework Modernization Step 1: PMPRB discussion paper on Guideline reform

12

June 2016 discussion paper identified aspects of the Guidelines that are thought to be out of step with recent developments in the PMPRB’s operating environment. Stakeholder views sought on changes which would: 1. De-emphasize therapeutic benefit

and international benchmarking; 2. Prioritize drugs at higher risk of

monopoly pricing; 3. Revisit introductory price ceilings

as market conditions change;

Step 2: Health Canada pre-consultation on regulatory amendments

13

On May 16, Minister Philpott announced pending changes to PMPRB regulations which would: 1. Enable the PMPRB to consider

cost effectiveness and budget impact in setting ceiling prices;

2. Change the list of comparator countries;

3. Require patentees to disclose confidential rebates to third parties.

These changes are first of their kind in over twenty years and an integral part of the GoC’s new federal pharmaceutical management strategy.

Next steps

14

“Pre-consultation” on Health Canada’s proposed regulatory amendments closed on June 28.

Health Canada aims to pre-publish amendments in Canada Gazette, Part I later this year, followed by a 75-day consultation period.

Following pre-publication, the PMPRB will resume its consultation on Guidelines modernization and will solicit stakeholder feedback on how to operationalize the regulatory amendments.

The intention is to have a more robust, modern and risk-based approach to regulating patented drug prices in force by the end of 2018.

Key questions for stakeholders in 2018

15

In seeking to operationalize the regulatory amendments…

1. What considerations should inform PMPRB’s screening of high risk drugs?

2. To what extent should low risk drugs be scrutinized?

3. How should a cost effectiveness threshold be established?

4. Should a different threshold apply depending on market size considerations?

5. How should re-benching work and when should it occur?

6. What price tests should the PMPRB apply to the proposed PMPRB12?

7. How should the PMPRB make use of confidential third party pricing information?