review form - factafictajournal.files.wordpress.com€¦ · web viewreview form. please fill in the...

Review form1

Title of the reviewed manuscript

Click to insert a title

Overall opinion (please mark a chosen answer by clicking on the left box below):

☐ innovative and erudite, a valuable contribution to the field

☐ distinguishing but not innovative

☐ average

☐ below average

☐ unacceptable for publication

Quality of the manuscript

☐ excellent

☐ acceptable after minor corrections

☐ acceptable after major corrections

☐ acceptable, but has to be rewritten

☐ unacceptable in its current form

☐ unacceptable

Required revisions

☐ formal (adjustment to the guidelines and journal’s scope)

☐ linguistic (grammar, spelling, punctuation)

☐ stylistic

☐ logical

☐ methodological

☐ meritorical

☐ bibliographical

Conclusion

☐ I recommend the reviewed manuscript for publication

☐ I recommend the reviewed manuscript for publication providing all the suggested

revisions are considered

☐ I recommend the reviewed manuscript for publication providing all the suggested

revisions are considered and accepted by the reviewer

☐ I advise against publication of the reviewed manuscript

☐ I strongly advise dismissing the manuscript

Text of the review

Click to write a text

Review date

Click and expand to select a date

Reviewer’s signature2

Notes

1 Please fill in the form digitally (in MS Word or Adobe Acrobat Reader) and send it at journal@factaficta.org with a relevant subject line.2 Please sign only a printed version of the review form.