unforseen grund
Post on 01-Jun-2018
230 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 1/24
Ground Condition Risks in Qatar
Paul Prescott and Gabriel Olufemi
14 October 2014
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 2/24
Contents
• Introduction• Standard Forms of Contract
• Adverse Ground Conditions Issues
• Contractual Remedies
• Remedies under Qatari Law
• Conclusion
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 3/24
Introduction
“The ground is the place where things are most likely
to go wrong during a construction project, and the
worse the ground, the greater the risk”(The Institution of Civil Engineers, 1991)
• Risk can be managed, minimised, shared, transferred or
accepted. It cannot be ignored!
• Who should be responsible for ground condition risk?
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 4/24
FIDIC „Red‟ Book and „Yellow‟ Book
• Employer is required to provide data before and after the
Base Date (i.e. even after the tender submission)• Contractor is deemed to have inspected and examined
the site only to the extent as far as practicable, taking
into account cost and time
• Contractor is responsible for interpreting data provided tohim
• Employer carries the risk of physical conditions that
could have been unforeseeable by an experienced
contractor at the date of tender • Follows the well established Clause 12 of the ICE Form
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 5/24
FIDIC Silver Book
• Contractor is responsible for the interpretation andverification of the data provided
• Employer offers no warranty as to the sufficiency or
completeness of information provided
• Risk of adverse ground conditions lies with thecontractor
• Contractor accepts full responsibility in completing the
works and has to include his price for any unforeseen
difficulties or costs
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 6/24
Ashghal Contract
• Employer is required to provide site data before and afterBase Date (i.e. those obtained on behalf of Employer)
• Contractor is deemed to have inspected and examined
the site
• Contractor is responsible for interpreting data provided tohim
• Contractor carries the risk of physical conditions that
could have been unforeseeable (i.e. No EOT or cost for
unforeseen ground conditions)
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 7/24
Qatar Rail Contract
• Employer makes no representation or warranty inrespect of site data
• Contractor is deemed to have obtained all site
information and priced for ground conditions risks
• Contractor bears entire risk of any and all physicalconditions (including contamination) at worksite
• Contractor has no entitlement to EOT or cost for
unforeseeable ground conditions
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 8/24
Qatar Petroleum Contract
• Employer makes no representation or warranty inrespect of site data
• Contractor deemed to have obtained all site information
and priced for ground conditions risks
• Contractor bears entire risk of any and all physicalconditions at worksite (including climatic, weather and
sea conditions)
• Contractor has no entitlement to EOT or cost for
unforeseeable ground conditions
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 9/24
Adverse Ground Condition Issues
• Risk Allocation• Foreseeable by an experienced contractor?
• Site information
• Employer to provide „adequate‟ GI reports
• Ground investigations can never fully disclose all groundconditions
• Pricing and programming at Tender Stage
• Liquidated Damages
• Risk Mitigation
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 10/24
Contractual Remedies
What are the Contractor‟s contractual remedies for adverse
ground conditions?
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 11/24
Contractual Remedies
“Red/
Yellow”
Book
“Silver” Book Ashghal Q-Rail and
QP
Responsibility for
interpretation of Data
Contractor Contractor Contractor Contractor
Responsibility for
unforeseeable adverse
ground conditions
Employer Contractor Contractor Contractor
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 12/24
Other Contractual Remedies
Alternative contractual remedies
• Force Majeure
• Impossibility
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 13/24
Force Majeure (FIDIC)
• Clause 19.1 (5 limbs)1. Exceptional event or circumstance in the Country
2. Beyond Party‟s control
3. Party could not reasonably have provided against it before
entering into the contract
4. Party could not have reasonably overcome or avoided
5. Not substantially attributable to other Party
6. Express exclusion of ground condition risk
• Clause 19.1 - Illustrative Examples of FM events
• 6th limb - Prevention (Permanent or temporary. Not
economic profitability)
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 14/24
Force Majeure (FIDIC)
• Notice of Force Majeure – 14 days (Clause 19.2)• Duty to Mitigate Delay (Clause 19.3)
• Entitlement to:
– Extension of time
– Cost (no profit)
• Other contract notices
• Suspension for 84 days or termination (Clause 19.6)
• Difficult to establish
• No case law
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 15/24
Impossibility under FIDIC
• Clause 19.7 – Event or circumstances outside Party‟s control in the
Country (including FM event)
– Impossible or unlawful to perform obligation
• Physical and legal impossibility (e.g. no engineeringsolution)
• Notice to Employer
• Release or discharge from performance of contract
• Termination and cost of termination under Clause 19.6
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 16/24
Remedies under Qatar Civil Code
Force Majeure and Impossibility-Articles 188, 402 & 704• No definitions
• The Contractor is released from further performance of
its obligation if it is impossible to perform the obligation
as a result of force majeure or unexpected eventbeyond its control
• Termination or Suspension
• Qatari law position on FM arguably more favourable to
contractor • No case law or guidance in Qatar - unpredictable
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 17/24
Remedies under Qatar Civil Code
EOT and Cost for FM/Impossibility• Termination cost under Article 704(2)
• Contractor not required to pay compensation to
Employer (Article 204)
• Contractor may seek relief from liquidated damagesunder Articles 257 and 266
• No case law or guidance in Qatar - unpredictable
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 18/24
Remedies under Qatar Civil Code
Onerous Terms - Article 171(2)• Court to reduce an excessively onerous obligation
• Contractor may be allowed to suspend work
• This Article requires there to be a “public or general and
exceptional incident”• Contractor to put forward arguments to
establish/persuade the court that this Article applies
• Difficult to predict how the court will apply this Article –
no precedence or guidance
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 19/24
Remedies under Qatar Civil Code
Misrepresentation - Articles 134 to 136• Applies if:
– Employer intentionally withholds any site information
or data during tender stage
– Contractor would not have entered into contract had itbeen aware of the withheld information or data
• Contract will be declared void
• Contractor will be reinstated to the position it was prior to
date of contract• Alternatively, Contractor might be awarded damages for
any loss incurred - Article 164(1)
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 20/24
Remedies under Qatar Civil Code
Fraud - Articles 152 and 155 of Law no. 11 of 2004
• There is a potential criminal liability for public officers
and other parties for fraud or deceit for failure to disclose
information or data during tender stage
• Employer cannot exclude or limit its liability for fraud
(Article 259)
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 21/24
Conclusion
• Generally, current Qatar practice is that bidders(Contractors) are invited to accept the risk of
unforeseeable ground condition risk (including ground
water and environmental contamination)
• Bidders should consider the position of ground condition
risk and their appropriateness on a project by project
basis
• Bidders should consider if any site investigation reports
have been obtained by the Employer
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 22/24
Conclusion
• If so, is the Contractor entitled to rely upon them if theinformation is inaccurate or does not adequately reflect
the conditions encountered on Site?
• What should bidders be expected to do?
– gamble on encountering less favourable groundconditions and expect the worse?
– amendments to the conditions to deal with project
specific ground risk (time and money or time only?)
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 23/24
ANY QUESTIONS?
paul.prescott@pinsentmasons.com
gabriel.olufemi@pinsentmasons.com
8/9/2019 unforseen grund
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforseen-grund 24/24
Combining the experience, resources and international reach
of McGrigors and Pinsent Masons
Pinsent Masons LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England & Wales (registered number: OC333653) authorised and regulated by
the Solicitors Regulation Authority, and by the appropriate regulatory body in the other jurisdictions in which it operates. The word „partner‟, used in
relation to the LLP, refers to a member of the LLP or an employee or consultant of the LLP or any affiliated firm who is a lawyer with equivalent
standing and qualifications. A list of the members of the LLP, and of those non-members who are designated as partners, is displayed at the LLP‟s
registered office: 30 Crown Place, London EC2A 4ES, United Kingdom. We use „Pinsent Masons‟ to refer to Pinsent Masons LLP and affiliated
entities that practise under the name „Pinsent Masons‟ or a name that incorporates those words. Reference to „Pinsent Masons‟ is to Pinsent
Masons LLP and/or one or more of those affiliated entities as the context requires. © Pinsent Masons LLP 2012
For a full list of our locations around the globe please visit our websites:
www.pinsentmasons.com www.Out-Law.com
top related