vietnam war sbcsq 2009 prelims

SBCSQ PracticeSelf-marking and evaluation

Qns 1 (a)

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

What the source said:

A lot of Vietnamese died because

of the Americans

!

Children too

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

What the source said: A lot of Vietnamese died because of the

Americans !

Children too

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

What the source said: A lot of Vietnamese died because of the

Americans !

Children too

Message? Convince Americans

that the War is terrible.

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible.

What the source said: A lot of Vietnamese died because of the

Americans !

Children too

Message? Convince Americans

that the War is terrible.

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible.

What the source said: A lot of Vietnamese died because of the

Americans !

Children too

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible.

What the source said: A lot of Vietnamese died because of the

Americans !

Children too

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children.

What the source said: A lot of Vietnamese died because of the

Americans !

Children too

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children.

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children. This source was published in an American newspaper, on 3 July 1966, when (what’s so special?)

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children. This source was published in an American newspaper, on 3 July 1966, when (what’s so special?)

background info - American involved from 1959 to 1975

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children. This source was published in an American newspaper, on 3 July 1966, when the Americans were still involved in the Vietnam War.

background info - American involved from 1959 to 1975

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children. This source was published in an American newspaper, on 3 July 1966, when the Americans were still involved in the Vietnam War.

Why do you think the cartoonist drew this cartoon? EYA.

The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince Americans that the War is terrible. This is because the source shows that a lot of Vietnamese died because of the Americans, including the children. This source was published in an American newspaper, on 3 July 1966, when the Americans were still involved in the Vietnam War. Therefore, the cartoonist is trying to garner the support of Americans to….(take what action?)

Qns 1 (c)

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

What is the logic for this?

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Just show that one of them is wrong!

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Just show that one of them is wrong!

wrong!

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Just show that one of them is wrong!

wrong!

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

How do you show if something is wrong?

wrong!

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

How do you show if something is wrong?

wrong!

= cannot believe

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

How do you show if something is wrong?

wrong!

= cannot believe

So what skill does it require then?

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

How do you show if something is wrong?

wrong!

= cannot believe

So what skill does it require then?

Reliability!

How about other possible combinations?

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?

wrong!correct

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?

wrong!correct

No need cause the question asked if ONE OF THEM IS WRONG

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?

wrong!

This will sufficiently show that ONE OF THEM is wrong isn't it?

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?

wrong!

This will sufficiently show that ONE OF THEM is wrong isn't it?

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Is there a need to do this?

wrong! wrong!

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Is there a need to do this?

wrong!

No. Cause showing that both are wrong still shows that ONE OF THEM is wrong .

wrong!

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Can this answer the question?

Right! Right!

No, none of them is wrong

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Can this answer the question?

Right! Right!

No, none of them is wrong

Yes you can. But you must explain why both are right even though the views are different.

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Can this answer the question?

Right! Right!

No, none of them is wrong

Yes you can. But you must explain why both are right even though the views are different.

Disclaimer: This rarely occurs.

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

So let’s look at Source D and E. Which one is likely to be wrong?

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

So let’s look at Source D and E. Which one is likely to be wrong?

“…will not resort to unnecessary

violence”

President Johnson picking up coffins of Peace and Progress

Source D Source E

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

So let’s look at Source D and E. Which one is likely to be wrong?

“…will not resort to unnecessary

violence”

President Johnson picking up coffins of Peace and Progress

Not supported by Source B

Supported by other Sources

So Source D is wrong.

The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.

Prove Source D wrong using reliability