an airborne simulation of the smap data stream · pdf filean airborne simulation of the smap...

21
Engineering An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream J. P. Walker 1 , P. O’Neill 2 , X. Wu 1 , Y. Gao 1 , A. Monerris 1 , R. Panciera 3 , T. Jackson 4 , D. Gray 5 , and D. Ryu 6 1 Department of Civil Engineering, Monash University, Australia 2 NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, USA 3 Cooperative Research Centre for Spatial Information, University of Melbourne, Australia 4 United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), USA 5 Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, University of Adelaide, Australia 6 Department of Infrastructure Engineering, University of Melbourne, Australia Acknowledgement: Australian Research Council DP0984586, LE0453434 and LE0882509 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=20120015416 2018-05-01T05:22:32+00:00Z

Upload: dangthu

Post on 09-Feb-2018

230 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Engineering

An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

J. P. Walker1, P. O’Neill2, X. Wu1, Y. Gao1, A. Monerris1, R. Panciera3, T. Jackson4, D. Gray5, and D. Ryu6

1Department of Civil Engineering, Monash University, Australia2NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, USA3Cooperative Research Centre for Spatial Information, University of Melbourne, Australia4United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), USA 5Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, University of Adelaide, Australia6Department of Infrastructure Engineering, University of Melbourne, Australia

Acknowledgement: Australian Research Council DP0984586, LE0453434 and LE0882509

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=20120015416 2018-05-01T05:22:32+00:00Z

Page 2: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

SMAP SpecificationsLaunch: NASA, 2014

Frequency band: L-band

Incidence angle: 40˚

Azimuth direction: conically-scanning antenna

Resolution: Soil Moisture ~9km -- 36km radiometer + 3km radar

Repeat: 2-3 days

1An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Radiometer observation ~36km

Radar observation ~3km

Downscaled product~9km

+ = AlgorithmsActive Passive Retrieval

and Downscaling

The Soil Moisture Active Passive mission

Page 3: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

4An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Airborne simulator

Page 4: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Datasets:

TB at 36km

& σ˚ at 3km

Downscaled product:

TB/SM at 9km

Reference dataset:

TB/SM at 1km

TEST DATA EVALUATION DATA

Pre-launch algorithm validation largely based on synthetic studies & few airborne data sets

SMAP Data Simulation

2An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Motivation

Page 5: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Radiometer TB36km

H&V polL-band

Incidence angle:40°

Radar σ3km

HH, VV & HV polL-band

Incidence angle:40°

SMAP

PLMR TB1km

H&V polL-band

Incidence angle:±7˚, ± 21.5˚ and ± 38.5˚

PLIS σ10-30m

HH, VV & HV polL-band

Incidence angle:15°- 45°

Aircraft simulator

UpscalingUpscaling

Incidence angle normalizationIncidence angle normalization

Azimuth effectAzimuth effect

Azimuth: rotating Azimuth: left/right of track

5An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Simulation of SMAP data

Page 6: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Soil Moisture Active Passive Experiments (SMAPEx)

Location: Yanco, Murrumbidgee Catchment, NSW;

Field campaigns: SMAPEx-1 (5th-10th July 2010)

SMAPEx-2 (4th-8th Dec 2010)

SMAPEx-3 (5th-23rd Sept 2011)

Flights

Regional flight, Target flights, Transect flight;

Multi-angle flights and multi-azimuth flights

Ground sampling

Soil moisture; and

vegetation

3An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Study site

Page 7: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Multi-angle flights

at 3,000m altitude

Multi-azimuth and multi-resolution flights

both at 1,500m altitude

7An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Target flights

Page 8: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Caveat Calibration solutions used here for PLIS are

still preliminary

Absolute calibration accuracy for PLIS based on SMAPEx-3 is ~0.8dB

Application of a specific SMAPEx-3 calibration to other dates results in ~1.5dB error

The calibration procedure for PLMR is mature and is accurate to ~2K

Flight line Swath

An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream 6

Page 9: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Reference 40˚ map

and more…

8 strips from 8 flights (HH-polarization)

Incidence angle: 42.5˚~37.5˚ ~3km

~5km

8An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Normalization to 40˚ for PLIS

Page 10: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Original flight (HH-pol) CDF method

See poster: WEP. P. 5, Wednesday 25th July 17:20-19:00

“A cumulative distribution function based method for normalising …”

9An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Normalization to 40˚ for PLISNormalized flight (HH-pol) Reference (HH-pol)

Page 11: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

RMSE vs Angle (1˚ / ~90m)

RMSE (dB) 10m 100m 500m 1km

Original 7.5 7.2 7.1 6.5

Normalized 4.7 2.9 2.3 1.8

Normalized flight (HH-pol)10m 100m

500m 1km

10An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Normalization to 40˚ for PLIS

Page 12: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

11An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Normalization to 40˚ for PLMR

360m

38.5˚ 7˚22˚

1.3km 700m850m

~3km

2

3

8

~6km

1

Page 13: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

RMSE(K) 1km 3km 6km

Original 13.7 12.6 11.2

Normalized 7.4 5.7 3.0

Normalized flight (7˚, H-pol)at 1km at 3km at 6km

Normalized flight -- 7˚̊

RMSE (K) 1km 3km 6km

Original 11.6 7.2 6.6

Normalized 6.7 4.0 2.9

Normalized flight -- 22˚̊

12An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Normalization to 40˚ for PLMR

Page 14: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Azimuth effect for PLISReference

90˚120˚150˚

210˚240˚270˚

700m

900m

13An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data StreamNormalized to 40˚ at HH-pol

Page 15: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Azimuth effect for PLIS

RMSE vs Azimuth direction for PLIS

Reference Azimuth=240˚

at 10m

at 500m

at 100m

14An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Page 16: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

1km

1km

Reference (40˚, H-pol)90˚120˚150˚210˚240˚270˚

RMSE vs Azimuth direction for PLMR

15An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Azimuth effect for PLMR

Page 17: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Original10m

Upscaled to 50m

Upscaled to 150m

Original 150m

Original 50m

600m

2.5km

16An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

HH-pol, normalised 40˚

Upscaling for PLIS

50m 150m

RMSE (dB) of upscaling 5.1 3.3

2.3

100m10m 500m

RMSE (dB) of normalisation 4.7 2.9

Page 18: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

Panciera, Walker et al. (2009), RSE

17An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Upscaling for PLMR

Diff

eren

ce b

etw

een

aver

age

TB (K

)Resolution (m)

Page 19: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

1km (H-pol) 9km 36km

PLIS 10m (HH-pol) 1km 3km

18An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Example of simulated data

(Data collected on 23rd Sept. 2011)

36km

36km

36km

36km

PLMR

PLIS

Page 20: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

• Refine the PLIS calibration and repeat the analysis

• Try and eliminate any angle normalisation contributions to the azimuth and scaling results and assess georegistration contributions

• Produce a time sequence of simulated SMAP data

• Undertake soil moisture retrievals from 1km PLMR (passive only), validated with higher resolution PLMR data and ground observations, for:

• Evaluation of SMAP downscaling algorithms based on simulated SMAP data from airborne simulator, and

• Evaluation of proposed active-passive retrieval algorithms using 1km and 36km radar/radiometer data

19An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream

Future work

Page 21: An Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data Stream · PDF fileAn Airborne Simulation of the SMAP Data ... IEEE IGARSS 2013 21 –26 July 2013 . Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - IGARSS-Ling_final.ppt

WELCOME TO MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIAfor

IEEE IGARSS 201321 – 26 July 2013

www.igarss2013.org