an introduction to french figured bass exercises
TRANSCRIPT
1
AnIntroductiontoFrenchFiguredBassExercisesbyDerekRemes
Thetraditionofusingfiguredbassexercises,orpartimenti,toteachharmonygoes
backto16thcenturyItaly.Churchorganistsinthe16thcenturyoftenaccompaniedpolyphonicpart‐musicbyplayingthelowestsoundingvoiceatanygiventime.UseofthetermbassocontinuobecamewidespreadfollowingthepublicationofLodovicoViadana’sCentoconcertiecclesiasticiin1602.Thispublicationwasuniqueinthatthecontinuopartswerenotextractedfromothervoices,aswasdoneearlier,butinsteadwerecomposedindependently.
Itwasnotuntilthe18thcenturythatfiguredbassexercises,alsoknownasthoroughbassexcercises,becameamajortoolforteachingharmony.Duringthatcentury,moremanualswerepublishedonthesubjectthatanyothermusicaltopic.Mostpublicationsfocusedonpart‐writingrules,suchasavoidingparalleloctavesorfifths.Bythelate18thcentury,thoroughbasswasnolongerthedominantcompositionaltechnique,buttheuseoffiguredbassexercisesasapedagogicaltoolcontinued. Aroundtheturnofthe19thcentury,teachersatthenewlyfoundedParisConservatoryturnedtoItalianpedagogicalmethodsfortheircurricula.ReproductionsofmanybassesbyfamousItaliancomposerswereused,althoughLuigiCherubini,whowastrainedinpartimentiinBolognaandwasdirectoryoftheConservatoryfrom1822to1841,contributedmanyexercisesofhisown.Later,graduatessuchasDelibes,FranckandThomas,madeadditionalcontributionstothecurricula.
PaulVidalusedhiscollectionofexercises,BassesetChantesDonnées,inhisharmonyclassesattheParisConservatory.NadiaBoulanger,oneofhisstudents,usedhisbooktoteachgenerationsofstudentsinthe20thcentury.Herstudent,NarcisBonet,recentlypublishedarevisededitionoftheseexercises,ACollectionofGivenBassesandMelodies,whichisavailableintwovolumes.
IntheFrenchtradition,realizationsaretobedoneatsightatthepiano,oftenwhilesingingonevoiceinsolfége.Transpositionscanbedoneinenharmonicallyrelatedkeys,soasnottorequireclefchanges.TherearealsotenbooksofexercisespublishedbyHenriChallan,whichareavailableatonline.Theseexercisesaremorecomplex,andthereforeprobablyintendedtobewrittendown.
PartI:Voice‐Leading&DoublingReviewRealizingfiguredbassesinfourvoicesrequiresanunderstandingofbasicvoice‐
leadinganddoublingrules:• Noparallel5thsor8thsbetweenanyvoice.• Nomorethanan8vabetweenupperthreevoices,ora12thbetweenbass&tenor.• Melodicintervals:2nds,3rds,4ths,5ths,6ths,8ths• Ingeneral,moveaslittleaspossiblebetweenchords,keepingcommontoneswhere
possible,exceptinthesoprano,whichshouldhaveaninterestingmelodiccontour.• Avoiddirect5ths&8thsinoutervoicesunlesssopranomovesbystepandthe
lowervoicemovesby“harmonicstep”(i.e.aperfect4thorperfect5th)
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
2
ChordFunctions:
TonicFunction(T):I,vi,iii(viandiiiareweaker)DominantFunction(D):V,viio,iii(iiiisweak,butisalsovofrelativeminor)SubdominantFunction(SD):ii,IV(IVisweakerthanii)
ChordSyntax:
TDT/TSDT/TSDDT
Thesearethemostcommonpatternsappearingwithinphrases,butotheroptionsarepossiblebetweenphrases.Forinstance,asubdominantchordmightfollowadominantchordthatispartofahalf‐cadence.
BasicDoublingRules:
• RootPositionTriads:Alwaysdoubleroot,exceptdeceptivevidoubles3rd.Ingeneral,chooserootforsoprano.
• FirstInversionTriads:Almostalwaysputrootinsoprano.‐ I6,V6,iii6:doubletheroot‐ IV6:doublethe5thwhengoingtoV;doublerootwhengoingtoI(plagal)‐ ii6andvi6:doublethe3rdbecausethisemphasizestheirsubdominant
andtonicfunctions‐ viio:doublethe3rdtoavoiddoublingtritone
• SecondInversionTriads:Thereare4kindsofsix‐fourchords.
‐ Passing,Neighboring,Cadential:doublethe5th,whichisalwaysinthebass
‐ “Deceptive:”doublesroot,thoughthischordisnon‐standard.Thischordwaslabeledas“deceptive”byNadiaBoulanger,soitisincludedhere.
Example1a:TheFourTypesofSecondInversionChords
• SeventhChords:Ifusingacompleteseventhchord,thenallfourvoicesareusedandnodoublingispossible.Ifincomplete,onlythe5thcanbeomitted,andthenrootmustbedoubled.
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
3
• Note:Adiminished7thchordresolvestodoubled3rd,whichresolvesboth
diminished5thsinward,towardseachother.
Example1b:DiminishedSeventhResolvestoDoubledThird:
StandardRootMotions:Noticethatwhenthebassmovesupbystep,allothervoicesmoveincontrarymotion.Ingeneral,successfulvoice‐leadingoccurswhentheoutervoicesmovecontrarytoeachotherand/orthesopranomovesbystep.Example2:RootMotionsofRootPositionTriadswithTypicalHarmonizations
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
4
PartII:Sequences
RealizingFrenchfiguredbassexercisesrequiresanunderstandingoftheFrenchmethodofanalyzingsequences.IntheFrenchschool,thereareonlytwotypesofsequences,whicharedistinguishedbytheirbassmotion:thecellofthe4thandthecellofthe5th.Bothcellsarepossiblewiththesecondtriadinfirstinversion.
Example3a:TheCellofthe4thandtheCellofthe5thCellofthe4th(C4) Cellofthe5th(C5)Cellofthe4th Cellofthe5th withinversion(C4I)withinversion:(C5I)
Thesecellscanrepeatatanyintervaltoformsequences(bysteporleap,upordown).Herearesomecommonintervalsforsequentialrepetition.Example3b:TypicalIntervalsofCellRepetitionC4repeatingdownadiatonic3rd C5repeatingdownadiatonic2nd
Example3c:TypicalIntervalsofCellRepetitionwithInversionsC4‐Irepeatingdownadiatonic3rd C5‐Irepeatingdownadiatonic2nd
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
5
C4Irepeatingdownathirdhasaproblemthough–therearedirect5thsbetweenthetenorandbassvoices.NadiaBoulangersuggestedthisvoicinginstead:Example3d:MlleBoulanger’sSolutionforC4IRepeatingDowna3rd
C4andC5canalsobereversed,makingfourpossiblevariationsinall.Example4a:C4andC5withChordsReversedC4Rev.(C4‐R) C5Rev.(C5‐R) C4IRev.(C4‐IR) C5IRev.(C5‐IR)
Theretrogradeversionscanbedistinguishedfromtheregularversionsby
identifyingwhichchordtoneisinthesoprano,(thesopranonoteintheaboveexamplesisalmostalwaysmaintainedthroughouttheexercises).
Herearesomeadditionalsequencesusingretrogradecells:Example4b:TypicalIntervalsofReversedCellRepetitionC4‐Rrepeatingupadiatonic2nd C5‐Rrepeatingupadiatonic2nd
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
6
Example4c:TypicalIntervalsofInverted,ReversedCellRepetitionC4‐IRrepeatingupadiatonic2nd C5‐IRrepeatingdownadiatonic2nd
Cellscanalsomodulate.Thissequencemodulatesupa5th.Example5:AModulatorySequenceusingC4IRepeatingUpa3rd
AMinor:CMajor: EMinor:GMajor: BMinor:DMajor: Herearesomeexamplesofsequencesfromtheliterature,withanalysesaccordingtotheFrenchschool.Creativeuseofsequencesresultsfromhowthesurfacerhythmisactivated.
Example6a:Mozart,PianoConcertoNo.9,K.271Mov.3(m.133137)
Thefollowinganalysisplacesgreaterimportancetothefirstnoteofeach
measurebecauseitismetricallyaccented,ratherthanthehighestnoteineachmeasure.NoticeMozart’sadjustmentofaccidentalsinthesequencetotonicizeG‐minorandC‐minor.(TheaccidentalA‐flatalsotonicizesE‐flatMajor,whichisnotrepresentedinthefollowinganalysis).
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
7
Example6b:C4RepeatingDownaDiatonic3rd
Example7a:Beethoven,ViolinSonataNo.3,Op.12–Mov.3(m.34145)
BeethovenalsomakesadjustmentstothesequencetotonicizeF‐minor:Example7b:C4IRRepeatingDownaStep
Example8a:Brahms,ViolinSonataNo.3,Op.108–Mov.3(m.4347)
LikeMozartandBeethoven,BrahmsalsomakesadjustmentstothissequencetotonicizeA‐Major.
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
8
Example8b:C5IRRepeatingUpaDiatonic2nd
PartIII:RootPositionExercises
ThefiguredbassexercisespublishedbyNarcisBonetareintwovolumesandarearrangedprogressively,beginningwithrootpositiontriadsandproceedingthroughaugmentedsixthchords.
• RootPositionTriads• FirstInversionTriads• SecondInversionTriads• DiminishedTriads• DominantSeventhChords• Non‐DominantSeventhChords
• TheDominantNinthChord• TheSeventhontheLeadingTone• TheDiminishedSeventhChord• Exerciseswithallpreviouschords• TheAugmentedSixthChord
Thisisthefirstexerciseforrootpositiontriads.Example9a:
Inordertofacilitatereadingatthepiano,identifythelocationandtypeof
sequencesemployed.Rememberthatinsequences,thesamesopranonotefromtheaboveexampleswillbeusedconsistentlythroughouttheexercises.Itisalsohelpfultolabelsopranopitchesoccasionally.Inthenextexamplesomepitchesarelabeledforyouinsolfege.
Knowingthesopranonoteisveryimportantbecauseforrootpositiontriads,allthreeuppervoicesarealmostalwaysarrangedincloseposition(i.e.,withouttheomissionofachordtonebetweenanyvoice)‐exceptforthedeceptivevi,whichdoublesthethird.Therefore,ifthesopranonoteisidentified,thealtoandtenornotescanbeplacedunderiteasily.
AsmentionedinPartI,thegoalofvoice‐leadingistomoveassmoothlyaspossiblebetweenchordswhileavoidingparallel5thsand8vasandmakingthesopranoasmelodicaspossible(i.e.,avoidingcommontones).Sincetheupperthreevoicesareusuallydeterminedbythesopranonote,movingthesopranostepwiseandcontrarytothebasswillusuallyfacilitatesmoothvoice‐leading.
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
9
Example9b:
Hereisthefinishedrealization,whichusuallywouldbedoneatsightatthepiano.Rememberthatforrootpositiontriads,generallytherootwillbeinthesoprano.Noticehowthesopranousuallymovesstepwiseandcontrarytothebass,whilethealtoandtenorareplacedinclosepositionbeneathit.Somevariationsarepossible.Example9c:
Thisisanotherexampleusingrootpositiontriads,withsomesopranopitchesgiveninsolfége(using“fixed‐do”)Example10a:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
10
Hereitisrealized.Somevariationsareofcoursepossible.Example10b:
Thisisonemoreexampleusingrootpositiontriads.NotethedeceptiveuseofanA‐majortriadinm.13!ThissortoftrickistypicalofVidal’sexercises.Also,m.9containsanerror–adominantfunctionG‐sharpmajortriadleadstoasubdominantfunctionF‐sharpminortriad.Technicallythisisnotcorrect,butperhapsVidalthoughtitwasacceptablebecauseoftheweakrhythmicplacementofthesubdominantchord.Example11a:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
11
Hereistherealization.Noticeinm.15howVidalusesIVratherthaniv,andiirather
thaniio,whichpreventsusinganaugmentedsecondmelodicallyinthesoprano.Also,noticehowthelastbeatofm.16requireskeepingacommontoneinthesopranotoparallel8vaswiththebass.
An“X”indicatesalocationofaV‐viprogression,whichforvoice‐leadingreasons,doesnotusethetypicaldeceptivevidoublingofthethird.
Example11b:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
12
PartIV:FirstInversionExercises Realizingexerciseswithfirstinversiontriadsrequiresuseofthe“melodicsixsolution.”Thegoalofthissolutionistoharmonizeaseriesofparallelfirstinversionchordswhileavoidingparallel5thsand8vas.Noticethatintheupperthreevoices,twovoicesmoveparallelwhileonemovescontrary.Parallelfoursareacceptable.Example12:MelodicSixSolution
InPartIitwasstatedthatfirstinversiontriadsmustalwayshavetherootinthesoprano.Whenthissolutionisused,melodicconsiderationsareoverrulingharmonicones,sotherootneednotbeinthesoprano.(Therearealsoexceptionswherethe5thcanbeusedinthesopranoforfirstinversiontriads).
Hereisanexerciseusingfirstinversionchords.Thesolfegepitchesandanalysisofthesequencesareaddedinthisexample.Rememberthedoublingrulesforfirstinversiontriads,whichwereoutlinedinPartI.Itcanbeassumedthatchordswithoutfiguredbassnumbersareinrootposition.However,forsakeofclarity,sometimesa“5”or“5/3”isincludedasareminder.Example13a:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
13
Hereitisrealized.Thisexampleusesaportionofthe“melodicsixsolution,”aswellasadoubledpedalpoint.Pedalpointscallusuallybeidentifiedbyconsecutivefirstinversiontriadswhichmovebyleap,asinm.17‐19.Example13b:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
14
Afinalexampleofanexerciseusingfirstinversiontriadsmysopranonotesandanalysis.Thisexampleoccasionallyindicatesthedirectionoftheinnervoiceswithanarrow.Example14a:
Rememberthatii6goingtoVwilldoublethethirdtoemphasisitssubdominantfunction.Thedeceptivevoicingisusedinm.11becauseitavoidsparallel5thsbetweensopranoandtenor.Notethatm.17doesnotusethedeceptivevoicinginordertoavoidparallel5ths.
The“X”inExample14indicatesthatthesefirstinversionchordsaretheproductofvoice‐leadinganddonotrequirethattherootbeinthesoprano.ThisexamplealsousestheBoulangersolutionforC4‐Imovingdownbyathirdinm.6‐7,aswellasadoubledpedalpointattheend(seenextpagefortherealization).
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
16
PartV:SecondInversionTriads
Rememberthatthereareonlyfourtypesofsecondinversiontriads;passing,neighboring,cadential,andthenon‐standard“deceptive.”Noothersecondinversionchordsshouldbeused.Itisimportanttonotethatallpassing6/4chordshavethesamestructure:twovoicesmovestepwiseinoppositedirection(alsocalledavoice‐exchange),onevoiceisalowerneighbor,andtheotherremainsapedal.Thesefourvoicescanbearrangedinanyverticalorder,solongasthebassmovesstepwise.Example15:Passing6/4Chords
Thisisthefirstexerciseofthesecondinversionchords.Itusesallfourtypesof6/4chords.Example16a:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
17
Hereistherealization.Noticethattheii6chordinm.19doublestherootbecauseitdoesn’tpreceedaVchordliketheii6inthefollowingmeasure.Thisexamplealsousedadoubledpedalpointinm.15‐16.Example16b:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
18
PartVI:DominantSeventhChords TheFrenchlabelingsystemforseventhchordinversionsisasfollows.Theplusreferstotheleadingtone.Aslashthroughanumbermeansthatpitchisloweredahalf‐step.
• RootPosition:7/+• FirstInversion:6/5
• SecondInversion:+6• ThirdInversion:+4
Thebasicstrategyforusingdominantseventhchordsistobeginbyrealizingthechordasifitwereatriad,followingthestandarddoublingrules.Thenmoveoneoftherootsdownasteptocreatetheseventhchord.Inthecasethattheseventhisalreadyinthebass,proceedasifitweretheroot.Thefollowingexampleillustratesthisprocedure:Example17:StrategyforRealizingDominaÎtSeventhChords
Rememberthatwhenpossible,theseventhofadominantseventhchordmustbepreparedbycommontoneinthepreviouschord.Mostseventhsinfiguredbassexerciseswillbecomplete–thatis,allfourchordtoneswillberepresented.Ifincomplete,onlythe5thcanbeomitted.Inthatcase,therootmustbedoubledbecausethe3rdandthe7tharetendencytonesandwouldcauseparalleloctavesifresolvedcorrectly.
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
20
Noticethevariousnon‐standardusagesofthedeceptivedoublinginthisexample:m.17&18useittocreatethe“deceptive”6/4chord;m.27usesitasaresultofresolvingthetendencytoneinthetenor;andm.29&37useittoavoidparallel5thsinthealtoandtenor.Bassmotionunderadominantseventhusuallyindicatesavoice‐exchangewithanuppervoice.Measures19through26createanextendedvoice‐exchange.Example18b:
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com
21
ConclusionVII:
Realizingfiguredbassescanbewonderfultoolforlearningharmonyandvoice‐leading.Atthepiano,itrequirestheactiveparticipationofthestudent,ratherthanpassiveobservation.However,itisimportanttorememberthattheseexercisesareonlydistillationsoftherulesthatcomposerstendtofollowmostofthetime.Therefore,theintegrityofeachindividualvoiceshouldbethefinaldeterminantinanysituation. Amasteryoftheprinciplesofvoice‐leadinganddoublingdoesnotmakegreatmusic‐creativityisessential.Theseexercisescanprovideasolidfoundation,buttheyarestillonlyapointofdeparture.Theultimategoalistoleavebehindtherulesandjustmakemusic.
Bibliography:
Bonet,Narcis.ACollectionofGivenBassesandMelodies.I.SantaAnna,Barcelona:DINSICPublicacionsMusicals,S.L.,2006.Print.
Lasser,Philip.KeyboardHarmonyMaterials.NewYork,NY:EuropeanAmerican
MusicalAllianceInc.,2004.Print.Randel,DonM.TheNewHarvardDictionaryofMusic. Cambridge,Massachusetts:
TheBelknapPressofHarvardUniversityPress,1986.Print.
© 2010 Derek Remes - Published by www.teoria.com