an online therapy network to supplement traditional therapy
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
1/34
AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK
TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
A Masters Project
Presented to
The Faculty of Digital Media Studies
University of Denver
In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Master of Arts
by
Jennifer L. Brunson
June 2009
Advisor: Adrienne M. Russell
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
2/34
2
Abstract
Oftentimes, the first half of a psychotherapy session is spent with the patient
recounting the events between sessions to update the therapist, leaving only half of the
session to analyze and work on the issues. An online therapy network could keep the
therapist current with the patients progress between sessions, allowing for more time to
discuss events and emotions during the scheduled session.
For this project I created a network (PsychSofa Beta) that patients and their
therapists could use to supplement traditional therapy. I interviewed and surveyed
therapists, patients, professors, and psychology students to gather input for the site. I also
considered issues such as privacy, anonymity, virtual identity, and legalities when
creating and modifying the site.
The PsychSofa will continue in Beta mode to assess how it can effectively
supplement in-person therapy. Further research is needed to determine if it can in fact
help therapists stay in touch with their patients between sessions and to what degree.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
3/34
3
The majority of psychotherapy appointments are scheduled on a weekly basis
with a therapist, allowing only one hour per week to try and untangle the knots of the
mind. Oftentimes, the first half of the hour is spent with the patient recounting the events
between sessions to update the therapist, leaving only half of the session to analyze and
work on the issues. In my experiences, and the experiences of many others, this creates a
problem, as there never seems to be enough time for actual progress.
After interviewing a number of current psychotherapy patients and therapists and
researching the topic, I have learned that there are various methods therapists have used
to help their patients keep in touch. Some patients are given pagers that they can use to
type in their emotions or use emoticons to send to their therapists. Others use email, text
messaging, or phone calls to communicate with their therapists. Still others keep a diary
that they share with their therapists; however, these diaries are not seen by the therapists
until the next scheduled session, so they do not address the problem of time spent to
catch up.
There is another issue with traditional, face-to-face psychotherapy. People who
have a difficult time expressing emotions and feelings in front of people still speak to
their therapists behind a barrier. This barrier also prevents progression in therapy as it
makes it difficult, or almost impossible, to get to the root of disturbances. However, many
of these same people who have issues with expressing emotions in front of people do not
have issues expressing themselves through instant messaging, email, blogs, or social
network correspondence.
This second issue, among others, has prompted a rise in online therapy and
online psychotherapy. Online therapy is usually hosted on a web site run by a
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
4/34
4
psychotherapist or etherapists. The sites offer therapy via instant messaging, video
conferencing, phone counseling, or email sessions, and many offer these 24/7. Some of
these etherapists also have a facetoface practice, but all sessions are kept very
separate. PsychSofa Beta is designed to incorporate both online therapy tools and face-to-
face therapy.
Therapists I have talked with expressed a desire to have a way to connect to their
younger patients. According to a study by the U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services (2004), teenagers and young adults spend an average of 16.7 hours online
weeklymore than they do watching TV. This avid use of the internet provides an
excellent medium for therapists to connect to their younger patients. Therapists may want
to investigate the virtual identity of their patients and determine if that concept could be
an important part of their analyses.
There are many online therapy sites such as www.etherapistsonline.com,
www.livecounselors.com, or www.headworks.com, which all offer instant messaging and
email therapy. However, these sites only offer therapy online and none of these sites
incorporate therapy that is already in progress with a therapist.
I have created an online therapy network, PsychSofa Beta, that is a tool for
patients and therapists already in psychotherapeutic progress. Once patients are seeing a
therapist, they can be introduced to this network to supplement their face-to-face sessions
with things such as blogs, emails, forums, interactive expressions, SMS (text message)
updates, and profile creation. Through this network, patients can choose to be networked
to other patients who share life experiences or diagnoses and can interact with each other
in a safe virtual manner. Therapists will be able to check on their patients and stay
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
5/34
5
current with their thoughts before a patient comes in for a face-to-face session. The
therapist can also interact with the patient online.
PsychSofa Beta users can network with other people and communicate behind a
virtual identity that so many online users find comfortable using. By creating this
system, I want to answer the question, Can an online therapy system successfully
supplement traditional therapy?
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
6/34
6
Literature Review
Millions of Americans are using psychotherapy to deal with emotional
difficulties. Research suggests that psychotherapy decreases patients anxiety, depression
and the physical symptoms associated with these conditions (APA, 2008). The American
Psychological Association (2008) estimates that more than five percent or 15 million
Americans are dealing with depression or anxiety, and the majority of these people are
seeking help through psychotherapy.
Therapy used to mean going to a psychiatrists office, lying on a couch, and
revealing innermost thoughts and feelings. Currently, patients with emotional or personal
problems have a variety of methods for support: chat groups, religious counseling,
medication, and the most contemporary method, online therapy. However, online
therapy, while being the newest therapy, is also controversial, and there are issues that
must be addressed before it is fully accepted.
In our society in the United States where access to the internet is widespread,
computer-mediated psychotherapy (online therapy) has become a hot topic for
psychologists. Research is being done on who is using online therapy, the types of online
therapy, and what the advantages or disadvantages are from using it. The therapist is
challenged with determining if the patient is suitable for this type of treatment and
assessing whether the patient is benefiting from the treatment. Additionally, the legal and
ethical implications of using online therapy are being discussed and debated in order to
keep the patient safe and give him or her a feeling of trust.
There are those who are not advocates of online therapy, though. Dr. Sherry
Turkle (2007) warns of becoming tethered to our online devices. She believes that we
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
7/34
7
are becoming one with our devices. She states that by having access to online or
technological support at all times, kids will not experience being alone, learn to be
responsible, or experience emotions (pg. 260).
Others advise that online therapy should not substitute face-to-face therapy but
could be used in concert with guidance from in-person therapy. Dr. John Grohol (1999)
asserts that E-therapy is not psychotherapy, nor is it psychological counseling. When e-
therapy is conducted via its preferred modality (e-mail, an asynchronous
communication), it allows both the client and the professional to fully reflect on issues
discussed previously (p.1). He goes on to state that without nonverbal cues, there is a
greater risk of misinterpretation of communications.
Types of Online Therapy
Online therapy introduces therapists and patients to different types of
relationships. Dr. John Suler (2000) has conceptualized a model to categorize these
relationships into five pathways of practicing online therapy. They include
1) synchronous/asynchronous, 2) text/sensory, 3) actual/imaginary,4) automated/interpersonal, and 5) invisible/present.
The type of therapy used would have to be designed for the individual client, and
there may be a combination of therapies used to address the needs of the client. It is
essential that the a therapist understand the different types of online therapy to be able to
assess which form is best to use with an online therapy patient. For this project, it is also
important to understand the different types of online therapy in order to create different
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
8/34
8
types of tools within the system to provide a diverse array of options available to be used
for supplementation of face-to-face therapy.
Suitability for Online Therapy
One dilemma the therapist faces is determining who will be suitable for online
therapy. There are not any sets of guidelines or factors a therapist may follow to
determine whether a person is suitable, thus adding to the importance of the face-to-face
clinical assessment of an individual. Without proper assessment, online therapy could
possibly prove to be a detriment to an individuals progress in therapy.
Abbott, Klein, and Ciechomski (2008) emphasize that there is also a possibility
that online therapy could even be dangerous to those who are high-risk personalities for
things such as suicide, aggression, or self-harm. Individuals who possess psychiatric
disorders that trigger the experience of distorted reality, suicidal thoughts, a frequent rate
of comorbid psychiatric disturbances, or who are currently being sexually abused or
violently abused may be included in the category of individuals that are not suited for
online therapy. Though, after thorough assessment some individuals with these disorders
may benefit from online therapy.
Some individuals may prefer an online environment to communicate and may
also feel safer communicating thoughts and feelings through a text-only setting or a
setting, which retains a sense of anonymity. Suler (2001) asserts that a therapist must
assess and discuss which medium of communication will best suit the individual and also
consider the possibility that an individual may benefit trying a medium that is out of his
or her comfort zone. If an individual is very experienced on multiple online mediums,
the therapist may be able to utilize multiple environments for treatment.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
9/34
9
Cook and Doyle (2002) agree with this assertion and believe that some
individuals may prefer the anonymity of online therapy. They point out previous
research has indicated that individuals with certain personality characteristics, such as
introversion, and particular problems, such as panic disorder and agoraphobia, may prefer
the perceived anonymity and sense of control the internet offers (p. 103).
Another area of concern is the persons computer skills and access to the internet.
If a person does not possess adequate knowledge of computer systems or the ability to
easily navigate the internet, treatment could yield frustrations and diminish progress. A
person must have reliable internet access, the motivation to explore the internet and new
online communication environments, and adequate knowledge of computer systems. It
may also be possible that benefits from online therapy may be partly determined by a
persons familiarity with online communication. A person who already has online
relationships or is used to belonging to online groups and being involved in online social
activities already has practice communicating online and may transition into online
therapy better.
An individuals ability to read and write effectively can influence the potential
effectiveness of online therapy. According to Suler (2001) even if a person can navigate
the internet, if he or she cannot write clearly enough to communicate or interact, therapy
could be stressful or near impossible to make progression. If the person does not even
enjoy online communication, then that would also make online therapy progression
ineffective.
The gender of the patient may also affect his or her suitability. According to Tsan
and Day (2007) women typically have fewer stigmas about seeking therapy. They
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
10/34
10
speculate that using online therapy may help men overcome the fear of appearing weak.
However, in a survey conducted at a large urban university, undergraduate psychology
and education students disproved that hypothesis. The survey did find that women have a
more positive attitude toward all modes of psychotherapy and that all participants
preferred traditional face-to-face to online counseling. Tsan and Day note, however, that
the participants surveyed were not necessarily currently in therapy
Issues for Consideration
One of the major issues facing all therapists is the lack of a visual to determine the
mental status of the patient. For example, the clients cleanliness, pupil dilation, and
demeanor may indicate his or her mental state or drug use. These clues would not be
evident in an online therapy session. Additionally, how are therapists to know if the
patient is being truthful or honest about his/her feelings? Tantam (2006) posits that an
unscrupulous or deceiving client may deceive a psychotherapist who relies completely
on the information from an online therapy session. The therapist should require a face-to-
face meeting at least once to make sure the client is, at the very least, the age, gender, and
ethnicity disclosed electronically.
Another issue would be the computer literacy of the therapist. The therapist
should be proficient in the use of the computer. Midkiff and Wyatt (2008) present the
following scenario.
A therapist may wish to send a document to the patient that will help him or her
keep a diary of emotions. If, using chat mode, the therapist struggles to both find
that document in the computers memory and then discover how to attach and
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
11/34
11
send it to the client, the time involved in those tasks probably has intruded
significantly on the therapeutic interaction. (p. 316)
Additionally, Midkiff and Wyatt point out that therapists should be experienced in
the use of chat rooms and forums and the roles of avatars, emoticons, and backgrounds.
Without visual cues and body language, these online standards are important tools in
reaching the client.
The patients confidentiality is paramount to therapy. The therapist must protect
the privacy of the client, which is a daunting task in online therapy. The therapist should
incorporate encryption technology to provide a secure and private place to exchange
information. Midkiff and Wyatt (2008) warn that email messages may not reach their
destination but may be lost in cyberspace, hackers may invade the site, emails may be
sent to the wrong address, or that others may gain access to the therapists computer.
Professional organizations such as the American Counseling Association (ACA),
the American Psychological Association (APA), and the National Board for Certified
Counselors (NBCC) have established guidelines for online therapists to follow. They
maintain that WebCounselors should:
1. Review pertinent legal and ethical codes for possible violations emanating from thepractice of WebCounseling and supervision.
2. Inform WebClients of encryption methods being used to help insure the security ofclient/counselor/supervisor communications.
3. Inform clients if, how, and how long session data are being preserved.4. In situations where it is difficult to verify the identity of WebCounselor or Web-Client,
take steps to address impostor concerns, such as by using code words, numbers, orgraphics.
5. When parent/guardian consent is required to provide WebCounseling to minors, verifythe identity of the consenting person.
6. Follow appropriate procedures regarding the release of information for sharing Web-Client information with other electronic sources.
7. Carefully consider the extent of self-disclosure presented to the WebClient and providerationale for WebCounselors level of disclosure.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
12/34
12
8. Provide links to web sites of all appropriate certification bodies and licensure boards tofacilitate consumer protection.
9. Contact NBCC or the WebClients state or provincial licensing board to obtain thename of at least one Counselor-On-Call within the WebClients geographical region.
10. Discuss with their WebClients procedures for contacting the WebCounselor when he
or she is off-line.11. Mention at their web sites those presenting problems they believe to be inappropriatefor WebCounseling.
12. Explain to clients the possibility of technology failure.13. Explain to clients how to cope with potential misunderstandings arising from the lack
of visual cues from WebCounselor or WebClient. (Manhal-Baugus, p. 555)
Exploring the Virtual Identity
Vybrial et. al. submit that In psychology, identity is understood as a continual
experience of the individual self; of that persons uniqueness and authenticity, as well as
the identification with life roles and the experience of belonging to bigger or smaller
social groups (p. 171). They go on to explain that on the internet a persons physical
being is not present, only a virtual representation is present. The thoughts, ideas, and
fantasies that the person bestows on that representation on the internet is the virtual
identity. Some of the therapists I interviewed were interested in learning more about the
virtual identity of their patients and also stated that for some patients it seems to be a very
affecting part of their entire identity.
There are myriad possibilities when someone logs online. Dr. Sherry Turkle
(1995), who has studied and written numerous documents on online behavior, notes that,
When people adopt an online persona, they cross a boundary into highly-charged
territory. Some feel an uncomfortable sense of fragmentation, some a sense of relief.
Some sense the possibilities for self-discovery, even self-transformation (p. 260). These
personas are what therapists need to study, while at the same time, be wary of.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
13/34
13
Some patients may thrive in an anonymous session. Often patients may be too shy
or ashamed to reveal sensitive information in person. These patients may interact
virtually and allow the therapist to see what the true persona is. Others may transform
into alter egos that do not resemble the live patient. These alter egos could be aggressive,
belligerent, or even offensive (Tantam, 2006). Some adolescents could be experimenting
with these virtual representations also. Wallace (1999) maintains that trying out new
identities is valuable and an integral part of human development.
Patients and therapist involved in once a week traditional face-to-face
psychotherapy could benefit from an online therapy tool. The online therapy tool could
supplement the use of time within the face-to-face sessions, open up new ways of
expression, assist in exploration of the virtual identity, assist in convenience of space and
time, and also build a support network.
For the online therapy tool to be effective, patient suitability must be assessed and
the therapist must experiment with different types of online therapy to know which tools
within the online therapy system will be most effective. Patients and therapists must also
be technologically literate and have access to required technology and internet access.
It is apparent through secondary research that some people are using online
therapy effectively already, and it is also apparent that traditional face-to-face therapy can
be ineffective for those who require more time or different avenues for expression.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
14/34
14
Procedure for Creating Web site
I decided on my preliminary goals and ideas and created sketches of the network
for direction. Before creating the PsychSofa Beta, though, there were many issues that I
needed to investigate alongside the research on therapy practices, virtual communication,
and virtual identity.
It was important to investigate which tools would be useful on the network. I
began with blogs and email as the first tools. Three of the volunteer patients and myself
began blogs on Livejournal.com and shared the link with our therapists. I instructed the
therapists that they did not have to access the site, but it was available for updates
between sessions if they chose to read them. Two of the patients also began typing up
thoughts in emails and sending them to their therapists to be discussed in a face-to-face
session. After two-to-three weeks, the volunteers noted that their therapists were bringing
up points made in blogs and were commenting on the depth of expression of emotion.
The volunteers then noted that this encouraged them to write more, and for some therapy
sessions seemed to be heading into deeper territory.
The blog I had set up for myself was also SMS enabled. On a daily basis I would
send at least two text messages containing a maximum of 160 characters. Within a week I
was sending five or more text messages a day to the blog. My therapist noted that the
one-line messages were really adding up and giving him a quick glimpse into the ups and
downs of my moods and emotions from day to day.
After testing blogs and email and learning that enabling SMS on a blog was
helpful between sessions, I confirmed that these three options would be available on the
first phase of the network.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
15/34
15
With some knowledge of tools that would be good options on the network, I
created surveys (see Appendix A) and distributed them to therapy patients, practicing
therapists, psychology professors, and psychology students. While distributing surveys
and receiving survey responses, I began assessing platforms that could run the network.
After working with content management systems, wikis, and social media applications, I
decided that Ning.com offered the best options for creating prototypes.
I created the first version of the PsychSofa Beta prototype as an open network
with blogs, email, personal photo and video uploading, an events calendar, and instant
messaging. Once I received a survey response, I sent a link to the network to the
responder, so he or she could then look at the network and use the tools. Many
respondents wanted to discuss the project via phone or personal interview in addition to
filling out the survey.
After many interviews, survey responses, and meetings with people in the
psychology field and with therapy patients, I redesigned the prototype with higher
privacy settings, added forums and groups, user profile privileges, and new administrator
options. I then sent out this new design for a second review, but this time some
respondents decided to create accounts and test tools by becoming part of the network.
After a few weeks of having users on the network, I made revisions and created
PsychSofa Beta. Once I created the beta, I wrote an instruction manual (see Appendix B)
which I sent out to all users on the network. I instructed users to attempt to follow any
instructions on how to use a tool he or she had not yet used. If he or she could not get the
tool to work, I edited the instructions until there was success.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
16/34
16
As more users join PsychSofa Beta, it becomes more of a network, revealing
positives and negatives of the network. Users have been noting any problematic areas that
they find, and as the beta version of the network grows, I am exploring more options and
mending any glitches.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
17/34
17
Discussion
After preliminary interviews with a few therapists about the proposed network, I
used what they had suggested and my research to create a prototype and included
information and tools that I believed were necessary for the site to be successful. After
distributing the surveys and speaking with some of the respondents, I discovered new
information that was integrated into the site.
Most of the therapists I talked with or who responded to the survey were
undecided on whether the patient should remain anonymous or be allowed to reveal
personal information about him or herself. PsychSofa Beta includes a suggestion for
users to remain anonymous, and there are instructions requesting users not to use
identifying information, but it is still allowed if the patients decide they want to identify
themselves. It seemed to be an agreed response that it would be interesting to the
therapist to see if the patient decides to disclose information about him/herself despite
being advised to remain anonymous. Right now the network is closely monitored, and if
things seem to be going in the wrong direction, either way, I can alter settings.
On the one hand, how patients present themselves online may allow them to
create more of a virtual identity. On the other hand, anonymity could give people more of
an opportunity to feel hidden and they may, therefore, open up about their fears,
anxieties, and apprehension. Some therapists thought that not seeing the patients
physical response may be a hindrance; however, others see value in letting the patient
think about responses and communicate after deliberating on the question in addition to
real time question/response sessions.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
18/34
18
The respondents were surprisingly very supportive of the concept of online
psychotherapy in addition to face-to-face therapy. When asked about keeping a diary,
some respondents preferred blogging. There were various reasons given for that response:
I can type so much faster, less of a chance to get found on the internet instead of in the
top drawer of my dresser, my therapist can view it before our session, or I am always on
my computer anyway.
Follow-up responses from some of the survey respondents have been positive, and
there are currently patients using the system and sharing it with their therapists. I have
received the following responses: Sharing this with my therapist is cool because he gets
a deeper look into whats happening in my day and with my moods when Im not in a
session.
Even though my therapist does not respond to my blogs or comments, I like knowing
that he has read my thoughts before our next session.
Sometimes I print out the blogs so that I can bring up points in our next session.
Seeing that someone texted or blogged ten times a day was very revealing.
Many of the therapists expressed concern with live chatting, so right now chatting
is not allowed and neither is live video chat. With the exception of the therapists working
with sex offenders, it seemed that many of the respondents preferred the tools that
allowed some form of time delay in communication on the network. Some therapists
feared if they got too deep into an emotion on live chat it could be dangerous if
something went wrong with the technology and too easy for the patient to just turn it off
in the middle of discussions. These same therapists felt a network would supplement best
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
19/34
19
and offer more insight if it mimicked the other social networks their patients are involved
in and was notably different than their face-to-face therapy.
I received responses from therapists in different fields of psychoanalysis, and
many of the therapists had ideas for tools that were very field specific. For example, two
of the therapists work with sex offenders and expressed how helpful a network would be
for their practices, but the needs of these therapists and patients are very different from
those in general practices.
There were also many differences between those therapists working with
adolescents and those working with adults on what would be most fitting for
supplementation. With all of the different needs, it seems that it would be most fitting for
field specific networks to be created to be helpful for each psychotherapy niche.
PsychSofa Beta is a prototype of a network that could be created for a psychotherapy
treatment niche.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
20/34
20
Conclusion
I aimed to create a network for therapists and their patients to see if it could
supplement face-to-face sessions. I did not design this site to replace face-to-face therapy;
in fact, it is important that in- person therapy be established before using the
supplemental site, so the therapist can put a face to an online voice.
The PsychSofa Beta will continue to be up and running to see if it can effectively
work as a supplement with in-person therapy. Further research will be needed to see if
does in fact help therapists stay in touch with their patients between sessions and to what
degree.
Additionally, some therapists have said they might use it to explore other areas of
psychology. One therapist is interested in how her patients communicate and present
themselves in online dating, others are interested in studying virtual identity and tracking
behavior, and some therapists want to use it to help with recovering sex offenders in rural
areas, using live monitoring and live chatting. The respondents are in agreement that it is
interesting to see which way a patient expresses him or herself the best. As one
respondent declared, The way you communicate defines you.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
21/34
21
Bibliography
Abbott, J.M., Klein, B., & Ciechomski, L. (2008). Best practices in online therapy
[Electronic version].Journal of Technology in Human Services, 26(2/4), 365-366.
American Psychological Association. (2008). A basic guide to depression.Medical
Library. Retrieved November 15, 2008 from
http://medem.com/medlb/article_detaillb.cfm?article_ID=ZZZDL37U2KC&sub_
cat=128
Cook, J.E., & Doyle, C. (2002). Working alliance in online therapy as compared to face-
to-face therapy: Preliminary results. Cyberpsychology & Behavior, 5 (2), 95-105.
Grohol, J.M. (1999). Best practices in etherapy. PsychCentral. Retrieved March 6, 2009
from http://psycentral.com/best/best3.htm
Manhal-Baugus, M. (2001).E-Therapy: Practical, ethical, and legal issues. [Electronic
version]. CyberPsychology & Behavior. 4 (5), 553-555.
Midkiff, D.M., & Wyatt, W.J. (2008). Ethical issues in the provision of online mental
health services (Online counseling). [Electronic version].Journal of Technology
in Human Services, 26(2/4), 314-321.
Suler, J.R. (2000). Psychotherapy in cyberspace: A 5-dimensional model of online and
computer-mediated psychotherapy. [Electronic version]. CyberPsychology &
Behavior. 3(2152-158), 553-555.
Suler, J.R. (2001) Assessing a persons suitability for online therapy: The ISHMO
clinical case study group. [Electronic version]. CyberPsychology & Behavior. 4
(6), 675- 679.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
22/34
22
Tantam, D. (2006). Opportunities and risks in e-therapy.Advances in Psychiatric
Treatment. 12, 368-374.
Tsan, J.Y., & Day, S.X. (2007). Personality and gender as predictors of online counseling
use. [Electronic version].Journal of Technology in Human Services, 25(3), 39-55.
Turkle, S. (1995).Life on the screen: Identity in the Age of the Internet. Boston:MIT
Press.
Turkle, S. (2007). Can you hear me now?Forbes.com. Retrieved November 4, 2008 from
http://www.forbes.com/technology/forbes/2007/0507/176.html
U. S. Dept. of Health and Human Services. (2004). Know What Your Child is doing on
the Internet. Retrieved May 1, 2009 from
http://www.family.samhsa.gov/monitor/internet.aspx
Vybiral, Z., Smahel, D. & Divinova, R. (2004). Growing up in virtual reality
Adolescents and the Internet. Society, Reproduction, and Contemporary
Challenges. Brno : Barrister&Principal. pp. 169 - 188.
Wallace, P. (1999). The psychology of the Internet. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
23/34
23
Appendix A
Surveys
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
24/34
24
Therapist Survey
Hello. I am a graduate student at the University of Denver in the Digital Media programworking on a thesis project that incorporates digital media and psychology. Online
therapy already exists as well as face-to-face therapy, but they exist as completely
separate entities. My thesis project aims to find a middle ground in which one couldsupplement the other.
The main goal of my project is to create an online therapy tool that will supplement face-to-face therapy. I have designed an online network that people who are already in face-
to-face therapy can access with their therapists. Patients can use this network to do thingssuch as blogging, joining forums and digital support groups, uploading videos and
images, and creating a personal profile. Therapists can go online and access what apatient does on this network, which will allow the therapist to be updated on what
happens in the patients life between sessions and also have insight into the life thepatient lives online: the patients virtual identity.
As a professional in this field, your thoughts and opinions on this project would be very
valuable to me. I have listed a few specific questions, but any additional comments,suggestions or guidance would be very appreciated.
1. Are you aware of your patients involvement in online activity?
2. Of those patients involved with online activity, do you feel they have created avirtual identity?
3. Do you feel it is important to include an assessment of a persons online activitywhen making an overall psychoanalysis?
4. Do you already engage in digital communications with your patients (i.e. emails,text messaging, blogging, video conferencing, instant messaging)?
5. If you answered yes to question #4, how does it work for you? If you answeredno, would you be interested in incorporating it?
6. What tools do you think should be included on the network?
7. Are you interested in knowing what happens with your patients between sessions?
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
25/34
25
Professor Survey
Hello. I am a graduate student here at the University of Denver. I am currently in the
Digital Media program, but I am working on a thesis project that incorporatespsychology. Since I am not a psychology student, I am looking for input on my project
from experts in the field.
The main goal of my project is to create an online therapy tool that will supplement face-
to-face therapy. Online therapy already exists as well as face-to-face therapy, but theyexist as completely separate entities. My thesis project aims to find a middle ground in
which one could supplement the other.
I have designed an online network that people who are already in face-to-face therapy canaccess with their therapists. Patients can use this network to do things such as blogging,
joining forums and digital support groups, uploading videos and images, and creating apersonal profile. Therapists can go online and access what a patient does on this network,
which will allow the therapist to be updated on what happens in the patients life betweensessions and also have insight into the life the patient lives online: the patients virtual
identity.
As a professional in this field, your thoughts and opinions on this project would be veryvaluable to me. I have listed a few specific questions, but any additional comments,
suggestions or guidance would be very appreciated.
1. Do you think the virtual identity is something to consider when doingpsychoanalysis?
2. Are you aware of therapists and patients who engage in digital communications(i.e. emails, text messaging, blogging, video conferencing, instant messaging)?
3. Do you think it would be helpful for therapists to be able to go online to see howthe patient is doing and see what is going on in his or her life between sessions?Why or why not?
4. What tools do you think should be included on the network?
5. What issues do you see as problems for an online therapy tool?6. If this type of online therapy tool is available, do you think it would be used?
7. What type of patients do you think would benefit from incorporating onlinecommunications in their face-to-face therapy?
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
26/34
26
Psychology Student Survey
Hello. I am a graduate student here at the University of Denver. I am currently in theDigital Media program, but I am working on a thesis project that incorporates
psychology. Since I am not a psychology student, I am looking for input on my project
from experts in the field.
The main goal of my project is to create an online therapy tool that will supplement face-
to-face therapy. Online therapy already exists as well as face-to-face therapy, but theyexist as completely separate entities. My thesis project aims to find a middle ground in
which one could supplement the other.
I have designed an online network that people who are already in face-to-face therapy canaccess with their therapists. Patients can use this network to do things such as blogging,
joining forums and digital support groups, uploading videos and images, and creating apersonal profile. Therapists can go online and access what a patient does on this network,
which will allow the therapist to be updated on what happens in the patients life betweensessions and also have insight into the life the patient lives online: the patients virtual
identity.
As a student in this field, your thoughts and opinions on this project would be veryvaluable to me. I have listed a few specific questions, but any additional comments,
suggestions or guidance would be very appreciated.
1. Do you think the virtual identity is something to consider when doingpsychoanalysis?
2. Are you aware of therapists and patients who engage in digital communications(i.e. emails, text messaging, blogging, video conferencing, instant messaging)?
3. Do you think it would be helpful for therapists to be able to go online to see howthe patient is doing and see what is going on in his or her life between sessions?Why or why not?
4. What tools do you think should be included on the network?5. What issues do you see as problems for an online therapy tool?6. If this type of online therapy tool is available, do you think it would be used?7. What type of patients do you think would benefit from incorporating online
communications in their face-to-face therapy?
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
27/34
27
Patient Survey
Hello. I am a graduate student at the University of Denver in the Digital Media program
working on a thesis project that incorporates digital media and psychology. Onlinetherapy already exists as well as face-to-face therapy, but they exist as completely
separate entities. My thesis project aims to find a middle ground in which one couldsupplement the other.
The main goal of my project is to create an online therapy tool that will supplement face-
to-face therapy. I have designed an online network that people who are already in face-to-face therapy can access with their therapists. Patients can use this network to do things
such as blogging, joining forums and digital support groups, uploading videos andimages, and creating a personal profile. Therapists can go online and access what a
patient does on this network, which will allow the therapist to be updated on whathappens in the patients life between sessions and also have insight into the life the
patient lives online: the patients virtual identity.
As a person working with a therapist, your thoughts and opinions on this project wouldbe very valuable to me. I have listed a few specific questions, but any additional
comments, suggestions or guidance would be very appreciated.
1. Do you engage in digital communications with your therapist, and if so, in whatform (text messaging, email, blogging, etc.)?
2. Do you feel you have enough time to talk with your therapist in a single session?
3. Would you feel comfortable networking with your therapist digitally?4. What issues do you see with anonymously networking with other people
concerning topics covered in therapy?
5. What tools on an online network do you think could help you in therapy?6. Which digital tools do you think you would take the time to update? -blog, email,
participate in online support groups and forums, and/or log into a network to
update your status in between sessions?
7. Do you feel you would communicate differently in a virtual environment? If so,would it be easier or more difficult for you?
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
28/34
28
Appendix B
Instructions for Using PsychSofa Beta
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
29/34
29
PsychSofa Beta Instructions
Getting On
Once you click to join on your email invitation, you will be directed to the site to createan account.
Create an account by filling in the requested information.
An email will be sent to you once the Chair (administrator) has approved your profile.Click the link from this new email, and you will be taken to your spot on the sofa.
Adding a Blog Post
Click on blogs in the navigational bar.
Click add a blog post.
Write your blog. Setting changes are available at the bottom of the page.
You can add text, links, images, and files to your blog post using the blog editortoolbar.
You can also select the privacy of your blog post to allow anyone on the PsychSofaBeta, just your friends on the PsychSofa Beta, or just you to view your blog.
You can save a draft if you are not finished writing the blog.
Creating a Group
Go to the Groups tab and click the link at the top right of the page to "Add a group."
Provide the requested information about your group and choose a name for your group.
Describe your group for members who are looking for groups to join.
On the right side of the page, choose which features your group will have, such as
comment wall, discussion forum, text box, and RSS reader.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
30/34
30
Set the privacy settings for your group.
You can allow anyone to join the group, or you can control membership. If youcontrol membership, new members will have to apply to join, and you can review
their request before they can join.
You can allow members to invite other people to join or allow people to requestmembership. If you turn off both of these options, the group will be invite-only, and
you will be the only one who can invite others to join the group.
Decide whether or not members of your group can send messages to the whole group.Click "Add Group" and your group will be added to the PsychSofa Beta.
Joining a Group
To join a group, go to the Groups tab. You can look through the existing groups and sort
them by most active, latest activity, most members, or latest created by clicking on the
"Sort by" menu.
Once you have decided on a group, click on its title. If the group is public, there will be a
link on the top right of the page to join the group. If the group is private, apply to join thegroup from the group's page.
Participating in a Forum
You can start participating on your PsychSofa Beta by checking out the discussion forum.To use the forum, go to the Forum tab and view the current discussions, or start your own
discussion by clicking the "Start Discussion" link.
To participate in a discussion, type your reply in the "Reply" box. Your reply will appearat the bottom of the discussion thread; scroll down to see it.
You can also reply directly to someone else's reply on a discussion thread. Click the
"Reply to this" link under any post and a reply box will pop open.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
31/34
31
Following a Discussion
Whenever you start or reply to a discussion, you will automatically follow the discussionby default. This feature allows you to see all replies and keep up with the discussion.
To follow a discussion, click the link to "Follow - Email me when people reply" on the
post's page. If you want to stop following a discussion, click on the "Stop Following"link. You will stop receiving email notifications about new replies to the discussion.
Managing a Discussion
To manage a discussion you started, locate the "Admin Options" box on the right side of
the page.
To edit the discussion you started, click "Edit Discussion."
To delete the discussion and all replies to it, click the "Delete Discussion."
Click "Close Discussion" if you want to close the discussion to any new replies.
Adding Videos
Go to the Videos tab and click the "Add Videos" link. The left pane shows the file
listings on your computer.
Drag the videos you want to upload to the right pane to add them to the upload list.
Videos must be in the following formats: .mov, .mpg, .avi, .3gp and .wmv. Using thebulk media uploader, you can add up to 30 videos at a time.
When you upload a video, the privacy setting is set to viewable by Anyone. You can
choose whether the video is viewable to Anyone, Just My Friends or Just Me. Tochange the privacy setting on a specific video, sign in to PsychSofa Beta, go to the video
detail page, and click the Edit Video link underneath the video.
You can change the default setting for uploading videos by clicking on the "Settings" linkin the box on the right column of any page. Then click on the Privacy tab on the left and
you will see options to allow "Anyone", "Just My Friends", or "Just Me" to see yourvideos.
You can also choose who can comment on your videos in "Settings." Changing this
setting will not change the privacy setting on any previously uploaded videos.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
32/34
32
You can also add videos to your PsychSofa Beta from other services including YouTube,GoogleVideo, and Hulu, by embedding them. Scroll to the bottom of the "Add Videos"
page and locate the section that says "Add videos from YouTube or GoogleVideo." Clickthe "Add Video" link.
Copy the HTML embed code from the YouTube, GoogleVideo, or other video sharingservice and paste it into the box.
Viewing Members on Your PsychSofa Beta
You can view all of the members on your PsychSofa Beta by clicking on the Memberstab.
Members are listed in order of most recent members by default, but you can sort them in
alphabetical order or in a random order by selecting the "Sort by" menu.
Adding a Friend
If you want to send private messages or invite someone to your groups or events, you can
add them as your friend on PsychSofa Beta. Once you add someone as a friend, he/shewill receive a notification that you want to be friends. He/she can choose to accept the
friend request or ignore the request.
To send a friend request to someone on the PsychSofa Beta, go to the profile page of thatperson. Click the "Add as friend" link under their profile photo. A confirmation window
will pop up. To add a note to your friend request, click the "Add a personal message"link.
Adding Twitter to your PsycSofa Account
To add your twitter account to your PsychSofa Beta account, go to twitter.com and createan account if you do not have one.
Once you are logged on to your account, go to your profile and click on the RSS feed
link, which is under the heading, to get the twitter URL. Copy the URL.
Go back to the sofa on the PsycSofa site and click Add RSS under the RSS heading.
Create a title for the RSS feed, paste the URL into the URL field, choose your settings,
and click save.
The feed should show up as soon as you click save.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
33/34
33
Controlling Your email Settings and Messages
PsychSofa Beta allows you to receive emails about new activity on PsychSofa Beta. Youwill receive email notifications when you have new private messages, new friend
requests, or when the PsychSofa Beta Chair sends a broadcast message. You can choosewhether you want to receive any of these notifications from the "Email settings" page.
You can also control who can send you a private message, and you can block anymember from doing so at any time.
Private messagesWhen you join PsychSofa Beta, you will automatically be able to exchange messages
with the Chair. In order to exchange messages with any other member of PsychSofaBeta, you must first become friends with that member.
You can block messages from any member on PsychSofa Beta. To block a sender, go
to your inbox and locate a message they have sent you. Open the message and clickthe "Block messages" link.
PsychSofa Beta notificationsYou will receive different types of notifications from PsychSofa Beta by default:messages sent to only you, to groups you belong to, to your events, to the whole
PsychSofa Beta, or messages people sent to all of their friends. You will also receivenotifications when you have new friend requests, when people you have invited join,
and when you have new comments to approve.
You can turn off any or all email notifications coming from PsychSofa Beta fromyour Email Settings page. To get to your Email Settings page, click on the "Settings"
link in the right column of any page.
Click on the "Email" tab. All of the different types of notifications will be displayed.
In the "social network" section, you can control the email notifications youreceive when messages are sent on PsychSofa Beta.
In the "Member Activity" section, you can control email notifications aboutactivity on PsychSofa Beta.
In the "Following discussions and blog posts" section, you can choose toautomatically follow discussions and blog posts you add to or those you reply to.
-
7/28/2019 AN ONLINE THERAPY NETWORK TO SUPPLEMENT TRADITIONAL THERAPY
34/34
You can stop following blog posts and discussions all at once by clicking "Clear
My Follow List."
If you don't want to receive any email notifications from PsychSofa Beta, checkthe box next to "None: I don't want to receive emails" at the bottom of the page.
Now you will only receive private PsychSofa Beta messages and broadcast
messages from the Chair when you log in to PsychSofa Beta.
Checking your Inbox for Messages
To check your messages on PsychSofa Beta, log in and click the "Inbox" link on the rightside of the page.
Sending a Private Message
You can send private messages to your friends on PsychSofa Beta. You can also
exchange private messages with the Chair of PsychSofa Beta, even if you are not friends.
To send a private message, click the "Inbox" link on the right side of the PsychSofa Betapage. Click the "Compose" link. Enter people by email address in the "To" field, or click
the "Choose from friends" link to select from your friends list on PsychSofa Beta.
To send a message to the Chair if you are not friends, go to their profile page and clickthe "Send a Message" link.