analysis as a potential source of renewable energy and bedding material for the organic dairy...

21
Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production Research Team: Jacki Amante, Makenzie Benander, Brian Godbois, Bella Oleksy, Paul Pellissier, Alyssa Reid, Bryan Vangel

Upload: dennis-stafford

Post on 31-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding

MaterialFor the Organic Dairy Research Farm

John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production Research Team: Jacki Amante, Makenzie Benander, Brian Godbois, Bella Oleksy, Paul Pellissier, Alyssa Reid, Bryan Vangel

Page 2: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Sustaining the Organic Dairy Research FarmMajor impediments: Imports

EnergyBeddingGrain

Forest resource could provide two of these

Additional ConcernsEnvironmental Footprint and ImpactFinancial Viability – Diversified Income

Required

Page 3: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Energy Demand Total Electricity Use and Distribution

Barns/2007 Milking Lights/ Elec.

Pig barn Process Pump Heat Residence Total% 0.410 0.169 0.124 0.255 0.042 1Kwh 46879 19317 14135 29134 4800 114,266$ $7,032 $2,898 $2,120 $4,370 $720 $17,140

50-65% chilling?

Total Energy Use Electricity Oil Gasoline

kWh kWh gal galHeat Process Heat Transport

Annual 76,013 38,253 810 400

Assumes build-out of house as office and education center

Page 4: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Bedding Requirement135 “Cords”

~ 5 semi tractor-trailer loads

$50-$70 per “Cord”Availability very limited

Estimated weight per “cord”?

Page 5: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

The Forest Resource160 acres of woodlands - UNH campus Master plan

Classic Old-Field New England Woodland

- White Pine - Red Maple - Black Birch - Red Oak - Hemlock

Page 6: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Measuring Biomass and Productivity

Random Plot locations23 plots7m radius plotsDiameter - All stems >5cm Radial increment – 50 stems

Randomly selected Weighted to larger trees

Leaf Productivity – 19 plots

LocationsWest

-98922-98906-99158-99131-99232-99385-99541-99837-99789-99206-98859-98483-99274-99277

9200

9400

9600

9800

10000

10200

10400

10600

10800

11000

11200

-100200 -99700 -99200 -98700 -98200

Page 7: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Results: Species and Diameter Distribution

Classic old field composition with selected large stems of Hemlock and Red Oak

Page 8: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Converting Diameter to BiomassGeneralized Allometric Equations

Different equations relate to different wood densities

Y= a x DBHb

Page 9: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Biomass by Species and Size Class

Page 10: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Biomass Production - Wood

White PineHemlock

DeciduousBiomass production per tree is: Biomass at current diameter minus Biomass at diameter five years ago

These relationships give five year growth as a function of diameter: Total wood NPP = 4.2 (+/- 0.4) Mg/ha.yr

Page 11: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Biomass Production - Foliage

Page 12: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Comparison WithOther StandsBoth foliar and wood production are in rangewith other old fieldstands in New Englandand the Lake States

Aber, J.D., J.M. Melillo, K.J. Nadelhoffer, J. Pastor and R. Boone. 1991. Factors controlling nitrogen cycling and nitrogen saturation in northern temperate forest ecosystems. Ecological Applications 1:303-315

Page 13: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Sustainable Energy Yield 4.2 Mg wood 13 MBTU 100 ha 5400 MBTU ha.yr Mg wood Farm Farm.yr

Energy RequirementsElectricity 114,266 Kwh 389 MBTUHeating Oil 810 gallons 112 MBTUGasoline 400 gallons 50 MBTU

Total 551 MBTU

Assume 50% efficiency in conversion to energy:Required Harvest: ~ 20% of Annual Wood NPP

Page 14: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Assumptions:Mean biomass: 165 Mg/haMean Energy Content: 2145 MBTU/ha50% efficiency in energy conversion and use

Calculation:Available Energy: 1027 MBTU/haFarm Energy Demand: 551 MBTU/yr

Required Harvest: 0.55 ha (~1.2 acres) per year

Acres to Harvest per Year

Page 15: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Sustainable Bedding Yield

Assumptions:

4.2 Mg wood /ha.yr = 420 Mg/farm.yrStandard cord = 1 Mg woodDensity of shavings = ½ density of whole, stacked wood

Calculation:Bedding yield = 840 “cords”/yr

Farm Demand = 135 “cords”/yr

Required Harvest: ~ 16% of Annual Wood NPP

Page 16: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Assumptions:Mean biomass: 165 Mg/ha1 Mg = 1 standard cord1 standard cord = 2 “cord” of shavings

Calculation:330 shaving “cords” per haFarm Demand = 135 “cords” of shavings

Required Harvest = ~0.4 hectare (~0.9 acres) per year

Acres to Harvest per Year

Page 17: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Maximum Use Scenario

Energy: 1.2 acres/yearBedding: 0.9 acres/yearTotal: 2.1 acres/yearTotal Forest Land: 160 acres

Sustainable Rotation Length: 160 acres/(2.1 acres/year) = ~75 years

Total Demand for Energy and Bedding

Page 18: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Energy Yield from Bedding/Manure Mixture

Jerose and Diamond Hill Farm

Estimates for Burley-DeMerritt:50 Jerseys5.6 tons manure/day90 day compost period194,000 BTU per hour1,700 MBTU per year

As low-grade heat

Total farm demand 551 MBTU

Page 19: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Alternate Use Scenarios

1. Cogeneration of Electricity and Heat

Efficiency: 80%

Yield: 4320 MBTU/yr

2. Composting of Shavings/Manure

Page 20: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

Alternate Use Scenarios

Thinnings for Bedding and Compost

Harvest of Select Trees for Solids and Veneer

Page 21: Analysis as a Potential Source of Renewable Energy And Bedding Material For the Organic Dairy Research Farm John Aber and the NR 403 Forest Production

ConclusionsThere is ample forest production on the farm to

meet annual demands for both energy and bedding

Integrated system including:Thinning for beddingCompost for energy and CO2

Greenhouse operation using heat and CO2

Final woodland harvest for solids and veneers

Could enhance financial sustainability of New England Dairy Farms