anchorage of css photo/courtesy brycspublic health (mdph), refugee and immigrant health program...
TRANSCRIPT
Lyn Morland, MSW, MA, Director Bridging Refugee Youth & Children’s Services (BRYCS)
Heidi Ellis, PhD Children’s Hospital Boston and Harvard Medical School Refugee Health Technical Assistance Center (RHTAC)
Dina Birman, PhD University of Illinois, Chicago, BRYCS TA Consultant
This Webinar is made possible by funding from the Office of Refugee Resettlement (DHHS/ACF/ORR)
BRYC
S Ph
oto/
Cour
tesy
of C
SS A
ncho
rage
1
BRYCS and RHTAC are National Technical Assistance Centers for the Federal Office of Refugee Resettlement (DHHS/ACF/ORR), serving refugee and mainstream providers.
BRYCS, a project of Migration and Refugee Services, U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, provides TA and support on refugee children, youth, and families.
RHTAC, a project of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health (MDPH), Refugee and Immigrant Health Program (RIHP), provides TA and support on refugee health and mental health.
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
iSto
ckph
oto.
com
bon
niej
2
Presentation Overview 1. Introductions 2. Risk and Protective Factors for Refugee Youth Adjustment 3. Promising Practices:
• Family Strengthening • Youth Mentoring
4. Question & Answer
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
iSto
ckph
oto.
com
bon
niej
3
Heidi Ellis, PhD Heidi Ellis is the Director of the Children’s Hospital Center for Refugee Trauma, Harvard Medical School, where she teaches and conducts research, and is a key member of the Refugee Health Technical Assistance Center (RHTAC) team. Heidi’s primary focus is on the development and dissemination of interventions for refugee children and their families. Her recent work includes research on the role of stigma and discrimination in the mental health of resettled Somali adolescents, and a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation grant adapting and implementing Trauma Systems Therapy for Somali refugees in a school setting. She will frame our approach today by speaking on risk and protective processes for refugee youth from an ecological perspective.
4
Social-Ecological Model
School Peer Group
Neighborhood
Culture
Family
Individual
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 5
Pre-migration / migration
Disruption of basic scaffolding of childhood
Identity and beliefs targeted
Separation from family, loss
Trauma
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 6
Resettlement
Discrimination
Peer acceptance, acculturative stress, school readiness
Intergenerational trauma, loss, acculturation
Trauma
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 7
Somali Youth Experience Project
N = 144 Ages 11-19,
living in U.S. at least 1 year
Community sample
Boston
Portland Lewiston
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 8
Trauma exposure
Trauma exposedNot exposed94%
•Average 7 traumatic events (range 0-22)
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 9
Consequences of traumatic stress
Social Drug abuse Anti-social behavior Isolation/withdrawal
Psychological Posttraumatic Stress
Disorder ○ Reexperiencing,
Avoidance, Hyperarousal Depression Conduct disorder Emotion Regulation
Academic
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 10
Trauma and adjustment
Trauma Adjustment
Proximal aftermath: Ongoing war stress
Distal aftermath: Ongoing resettlement stress
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 11
Trauma and adjustment
Trauma Adjustment
Proximal aftermath: Ongoing war stress
Distal aftermath: Ongoing resettlement stress
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 12
Trauma, social connection, and adjustment
Trauma
Discrimination
Social Support at
home
PTSD
Proximal aftermath: Ongoing war stress
Distal aftermath: Ongoing resettlement stress
Family Acculturative
stress
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 13
Trauma, social connection, and adjustment
Trauma
Discrimination
Social Support at
home
Depression
Proximal aftermath: Ongoing war stress
Distal aftermath: Ongoing resettlement stress
School Belonging
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 14
Trauma, social connection, and adjustment
Trauma Adjustment
Proximal aftermath: Ongoing war stress
Distal aftermath: Ongoing resettlement stress
Social connection:
Family
School
Community
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 15
Lyn Morland, MSW, MA Lyn Morland, Director of Bridging Refugee Youth & Children’s Services (BRYCS), has 30 years experience serving refugees and immigrants as a social worker and anthropologist, including developing and evaluating mental health programs for refugee youth here in the U.S. and in Asia and Latin America. She currently provides national consultation on refugee and immigrant children, youth, and families. In today’s presentation, she will speak about programs that strengthen families and promote positive youth development.
16
Resilience research suggests that protective factors – supports and opportunities that promote healthy behaviors – are more predictive of adjustment than are risk factors
The Power of Protective
Factors
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
A hopeful message!
risk factors predict negative outcomes in about 20 to 49 percent of a high risk population
protective factors predict positive outcomes in 50 to 80 percent of a high-risk population (Rutter, 1987, 2000; Werner, 2001)
BRYCS Photo / Courtesy of CSS Anchorage
17
Family Attachment and Stability
Social Skills, especially “Bicultural”
Pro-social Relationships (adults, peers)
The Role of Religion
Academic Engagement/Achievement
Community Resources - ECBOs
Protective Factors for Refugee Youth*
* From BRYCS Strengths-Based Programming: The Example of Somali Refugee Youth
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
BRYCS Photo/Youth Arts & Voices
18
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
Social Connections & “Strong Roots”: Programs that Strengthen Families and Build Bridges to the Mainstream
Family Strengthening Programs
Mentoring Programs
BRYCS Photo, Claudia Gilmore
19
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
Family Strengthening Programs BRYCS: Supporting Refugee Families
highlights the Strengthening Families Program and the adaptation of EBPs for refugee families
BRYCS: Helping Refugee Families Stay Together Strengthening Refugee Families and Marriages Programs
Bicultural Skills Training - Entre Dos Mundos/Between Two Worlds, directly addresses the acculturation gap for immigrant families and discrimination, CDC-funded, needs more testing
iStockphoto.com theboone
20
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
EDM Curriculum
The following themes are posed as questions for families to grapple with during sessions and between sessions as homework.
1) How is our family changing, how do we balance cultures?
2) What worries do youth have for parents, parents for youth?
3) When cultural conflict arises, how do we stay united?
4) How do we handle discrimination & support one another?
5) How do youth and parents participate in school?
6) How do we strengthen connections to US-born adults/peers?
7) Where will we be in ten years?
8) Review, integrate, evaluate, graduate, and celebrate! Smokowski & Bacallao 2006
iStockphoto.com MissHibiscus
21
At post-test: 84% completion rate Youth experienced sig. lower levels of aggression,
oppositional defiant behavior, and attention problems Youth and families improved on adaptability, bicultural
support, and bicultural identity integration
One year later: In addition to above improvements, levels of
anxiety/depression, parent-youth conflict, and overall problems were significantly lower
Long-term results were strongest for the group using psychodrama techniques
Results (RCT)
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
Smokowski & Bacallao 2006
BRYCS Photo / Courtesy of CSS Anchorage
22
Dina Birman, PhD Dina Birman, Associate Professor of Psychology, University of Illinois, Chicago, and BRYCS TA Consultant, has conducted research and written extensively on the acculturation and adjustment of refugees and immigrants across generations. She has particularly focused on the differences in acculturation between adolescents and their parents, and the implications of these differences for youth and family adaptation. Among her many roles, she has provided TA on refugee mental health for the Office of Refugee Resettlement, and has consulted on program development for those serving refugee youth and families for over 20 years. Dina will speak today on mentoring programs for refugee youth.
23
Mentoring
Mentoring Goals: Instrumental Mentoring:
tangible assistance Developmental Mentoring: psychological
Mentoring Context: School based Field based
Mentoring Structures: Adult mentors Cross age (older peer, like a sibling) Family mentoring
* Birman, D. & Morland, L. (in press). Immigrant and refugee youth. In D.L. DuBois & M.J. Karcher (Eds.), Handbook of Youth Mentoring, 2nd Edition, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 24
iStockphoto.com abbejon
Consider Acculturation when designing a mentoring program
Behavioral and language acculturation happen first; identification occurs later
Kids adopt the new culture faster than parents (particularly language and behavior)
Identity issues for children and young adults are very complex American identity? Ethnic identity? If their ethnic
group is devalued by the larger society, important but difficult to have a positive ethnic identity
Acculturation Gaps develop between children and parents.
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 25
What does the current research tell us about mentoring as a strategy for refugee youth adjustment? *
Informal mentoring (family, friends, teachers, etc) Most programs are school based, focused on academics Advantages to engaging entire family in field-based
programs; empowering for parents Empower mentees by nurturing them to become mentors
and program leaders Acculturation level should be taken into consideration Programs should address issues unique to refugee youth,
such as family acculturation gaps
* Birman, D. & Morland, L. (in press). Immigrant and refugee youth. In D.L. DuBois & M.J. Karcher (Eds.), Handbook of Youth Mentoring, 2nd Edition, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
iStockphoto.com abbejon
26
Checklist for Practitioners
Consider family strengthening mentoring strategies such as assigning an individual mentor to an entire family or pairing with a mentor-family
Focus initially on instrumental mentoring to facilitate trust and communicate support to parents of their own parenting practices
Explore ways to support native language learning/ maintenance for the youth
Explore ways to assist parents in understanding U.S. schools and peer norms to support their parenting practices.
1. How do you address the acculturation gap between parents and youth?
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 27
Consider prioritizing an instrumental mentoring approach
Consider pairing with U.S. born mentors to provide “institutional agents” to help with orientation to new settings such as school
Consider cross-age paring with mentors who are immigrants but have lived in U.S. longer, and provide opportunities for mentees to later become mentors for newer arrivals
2. What are you doing to serve the unique needs of newly arrived immigrants and refugees?
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 28
Consider prioritizing a developmental mentoring approach, particularly in dealing with issues of cultural/ethnic identity
Adult mentors from the same ethnic/immigrant group, or from a similar immigration background may be particularly useful in serving as role models for how to integrate cultures and identities
Structure mentoring so that it helps support the family to alleviate the negative impact of acculturation gaps that develop over time
3. What are you doing to serve the unique needs of immigrant and refugee youth who have lived in the country longer?
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 29
Promote a school-based instrumental mentoring approach that emphasizes academic support and tutoring
Couple mentoring with academic support for extended periods of time (several years after arrival), particularly for those with backgrounds of no prior literacy or schooling
Utilize a field-based family-focused mentoring approach if literacy is an issue for the entire family.
4. How are you addressing the problem of interrupted schooling?
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 30
Consider developmental mentoring from adults with good training in trauma-informed services to help youth develop a trusting relationship
5. How are you addressing the problem of traumatic experiences?
Utilize cross-ethnic mentoring to provide additional sources of instrumental, emotional, and social support
Require cultural competency training for staff and mentors
6. How can you compensate for the lack of local ethnic community?
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 31
The Go-Betweener Mentoring Program (Culture Connect, Atlanta, GA)
Pairs refugee and immigrant youth ages 7–17 with ethnically and linguistically matched adult mentors, so that newcomer youth can build positive relationships with adults who have themselves successfully navigated the acculturation experience and know what it is like to “go-between” two cultures.
Goals are to prevent or reverse barriers to success, develop self-esteem, help mentees set goals, and instill pride in one's culture and comfort in American culture.
Mentors work with individuals or sibling groups and are encouraged to be a resource for the entire family.
Culture Connect has developed strong partnerships with area refugee resettlement and ethnic community agencies.
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
BRYCS Photo / Courtesy of CSS Anchorage
32
African Immigrant Mentoring (AIM) program (Immigrant and Refugee Community Organization, Portland, OR)
Matches young African refugee and immigrant women (14-23) facing adjustment challenges with adult mentors from the community
Youth who complete a year of mentoring and who graduate from the service-learning course may become peer mentors
Program graduates are provided with leadership opportunities on the agency’s African Youth Advisory Council
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
iStockphoto.com peeterv
33
Principles for community-based youth services based on key risk
and protective factors…
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
BRYCS Photo / Courtesy of CSS Anchorage
34
Principles* 1. Partner with the community from the start
2. Engage entire family, especially parents
3. Strengthen positive ethnic identification and bicultural identity
4. Encourage youth leadership in the program and in their communities
5. Support academic success and career development
6. Recruit and support staff from the community
7. Build bridges with mainstream organizations and businesses
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
* Morland, L. (2007). Promising practices in positive youth development with immigrants and refugees. The Prevention Researcher, 14(4):18-20.
iStockphoto.com Claudiad
35
BRYCS Provides…
National Technical Assistance on refugee children & families
Web site & Clearinghouse www.brycs.org
5,000 resources Spotlight Briefs, Promising
Practices, Resource Lists , Webinars, Toolkits
Monthly “What’s New” BRYCS Publications Monthly Email Bulletin Alert
Consultations
BRYCS is supported by the Office of Refugee Resettlement ACF Grant # 90 RB 0032
National TA Network Experts available by telephone
(888-572-6500) & email ([email protected])
Discussion Listserv Topical trainings by request
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012
BRYCS Photo/Catholic Charities of TN
36
Selected BRYCS Youth Publications
BRYCS Toolkits Growing Up in a New Country: A Positive Youth Development
Toolkit for Working with Refugees and Immigrants Refugee Children in the U.S. Schools: A Toolkit for Teachers
and School Personnel - Refugee and Immigrant Youth and Bullying FAQ
BRYCS Spotlights Adapting Family Strengthening Programs that Build on Assets New Directions in Mentoring Refugee Youth Strengths-Based Programming: Somali Refugee Youth Helping Refugee Youth Find the Right Path Selected Funding Opportunities for Youth Programming
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 37
RHTAC Provides…
National Technical Assistance on refugee health and mental health
Refugee health & mental health resources (www.refugeehealthta.org)
Webinars Continuing Education Credits Community Dialogue discussion forum Trainings Workshops Monthly e-newsletter
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 38
Selected RHTAC Resources
Website www.refugeehealthta.org
Youth and Mental Health webpage
Community Dialogue online discussion forum for refugee-serving providers
BRYCS & RHTAC, Strong Roots & Bright Futures, February 8, 2012 39