annexure-i (referred to in para 2.4) statement showing ... · 5 rallison electricals pvt ltd nov...

22
Report No.9 of 2017 217 Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing loss of potential revenue from rental income from the Air India properties in Hong Kong Property details Vacant since Date on which approval sought for renting out Time assumed for renovation work Date from which actually rented out Period of avoidable vacancy Period of occupancy in between Effective avoidable vacancy period Revenue loss @ HKD 75000 per month Revenue loss equivalent in Indian Rupee at 1HKD=` ` `7.43 Woodland Heights May 2009 November 2009 3 months (Dec 2009 - Feb 2010) November 2012 March 2010 to October 2012 32 months 15 Feb 12 to 15 Aug 12 on ad- hoc basis 6 months 26 months 19,50,000 1,44,88,500 Villa Monte Rosa May 2010 January 2010 3 months (May 2010 – July 2010) November 2015 August 2010 to October 2015 63 months Nil 63 months 47,25,000 3,51,06,750 Total 66,75,000 4,95,95,250 Although the Villa Monte Rosa was let out at a rental of HKD 88000 per month, the monthly rental of HKD 75000 has been assumed for both the properties based on the rent at which the property at Woodland Heights was let out from November 2012.

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

217

An

nex

ure

-I

(Ref

erred

to

in

Pa

ra 2

.4)

Sta

tem

en

t sh

ow

ing

lo

ss o

f p

ote

nti

al

rev

en

ue

fro

m r

en

tal

inco

me

fro

m t

he

Air

In

dia

pro

per

ties

in

Ho

ng

Ko

ng

P

rop

erty

det

ail

s

Va

can

t

sin

ce

Da

te o

n w

hic

h

ap

pro

val

sou

gh

t fo

r

ren

tin

g o

ut

Tim

e

ass

um

ed f

or

ren

ovati

on

work

Da

te f

rom

wh

ich

act

uall

y

ren

ted

ou

t

Per

iod

of

av

oid

ab

le

vaca

ncy

Per

iod

of

occ

up

an

cy

in

bet

wee

n

Eff

ecti

ve

av

oid

ab

le

va

can

cy

per

iod

Rev

enu

e

loss

@

HK

D 7

500

0

per

mo

nth

Rev

enu

e lo

ss

equ

ivale

nt

in

Ind

ian

Ru

pee

at

1H

KD

=`̀̀̀7.4

3

Wo

odla

nd

Hei

gh

ts

May

20

09

Novem

ber

200

9

3 m

onth

s

(Dec

20

09 -

Feb

20

10)

Novem

ber

20

12

Mar

ch

20

10 t

o

Oct

ob

er

20

12

32

mo

nth

s

15 F

eb 1

2

to 1

5 A

ug

12

on a

d-

ho

c b

asis

6 m

onth

s

26

mon

ths

19

,50,0

00

1,4

4,8

8,5

00

Vil

la

Mo

nte

Ro

sa

May

20

10

Jan

uar

y 2

01

0

3 m

onth

s

(May 2

010 –

July

20

10)

Novem

ber

20

15

Au

gu

st

20

10 t

o

Oct

ob

er

20

15

63

mo

nth

s

Nil

6

3

mon

ths

47

,25,0

00

3,5

1,0

6,7

50

To

tal

66

,75,0

00

4,9

5,9

5,2

50

Alt

ho

ugh

the

Vil

la M

onte

Ro

sa w

as l

et o

ut

at a

ren

tal

of

HK

D 8

80

00

per

mo

nth

, th

e m

onth

ly r

enta

l of

HK

D 7

500

0 h

as b

een a

ssu

med

fo

r bo

th t

he

pro

per

ties

bas

ed o

n t

he

rent

at w

hic

h t

he

pro

per

ty a

t W

oo

dla

nd H

eights

was

let

out

fro

m N

ovem

ber

20

12

.

Page 2: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No. of 2017

Annexure-II

(As referred to in Para 7.1.2)

Sample selection for Audit of Non-performing assets

SL.

No.

Clients Name Month

of NPA

Branch Asset Classification NPA

(`̀̀̀ in

Crore)

1 Ashapura Garments Ltd Jun-15 Mumbai Sub-Standard1 24.00

2 Arch Pharmalabs Ltd Nov-13 Mumbai Doubtful2 -2 17.71

3 Shashi distilleries pvt ltd. Mar-15 Bangalore Sub-Standard 17.97

4 Innoventive Industries Ltd Apr-14 Pune Doubtful-1 14.26

5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov-11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20

6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar-16 Indore Sub-Standard 13.04

7 Aegan Batteries LTD Jan-16 Hosur Sub-Standard 10.74

8 Ankur Drugs & Pharma Ltd. May-11 Mumbai Loss 8.91

9 VKS Projects Ltd Mar-14 Mumbai Doubtful-1 7.98

10 Arvind Remedies LTD Apr-15 Chennai Sub-Standard 7.61

11 Rajat PharmaChem Ltd. Feb-09 Mumbai Loss 7.22

12 Accord Industries Jun-15 Ahmedabad Sub-Standard 6.80

13 Uniword telecom Ltd. Aug-10 Delhi Loss 6.23

14 Varia Engineering Works

PVT LTD

May-15 Ahmedabad Sub-Standard 5.23

15 Jupiter Bioscience Ltd Sep-11 Hyderabad Doubtful - 3 4.95

16 Avon Organics Ltd Mar-14 Mumbai Doubtful-1 4.83

17 Ramalinga Fabrics Pvt Ltd Sep-12 Coimbatore Doubtful-2 4.07

18 Pioneer Alloy Castings Ltd Jul-11 Chennai Doubtful - 3 4.05

19 ICOMM Tele Ltd Nov-12 Hyderabad Doubtful -2 3.98

20 Bharat Logitrans Ltd. Jan-09 Delhi Doubtful - 3 3.85

21 DF Forgings LTD Nov-15 Bangalore Sub-Standard 3.63

22 Supreme Tex Mart LTD Sep-15 Ludhiana Sub-Standard 3.44

23 Priyadarshini Spinning Mills May-12 Hyderabad Doubtful - 2 3.21

24 Anus Laboratories Ltd Nov-12 Hyderabad Doubtful -2 2.91

25 Raagam Mines Pvt Ltd Nov-15 Hyderabad Sub-Standard 3.19

26 R S Electricals Ltd Dec-15 Delhi Sub-Standard 2.59

27 Delta Fashions Ltd. Apr-11 Mumbai Doubtful - 3 2.50

28 Paper Prints (I) Pvt Ltd. Aug-09 Mumbai Loss 2.49

29 Sri Balaji Foundries Pvt.Ltd. Jul-08 Bangalore Doubtful - 3 2.45

30 G S Oils Ltd Dec-12 Hyderabad Doubtful -2 2.44

31 Multi Flex Lami Print Ltd Mar-14 Mumbai Doubtful-1 2.23

32 Unibios Labarotaries Ltd Nov-14 Mumbai Doubtful-1 2.14

1 An asset which has been classified as NPA for a period not exceeding 18 months

2 An asset which remains a sub-standard asset for a period exceeding 18 months.

Page 3: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No.9 of 2017

219

SL.

No.

Clients Name Month

of NPA

Branch Asset Classification NPA

(`̀̀̀ in

Crore)

33 Amar Remedies Ltd Nov-13 Mumbai Doubtful -2 2.14

34 BSPN Industries Pvt Ltd Mar-14 Hyderabad Sub-Standard 2.00

35 Fast Flying Fashions India

(P) Ltd.

Aug-12 Coimbatore Doubtful-2 1.93

36 Karnataka Bank/Classic

Cottage International

Apr-07 Bangalore Doubtful - 3 1.90

37 Calyx Chemicals &

Pharmaceuticals Ltd

Jun-15 Mumbai Sub-Standard 1.86

38 Mindlogicx Infratec Limited Mar-15 Bangalore Sub-Standard 1.65

39 Prasad Impex Pvt Ltd Feb-16 Mumbai Sub-Standard 2.08

40 Unijules Lifesciences Ltd Nov-13 Mumbai Doubtful -2 1.62

41 RJ Spinning Mills India Pvt

Ltd

Oct-13 Coimbatore Sub-Standard 1.52

42 RGC Construction (P) Ltd. Jan-09 Hyderabad Loss 1.50

43 Central Electricals and

Electronics

Mar-16 Mumbai Sub-Standard 1.35

44 Carline Pressings PvtLtd Oct-12 Pune Loss 1.21

45 S R Steels Jun-15 Ludhiana Sub-Standard 1.05

Page 4: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

220

An

nex

ure

-III

(As

refe

rre

d t

o i

n P

ara

7.1

.5)

Dev

iati

on

s n

oti

ced

in

th

e N

PA

acco

un

ts

SL

.

No

. C

LIE

NT

NA

ME

D

ate

of

San

ctio

n

Da

te o

f

last

Ren

ewa

l

Mo

nth

of

NP

A

NP

A

Am

ou

nt

(`̀̀̀ i

n

cro

re)

Dev

iati

on

s n

oti

ced

in

th

e N

PA

acc

ou

nts

San

ctio

n

in e

xce

ss

of

MP

BF

San

ctio

n

of

lim

its

wit

ho

ut

con

sid

erin

g

lim

its

alr

ead

y

avail

ed f

rom

oth

er

fact

ori

ng

com

pan

ies

Waiv

er o

f

UT

L/l

ack

of

dir

ect

com

mu

nic

at

ion

wit

h

cust

om

ers

Fa

cto

rin

g

on

All

ied

/

rela

ted

pa

rtie

s

Dis

bu

rse

men

t o

f

fun

ds

in

dev

iati

on

to

san

ctio

n

term

s

No

n

red

uct

ion

of

lim

its

des

pit

e

clea

r si

gn

s

of

inci

pie

nt

sick

nes

s

Oth

er

issu

es

1

Ash

apura

Gar

ments

Ltd

D

ec-0

6

Ap

r-1

4

Jun

-15

24.0

0

Y

es

2

Arc

h P

har

mal

abs

Ltd

M

ay-0

3

Marc

h-

12

No

v-

13

17.7

1

Y

es

3

Inn

oven

tive

Ind

ust

ries

Ltd

S

ep-0

5

Jul-

13

Ap

r-1

4

14.2

6

Yes

Y

es

Yes

4

Aeg

an B

atte

ries

LT

D

Au

g-1

4

Ja

n-1

6

10.6

9

Yes

Y

es

5

VK

S P

roje

cts

Ltd

A

pr-

13

Mar

-

14

7.9

8

Y

es

6

Arv

ind

Rem

edie

s

LT

D

No

v-0

7

Jul-

14

Ap

r-1

5

7.6

1

Yes

Y

es

7

Acc

ord

Ind

ust

ries

N

ov-1

1

Jan

-14

Jun

-15

6.8

0

Y

es

8

Un

iwo

rd t

elec

om

Ltd

. O

ct-0

7

Oct

-08

Au

g-

10

OT

S3

Yes

9

Var

ia E

ngin

eeri

ng

Work

s S

ep-1

4

May-

15

5.0

8

Y

es

Y

es

Y

es

10

Jupit

er B

iosc

inec

e

Ltd

S

ep-0

6

Jul-

10

Sep

-11

4

.24

Yes

Y

es

11

Avo

n O

rgan

ics

Ltd

S

ep-1

0

May-1

2

Mar

-

14

4.8

3

Yes

3 A

mou

nt

reco

ver

ed u

nd

er O

TS

wa

s `̀̀̀1

.60

cro

re a

ga

inst

th

e b

oo

k l

iab

ilit

y o

f `̀̀̀7

.69

cro

re.

Page 5: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

221

SL

.

No

. C

LIE

NT

NA

ME

D

ate

of

San

ctio

n

Da

te o

f

last

Ren

ewa

l

Mo

nth

of

NP

A

NP

A

Am

ou

nt

(`̀̀̀ i

n

cro

re)

Dev

iati

on

s n

oti

ced

in

th

e N

PA

acc

ou

nts

San

ctio

n

in e

xce

ss

of

MP

BF

San

ctio

n

of

lim

its

wit

ho

ut

con

sid

erin

g

lim

its

alr

ead

y

avail

ed f

rom

oth

er

fact

ori

ng

com

pan

ies

Waiv

er o

f

UT

L/l

ack

of

dir

ect

com

mu

nic

at

ion

wit

h

cust

om

ers

Fa

cto

rin

g

on

All

ied

/

rela

ted

pa

rtie

s

Dis

bu

rse

men

t o

f

fun

ds

in

dev

iati

on

to

san

ctio

n

term

s

No

n

red

uct

ion

of

lim

its

des

pit

e

clea

r si

gn

s

of

inci

pie

nt

sick

nes

s

Oth

er

issu

es

12

Ram

alin

ga

Fab

rics

Pvt

Ltd

Ju

n-1

1

S

ep-1

2

4.0

7

Y

es

13

ICO

MM

Tel

e L

td

May-1

2

No

v-

12

4.2

6

Yes

14

DF

Fo

rgin

s L

TD

M

ar-1

4

No

v-

15

3.6

3

Yes

15

Su

pre

me

Tex

Mar

t

LT

D

Feb

-13

A

ug-1

4

Sep

-15

3

.44

Yes

16

An

us

Lab

ora

tori

es

Ltd

A

pr-

02

Mar

-12

N

ov-

12

2.9

1

Yes

17

Raa

gam

Min

es P

vt

Ltd

O

ct-1

4

No

v-

15

2.8

7

Yes

18

Pap

er P

rints

(I)

Pvt

Ltd

. F

eb-0

8

Au

g-

09

2.4

9

Yes

Y

es

19

Sri

Bal

aji

Fo

un

dri

es

Pvt.

Ltd

. Ja

n-0

8

Au

g-

08

2.4

4

Y

es

Y

es

20

G S

Oil

s L

td

Jul-

06

Oct

-11

Dec

-12

2.4

4

Y

es

21

Mu

lti

Fle

x L

ami

Pri

nt

Ltd

A

pr-

13

Mar

-

14

2.4

1

Y

es

Y

es

22

Am

ar R

emed

ies

Ltd

M

ay-1

2

No

v-

13

2.1

4

Y

es

Yes

23

Fas

t F

lyin

g F

ash

ion

s

India

(P

) D

ec-1

0

Au

g-

12

1.9

3

Yes

24

Cal

yx C

hem

ical

s &

Ph

arm

aceu

tica

ls L

td

Au

g-0

2

Jul-

13

Jun

-15

1.7

0

Yes

Page 6: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

222

SL

.

No

. C

LIE

NT

NA

ME

D

ate

of

San

ctio

n

Da

te o

f

last

Ren

ewa

l

Mo

nth

of

NP

A

NP

A

Am

ou

nt

(`̀̀̀ i

n

cro

re)

Dev

iati

on

s n

oti

ced

in

th

e N

PA

acc

ou

nts

San

ctio

n

in e

xce

ss

of

MP

BF

San

ctio

n

of

lim

its

wit

ho

ut

con

sid

erin

g

lim

its

alr

ead

y

avail

ed f

rom

oth

er

fact

ori

ng

com

pan

ies

Waiv

er o

f

UT

L/l

ack

of

dir

ect

com

mu

nic

at

ion

wit

h

cust

om

ers

Fa

cto

rin

g

on

All

ied

/

rela

ted

pa

rtie

s

Dis

bu

rse

men

t o

f

fun

ds

in

dev

iati

on

to

san

ctio

n

term

s

No

n

red

uct

ion

of

lim

its

des

pit

e

clea

r si

gn

s

of

inci

pie

nt

sick

nes

s

Oth

er

issu

es

25

RJ

Spin

nin

g M

ills

India

Pvt

Ltd

S

ep-1

0

No

v-1

1

Oct

-13

OT

S4

Yes

26

RG

C C

on

stru

ctio

n

(P)

Ltd

. D

ec-0

5

Dec

-07

Ja

n-0

9

1.5

0

Yes

Y

es

27

Cen

tral

Ele

ctri

cals

and E

lect

ron

ics

May-1

5

Mar

-

16

0.7

6

Yes

Yes

28

Car

lin

e P

ress

ings

Pvt

Ltd

O

ct-0

2

Mar

-12

O

ct-1

2

1.2

1

Y

es

T

OT

AL

14

3.4

0

5

6

8

8

3

2

4

5

4 A

mou

nt

reco

vere

d u

nd

er O

TS

wa

s `̀̀̀1.8

0 c

rore

ag

ain

st t

he

bo

ok l

iabil

ity

of `̀̀̀2

.07

cro

re

Page 7: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

223

An

nex

ure

IV

(As

refe

rre

d t

o i

n P

ara

7.1

.5.1

(I))

Ca

ses

wh

ere

fact

ori

ng

lim

its

wer

e sa

ncti

on

ed/d

isb

urs

ed t

o C

lien

ts i

n e

xce

ss o

f M

axim

um

Per

mis

sib

le B

an

kin

g F

ina

nce

(M

PB

F)

( `̀̀̀ i

n C

rore

)

Sl.

No.

Na

me

of

the

Cli

ent

T

yp

e o

f

Fa

cto

rin

g

Fa

cili

ty

Date

of

firs

t

san

ctio

n

Da

te o

f

last

Ren

ewal

Da

te o

f

NP

A

Ass

esse

d

MP

BF

Wo

rkin

g

Ca

pit

al

Lim

its

san

ctio

ned

/

av

ail

ed

Lim

its

act

uall

y

Sa

nct

ion

ed

Exce

ss

Lim

its

san

ctio

ned

bey

on

d

MP

BF

FIU

as

on

Da

te

of

NP

A

1

Fas

t F

lyin

g F

ash

ion

s S

BF

D

ec 2

01

0

Nil

A

ug-2

01

2

0.7

0

0.7

0

2.0

0

2.0

0

1.9

3

2

Raa

gam

Min

es P

vt

Ltd

SB

F

Oct

-201

4

Nil

N

ov-2

015

1

.21

0.0

0

4.0

0

2.7

9

3.1

9

3

Su

pre

me

Tex

Mar

t

LT

D

SB

F

Feb

-201

3

Au

g-2

01

4

Sep

-20

15

18

0.0

0

18

3.1

9

5.0

0

5.0

0

3.4

8

4

Aeg

an B

atte

ries

LT

D

SB

F

Au

g-2

014

N

il

Jan-2

01

6

29

.00

29

.17

10

.00

10.0

0

11

.72

5

Inn

oven

tive

Ind

ust

ries

Ltd

SB

F

Sep

-200

5

Jul-

20

13

Ap

r-2

014

30

0.0

0

45

0.0

0

15

.50

15.5

0

14

.52

To

tal

3

5.2

9

34

.84

Page 8: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

224

An

nex

ure

V

(As

refe

rred

to

in

Para

7.1

.5.1

(II

))

Case

s w

her

e fa

cto

rin

g l

imit

s w

ere

san

ctio

ned

wit

hou

t a

scert

ain

ing t

he

fact

ori

ng

lim

its

alr

ead

y a

va

iled

by

th

e cl

ien

ts

( `̀̀̀ i

n c

rore

)

Sl.

No

.

Na

me

of

the

Cli

ent

Da

te o

f

fres

h

san

ctio

n

Da

te o

f

last

san

cti

on

/

ren

ewa

l

Wh

eth

er

fact

ori

ng

alr

ea

dy

ava

iled

is

kn

ow

n o

r

no

t

Pro

ject

ed

Tu

rno

ver

MP

BF

as

per

TO

met

ho

d

Ass

esse

d

MP

BF

as

per

CM

A

Fa

cto

rin

g

lim

it

alr

ead

y

ava

iled

Wo

rkin

g

Ca

pit

al

Lim

its

fro

m

Ba

nk

s

To

tal

lim

its

ava

iled

PP

Lim

its

san

ctio

ne

d b

y t

he

com

pa

ny

Ex

cess

fin

an

cin

g

by

th

e

com

pa

ny

Da

te

of

NP

A

FIU

as

on

Da

te

of

NP

A

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

(9+

10

) 1

3

14

15

16

1

Am

ar

Rem

edie

s

May-1

2

No

ren

ewal

No

6

90

.14

138

.03

16

0.0

0

16

.00

15

9.0

0

17

5.0

0

8.0

0

8.0

0

No

v-

13

2.2

4

2

Mu

lti

Fle

x

Lam

i P

rint

Ltd

Apr-

13

N

o

renew

al

Yes

2

40

.90

48

.18

72

.00

25

.00

65

.61

90

.61

5.0

0

5.0

0

Mar

-

14

2.4

1

3

Car

lin

e

Pre

ssin

gs

Oct

-02

Mar

-12

Y

es

42

.28

8.4

6

NA

2

.50

9.9

6

12

.46

1.5

0

1.5

0

Oct

-

12

1.3

6

4

Inno

ven

tive

S

ep-0

5

Jul-

13

Yes

9

89

.33

197

.87

30

0.0

0

16

4.8

9

45

0.0

0

61

4.8

9

15

.50

15

.50

Ap

r-

14

14

.52

5

Ash

apura

Gar

men

ts

Dec

-06

Ap

r-14

Y

es

80

0.6

0

160

.12

20

1.0

0

28

.50

19

9.9

6

22

8.4

6

23

.00

23

.00

Jun

-

15

24

.00

6

Arc

h

Ph

arm

alab

s

May-0

3

Mar

-12

N

o

14

84

.75

296

.95

NA

--

- 6

91

.50

69

1.5

0

18

.00

18

.00

No

v-

13

17

.76

T

ota

l

71

.00

71

.00

6

2.2

9

Page 9: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

225

An

nex

ure

VI

(As

refe

rre

d t

o i

n P

ara

7.1

.5.5

)

Ca

ses

wh

ere

fact

ori

ng

lim

its

con

tin

ued

des

pit

e in

cip

ien

t si

ck

nes

s o

f C

lien

t

( `̀̀̀ i

n c

rore

)

Sl.

No

Na

me

of

the

Cli

ent

Typ

e o

f

Fa

cto

rin

g

Faci

lity

Last

PP

Lim

it

san

ctio

ned

Date

on

wh

ich

Inci

pie

nt

sick

nes

s w

as

iden

tifi

ed

Am

ou

nt

of

Pay

men

ts

rele

ase

d a

fter

sick

nes

s

Da

te o

f

NP

A

FIU

as

on

Da

te o

f

NP

A

Rem

ark

s

1

Avon

Org

anic

s L

td

PB

D

5

Jul-

13

4.7

7

Mar

-20

14

5.0

8

Wo

rkin

g C

apit

al B

anker

of

the

Cli

ent

was

cla

ssif

ied a

s

NP

A i

n J

uly

20

13

2

Am

ar R

emed

ies

Ltd

S

BF

8

Ja

n-1

3

2.9

7

No

v-

201

3

2.2

4

Wo

rkin

g C

apit

al B

anker

of

the

Cli

ent

was

cla

ssif

ied a

s

NP

A i

n D

ecem

ber

20

12

3

Cal

yx C

hem

ical

s &

Ph

arm

aceu

tica

ls L

td

PB

D

2.5

D

ec-1

3

1.8

4

Jun

-201

5

2.0

4

Cli

ent

refe

rred

it

self

to

CD

R

in

Jan

uar

y

201

4

/

Feb

ruar

y

201

4.

Can

ara

ban

k

info

rmed

ab

out

the

irre

gu

lari

ties

in

the

acco

unt

on 0

5.0

2.2

013

4

Inno

ven

tive

Indu

stri

es L

td

SB

F

15

.5

Sep

-13

5.3

A

pr-

20

14

14

.52

Cli

ent

refe

rred

it

self

to

CD

R

in

Oct

ob

er

20

13.

Fac

tori

ng

was

p

erm

itte

d

des

pit

e th

is

and

amo

unts

agai

nst

fa

cto

red

in

voic

es

cred

ited

to

W

ork

ing

Cap

ital

Ban

ker

s

1

4.8

8

2

3.8

8

Page 10: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No. of 2017

226

Annexure VII

(Referred to in Para 11.2)

Statement showing loss of generation

Month

Possible

Generation

Hours

(Hours)

Stoppage

due to

external

factors

(Hours)

Net

Possible

Generation

Hours

(Hours)

Possible

Generation

(KWH)

Possible

Generation

(MU)

Rate

per

KWH

(`̀̀̀ per

KWH)

Loss of

(`̀̀̀ in

crore)

(A) (B) (C ) (D)=(B-C) (E)=(D*2*1000) (F)=(E/10^6) (G) (H)=(E*G)

Jun-13 720.00 720.00 14,40,000.00 1.44 4.37 0.63

Jul-13 120.00 120.00 2,40,000.00 0.24 4.37 0.11

Nov-

13 720.00 720.00 14,40,000.00 1.44 4.37 0.63

Dec-

13 744.00 100.00 644.00 12,88,000.00 1.29 4.37 0.56

Jan-14 744.00 13.75 730.25 14,60,500.00 1.46 4.37 0.64

Feb-14 672.00 1.75 670.25 13,40,500.00 1.34 4.37 0.59

Mar-

14 744.00 75.42 668.58 13,37,166.67 1.34 4.37 0.58

Apr-14 720.00 4.17 715.83 14,31,666.67 1.43 4.47 0.64

May-

14 744.00 744.00 14,88,000.00 1.49 4.47 0.67

Jun-14 720.00 720.00 14,40,000.00 1.44 4.47 0.644

Jul-14 744.00 744.00 14,88,000.00 1.49 4.47 0.67

Aug-

14 744.00 69.75 674.25 13,48,500.00 1.35 4.47 0.60

Sep-14 720.00 69.75 650.25 13,00,500.00 1.30 4.47 0.58

Oct-14 744.00 744.00 14,88,000.00 1.49 4.47 0.67

Nov-

14 432.00 432.00 8,64,000.00 0.86 4.47 0.39

Total 10,032.00 334.58 9,697.42 193,94,833.33 19.39 8.60

Page 11: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No.9 of 2017

227

Annexure VIII

(Referred to in Para 12.4.4)

Statement showing the detail of 27 stretches covering 37 projects and 23 toll plazas

Sl.

no.

Name of stretch Name of project Name of toll

plaza

State

1 Lucknow Kanpur

(Km11.000 to Km 59.000)

1. EW-2

2. EW-8

3. EW-9

Nawabganj Uttar Pradesh

2 Lucknow Ranimau

(Km 8.250 to Km 70.000)

1. LMNHP-EW-II-WB-1

2. LMNHP-EW-II-WB-2

Ahmedpur,

(Km53.000)

Uttar Pradesh

3 Ranimau-Faizabad

(Km 70.00 to Km 135.00)

1. LMNHP-EW-II-WB-2

2. LMNHP-EW-III-WB-3

Ronahi

(Km107.000)

Uttar Pradesh

4 Ayodhya- Basti

(Km 135.00 to Km 190.0)

1. Package LMNHP-4

2. Package LMNHP-5

Choukadi,

(Km 163.000)

Uttar Pradesh

5 Ayodhya- Basti

(Km 190.00 to Km 252.86) 1.Package LMNHP-5

2.Package LMNHP-6

Mandaw Nagar

(Km 198.000)

Uttar Pradesh

6 Gorakhpur Kasia

(Km279.80 to Km 320.80) 1.Package LMNHP-7

2.Package LMNHP-8

Muzaina Hatim

(Km 307.000)

Uttar Pradesh

7 Kasia UP Border

(Km320.80 to Km366.80)

LMNHP-8 Salemgarh

(Km 357.000)

Uttar Pradesh

8 Varanasi Mohania

(Km 317 to Km 319, Km

319 to Km 21.000 and

Km21.000 to Km 46.000)

Varanasi-Mohania Daffi

(Km 12.000)

Uttar Pradesh

9 Tundla- Makanpur Agra Makanpur Tundla Uttar Pradesh

10 Jallandhar-Mukerian

(Km 4.230 to Km 70.000)

1.Jallandhar- Bhogpur /

2.Bhogpur-Mukerian

Chollang

(Km 34.500)

Punjab

11 Mukerian-Madhopur

(Km 70.000 to Km 117.750/

Km 4.000 to Km 16.350)

1.Mukerian –Pathankot

2.Pathankot-Madhopur

Harsh Manesar

(Km84.500)

Punjab

12 Madhopur-Vijaypur

(Km 16.350 to Km 80.00)

1.Madhopur-Kunjwani

2.Kunjwani-Vijaypur

Rajbagh

(Km43.600)

Punjab

13 Vijaypur-Jammu/Jammu

bypass

(Km 80.00 to Km 97.200/

Km00.000 to Km 15.000)

Vijaypur-Jammu/Jammu

bypass

Thandikui

(Km 88.300)

Jammu &

Kashmir

Page 12: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No. of 2017

228

14 Swaroopganj- Pindwara

(Km 249.700 to Km 264.000

of NH-14 and Km 0.00 to

Km57.00 of NH-76)

1.Swaroopganj- Bekaria

2.Bekaria- Gogunda

Malhera

(Km11.200)

Rajasthan

15 Poindwara –Udaipur

(Km 57.000 to 104.724)

1.Bekaria- Gogunda

2.Gogunda to Udaipur

Gogunda

(64.200)

Rajasthan

16 Chittorgarh Bypass

(Km 159.0 to Km 168.50)

Chittorgarh Bypass Rithola

Rajasthan

17 Agra bypass Agra bypass No tolling as the

stretch is under

construction

Uttar Pradesh

18 Jhansi- Lakhnadon

(Km99.05 to Km 160.000)

1.Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C-3)

2.Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C-4)

Malthone

(Km142.319)

Madhya Pradesh

19 Jhansi- Lakhnadon

(Km 160.0 to Km 219.49)

1. Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C4)

2. Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C5)

Mehar

(Km 187.000)

Madhya Pradesh

20 Jhansi- Lakhnadon Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C-6) No tolling Madhya Pradesh

21 Jhansi- Lakhnadon

(Km 262.739 to Km 309.0)

Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C-7) Titarpani

(Km294.500)

Madhya Pradesh

22 Jhansi- Lakhnadon Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C-8) No tolling Madhya Pradesh

23 Jhansi- Lakhnadon Jhansi- Lakhnadon (C-9) Khamaria Madhya Pradesh

24 Lucknow-Bypass Lucknow-Bypass No toll plaza Uttar Pradesh

25 Ashapur-Tharivan

(Km 38.00 to Km 94.020)

Ashapur-Tharivan Chittora toll plaza

(Km71.000)

Uttar Pradesh

26 Etawah-Sikandra

(Km 321.00 to Km 393.0)

Etawah-Sikandra Anantram toll

plaza

Uttar Pradesh

27 Udaipur-Kherwara Udaipur-Kherwara Paduna toll plaza Rajasthan

Page 13: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

229

An

nex

ure

– I

X

(Ref

erred

in

Pa

ra 1

2.4

.5.1

(II

))

Sta

tem

en

t sh

ow

ing t

he

no

n r

eali

sati

on

of

use

r fe

e d

ue

to d

ela

y i

n i

ssu

e o

f to

ll f

ee n

oti

fica

tion

S

l.

No

Na

me

of

the

stre

tch

Na

me

of

Toll

Pla

za

Act

ual

date

o

f

com

ple

tion

o

f

stre

tch

/

Sch

edu

led

d

ate

for

pu

bli

cati

on

of

toll

fe

e

no

tifi

cati

on

Sch

edu

led

da

te

of

sta

rt

of

toll

fe

e

coll

ecti

on

Act

ual

da

te

of

pu

bli

cati

on

of

toll

fe

e

no

tifi

cati

on

Del

ay

in

da

ys

Am

ou

nt

of

no

n

rea

liza

tio

n

of

toll

(`̀̀̀ i

n

cro

re)

Rea

son

s

1

Luck

no

w

Kan

pu

r

Naw

abgan

j F

ebru

ary 2

00

6

1 A

pri

l 2

00

6

18

Mar

ch

200

9

35

mo

nth

s

and 1

8

days

57

.59

NH

AI

pro

vid

ed o

ne

file

rel

atin

g t

o t

he

toll

fe

e n

oti

fica

tio

n

of

the

stre

tch

star

tin

g f

rom

20

11

, th

us

audit

co

uld

no

t

reco

gn

ize

the

reas

on

for

del

ay in

to

ll

no

tifi

cati

on f

or

35 m

onth

s an

d 1

8 d

ays.

2

Luck

no

w

Ran

imau

Ah

med

pur

Sep

t 2

01

1

15

No

vem

ber

20

11

14

Dec

emb

er

201

2

13

mo

nth

s 42

.04

Pro

po

sal

wer

e se

nt

four

tim

es

to

MoR

TH

an

d

the

sam

e w

ere

retu

rned

,

fin

ally

af

ter

forw

ardin

g

pro

po

sal

fift

h

tim

e th

e n

oti

fica

tio

n w

as p

ub

lish

ed w

ith

a d

elay

o

f 24

m

onth

s fr

om

dat

e o

f

init

iati

on o

f fi

rst

pro

posa

l.

3

Ayo

dh

ya-

Bas

ti

Ch

ou

kad

i

31

Dec

emb

er

20

11

15

Feb

ruar

y

20

12

1 M

arch

201

2

15

days

1.2

5

Toll

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

for

the

enti

re l

ength

of

55 k

m w

as n

oti

fied

on

1 M

arch

201

2

wit

h a

del

ay o

f 1

3 m

on

ths

fro

m d

ate

of

init

iati

on o

f fi

rst

pro

posa

l.

4

Ayo

dh

ya-

Bas

ti

Man

daw

Nag

ar

31

Dec

emb

er

20

11

15

Feb

ruar

y

20

12

6 A

ugu

st

201

2

17

2 d

ays

17

.62

NH

AI

sub

mit

ted

p

rop

osa

ls

five

tim

es

for

pu

bli

cati

on

of

toll

fe

e n

oti

fica

tion.

Fin

ally

F

ee

no

tifi

cati

on

was

ap

pro

ved

by

the

Min

iste

r of

MoR

TH

on

17

No

vem

ber

2

011.

Ho

wev

er,

the

sam

e

was

pu

bli

shed

on 6

Au

gu

st 2

01

2 w

ith

a

del

ay o

f 9

mo

nth

s fr

om

dat

e o

f ap

pro

val

of

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

as

the

Mo

RT

H/N

HA

I

too

k

nin

e m

on

ths

in

pre

par

atio

n

of

Page 14: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

230

Hin

di

ver

sio

n o

f fe

e n

oti

fica

tio

n.

Th

us,

toll

fee

noti

fica

tio

n f

or

the

enti

re l

ength

of

62

.86

km

was

no

tifi

ed w

ith a

del

ay

of

18 m

on

ths

from

dat

e of

init

iati

on

of

firs

t p

roposa

l

5

Go

rakhp

ur

Kas

ia

Mu

zain

a

Hat

im

7 M

ay 2

01

2

21

Jun

e 2

01

2

3 J

anuar

y

201

3

19

6 d

ays

13

.05

Rea

son w

as n

on

fu

lfil

lmen

t o

f cr

iter

ia

of

60

km

o

f d

ista

nce

fr

om

oth

er

toll

pla

za a

nd

qu

erie

s ra

ised

by t

he

MoR

TH

Fin

ally

to

ll f

ee n

oti

fica

tio

n f

or

the

enti

re

len

gth

of

41.0

0 km

was

no

tifi

ed on 3

Janu

ary 2

01

3 w

ith a

del

ay o

f 1

3 m

on

ths

fro

m d

ate

of

init

iati

on o

f fi

rst

pro

po

sal.

6

Chit

torg

ar

h B

yp

ass

Rit

hola

O

cto

ber

20

09

15 D

ecem

ber

20

09

24

Dec

emb

er

200

9

9 d

ays

0.7

9

NH

AI

sub

mit

ted

the

pro

posa

l fo

r is

sue

of

toll

fee

noti

fica

tio

n f

or

toll

coll

ecti

on

at R

ithola

to

ll p

laza

of

Ch

itto

rgar

h b

y

pas

s o

n 2

2.9

.200

9 a

nd

fu

rther

rep

lied

by

NH

AI

on

15.1

0.2

00

9

on

th

e qu

ery

rais

ed

by

Mo

RT

H.

Pro

po

sal

was

clea

red

by t

he

Fin

ance

win

g o

f M

oR

TH

on

3.1

1 2

00

9,

bu

t th

e fi

le w

as m

ispla

ced

in M

oR

TH

. T

he

file

was

rec

reat

ed a

nd

clea

red

th

e sa

me

by

Fin

ance

w

ing

of

MoR

TH

agai

n o

n 2

6.1

1.2

00

9.

Min

iste

r,

MoR

TH

ap

pro

ved

th

e p

rop

osa

l o

n

30

.11.2

00

9

and

pu

bli

shed

th

e fe

e

no

tifi

cati

on o

n 2

4.1

2.2

00

9.

7

Jhan

si-

Lakhn

ado

n (

C-3

)/

Jhan

si-

Lakhn

ado

n (

C-4

)

Mal

thone

28

Mar

ch 2

01

2

12 M

ay 2

01

2

21

Feb

ruar

y

201

3

28

4 d

ays

5.2

0

Th

e m

ain

rea

son

s fo

r d

elay

in

iss

ue

of

toll

no

tifi

cati

on w

as d

elay

in

sub

mit

tin

g

the

pro

po

sal

of

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

by

Reg

ion

al o

ffic

e, B

ho

pal

to N

HA

I, H

qrs

.

and

fu

rth

er

del

ay

of

13

4

days

(19.0

8.2

01

2

- 3

1.1

2.2

01

2)

for

sub

mit

ting t

he

pro

po

sal

to M

oR

TH

.

Page 15: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

231

8

Jhan

si-

Lakhn

ado

n (

C-4

)/

Jhan

si-

Lakhn

ado

n (

C-5

)

Meh

ar

31

. O

cto

ber

20

12

15 D

ecem

ber

20

12

21

Feb

ruar

y

201

3

68

days

1.2

1

Th

e pro

po

sal

for

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

w

as

mo

ved

b

y R

O,

Bh

op

al on

1

8.0

8.2

01

2

wit

h a

del

ay o

f 47

days

(12

0-7

3 d

ays

(fro

m 3

1.1

0.2

01

2-1

8.0

8.2

012

)) a

nd

th

e

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

w

as

issu

ed

on

21

.02.2

01

3

9

Jhan

si-

Lakhn

ado

n (

C-7

)

Tit

arpan

i 5 D

ecem

ber

20

09

19

Jan

uar

y

20

10

14

Dec

emb

er

201

1

69

3 d

ays

8.1

6

Th

e pro

po

sal

for

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

w

as

mo

ved

b

y R

O,

Bho

pal

o

n 1

8 Ja

nu

ary

20

11

wit

h a

del

ay o

f m

ore

then

a y

ear

for

whic

h

no

re

aso

ns

wer

e fo

un

d

on

reco

rd.

Furt

her

it

too

k o

ne

mo

re y

ear

to

com

ple

te/

reso

lve

the

pro

cedu

ral

wo

rk,

inte

r-m

inis

teri

al

con

sult

atio

n

and

th

e

rese

rvat

ion

o

f M

inis

try

of

Law

as

to

wh

eth

er C

entr

al G

over

nm

ent

could

lev

y

toll

o

n

a par

tial

ly

com

ple

ted

st

retc

h

46

.26

1

(fro

m

km

26

2.7

39

to

km

30

9.0

00)

as

the

stre

tch

of

sect

ion

entr

ust

ed

to

NH

AI

was

fro

m

km

13

1.6

95

to

km

40

5.0

00

a l

ength

of

tota

l

abo

ut

27

3 K

m.

10

Vij

ayp

ur-

Jam

mu/J

a

mm

u

byp

ass

Th

and

ikh

ui

Au

gu

st 2

01

2

15 O

cto

ber

20

12

27

Sep

tem

ber

201

3

34

6 d

ays

24

.37

Du

e to

d

elay

in

sub

mis

sio

n

of

the

wan

ted

in

form

atio

n b

y t

he

PIU

11

Ash

apur-

Thar

iwan

(Fat

ehp

ur-

Kh

aga)

Chit

taura

2

4 M

ay 2

00

8

23

. Ju

ne

20

08

8 F

ebru

ary

201

2

43

Mo

nth

s

and 1

6

days

12

3.1

7

Fee

n

oti

fica

tio

n

was

ap

pro

ved

b

y

Min

iste

r, M

oR

TH

on 1

4 J

anu

ary 2

011

wit

h

concu

rren

ce

of

Min

istr

y

of

Law

and

Ju

stic

e o

n

7

Feb

ruar

y

20

11

.

Ho

wev

er,

the

fee

no

tifi

cati

on w

as n

ot

pu

bli

shed

du

e to

am

end

men

t d

ated

12

Janu

ary

201

1

in

the

Fee

R

ule

s 20

08.

MoR

TH

, re

vis

ed

the

dra

ft

fee

no

tifi

cati

on i

n l

ine

wit

h t

he

amen

dm

ents

Page 16: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

232

and

sam

e w

as a

ppro

ved

by t

he

Min

iste

r

MoR

TH

on

7 A

pri

l 2

01

1.

Ho

wev

er,

at

this

ti

me,

M

inis

try

of

Law

ra

ised

ob

ject

ion

(13.0

7.2

01

1)

on t

he

issu

e o

f

toll

ing

on

par

tial

ly

com

ple

ted

st

retc

h

and

mat

ter

was

sen

t b

ack t

o N

HA

I o

n

22

Ju

ly

20

11

. N

HA

I cl

arif

ied

(30

Au

gu

st 20

11

) th

at F

ee R

ule

20

08 did

no

t b

ind t

o l

evy f

ee o

nly

on

co

mp

leti

on

of

enti

re/w

hole

len

gth

of

NH

. H

ow

ever

,

MoR

TH

ap

pro

ved

th

e p

rop

osa

l fo

r

toll

ing fo

r se

ctio

n fr

om

k

m 3

8.0

00

to

km

94

.02

0,

on

24

No

vem

ber

20

11

on

the

bas

is

of

new

m

od

el

of

fee

no

tifi

cati

on.

Fu

rther

it

took o

ne

mo

nth

in fi

nal

isat

ion

o

f H

indi

ver

sio

n o

f fe

e

no

tifi

cati

on.

Th

e fe

e n

oti

fica

tio

n o

f th

e

stre

tch w

as i

ssued

on 0

8 F

ebru

ary 2

01

2.

12

E

taw

ah-

Sik

and

ara

An

antr

am

12

Novem

ber

20

07

12 D

ecem

ber

20

07

18

Mar

ch

200

8

97

days

7.3

5

Rea

son

for

del

ay

cou

ld

no

t b

e

asce

rtai

ned

in

th

e ab

sence

o

f re

late

d

reco

rds

in t

he

file

.

Tota

l 3

01.8

0

Page 17: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

233

An

nex

ure

X

(Ref

erre

d i

n P

ara

12.4

.5.1

(II

I))

Sta

tem

en

t sh

ow

ing d

ela

y i

n s

tart

of

toll

op

erati

on

Sl.

No

Na

me

of

the

Pa

cka

ge

Na

me

of

To

ll P

laza

Act

ua

l d

ate

of

Com

ple

tio

n

of

pro

ject

/

Sch

edu

led

da

te f

or

pu

bli

cati

on

of

toll

fee

Noti

fica

tio

n

Sch

edu

led

da

te o

f

sta

rt o

f to

ll

coll

ecti

on

as

per

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

Act

ual

da

te o

f

pu

bli

cati

on

of

toll

fee

no

tifi

cati

on

Act

ua

l d

ate

of

start

of

toll

coll

ecti

on

Del

ay

in

da

ys

Am

ou

nt

no

n

rea

lize

d

(`̀̀̀ i

n c

rore

)

Rea

son

s

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

1

Lu

ckn

ow

Ran

imau

Ah

med

pur

Sep

t 20

11

15

No

vem

ber

20

11

14

D

ecem

ber

20

12

1 J

anuar

y 2

01

3

16

days

(7-6

)

1.7

6

Du

e to

d

elay

in

su

bm

issi

on

of

per

form

ance

se

curi

ty

by

the

toll

coll

ecti

ng a

gen

cy.

2

Lu

ckn

ow

Ran

imau

R

on

ahi

Sep

t 20

11

15

No

vem

ber

20

11

8 J

uly

20

11

9

Oct

ob

er 2

012

32

7

days

(7-5

)

36

.48

Du

e to

sh

ort

com

ings

in

bid

din

g

pro

cess

, bid

s w

ere

re-i

nvit

ed

by

NH

AI.

3

Ayo

dh

ya-

Bas

ti

Ch

ou

kad

i 3

1

Dec

emb

er

20

11

15

Feb

ruar

y

20

12

1 M

arch

20

12

16

Oct

ob

er 2

01

2

22

6 d

ays

(7-6

)

20

.52

Rea

sons

for

del

ay i

n s

tart

ing o

f to

ll

pla

za w

ere

that

no

min

imu

m b

asic

infr

astr

uct

ure

fo

r to

ll c

oll

ecti

on

was

inst

alle

d o

n t

oll

pla

za b

y N

HA

I as

req

uir

ed

in

bid

do

cum

ents

. N

o

div

ider

s, t

oll

booth

or

bar

rier

s si

gn

bo

ards

and

el

ectr

ic

D.G

. se

t et

c.

wer

e p

rovid

ed b

y N

HA

I in

tim

e.

4

Ayo

dh

ya-

Bas

ti

Man

daw

Nag

ar

31

Dec

emb

er

20

11

15

Feb

ruar

y

20

12

6 A

ugu

st 2

01

2

31

Oct

ob

er 2

01

2

84

d

ays

(7-6

)

8.8

2

NH

AI

invit

ed

the

bid

s fo

r

app

oin

tmen

t o

f use

r fe

e co

llec

tin

g

agen

cy o

n 1

4 N

ovem

ber

20

11

wit

h

a d

elay o

f 1

0 m

on

ths

from

the

dat

e

init

iati

on

o

f fe

e n

oti

fica

tio

n

Page 18: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

234

pro

po

sal.

H

ow

ever

, th

e sa

me w

as

can

cell

ed

as

NH

AI

no

tice

d

sho

rtco

min

gs

in e

-au

ctio

n p

roce

ss.

NH

AI

re-i

nvit

ed

the

bid

in

A

pri

l

20

12

an

d

sele

cted

M

/s

Su

rya

Inte

rnat

ion

al (

P)

Ltd

but

he

refu

sed

to s

ign

agre

emen

t. F

inal

ly t

hro

ugh

lim

ited

bid

din

g t

oll

was

sta

rted

on

31

Oct

ob

er 2

01

2.

5

Go

rakh

pu

r

Kas

ia

Mu

zain

a

Hat

im

7 M

ay 2

01

2

21

Ju

ne

20

12

3 J

anu

ary 2

01

3

19

Jan

uar

y 2

01

3

14

d

ays

(7-6

)

0.9

3

NH

AI

invit

ed

the

bid

s fo

r

app

oin

tmen

t o

f use

r fe

e co

llec

tin

g

agen

cy o

n 2

3.5

.20

12

. A

gen

cy w

as

sele

cted

on 2

6.9

.20

12

.

6

Kas

ia

UP

Bo

rder

Sal

emgar

h

7 M

ay 2

01

2

21

Ju

ne

20

12

22

May 2

01

2

16

D

ecem

ber

20

12

17

7

days

(7-5

)

8.9

6

NH

AI

fail

ed t

o s

tart

the t

oll

in

tim

e

du

e to

del

ay i

n c

on

stru

ctio

n o

f to

ll

pla

za a

nd

to

llin

g w

as s

tart

ed f

rom

16

D

ecem

ber

2

012

. R

easo

ns

for

del

ay in

co

nst

ruct

ion o

f to

ll pla

za

was

not

avai

lab

le o

n r

ecord

7

Bh

ogp

ur-

Mu

ker

ian

Ch

oll

ang

30

Ja

nu

ary

20

14

16

M

arch

20

14

27

S

epte

mb

er

20

13

21

M

arch

20

14

(7-5

)

4 d

ays

0.4

4

OM

T a

gen

cy d

id n

ot

star

t th

e to

ll

op

erat

ion

sin

ce o

ther

ad

join

ing t

oll

pla

za c

ould

not

star

t to

ll i

n s

tate

of

J &

K.

8

Ku

njw

ani

Vij

ayp

ur

Raj

bag

h

May 2

014

15

Ju

ly

20

14

27

S

epte

mb

er

20

13

Not

star

ted

til

l 3

1

Mar

ch 2

015

(7

-5)

25

9 d

ays

21

.66

OM

T a

gen

cy a

s w

ell

as N

HA

I d

id

not

star

t th

e to

ll p

laza

fo

r w

ant

of

Sta

te

Go

ver

nm

ent

sup

port

ev

en

afte

r th

e m

atte

r w

as ra

ised

at

th

e

level

of

Chie

f S

ecre

tary

an

d C

hie

f

Min

iste

r o

f th

e st

ate

of

Jam

mu

an

d

Kas

hm

ir.

Sta

te G

over

nm

ent

wan

ted

to

mer

ge

the

toll

p

laza

w

ith

th

e

Sta

te

Go

ver

nm

ent

toll

pla

za

at

Lakhan

pu

r km

1

6.4

00

. H

ow

ever

,

NH

AI

did

not

acce

pt

the p

roposa

l

of

the

Sta

te

Go

ver

nm

ent.

N

HA

I

fail

ed

to st

art

toll

co

llec

tio

n

even

afte

r is

sue

of

sep

arat

e fe

e

noti

fica

tion

fo

r th

is

toll

pla

za

on

4.3

.201

4.

Page 19: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.9

of

20

17

235

9

Vij

ayp

ur-

Jam

mu/J

amm

u b

yp

ass

Th

endik

hui

31

A

ugu

st

20

12

15

O

cto

ber

20

12

27

S

epte

mb

er

20

13

Not

star

ted

til

l 3

1

Mar

ch 2

01

5 (

7-6

)

54

9 d

ays

40

.33

Sam

e as

ab

ove

10

Ch

itto

rgar

h

Byp

ass

Rit

hola

3

1

Oct

ob

er

20

09

15

Dec

emb

er

20

09

24

D

ecem

ber

20

09

28

D

ecem

ber

20

09

3 d

ays

0.2

6

NH

AI

sub

mit

ted

the

pro

posa

l fo

r

issu

e o

f to

ll f

ee n

oti

fica

tion

fo

r to

ll

coll

ecti

on

at

Rit

hola

to

ll

pla

za

of

Chit

torg

arh

b

yp

ass

on

22

.9.2

00

9

and

fu

rth

er

repli

ed

by

NH

AI

on

15

.10.2

00

9 o

n t

he

qu

ery r

aise

d b

y

Mo

RT

H.

Pro

po

sal

was

cl

eare

d b

y

the

Fin

ance

w

ing

of

Mo

RT

H

on

3.1

1.2

009

, b

ut

the

file

w

as

mis

pla

ced i

n M

oR

TH

. T

he

file

was

recr

eate

d a

nd

the s

ame

was

cle

ared

by F

inan

ce w

ing o

f M

oR

TH

agai

n

on

26

.11

.20

09

. M

inis

ter,

M

oR

TH

app

roved

th

e pro

po

sal

on

31

.11.2

00

9

and

p

ubli

shed

th

e fe

e

noti

fica

tion

on

24.1

2.2

009.

11

Jhan

si-

Lakh

nad

on

(C-3

)/ J

han

si-

Lakh

nad

on

(C-4

)

Mal

thon

e 2

8

Mar

ch

20

12

12

M

ay

20

12

21

F

ebru

ary

20

13

17

Ap

ril

20

13

53

days

0.9

8

To

ll

coll

ecti

on

ag

ency

M/s

Pra

tyu

sh S

hu

kla

was

aw

ard

ed w

ork

of

toll

co

llec

tio

n

on

07

.03.2

01

3,

ho

wev

er,

du

e to

no

n-s

ubm

issi

on

of

Ban

k

Guar

ante

e (B

G)

by

the

agen

cy,

NH

AI

sele

cted

a

toll

coll

ecti

ng

agen

cy

thro

ugh

lim

ited

bid

din

g

and

star

ted

th

e to

ll

coll

ecti

on f

rom

17.0

4.2

013

.

12

Jhan

si-

Lakh

nad

on

(C-4

)/ J

han

si-

Lakh

nad

on

(C-5

)

Meh

ar

31

O

ctob

er

20

12

15

Dec

emb

er

20

12

21

Feb

ruar

y20

13

1

4 A

pri

l 20

13

(7-

6)

50

days

0.9

0

To

ll c

oll

ecti

on

agen

cy M

/s M

ahes

h

Chan

dra

was

aw

ard

ed t

he

wo

rk o

f

toll

co

llec

tio

n

wit

h

ann

ual

rem

itta

nce

of

`9

.72

cr

ore

o

n

07

.03.2

01

3.

Ho

wev

er,

the

sam

e did

not

mat

eria

lize

d

ue

to

no

n-

sub

mis

sio

n

of

ban

k

gu

aran

tee

by

the

agen

cy.

The

NH

AI

ther

eaft

er

Page 20: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Rep

ort

No.

o

f 2

017

236

thro

ugh

lim

ited

bid

din

g s

elec

ted

a

toll

co

llec

tio

n

agen

cy

and

st

arte

d

the

toll

ing

fro

m

14

.04.2

01

3

on

war

ds.

13

Jhan

si-

Lakh

nad

on

(C-7

)

Tit

arp

ani

5

Dec

emb

er

20

09

19

Ja

nu

ary

20

10

14

D

ecem

ber

20

11

4 M

arch

.20

12

79

days

1.0

0

Com

pet

ent

auth

ori

ty

app

roved

th

e

toll

co

llec

ting

agen

cy

on

23

.11.2

01

1,

but

Let

ter

of

Aw

ard

was

iss

ued

on

28

.02

.20

12

.

14

Ash

apur-

Th

ariw

an

Ch

itta

ura

2

4 M

ay

20

08

23

Ju

ne

20

08

8 F

ebru

ary 2

01

2

14

Ap

ril

20

13

42

8 d

ays

49

.69

Aft

er

fail

ure

o

f e-

auct

ion

ca

lled

vid

e N

IT

dat

ed

14

.11

.201

1,

two

new

N

ITs

wer

e p

ubli

shed

o

n

02

.04.2

01

2 &

10

.10

.20

12

, to

wh

ich

only

a

sin

gle

bid

an

d

zero

b

ids,

resp

ecti

vel

y,

wer

e re

ceiv

ed.

NH

AI

sele

cted

M

/s

Su

rya

Inte

rnat

ional

Pvt.

L

td.

for

toll

co

llec

tio

n

fro

m

14

.04.2

01

3 vid

e N

IT p

ubli

shed

in

Dec

emb

er 2

01

2.

15

Var

anas

i-

Mo

han

ia

Daf

fi

12

Oct

ob

er

20

07

11

No

vem

ber

20

07

7 S

epte

mb

er

200

7

18

May 2

008

18

7 d

ays

12

.14

NA

T

ota

l 2

04

.87

Page 21: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No.9 of 2017

237

Annexure-XI

(Referred in Para 12.4.5.5 (I))

Statement showing details of delay in remittance of toll to

NHAI Headquarter Toll Account

Name of

PIU

Name of the toll plaza Number of instances for

delay in deposition

Delay in days

Agra Tundla 70 3-11

Udaipur Rithola 2 8

Paduna 11 4-8

Gorakhpur Chaukadi 3 3-6

Mandaw Nagar 12 3-7

Muzaina Hatim

11 3-8

Salemgarh

6 5-8

Lucknow Nawabganj 31 3-11

Ahemadpur

Ronahi

Narsinghpur Titarpani

6 3-33

Total 152

Page 22: Annexure-I (Referred to in Para 2.4) Statement showing ... · 5 Rallison Electricals Pvt Ltd Nov -11 Delhi Doubtful - 3 13.20 6 Neo Corp International LTD Mar -16 Indore Sub -Standard

Report No. of 2017

238

Annexure –XII

(Referred in Para 12.4.5.5 (II) (a))

Statement showing the detail of delay in deposit of toll collection amount in

Consolidated Fund of India (CFI) by NHAI

S.

no.

Name of

PIU/toll

plaza

Name of toll

plaza

Date/period of

collection

Date of

deposit in

CFI

Amount

( `̀̀̀in

crore)

Delay in

deposit in

CFI

Account

from which

dues

adjusted

1 Jalandhar Harsa Manesar 15.2.2013 10.10.2013 0.26 8 months Cash

deposit

2 Jalandhar Harsa Manesar 04.02.2014 to

14.03.2014

Not

available

2.23 Not

available

Performance

security

3 Agra Tundla 13.3.2013 20.11.2013 1.68 8 months --Do--

4 Lucknow Amhadpur May-13 Oct-13 2.97 5 months --Do--

5 Udaipur Paduna Jul-14 Jan-15 5.00 7 months yet to

recover

6 Narshigpur Titarpani September

2012 to

April 2013

12.02.2013

to

28.05.2013

1.52 5 month

and 8

months.

Cash

deposited in

two

instalments

Total

13.66