7/30/2019 Appellate Court 10-16450 Janetra vs. California National Guard_Prior to January 2012

1/122

Xo`oh}om mnhko} of}ucox dnu hjxo :2:4=?2

Iofouj}om< 24.5?.52:5 :5

7/30/2019 Appellate Court 10-16450 Janetra vs. California National Guard_Prior to January 2012

2/122

::.2?.52:2 Dc`om Jrro``oox Mjtcm Ejfmcfc, Hj`cdnufcj Jcu Fj}cnfj`

Ijum, Ju}un Hjf}n, Lngf Hn}}ou, Lngfj}gjf D`jigou,

Ujsanfm Iuoou, Iuntox, Lngffs @oj`, Iuoi Annuo, Ljaox

Rj}}nf, Xohuo}jus nd }go Jcu, Ljgunac Xgjg|jm jfm Achgjo`

Sjajan}j xrr`oaof}j` owhour}x nd uohnum nf jrroj` cf :

tn`aox& [9?=89=3Q 'D]#

::.23.52:2 3 OHD Eucod Dc`om Numou 99 Dc`om h`ouk numou< ]go jfxyoucfi eucod [9Q xeac}}om esMjtcm Ejfmcfc, Ju}un Hjf}n, Lngf Hn}}ou, Ozj`

Nrrnu}fc}s Hnaacxxcnf, Achgo``o Dco`mx, Dcfjfho

Nddchou, Lngfj}gjf D`jigou, Ujsanfm Iuoou, Iuntox,

Lngffs @oj`, Iuoi Annuo, Ljaox Rj}}nf, Xohuo}jus nd }go

Jcu, Ljgunac Xgjg|jm jfm Achgjo` Sjajan}j cx dc`om&

Yc}gcf 9 mjsx nd }go dc`cfi nd }gcx numou, dc`ou cx numouom }n

dc`o 9 hnrcox nd }go eucod cf rjrou dnuaj}, yc}g j uom hntou,

jhhnarjfcom es hou}cdchj}cnf, j}}jhgom }n }go ofm nd ojhg

hnrs nd }go eucod, }gj} }go eucod cx cmof}chj` }n }go touxcnf

xeac}}om o`oh}unfchj``s& [9?=2957Q 'D]#

::.:5.52:2 Uohoctom 9 rjrou hnrcox nd Jfxyoucfi eucod [9Q dc`om esMjtcm Ejfmcfc, Ju}un Hjf}n, Lngf Hn}}ou, Ozj`

Nrrnu}fc}s Hnaacxxcnf, Achgo``o Dco`mx, Dcfjfho

Nddchou, Lngfj}gjf D`jigou, Ujsanfm Iuoou, Iuntox,

Lngffs @oj`, Iuoi Annuo, Ljaox Rj}}nf, Xohuo}jus nd }go

Jcu, Ljgunac Xgjg|jm jfm Achgjo` Sjajan}j& [9?=?584Q

'XM#

::.55.52:2 :5 Ajcf Mnhaof} 97 Dc`om nucicfj` jfm 9 hnrcox nd Jrro``jf} Ljfo}uj Lngfxnf

'Cfdnuaj`< Fn# uor`s eucod nd :? rjiox&& Xoutom nf

::.:7.52:2& [9??7547Q 'D]#

24.24.52:: :8 Ajcf Mnhaof} 37 Dc`om Jrro``jf} Ax& Ljfo}uj Jff Lngfxnf an}cnf uo>>x

xrr`oaof}j` owhour}x nd uohnum }gj} youo fn} rju} nd }go

mcx}uch} hnu} uohnum cx iujf}om& JDDCUAOM& DC@OM JFM

OF]OUOM L_MIAOF]& [7255:3:Q 'X]#

:9 Rnx} Lmiaof} Dnua ::9

25.57.52:5 :7 Ajfmj}o Numou :55 AJFMJ]O CXX_OM& 'J]I, LHY jfm AAA# [7278?3?Q

']E#

'8 nd :

https://ecf.ca9.uscourts.gov/docs1/009123691377https://ecf.ca9.uscourts.gov/docs1/009123551303

7/30/2019 Appellate Court 10-16450 Janetra vs. California National Guard_Prior to January 2012

4/122

_FC]OM X]J]OX HN_U] ND JRROJ@X dnu }go FCF]G HCUH_C]

Nddcho nd }go H`ouk

Jd}ou Nrofcfi j Hjxo Hnfxo`om Hjxox

'Mohoaeou 5223#

Hnu} Jmmuoxx Xjf Dujfhcxhn Gojmzju}oux

Ajc`cfi Jmmuoxx dnu

_&X& Rnx}j` Xoutcho

Ajc`cfi Jmmuoxx dnu

Ntoufcig} Mo`ctous

'DomOw, _RX, o}h

X}uoo} Jmmuoxx

Nddcho nd }go H`ouk

Ljaox U& EunyfcfiHnu}gnxo

_&X& Hnu} nd Jrroj`x

R&N& Enw :38383

Xjf Dujfhcxhn, HJ

3=::3!8383

Nddcho nd }go H`ouk

Ljaox U& EunyfcfiHnu}gnxo

_&X& Hnu} nd Jrroj`x

3? Xotof}g X}uoo}

Xjf Dujfhcxhn, HJ

3=:28!:?54

3? Xotof}g X}uoo}

Xjf Dujfhcxhn, HJ3=:28

Hnu} Jmmuoxxox Mctcxcnfj` Hnu}gnxox

Rjxjmofj Rnu}`jfm Xoj}}`o

Uchgjum G& Hgjaeoux

Hnu}gnxo

:5? Xn}g Iujfm Jtofo

Rjxjmofj, HJ 3::2?

Rcnfoou Hnu}gnxo

922 XY 4}g Jto, X}o ::2

Rnu}`jfm, NU 3952=

Yc``cja K& Fjkjauj

Hnu}gnxo

:2:2 Dcd}g Jtofo

Xoj}}`o, YJ 37:2=

Hnu} Yoexc}oyyy&hj3&xhnu}x&int

]go Hnu}x yoexc}o hnf}jcfx }go Hnu}x U`ox jfm Iofouj` Numoux, cfdnuaj}cnf

jen} o`oh}unfch dc`cfi nd mnhaof}x, jfxyoux }n duozof}`s jxkom zox}cnfx,mcuoh}cnfx }n }go hnu}gnxox, dnuax fohoxxjus }n ijcf jmacxxcnf }n }go eju nd }go

Hnu}, nrcfcnfx jfm aoanujfmj, uohnumcfix nd nuj` juiaof}x, `cfkx }n rujh}cho

ajfj`x, jfm jf cftc}j}cnf }n lncf nu Run Enfn Runiuja&

Hjxo< :2!:4=?2 29.2:.52:2 CM< 983:43? Mk}Of}us< :!: Rjio< : nd 9 '= nd :

http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/

7/30/2019 Appellate Court 10-16450 Janetra vs. California National Guard_Prior to January 2012

5/122

Jd }ou Nrofcfi j Hjxo Hnf xo`om Jrroj`x Rjio 5

Hnu} Rgnfo @cx}

Ajcf Rgnfo Faeou& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!7222

:=!mjs ]o`orgnfo Ow}ofxcnf dnu Eucodx

Fnu}gouf $ Ojx}ouf Hj`cdnufcj, Gjyjcc,

Juc|nfj, Fotjmj, Ija,

Fnu}gouf Ajucjfj Cx`jfmx 'Xjf Dujfhcxhn# && & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!97?8

Hof}uj` $ Xn}gouf Hj`cdnufcj 'Rjxjmofj#& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '454# 553!954:

Ojx}ouf $ Yox}ouf Yjxgcfi}nf, Cmjgn,

Anf}jfj, Nuoinf, J`jxkj 'Xoj}}`o#& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '524# 55=!55:2

J}}nufos Jmacxxcnfx& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!9722

Hj`ofmju _fc}& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!7:32

HLJ Aj}}oux 'Nrouj}cnfx _fc}# & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!9352Mnhko}cfi& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!9782 nu '=:?# 8??!97=2

Moj}g Rofj`}s& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!7:39

O`oh}unfch Dc`cfi Jrro``j}o OHD& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & Xofm oajc` }n

haohd^hj3go`rBhj3&xhnu}x&int

@ceujus& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!74?2

Aomcj}cnf _fc}& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!9322

An}cnfx J}}nufos _fc}& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!7252

Runhomuj` An}cnfx _fc}& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!9742

Uohnumx _fc}& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & '=:?# 8??!9752

Mctcxcnfj` Hnu} Nddchox