application decisions · decision visa type/refusal reason(s) refused id:- you have failed to prove...

Decision Visa Type/Refusal Reason(s)

Refused ID:- You have failed to prove that you qualify as a beneficiary of

Directive 2004/38/EC




Directive 2004/38/EC.







Approved Join/acc. EU Citizen Parent



Approved Join/acc.EU Cit (Spouse)






























28844472

28844142

28844282

28844402

27433402

27433502

27433572

25814942

26630812

27433052

25002882

25356162

25810952

23699812

23699992

23869242

23690162

23690242

23690302

23457232

23457472

23457682

21218602

21218822

23456472

Application Decisions:

Decisions for period from 30/10/2018 to 05/11/2018

Classification: DJELR

Mission: INIS Dublin

Application



















Approved Join Spouse

Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient:

- The financial documents submitted do not clearly & quickly

demonstrate to the visa officer that are sufficient finances in

place.

- The applicant has not satisfied the Visa Officer that the

sponsor will maintain the current level of income as set out in

the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification section.

17.4.

- The applicant has not satisfied the Visa Officer that the

sponsor will maintain the current level of earning as set out in


17.7.

- Sponsor has failed to show that they meet the criteria set out in


17.6.

F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete:

– As per INIS website applicant has not provided a detailed

statement of their bank accounts covering a six month period

immediately prior to their application.

ID: - Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application:- The INIS website (www.inis.gov.ie) contains

comprehensive guidelines on documentation required for each

type of visa application. If you intend to appeal this decision you

should consult the documentation guidelines available:

– Insufficient documentation has been submitted as evidence of

social or financial dependency.

If you are making your application on the basis of financial and

social dependency on your sponsor you must provide

documentary evidence to establish that you are actually

dependent on your sponsor. While the nature of the Refused AS PER PARENTS REFUSAL


29649462

29649612

29885172

29404732

29404922

29517372

29021252

29021362

29404322

29020912

29021102





Refused Family member - There is no automatic right for non-EEA

nationals who are family members of people who have been

granted temporary leave to remain, to migrate on a long-term

basis to Ireland. Your case has been fully examined on the

basis of the documentation submitted and it has been decided

not to grant your application.

This visa application does not meet the qualifying financial

criteria as per section 17.6 of INIS Family Policy Document on

Non--EEA family Reunification.

The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public funds.

The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public resources.

Refused Parent's visa application refused.


- Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in sponsor’s

bank account.

- Financial\economic position of the sponsor deemed

insufficient. Source of credit lodgements in their account not

detailed\clarified.




type of visa application. If you intend to appeal this decision, you


– Insufficient documentation submitted as evidence of social or

financial dependency.

If you are making your application based on financial and social

dependency on your sponsor you must provide documentary

evidence to establish that you are actually dependent on your

sponsor. While the nature of the documentary evidence may

vary from case to case, evidence of the following will normally

be relevant:

• Amount, frequency and duration of the financial support

provided by your sponsor (e.g. copies of your sponsor’s bank

statements showing transfers to your account, copies of your

bank statements showing receipt of those amounts),

• Any other sources of income that you may have,

• If you have no other source of income, evidence of why you

are unable to work, why you are not eligible for state benefits

etc.,

• Your living costs (e.g. evidence of mortgage/rent, utility, food,

medical, education payments).

• Details of any other family members in your country of

residence.

• Your medical condition (where relevant), relationship with the Refused ID:- You have failed to prove that you qualify as a beneficiary of


30799192

30041952

30043072

30553652







bank account.



detailed\clarified.


incomplete:


statement of their bank accounts covering a six-month period


- As per INIS website applicant has not provided evidence that

their sponsor meets the minimum level of earnings required -

P60s for the 3 years immediately prior to the date of their

application and 3 recent consecutive payslips or if self-employed

you must submit Notices of Assessment of income from self-

employment for the three most recent years, and evidence of

earnings in the period since the most recent tax return was filed.














30859262






- Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in applicant’s

bank account.

- Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in sponsor's

bank account.



detailed\clarified.


incomplete:










17.2.












30864902







bank account.



detailed\clarified.


incomplete:

- As per INIS website applicant has not provided a detailed

statement of their sponsor’s bank accounts covering a six-

month period immediately prior to their application.













be relevant:








31326832







bank account.



detailed\clarified.



17.6.


incomplete:




















evidence to establish that you are actually dependent on your Refused AS PER PARENTS REFUSAL

Refused AS PER PARENTS REFUSAL31425562

31425252

31425382








17.2.


incomplete:
















be relevant:








etc.,

• Your living costs (e.g. evidence of mortgage/rent, utility, food,

31488202





Refused F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete:


bank account.


bank account.



detailed\clarified.

ID:- Documents provided not translated.













be relevant:








etc., Refused AS PER PARENTS REFUSAL31516332

31516062






– The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the

financial criteria set out in the Policy Document for Non-EEA

Family Reunification section 18.4.

- Large unexplained lump sum lodgements visible in applicant’s

bank account.


bank account.

FM:- There is no automatic right for non-EEA nationals who are

(extended) family members of Irish citizens to migrate on a long-

term basis to Ireland.






- Insufficient documentation submitted to demonstrate that there

is not viable alternative to the applicant joining the sponsor in

Ireland as per the Policy Document 18.3.

- Applicant has not submitted a full copy of passport No:

******498 – as per INIS website applicants must supply “Your

current passport and a full copy of any previous passports”.

No contemporaneous police report reporting loss and/or

damage to this document submitted.

- Applicant has not submitted passport No: ******824 – as per

INIS website applicants must supply “Your current passport and

a full copy of any previous passports”.



- No birth cert submitted for prove family link.

31634762






– The sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the

financial criteria set out in the Policy Document for Non-EEA

Family Reunification section 18.4.


bank account.


incomplete:















- Insufficient documentation submitted to demonstrate that there

is not viable alternative to the applicant joining the sponsor in

Ireland as per the Policy Document 18.3.

- Applicant has not submitted a full copy of passport No:

******544 – as per INIS website applicants must supply “Your

current passport and a full copy of any previous passports”.



31634832







bank account.


incomplete:






















be relevant:



statements showing transfers to your account, copies of your Approved Join Spouse

Approved Visit (Family / Friend)

Approved Join Parent







Relationship History - Have not shown evidence of a relationship

being in existence prior to or since the marriage. Note: For

immigration purposes it is not sufficient for a relationship to have

developed over the internet or by telephone/sms. A relationship

must include a number of face to face meetings (excluding

webcam) between the parties. You must satisfy the visa officer

that the relationship is bona-fide. (email requesting evidence of

the relationship was not responded to)


33146512

33988262

34067972

31661492

32502412

33067772





Refused FM:- There is no automatic right for non-EEA nationals who are

family members of Non-EEA nationals entitled to reside in the

State to migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland. Your case has

been fully examined on the basis of the documentation

submitted, and it has been decided not to grant your application.

ID:- Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application:-

• Full copies of current and previous passports not submitted by

sponsor.

• Evidence of on-going routine communication between the

applicant and the sponsor not submitted.

• Evidence of sponsor having visited applicant in home country

not submitted.

• Evidence of suitable accommodation were applicant to arrive

in the State by sponsor i.e. title deed, recent tenancy agreement

not submitted.

• Up to date proof of address not submitted by sponsor i.e. utility

bill.

• Up to date six months bank statement not submitted.

• Three recent consecutive payslips not submitted by sponsor.

• Company Registration Certificate not submitted by sponsor.

• Divorce Certificate for sponsor not submitted.

• Signed letter of application not submitted by applicant.

• Signed letter of invitation not submitted by sponsor.

INCO:- Inconsistencies e.g. contradictions in the information

supplied. Applicant’s signature on application form.

RH- Relationship History. Have not shown sufficient evidence of

a relationship being in existence prior to and since marriage.

Note: For Immigration purposes, it is not sufficient for a

relationship to have developed over the internet or by

34111802






nationals who are family members of people who are

Naturalised Irish Citizens, to migrate on a long-term basis to

Ireland. Your case has been fully examined on the basis of the

documentation submitted and it has been decided not to grant

your application.


criteria as per section 17.2 of INIS Policy Document on Non--

EEA Family Reunification.



The visa application does not meet the qualifying criteria as per

section 13.3 of INIS Family Policy Document on Non-EEA

Family Reunification. (A person aged over 18 years of age

would be permitted to apply where he/she is dependant on the

care of the parent sponsor, directly or indirectly, due to a serious

medical or psychological problem which makes independent life

in the home country impossible. Adopted children and children

in the care of a sponsor are included in this definition provided

that the adoptions are recognised under Irish Law. In the latter

cases INIS may undertake an extensive examination of the

circumstances to confirm that the sponsors caring for the child

and, where relevant, that the other parent has agreed to the

child's move to Ireland. In cases involving a child, the best

interests of that child will be a key consideration in any decision

made.)

Applicant does not meet the qualifying criteria, as per 14.1 of the

Policy Document on Family Reunification', where, “Dependency” Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient


application:- please see link to "Documents Required" as

displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie

VR:- Previous visa refusal(s)



incomplete

OB:- Obligations to return to home country have not been

deemed sufficient

OC:- Observe the conditions of the visa - the visa sought is for a

specific purpose and duration:- the applicant has not satisfied

the visa officer that such conditions would be observed.

R:- No confirmation of hotel booking for duration of stay

34171972

34200402

34123732

34153012





Refused The failure to submit sufficient supporting documentation in the

following areas has diminished the overall credibility of your

application;

Employment documents (P60s or P21s for last 3 years, 3

recent payslips)

Application letter/Invitation letter

Family member - There is no automatic right for non-EEA





your application.












that the relationship is bona-fide.



34379492

34389502

34368202





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient. Sponsor

has failed to demonstrate that they meet the financial criteria set

out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification

Section 17.4 and 17.6.







application:-

• Application does not meet the qualifying criteria as set out in

the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification Section

17.4 and 17.6.

• Evidence of income over previous two years not submitted by

sponsor.

• Up to date six months bank statement not submitted by

sponsor.

• Evidence of financial support from sponsor not submitted



• Insufficient evidence of sponsor having visited applicant in

home country not submitted.


in the State by sponsor i.e. title deed, recent tenancy agreement

not submitted.

PF:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public funds.

Sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the financial

criteria as set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6.Refused F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed insufficient or

incomplete





deemed sufficient

OC:- Condition - The applicant may overstay following proposed

visit.




R:- No clear link to reference has been shown


34405922

34438842

34404502











Applicant has not satisfied the qualifying criteria, as per 18.1 of

the Policy Document on Family Reunification' where, The issue

of elderly dependent parents has arisen in a number of cases

involving both Irish and non-EEA national sponsors. This form of

migration can, however, be hugely problematic and is subject to

considerable restriction in many jurisdictions, in some cases

with extreme waiting times. It is of course entirely

understandable that an Irish citizen or a non-EEA national

lawfully resident in the State would wish to have his or her

elderly parent residing with them so as to ensure their wellbeing

as they get older and for the general enrichment of family life.

However, it must also be acknowledged that the potential

financial liability for the State of providing medical treatment,

perhaps nursing home care and other services to an elderly

person who is unable to support themselves is very

considerable.

Applicant has not satisfied the qualifying criteria, as per 18.2 of

the Policy Document on Family Reunification' where, The Irish

State is simply not in a position to take on financial

responsibilities of this nature, nor should it be expected to do so.

Moreover, even where the family in Ireland is willing to assume

the initial responsibility of providing for their relative and has a

good faith intention to continue to do so, circumstances can

change. If the family becomes unable or unwilling to assume the

costs of maintenance, then the State could be faced with an Refused ID:- Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application:

• Sponsor does not satisfy the criteria as set out in the Policy

Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 12.1.

• Application does not satisfy the criteria as set out in the Policy




• Divorce Decree from sponsor not submitted.

INCO: Inconsistencies e.g. contradictions in the information

supplied e.g. dates/residence/occupation/finances. Marital

status of sponsor at time of marriage to applicant.

34486062

34455082






incomplete


supplied

OC:- Condition - The applicant may branch into the Common

Travel Area between Ireland and the UK.





incomplete


application


deemed sufficient

OC:- Condition - The applicant may branch into the Common

Travel Area between Ireland and the UK.




Refused ID:- Dependant minor was travelling with his parents. The

parents' visa applications were refused.

Refused Parent's visa application was refused.


34512262

34545502

34588632

34511112

34511672







application;

Financial documents (6 most recent months bank statement)


recent payslips, employer letter)



nationals who are family members of people who are Irish

Citizens, to migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland. Your case

has been fully examined on the basis of the documentation

submitted and it has been decided not to grant your application.



Non--EEA family Reunification. An Irish citizen, in order to

sponsor an immediate family member, must not have been

totally or predominantly reliant on benefits from the Irish State

for a continuous period in excess of 2 years immediately prior to

the application and must over the three year period prior to

application have earned a cumulative gross income over and

above any State benefits of not less than €40K. The reference

has failed to demonstrate that they meet the above criteria.





immigration purposes it is not sufficient for a relationship to have Approved Training



34594082

34621492

34630162








Section 17.6.







application:-



17.6.

• Evidence of income over previous two years not submitted by

sponsor.

• Insufficient evidence of self-employment submitted by sponsor.

• Evidence of financial support from sponsor not submitted



• Full copies of current and previous passports of sponsor not

submitted.


in the State by sponsor i.e. title deeds, recent tenancy

agreement not submitted.

• Sponsor’s father’s Passport/National Identity Card not

submitted

• Letter from sponsor’s partner consenting to arrival of applicant

not submitted.

• Birth Certificate for sibling of applicant residing in the State not

submitted.Approved Join Spouse


Refused ID:- Dependant minor was travelling with her parents. The

parents' visa applications were refused












34750532

34760062

34669302

34679132

34697922













your application.






Information with regard to your immigration history, which was

supplied to the visa officer when considering your application,

has diminished the overall credibility of your application. The

visa officer has considered all the information submitted in

support of your application and this has not been sufficient to

satisfy the visa officer, on the balance of probabilities, that you

are likely to observe the conditions of any visa granted.

Approved Join Spouse34838232

34773592

34827672

34837902

34772702















application:-



17.4 and 17.6.

• Evidence of on-going financial support to the applicant not

submitted.

• Insufficient evidence of sponsor having visited applicant since

returning to home country submitted.

• Full copies of previous passports of sponsors not submitted.

• Letter of application not sufficient.

• Up to date Utility bill not submitted.

• Insufficient evidence of guardianship of applicant in home

country submitted.

ID:- Application form incomplete or unsigned. By

guardian/parent.

P:- Passport expires within 12 months.



34852952















application:-



17.4 and 17.6.


submitted.







country submitted.


guardian/parent.




Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6.

34853832















application:-



17.4 and 17.6.


submitted.







country submitted.


guardian/parent.




Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6.Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient





deemed sufficient




Refused ID:- As per parent's refusal reasons

Refused ID:- As per parent's refusal reasons34863812

34854102

34862612

34863542






incomplete





deemed sufficient


visit.




R:- No clear link to reference has been shown

Refused OB:- Obligations to return to home country have not been

deemed sufficient




PR:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public

resources













This visa application does not meet the qualified sponsor criteria

as per section 12.3 of INIS Family Policy Document on Non--

EEA family Reunification.

35052332

34992702

35036662

35050252

34870572

34936282

34967002

34869242

34870342






family members of non-EEA nationals resident in the State to

migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland. Your case has been

fully examined on the basis of the documentation submitted and

it has been decided not to grant your application.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie. Detailed account of

relationship history between applicant and sponsor not

submitted. Evidence of ongoing routine communication between

applicant and sponsor not submitted. Evidence of sponsor

having visited applicant in home country not submitted.

Evidence of financial support from sponsor to applicant not

submitted. Evidence of suitable accommodation if applicant

were to arrive in the State not submitted i.e. title deed, tenancy

agreement. Up-to-date proof of address not submitted i.e.

recent utility bill. Six month up-to-date bank statements not

submitted by applicant. Full copy of previous passport for

sponsor not submitted.

RH:- Relationship History - Have not shown sufficient evidence

of a relationship being in existence prior to and since marriage.

Evidence of ongoing routine communication between applicant

and sponsor not submitted. Evidence of sponsor having visited

applicant in home country not submitted. Note: For immigration

purposes it is not sufficient for a relationship to have developed

over the internet or by telephone/sms. A relationship must

include a number of face to face meetings (excluding webcam)

between the parties. You must satisfy the visa officer that the

relationship is bona-fide.

35061372






has failed to demonstrate that they meet the financial criteria as

set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA Family

Reunification Section 18.4


family members of non-EEA nationals resident in the State.




Application does not meet the qualifying criteria as set out in the

Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification Section

14.1, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4.



18.1, 18.2, 18.3, 18.4.

Evidence of on-going routine communication between applicant

and sponsor not submitted.


submitted.

Insufficient evidence of sponsor having visited applicant in home

country submitted.

Evidence of employment not submitted by sponsor.

Evidence of income over the previous three years from sponsor

not submitted.

Evidence of suitable accommodation were applicant to arrive in

the State not submitted by sponsor i.e. title deed, recent tenancy

agreement.

Proof of address not submitted by sponsor i.e. up-to-date utility

bill.

Full copy of previous passport not submitted by sponsor.

Death certificate for spouse not submitted by applicant.Approved Join Spouse



35092882

35095872

35096762

35088032










family members of non-EEA nationals resident in the State to

migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland. Your case has been

fully examined on the basis of the documentation submitted and

it has been decided not to grant your application.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie. Applicant does not

meet the qualifying criteria as set out in the Policy Document on

Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6. Evidence

of either sponsor having visited applicant since returning to

home country not submitted. Evidence of financial support to

applicant from either sponsor not submitted. Evidence of income

over the previous three years not submitted by either sponsor.

Evidence of suitable accommodation not submitted by either

sponsor i.e. title deed, recent tenancy agreement. Up-to-date

proof of address not submitted by either sponsor i.e. utility bill.

Birth certificate for sibling of applicant not submitted.





PR:- The granting of the visa may result in a cost to public

resources. Sponsor has failed to demonstrate that they meet the

financial criteria as set out in the Policy Document on Non-EEA

Family Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6.

35116912











application:-

• Full copies of current and previous passports not submitted by

applicant and sponsor.

• Insufficient evidence of financial support from sponsor

submitted.



• Evidence of sponsor having visited applicant in home country

not submitted.

• Up to date proof of address not submitted by sponsor i.e. utility

bill.

• Divorce Certificate for sponsor not submitted.

RH- Relationship History. Have not shown evidence of a

relationship being in existence prior to and since marriage. Note:

For Immigration purposes, it is not sufficient for a relationship to

have developed over the internet or by telephone/sms. A

relationship must include a number of face-to-face meetings

(excluding webcam) between the parties. You must satisfy the

visa officer that the relationship is bona-fide.















35193582

35193732

35198292

35140972

35164442










your application.















made.)


Policy Document on Family Reunification', where, “Dependency”

means that the family member is (i) supported financially by the

sponsor on a continuous basis and (ii) that there is evidence of

social dependency between the two parties. The degree of

dependency must be such as to render independent living at a

subsistence level by the family member in his/her home country

impossible if that financial and social support were not

maintained. A minor child living with its parents will be

automatically assumed to be their dependant.Approved Join Spouse

35214132

35215612







application;

Employment documents (P60s or P21s for last 3 years)






your application.
















35241602

35241802

35241982

35217062















Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 15.2



and 17.6.


Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 20.3.




submitted.


country submitted.


not submitted.


the State not submitted by sponsor i.e. title deed, tenancy

agreement.


Signed letter of invitation not submitted by sponsor.

Divorce certificate not submitted by sponsor.

Approved Visit (Tourist)

Approved Partner of Irish Citizen

Refused CP:- Need to undertake the course in this State not

demonstrated or warranted


deemed sufficient




Detailed reasons for refusal outlined in the refusal letter.

35329642

35283552

35291172

35302152





Refused CP:- Need to undertake the course in this State not

demonstrated or warranted


deemed sufficient




Detailed reasons for refusal outlined in the refusal letter.





Reunification Section 17.6.







Policy Document on Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 17.6.


submitted.


country submitted.

Three up-to-date payslips not submitted by sponsor.


not submitted.



agreement.


bill.

Six months up-to-date bank statement not submitted by sponsor.


Full copies of current and previous passport not submitted by

applicant.

INCO:- Date of birth of father of applicant.


35365902

35330172

35355962






nationals who are family members of people who are Irish

Citizens, to migrate on a long-term basis to Ireland. Your case

has been fully examined on the basis of the documentation

submitted and it has been decided not to grant your application.









above any State benefits of not less than €40K.










Approved Parent of Irish Citizen Child

Approved Parent of Irish Citizen Child35414872

35404302

35408642








Reunification Section 17.4 and 17.6








and 17.6.




submitted.

Evidence of sponsor having visited applicant in home country

not submitted.


not submitted.



agreement.


bill.

Full copies of current and previous passport not submitted by

sponsor.

Six months up-to-date bank statement not submitted by sponsor.

Letter of invitation not submitted by sponsor.

INCO:- Inconsistencies Approved Join Spouse








your application.






Approved Spouse of Irish Citizen

35454482

35456822

35469932

35443962

35450082







application;


recent payslips)







your application.



EEA Family Reunification. (No evidence of same provided)








35479502










your application.















made.)


Policy Document on Family Reunification', where, “Dependency”

means that the family member is (i) supported financially by the

sponsor on a continuous basis and (ii) that there is evidence of

social dependency between the two parties. The degree of

dependency must be such as to render independent living at a

subsistence level by the family member in his/her home country

impossible if that financial and social support were not

maintained. A minor child living with its parents will be

automatically assumed to be their dependant.Approved Study

Refused This visa application does not meet the qualified sponsor criteria

as per section 12.3 of INIS Policy Document on Non--EEA

Family Reunification.


Approved Study

35546612

35563952

35570942

35522662

35541132
















Refused

A - Information– As outlined on the INIS website

1. The failure to submit sufficient supporting documentation in

the following areas has diminished the overall credibility of your

application;

- Financial documents for the applicant

2. The visa appeals officer has examined the evidence

submitted by you in support of your application and has found

insufficient reasons for the proposed trip. The following

information has been considered as part of this decision;

- Your financial situation

- The cost of the proposed trip

- Your family circumstances

- Your employment details

B - Finances

1. No personal financial documentation has been submitted in

respect of the applicant.

2. The financial documentation submitted in support of this visa

application has not been deemed sufficient.

C - OB/OC- Obligations to return home and observe the

conditions of your visa

1. The visa appeals officer has considered the information

submitted in support of your application and has found

insufficient evidence of strong obligations to return to your home

country. The following information has been taken into

consideration;

- Your family circumstancesApproved Spouse of Irish Citizen

35575912

35614962

35619572










your application.









above any State benefits of not less than €40K.









35624112

35643322







application;

Marriage and Divorce certificates from reference’s previous

marriage






your application.





























35943082

35988232

36088512

35749442

35770872

35794432

35662552

35701442

35701452

35644802






incomplete

IH:- Immigration history of applicant


deemed sufficient




R:- Letter of invitation no longer valid - dates for event/course

have passed

R:- No confirmation of hotel booking for duration of stay

Approved Stamp 0-no recourse to public funds

Refused A – Information – As outlined on the INIS website

1. The visa officer has been unable to adequately establish the

credibility of the reason for travel provided due to the failure to

provide sufficient supporting documentation in the following

areas;

Financial documents

Evidence of sponsor’s circumstances

Other, outlined below

All pages from all previous passports must be included with

application.

2. The quality of supporting documentation submitted by you in


application;

Financial documents

3. The visa officer has examined the evidence submitted by you

in support of your application and has found no credible reason

for the proposed trip. The following information has been

considered as part of this decision;

Your financial situation

The cost of the proposed trip

Your family circumstances

Your employment details

Your travel history

Your host in Ireland

Your itinerary

B – FinancesApproved Join Spouse

Approved Study

36397502

36422942

36108722

36130132

36139212






incomplete


deemed sufficient





incomplete


deemed sufficient





incomplete


deemed sufficient





incomplete


deemed sufficient





incomplete


deemed sufficient




36506572

36506012

36506272

36506422

36505792






incomplete


deemed sufficient




Approved Exam

Refused The INIS website has all of the information you will need to

make an application for a visa. Before appealing this decision,

please check the INIS website to ensure you have included all of

the relevant documents.

A – Information – As outlined on the INIS website




areas;

Employment documents

Employment contract

2. You have submitted information in support of your visa

application which has been deemed by the visa officer to be

false or misleading.

3. Inconsistencies in the information supplied in support of your

application have been noted by the visa officer and have

diminished the overall credibility of your application.

Inconsistencies have been noted in the following areas;

In a previous visa application, you provided employment details

which indicated that you had been working as a Club Manager

for 1 year and 2 months, commencing said employment in

January 2012. This is at odds with the information provided on

this application, that you have been employed as a Chef

Assistant for over 13 years. You have also not provided any

supporting documentation to support your claim of having been

employed in this capacity for the stated period. No explanation

has been provided for this discrepancy and the visa officer is

36528242

36506702

36515712













areas;

Financial documents

2. Inconsistencies in the information supplied in support of your




You have claimed in your application that you are an

experienced chef, yet in an interview with the visa office you

have stated you purchase ingredients for the restaurant and

have made no mention of any food preparation experience.

Your potential employer has stated that the role requires a chef

who is “skilled and with qualified certificate, previous training on

the job experience”. You have submitted a Qualification

Certificate showing that you have very basic level skills in the

area of food preparation. This certificate was obtained after your

most recent employment ended. The visa officer is therefore not

satisfied that you possess the required skills or experience to

undertake this role as advertised.

36548192





Refused The quality of supporting documentation submitted by you in the


application;


Inconsistencies in the information supplied in support of your




Duration of employment – Employment letter Vs Information

supplied by employer when contacted

The visa officer has examined the evidence submitted by you in

support of your application and has found insufficient evidence

that you possess the required skills or experience to undertake

the proposed employment. The following information has been


Your employment history

Your educational qualifications

No personal financial documentation has been submitted.

Information supplied by you concerning your personal, economic

and family circumstances has been insufficient to satisfy the

visa officer that you would observe the conditions of any visa

granted, with particular regard to the use of public funds and

public resources.


Approved Study

Approved Employment

Approved Join Spouse36730372

36550772

36617192

36623162

36550062






family members of Irish citizens to migrate on a long-term basis

to Ireland. Your case has been fully examined on the basis of

the documentation submitted and it has been decided not to

grant your application.

ID:- Quality of documents. University documentation submitted

by applicant.



displayed on our website - www.inis.gov.ie. Application does not

meet the qualifying criteria as set out in the Policy Document on

Non-EEA Family Reunification Section 13.2 (See below).



14.1, 14.2, 14.3 and 14.4. Insufficient documentation has been

submitted to demonstrate that there is no viable alternative to

the applicant joining their sponsors in Ireland. The application

has further failed to establish or evidence any special

circumstances that would warrant an exception to the general

policy. Insufficient information has been provided to

demonstrate a level of dependency between the applicant and

their financial sponsors which is considered to be more then

“normal emotional ties”. Evidence of ongoing routine

communication between applicant and either sponsor not

submitted. Evidence of either sponsor having visited applicant in

home country not submitted. Evidence of financial support from

either sponsor to applicant not submitted. Evidence of suitable

accommodation if applicant were to arrive in the State not

submitted i.e. title deed, tenancy agreement. Full copies of

current and previous passports not submitted by either sponsor.

Evidence of employment in home country not submitted by

applicant. Six month up-to-date bank statements not submitted

by applicant.Approved Study

Approved Study





Approved Employment

Approved Study

Approved Business 36930432

36806272

36886232

36916482

36755662

36769942

36806222

36730612

36739242











application:











areas;




application;

Financial documents

College documents

Invitation letter

Evidence of registration at the event

Evidence of ties to your home country








Your study detailsApproved Join Spouse


36954752

36954912

36935752

36949722









areas;

Financial documents


Application letter

Invitation letter


Evidence of link to reference

Evidence of link to sponsor




application;

Financial documents


Application letter



Failure to show sufficient link between applicant and sponsor.






36969412













areas;


Evidence of a reference in Ireland




application;










The relationship between your business/employment and the

proposed eventApproved Visit (Family / Friend)

Approved Visit

Approved Visit

Approved Visit

Approved Visit

Approved Visit36982582

36982122

36982442

36982542

36969732

36979892

36981562













areas;






application;










The relationship between your business/employment and the

proposed eventApproved Visit

Approved Visit

Approved Family Reunification


36996752

37008692

37008812

36986702

36996452









areas;

Employment documents.

Invitation letter.

Evidence of ties to your home country.

Evidence of a reference in Ireland.

Evidence of link to reference.

Accommodation booking



application;


Application letter/Invitation letter.

Evidence of ties to your home country.





Your financial situation.

The cost of the proposed.

Your family circumstances.

Your employment details.

Your travel history.

Your host in Ireland.Approved Study

37038682

37065622





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient - sponsor 2

(father).

F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed incomplete -

sponsor 1 (cousin) did not provide a six month bank statement.

lump sum lodgements not explained.


application:- sponsor 1 & 2 did not provide an undertaking.


supplied - birth certificate.

IS:- Immigration status of the reference in Ireland. Evidence of

this has not been provided - Copy of GNIB card:- copy of

passport of sponsor 1.


deemed sufficient.

OB:- Obligations to return to home country not shown.


visit.

OC:- Condition - The applicant may work illegally in the State




SP:- Course applied for in the State is not warranted.

37073572






1.The visa officer has been unable to adequately establish the



areas;

Financial documents



Evidence of sponsor’s

Other, outlined below

Applicant must provide all pages from all current and previous

passports.

2.The visa officer has examined the evidence submitted by you








Your travel history


B – Finances

1.No personal financial documentation has been submitted in

respect of the applicant.

2.The financial documentation submitted in support of this visa

application has not been deemed sufficient.Refused ID:- You have failed to prove that you qualify as a beneficiary of






Approved Study


37107432

37125402

37129502

37087222

37106472

37106962





Refused F:- Finances shown have been deemed insufficient - sponsor.

F:- Finances:- evidence provided is deemed incomplete - six

month bank statement not submitted.


application:- evidence of third level education not provided -

college transcript not submitted.


deemed sufficient.

OB:- Obligations to return to home country not shown - e.g.no

social, economic or professional ties in home country shown.


visit.




SP:- Gaps in education or employment not accounted for -

March 2015 - August 2016 not accounted for.


SP:- Relevance of English to employment.

37129942









areas;

Financial documents

Invitation letter







application;

Financial documents













37130582









areas;

Financial documents

Invitation letter







application;

Financial documents













37131212





Refused 1. The visa officer has been unable to adequately establish the



areas;

Financial documents


Application letter

Invitation letter

Evidence of ties to your home country Insufficient details

provided of persons living in home country.





application;













Your itineraryRefused ID - You have failed to prove that you qualify as a beneficiary of


Refused ID:- Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application:- letter from university not submitted.


supplied - previous course study.


deemed sufficient.


visit.




R:- No clear link to financial sponsor has been shown.

SP:- Gaps in education or employment not accounted for - July -

September 2017.


SP:- Relevance of English to employment.

Approved Visit37180822

37144082

37158642

37162332









areas;

Financial documents






application;

Financial documents













Your travel history

37184842









areas;

Financial documents


Evidence of a reference in Ireland – none provided




application;

Financial documents











Your travel history

Your itinerary

B – FinancesRefused As per parents' refusal

Refused As per parents' refusal

Refused As per parents' refusal

37186012

37186282

37186452

37185692





Refused FM:- Minor child not a family member. Your case has been fully

examined on the basis of the documentation submitted, and it

has been decided not to grant your application.


application:-



13.2.



13.3.



14.1.

• Evidence of on-going financial support to applicant by sponsor

not submitted.


in the state not submitted.

• Up to date employment letter not submitted by sponsor.

• Late registration of applicant’s birth certificate not explained.

IS:- Immigration status of reference in the State. Spouse of

sponsor has no right of residence in the State.

R:- No clear link to reference has been shown.

37188782









areas;








application;














Approved Study




Refused ID:- Insufficient documentation submitted in support of the

application:- college transcripts & certificate (masters degree)

not submitted.


supplied - course applied for.

SP:- Gaps in education or employment not accounted for - July

2011 - February 2012 not accounted for. January 2016 -

September 2016 not accounted for.

SP:- Previous educational or employment background is at odds

with course applied for.

37221332

37213192

37215322

37215652

37210092

37211962









areas;








application;

















Approved Employment

37245272

37245522

37252442

37244282

37244642









areas;

Financial documents




Application letter


B – Finances

1. The financial documentation submitted in support of this visa

application has not been deemed sufficient.

2. You have not provided sufficient evidence as to the source of

your income.

C – Obligations to return home and observe the conditions of

your visa

1. The visa officer has considered the information submitted in

support of your application and has found insufficient evidence

of strong obligations to return to your home country. The

following information has been taken into consideration;



Property owned or rented by youApproved Study

Approved Business





Approved Reside

Approved Reside

Approved Reside37451262

37369832

37406632

37450292

37367792

37368622

37369332

37261062

37281182

37344892