applying lessons from leadership to address societal problems dr. william j. soesbe iii gustavus...
TRANSCRIPT
Applying Lessons from Leadership to Address Societal
Problems
Dr. William J. Soesbe III
Gustavus Adolphus CollegeWednesday, June 10th
@8:30-9:30 Beck Hall Room 111
Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
• Father of five amazing children
• Assistant Professor of Education• Teach within the Institute for Leadership Education• Director for the High School Leadership Institute• Iowa Campus Compact Engaged Faculty Fellows
Scholar• Been at Wartburg for the past nine years
Initially in the Center for Community Engagement
Currently teach in the Education Department
• Served as secondary science teacher and coach at Waverly-Shell Rock prior to coming to Wartburg
Who am I?
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Professional Learning Networks
Let’s not have these conversations in isolation or stop them once this session is over.
Follow me on Twitter at @drbillsoesbeand I will follow you so we can grow together.
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
• Let’s play “Flash”
1.Name?2.Institution?3.Position?4.Role?5.Why are you here?6.Why did you attend this presentation?
Who are you and why are you here?
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
1.What do you hope/need to gain from the presentation?
2.What don’t you want as part of the presentation?
Two very important questions.
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Network with other educators and expand your Professional Learning Network (PLN)
Identify and differentiate the differences between adaptive and technical issues
Brainstorm ways to infuse leadership initiatives within yourclasses/program as a means to better address
adaptive problems
Collaborate with each other to determine how the presented materials and resources could be applied in new and innovative ways to further enhance teaching and learning
Goals and Objectives
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
What is the function of teaching and learning (i.e. education)?
“Anything worth believing is worth questioning.”
-Anonymous
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
It is a process and lifestyle that cannot (well should not) be turned on and off
I have been blessed with talents, abilities, education, resources, etc. that should be shared and used wisely
Ultimately it is about an obligation and responsibility that I have to society to contribute to the betterment of our communities and those I serve
Context for My Leadership…
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
“Taking responsibility for our communities and making them better through public
action.”
Wartburg Definition of Leadership
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
• Leaders can be born, but they are also made and anyone can lead
• Leadership is personal and relational; it is not about positions and roles
• Leadership is about clarity of purpose not necessarily a vision or blueprint
• Leadership is about your quality of presence more than your personality type
• Leadership is about helping to make progress not using power
Leadership Assumptions
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Leadership takes place when you realize no one has the answer and you are willing to stand on the edge and try to make sense of the challenge.
Using and Applying Leadership…
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Take some time to reflect deeply and intentionally about issues/problems/challenges facing you personally and professionally. Record your thoughts and ideas. Go beyond the surface.Be honest with yourself.Be transparent.
Identify Personal and Professional “Struggles”
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
We must first and foremost correctly identify the type of issue/problem/challenge.
Otherwise, how will we effectively address it?
We too often misidentify the problem and use the wrong methods to address.
Addressing the Issue/Problem/Challenge…
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Dr. Herb Childress and Dr. Ron Heifetz have addressed the differences between each.
Tame (technical) problems - problems that are easily identifiable, can be adequately addressed, typically a solution can be found and is already identified, and are solved by those in authority
Wicked (adaptive) problems - problems that are insoluble, undefinable and urgent
Tame (Technical) vs. Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Tame (Technical) vs. Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
Situation Problem Definition
Solution and implementation
Primary locus of responsibility for the work
Kind of work
Type I Clear Clear Leader Technical
Type II Clear Requires learning
Leader and follower
Technical and Adaptive
Type III Requires learning
Requires learning
Follower and leader
Adaptive
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Take time to look at your list and identify whether the problems are tame (technical) or wicked (adaptive) problems.
Use the qualifiers previously identified to help you classify.
Classify your Personal and Professional “Struggles”
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Properly Identifying Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Not going to address these as you already have the tools, resources, and people to address these problems.
However, take them seriously and be proactive rather than reactive as “little by little the cup fills.”
Tame (Technical) Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Wicked problems on a global scale: Climate changeGentrificationEducational attainmentPoverty and wealth distributionViolenceSustainability
“Wicked” problems in Waverly, Iowa: Green BridgeGentleman of the Road Tour (GOTR)
• For me personally…the last two days of the High School Leadership Institute occur during the music festival
“The world is more wicked than our disciplines. Wicked problems require judgment beyond expertise.” –Herb Childress
Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
Think about the wicked (adaptive) problems that you are dealing with personally and/or professionally.
• Have you correctly identified them?• How are you addressing them?• What is working? What is not?
In order to address these issues/problems/challenges we must understand what they are and what they are not. Then and only then can we better understand how to manage, control, and address them.
Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
There is no definitive statement of “the problem.”Emphasizing different values can mean the problem is understood differently, and one cannot understand the problem without knowing about its context.
Wicked problems have no stopping rule.The problem-solving process ends when you run out of resources, such as time, money, or energy, not when an “optimal” solution emerges.
Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Solutions to wicked problems are not right or wrong, but are simply better or worse, or good enough or not good enough.The assessment of proposed solutions varies (sometimes widely) and depends on stakeholder values and goals. There is no immediate test of solutions.Solutions to wicked problems generate waves of consequences. As a result, a solution may lead to undesirable consequences that outweigh the putative advantages of the solution.
Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Every solution to a wicked problem is a “one-shot” deal.There is no learning by trial and error or experimentation. Every implemented solution leaves “traces” that cannot be undone and alters people’s lives in irreversible ways. Every wicked problem is essentially unique.The many factors and conditions that serve to define the problem and a dynamic social context mean that wicked problems are uniquely different. Thus, there are no principles of solution that can be applied to classes of wicked problems.
Wicked (Adaptive) Problems
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
One more time…take a look at your list and reassess whether the problems are tame (technical) or wicked (adaptive) problems.
(Re)Classify your Personal and Professional “Struggles”
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
This is what we are doing at Wartburg
to prepare our leadership students
for adaptive and wicked problems.
Soesbe, W. J. (2012). Voices of the lived experiences of alumni who completed an undergraduate leadership program in a small liberal arts college.
The “answers” are up to you.
There are no panaceas or logarithms for wicked and adaptive problems.
None of us alone can do the work that wicked and adaptive problems demand, but as one among the many we can better and more effectively address them.
So Now What?
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
So what are your “answers” to your problems?•What resources are needed?•Who are the stakeholders?•What is the timeline?•What questions do you have?
Time to Reflect
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Good Leadership Reads
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Final Thought…
If I have left you with more questions than answers then I have
fulfilled my role today.
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit
Questions or
Comments?
2015 Upper Midwest Civic Engagement Summit