arcam re-design

8

Upload: ruben-smits

Post on 09-Mar-2016

223 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

This is an article about the re-design of the Arcam building in Amsterdam as a result of a building technology assignment.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Arcam Re-design
Page 2: Arcam Re-design

2

tentoonstellingsruimte

receptie

tochtsluis portiek

vide

gang

lift

TUSS

toilet

lift

tentoonstellingsruimte

receptie

tochtsluis portiek

vide

gang

lift

TUSS

toilet

lift

tentoonstellingsruimte

receptie

tochtsluis portiek

vide

gang

lift

TUSS

toilet

lift

tentoonstellingsruimte

receptie

tochtsluis portiek

vide

gang

lift

TUSS

toilet

lift

Page 3: Arcam Re-design

left:

Photo of ArcamFacade erectionFacade images

right:

orientation of Arcam to the sunsunlight and Arcam in all seasons and timesVentilation duct ArcamRadiant fl oor heating ArcamOld summer situationOld winter situation

The climate system of ArcamHow can the climate system in the Arcam building be improvedto get a more comfortable indoor climate in summer and inwinter times?Ruben Smits, 1320106

Arcam (in words: Architecture centre of Amsterdam) was set up as a foundation in 1986 and

concentrates its activities in Amsterdam and the surrounding area. Arcam aims to reach the

largest possible public in order to broaden architecture’s appeal and zeros in on topical issues and

developments in Amsterdam, so that the discussion about the future is constantly fuelled. Arcam also

has a function as co-ordination centre and works together with a large number of institutes in order to

support and co-ordinate existing programs and to initiate new activities.

The Arcam building is located in the heart of the city Amsterdam, on Prins Hendrikkade. The building

was constructed in 2002. The building has been designed by René van Zuuk and consists of a

compact, sculptural structure whose three storey’s are interconnected by voids. Arcam’s offi ce

is situated on the top storey. At the level of Prins Hendrikkade are the exhibition space and the

information point. The lowermost storey, on the water, is used for small-scale discussions, large

meetings and for receiving school groups. The elevation on the waterside is entirely of glass. The

building is clad with coated aluminum, which has been folded over the roof, right down to the ground.

An unusual feature is the sculptural form of the entrance on this side. René van Zuuk has built some

buildings with an aluminum cladding before, but not in this double curved geometry and this extremely

bend aluminum.

There is a lot of activity in the Arcam building going on, from exhibitions to little workshops, etc. but

there are people working and doing their job too. This means that there are many people involved

and therefore the climate in the building has to be comfortable. At this moment people who work in

the Arcam building are complaining about the heat in the summer and the cold in the winter. For this

problem I fi rst have to mention the analysis of the climate system of the Arcam, before I can mention

my proposal for the redesign of the climate system of the Arcam.

First I’ll go to the facades of the Arcam building, it has been built up like this; On the outside there

are bent Kalzip sandwich panels placed, and behind these panels the insulation is situated. Behind

the insulation there is a profi led steel plate that holds the aluminum Kalzip panels, this profi led steel

plate is attached to the structure of the building, steel columns of an IPE 300 size. The fi nishing layer

is attached to these columns and in the interior the facade has been plastered. Nothing seems wrong

with the composition of the facade, maybe the insulation depth (100 mm. with a thermal resistance

of 2,5 m^2K/W) is a little too economical. But what attracted my attention is the empty nonfunctional

space between the plastered board (interior) and the profi led steel plate. This whole space is reserved

for the IPE 300 columns, but these columns only stand there once in the 6 meters, we can conclude

that this is a vacant space which isn’t necessary.

3

Page 4: Arcam Re-design

4

Page 5: Arcam Re-design

The Arcam building has its windows orientation on the waterside. From a climate technical point of

view this is perfect, because the closed aluminum facades are orientated on the south and the glass

facades are oriented to the north. The building gets little direct sunlight, because the architect thought

about the climate of the interior building in an early phase in his design process. So this is actually well

designed for the interior climate.

I went to the Arcam to analyze this building and I interviewed some employees of the Arcam, they

thought it is a beautiful and well-functioning building, but it isn’t that comfortable because of the

inner climate. In winter-times it’s too cold and in summer-times it’s too warm. After these interviews I

wanted to research on this indoor climate. What’s wrong with the climate control and how come the

uncomfortable indoor climate in winter and in summer times? It either has to do with the insulation

layer mentioned before, or with the ventilation and heating/cooling system of this building. We’ll have

to fi nd out how this ventilation, cooling and heating system works in the Arcam, before it’s possible to

come with a reliable solution.

The Arcam building works with natural ventilation, so it needs ventilation ducts for sucking air to

get an under pressed air volume and it needs grates or openable windows to suck fresh air into the

building. The ventilation ducts are situated beneath the fl oors and fi nished with another layer of curved

plasterboard. The building has openable windows to be able to let the natural ventilation fl ow. The

fl oors of the Arcam building have radiant fl oor heating, so the concrete core activation takes place

in the fl oors, but this is a rather slow process of heating the building up. I found out that there is no

cooling system in the Arcam building, and this is a problem. There are not enough ventilation ducts

and they are situated quite bad, there isn’t even a ventilation duct in the ceiling of the upper fl oor,

which is the most important ventilation space to suck all the air in the top. Heat normally rises to the

ceiling, especially on the upper fl oor, so heat air will keep circulating in the upper fl oor.

What solution can we bring for these climate problems? I think the solution lies in the unutilized

space in the facade itself. A lot of supporting technical functions of the building are situated within

the facade (all construction elements and the whole thermal shell), except the climate system. Why

not strengthen the concept of the ‘servant shed’ and put the ventilation and cooling / heating in the

spare space of the facade. This concept is the same that Norman Foster did with his design for the

Sainsbury centre for the visual arts. He used two out of four facades and the roof as a servant shed

with all technical supporting functions. So all of the load bearing structure lies within its façade, the

whole climate system is controlled in the façade and the thermal insulation is situated in the façade.

Actually in the Sainsbury centre for the visual arts the architect really exaggerated this concept of the

servant shed by putting toilets and staircases in this two meters wide cavity between the actual inner

and outer façade. Arcam doesn’t have this wide cavity, but the design of the Arcam building really

has the potential to have this concept as strong as the Sainsbury centre for the visual arts, because

it has also this one direction in its facades. It’s not as clear as in the Sainsbury centre for the visual

arts, because the Arcam building is twisted, but that doesn’t matter for the concept of putting serving

5

Left:

Sainsbury centre for the visual arts of Norman foster:axonometrysectionexterior elevation

Right:

Sainsbury centre for the visual arts:partial sectioninterior elevation

Page 6: Arcam Re-design

6

ncept

Page 7: Arcam Re-design

functions of a building in the two closed facades.

In my proposal for the redesign of the climate system of Arcam the spare space between the columns

are used to improve the climate system. We will keep the natural ventilation, but the climate system

needs to be improved with artifi cial heating / cooling ventilation for extreme warm or extreme cold

situations. So the new improved climate system works like this; The spare space between the columns

of the southern facade will function as a ventilation area, constantly there will be an under pressure

in this area, so air will be sucked in and natural ventilation will take place. The spare space between

the columns of the eastern facade will only work in extreme conditions, then this whole area would

be in overpressure. Only for extreme cold or hot conditions we will use the artifi cial ventilation with

cooling or heating device. The air handling unit will be situated like the other installation devices in the

installation room in the basement. Grates are placed in a line high on every fl oor on the plastered wall

of the inner façade. Now we can ventilate the hot air in the upper fl oor in the summer, because we will

put the grates in the inner façade wherever it’s necessary.

The Arcam building doesn’t use air ducts any more, but under and over pressured areas to control

the airfl ow. This means that we can delete all air ducts in the building, included the fi nish of curved

plasterboard at every ceiling, so the building gains in fl oor height. The under and over pressed area

will be stopped up securely by closed fi nishing plates and perforated fi nishing plates, so we’re sure

that there aren’t any other openings than the grates. What needs to be done is replacing the air

handling unit with one exit to suck and one exit to blow air, respectively on the eastern and the western

façade. The IPE-300 columns in the two closed facades have to be perforated, otherwise the air

cannot get into the whole cavity for controlling the inner spaces of the Arcam building.

The redesign fi lls up the unused space between the façade and the fi nishing of the façade with

necessary climate improvements. Although the Arcam building after renovated uses artifi cial

ventilation (at times), the redesign actually is sustainable, because this is only used in extreme

outdoor conditions. The other sustainable thing is that this is a small operation. There isn’t much to

be renovated or changed, so I think this really is an economical solution to the major problem of the

complaints of employees about the uncomfortable inner climate.

So is it possible to improve the climate system in the Arcam building to get a more comfortable indoor

climate in summer and in winter times? Yes it is, it’s possible by using artifi cial cooling and heating in

in extreme conditions and thereby improving the natural ventilation in ‘normal’ conditions. The redesign

did so by replacing all air ducts by over and under pressed spaces, the western façade always under

pressed to ventilate the spaces and the eastern façade over pressed at times, when there has to be

cooled or heated in extreme conditions. These areas are situated in the left-over space between the

insulation of the façade and the fi nishing plates on the interior of the façade.

7

Left:

New situation climate Arcam:horizontal airfl ow summersituationhorizontal airfl ow wintersituationfi rst fl oor vertical detail

Right:

New situation climate Arcam:vertical airfl ow summersituationvertical airfl ow wintersituationground fl oor vertical detail

Next page:

Left:

Old situation climate Arcam 1:50Entire vertical sectionGround fl oor sectionBasement section

Right:

New situation climate Arcam 1: 50Entire vertical sectionGround fl oor sectionBasement section

Page 8: Arcam Re-design

8

SOUTH E