archives - dspace.mit.edu

236
A COMPUTER MODEL OF THE RECTISOL PROCESS USING THE ASPEN SIMULATOR by Rosalyn A. preston SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN CHEMICAL ENGINEERING at the MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY December, 1981 Q Massachusetts Institute of Technology 1981 Signature of Author Signature of Author Department of Chemical Engineering December 7, 1981 Certified by Lawrence B. Evans Thesis Supervisor Accepted by Glenn C Williams Chairman, Departmental Graduate Committee Archives MASSACHUSETTS INSTiTUTE OF TECHMflLOGY JUN 1 13982 i IRRA!ES

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jan-2022

21 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

A COMPUTER MODEL OF THE RECTISOLPROCESS USING THE ASPEN SIMULATOR

by

Rosalyn A. preston

SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENTOF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE

DEGREE OF

MASTER OF SCIENCE INCHEMICAL ENGINEERING

at the

MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY

December, 1981

Q Massachusetts Institute of Technology 1981

Signature of AuthorSignature of Author Department of Chemical Engineering

December 7, 1981

Certified byLawrence B. EvansThesis Supervisor

Accepted byGlenn C Williams

Chairman, Departmental Graduate Committee

ArchivesMASSACHUSETTS INSTiTUTE

OF TECHMflLOGY

JUN 1 13982

i IRRA!ES

Page 2: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

A COMPUTER MODEL OF THE RECTISOLPROCESS USING THE ASPEN SIMULATOR

by

Rosalyn A. Preston

Submitted to the Department of Chemical Engineering

on December 7, 1981 in partial fulfillment of the

requirements for the Degree of Master of Science

in Chemical Engineering

ABSTRACT

A computer model of the Rectisol process for acidgas absorption has been developed with the ASPENprocess simulator. The model uses a modified ver-sion of the Redlich-Kwong-Soave equation-of-stateto represent the phase equilibria for the methanol-water-aromatics-acid gas system. This report de-scribes the development of the physical propertiesmodel and the flowsheet simulation. The work isbased on the CONOCO design for a commercial scalecoal gasification facility. The computer modellingeffort was carried out under contract to the Morgan-town Energy Technical Center, U. S. Department ofEnergy.

Page 3: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

I. INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

II. AC:ID GAS ABSORPTION PROCESSES . . . . . . .

General Features of Acid Gas AbsorptionProcesses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Absorption . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Regeneration . . . . . .. . . . .

Solvent Selection . . . . . . . .

Heat Integration . . . . . . . . . .

Solvent Recovery . . . . . . . .a

Advantages of the Rectisol Process . . .

Rectisol Process Description . . . . . .

III. DEVELOPMENT OF PHYSICAL PROPERTIES MODEL ..

Selection of the Thermodynamic Model . .

vii.. . 6. a . 6

· · · 6

a1 a a 7

a a a 7* a a 9

* a a 10

. . . 12

. a a 12

* a a 13

. a a 19

a . . 19

Modified Redlich-Kwong-Soave Equation-of-State

Experimental Phase Equilibrium Data . . . . .

Development of Modified Redlich-Kwong-SoaveModel Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Evaluation of the Preliminary ThermodynamicModel . . . . . . . . .. . .. . .. . . .

Enthalpy Calculations . . . . . . . . . . .

IV. SIMULATION OF THE RECTISOL PROCESS . . . . . . . .

Basis for the Process Simulation . . . . . . .

Absorption Section . . . . . . . . . . . .

Flash Regeneration Section . . . . . . . .

Naphtha Extractor . . . . . . ... . . .

Azeotrope Column .... . . .a a .a

Methanol-Water Column . . . . . . . . .

iii

21

23

25

27

32

36

36

38

43

43

44

49

. . .

Page 4: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

Hot Regeneration Column . .

Water Wash Column . . ..

Heat Exchangers . . . . . .

Methanol Make-up . . . . .

Flowsheet Convergence . ....V. RECTISOL PROCESS SIMULATION RESULTSVI. CONCLUSION. ........ ...

APPENDIX A OVERALL RECTISOL MODEL

APPENDIX B ABSORPTION SECTION SIM

APPENDIX C AZEOTROPE COLUMN SIMUIL

APPENDIX D METHANOL-WATER COLUMN

APPENDIX E HOT REGENERATION COLUMI

APPENDIX F WATER WASH COLUMN SIMU

LITERATURE CITED

* O . . . . ·

a 0 0 · a a a

* a a a a e a a a a a a ·· · ··

U a a a a a

[LATION

MTION

SIMULATION

[ SIMULATION

LATION

BIBLI OGRAPHY

iv

50

52

52

53

53

55

59a

Page 5: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LIST OF FIGURES

1. The Pipeline Gas Demonstration Plant . . . . . . . 2

2. The Rectisol Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

3. Comparison of Equilibrium Loading of Chemical andPhysical Solvents . . . .. . . . . . . . . . 11

4. Block Flow Diagram of the Rectisol Process . . . . 14

5. Process Flow Diagram of the Rectisol Process . . . 15

6. Process Flow Diagram of the Rectisol Process . . . 16

7. Henry's Law Constants for Nitrogen in a Methanoland Carbon Dioxide Mixture . . . . . . . . . . . . 30

8. Block Flow Diagram of the Rectisol Computer Model 39

9. Effect of Solvent Rate and Number of Trays onCarbon Dioxide Absorption . . . . . . . . . . . 42

10. Ternary Diagram for Methanol-Benzene-Water . . . . 45

11. McCabe-Thiele Plot for Azeotrope Column . . . . . 48

v

Page 6: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LIST OF TABLES

1. Comparison of Modified RKS Model Predictions withExperimental Data for Methanol-Hydrogen Sulfide-Carbon Dioxide- Nitrogen . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33

2. Binary Interaction Parameters for the ModifiedRedlich-Kwong-Soave Equation-of-State ......34

3. Composition of Feed Gas to Rectisol Process . . . 37

4. Desulfurized Gas Composition . o . . .....56

5. Acid Gas Composition . . . . ... . . . .. . . 56

6. Regenerated Methanol Composition . ... . . . . . 56

7. Cooling and Heating Duties for the Rectisol Process 58

vi

Page 7: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

I would like to express my appreciation to all the ASPEN

staff who gave me help and support on this project, especially

to Herb Britt and Chau-Chyun Chen for assisting me in almost

every aspect, to Joe Boston and Paul Mathias for their help

with modelling the physical properties, and to Willie Chan

and Fred Ziegler for their debugging efforts. I would also

like to thank my advisor, Professor L. B. Evans, forhis gui-

dance and optimism throughout.

vii

Page 8: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

I. INTRODUCTION

The objective of this work was to develop a computer

model of the Rectisol process (Hochgesand, 1970; Scholz, 1969)

using the ASPEN process simulator. This simulation was pre-

pared as part of a program to transfer ASPEN technology to the

Morgantown Energy Technology Center (METC) of the United States

Department of Energy. The overall program involved develop-

ment of computer models for the major process units in the

CONOCO Slagging Lurgi Coal Gasification process.

The computer modelling effort took CONOCO's design for

a commercial scale coal gasification facility as the basis

(CONOCO, 1980). This facility, shown schematically in Figure

1, is designed to generate pipeline quality substitute natural

gas from coal. Briefly, the process gasifies coal with steam

and oxygen, generated by cryogenic air separation. The gas-

ification takes place at high pressure in a moving bed slagging

gasifier using Lurgi technology. Crude synthesis gas is re-

covered from the top of the gasifier, while the ash is with-

drawn in a molten slag form from the bottom. The synthesis

gas is subsequently directed to the Rectisol unit for purifi-

cation. Here, light oils and sulfur compounds are removed

from the gas and recovered. Following purification, the gases

are allowed to undergo water-gas shift and methanation reac-

tions simultaneously. Carbon dioxide produced in the shift

reaction must then be washed out with hot carbonate solution

to improve the BTU quality of the substitute natural gas. The

final gas treatment involves compression and drying.

1

Page 9: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

cl

Cd

0

Cd

a d4a)

3d d

o0

a,

o0

Cd000\TO

co00:z;0

e,0oa)

CD

a,a)

a)fAt

w 2

ro

ordHc-)

a)for

0

o0

Cd

E

E

CEE

P-a) t=.H C

-

pxEC

W

oo

Page 10: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

3

The Rectisol process itself features refrigerated meth-

anol as the solvent into which the acid gases in the synthesis

gas are absorbed. The process is comprised of an absorption

section followed by a series of regeneration processes in which

the rich solvent is purified and the absorbed compounds recov-

ered. The diagram in Figure 2 illustrates the particular

Rectisol design proposed for the CONOCO coal gasification

facility.

The Rectisol computer model described in this report

provides a stream-by-stream heat and material balance for the

process. In addition, the model predicts the composition of

the outlet streams for a given set of operating conditions.

Therefore, the model can be used to assess the effect of var-

ious process variables on the composition of the desulfurized

gas and acid gas products. The model also predicts the purity

of the regenerated methanol solvent for specific regeneration

operating conditions. Separate models of the absorbers and

distillation columns yield a rigorous tray-to-tray analysis

of each column. Overall, the Rectisol simulation represents

a flexible tool which may be applied in future design and sen-

sitivity studies and in trouble-shooting after process start-

up.

The input to the simulation is based on the process flow-

sheet and feed streams from the CONOCO commercial design.

Since Rectisol is a proprietary process licensed by Lurgi Min-

eraloltechnik GmbH, the CONOCO design did not provide any in-

formation on the actual process operating conditions. For

this reason, development of the computer model entailed a

Page 11: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

o.H

34

d

i a)

) 0D ts

M *H

Z

~oooo

O 0zF ¢ C:

E0

0oH

oPE-4:0 Vm X

E

Z 0

4

U2U)

Wo0

U2a) a4.H &4

E-1

Page 12: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

5

fair amount of design work to establish reasonable process

operating conditions.

The following chapters describe the development of the

Rectisol model. The work initially involved a literature

search to locate published process data regarding Rectisol.

Subsequently, considerable effort was devoted to developing

a good thermodynamic model of the system to provide adequate

physical properties predictions. The actual computer model-

ling work required testing of several ASPEN models which were

still in the development stage. Further, it was necessary to

perform sensitivity studies on the design variables in order

to establish suitable operating conditions. It was orig-

inally intended to use the final Rectisol model to examine

the sensitivity of the process to various design variables.

However, lack of computer funds curtailed the project once

the model was developed.

Page 13: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

6

II. ACID GAS ABSORPTION PROCESSES

This section discusses the general features of acid gas

absorption processes in order to provide some background for

the detailed description of the Rectisol process. In addition,

the discussion serves to present the basic design variables

which must be considered in designing a process to remove acid

gases.

General Features of Acid Gas Absorption Processes

Removal of acid gases, primarily carbon dioxide and hydro-

gen sulfide, is important for many industrial plants producing

a gaseous intermediate or final product. In the production

of substitute natural gas by coal gasification, hydrogen is

generated together with a substantial quantity of carbon dioxide.

Since carbon dioxide has no heating value, it must be separated

out of the final pipeline gas to raise the overall BTU value.

The separation may occur at several points in the process.

Removal prior to shift conversion of the carbon monoxide and

water to hydrogen and carbon dioxide favors the equilibrium

hydrogen concentration. However, since carbon dioxide is pro-

duced in this reaction, further treating to remove carbon di-

oxide may be required. All sulfur bearing compounds, on the

other hand, must be removed before methanation to avoid poison-

ing the methanation catalyst.

Rectisol is just one example of the many acid gas absorp-

tion processes. In general, these processes feature an ab-

sorption section in which the acid gases are absorbed into a

liquid solvent, and a regeneration section where the acid gases

Page 14: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

7

are recovered to yield a lean solvent of sufficient purity

for recycle. In addition, the processes usually include a

final wash to recover solvent carried over with the acid gas

stream. The details of each section are discussed below,

highlighting the major factors affecting each section.

Absorption

Acid gases are removed from the sour gas by absorption

into a liquid solvent. The gas stream is contacted with the

solvent in an absorber column where it flows counter-current

to the downflowing liquid. The column itself may contain pack-

ing or trays, as dictated by the economics of the specific

design. Plate columns generally operate at lower efficiency.

Thus, a packed column design, which requires less height, may

be preferable when a large concentration of acid gas is to be

absorbed (Kohl and Riesenfeld, 1979).

Most absorbers operate at low temperature where equilib-

rium favors absorption. However, the fact that the absorption

rate increases with an increase in temperature justifies oper-

ating some absorption processes at elevated temperature.

Regeneration

The solvent regeneration section serves two functions:

namely, to recover the absorbed acid gases from the solvent,

and to reduce the gas concentration in the solvent to a low

level prior to its recycle to the absorber. A recycled sol-

vent of higher purity will absorb a greater quantity of gas

per pass, thereby reducing the solvent recirculation rate.

The tradeoff must therefore be considered between regeneration

costs andthe costs associated with a higher recycle rate, such

Page 15: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

8

as larger equipment and higher pumping requirements. Further,

the purity of the treated gas is limited by the degree of re-

generation. The gas will approach equilibrium with the fresh-

ly regenerated solvent which it contacts in the final stage

of the absorber (Hochgesand, 1970).

There are three primary methods of regeneration. The

choice is determined by the nature of the solvent and the de-

sired purity. Flash desorption represents the cheapest method

where the pressure of the solvent is let down in several stages.

The final stage is usually atmospheric. However, a vacuum

flash may be employed to remove the dissolved gases further.

If flash desorption is not adequate, the gases may be stripped

from the solvent following a single flash. Heat must be sup-

plied to the stripper to provide the heat of desorption and

to vaporize the stripping medium (often steam). This heat

is frequently supplied in the form of steam through the strip-

per reboiler. As such, the regeneration step can be a sig-

nificant energy consumer.

Hot regeneration provides the most complete regeneration

and consequently leads to the highest purity for the feed gas.

Gas solubility tends to decrease with increased temperature.

This effect is augmented by heating the solvent to its boil-

ing point so that solvent vapors provide some stripping action.

In this case, heat is required to raise the system to the sol-

vent boiling point, to supply the heat of desorption and fur-

ther to supply the heat of vaporization for the solvent vapors.

Although some of this heat may be obtained through heat ex-

change of the hot overhead gases and hot regenerated solvent

Page 16: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

9

with the incoming solvent, heat exchanger losses make external

heating necessary (Hochgesand, 1970).

Solvent Selection

A variety of solvents are employed to absorb acid gases.

Despite the varied chemical nature of these solvents, all

should exhibit certain characteristics to render them suit-

able as solvents. Foremost, the solvent must have a high sol-

vency for the acid gas constituents at reasonable operating

conditions. In addition, the absorption process must be rever-

sible so that the solvent will release the gas components with

relative ease to yield both gas and solvent of high purity.

It is highly undesirable for the solvent to form an irreversi-

ble compound with any of the feed gas constituents since this

may lead to appreciable solvent losses. The solvent should

also have low volatility to prevent excessive solvent losses

in the gas stream by vaporization. Other desirable character-

istics include low viscosity for minimal pumping costs, good

heat transfer properties and low heat capacity to minimize

heating requirements, stability, and low corrosivity. Finally,

low cost and availability are obviously desirable (Nonhebel,

1972).

The acid gas components may be absorbed into the solvent

by physically dissolving or by reacting chemically with an

active solvent component. The absorption process involves

transfer of the acid gases from the gas phase, through the

gas-liquid interface, into the liquid phase. In the case of

a chemical solvent, the absorbed gases then react reversibly

to form compounds. Chemical and physical solvents have

Page 17: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

10

several distinguishing characteristics which account for the

different absorption mechanisms. As the diagram in Figure 3

shows, the equilibrium loading of a physical solvent increases

in direct proportion to partial pressure, provided Henry's

Law applies. In contrast, the loading of a chemical solvent

rises rapidly at low gas partial pressure, but then reaches

a point of saturation beyond which little absorption occurs.

This distinction makes chemical solvents the best choice for

purifying gas streams at low gas partial pressures, and phys-

ical solvents the choice for purifying high pressure concen-

trated streams. The same behaviour dictates the method of

regeneration. Physical solvents are easily regenerated by

flash desorption, although stripping or hot regeneration may

be used for greater purity. However, a saturated chemical

solvent subjected to a pressure reduction will release only

a fraction of the total absorbed gas. Some form of reboiling

is required to effect adequate regeneration (Hochgesand, 1970).

In a chemical absorption system, chemical reactions in-

crease the liquid film coefficient, thereby raising the over-

all absorption rate (Kohl, Riesenfeld, 1970). Since chemical

absorption is more rapid than physical absorption, chemical

systems require fewer trays and thus smaller towers.

Heat Integration

Solvent regeneration usually takes place at higher temp-

erature than absorption. As a result, most acid gas absorption

processes are highly heat integrated. Often the rich solvent

may be preheated and the lean solvent cooled by heat exchange.

The absorption process is exothermic so that the solvent

Page 18: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

11

Figure 3

COMPARISON OF EQUILIBRIUM LOADINGnp' rT4.-.MTTAT. ATTh T.TVTAT. (NT.'T/1XTr1Z'

ChemicalSolvent

Pads

GasPartialPressure

Pdes

-icale nt

I I

I I

I

I I

I I

I I

I I

I I

I I

I I

I I

:ium

Re ference: Hochgesand, 1970

Page 19: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

12

temperature is raised within the absorber. This means that

additional cooling beyond heat exchange is necessary.

Solvent Recovery

To minimize the solvent losses from the system, the gas

streams may be washed with water or other suitable wash sol-

utions to recover the vaporized solvent leaving the absorption

or regeneration sections.

Advantages of the Rectisol Process

The Rectisol process employs refrigerated methanol as a

physical solvent to absorb both hydrogen sulfide and carbon

dioxide. According to the literature, the absorption process

is carried out at low temperatures, generally between O°F and

-75°F. At this temperature level, both hydrogen sulfide and

carbon dioxide are highly soluble in the methanol, although

the solubility of hydrogen sulfide exceeds that of carbon di-

oxide by a factor of 5-6 (Hochgesand, 1970). Methanol has a

high vapor pressure compared to most solvents. Thus, the low

temperature is also desirable to reduce the methanol losses

due to vaporization.

Rectisol has several attractions supporting its applic-

ation in the CONOCO design. Firstly, Rectisol is ideal for

high pressure processes since the equilibrium loading of a

physical solvent is directly proportional to pressure. In the

CONOCO design, the synthesis gas comes directly from the gas-

ifier and is therefore at high pressure. Further, since Rect-

isol favors absorption of hydrogen sulfide over carbon dioxide,

the hydrogen sulfide may be totally removed with only a frac-

tion of the carbon dioxide. Such selective removal is important

Page 20: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

13

for two reasons. Firstly, if the sulfur compounds are recov-

ered with a low concentration of carbon dioxide, the gas

stream may be handled directly in a sulfur recovery unit,

such as a Claus Plant, without overloading the sulfur plant

or without recourse to further separation. Secondly, since

carbon dioxide removal prior to shift conversion and methan-

ation is not necessary, utilities would be needlessly consumed

in removing a high proportion of the carbon dioxide at this

stage (Hochgesand, 1970). However, as mentioned earlier, it

may be attractive to remove a fraction of the carbon dioxide

on account of the equilibrium considerations associated with

the subsequent water-gas shift reaction.

Rectisol Process Description

This section discusses the specific design of the Rect-

isol process developed as part of the CONOCO Slagging Lurgi

Coal Gasification commercial design. Figure 4 shows a simpli-

fied block flow diagram of the process, indicating the major

process sections. A copy of the Rectisol process flowsheet,

taken from the CONOCO commercial design report,is displayed

in Figures 5 and 6. The details of each section are outlined

briefly below.

In the Rectisol unit, the synthesis gas produced in the

gasification section is treated to remove the undesirable

sulfur compounds and to recover any light oils in the gas.

Purified gas is then directed to the joint shift/methanation

section. The removed sulfur compounds proceed to the sulfur

recovery unit.

Page 21: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C12010

(aU2tr1

CC

0

U)

HP-)II0q.CAE0XaaH4P-

A_

b4

.0 *

Fr

L

0U)

Izcil

a)"IPL,

r

I

Page 22: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

15

T r

I.

'. O1_ 5|

il

_ . -,I

I ~ ~~~~~~~~~~ I

:I

r I_

!'3

!I

g.I,

II_

I-

lt"

I LI1 .1- -- , -,,II .,

Ir X -'-"0X I f__

- - -T-

A1 I

-i I

- -. .

L

- E- .4 - -

i- 1- -

*lg;(I�

_____ 1 tT7�TTh, '¾�IwiI,'' 4

~~~~~~~~~~~'Ia* I-- . - - - - -- - 2

fi.

1T

_\

_ _

I, -. --

1-

ill

0 -

I

.t4

iif

JA-

i..

Wa

iiaIi

I

- I

r'v"'|It . -t r ..

5 i * ai

(

II &'

A

1 tI

I !....... . t . _

I ------- r�------l-------

- -.-r·~-

I

I

\I

1~~~~

= .J..

J-, f.- �i� I,

" fi i. II ,� Ii - . ---

II

,;II, 4

'I

0 -,

!

4.11

i -! i -I i I I

I I II i I

II i I

II I

iI i i

I Ii i i , I

�- I 1.-, 1-i

i I , . I II

I

t

I

I

L----. -- �I

i

- . .-

Page 23: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

16

r II

..

I . Z z

.I .t . , _

I

_

id

I

.tl~

-. ,_ .,.

. is-l

I ,t f . e !

_ :.2_i-_ t | rt -i !

I ( I I I y I I Hl _' _3 a

+ < - t ' -----

, I , .F , , i ,

'IfX '

I -_ _ _

! ~----- _ -,-' -

I

,I i-- - I, 1 I __ i

,; .,A I Iz -i i -I . f-ts,

- j - --- - -, -'

I. ia..

I!I

.- ji' -

.__~~~ ~~~ ___ =

- , ,

--i I

.;I"Ir

.iI

I_

a

r ---.

I ij�1�tc.;'A

A� -- -, i.;- r1 1,

,1 .41 ., '

. '.

I

i j

3 -

-i !

3 11

., .g

\0

~t4...

. I

tI

f,. . _ .

lol~ .i tI a, ' -

, ' .

I

I i

j

iII

,f,

'

i I,,* a

. ...-

L.- --- 1

- - - j w~~_

ii -, , I

I g;i h.I Z,. 8-, 'I

i�tI -ill1� 5 ; , I -. I ,, �7 ti�l211'1

11

t

! ;:

; i

i!

F

. I

.I

; IL

I

I- , - -- - --,tI

I- - i --.- __j

--- -- i

i.14

'4i !I

1

I

. I3 i3: " Z�� i -, �11I .1

:,1; ,9 !?-� _ .,

Ii I

Page 24: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

17

The feed gas is first cooled to absorption conditions by

heat exchange with the purified gas and by supplemental refrig-

eration. The cooled gas then proceeds to the absorption sec-

tion where the sulfur compounds, naphtha, hydrogen cyanide and

water are physically absorbed with refrigerated methanol. The

absorption process occurs at high pressure and low temperature

in two stages; in the prewash section, all the naphtha, water

and hydrogen cyanide are removed with some of the acid gas,

while in the main wash section, the remaining sulfur compounds

and a portion of the carbon dioxide are absorbed.

The ensuing process steps are devoted to solvent regen-

eration in which acid gases are recovered from the methanol

to yield a lean solvent of sufficient purity for recirculation.

In the first step, the rich solvent streams from the prewash

and main wash absoprtion sections are separately flash regen-

erated. The pressure of the solvent is reduced causing a frac-

tion of the acid gases to desorb.

The liquid from the prewash flash regenerator is sent to

the naphtha extractor to recover the absorbed naphtha. Here

a liquid-liquid separation is attained on adding the water

rich bottoms from the water wash column. The high purity

naphtha layer is decanted and sent to storage. The remaining

methanol-water-naphtha liquid is fed to the azeotrope column.

This column produces an overhead composed of naphtha, carbon

dioxide, hydrogen sulfide and methanol. A mixture of methanol

and water is recovered in the bottoms which is subsequently

separated in the methanol-water column.

Page 25: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

18

The hot regenerator serves to strip the main wash solvent

of the gases that were not desorbed during flash regeneration.

The methanol overhead from the methanol-water column is also

fed to this unit where the methanol vapors, in conjunction

with those generated in the reboiler, act as the stripping

medium. The acid gases are recovered in the overhead and com-

bined with the gases from flash regeneration, the azeotrope

column and the naphtha extractor. This total gas stream is

finally water washed to recover any vaporized methanol prior

to being sent to the sulfur plant.

A portion of the regenerated methanol from the hot regen-

eration column bottoms is used as reflux for the methanol-

water column. The remaining methanol is cooled by heat ex-

change with the naphtha extractor feed and the hot regeneration

column feed. After further refrigeration, the regenerated

methanol is recirculated to the absorption section.

Page 26: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

19

III. DEVELOPMENT OF PHYSICAL PROPERTIES MODEL

Accurate representation of the phase equilibria was es-

sential to the simulation work in view of the lack of process

data. Moreover, the physical properties estimation was esp-

ecially important since the hydrogen sulfide-carbon dioxide-

nitrogen-hydrogen-methanol-water-aromatics system is highly

non-ideal. The presence of methanol and water, which are

significantly polar, and hydrogen, nitrogen, carbon monoxide

and methane, which are supercritical, render this system hard

to describe. Therefore, considerable effort was devoted to

developing a good thermodynamic model.

In order to simplify the system, all the sulfur compounds

are treated as hydrogen sulfide, and the C2, C3, C4 compounds

are lumped into the methane component throughout this work.

The naphtha in the feed is represented as benzene since coal-

derived liquids are generally aromatic. These simplifications

reduce the system to the following nine components: H2, CO, N2,

C02, CH4, H2S, H20, C6H6, and CH30H.

Selection of the Thermodynamic Model

There are two approaches to modelling the phase behaviour

of a mixture. The conventional method invokes a liquid act-

ivity coefficient model to represent the liquid and an equation-

of-state for the vapor. Thus, the system is described according

to:

iYiPT xfwherei = vapor fugacity coefficient

PT = total pressure

Page 27: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

20

Xi = liquid activity coefficient

fol= liquid reference fugacity1

yixi = vapor, liquid mole fractions

The alternative approach uses a single equation-of-state to

describe both the vapor and liquid phases. Noncondensable

components in the mixture present a problem with regard to

establishing the reference fugacity for the activity coeffi-

cient approach. Generally, the standard state fugacity is

that of the pure liquid at the system temperature and pressure.

It is meaningless, however, to consider a pure liquid state

for a supercritical component and, thus, it is necessary to

follow the unsymmetric convention. In this case, the activity

coefficient is normalized to 1.0 at infinite dilution and the

Henry's Law constant becomes the standard state fugacity. As

O'Connell (1977) points out, there are difficulties associated

with referencing to the Henry's Law constant for multicompon-

ent solvents since the constant is dependent on solvent comp-

osition. As such, the composition dependence of the standard

state fugacity should be built into the thermodynamic model.

On the other hand, equation-of-state models have generally

proved to be inadequate for predicting the non-idealities of

mixtures containing polar substances (Mathias, 1981). How-

ever, ASPEN has recently adapted the Redlich-Kwong-Soave

(RKS) equation-of-state to improve its ability to represent

systems containing highly polar compounds. Mathias (1981)

has demonstrated that this model is effective in describing

the coexisting vapor and liquid phases for systems such as

methanol-water. An alternative model applicable to polar

Page 28: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

21

systems is the Perturbed Hard Chain equation-of-state (Gmeh-

ling et al., 1979). In this case, the model handles polar

components by assuming that they dimerize. Thus, the model

must evaluate the chemical equilibrium for the dimerization

process. Such treatment proves to be a major drawback for

this equation-of-state since it augments the computational

effort substantially. In addition, as Mathias (1981) notes,

dimers are rarely observed experimentally, so that the equation

rests on a weak theoretical foundation.

Consideration of the difficulties and inaccuracies assoc-

iated with the activity coefficient model approach led to the

selection of an equation-of-state to correlate the Rectisol

system for this work. The particular equation-of-state that

was chosen was the modified version of the Redlich-Kwong-

Soave model which is described in the next section.

Modified Redlich-Kwong-Soave Equation-of-State

The basic Redlich-Kwong-Soave equation is given by

RT aV - b V( + b)

where 'a' and 'b' are functions of critical temperature and

pressure as follows

a = (T)a

2 2ac= 0.42748 R TciciP

b = 0.08664 RTci

P .ci

To some extent, the 'a' parameter may be regarded as an attrac-

tive parameter, accounting for the intermolecular attractive

Page 29: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

22

forces. On the other hand, the 'b' parameter is a repulsive

term, representing the finite volume occupied by the component.

c(T) is used to correlate pure component vapor pressure data

and has been modified by ASPEN to the following form

05 = 1 + m(1 - Tr05) - p( - Tr)(0a7 - Tr)

Tr = reduced temperature

m = function of acentric factor

p = polar parameter

The correlation for m, taken from the work of Graboski and

Daubert (1978), is

2m = .48508 - 1.55191 - 0.15613ao

where = acentric factor.

The ASPEN work has introduced the polar parameter, p, in the

expression for to improve the vapor pressure predictions.

This parameter is empirical and must be determined by fitting

experimental pure component vapor pressure data.

For supercritical components, Boston and Mathias (1980)

recommend a different expression for to extrapolate into

the supercritical region

= exp(c (1 - T))

with c = 1 +0.5m +0.3p

d= c- 1

c

Mixtures are represented by the above equations using

the one-fluid theory. This means that the parameters 'a' and

'b' become quadratic mole fraction averages with the following

form

a - zzx x.a.1 1 3a = '.: f i

b i xix .b..1 jj

Page 30: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

23

where

aij = (a.a.)0 5(1 - K0 - K1 T )l13ai a i j 1000

b. (b + b )(1 - K ° - K1 T )13 i 2 i bij bi 10002 1

As these equations show, the binary interaction parameters,

Kai and Kb , are expressed as linear functions of the absol-

ute temperature in Kelvin. These parameters account for the

deviation of the behaviour of a binary pair from that predicted

according to the basic mixing rules. Any combination of these

four parameters, K K K0 K may be used to fit binary'a' a' Kb' Kb'

vapor-liquid equilibrium (VLE) data to the modified RKS equa-

tion-of-state.

Experimental Phase Equilibrium Data

The physical properties model requires only binary inter-

action parameters in order to describe a multicomponent system.

In the absence of multicomponent vapor-liquid equilibrium data,

values for these parameters may be established by fitting bi-

nary phase equilibrium data alone. Prausnitz (1980) indicates

that his experience has been good in employing only binary

experimental data to predict multicomponent equilibria, pro-

vided that the system is well removed from the critical for

each component. He cautions that, in cases where the critical

conditions are exceeded, multicomponent predictions may be

unreliable even if the binaries are fit well. Unfortunately,

published multicomponent data are not available for the spe-

cific Rectisol system. This deficiency made it necessary to

rely on experimental binary equilbrium data to a great extent.

As the work proceeded towards determining the parameters for

Page 31: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

24

the modified RKS model, the results of a recent study at North

Carolina State University became available, presenting quater-

nary data for the hydrogen sulfide-carbon dioxide-nitrogen-

methanol system (Rousseau et al., 1981). These data initially

served as a comparison for the multicomponent equilibria pre-

dicted by the preliminary physical properties model. Subse-

quently, the quaternary data were used to improve the binary

parameter estimates, leading ultimately to an improvement in

the model predictions.

In order to maintain the data fitting effort at a manage-

able level, it was initially decided to ignore the interactions

between two gas components. Justification for this simpli-

fication lay in the fact that the non-idealities of the liquid

phase were expected to dominate over the vapor phase non-ideal-

ities, as Prausnitz notes (1980). This decision reduced the

data fitting to the 21 possible interactions of the gas com-

ponents with methanol, benzene and water and the interactions

between methanol, benzene and water themselves.

The temperatures in the Rectisol process span a broad

range, varying from -75°F in the absorption section to as high

as 250°F during solvent regeneration. To minimize the degree

of extrapolation, the parameter estimation work called for

data covering as wide a temperature range as possible. A

literature search revealed experimental phase equilibria for

each of the binary pairs. Although this information did not

provide complete temperature coverage, the data adequately

spanned the temperatures where a given interaction was most

relevant. For instance, gas-liquid non-idealities are most

Page 32: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

25

important at the lower end of the temperature range where ab-

sorption takes place. On the other hand, the high temperature

processes mostly involve the separation of benzene, methanol

and water.

In cases where more than one data set were located for

a binary pair, only the most recent was selected for the model

development unless these data appeared to be generally incon-

sistent with previous data.

Development of Modified Redlich-Kwong-Soave Model Parameters

Fitting the modified RKS model to binary experimental

data involved adjustment of a combination of the four inter-

action parameters, K, K, K, K1, as discussed previously.

The best estimates for the combination of parameters were

generated for each set of binary data using the ASPEN Data

Regression System (DRS). DRS employs the maximum-likelihood

principle in reducing experimental data. This analysis recog-

nizes that experimental data contain random measurement errors

which it takes into consideration, assuming that the errors

are randomly distributed about zero with a normal distribution.

The standard deviation associated with a particular measure-

ment is supplied by the user. The system creates an objective

function comprised of sum-of-squares terms for each observed

variable, for example:

N e 2 o 2 o. e 2(Pi-Pi) -T i ) (Xlil)

T. + . +1 a,.2 x2

P, Cr1 1 .1

in which the superscript 'o' stands for the value adjusted

according to the thermodynamic model, while 'e' refers to the

Page 33: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

26

experimental value. The terms are summed over all data points.

In DRS, the Britt-Luecke (1973) generalized least-squares al-

gorithm computes estimates for the model parameters such that

the objective function is minimized. At the same time, the

parameters must satisfy the equilibrium constraint that the

fugacities of all equilibrium phases are equal.

Prausnitz (1980) presents an informative discussion of

the methods of estimating parameters. Many of his recommend-

ations were adopted for this work. For instance, the follow-

ing values were used for the standard deviation of the measured

variables, as Prausnitz suggests: temperature - 0.050°C, pres-

sure - 1 mmHg, liquid mole fraction - 0.001, vapor mole frac-

tion - 0.003.

The data regression work demonstrated that, in most cases,

two parameters adequately correlate the equilibrium data. How-

ever, in the final set of interaction parameters, additional

parameters are included for some pairs if these improve the

fit significantly. One notable example is the benzene-water

system for which all four parameters are essential to modelling

the observed liquid immiscibility. It should be noted that,

in order for the 'a' and 'b' parameters in the fundamental RKS

equation to retain their theoretical significance, the term

(1 - K0 - K1 T ) and the analogous term for the 'b' para-aij aij 100-0

meter must have a positive value. Unfortunately, in the case

of benzene and water, large parameter values are necessary to

represent the equilibrium, rendering the above terms negative.

While this anomaly causes no computational difficulty, it does

mean that the model must be considered to be purely empirical

Page 34: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

27

as far as benzene and water are concerned. As such, there

may be some concern about using the equation-of state to ex-

trapolate information. However, the benzene-water experimental

data adequately cover the temperature range of importance in

the Rectisol process. Further, a comparison with experimental

data demonstrates that the model provides a good prediction

of the liquid-liquid equilibrium for the methanol-benzene-

water system. This comparison is illustrated in the follow-

ing chapter.

It has been suggested that highly non-ideal mixtures,

such as the benzene-water mixture, may be better represented

using the recently proposed mixing rules based on the local-

composition concept (Boston, 1981; Whiting, Prausnitz, 1981).

Further work in this area lay beyond the scope of this project.

In general, good agreement was obtained between the ex-

perimental binary data and the thermodynamic model predictions.

The maximum error in the liquid composition for a set of bi-

nary data was, on the whole, less than 6 percent. For a given

binary pair, the binary parameters exhibit a high degree of

correlation which indicates that the parameters are not uniquely

determined. In other words, the experimental data may be rep-

resented by several alternate parameter combinations with

little loss of accuracy.

Evaluation of the Preliminary Thermodynamic Model

The preliminary thermodynamic model of the Rectisol

system was comprised of the modified RKS equation-of-state

with interaction parameters generated by regression of binary

Page 35: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

28

data, as just described. This model neglected any gas-gas

interactions, considering them to obey the simple mixing rules

without correction. To assess the validity of the model, the

predicted equilibria for the hydrogen sulfide-carbon dioxide-

nitrogen-methanol subsystem were checked against the data pre-

sented by the North Carolina State University team (Rousseau

et al., 1981). Bubble point calculations using the experimental

liquid composition and temperature permitted a comparison of

the predicted bubble point pressure and vapor composition with

the actual data. Unfortunately, the model did not prove to

represent the data adequately, overpredicting the bubble point

pressure by as much as 30 percent and overestimating the nitro-

gen in the vapor at the expense of the carbon dioxide. In an

effort to ameliorate the situation, parameters modelling the

gas-gas interactions (carbon dioxide-nitrogen, hydrogen sul-

fide-carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide-nitrogen) were regressed

from binary data and included in the model. The resulting

improvement in the model predictions was not considered suf-

ficient. Further, the predicted Henry's Law constants for

nitrogen in mixed methanol-carbon dioxide and methanol-hydrogen

sulfide solvents exhibited unexpected behaviour. The experi-

mental data appeared to be consistent with the approximate

relationship that

~~,ln HN mix =Zixi ln HN, i(Prausnitz, 1980)

with x. = solvent mole fraction on solute free basis21

However, rather than displaying linearity on a logarithmic basis

according to the above expression, the predicted Henry's Law

constants increased initially with a small increase in the

Page 36: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

29

amount of dissolved carbon dioxide or hydrogen sulfide. The

constants appeared to reach a maximum before decreasing to the

Henry's Law constant for nitrogen in pure carbon dioxide or

hydrogen sulfide. Figure 7 illustrates the variation of the

Henry's Law constant with solvent composition. The plot in-

cludes three curves. The upper two demonstrate the improve-

ment in the behaviour of the constant on inclusion of the gas-

gas interactions. The lower results from utilizing the quaternary

data in estimating the parameters for the physical proper-

ties model, which is discussed in detail in the following

section. The abnormal solubility behaviour is in part re-

sponsible for the deviations between the predicted and experi-

mental compositions. In the model, a small amount of dissolved

gas in the methanol results in an unexpectedly high Henry's

constant and consequently a lower solubility for nitrogen.

Therefore, the vapor mole fraction of nitrogen is overpredicted.

From an analysis of the experimental data and the model

predictions, it was concluded that the vapor interactions

between carbon dioxide and nitrogen are strong and conceal

any non-idealities in the liquid. This fact makes the system

hard to analyze. It did not appear possible to isolate the

vapor and liquid behaviour from binary data using a single

equation-of-state. The apparant success of Rousseau et al.

(1981) in modelling the quaternary system may be attributed

to the fact that they adopted the activity coefficient ap-

proach. -This means that they employed a separate equation

for each phase. In their model, the vapor is represented by

the RKS equation-of-state with interaction coefficients set

Page 37: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

30

0

omq'e 'ueosjqTN oJ us!suoo M1j sRJuaH

R~

0 ~:E-q H

Z X00 Hi--.tH

zO P4Z

EOZCl . m

z .H Hr- CD Q¢ a4

> E1Z~ vN <

--I

0C0

0 ,

o*H .,i

0000Oi *H

o .

a) *I-- 0H 0

()0

00 O\ 0 0 0 0 00C) C- 0 0 0 0 V0oo 0 0 V 0 C1,2_) n cn CM -A-

00

;

Page 38: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

31

to the standard vapor values available from separate vapor

phase studies. Having established the vapor behaviour in

this manner, the liquid behaviour could be considered indep-

endently.

In working with the modified RKS equation, it appeared

that the 'a' parameter, the attractive term in the basic

equation, could be treated as the vapor term, while the re-

pulsive 'b' term could be considered as representing the liq-

uid. This observation suggested that the vapor interactions

could be isolated from those in the liquid by fixing the in-

teraction parameter for the 'a' term to the standard RKS vapor

value reported in the literature. The remaining non-idealities

due to the liquid phase could then be reflected in the 'b'

parameter. It should be noted that this approach is only

suitable .for subcritical components since the modified RKS

equation only reduces to the original RKS equation at condi-

tions below the critical.

For the final model. it was decided to use the quater-

nary experimental data in the data regression runs to gener-

ate improved parameter estimates for the interactions between

carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide and nitrogen. So that the

DRS runs would converge, several parameters were fixed before

the final DRS run rather than fitting all the gas-gas inter-

actions with the quaternary data. Hydrogen sulfide-nitrogen

gas interactions appeared less significant, so the original

parameters developed from binary data were used. The effect

of the vapor interactions for the hydrogen sulfide-carbon di-

oxide pair, which are both subcritical, was modelled with the

Page 39: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

32

standard RKS value for K (Graboski and Daubert, 1978). Dataa

regression of the quaternary data then established parameter

estimates for aKtrge and thestimates for nd Kb for carbon dioxide-nitrogen and the

liquid K for hydrogen sulfide-carbon dioxide. The resultant

model predictions agree substantially better with the experi-

mental data as the comparison in Table 1 shows. The bubble

point pressure predictions still appear to deviate from the

data, especially at the higher pressure levels, however.

Table 2 displays the final parameter estimates, indicating

the literature source of the data. This table shows that the

final set includes values for several additional gas pairs

which were readily available from previous work (Mathias, 1981).

The parameter set is stored in a user library under RKAKIJ,

to be called directly by the simulation program.

Enthalpy Calculations

In order to guarentee reliable enthalpy predictions from

the modified RKS model, enthalpy data should be included in

the data regression runs to determine interactions parameters.

However, such data were not available for the Rectisol system.

Under these circumstances, the Lee-Kesler equation-of-state

was favored over the modified RKS equation-of-state for enthal-

py calculations. The former correlation has a good reputation

for predicting reasonable mixture enthalpies based on the pure

component properties.

Page 40: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

33

Nc O N N0 ~ 0 O\ V

o O cox 0 -0i- co 0i

0 o 0 0U O C' O Co

0 0 0 0000o o o

q C0 0 0 0

0 n C O

o 0 N nx * * *

O~EV2 ~ O O O O

M ~ O ad) E-4 c o # u-4 i2C 0 0 0 0H o 0 No c N

:HE0 0 0 0s a 72 N 0 0~C \0

O¢ C TO CO CO N

o fail 0H M Co 0 \tz H N iH N H

UE S\ 0 0 0 00 r z0 0 0 0H \PO O O OC'2P X ¢ O0 0 0 0E Eq CM0 O O o~

O~~~- N O OCO V3 N 0 0 0 O O O O

~:2~ O O O OO O 0 O

a) c . .

So CQl C\1 Cr

I I I I

N C V O,

I\0 c- c- -\O O' O'- O~

0 0 c'- CO

o \0 0 0 0

O 0 0 0C; C; C~ ;'O O O O

n n N OnO O O OO O O Oo 0 0 0o; 0 0N C n Cn \0o \) 0 c'-

O 0 0 0iN i- NM n

O 0 C\l n

00 0 0V- --I n -w n m m)CO N CO cO

o 0 0 0;__> 4 wr6

o N N N

o 0 0 0C- \o o n, 0 C)- 0I .o o o o

t0 0 0 0e C" " co 0i v- CN T- CMli o o o o* * 0 0 0 0

co \0 C \0o C C'-o o 0 00 0 0 0o 0 0 0O o 0 o oo o o oo o 0 0

o~ -; o;(O c O 00I4 C n -0

0s 0 C Y'ON, ,-4 ON, O._ N N CnIqO O O O0 0 0 0

- -T

IW l T I' * i.1%

_-

.~

Page 41: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

34

O ON ON

o7\ C\

* Cd

a) c~~- C~ Cd cd -

ON O\ 4-' 4-

o a)U2 _ -a) a) S

Ld d Cd~ d-P a a) cN N UCd 4S .- *H *H 4-'

w a) 00 ifq (~: >-i >-i 11

n\ \

\_ COON - '\-C'--

* a) .

cd~ ONON a) 3

O ON a) H

_ O CO ') a)

$s cqcd 0 0 *H Hc) Cdo 000-PHM

C- cr\

U) C.'-U-- C--a) OOCd Cd N N N N N c N *H+- O O, r O\ O\ O\ O\ 4-a) . i-I # d i-i i-I ~-I i-I Cd v-f

- ' Cd

-P HH r- HH -H C H ) . ) ) 0 ) ~> Oa) a) a) cd a) a a) U)

bfl * O rO ;4 rO rO ' C= - *H M q -M -, M 0

C.- 0 D O C OCY N ON0?C -.I

0", 0 -.I ~01ON co NC ON

0 0 v-) 0

0000I I I

· .-"t . O.C) 0 o £ Cdo--j co OC\ '--

I I Io d-t \0 cOn C\l C\ O

oN \ O 0 N 0·O-gj -~m~- N\O ONH NO000 - 0I I I I

\D C\? C>1

0 0 Oo000

O 0oC')\0 co0 °c'V-4 V) V'

I

0 C\l

0 0 O o co I

o 0 0 0 d )I I

C- C- V, 0 N H \ ON\ CO

C .- CO \ ' O O \cn C nN co T-0 [,-- CcO O0 ~ 0 0.4 .-. 0

CO 0 \ CO N V)' c O

000000 0000V' V) <ztN V l1 n n n V--i I I I

o~~~~ ~ ~ 0 o o0 0 C0 C

O~ O~ O~ O O O O O C) OOOOOOOOOOOOO0OOOOO00O

C-\ o00 0 0 -. o0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0(O O (O O A ( (H (O (O (O (O (O (: O O (

I

0 N = U N CM C\l Ne\0 cN NO= NO X : : N \ NO N O X: CN CN 0 CZ CN

C, = V Z V 2 C. C. M 0 X V Z C.) V :M: O V t) Z =

:m = t' m: = m0000000 ,0 \0 \0 0 0(n n n n n n n 0 0 0 0 0 0 = ' ,00000000 : : = = : = N N N O 0 0 \ 0 rOV V V V 0 V V V m =:r = = t m V 0 V V 0 )

HH

E

0EIEq D0

O;ZN Ui) -

H tr>E q

I

E O

~HZtq:E

*,rCdP-4

-'

Za)0pS0C-

Page 42: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

aNC\

o O U

a) U: CC -)

o ,la ) H

-P N 0 a.· H r oo i o-4 U2>0 o

U~\O cO\0QJG\\Q

'-4

OOH

· \ l Cd-4 a)

*H +'_ a)

E - o

0 *H AE- S )

- C\ 1-IO\ co oD-.I-C\ --O ocl-0 0o0 ' '~~~~~~0 0 m -0C\l

I

o1-40-

C\.l 1Lf\Cno0 - CWl

I I II I I

n V)

00· o0o o

o o0 o o 0 O · o

o a a a 00000\.O0 00000 - 00 0

i cs oI

U) _ N Oj C~l O O O C0~4=:a: 0 0

0 0 C\ 0 C'JeC~io

35

V~ON

o

0

o

0

-iN-P

HH

0

0

0

I-

o

C\Z

a)EH

HHO Eqqr V20 E-1

0Io

Z I'0 Z

PI-I'HU E-

wE

i OV2O RO

EH

Z H,H

'- R

H~

mq

cc0ooc0

0

coCO\ON

00

\0

0\I

*ri

-p

a)

0

00V

Page 43: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

36

IV. SIMULATION OF THE RECTISOL PROCESS

Basis for the Process Simulation

The proprietary nature of the Rectisol process restricts

the amount of process data disclosed in the literature. The

information presented in the CONOCO Commercial Design Report

consists solely of the feed and product compositions and a

process flowsheet. While the process flowsheet shows detail

of the sequence of operations and the destination of all in-

termediate streams, no specifics are provided for the process

operating conditions. On account of the lack of actual oper-

ating conditions, it was impossible to develop a simulation

that would match the CONOCO design. Therefore, this work

adopted the approach of developing a viable Rectisol design

based on the CONOCO design flowsheet and feed composition.

The feed gas composition, pressure and temperature displayed

in Table 3 were taken for the process model.

The literature search located typical absorption temp-

erature and pressure ranges only. Detailed simulation of the

other process units using ASPEN established the remaining

operating conditions necessary to achieve the desired separ-

ation.

To minimize the computer time and cost associated with

simulating a complex cyclic process such as Rectisol, a sim-

plified process model was assembled. In this simulation, a

series of simple unit operations such as mixers, splitters,

flashes, heaters and pumps represent the Rectisol process.

Rigorous simulation of the staged separation units is performed

Page 44: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

37

Table 3

COMPOSITION OF FEED GAS TO RECTISOL PROCESS

Component lbmol/hr

Hydrogen 1909.7Carbon Monoxide 4052.9Carbon Dioxide 299.1Methane 471 1Ethane 18.9Ethylene 2.2Propane 4.7Propylene 2.2Butane 1.8Butylene 1.6Nitrogen 41.7Hydrogen Sulfide 131.0Carbonyl Sulfide 8.0Carbon Disulfide 0.1Thiophene 0.4Hydrogen Cyanide traceNaphtha 23.1Water 13.8

Total 6982.3

Temperature, OF 95Pressure, psia 427

Page 45: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

38

on a stand-alone basis, external to the overall flowsheet.

The results of such rigorous simulations established the splits

to be used in the simplified model, where the units are modelled

by separator blocks. A block flow diagram of the overall

flowsheet simulation is shown in Figure 8, indicating the

correspondence between the model and the actual design flow-

sheet. Appendix A contains the computer input and output for

the simplified Rectisol model.

The development and design philosophy employed in each

of the major process sections is discussed in detail below.

Absorption Section

The hydrogen sulfide absorber consists of two separate

sections; a prewash section, which removes all the water and

naphtha from the synthesis gas, and a main wash section, where

the bulk of the hydrogen sulfide absorption occurs. Each

section was simulated independently using RADFRAC, which is

ASPEN's rigorous model for multistage vapor-liquid fraction-

ation. The results of these simulations were used to set the

degree of absorption in the overall flowsheet simulation in

which two mixers and two separators (PREWASH1, PREWASH2, H2S-

ABS1, H2SABS2) model the absorption section.

In designing the absorbers, the designer must establish

the number of trays, the temperature of the entering gases

and solvent, and the operating pressure. For a given degree

of absorption, these parameters then dictate the required

solvent rate. Hochgesand (1970) indicates that for the Rect-

isol process the methanol circulation rate greatly affects the

process economics, since it influences the size of all process

Page 46: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

I

p i 0 239-s

'4

-1 -- - -- . .....

&| s--3--- -- g

CL_ r1 . ' ? w 8 3

. ...... .... ; X/ X7--Lh .0 I WI,!Ge~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~O

- ~~~~~~~IQC4 ~ X ~i

a'

4t1 1

A .1I~~~~~

-4 I

.1 I

C

~1 I'

A.

I

iI

II

p a

O CD

¢- P

O E<E-I D0) Ha5 or : O

I HnV E4OD V

W 2 ! . ! , I =

i I

- . - I

I

- -- --- TI

I'( I

11

-,,1

I

41o I 11

I- t I

F

--- jI

Page 47: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

40

equipment, pumping costs, regeneration costs etc.. The design

of the absorption section, therefore, sought to minimize the

methanol solvent rate. Since high pressure favors physical

absorption, the absorbers are designed to operate at the maxi-

mum pressure compatible with the other units. This pressure

of 421 psia is the pressure of the gasifier overhead less an

allowance of 6 psi for the pressure drop through the heat ex-

change train. According to Hochgesand (1970), economics rarely

justify compressing the feed gas further. With the same con-

sideration in mind, the absorbers are designed to operate at

low temperature with the recirculating methanol cooled to -75 °F

and the feed gas cooled to -30° 0F. Sasol report such temper-

ature levels for their Rectisol operation, which appear to be

typical (Hoogendoorn, 1957). Further, although this study

did not examine the detailed heat exchange between the feed

and desulfurized gas, a heat balance shows that the feed may

be cooled by heat exchange to -30° F without supplemental

refrigeration.

Absorption columns may contain packing or trays, although

there is some evidence in the literature to suggest that trayed

columns are more common for Rectisol (Maddox, 1977; Herbert,

1956). In the current design, the absorbers are designed as

trayed columns. The pressure drop through the column is based

on the rule-of-thumb of 0.15 psi pressure drop per stage

(Treybal, 1968).

The design for the prewash absorber features six theoreti-

cal trays and a solvent rate set at 25 percent greater than

the theoretical rate required to absorb all the naphtha. This

Page 48: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

follows the recommendation of Kohl and Riesenfeld (1979).

Given the objective of the prewash absorber to recover the

naphtha with as little hydrogen sulfide as possible, the meth-

anol rate is restricted to the minimum that ensures complete

naphtha absorption. In order to improve the performance of

the RADFRAC model for the prewash absorber, the feed is pre-

flashed so that any liquid may bypass the absorber. This

preflash simulates what would actually occur in the bottom

of the absorber.

The gas from the prewash absorber proceeds to the main

wash section where all the hydrogen sulfide and part of the

carbon dioxide are removed. The methanol solvent rate to the

main wash section was determined so that the degree of carbon

dioxide removal agreed with the information presented in the

CONOCO Commercial Design Report, while achieving complete

removal of hydrogen sulfide. However, the basis for the ab-

sorber feed composition did not account for the small amount

of recycled hydrocarbon gas. This means that the predicted

carbon dioxide gas removal in the overall simulation is not

in complete agreement with the CONOCO commercial design.

It is unusual for an absorber to contain less than six

or more than ten theoretical trays (Perry and Chilton, 1973).

A sensitivity study to the number of trays in the main wash

absorber indicated that an increase from six to ten trays re-

sults in a reductions of only 2 percent in the required meth-

anol rate. Figure 9 shows a plot of carbon dioxide in the

outlet gas versus solvent rate and number of trays. The rel-

ative insensitivity of the required amount of solvent to the

Page 49: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

42

Figure 9

EFFECT OF SOLVENT RATE AND NUMBEROF TRAYS ON CARBON DIOXIDE ABSORPTION

02 in Feed)er

5200Methanol Solvent Rate, lbmol/hr

260

d~ 220

o0

d 180

q,

; 140C\2

ro0- 0O l

. D-

3000 3400 3800 4200 4600

Page 50: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

43

tower size justified designing the main wash absorber with

six trays.

The output from simulating both the prewash and main wash

absorbers rigorously is included in Appendix B. In the final

simulation, the main wash and prewash absorbers operate with

3100 lbmol/hr and 330 lbmol/hr of circulating methanol respec-

tively.

Flash Regeneration Section

In the flash regeneration section, a fraction of the ab-

sorbed gases are recovered from the rich solvent by a reduction

in pressure. The pressure of downstream processes dictate the

final flash pressure. In this simulation, the prewash flash

regenerator flashes the prewash solvent to 30 psia, allowing

sufficient pressure head to feed the water wash column with-

out further compression. Similarly, the main flash regenerator

is designed to flash the main wash solvent to 30 psia in two

stages, with an intermediate pressure of 75 psia. Since the

vapor from the first flash is recycled to the absorption sec-

tion, the intermediate pressure must minimize the amount of

hydrogen sulfide and carbon dioxide desorbed while recovering

as much of the desired hydrocarbon gases as possible. An

intermediate pressure of 75 psia represents an appropriate

compromise. The three flashes are simulated as two-phase

adiabatic flashes (PRWSFLSH, FLSHRG1, FLSHRG2).

Naphtha Extractor

In the naphtha extractor, the methanol-water-naphtha-gas

stream is allowed to separate into two liquid phases to permit

removal of the naphtha-rich phase from the system. The feed

Page 51: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

44

consists primarily of the bottoms from the prewash flash re-

generator to which a water-rich stream is added to effect the

liquid-liquid separation. The water source is the bottoms

from the water wash column. In order to ensure that the

naphtha extractor operates without any of the water icing,

the prewash flash bottoms is preheated to 50°F. The design

pressure is 30 psia, 5 psi higher than the water wash column

to which any vapors are directed. At these conditions, the

physical properties model predicts a phase separation into

two liquid phases which are in reasonable agreement with liq-

uid-liquid experimental data for the methanol-benzene-water

ternary. The plot in Figure 10 illustrates the comparison

between the predicted separation at 38°F and experimental

data at 77°F. Unfortunately, published data were not located

at the actual separation temperature.

In the overall model, the naphtha extractor is represented

by a feed mixer (NEXMIX) followed by a three-phase adiabatic

flash at 30 psia (NEXSEP).

Azeotrope Column

The objective of the azeotrope column lies in removing

the residual naphtha and dissolved gases from the methanol-

water mixture. Preliminary simulation of the column using

RADFRAC suggested that a good separation is possible in this

column, yielding an uncontaminated methanol-water stream.

This simulation indicated that all the gas components and

naphtha are distilled in the overhead along with a small

portion of the methanol, while all the water and remaining

methanol are recovered in the bottoms. As the name of the

Page 52: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

d)a)

45 N

a)

wIu 1 9 MI4 1-1 a)

I C

Page 53: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

46

column suggests, the overhead may be expected to contain ben-

zene and methanol in their azeotropic compositions (61.4 mole

methanol at 128.8°F). Further simulation of the column with

RADFRAC demonstrated that in the overhead methanol and ben-

zene may indeed reach their azeotropic composition on a meth-

anol plus benzene basis.

Development of a feasible design for the azeotrope col-

umn involved setting the distillate rate, the reflux ratio,

the number of theoretical trays, and the feed entry point.

Seeing that the split between the overhead and the bottoms

was well defined in the preliminary study, the distillate

rate could be established purely by material balance consider-

ations. The behaviour of the column proved to be highly sen-

sitive to the reflux ratio. The amount of material in the

rectifying section of the column depends directly on the reflux

ratio. Since such a large percentage of the feed (94 mole

percent) ultimately appears in the bottoms product, a high

reflux ratio is necessary to ensure adequate vapor flow through-

out the column. In the final design, a reflux ratio of 2.0

leads to satisfactory operation. While this ratio appears to

be substantially higher than the minimum reflux ratio, diffi-

culties were encountered in obtaining a converged RADFRAC

solution at lower reflux ratios.

A revealing method of interpreting tray-to-tray output

uses the idealized McCabe-Thiele techniques (Russell, 1981).

This tool provides valuable insights despite the non-ideality

of the particular system. If methanol and benzene are iden-

tified as the two components which require separation, and

Page 54: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

47

all the compositions are normalized on a methanol plus ben-

zene basis, a McCabe-Thiele x-y diagram may be prepared. Fig-

ure 11 displays such a diagram for the upper portion of the

azeotrope column, where compositions are plotted on a loga-

rithmic scale for clarity. The equilibrium compositions were

taken directly from the RADFRAC output. This type of plot

identified pinch points, the minimum reflux ratio, and indic-

ated the optimum feed location during the column design. In

the final design, the feed enters at the third stage. Figure

11 suggests that a slight improvement in the column efficiency

may be realized with the feed located at the second stage.

The diagram also shows that the physical properties model pre-

dicts an azeotrope composition close to that reported. Since

the overhead lies at this composition, it can be seen that

increasing the number of trays would not improve the separa-

tion.

The feed quality plays a significant role in the column

design, as well. Given the fixed distillate rate of 45 lbmol/hr

a simplified material balance analysis, assuming constant molar

overflow, predicts the maximum percentage of vapor permitted

in the feed for the column to operate as desired. For in-

stance, with a reflux ratio of 2.0, the feed must be greater

than 82 percent liquid in order to meet the desired distillate

rate. Higher degree of vaporization results in insufficient

vapor in the stripping section. In the actual process flow-

sheet, the azeotrope column feed is preheated by heat exchange

with the waste water from the methanol-water column. The final

temperature of the waste water was taken to be 118°F, as

Page 55: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

48

o

I~~~~4z -,e7 _ -I I is

I ; e I I,

m 4ffll

1-H0 H +Hg

N

I; I I i i ' i I I '0Io

4t..

o

0

o0

:E0aio

H¢C)a) Ox4 rG

H-

Eq4

¢

b

.I i: ! I ;

4

J.

.$ ..t.? Ai'

CD _

0

0N:

\0\0XO

, j .

I-_ I

T

0N

IL

4

4

I1

, i i i i.! I I I

, , o InI IvWg

0'

i

c

I I I i iIll : I

-

3a10Y

i i

) q o

i 2 0i I I i10 -g D P 0 1D,

imq N

%t0

(2)i

0

w

¢

N

. I!---- - I"t~

lp

v

_ _

- I. . I 'li I' 1·

I

_.

I I I.

I

I I

iI

!15,

J

It I tf- . E

. I

-[ - - -

4~D

i 11 I : .

I I '

,l

i Nj i U- - I- � I ::i . , � !, i I i NJ I 1 1 - I I - i .mm+mw

A , . 'CA

I -, . I I

Page 56: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

49

indicated on the CONOCO flowsheet, for this simulation. This

heat exchange results in an all liquid azeotrope column feed

at a temperature of 96°F.

The rigorous simulation of the azeotrope column is shown

in Appendix C. This simulation required 40 outside loop iter-

ations to achieve a converged solution. The difficulty in

converging is a consequence of the non-ideality of the system

in which the outside loop variables for RADFRAC, namely K-

values and enthalpy, are highly composition dependent.

Methanol-Water Column

The methanol-water stream from the azeotrope column bot-

toms is separated in the methanol-water column. In this sim-

ulation, the column is designed to yield a 99 percent pure

methanol distillate. A RADFRAC model was used to develop

the column design, and to examine the sensitivity to various

design parameters. In addition, a McCabe-Thiele diagram pro-

vided initial estimates of the number of stages required to

effect the desired separation at a given reflux ratio. This

same diagram showed that the minimum reflux ratio occurs at

a value of approximately 0.9.

Perry (1973) indicates that setting the reflux ratio 30

percent higher than the minimum reflux ratio generally mini-

mizes the combined operating and fixed costs. This general

rule was followed in chosing a reflux ratio of 1.2 for the

column design. At such a reflux ratio, the desired methanol-

water separation requires 25 theoretical trays. The final

design introduces the feed on the nineteenth stage from the

top which is the optimal stage according to the McCabe-Thiele

technique.

Page 57: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

50

In the RADFRPAC model of the column, a total condenser

is included on the overhead. In the actual flowsheet, however,

the overhead vapors proceed directly to the hot regeneration

column to act as reflux. Since the methanol overhead and the

hot regeneration column bottoms differ very little in comp-

osition, the hot regeneration column is, in essence, acting

as the total condenser.

Detailed output from the RADFRAC simulation is located

in Appendix D. In the overall flowsheet, the column is

represented by a mixer and separator block (MWMIX, MWSEP)

with the reflux rate calculated by the Fortran paragraph

REFLUX.

Hot Regeneration Column

The purpose of the hot regeneration column is to strip

the main wash solvent completely of the acid gases remaining

after fash desorption. Methanol from the methanol-water col-

umn is also fed to this column. The methanol vapors, combined

with those generated in the reboiler, strip the acid gases

from the solvent.

The column is designed with 10 theoretical stages with

the main wash solvent and methanol distillate feeds located

on the third and sixth stages from the top, respectively.

The column was simulated with RADFRAC at reflux ratios ranging

from 0.5 to 2.0. These simulations indicated that it is poss-

ible to strip essentially all the acid gases from the methanol

at reflux ratios of 1.0 or greater. At the same time, the

overhead vapor contains less than 0.07 mole percent methanol

vapor. Increasing the reflux ratio from 1.0 to 2.0 does not

Page 58: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

51

improve the separation significantly. However, at a reflux

ratio of 0.5, the separation is inadequate, resulting in approx-

imately 13 mole percent methanol in the overhead. The overhead

column temperature varies greatly with the reflux ratio. At

ratios exceeding 1.0, the overhead contains practically no

methanol and must be cooled to -40°F or less in order to

condense sufficient material for reflux. The temperature is

low enough so that the acid gases require no further refrig-

eration prior to the water wash column. On the other hand,

at low reflux ratios, the overhead may contain a significant

percentage of methanol vapor and, therefore, the column can

be refluxed by condensing the methanol. For instance, at a

0.5 reflux ratio, methanol accounts for 98 percent of the

condensate which is condensed at 97°F. Under these circum-

stances, a significant amount of the methanol is lost with

the acid gases. Some of this may be subsequently recovered

in the water wash column. Thus, the design of the hot regen-

eration column must consider the trade-off between a high

condenser duty requiring refrigeration on one hand, and in-

creased methanol losses on the other. Such a trade-off lay

beyond the scope of this work. For the purpose of this sim-

ulation, a reflux ratio of 1.0 was selected where the methanol

losses are negligible.

The detailed RADFRAC simulation of this column established

the splits for the separator (HTRGSEP) representing the column

in the overall flowsheet. The RADFRAC model is included in

Appendix E.

Page 59: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

52

Water Wash Column

Methanol vapor is recovered from the combined acid gas

streams in the water wash column. The water-rich stream from

this unit is sent to the naphtha extractor to effect the liq-

uid-liquid separation. The rate of water addition was deter-

mined from experimental data so that the subsequent liquid-

liquid separation in the naphtha extractor would yield a meth-

anol-water phase containing less than 1 mole percent benzene.

The results from simulating this column as a four stage ab-

sorber with RADFRAC (see Appendix F) demonstrate that such a

water rate is sufficient to ensure no methanol carryover with

the acid gas. In the simplified flowsheet, the water wash

column is modelled with a separator block (H20WSH) which sep-

arates the feed according to the distribution predicted by

the rigorous model.

Heat Exchangers

The naphtha extractor feed/regenerated methanol, azeotrope

feed/waste water, and hot regenerator feed/regenerated methanol

heat exchangers are each modelled using two heaters. The heat

duty calculated in one heater is passed to the second heater,

which represents the other side of the exchanger, as an input

stream. The split in duty between the two regenerated methanol

coolers is determined so that the naphtha extractor feed (pre-

wash flash bottoms) is preheated to 50°F to ensure operation

of the naphtha extractor without any icing.

The absorber feed gas cooling train is handled by a series

of heaters. The simulation does not model the detailed heat

exchange with the purified gas. An enthalpy balance, however,

Page 60: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

53

indicates that the heat removed from the feed gas in cooling

the gas to -30°F is sufficient to heat the purified gas to

67°F. The CONOCO Design Basis shows that the purified gas is

heated to 77°F after heat exchange. Thus, the absorber feed

temperature may be achieved through heat exchange with the

purified gas without any supplemental refrigeration.

Methanol Make-up

A methanol make-up stream contributes to steady operation

of the hydrogen sulfide absorbers by maintaining the methanol

circulation at the design rate. The make-up stream replaces

any methanol lost from the recycle stream. In the simulation,

a Fortran paragraph (MAKEUP) calculates the required make-up

rate.

Flowsheet Convergence

To facilitate the convergence of the overall flowsheet

which contains several recycle loops, the regenerated meth-

anol recycle stream is broken. More specifically, the meth-

anol solvent to the absorption section (RGMETC) is treated

as a feed stream, while the regenerated methanol from the hot

regeneration column (RGMETC2) is considered as a product stream.

This simplification is possible since the stream composition

is well defined and the stream rate is maintained at the de-

sign rate by the methanol make-up stream. Such treatment

permits the flowsheet to be divided into two subsystems which

can be converged separately.

The flowsheet is converged with an ASPEN generated tear

stream set using the Wegstein convergence method. Three

Page 61: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

54

material streams and two heat streams must be converged to

converge the entire flowsheet.

Page 62: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

55

V. RECTISOL PROCESS SIMULATION RESULTS

The process simulation provides a stream-by-stream heat

and material balance which is shown in the simulation output

in Appendix A.

The predicted composition of the desulfurized gas is com-

pared with the composition from the CONOCO Design Basis in

Table 4. The comparison shows that the ASPEN model predicts

a higher yield of each gas constituent. This discrepancy

stems from the fact that the methanol circulation rate was

established based on the fresh feed gas composition which ne-

glected the recycled hydrocarbon gas, as was mentioned earlier.

Therefore, the degree of absorption predicted by the ASPEN

model is lower than that accomplished by the CONOCO design.

To improve the agreement between the simulation and the design,

the methanol circulation rate in the simulation could be in-

creased.

The acid gas and the desulfurized gas are related by

material balance since virtually all the gases are recovered

in these two streams. Therefore, the lower degree of absorp-

tion shown by the ASPEN model leads to a lower acid gas re-

covery as compared to the CONOCO design. Table 5 presents

the acid gas composition for both the design and the simula-

tion.

The composition of the regenerated methanol calculated

by the rigorous simulation of the hot regeneration column is

shown in Table 6. The model predicts that it is possible to

regenerate the methanol to 99.8 percent purity, contaminated

only by 0.2 percent water and 2 ppm hydrogen sulfide.

Page 63: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

56

Table 4

DESULFURIZED GAS COMPOSITION

Component ASPEN Modellbmol/hr

CONOCO Designlbmol/hr

HydrogenCarbon MonoxideCarbon DioxideMethane - ButaneHydrogen SulfideNitrogenWaterNaphthaMethanol

Table 5

ACID GAS COMPOSITION

Component ASPEN Modellbmol/hr

CONOCO Designlbmol/hr

HydrogenCarbon MonoxideCarbon DioxideMethane - ButaneNitrogenHydrogen Sulfide & Carbonyl

SulfideWaterNaphthaMethanol

0o.34.2

125.62.90.0

134098 01.8o0.o

Table 6

REGENERATED METHANOL

Component ASPEN Modellbmol/hr

Hydrogen SulfideWaterMethanol

1909.44048.7173.4499.6

0.041.6o0.0

o0.o0.1

1907.74037.4

159.2485.9

0.041.60.00.00.0

2.015.5

139.916.60.1

138.75.60.00.0

0.138.84

3817.90

Page 64: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

57

Table 7 shows the heating and cooling duties calculated

by the process simulation. The heat balance predicts that

the refrigeration duty to cool the recirculating methanol is

10.86 MMBtu/hr. The total predicted cooling duty, including

both refrigeration and cooling water duty, is 16.80 MMBtu/hr.

This is lower than the duty quoted for the CONOCO design.

The deviation may be attributed to the differences in the de-

sign basis for the simulation and the actual CONOCO design.

In order for the simulation to match the degree of carbon di-

oxide absorption in the CONOCO design, a higher methanol circ-

ulation rate or a lower absorption feed gas temperature is

required. Both of these design changes would raise the re-

frigeration duty. As Table 7 demonstrates, the calculated

heating duty is significantly higher than that for the CONOCO

design. The heating duty represents the steam heat required

to reboil the azeotrope column, the methanol-water column and

the hot regeneration column. As such, the heating duty is

highly sensitive to the specific column design.

Page 65: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

58

Table 7

COOLING AND HEATING DUTIESFOR THE RECTISOL PROCESS

ASPEN ModelMMBtu/hr

CONOCO DesignMMBtu/hr

Refrigeration andCooling Water Duty

Solvent RefrigerationHot Regeneration Column CondenserAzeotrope Column Condenser

Steam Heating Duty

Azeotrope Column ReboilerMethanol-Water Column ReboilerHot Regeneration Column Reboiler

10o864.311.63

16.80 18.76

4.2210.7510.10

25.07 11.96

Page 66: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

59

VI. CONCLUSION

The process model described in this report represents a

viable Rectisol process, based on the CONOCO design. The

model demonstrates that the synthesis gas may be desulfurized

and the methanol solvent may be regenerated with reasonable

operating conditions.

It is difficult to assess the validity of the computer

model in view of the lack of published process data. One

point of comparison lies in the predicted compositions for

the desulfurized gas and acid gas. The current basis for the

methanol circulation rate, which is not consistent with the

CONOCO basis, renders this comparison meaningless. Unfortu-

nately, this project was concluded, due to lack of computer

funds, before a valid comparison could be made at an increased

methanol circulation rate. However, a minor adjustment of

the main wash solvent rate to approximately 3400 lbmol/hr

from the current 3100 lbmol/hr is expected to bring the model

predictions in line with the design basis.

The Rectisol computer model was developed as a flexible

tool which may be applied in future design work or sensitivity

studies. The effect of a design modification to one of the

major process units may be examined using the rigorous stand-

alone model. The results of this simulation may then be trans-

ferred to the overall simulation to assess the impact of the

change on the process as a whole. In addition, the model may

be employed to consider the trade-offs between such variables

as the absorption temperature, the degree of regeneration,

and the methanol circulation rate. An enhancement of the

Page 67: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

60

Rectisol model by linking it to the ASPEN Cost Estimation

Subsystem and Economic Evaluation Subsystem would permit these

design changes to be evaluated from an economic standpoint.

Page 68: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LITERATURE CITED

Boston, J. F., Energy Laboratory and Chemical EngineeringDepartment, M.I.T., Cambridge, MA, Personal communication.

Boston, J. F., P. M. Mathias, "Phase Equilibrium in a ThirdGeneration Process Simulator," Presented at Second Inter-national Conference on Phase Equilibria and Fluid Prop-erties in the Chemical Process Industries, West Berlin,March, 1980.

Britt, H. I., R. H. Luecke, Technometrics, 15, 233 (1973).

Clarke, E. C. W., D. N. Glew, Canadian J. Chem., 49, 694 (1971).

CONOCO, Inc., "Phase I: The Pipeline Gas Demonstration Plant,Design and Evaluation of Commercial Plant, Vol. 2,Process Design and Preliminary Project Engineering Design",FE-2542-28, V2, 1980.

, "Phase I: The Pipeline Gas Demonstration Plant,Quarterly Technical Progress Report for Period 1 Oct.,1979to 31 Dec., 1979," FE-2542-26, 1980a.

Cook, M. W., D. N. Hanson. B. J. Alder, J. Chem. Phys., 26 (4),748 (1957).

Dechema Chemistry Data Series, "Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium DataCollection," Published by Dechema, Deutsche Gesellschaftfur Chemisches Apparateweses, Eds: D. Bahrens, R. Eckermann,(1977).

Donnelly, H. G., D. L Katz, Ind. Eng. Chem., 46 (3), 514 (1954).

Evans, F D., R. Battino, J. Chem. Thermo., 3 (6), 753 (1971).

Gerrard, W., J. Appl. Chem. Biotechnol., 22, 623 (1972).

Gmehling, J. D., D. Lui, J. M. Prausnitz, Chem. Eng. Sci., 34,951 (1979).

Graboski, M. S., T. E. Daubert, Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev.17 (4), 448 (1978).

Herbert, V. W., Erdol und Kohle, 9, 77 (1956).

Hochgesand, G., Ind. Eng. Chem., 62 (7), 37 (1970).

Hoogendoorn, J. C., J M. Salomon, Brit. Chem. Eng., 2, 238 (1957).

Houghton, G., A. M. McLean, P. D. Ritchie, Chem. Eng. Sci.,6, 132 (1957).

Page 69: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

"International Critical Tables of Numerical Data," NationalResearch Council, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1933.

Kirk, B. S., W. T. Ziegler, Adv. Cry. Eng., 10, 160 (1965).

Kohl, A. L., F. C. Riesenfeld, "Gas Purification," Houston:Gulf Publishing Co., 1979.

Kretschmer, C. B., J. Nowakowska, R. Wiebe, Ind. Eng. Chem.,3-, 506 (1946).

Maddox, R. N., "Gas and Liquid Sweetening," John M. Campbell,1977.

Mathias, P. M., "A Versatile Phase Equilibrium Equation ofState," submitted for publication, 1981.

Nonhebel, G., "Gas Purification Processes for Air PollutionControl," London: Newnes-Butterworth, 1972.

O'Connell, J. P., "Some Aspects of Henry's Constants and Un-symmetric Convention of Activity Coefficients," PhaseEquilibria and Fluid Properties in the Chemical Industry,ACS Symposium Series, 60, (1977).

Perry, R. H., C. H. Chilton, "Chemical Engineer's Handbook,"Fifth Edition, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1973.

Prausnitz, J. M., "Computer Calculations for MulticomponentVapor-Liquid and Liquid-Liquid Equilibria," EnglewoodCliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1980.

Rousseau, R. W., J. N. Matange, J. K. Ferrell, A.I.Ch.E. J.,27 (2), 605 (1981).

Russell, W., Badger America, Inc., Cambridge, MA, Course notes,1981.

Sander, W., J. Chem. Soc., 121, 2667 (1922).

Scholz, W. H., Adv. Cry. Eng., 15, 406 (1969).

Siedell, A., "Solubilities of Inorganic and Organic Compounds,"New York: Van Nostrand, 1952.

Sobocinski, D. P., F. Kurata, A.I.Ch.E. J., , 545 (1959).

Spano, J. ., C. K. Heck, P. L. Barrick, J. Chem. Eng. Data,13 (2), 169 (1968).

Stephen, H., T. Stephen, "Solubilities of Inorganic and OrganicCompounds," Oxford: Pergamom Press, 1963.

Toyama, A., P. Chappelear, T. Leland, R. Kobayashi, Adv. Cry.Eng., 7, 125 (1961).

Page 70: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

Treybal, R. E., "Mass Transfer Operations," Second Edition,New York: McGraw-Hill, 1968.

Wiebe, R., V. L. Gaddy, Am. Chem. Soc. J., 6, 76 (1934).

Whiting, W. B., J. M Prausnitz, "Equations of State forStrongly Nonideal Fluid Mixtures. Application of theLocal Composition Concept," Presented at the AIChESpring National Meeting, Houston, 1981.

Yorizane, M., S. Sadamoto, H. Masuoka, Y. Eto, Kogyo KagakuZasshi, 72, 2174 (1969).

, S. Yoshimura, H. Masuoka, Kagaku Kogaku, 34, 953(1970).

Page 71: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Rectisol Process

Herbert, V. W., Erdol und Kohle, , 77 (1956).

Hochgesand, G., "Rectisol and Purisol," Ind. Eng. Chem., 62(7), 37 (1970).

Hoogendoorn, J. C., J. M. Salomon, "Sasol: World's LargestOil-from-Coal Plant," Brit. Chem. Eng., 2, 238 (1957).

Linde, W., G. Ranke, H. Jungfer, "Ammonia," Fertilizer Scienceand Technology Series, New York: Marcel Dekker, vol. 2,233, 1973.

Maddox, R. N.,"Gas and Liquid Sweetening," John M. Campbell,1977.

Partridge, L. J., "Production of Ammonia Synthesis Gas byPurification and Shift Conversion of Gas Produced fromCoal," The Chemical Engineer, 5, 88 (1979).

Scholz, W. H., "Rectisol: A Low-Temperature Scrubbing Processfor Gas Purification," Adv. Cry. Eng., 15, 406 (1969).

Acid Gas Absorption

Kohl, A. L., F. C. Riesenfeld, "Gas Purification," Houston:Gulf Publishing Company, 1979.

Treybal, R. E.,"Mass Transfer Operations," Second Edition,New York: McGraw-Hill, 1968.

Physical Properties Models

Davis, J. J., R. I. Kermode, "Wilson Parameters for the System:H2,N2,CO,C02,CH4,H2 S,CH30H and H20," Fuel ProcessingTechnology, 1, 247 (1977/1978).

Mathias, P. M., "A Versatile Phase Equilibrium Equation of State,"Submitted for publication, 1981.

Prausnitz, J. M., "Computer Calculations for MulticomponentVapor-Liquid and Liquid-Liquid Equilibria," EnglewoodCliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1980.

Prausnitz, J. M., "Molecular Thermodynamics of Fluid-PhaseEquilibria-" Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1969.

Page 72: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

Reid, FR. C., J. M. Prausnitz, T. K. Sherwood, "The Propertiesof Gases and Liquids," Third Edition, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1977.

Soave, G., "Equilbrium Constants from a Modified Redlich-KwongEquation-of-State," Chem. Eng. Sci., 27, 1197 (1972).

Page 73: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

APPENDIX A

Overall Rectisol Model

Page 74: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

* cf ** LU ** m ** ft ** 0 ** Uo ** m ** 4 ** ** I ** U ** 4 ** 3 ** I..

* 2 ** z ** *5 * 2 ** ** 4 ** ** m

-J0I.

a.

0U.U)3a.

0

(A ft3 U)t ma 4IL .uU) U)

- II 11

0003000F-j0

CA >U) -A30

lz U)

00 4L IL

3 3 30. 0. xM~N 0 tY

MIMMI22222P a- - a- u

-j0U) fz inU) 3

a -jClta 1 Iu4 0 ) 1 OY) 31 -ft 3 . Z.2IL CL *e m a U 11 1

t .. .J U00000

-J

(n3ft

U zSU) - n U) -al LL 3 3 l

N U If 1 11ZZLZUZZ_ H _ II I

f 4 *N 1- 1-a.* 0 4 fiI SIN .> J S

* U) 4 C U U )U U)U) W a X .* S* I * 0 I C N 0 U)C CY U)..IL 4CDCD' Lo w cU)04 4 * N aaa I I S LULU* 4 * LU L U L U U ) U 4 .. J 9 - 2

4~ ~ mmmmmmmmmmNNLU OUuaL U 4 1 U U U U U4 f 4LU0000000000

......... 4 L - A..J- - - ...J...J... 1...J. l310.~~~~U.

IL -

U) 03 ft(in cpno ft Ifl--A .1 L

L LL. . - XW ) U)Cz0i 3 9Kz C Of -jI

333330a0a U II I I.-I9-9-9-,-'-00 00 0

* z ** 0 ** P ** 1- ** U ** LU ** Uz *# *m

'1.

* 0 ** O. ** _- ** 1- ** 4 * Z4 ft L U* lY * w* 2 * L* z * ui* LU * ft* a * I* L * UV)* CY * -9

* J* I * LL.* U) ** -C * * .J * LU* L. * wI

U)30

†. .. .. .. .. .. . U.

020U

a._ L L. -U)) W n lz f3 3 U) CZCZm -a a 0. 4U...J - -J J J

IN0OZ ft 0U. 0-i U

a.N U. U

C z U7 U

1 ft ft> *i CZ UH 11 11H I I II

X N -z x

j U L UlL > :

u 11 U N N n 1 H

tI X aoJ u00moa.:EMMMMUMUs

o . 2 1 u . . I M MYYYYYYXYYYuuuuuuuuu000000000

-j - - - - - - -,mmmmmmmmm

0INS

O( IL

0

S. S I Si 30000~#INM

00000aH n n4 HU

o3 3 o o 30

Z-J0zzI

O W

~Zsrz

LoZ-

-

4L.

ftZJO 'tu

04LU-AZ U) Z

UL - .4 4

Z Z X -C*aJ w

_f U 0x Z0ftLU"z I-

L _WCa.U fNj 0L U I 1U0 1J U)09

n14400O

0I0IU)

NIU)I

zz

II

IN0

Nn * cN

ftLU UCl

ft 0u LU II t -U x

IU

-. * SO.C>I20 uo 2- O 0 Z ftU1 I IS 0U} U Z= 0 tZU

M

x

x

x-aox>SOI0UI'IoaU)

ca * o1 U)

X n0 CD 1-

, < W z uYU4LU

1x LU

1aa. I 0 0 io Ax tncM CL Z

O.

zI-1

INx O-aE0U.U.

O-iI

.)0-'020

00ZO -co0c

4**

**

*******4

**4

a0IUfe

U0 xLU X ZLUZOLL A aIL C0 L

U.II II #2221 11 I

-J 0_ Z Z_0 -0 :] _j x'Q x 0a.v - Lu42zU U)OI-ImOO0q" m O m0O0

U .

Z ***

Oj *O **0 *29 *

a*0 *0 *U *

**

Page 75: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

OI-.1.

LU4 uZZw]i0Ii LAp-044N~XlIZ1N1 I Oj11 LU0 N LLO < N

3z,In LL F F3 Z M m3>0

Oa ZO0N

4 0CYLL 10U) O W

ob U < N~xZ~cjx 0LL4N1 * tr * w 1 ii* O * N ZZZ* P- * Z -11 * () * -Z* 4 * .40.* cx * cx Z* P- * Px- ~* L * XLLf

* * X . Lu* < * 4 IU U. * I * ZZZ* P- * Z* I * YY . * I-0O O)0Z * J J.J

30-J~~~~~- .................

NO4jZO'4C N

ON0 NN

II It-I-

0

o >JI~30LU>~ONN

II II* c * zZ4 LU * 8 _* 3 ** O ** P- *. -a * * O--Z* LU * O 0* 0. * 00 0* O * LUNN* CY , N4[4[* - * 4* O * Yv* "' * I- (3 (3* N * WOO

0* C:[ * tJ =J J

3

-J. E-

* Z ** 2 .** :3 ** -. ** O *4 ** U ** CZ ** U. *

* 3 ** I *

* 0 ** O ** r ** I- ** LU ** U *

00I1-

LU-LU-rIU)

003 r'O0a 0 0I^J N CN

1 I InL-1 p-- u --1 3 3ii Ii ii

003 o o

-JU.a!

LJ

0 01II II .1 L uujN U.P

-LU-_a330Cr 0i i 000~UO

00-J .= --m m m

cx-II O .

x I > -(.O014>xc

* Z ** : ** -j ** 0J ** ** U ** Q ** O ** I. *

4 I 4 * 4 * Z a.C * U * U

4 ZL 4 0(.- fa* Z * LU <I-

4 aL 4 xU x* * 4 2 11* c * I* , YYY* 4 * -003(* o * UJoo o* I * LU..4..O

30JL

LU

XcxX-.U-C:

0LUJn,

ii 1ii I Ii i

-- 0I----000000

3O a.(O0 U.

C o

II IIZZi=,zZ

- aOI00cwwx

II II IIZZZ

P-- 2 -JI a-

IU m U

00~-I-i-0 (9. 0.r

N o

-.- -m JM coCI

* U ** J ** 0 ** Z ** P- *

* LU ** Q * * ** J~ ** 0 ** Z *

n,

* 4 ** I ** I- ** LU ** s ** *, 0 * LU* LU * -a* 1- * 0* 4~ 4 >U..* Qx * 0* Z * Cx4 LU *

4 LU * *LU* Qx * wS

o3.... i0

CZ0(3I-LU

0crx

I,1Oa

CD0(N

U

II II'-i-211 1

O0

U10(N

~- (3 (3

Cl zO L

II II CIIZz,, I--I-

Y Y Y(300U.O Oi (3 (3 n,0'LU(3(3(3

0O0m mn ,,000Il-aUa-a(0(0(0

* Z* D* -a* 0* U*

* V)* .d* Or* 34 'rn

,* a* U* c* 49* 3

****

*4**

*

Page 76: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

clz

Cl0N

rUXNrCo

C.)CIDI~~~~~I M

0~~~~O _04

. .

o * 0 Cl 01 1 ' .I- # I'* Z-* . # ..0C·0~ * -~ * u..*~OZ ·~ * Z * * wr0(ntD ~ ~~ N 044 2 4 Z * Z~ * F . 0 *. Cl * O * .0)O

-* * t 4ClSl

L 4 I- 4 LU 4 IZ4 0 4 U-o * I. 4 LU4 Z * 4 4 4 . u4 z * *LU Z LL. .J

* O .U * O ·1 0 * I * O * J IA· h- * IA * Z * u..

i~ *e e. ~e * Ie * le *I e e e f~

oIt0C.U

0'Iii

0I it LN It

IO II II IA I q tII 0) I II) C1l Z'' I .II t , , LU 0. · .0OU In In n qY fUL Y -I n L LU LU -0. H * o -11 sn zn ~~~n lz Y IV - 11 L

LU O - u ·w a 0. H 'U 0. 0.C 00Z DeI I ILz~

tL O C. q ' Y OU

0' 0. 0.' 0.-' LUCi') 4 * * N I. t- LUn4 o Un o u in a t. * 0 * N CD X tlO fi Cq l: I J CL * : c LIs~~~~~~~~~1 IS X X s t r Icr 0~ rz -11LUN C a LU U wI LUc LUo C * 0 4 UN -U) 0.I U

1- 1 . * 1 * * _ * XU) L l U , U)03 3 3 3 .j3 * z *W *UC in * CDI 0 O0 -0 OO .o * - * 0 * az r . .0-i CL- . .. I --I CZ * 0 * *. U) U)LU. IL CZ ' L LULL I U. U * * 4 * C - c1 · 0 - N 0' 4 0 *Z JZ Un

uJ 0W LU W LW 0 4 4 0 in * X 04 - . n U)Z iJ ( J J J - *..J . 4 * 4 .. a o 4 u ,0 0 0 0 0 * 4 * * * 4 4 oIn ·Y cY z, z C oco CO4 -4 49 4 4LU LU LU LU LU 0 U 0 0 0*- 1- 1- !- *- .- - -

.- If] .In~ *.-l *.-n *. *..0)...........[ .-~.-

ad

0CZ U)3

0 3

> 1U 0ILU CUaIzL >30N000

N

Cl

-JU-

IL O

Wr uj In LUJ0 33> 3 JN Eli1

Z Z ZU) I zx X zn

4- 30.*s 003 CNN 3 II

1- 1.2LU;, O0O

Im30-JIL

6IiUill

I-cz

x LU'P. F 11

Z4nI- IIaLUW

r rz0 Y.LU Clo 042 0

0 000*i -i.m co .. c

Page 77: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

I0Cl Cax

O 0(DOI°

C

-N IN

cI,'rm0. 0. N -

ZZea-0-_ _ CDCD

0. COZ Z 4

O #* ~.~ ODN I t)v 1111 ' . (S O

(/)If)V)~ O UC' N In, . 0] >. .00. _ ut/3Ow-0m/ ,.~ m -v CZ rIt z U. if In

uw CZ M a

.W U- .U-'0' V )(lf.'33 0 { t.N . c0 (NI. W N . .. C .W 0

* C * I M X 0. > i X c 0* W * 4' - W I.u 4 * m * J :EU G O Z O* t * LL cL U u O* 0 * Z- W EA I) 0* ) * W I 10. CD* C * (flu- (/) I.l.l) U0U* 4 * 4 ( 4I .-. * ILZ 3 31r l

U) * W4zs W WV) a of(N * O! tY tY 44<

CL IL IL

O 0 0

...... -co .CO.. C*O*m

IC,IZ0

0tD.10( 0

00)(N

::O

U xZ 4-"I (N0. CNd 0

IC

# t 'r'

_ '11i IIeH Y000.

0. Z N-z OmZ t 00_ U C N O 0

(N yu. u (N u V)xI

.a 0N

{3 C) 0. z)0. 0 .(')Uf-In

C')Icr )IV)11II L W D0. 0.a'Zu Zi I C

000U) co o

ix: , < uL NI-." co

U 0 0 co

I U if a) V)X m

)N 0 CD O

-j II u

IL L L

Q U DU) V))COCm CD V

0I 11 * * U 11 HU) (' * z * > L. >U 0 * 0 * .-· 0) * - .- .. W .0. I-* I-ti In ( NO I.- 0

_ 4 O O * I (N o (NJ 0.N 4 * ( 4 ) I W m 1

I:Y 0.> Ce 0 Z:H * W * 4 0 0 Ct U' U) U1 X V)OUJ V).J W U 4 Z * .J Z W I 4t I-. 4C '-11 IL X N ILL o. * W * If = 1 F- 1l J Z s it4 Un _ 11 I- I- * c * U 0.1- 4U ) ILV) IL VWAJ *-~ cc I-W 0. 4 W 4 1W = WWLL W )< W1W -..V) (. -Z O y F : * I 0.0 I - Z ( N14 X X

0. co XZ 00.. 4 4 .J0 * z . 0. C . C0 ( 0.) < - In S . * I * IL : ti-I > 1 W UJ WZ 4 * V) z 0.1 I- II I II4 -.10 J -4 10 4 4 : 4 4 3 < x44 V)4 V V)4WJ 04 o~ 04 o.) 4z .. Y*J 4 crc W c W~ tY J~ .J .J cUIx s u< C mCZ Ur -C C-) Is * CZ CZ LU Ix Z oe I j I -t IL14 iVo:W 04 CZ CZ 4 ILU. 0. 4 Z 4 4 L 4 IL IL4-

0. IL 0. IL . 0. 0. 0. 0. 0.Y Y Y Y Y4 Y Y Y Y Y YU U U 0 U U U 0 U U U0 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

cO *C c co *-CD -CD.C -co CID O O cO o co

Page 78: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

043lI(D OI(0

0-

I -- N U

II T04 (I I-0. 0.'

Z) Z_-' _ -I

0 .0. -.11 il N: O YY In '0 00 ->11 0 11UJ~~~~~~~~~~~~111A .II ~ QI

>, ... U1 I '- C]

0 0 . 0 4 > 0 t CZI . ~ . ~ LI~Li~ i.

Z ~~~~~~C)N I 'IW '-C .',> 2Yf f 0 C

.Q.N H-

01 0 0 ZWW 00. 11 C Z C

II *II 03-ct I- - x* W ~ * 0 * Wz * Z * I U) -H-O I' I * n, * * Z 4 >~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ inI C x * * 0. * : * N II0. U. 1' W * * 4 * " . 0. * .. * N W U)20 4 CI I C QN CX * CX I - 2 0 Z O 4 0 4 .. X mwN JD U0.U 4' I W1 U 0 o C * W in * 0 4 .

0.11 L. 11 I I * XW * X I4 i 0. I- I * * 4 ( U)OW 0C.) 0 W * * Z Lz 0 Q WW 0. * W U ) 320 Z t C Q' * , * Z O0 I Q * 0 * 10. CD 00. 0 0. 0. Q 0. 4 I * 0. 0 . 0. * CZ 4* U = -J

0. z , * : W 0 4 * * J v) L.( 2 0 C *- u I O .* * o x Ix > -4 04 U4 I.0. 4C 4 4 4 0. 4 4 4 W CAPU 0 WlQ- OCX O CX WCX 4 4 4 W WX Q X * 4 * 4 N 4 ..Ir . O , (3 O,3 CZ J a * O * J Q Il Qx J Q * N * - < rJ(3'.X 4 M 4 m * Z * Z Z < Z- I 4 -1 CZ 00. 0. 0 0. 0. 0. 0. LL L. Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y YU U U) U U C) U U 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00.c .. co .. .. .. .. .... .... J.0 * m *m *m *D** *.(D ..(D m..... . 10*-rl m *(m *m

Io

coN0In

(D 0

0InCJ I

N4 mI.

C' t I

U ZO0

0. 00UC 0 0

11 U -

.V) 00 ' C InII 0 C

' 0oocR u

. 0 11 UJ If _0. 0z ix OZ0OII IINIIII

< rN LL U> x xU ) . Ic. n z U.

W 110. 00 )tn m

Z I V)0'20ONNCV) U. 4

N W <2f CZ(3 U-

0W I 0IL L4J C

-m

I0oI(DI i(D O

O I0)oU)

0)CIO*.4 Z 0c z

if~ ' 00.0. .1103

l 0

0. 0.0 Z00OII (~.) ClS-4 , 0 *13 '0

q~ 4 tOII I II

II N 0Cwws'0004 ", H- . ,,YY 03.L 0.0 I3t* Z * 002

0 I' II4 NU.

* 0 03 I I- * Z * 22 -w NA 11

* C) * I4 (LU~~~L 2 o o*. ~ , *'T'~0 I 0t uj I c u

.O 0 - 2* C 0 C /u) t-

(1 C.) 3 * Z * I 20* ~ * 3 . O

* JI * U '2 -

.~~~~~L U[. ~ .t C) U

* -. * 3> C X* 4 * NX '. ~* 3 W 10 : U * I * 3 0.0 X I

* w .* ww ~ 3* 0 * UJ U) E0 0* I * X I X 1* 4 * 4 0. L) LI.3* o * - W Im * Z- * 2 U) 0 W* * 3 3 4 .... * 2 * :E 2-J CY 0

Y 00 0)

Page 79: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

I0

0XCD f'' ~~~~~~~(D an

0 .(N.10InC-4_I

N1 0I c"I N

0. i Z 04

Y U

0. CN 0ZY 00. 0

Z Ot Z C.

Cl LOU') II q-)11 C Nin N I

0. 0.0..

* Z ·* I* 0 * IC CL I-

* 0 * X

.~ ~~u IX w4 _J~0. P* w * . :I n* J * --J "* O~ * CYn ~ 1O n0 _ * , - F 0.

*, "r .q-. q-I IXW0. ,, u- )* < * 2 J UJN0 (D 0 C ( L..* I- 4 C 1 W

4 . 4 4-J W ...J

.* W * . n.. - .. i Co4 W 4 WJW W in* CO * I~ 4 X .0. in* W 4 0. E Win U}

* * 1.- sb c CD II- * 44 1- F i UY) c

* W m I m-

I O0 0

cv0I(DOI0

0

C4inOr4I NI _

NlI inI0. x X

_11 y01 0. v0.C.0.Z 0Z 0

IDen N N in

I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 11 I00I t I O

1 I 0. C)cn n 0J.fC 0 00. ,. in.0 ~~~~~~~~~0 0

0. 0. '-' *"' C~ E ~ , ,,u~ C

Ow 0Ur LJ W4r.- )~ ~ . , FI-- I NI

* i N 1 1

0 U0.0.on 0N XN * Z * 4 I ZO J *Ii * .J * W W, * AE * CD inU.

-. -J * 0 * '" . * 0 * oU w* Cs - * Z *.> * -. J X 30t O J I 4 4 * * 4 0 * O 03W

Z N * 4 I * I I 1 In * C * -J x1 I- -n W- * * W WI 4UJ' * . * - (N _

X 4 11 LL N 11 * I 11 it WN * I * w L 0 i 2.U O w 0 . (A tO In * In * WC) N 11 [-- * * WW l W W * 4 L InW in

lY JO * l * I I t * 3 * 0. CDX 0.0. 0.J > * -J * 0. 0. a0. * * I ::E Ou .L * C) * D In _ * X 4 x in n iI 2 X 4 Y * > * -J 2 -J Z 4 W 4 - 31:i 0. ..' 4 C.' * O4 O 4 IXL * 1 On 0 UU co IJ..L-J 4 W 4 o r 0 W * 4 4 3 CN 444 O0 4 Y 4 UU U* -*t * 3 * 3 I- i

0. 0. 0 0. LL u.

C. C. U U U U) C. U0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0I _ .. .. O CD =. o Co... Pm ..m .. m .............. * m.*m . -* ............ ~D . m

* ** ** *

05* '~ ** i *0 -* "' ** J- *

* CL *40 * .IX *

n 4 0 4* in ** *4 Z ** s 4

0.*

U0

.Jo0I * O4

0.1 4 W *

0.0 4 0 *D0 * F *0.s * 0 *04 4 W *(NS 4 N 4I4 4r * 4

0.

O*0n *e*

Page 80: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

30-JLi11

-J

>MI 4

0 >

(DI 311 Z 11

ILU I LUzz-J 020 0 0.LU a0 OZZ>

U I-N JL F IN

O LUO Z 4L L WUW L 11LJJ IN LA ( .-L< . 0N I N J

i 4 11 0u :E r u

C :r 4 . xu I-F IJ

C/ LlO LU3 -JO E

3 0 3 O Fe u. 0 J 0 N 11 0LJ u. LZ 4 N

u. u < XsILUIe>I-( 4Lu.J u I *

JLO .J Y ZU-1 LUOZOUZ0WF-M

I .J..J C S uNcI u., u. Z cu -oulJ S <- l F-

) uL 3 X -L fL

1w1 LX Uj i j UJU e-N Z _ :

er i-'-4 -11 LU. . - U. X

,L u. u. *

I0C',I

G'ru.,zLUz0c0

0

I-I-J

z r,,.* 0 * Lu* - * t* F * F* 4 * {3)* 4 ** D * 3* CJ * 0* .J *4. .X

4 4 LU* 4 * u.* I. * IA

* ~ * Z* * .* Z * SJ* a. *4-0 .4 o 4 , -I* F * Q

* uJ * 0* s * (.tI* * u0

.LQ* a.

o

'r3L-i

wI u

O uY

tn _iIU-0 J

-

3 ·-j

W I L.

. LU I-J I

0 l I(.1 (*y

L IL Qa,.

I llI -0J

zrN tr

.. 1111 -J Y

W .J

LfL3 >03 'J O Y- 0 LAJ .O-O

WI .J3 a.

. La.La

L L L000W u

0 0: II

z F

'Z Z0 0LU L0. 0.

O0I X

0 L)U

I

0hII LU411 0.0 0I uJ a Ix 4 -0- LU X 1

OI,0 0IJ30-J4. CZt U. I . 3:-.I j 0 UfUJ

t ut z ct zI J-

I UJ

3 X CMeu--- 0=I~-j Ju. cn D

01 LUI. 0 -'3Z Z 3 u. _

.J uJ LL u; u u13ZZ u.--0 -'

* ** ** ** ** ** *

* Xj ** W ** J ** L. *4 Lu 4* Qf 44 ** Z *

* 1t *

* -J ** 0 ,* 0 ** ** Q 44 Lu *

* et *4 3 4* I *

* 0 ** Z *4 4 ** I ** I- 4* Lu 4* :E ** *

00-

X *A.4

C 31I'.-+

u.,-LU -t 0)II 0)3

* 0003 >0

II N311-'r-Jca.IC')> .O CZ

I--- IU.)X

--J.La.

oCDLUf0LLLUjCD

UI-

LU

LU'X

4-J

LLitr

z

CZ

..I-C)F.rLL. . ............ .LL.

Page 81: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LUI

.40.

OWO(D

0 *InV)nWn(A W

2-jIL 3 3.4 41~0 LU LUWVn V.4Z, W.C.C ..0a. .. . .1

-j-l * j I n 0 . q - z 3 .9L ) s(.M -, 2 .0 ·,C D 5 O0. ,3U)n Cn0. m U U CZM IL)02--L u 0.> Z W WA .1-III,~ 0 Ocz -II- Z 3X InWn U CZ)-OU L 4)X X00 0 UUWZW JLJ I j - U0W LL U .4InIWmm Mz XILLIL L Xcc zZ z

,.,o

4002LUNN314 42z

L2J --10 1 U

.0. . .(LU...2In22

X W X 91 1U 2 4

Iun ID U

.00lILCOU

CZ ~ mCZ i i- C ~Ci Cd (N a m m l m I m mW *M LI M LWUX C m W -m Lu X mI ICZ u m M l LUW m LULJ Wam mLU WUW

*I LLI LU UJ ..J LU s UJ LU In s- In M J LU W -J s- - -J 0 WU - M LU WU WU WL LU LU WL s- W In W LU

0 1 1..J 1~~ ~~LU WU j I- J -i - Z I -i I.- F- - W I-I0-I- 4 C i 41- (N Ct 4I4 I- 41C - I - 4 I-- . C C C 4 4 Cl . 1- 4 .4,0 WI W I 'WILU LU L WII I W I W I- LU WLU X ix C 0 of mxs-s 0 10 0 OM I 0 0 'm' I, IlIn 50 I I 0 0 1-i .J I 5 I I Im l I 100 0)I I 0 IJi l. I.- .j C I 1- Ji 0. 0. Cl i .J 4l (N ( I- .Ji C ('3 J - I-- I- ..J..J I.- .J 0 . .-j ~ 4 49. .. 49 .C4 4 In nU) .4 .. . 4 4 4 d 4 4 4 4 .4 4 t .4In).4.WUmmmmmlnmlmmmMI m, mI :mmm mMmMMmmmmmmMM

In0 Wt uWU 1W- 1W3

*i-IO 0LUZ O W

*..Z.,

*W.

*InO0

> - >- LU

00

zz mZoomOOWW3- 00L W WLW WLUCa

In In0LU W

IILLL OO

0U.

LUI-40

Z01-

.4N W

IL--- Z

LUa

U.

4W

U) --. 10LUWI.

LU L

z0Z0In

LU

0.In.4

.L

LU .4

-Iv24U I-JWA WI,-..JLn.4310 -i

I--

. v.4W0 >

U0

z.: 0

WI.,..I

W.I,,-I.,-I~in-

0.

I

0.

Page 82: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LUC,4a.

VMW(oW 00 ON V OC- LflM ML() Dfl,) l w C Dwww 0w w C h I - ~ ~r~

. . ..

. . .

o mr * a .I.. :K o0 M

4 x -3 1Ns tn U. 7 o o

1 u 3 N NC z l '3 I-J Z

IfOou-V 0L)

-J00

wel-.CO-wwu0 Zr "-J UUAJ

I-.4 JCY 0

uj I-

4 4VwwjaZxa.

w - w =ei1 2 u a.

w

uLJz0z0In

zILa.In41

.> . . . . . . 3. .j . a . . .o. ..Zo,*Z. .. o Io.o... ,,......,.N..o.o.......... U . . . . . > .

U 'Z ..N..W

.W t 0 3a.j fj N > -r ... .X> .. . . . . C .-i X u a U,) U 0 tf lO N m a > x CN.44 * >z3u -0 > X4 aj

tL V CZ; )4 J L CZ LQ O 0 > I i

Z00 *03m0a ~ZZCN-4*I O .C NX WU.2J- 1N >0-< Ut X>JU< 8 Q1 >3 ui 0(A0 tn ClO*I s 0J IL Z. I a z z .O03 . /)a.OfCCZ x 1-3u- I-O CY ' C 0 3 L m X .Z 0. N x a

S Nu- >- > O I C4 JO 3 CLO LE OX34CIU MQN0 0044 2I.

Z Z0 0u'3-MOma czW0a tz X 0 M CY N U J M/ 1 3 N- I.. L O C < 1X L C Xw N 0 C 1 X

ugx* u 0 LL. : * L< 0 C-0 .. ;I0 UlL 0. 40U .) 3 X a a Nfi-lL-4' OI-4 O. 'L Z I IL O J

0 0 0L > U. - - > Z> 3 CZ I -4 II N

w* I- )311=c Lt Yw I ot z

Page 83: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

NI I : )Uc cIU) Ii.-j U) 1-C4 x U 0.I o I LU 1- U U)U )IC OW 0 0 0 C C -J

U) C.) c I L

CL-:E IV) M Oo 0.Lfl 0a x -4Lu1N4 ZI C -

0.

(n 0. 1Lu44X LwLz z

a.z N z cQ 0.1 - I. C c I>. V) . LL I

I CJ I - OUJU CI CZ

a.I

M)=Ia .0 =N

3Z4 0 L

x1-4'n uAJ xC 3 Li

xE Z(fl-wIX03W

0.LI

wo t wcx)

C) I ~

Lu IW 000 - N UJ CYcxJ E Je

) 0 0 tnI U(nO~ZO

Ui C) C

L. U. LL

I I 0 (0

0t X 0 :E 0

U)

(LuO IU-QC.)U)Z Q: - W

LuLLu (NoJoincxx X mO 31- 4 Ex3Luo inOQ _ox uu.1ouaffi

U) tY xC-:43w .0. 0.

-I0Lu U.Cxin

3tncx

a.

tYcot)

c,I0I-x0LuU)

F-

Wu

1-1- 0.(n in 0. 0 z

UV) 0.4 4 ->WW U04 N4 1 0 0 I u CZ M

in CZ3 U)cx coa. 4>> m

-NI IV) n X.C< 3 3 Iu LU I-x Co

L .co

-I

M 4U II mx cXxr w U

-jI Lf l._I <

I1 3LU< Lu zu CZ UI CZ

U)>-.doJ C~.n3 jr om IA

-CN I- Lu II C J -JoU))U 0 .QXmQQ- <I<W-Ifl-U)= 3 3 > IOWW Wn4-.II-2IMc Q (UN LU O0O

Qa. a0IuxwmQ

w <

Ln of (1- o (n aLu

inCW

cx in cx0.WU =Q J0.

-J X

in (Un U-U)33Luw

0. .-i cx

IW in

0 3incx

0.

4U 2

in C CM)<)Lui-1IIu u.1- x IIr U L

0Nz M E CZ ' a )-j U C) LLLL C Of I

z I< IL l,-X U

tr 3 3 r a UC)

-J J > W j a lY a

t- X un - '-('WIu03_j 3c 3I(A... IU. u U)

U JZ U.

0 30.Lu

U)

IWU. incU < .(n C 33 x0 n )0..j >U.

4LuI:

x_n x @

0 in 0 - 3W U 3

4IJ Jx

:L

0.0aa: '-CNI ZCx2 Uo O O. c a x U a

. 0L .--- I- C Lu

,. 1 CNCN O.U) C C 0.3 a a c ov .. Q-i > J U a

LuJ

Cy w Ui lw

X V w U LUz z

I 4I4 IO

- LU 0. LU.< N

> Z

a.(n 0n I-

cZ w x rI a jcw 4X ZI

0.Z U 2

C) X 0. DZ CZ - UJ CL

0 X X CL

U ZZZZ LU)

IU)wO3n0-1U.

wQ ~< N a ItU 1= w a: u. u1 3I

1 N z . z

LuC.) 0

~00ot Ji ZCOC.)0 O OV N sc )N

I.4LUIx

U)

Lu

U3o n 3

2 cUO 400z Lu CCY0 X-

4N nnf< N 33 Vn -j< 3 3

0Z X

In 0o-'

Ou~- N 3a < 300LuN

O

0z00

Z O 44c3r Fn NLuLulIW I

J -NU.

x 4 0.UW uc a U )CN LuinCZx4 z u C 2a.

0 3 C, 1 Q 0 3 O 2 I 3I 0 3 I cx

u 1W 0.Z X z cc co n

:-J UJ. O M OI.) 3 3 C .) W4 ui

O Z C. III :u Lu(n inF-LuLumW130-1U.

z< aJQWWn,,tut 3 IV

L Lu

.

4CD

I-X 0

x (n= Xl- 1uLJ U.Ix

z0

IZ4NZ -

-U U)U.C.)-I I

tn

v Jtn

U)a 30-I -I

J -

cxcZ0z0

ain4

LU .

U. X mw a.0:

W C Oa: 0 LoxI .< J rLAC O 0oCxCZxa

cx cxwI- -I

V)x4n

CZLJtn

:d

Oc.

I.-:UiLuzz0

LuLuIEn30-LL

w U <uIW(n CZ3 Fo WJ-U.-1.

0 -IXuL.C0 C axLUM -I1-IC,0>x

Page 84: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

i |XCD 1i-CD' t -J () F- : 0 '. :E0 LU41 I IXo aw LUU I Z

LU IT

V) O LUU tr

4LU

i--Or0 F

j-1

0LUz0i-!

C.)0In

t-X -L..J LU,, ,, 'r wLX U In7

0 ", ") a-30 3 I0U. 0

LA. Ui.

UJ 0.(<) I :E

000

N 2 nL) 4 <i- LC1 0.U a0 a x F- 3a I) 3CZ t 4-

0 I

LL0 CYILU 0 LA. 00~W

U

*o aX W Ln tY

I00E

zN4 (N: U

tY i ULJ' U0 0 vI Ca a

M CZ (O

I.- FwOUi-n

O

oIn3XN30C4

C., 3U JUI

0.Q

Oz0.- a 3IN3

XIIn'3'0''I

LUJzLU4<0 0ILU LU (Ny

3i- U. 3 0-A 3 j <LI.

mIn0-jm>

C

I-

0LUzz0LU

LULIIn3c0-jLI.

cN

LU

40.

-J0L.

UaQI--V30.InLUOa IL

O-CY

LII-0Uj _

O[C- C .

U.L.

Z

I--NZ0F

U-.,I..LLL J wD InIn= 'rW I-. LJInIna 30

4-jjW --J LU

-j0

IInC

c >-J0-VJ

40 OU CvnOLU zLUCa00. 0.

In30.-JIn3C.

>

n3x0.-A4

3 CZ~ '' .

C/HI=.'

,__ n, i'

L.

3Ix0.

LI) -J- 0.

U LL U.J~ In In. 3 3D 00 .O 0. 0.

I--JC.cn4-JLUlC

_^

z0

LU

- X-0.U) x'

LU- I0 a0 z2 ?-

I- QF- U} aX I

L X I

Z LLZ lx0

CZ

cr

-AI. ; X

. LL-j.j> LL

CYNt 0-J Z

L 0. 00.

-J -J > IU. LA 0U.> -j ix of

CZ

00.I0

V)

Oi-aLU LJ w

z

ocmIX Nx0 0U.

IL3N U.VNx0L. U. 0.Oo t. Wz u

0.I2i-

00"l-xx . Ul.

I0I~ (,u L

-0i O2 -C

-J0 >In) -S

CZ In 0co 3 InIn Q co 0. In.4 coI n) > 4I LU U. L I n)

-J tn 3Z Z 3 CZ0- 0. X 0I. 0. 0. 4>

LUIn

-A 00 0.0 C~U xv ) uf ).- t f

Z J

U. U. U.

UJZZLU

i-LUJLU U O

3 Ji X o 0 o u

L 0

0.

0N

IIU)30.-J

0

-U. U. '-XQQ mz0UIn n n ex Ca

J. 0. 0. J U.- - ..j - - L.

-ILA

: )3CY

C.) mm ) - U7 U) 1-

C! Uw1 3 3 0 z Ini-InXni-ocr J J cU

i- - 0.-j - zCL X CL :

-I0 - n 0.> ZL UJ

rr X z z

LI Uf m Q 0i->) C IX I

OC

< 0J -

Z ZO ~

~0 .UIInLU

LI xU 0 -JI-

LU

XUI

0.InA4-C

ZLZz z0-"LUI)

I--LILU

30-jU.-

IxOU. 3

LUc Q CZ

0. 0.

(N

,"CNn344OX C4n 'n unL co c3 Luo U QL N1 N1. I: I

4 - f

-J -J> IU. U. '0 0s- > Q Q:

0.

0. U w-Ci > Uf L- C.)O UJI mt 0 Qf

Q

U . !--R-j 23m X U:Q 0.Q i.i-[1. Z "r

- 4X

*I I I-I-* L -ULA. U. UL.

LULU Y XI Qf -1In0 o cou.-J zU.

Page 85: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000Iq I

000m "It M0 r-0(X;:T -Oa 0ooa 0 0

00 0 b3 1! t.6 0

C;

J 1-w - I: I*j L a O aI- 0.Z i 'WO 'II 0 - U 0

M -C> Ix

U.

I0W1-r'0LI.

:ELlI0WO.

000- I

3 (J1 00

W toI- 0

(N w

O O OI-- 0D0

W

(-'U

WI-w

Z Z0-F-

UJU3

0Ix

NF-

0uIQ

IL

NUWW

000-,, n,

F- F-.J UJW

4 0OL0. Wi 0 X Q)X W I m X 0 J -j F- 0. J 3 J 0 C 0 . 0 0 m 0 W Z QJ Cie -i UQ'

U)33-j

U)

F- 0 (.IW 00.I U. '- 303 033 UJ

xzN4

NI Q I< L0

3 > CU1N - -

J 3 Q' a. uZ Z e - L 3

OQ I3IWU0O.J3WZZrIu.1-WY

*J 3LUu.X

0.MD3 :)3 0.0 0N(NI I

OWu.> - 3

Ur Ou

U)

Z IJ Wa1--

zIYZ0C)

U,in

0'zZr~uj *

C.) 0

00LUu

W >

0 ZU. f 0-*0"O

ujZ*WI-O W

I _J ',~-- WYZU)0WO

C Z W431-

4>4J0

000+ + +x o ) (- I- r-

N(00)0.O 04 LO

000oN - tD 0 00r.- I

. . (+ + +-~ 01

X 4 IL) (DIZI q) to

('-C0D- -cN - ED (o zo,r~.- ,q

0 tq u0 0

co CD LO Lr cot I L I ' I I0000000000a) C13 Ln ao ( n u (F

(1) v 0 0 am um

r.) V) 04 V O(0 0' 0) (00000

oq t N IV 00000+ + ++ +'-0-0 nul Ln IT aa0

0 0 00000

0("4 C',,-

Or-(0m(NtM U7 - N4

00000000

00-00O 04 V

D-0 0+ I +co

0000W O

N N 0C.] O -

+ 0 + +

0ITod Q,0C) 0 0

r- N a)NL- --00001+ + +4+

l 0 '-11 O C0 0+4+

0000

IIIIIIIIIII 11 I 11 : I I~ J J I0000000000 "

m c m m c m c c -i -j i -j j -j i -j j -j Q CD

0.JwO.U.3

WOCU -

J O

F-O NF- I

0 0 J 1>3 3 J3 - 0. J tL =J ILU.L IL ULW..J IUL W W U. W W -J 0 W -

.JOO.JOOZ flW_001 (N(0IM4

N1 T O I 3: m U

W

4C.

.4

I.

z0

W 0. M~-w

Z < N> Z Z4N>Z'4

NOZ

Il N

J I -CONF->fo N

Z0-4NZ

u-0-

. uJ"U)W I-U U

.~X 3,,J JOWU)IU0 30_l.J

u 0 uL.

Wi.-J C-)uW

Q Q'

CYtn >F- 0Wa0aJ N NF- W I IDU 1 -0 3 u

3 3

4J .J0 U.U m

- s 00Z Z 19 w F

_ J -C 3 IUAJLn

I-W I- OW M L X Q IV

O c 33 -W WCN..

U)

CW

0uj

C)

.Ja)

0-

(0N

a>WU

-U. I UJ

-ZZz0C-OF- 0.

W IWi0. lO O Z

3X0.4-. Z Z IU-

0U0N

Z0I--W-U)

I--

I30U.

u Iw Ir-J >Z U. -'N N4 <

¢ 0

- 3 c3N(NN

Z.UiW0WI-0

IO

z

-rZI-C-)WU)I-WLIU)30U-

(D 3WO

0A.0Z -J

U. 4W

010.-Y O - N(0W --II I

Page 86: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0s CD CD 0 o---0--00000o D coQ

0 C tD07 N 0 tiX t0 t N - ;0 ~; ~ ld0(1 w0 r c

0i t- cl) t- u00000Or-CDCDN OIOr-

D C 0 0 N0 i tD D t? ts N4 co0

-4 N I t-

N00CDcI0-I-O

mO

rl- - IV-0 0- 0O OLO

0) W 8r-o aoa

v o In rT tO I-r- N4 -C

OO O O OO c'-000000 66 .000.0.0000000 .'00 0.

to M - 400000+ + +ll+1M 0O(D 0

n n 0v VI) ) C

CD () c T. . . . .

0 0 0 0 O0000

IV N tDN tN)00000I + + 0000) D d

- V N-7) - CD) 'V 0

a {8 O T0) D 0) 0 or- M r- r- M'

-N Cl N q. . . . I00000

CO cO0 00 00'-oQ co0O SU '-17 c7 10 1

00

00000000000000oooao8oaoooOt -0 a O -Cl c-

C m C' - 2 - - N MCD

0000000 0' 0

II I r r 00a 0 000aN N ' Nco c . oc° ° E s - -I

.m m

s0 0 m m m m mcoaoaoacac11111j - -

3t33 330300300.10.J..J0aIOJU.

U .j -i LU .j -j 0O x 2 :W:E00 '00NNOI N uuuZIIu

310u.Li.-J0NI0'2U

0

+

cor-

OO 0

000000d O O OO0

COr-

00 000 0 o o 0 00

t 00

cn 0

+4+000(DO tco LOO 0' - N

. . .0)D~000'1

r- N ODo O -

C -

000'

= -i Qj Qi -j -j -j -J 10000000 1IJJ-J..JJJ Is _ DN N N Nzag N N N s -U)1-0(0 0(0 0(0 0(0 0U)-

0.~30I-JI

M Z JLU -UJU

1-

OU) 0zn tn 2U) U)

0. N I

33 333003000 J- 0 3r .J0

.j U. LU .. U. U.U. LJ LJ U. UJ JLUJ -j -j Lu .j -i.JOO.JOOONNONNN N

OOICININUUUZII

330 >0J 0..j U. -jULLU 4WAJ I-J 0 WOxaCZN LUJr U

(D O V) UnI3 C W U)O3Ia:4UU U . N

0w

ND 4CY t O t

I j C,) V) Xu

*L IL -L X0C.I1 -

in x u 2 LO

. C X U) (A cc UJ NNU Ui I ZI

- . U.U7 < 3 1CDXL 0.CZC 0N4

x0 <t I (A N U 0.40. X 40 :

N L OL z I0u -jC U) 4 3WXuZ 00 CZ I0! 0.OL ZN

:rX I ui-I J. 0 >IONU33) C 30 t

w C 7 x CZ co VLU LULU 0 Lu 0.o I u. N>

Z Xn Ul U

0 Il NL

x <10-i > aiw -3 JN I0 -0 wI-0

J) t asooLU W400.3 i LU 4N 2 ff0 DOONI-U) O u>0CdI >

O U1-0O-J 00U0Z

W

.40.

000t''9 +o a bQOQ=000orI- M IVIa '4to v

tl- 0 -Go e'iLOGo GoCN

000

x0

.+o 0 0I U7(00 0I1 t 4

tr (1

OzI--4a:LUJ-J-JLUJUIU

0L LOOa00J .

it _1Z 0. *0'*

*

0 .M,*O

0 Zoa:z

z0

-

-J wU)

LnI--W

IT LU) I< Wn030

0

4

xa

Ix0LULUwU.XLUZ

L i 0

*(3 cZ0n,'t< r_x ww

W1-

z

OW.,. - ~.i-

- Cw04>U)II . J.-.. JO

0

W - CYI..JU 0

-J

. .I

0 *( 1-O Oz C z- U)4U) L

W Z0 o -LUW

U~ Z~a

OI

0UJ

3 300

00 U4:JwwI 00 0- ("11- z 1- U)JJ@Oej -j I :

O OC 2 C- ~- tz:

LUJUz4.-j

LUW

0-jU.

-j-j.4a:LU

0

Page 87: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U. |U- 000000000

0 000 000004 N N - - N o NLu I

00;0808wJ 0) . . . ., . . .

o o* I- O

* o V".Ve. o u0O 0OzCa Lu o _'A '-0 'tNU DNt

0 0

I0u~0m ,- CY) Nsaw

m

(AI-* z* w* z

00.

-J4z0i-z

N z0U

080000 vm0 OO OO 0m. t . .__

I' n - C NtO~~m~mtD ON T (n O I: m0 O c N N C Z IC

000in 0 0 0M 0 r-aO (Ot'

CNN0- (Dil

0

0a+O

I *O (IDow tc'OaY) Vb N

t-c00D+

. N

I mN.

Lu.J001'-I - N.>~Lu Q)I

I- I0 a- mff

U,

LuIa40.

CD

0

w

a'N

Lu

..

4

z0I.4

NZ-0

U- O.J u

~W-O LucflIIt U}

a30WJOU.in inul--J

Lu LuIx CZ

UJz0z0U

CZuzLuJ0

Uz.4-J

CZ

Lu.zLu

0z

S)z4~

0wZzI-,z00

uj0z-J4

0.-uuUl30-jU-

-j-j4

0

Page 88: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

CD

0LAJwQ

.000

22

zr

00NsW'-4 LI)

LU ) LI)LW 4J

<ZZZZZZZZZ jI4 - 1 " " 1 ")-J

0 0.VN)

X S Z ~ ~ ~ Z

.0. 0 0

sn ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~t sn Lu 0 ( O 340 W tLq .. 0Z

4.-eLI):.

> ~ ~~~~~ tn Vn uQ uxu nu xu :E Mn t u) x )u n0v

z z D :E :Ez W I->v naX l I-0Q~~~~ 0~~~Z IL,0~cc W Wtr OX Z - 0.Z Z L Wn z

O LI)t ttOIf°: o

O 0. 0 0LtJ O-O O.O C~C) me-

Page 89: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

> X X

Q. 0 I IXX

> >: O L

CN

IxO__-XzX 2 EA >

C14i

x000Z.XXXD -MYO

0- X

_IC-OU£

XXxXXXxx XX xJ-j > j > -i > -i ) > _X > -J ^IC x on on> > ExEY xCc

CN N10

--- XXXOOIU)U)>>xYY

x x»xxxxxI>Z> J > J > i D > JXOa>w>o>ZZY

0

OOw ZE I X 0 ..xX X 00U)

X

>> 'O0X X )

lxxxXOm > Xj >J :E xE

-o o-XOO0100J I

U) 0. 0.

0000000>-00--0O 0ooo0 0>>x 0

XXXX zE

X XX X X ZE X XX >

:> > > > > cnonu>xx Iaxx

cN0

- X 4 N0 0'J ( X XCq - 5 II U)U)0. IC

0000-x N -0U ) ) UO U ) U UX o tmN N -0> z Y xO O> O

4x_J)xx)x x( x - I I I z-> J I IU)U)U)}U)) I) U) U )U)

Wz0zaW

zW0.4

W

0.

ZZ0OI-- NW- U)tr

LL I_- -

W W

0 0.. 040~.

C,

WO

4-U)-J

( IuAJ W- Q-i U

> J Xx I >Q 0. =

x x

0.0.0.10

x)xxo o oo o oX X XO ( U)

LLJ

ZIz0Q

Ul

I-,LLU)zC0.C

~x80> D. I IX

O z0. -xXU>- J 0.11V)

Page 90: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000V 0 C4, | co 'm ;

r- O rq eq-

N )t 0 w t-4't- c')000C,,0cu,--? JM - ; 1 NO

. . . .! . . .

I.: al o-0

_-(90)w

CD 0 0* ·-

Ir'- c0 O a P - D

CoC2 _ co .-

-j

ZI--zz0.0

0UQOO

0)112!-00)!-O0 O-m

0.0l~-

0 -'-o-

0' r -o oo -r .o -'

Lnw -

v aw t- r0 000O OQOIi

0 0004 0 tD OD

N 0 t )0 Oizn N

I I I

0 I-

8

* *1'-

C C')(NV -( cN-

A

O rr-

rn ( N- N4

=IOO~ ~~ O i< 0nW OO4 T 0 c0 0 x " Z "ID2:00022:2:0

CD00+

0 N w .0

r.t

O t - .

l

CN w P-

. O_ wO '- '-

Cr_ -i

U ..J C,z --4 . co

-o

0I-

00

*

000

4O

OCO00

8

6

LL.

0

wI-4

-JLUIuCQ'

000000000

o 0 0 m)* r--O0*a -. .O*1 o -( D0

*1-000Lu '- C, u~0

z*~~~~mA

co '4- 2:

LO 0 4wD C CZ U.

0. 0. Z :z sn o * eSt Za Q Z I

- > 4Z U.in C* 0

* LU-4Cr * Unfr-o

CZret tn o

Qe -i 00 I Z ZLD LU OLtu- CrY I J

- U)U)Cos

0. LU4 LJ c J Dc0tZ LU0O D CrELUt J E -U

I-LU H>Di.)xZ0> 4 0t

-j00U

-X XwUOO

i~ . .I -E-z-x'- U.U.4

U,

Z 4ZLUw9 LUI-U)(I I< =0.

Cr 0. 1-

z-4

O 0Z Z 'o r-

r -o0 I'mz -a'-4 0

o * m4 4

n 0in C--0. * Z0 * wO * ZI-ZEnz0I-0.0

lz

C,0.0cr0.

'- DQOOOW, . .00 IV .m ID0)C-0 0 0q t

0.00-Jz0

- CS:Z> N N O U N Oz00

-- 00; c-. _ .,

mO0) .) '-

'-'-00.w

C, c, - - c

UI

00

00-

0 0, +

O 0t-F N 0- D t- CD0 *Oi LO'- t tDC ,r- -t- to(N 0 IV NIO. F

·

I +0 0

!- ( -tcot'- C t- C D0 . 0 ,C- w w cIC- '- I- D(N 0 IV 0* - '- .

I

CZ__ "

"I 2u. I-m

Z O I LU .. C r Cz x -N>

4 U)02:C') .. coU)I

0I- m i

u

40.

LA.

U.I.0

LU

I-..J

m,

O0

008 0-

c.

04C O

o .I r

z0I--ZNO

L. UceQ= U..JU)

O0

,I4 -W4tn co

-Jo4-, -C In iun

zr --J w -sLU LU

* *0

LAU

Z0

,* . z4-J

m

0 00. CZ0 YI: ZZU Lu lz 0

z

4etnU)n

4C 4i- s

a X LULU Xnw 0 . *U. U. O **

C.)X02<

cc

z > 0 -

z X0 4- LU(n aZ

w n, -> ~ ~ CZ ww -j 0. w Z(n x_-

IE

-Z

X 4'-0.

IC 0

i-On >

O=CL

-jz,i20I-z

IAI%'> :200

**

C-4

0 u 0I-

a.,z0* -

* U

U=-w

(S ix

<am 0II-

0.D0. QU)I-Cr!. I x_. " V)

4 00.LULU.o -. C r-s3 Q)-n )

Z, Zi0

Z -Y ZLU

J ICZ

U 4LU

: - -jI i' .,

t "

x 0-4zIx

-"Z

z OL0 -'-

...

Page 91: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

inCDDCDOO (1 N r--D ( MC t D

o. . .. to r Wn C IV W

'- W IV~(0(0CDV

Cv,'-C(N- 0(

L-

LUJ

I--JLU.n,,- N - N :0000000

O/QOOOOZD O Faa o0 (N CD- N N 0

t r( t (N 1 0 0) N '

-10)00)IT ....

000

000cv) M' 0 (N4 0)cl o ( D-CC' (0)i.CN 10t - DU)

0 f000

000tt- ISX N I t

-CY m C4 M-N IC- e I

X4 X _- N C. U U.O 0.O (92 co a

0(N00r(N0-N (.O -N

- 0 - T00000 00

D Q-FOtD U 0OD L r n0 VD-MIT . .

'-CN( NCD

0 o aw M

, O ) IT:00000000N(-CN Ci

(O 0OI0C.

(N(NC0m x U

0-NI0.W

X I.O L U4x1 20

0. U.I

I

U) I

l-l..a lU-

Z -

) -

-.

i i

X LUO0

U.Z0

iQ00(N

Ia

II-XLU

0.0IQ0.

000000000. . . . . . . . .

c 0 0D* r- (D O* :3 .1 40* -00 . .

- (D CT f

LL -q V 1 LUz4-J 0t4

C0

COLU U-z znZ-Z-

4 02wA

U) -i'm-4 2

U)I-* z* U* z

0Qx0.U

-AJ

z0zU

C-,

· .0C 0000-tD ')C

0 0 0I t )

11 t- O O r-000 o-00r----000. . .-

IV - -

U't-0oo @ a0

.00 .- 0_'-'-0D _ _

CN NIuoOIC'4Z(I

uJ

40.

0+O

o.0088 ot'-O* .DO

0 N -t ._

! M! IC(N

t-0- N

01

0C. .0)i

(D I- (D.0(D_0(0(0O t Nt'-'-r- .

z0Z

NO I.-.

J .U

U) YLL U0 0

jJu)Cm

tAn4o

LUO I

Uf l);---dU-L, LU,nx CZ

0LUJ

(3zP-.z

U

-,-J000

#

-J

* II* -.11

0 I.=(fQ.~ 2

I.4m

0.-rQ..dJ!n

0 L.(M

Iz i0

.. I-U) .4LU ULU I-JZz W

U 0. LUU) z4 LU

LU

I-4LUJ0.2LUII-

iI

0.I--0

LUIQ Z:) 0U) 1-tn "0CZ >" <0.1-C

Q 40Q1 aQ.C0. 0- I= 'r~

0 0+

-r- (0D 0(0 (') 0 T*- CD _D (D

N O J

- I0~I 3

U0Xmt) I-Z x 't >-LU .1 m DI. 0 I '-4CO D 0.I

I ( -j u) ~-D -J- ZU U 14 2(OCW)

Page 92: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0

000 0I-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~W

o 0

0 0z I

0 ZI.- zzz zz 8 zzz zz4 z " - - b . - a oNO oLn LI Cn tn o i /n (n v O

-'- 101010 10Lflau- 101010 1010uI 1 * " - N I -- - - -a a C: Q * :E' z 0E s :EO ESz : 0 11Uw U * 3

in J0 z Iq 0 -j

wn CD I -

V 0 QIj ~) 0.

..JO Z 0Z Z 1uj 0 I -0 ZNuC " 0 0 O 4.AJ 3N (NItLu 1- 2 * I -- X -. 1J 0. * 0 0 1

L U u * L. L 0.

I _ 0 CZ -4 0 O '2 U O

LL 0. - U. 0.* 0.e) -- F J (A -- i FJ _j 0L CN U. Z 4 LL Z 4 0 CZ X CN

0 0. 0 0.-a L L x . of -I.0 10 Lli -wCZ~ -20w C) t) I. L w U" - 1- LL -1 z a10 1. 0. < F U LLW0.- 4 < 1LU m L.

z CZ _ U LL X Z Q Cl _ U u z z U -j J "0 M < u- a- Z LnM 40 a uj Z ' -11-U-u 0 1 o 0 0I- - Lu U 1 L c 0 tn1-1 *w 4U 2

tn el < LLU. L) 0 L C U U U ( 0 O 3 Lu tr I 0. iY I u z 0. cy ) IU ILu Z 0 o wLu x tu 10 w v U0 uu 0 u w iLa0. L u . I- e> o 1 0 .10 0. 10 > 0.0 0 0 ) 0.0 n > L U) -F- 1 121 tL I XW0.>-2u4xZ z L0. >- z x Z CD nZ c 0a12 m xw wax:< o uw wL a t I: Ul w a o V) DLu I-: SF0 > Y - m : Q < I- af > m if I- m 2 U V) e0. 4 - 4(n 0U. U z

r uw10

Page 93: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LLIL

0

I-

-J

LuO>x

II

z0C]Ca - Lu<o Q4 Q

IL

H uH4- 4X U Lu. L" o . I

I-- I-

03 0U) U)

0(N

000000000

O0g8g~88-o·0 t-o o o o H. . . . . . . . .

1 U II II 11 H H H

zzzzzzzzz000000000I II fi H H III IiIL U. IL .LU IL IL U U

---- ---- -;. 0 0 0 0. 0 a. a.

(0 0

I I I o o Z I I H O

CZ I- Q I- 1 1 F- 1- I F- F- F

LZ ZZZZZZZZZz zzzzzzzzz0 000000000Ila.n10. 110.0000.0.0.00z EXsz zzzzzz Xz z40 4000000000

WuC Luuuuuuuu

I- I--In In

-0Lu

D co c - T C12 MlU* 0 . _-0- C4 -* O 0-0C. , v C - V 12D O t- N N -

z U 0l - IwS :T -Z-J4m

0.~I 2 sFSNt l0WI- Lu z- _ o- U -O Lu3t-'0 *0 * c')('eQ aDO-O- *CNIZF4 0

;) 0nu) Jo 4 4 cN --ZE

Z X u w

U. .

u

Lu-X- Z-U) .. 0

u 1-

4 0.

U) I-

I-J l0

z

In* z* u* z

00.a0

-.Iz0

zLuC4> xz0L0

L Go

a 0N I0 CO

I

00+

i

+

04 .o-CN0

* -'-N IV tDt- -

0

N 0

N0 9Nt -

cr=-II D

Z X -: >-cO I-

-.I-.1-J -jIr - -w o m0 LU I

00 v o O I. .J 0 1

0I--

LuC,40.

In

(N

o

0

.-

Q 0 z4ZNO

C-i

uj CLU

LA. LuIJ tU=dlY

QO, J

.O

tU o0u)

JOWtunuu)

-o

z

0In

u

LUI-

C_.

zZ-z0

0

0.LuIU,

0I0

CI #

(N

LuU)

ix

0<I-44a.CY

U)

Page 94: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000

0ul

*9

(D r-*1 I'-CN*0 -co

0)0LU O -'-ZW -T0z4-J4-C

Z' 1 I- 4 U )Z'

_. V sI ~<I - 4Z * 0

nI* W ,-4.Z * )1-0· .

0. L LUI QU) 1-

'-4 0.0 Z.3 4t1 -LL

LU LU O W1

4- OZ U)I W-

W s LuCK J coQW -CX W0. ZZ

LUj

LU 0LU

LU1 0>40QJ 1-U0CZ X

UJW > -C OX

>..0CY

Z Z-[IJ _ 1I'z - '-Z .J -4 0

NN U) 54 40 Z0 LIU U)O U) 1

0. * Z00 * LU

*- CNIL * Z

I.I--4LU-r

I-r

LU.44

LUJ2LUCD

X tll I)(U)1-3 C

U. . z

W Onli--F- U) >-U) 1.-.. 0.- LU< .1-0W CZ aCZ I--0VZ n,

I- 11 NN M IV"-0D O r-0'-04(4)n IS)

0)00)0 0 1

. Iq') CV aWIT0 4

*edU)_q- ~. .'4

'-or-- N -1 a O30 .. a ."-

00.0

4z0

Z CN4 )(nwN'OOI(NN(N>XU0U21X20U

U1 - -CN

M Cl' to"--* cO- 0

qU, .C4

C'2CU) (0"-N'- 4, (N'- ---Un * (O

00* eq P.UZI z N "I

CD 00 LU W(

ID -O _J -

C)0Go+

00

@ aa ~ ~0 .* r-

I {D~~~~~~~~~IW NL0) Ul~ ~ ~0 _0 I- LUi+ 4

0 I.- oU

M wxCO 1- O 4* a.

I Z V)

U)ZU)* LU* _- D* U) C

_ 00-

vI 1 44-_N4 4 Z ( Z

:- :E QU0F 0. U)I-WLOLU.4Q 4 1 -0

I 0.WL J W JI* uU s z 4

LU 4-eULU..0U'->U3OQ LUXZ 30. Q50.

N

LUCD

0.

0 0

I0

U-L

I.i.

U.LU

I---

-JWuCZ

z)

U)4-

CD

t3-N.0

..0i~91

,,.0

i I0 '0"-("("C.),

z0I--_C _NO L/.

-t YWOM 0W mW n

4

oWO 4-

LJ -LU- U

Q Q'

-oLUJz0z0U)

QLUJzLUJ0..U4,

Page 95: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

.O-C t

r- L -t-M O IV co

0I

00 t I . . ..

_ - C4 0000? I I I000a a a 0

M M (D M

1! I" .

ILI.

-iLUI--00000

I ITI0 0

00000(N 0) In (O 0CY C'N (D CDm am CD Ln co0)0)021(202U1-N G) t2

cM vr t -000 0tl- O I- N 000 0'-0~o-- w - w 0C-(D -- ' 0 . . . .0

- - N - C " N0000000I I I I I I I0 000000

0 N 0 I( 0 ( U W (0(N 0)'-'- U(' CN to (0

L . ........

I0N4 v Zn o I c

CI 0 O N D II o q U)0Cxu

I-4

LU0z_J4

(0C,-joco

I ZU) u3iZ 0

0. Z

U)U)

L 4>a 0LU

1L U. IL )O U0.3 30

C4 U

- U CL

0.

I0. -

0 -0.-4U.

X

000000000C 0)C1I(N4 (' 0) to Ii) M' C('2r( IV L 00 C O N

N - N~ 1 - C] -

I I0).O. . '.0. . .~~~~~O )~~~~~~~~

CD t- co CY* * r-N M IV* . . - 0* -0 2

CD 0 '-Q00 0

ZA

.I

-j0-4

UnI--

* Z* LU* Z

0O

(J0.Z0

LoOC)U-Jz0LU, (N 0

z0Q

-£ 00 a) Uam w- aw u

CO - C0 .C , U 2_ '-. ,

V N -

000',- 0~0 N .,

· U1 (c I (DN 0(' L ( 0 00 00 OcOI' '

0)0+

N c tO, _ .o IV '-*C'2(N

W tl IS N - fft cn w In N4t-"v wm N Cqs 000 4~ . ,~ 0 Go~ ~L .C1

:-CO *'- 0 W * IV - (D-. - 02 *4'in ' O Cy N

M -0-O-t v t F 0 lwI - 0 VqU - N N - t- -

I0o 0

O Z UCN U)01('2w OICNzC'd(0

I0 1

Z sN4 _J _J _,- -

.-J o .iC--oi- (0LU

0

0

U)

.-4

0U)

0

LUI -Ul0

I - U)

0: iLUUo0O

I XaI-.U4 0n0 _

-01*. O' Z FC Z z

- )<' O O. (0

-. oM m 0.i w* a M}U

* 0* LU0 *

O <' OO -+0I- L C

4N 00. z V

U)* ~~~LUI Z U'* -4

* U) 0

-j4 O! CC.)-* U.n zzI-w u < @ u.

CY Z Z .I 1 u Z0. WLU-4

<' CYi Z CYZV) CL Ola (0m CL /t 1 00

XCO4-ZJJ- . LUL u

nI. C U .Lu . J I5~ 4 L -LDC)<u0-) > U.

t lLu L X Z3 0. 0. 4 00.3 i CL CL O-

0(D0a0(0Ln

v .4-N C.-N'2-

(0

o

LUI--

0

0+0 _0

1~0 *eJ(CO C!

I I

z0I-4 ZNO

I..c U- U)

L~UJ 0Cjt3

-C0OmI.. oW o I

-C0LUJW

00000o C'- 0020w

- 1- (

X . .*4

*

I-

LU

#

LU

zI--z0..0-j00U

Ic

U-J MU. 0. ..

m-i

CYLU

LLV)4I

LULU I-Z -.0 LIz r0

LU'r LU I> I-4Z -,LU CZCL ujUn z4 LUa

LU

ILU

LUU) -0.UV) IrL Cy Z

F-0..1-0Cz LU 0 0= :) CZtL CL I. O1- - t' tL= = LI oOI >

0

_ IT LE)

Page 96: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

O0+

co W9 -(N t- ' N ~Y * LUi

0 cI t-

I I

m0-, (N 1,,... .~ a

0O

e1IVCS a

X . ID

C N0000'000

0 0 0

( 0. SJ MI - -00 . . . .

LL.U-

..t0LUI--jLUCZ- - N - Vt t0000000

0000000*O sNOa t- m lv m ZX- v Iw NT W m Ow _ N as)VNM-CD0W

IV r- N M)t :a. . . . . . .

000I I I

0~000C,'0,0 0 0O C O

-. .

0

,00a) In) toma0N D 101- 00. . . .

00 O0O I I I l00

~01NO U1

- N 0- -_ IU t .U. . .. .

-j0inU,CZ0.

iU)-C0 a 00 D 00

inMC N (DOE

. . . . .0 ( ( (,- ' (0 01

I0. (D 00(N0IN(N(NCDoI O NI oa O I N ( c c= N "Z II

30 -4LU I-

I M0 .3 cna: tL.. 0

LUJa n

LU.*X- Z4-4

< UJ X.4LUJ0.

I-Intz

I I-I- LUJ LULLUJ 0.

CZ -4 00iz I X "0 C

000000000. . . . . . . . .

r- I-* I- 04 CM

*0 '- 0 * CD *

.)z4-i4CD

0LU Wr-NO-

LUi-(00X -W >

0 - 0) 0'Z Zj-q o4 0eKzIn (0LI) -L4

*

n

zLU

-J4z0I-z

UCN>1z0(a.

C O cNvt 0 0 0 - co

o00 *r- -I * 0) NO'-Cq * CD

110 S- - . CM

· - (D

* 00 -'r- *C"0 - l0-C,,

m 0 C) 0O r- co!". 4

.(,DO]( (D {0} D * C3

0N IO I CO Q (N(N(N (0I(auauaZII a

'-0I I

0) c0N-

01

0IO W-ol0

+0 ' IT1'- ('] W

1-- 0 I~)O CD O0(000

0. *,.O *

!' 0f li10(0( I

z

*

4I--I4 I-j

- U-Z,--. Zz I)z* 0

* UJ

1-0.In

a: 0. 0

I : LU' o I- u:

Z 2 > O) (A

m co 0. I L U.J a( 0 U.4o ( 0 ( 0 0 . L

-j nI- I-U.4 LL U -j

0 ~ ~ ~~0 .

LU

0.

co

1-1.4a

C"0 0C',

0

dCw

z

4ZNO1,. -

= UIJn. J.dtoU0

4

-JOLUO c

CK 4-UWI

0LU)

z-z0C

,-1-JU

.I11,

*,

I-)-J

mULUa:CZ

* P..

LL 0. w

,-I

(0j

LU

.4I0.-J

CNIz <

_l0 izI

0 .

Ln

.,.a:LU 0CNIz0. U)in .4-4 -,

LU

a:I--4C,a:LU

LUI-

I--

0.I-

LIC' Za: z) 0O' I-LU (a)

MLLI-0:) a:0. I--0O--0.L40 x>

. n-j..=l.L

iCJZ.a:

._10LL'ZWLUz-j,*W0

0iLU

zLUJ

CZa:

0

I-4

LUI-

0:

LU

Zz

4X

Page 97: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LA.

0

I--.4-jLU

000000000. . . . . . . . .

* r- 04 * 3 * -at

-(D· 0LU '-' t

z-j..

(N

.4LIU - 3 4-JC) L I-wiLUI I LaiWL~ n n

.n 0. I00

_33'-JI CN > -J

Z x Z0 LU I 0

0 0.

LU ~ i. I-

Z ~ - 0.LU nI-- ' 0U) N UJz I w s >**> (A e 0 lJJ

U) 0. M F .uj WZ

C'LUjz z_

IZ Z 0 Nz -J.4 02U) ..Jzn.

U)I-* z

* uJ4 z

0a-20tL

tD r- t

.O 0_ CO ''," (D 0-'- IV '-(00t

-J

z0I-zLU C>1:z0(J

00-01 .- 0 '-0o-c'~n S

t.- .C'-c .0 M

(0OOXNNNJ'.WU U Uz m m

Ln

z

4 zNO

=U U.(jjW~

0.. J

IT I. YUO V)

-j oofLu 0 .4'-

r- ._ .M M o NCl- o

* C.)

c 0 NOr~aor a:

-ID co

D D (D-(0(!. .cw

Ln 1g1 N--0t-000

I tD T

. .

Ij I

n c-

r- O Ino uo0t 0

00*,-

0 -f-0 ob _

0 (0 0Cl UR . _ o

IS N.

*N I-C. 01xZ Nm m "OCI

: co * en m I J <ZU < Z S

I--0I.-

Page 98: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

00 -0000 o) u 0n MI) LOa) aw r a a -M a) om a M co

16 . .6 . . O

CLUWzI-.za(J

C4':VI

3LUa:0.

O'z

i0-*. .

44 * N I

z-3 In-3* V/)

* O.* >.

C',00C a 0z 00

ZZ 0V) V n -) -n - --

_ _ N6

· ~~~~~~~~. w i.Z4 In

u w- ) , .. - tu*~L * W -Zt

0'. z- OU > X Z Z_#~~~~~L 0. _ C > tu Z

U,

V.M (N: U- Q 4 0 -I n I L U 0 I ll4t4O 1 - LUF @ J

a:Ut ~ : u C 4cnl n O C1 ~ : I Ei ILf <>sulUXZ

a: InLul o : L a LU u 1s

a . IL Y1 tLUC1,

C'0 Z

N O.

N Nl I -T

azU,

V)(N 4

VU3

-

I

4n 4oLUtrInIL Z

U - LL U V

V) w ) ixw0O (Afl Vi W CL <a: _ C -

Ifl L a La .I n OlcY nI I < L L , >InL a:41LI

-J

C',0!

0 Z 8tnzx 0

0INcnLO(N

oo8000

z0I--(34CYU.

I(DO

N4 T V) I cn

IxuuuZZIC.uI-.0.CL

(A

U0X'- '- I-- _4_ Z40LU L.a I-

Z - U

__ ZII'-' C)1- I- 'LULUJIL U) ZL a:401- 0. z U

0LU fX 3Z CX20.

O >

,,4 I-.n

D

).- X IiJ 41tLU' nc -

0.V)

<

C,

oG0,q.

w

43

z0-<ZNOCm F

IL LUJ-J Un

LflYV) ywUo00It -4tnr4

J OWO0r _LU ULJ U

z0z

UaL<0In4)

Page 99: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LuU.I.

0

I-

4.4L.u

00 CO IV - N4 U1 Cl

M 10 t r tO _ 0 0 0 ) 0- 0

6 6 6 6 c6o

II t n II II II

Lu I-I-I--O O O- ..U U U

X I C C

L LL

I- -

0. 0. 0.LI) I) LI)

Z Z Z Z

.- I-- I- -tY> tr tr (3iLL U. U.U

I.. I..,1

CL O. O. 0.u n V V)LO

IC4 ' f O m

00 00000 0 I'0 00-

C00 0000Q O-O ! O O 00 R N ? 00 0. .0 . . . . . !000000--O

nII n II I I I I I II

z00 -O- 4" I-Xa

< ..U)

Y)

LI)

z00

I-

-j.=CLI)

zzzzzzz0000000I-- -- ---

.= .. .= .d - _J _0 00 .t /) 0 0/)L L Lu IL Luq L L* - -1- 1

t0)0(s L O I CN O O r N N O O I N N WI

I) L )C ZIO I) OQt ;s3 11 I 1111111 U 3 11 11 Nil li n IfIxr > Z Z Z Z Z Z Z ' J Z Z.Z Z Z Z' Zr Z Z>ZZZZZZZ -iZZZZZZZZZ

ZZZZzZZ zzZZzzzzZ0000000 00000000011 0 . 0CL 0 . 0 . 0Q . 0 . 0 . 1 1 0 . 0Q . 0 . 0 .SL0. 0 . 0 . 0 . D40000000 4000000000Iu .I . Q. O .t . tt l. C . Cu. O a Q C. ~

I-- I.-(I LI

LI)U)4Cx(NI

000000000. . . . . . . .

Ol (D (D I- C~ CD* - In I) cl co tl IV* M ' ' cqOr.* O '-tO · .O a*0 '-0 . O- 0)D 000 '- 00 0 0 0 -O

LO D-O

0co LnO0 0_ 03

0 q N!O N )C'). J

)0

0 .0atco LO-

o0 0 ' 000- Oc (D

tU,, _"- q U tO -

· 0'(AJUz

0-4>

o O~~V) Z coL Z- u (D oo . z,- o0) Lu '-). co. 04 I'-0)~(DCN0) *D c 00 o0 000 - o000-.Z 0)vtqu) q- @@c

4 0. > I) 0)m~~~II .J3 Lu LI), C tW

0. . * Z> ) O * Lu* Z

n -' Z.n -o

,,~ tr OIx LI, I-'I- UL >-W) -

I- L

Lu..J0.a!- -w z rIX - 0.:E.tuZ:3n

0.z0C,

J-4z0zLuC4> Xz0U

(D

0uuuZII

I0U'

O00+0n

N-( CI. (D i

UI-,,, I-

Z >

.J ) I-·J o , ZI--40a0)0.

O-4=.4-

uJ

0.

co

0

"-40

*

)i-

LI

OLuJz

zC~=10

n,I4!3Lu

C

z0I--4ZNOC FM C)U. W.JI W

U0 0

IV -4

O C: O

*j o

*U-

CL Y

z0z0LI)n~ncrLu

zUJ

0.O

tx 11

* Lu* w* Ix

in

040.LuJLI)

(N

-CZ40.LuJU)1

-

Page 100: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

(D Ul IN_ O

I I I0 00Cl 00)SCD(0 0)'t(0 ('2It

I I00000000C' 0 N C4. . . . . . . . . . . .

W **

Z0Z~S

Z Xo L

Z 0- ) 4m z~~~~~~L

I <Zn ZU. I 40

.3 45W W OW

m Ix 0

)E X I J tw z LUC J Q0.LLZZ

J W

U. 0L U i-J W UU 0 0 x zW o- oX Fst

M (D CD ts C(D* I- Zr n n co Z- I* .U oUC'01-* -CD *

-D N000 D - 00LL - V M n V t- ~.z4co

ClV)m

'r

_ (7U)Coo>UA

U),_ 00. >.

W tI

ul-Icr t fI C0 I )4C I--

14 =0.0 -W z :

U)I..O

4I-LJU)0.0I--tn L

< U)

-Jz0>.0I-

LU0.00.

Z-LU

Z Z-W CZI0 Nz -J4 0

mU) coU) -J4 .J

I--IV)* Z* W* Z0o.

o0U-

m (D * tn M coU) In tM co t- it. so CD o r-- (D . . wt 0*

.- (D N D *Z00) 00 0 - 0 0!-V ' L t

O N CY C

-J4Z0I-z

C4>'rZ0U.

07)0+

OCD 04.oMC.0 c'20O0 0 C 00' I (D

0

0 .00

Q n I) t0On Q*(D* ZnC')'-S

CZ0 -I v o I-

LO 0 1 '-') z n>-LO m m 0 X

LIJO4LII tO4X L eDI-Xoz 0)C I-

4

C,,O0

08~

C,zU)U)

t-U.

LI-

4-J==1.1.

z04Z_c oNO

tLLLof />UJ-J n

W )tuJ00

IV -Jin co

tO (An-JO01WOU) .--JCLU JZ CZ

Uz0z0U)

.,'

z0.U)-4

Page 101: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0 .4c:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~c -. _0 0o (D () U 0 N0o LO N4 D D O r- 0 0 UJ OU O)O O0O0O

000000000

0~~~~~~~~~~~~0 0Z i

Oj V) 0 0° o o

a V) , 3 ~

- 0 00 y 0 00 00' 0 Z 0 O Z ZZ

/Uw0- ' 0 00- QNO 0 U) U)U) 0 0U) 0-cF*- - 0CdU N)) C'2 ^-U N ) N U:f V * C -Z w 0 r-s o 0

.LL1 * (N b N .JU) Cl '. '. t 4

WC Z I00 - .4

U)W Z~~~~~wZ 0 u) z i

a. ~~~~~~U.0 U .,~~~~~~V -- X- -j LD OJO Z N 0 O C a1WO' (N ' C~l *N O O IN N tO

0 )~ Uji 0 U) ~ -- LJ 0 V " ~ - Z ZZUW1- . * U) '. . tr w '-.. I VS M -U ti U ULJU .i.J U U * < Z I-U N * O- - a.ce M ( W Z Z

.4) __ .4 ' (A - ) w 0 CXZW<-Wz w zm<-ZwZ coVLU 0N LL Z 40 o . Z 0 O 0z 1l _-_O WWuI 1z 05 UJUJ~ 11 -U)Q w0 LU J 0 i~-e I-I--L 0 1_'- I-I-LU Z 2UJU) IL Iw t C4 41 ILwai 44Q 1d-LF U 0 0O U)fl .40D '- '-- Z tOf .4L'D- ZS D s nZ1 E1- V 1-LU Q O- UJ 1 I-LUV z0t)-- 1 U 1 UJ VZt

t I a Q D IJJwJZ~ a. QD I n ILI Z l!Q wC O Q )OU a.QU) * > Q.U0U O a. QU) *> U)I-i- I.Z LJ Q.4>- Z1X Z S' : a. L '- 21U XZ I-mWu)Z 4 U)L'JQ < SIvlULu a 4 U)Lw 4ILULU I 40 I '-CY ' O i

Q. .4 J .J a.U) 0. L U).4 U

U)

Page 102: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000IT0 00 0 0

03 C 0 C ) 00 0 03 OO

0,w 0 0 00)0)tn -o 00U 0. . ..0000000mOOOOOOO

*11 I U II II1

zzzzz00000I- - ~- --~44444

L U. U. LL U.

I-I-I-I-a-v - - - -i

a. a. 0. a. a.V) En V) U) V)

x0I

ZZ0 0V) 0'-"-..I- t -I--J 400~

CZ 11n -4u* L L J~' II

* CZ 0. 0.* i- U) iU

U)coi)

( N 0 oI N N Iwfi 'o w ZA uU. U )U) If II U II II

U)wI -I-- - - - I-- I-ozzzzzzzNl W 1 .IW I .1 U 1 U .

0000000tY OIO O O O O

4 40000000I . U (juju j c) r,13. I-U . U ) t < UW UiUJ[,

O ON

0 0-000h00t

0co

O 0r- -Dt

N I- Q )*qo o 0)

0000000

11 II II I 11

0U4Ii

4U.

U)i!U)i-J

I03

U.

I-U)

z z z ZZZZ

U U.C U. U.OOOO r .OYOYOO

Z Z Z

C) 00I-F-I-

. < ZU U L

0

--- - - -JJJJJJJu) u U) UV) Mu

INN 0 " x

10

00000000000000

uuOOuuuN n Os I N I III uI-I-u-Z-I--I

' . U .5 . U . U. U5

[00000000.U0U0U0U0U0.0.

Ui.0z4-J

UJzza4

a, U)

4 I-W WU. U.U)

-0 0. zw 0U.IJ V)ZZZO O4 ..

WI-U):E-2) I-4 0.0.F UJ -0wrZ F

UJ OU 0.Iu. ,0 C

U)

-C

* _- I r 0 am r 0* :) . @ U* r- C'* o l co to inz 00 IT (Uo7 0 r- aw) -a0 o t a) _ ) q. )Oc-..-c'

I OtO

0 cvm-.o-J

UA

* Z* w* z0a.

O0

-J4zI-ZztU

z0rU

U) .Cv3 oc'0 *~0 C

00 t- IT0 - (DC'* . CD -

00

IV c- un Cl t q .U..cn UIs ' -0 3 0 ) D C '* -C) - M 0 0I '01."- N.

t O O)-q 0O -

CY)000U)CLIO

OP0)0O+

di O Io.r- r,.O0tn(DC cl(D- .

0:-I= m

J. I-JU. 01= z - >-x <4 (

(DO omuJ UN14 Om Oj I N N0I z

0I.-

O0CY

U

0

c0

0

u.J.

I-.4..JL.

U)

(00 0~

0.Zzz0

C9I-,V.)4:

IZO(N

1.I-4a

z04Z

UW UJNO U. La

mur~

Ci Ull0IV. -i

U o

0U4-

WI-

zo

zo0

U,

.

zCLU)4L U

_ _ I

Page 103: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

v 0 t-mv v mr W r

_-om0" t W v"Mw 0cs@ w s w

_. . . . . . .

Y Ma- wr u Ve FtN

u.U-0LAJ

I-.4-aL,_CZ000000000

to0) ICN U)I. (N 0 n 01 CD 0 cIz .C 9 Cw 10 1t c uz

0 IT lI o

-- N n t0000000 - co (O Ln c

_- (t t WV7 - CN)N U) - -4a C N U1 I00000- C D U) CD CO

-CD C.D 0 COtN U1

COOO- (N OD O I ND 'q

I . )

-.-J0(A-J0U) >-J

0.. QU ·- I. U) V

IW3t- - w

·I-- (3) UU. CV) I-cx

I- U)

XU) I--I ~Z3 0.-i-icm

JL Z

I-LU

nU ).. 0.0 0(n

UxI--co

CO4c z0

.I-0.0

I-LUJ0.0cx0.

* F

* 0

Lu

z4-14

im

Z Z--CY

I0 .z -J4 0

tn CU/) ..J4 -.

0Z0* Z00.J

z0I-jz0I..

CD

00)

(DO0 0 0 0 0 C0

00

0

8

00000000000w

m U O O ) I ', NC (C'.I Ot7Z IQ S

cly

JCD40.

0

8 I0 0oo o08-

r v in .

t'-0+00000

8c0t- o-r ., ~- -:'r- '

***1

z04ZNOc--

.. I U)0clYW I

t. UJ uen YO T ,J

wl-*r O

Z 10n ~v

-0I-0.z

C2LU

zI-z0

¢-

LUI

**

-MU)-J

U)

* I* .* 4.4D

U) I--

**

0L

cx4ciLUcx

V7

L

Z ZoU)LU

Z- Z Z CZ-zJWO

zZCLri Z4 CY

UAJ s I

tY z U Mz DCY O~sW'-Jg--I-0X0

QU W

CD

0TVIT

mO

0)0 .0ooTAmI ) C4

V CN

*00 .MO)*'O

0)00+0 M 0 t-oT o M

00CZ

LL Oj (ZC.))

c')wcx-.

^-I

C. co CD -I z4u w c m

I- IZ0 >I- mC

ILU.

J204WL.ffi CZIL0.

U

U

3 0.I-)

crLU

z -0 L

z0) 4

cx LULU I

-jz <0. LUIU) za L

(Z

5

CZ

-J

UJCYLU(A40.

uwcx

I-LU

4DDW uLU U)0.=)LU 0I- 0.

I-O -0. 0.0 0

z0

LI-

O~'

I ,cxI-0aC 0.I

>

Page 104: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

IL..IL

0

w

I-

-JLuiCZ

0 000

0 * JL

0 Y

80(D C0 0* 00

* 0 U)I-..I

U')tuLJCY

* I-

*

LuC.)z4-J

Ji >

CN. CZ

3 ZZcr z 0.

0zC

n X* I - X* - s * ~J C-U)U)n -

0. 0 3 3 0. 0.0.

,.. ILU

2 U)*..> > X- Z00 X _ -oO)UO '-Z41-t Z -C LL Mt3 ) LU et

I-0 j -0.4 -U)>.

U) - I-

C- XO -0. ~1Fs~ Zl V)

vX

z

Ln az)t-0O

ao !G00- N

0 0

. . .000000000. . . . . . . . .

00

<o I m VW - mm rto 0 C) Vr ) 0 0 -

C *4r- In - *L, C W(N ( D W - . 4 4 T

- t- - - C4 N

(ID

,-., tD'lwnCDI CNJ .

-J0-jUn

* Z* lu* Z0

0.70U-J40

zU-

z0U

CD I0 0 t.W_ r .

0

0tD0)

~ 0) 0

(' 3 ('4UZ L07 * £tS IV N

to('14 o

C1 a O I l C N1 :?I OOI('4Z I I (

CZ

U)

Z

!~ .r~-.0)

IT-

I tn ro I r-

D 1-1m4 'T-

I-u -ieco LL _U-C

0).- JI-JI-<_0omI- U

Cl0O

8gOo

Go0+

0oco

CD,0

*

0 *

+O

0 J

zn J

04 U)U0)0

0)_ I CC* 0. Z

MI LL LLU1 lL ZLL

D i 0* 0

:- t/> I) coJ Lu 2 U) I -u

-i CZ 0MC.0.OU. Z

w -J w

0) >0. Lu4 L-J - < U

.LLZZC.

(NNI

wCL0

u

-0

z

ZNOCZ ,.

:) 0

U. uJ ~O

0 4 ~.Ico

CU)I

a 4tUO ~

l-wr

0LuJ

Z'

z0U

I--j

0.

-J'

*

4UU

-C L

C

Oz 40. CZrv

uI -* U* 4

* U

*

Lu -jZ 0.O U1

Ui

Z uU) C-

ULJ I.Lu -4

0.Z Vw I

30. 3U) 04 -iI L

3r0-JIL

0z0-

CiL i==

Page 105: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

cw,N

0,

LA. in u D W In if Ina. IL.I I I I I

0 0 00 0 N.Z~~ >* 0 0 0 - CY .n~Z> 0 0 - i - N LO

N M C4 lw N t- N0

_ ~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..4 - 0 0

o 0 0~~~~~~~~~m m mm m c 3 00) 1O 00 O 0 0

z m 0 m v c'ro - v orco ~ i

*1- ~N-o-in - .. *0 0OLLI + ~ C]C,'C4CZ *0 U)0--C *0'O (N~~~U7'- *U) .0 I~~~~-U0 CZ Fi 0 rZ- * c .0 (f-ciciq o 0

ZZ 0 INO Z O-- 4~~~~~~ 00vrmm-f <U fCt: _ -J * 00OD Q <~~ * LD 1S)mLW - 0 * * 0 .E n 0 0 11 *D >_ , ~~~~~+ 0 * 00 O 0.UJ 04 C LD CX n - n a a D 0 In o 4 1WO~~~ Z-W a0 ~ ~ )U 0t.-CX z - r a 7 2- F 1-

00 az W H z Ln o aw u~- t r c 0 X uj< I~ ZZO(Th'-q 100)0 0 a. 0O U) 0 -.c * * X D U) 1

W Z J *- . *c@ t cicN 'qt- .

LLS10 I- 4 Z ILI01Jo O J F- W l fClUl~ O .Il) 0 II41- U) 1/) ..J 0 * I-. 1-. W- UJ 4u 4 r -'* tY * _ w3 IJ9 t C Z * i * * :O1-uJ 0u LU t ua * . W

z cr ec x z uz 2 ux0. * Z _t co 0.w 4T O * W u) 0L .. X -) * Z ..^x U (UZ3 F- 0 I- u'-4I0 z ( V) en z I> _J (A Z J 0o 0 CZ 0.i Z 0 N. 1 3 Z Z0 U) I 0 W.~ 00 w 0ol I- P- o u. Jt 0. CZZ ^- U) 9- 4 ZZ .> L I-U)f '-I0 C 0 Z 40 W Z z - .< ~ fi Z U m m z- W~ 0E 0 L O w * .*oU) I-U. '- 1 4 I -- 4 0 00. Q Z

..JI-(:/) ~ n m WLOINNND.J04 0z I I I0.u) W :>I 07 ZI) 07 Z I 1-4S 1 H IJZ U) I- 0 Z F- F- 4 0.w II- 0: 0 0 0t W 9-00. 30 D 0 I- 47 F 0 Y fi1Wt

4 -J Z IL U) D Z

Page 106: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

. ** ... .* ** ** ** *4 4* ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** 4* ** ** ** ** ** ** *

4 U * ** In 4* 4) *

z~~~~

z~~* . ** - *o X *LU * *

-~ .4 .d d:z * mn *z * -:- * 4 *Z- * _ *Z * *nU

Z* U) Z *o * Z 0 *'U * 0 -J ** - *

.* - *. 4 ~ 4 .4

:* * Z *0L * U - 411 * ..J In *

:E* 4 In *UD * U '- *2 * z *

4 U > ** 0 0.

,_ * JI -J 4

* I *a. * z z- *_ * o Z *

0. * * *U U * ** ** *4 * 4

4 4

U.

-

LUI--JLU

000000000

00cv,

O Noi ~ 04.

00 0* I IV ItC t C4

* oo M cl40a ccs cLUUz4-j4013

0 -cOz -J4 0In coIn J4 -z

In1.1. IZ-,* Z

00.Z0U-C

z0I--zLU

z0U

00 0Cv, CD CN -

N - N

' - t03 C- co Cl N

I. . . .

C00Ic*o r- tncwo 1 V n 1 0 t- Io U1 - * C4 r

Cv,00I-C0 0 t

10 ( II CN

IC* t- Noo 1s -CI C4

L . .

0" In

0 ,

o.

0 CO

Co-o

ILU. JQmmZ 0.d2 -d

40 3k- c m3I 4-'-t rnO I x *l uj

0N O O I N N N s ~~I .-

('0Z O

001 0 . . .-0

O oo o (D

InOO-0000. . .! . . C .

CD~~~c ITO0

co(nI IT_(n.

a.

0.

-Z

4 LUr- * 0 UOO+ U

0

tf O 0. 0.

L 0 InI- I- 0.0* . > Z

C a .Z >

z -a m

1j a C U j- I_ LU CZCL J U -J1I u0.LU->-

a.- ULUS-a 0. Z v- 1U. , UJ NLUUQ >

Q. Oz4-J> LU Q01- Q Q O U

4

I-J

CU0.

_ : _X

I

* i LLI IjL Ca Z ZU. IU ZZL U 0 a U U.

-3i CCZ Cl0 LU L w LU U--. > t> 'C Z

Q tL: I^JL2 -D cU nULW l-UQ.i-'w L 33 3- -

I- > 0 U.0W 0.

LU

0.

z

ZNOI _-

Q UU. LJ In

In YlUUQ:0dO

J AAJ U

Z0

0 UX -j

Q -

LU U

LUJz0z0InLU

zLUJa.In4

LU.In3a-JI

-JU.In 4

3 5-U..L UJ

Q In0nVn33 00. 0.

- >J :>-C-Il LUI *Inm .. 4-InZU..

LU-J zn o IL _ s

n -C4 F LU

M 0. .10. a-

-JUI.

. . . .

Page 107: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

I I I

00 0 0 0) N - IT ln 0)

N4 N - N N 0 U1. . . . . . .I....,.

C')C90-)* i- U7 M7 lw N* M M t r* Vt Cl -to 40)'q(_0 CDN - 0 (N

(I,(~0'r--toI-_1 .0mE.J

zWz00.x0-jz0I-.z

z0C.

D 0-0 ,qt r'N N _

- 4. o (a~tD

C

(0

0,.

i I

0 0I- -C00 N OD N I- 0)

. .- .- . . 8

0000') . ')

O 0 0 -000IT N- -

(N C' NC') Nl N C')

._

0

0 (' 0W O -(N N -' .( .7'- Nl .o0 N

. Cq 4 N t

co0+0o) -(D .C)D.(Do)

w 0 (Do')oC0 - .

i

OD0a

700),t- MD 07 am c (D0C) .(~O)Co).(00)

M0000'-

I-..0.U)

0

z.I

LUJ0Y)

CZIAJnc-m(U

*

4I.-

0.zrI

* 'N* _A f U

_ .40

N I ( 0N l O O 4 I N I 00I l2 I

--r-^II ='N I-

UAJ j ez co

4I0400.I z -J > -<CD co D. z

IC' m-JUV)I-(D Xi J 0:Z

0

U)z4 'LUJ U)~J 0 O Zu. >ZZ 0

W Z -ZI- am00L LU V

Cn I- I- 0 z LU 4 -. LL.

UJ 1-01-'-'UU I LU a-.)

OLULUXZ Z J30..404-403 (U. U. CZ I W~z

ca uJ x O -3 4 0 O

,q0 1 .

0ll!1

(00 *0 ) '

- (D a a C --(D 0 0r- 0Y - N -I

0

0C,CNC'

0O1

**

U)I---1

U)LaK

0 0LU * Ix * Ns

L 0. co

LJ

_~ z* =D 00 UU7 -z .) I-

LUJ C)I U > 4 I Q0.I-CU LLQ I-I1 01- : QU7 0. 1-0mC 1- 1-0.D D uLUJ4<U) 00 o >

U1IN

LU

0. LA.

0

I i-i

-JLUJ

0o

0o,

LblI-

0

000M - N0 0 00000 G t (D N0 1r1

(s (D U1-* C4 CN

In ,Cl l

CD Q Q-0 C4in co-w 04 N O N It 0

co0'

'-4,.- (D I>. - ,q

z0I-

ZNOW) W

LL. W

LJ 27

0J -7

V)U 4a En-.1

UC I

-LUJ I---JO LU L)U w

er c

LUZ0z-Jo- 4

UJ

ZOI- LU,Cc Zo z0- 0

U)U) Z3 1

0.*

.*

w0

0CD

- 0_ ._ .0)X C'

O OO

QICl"-C",

000 D D0000(0)ITN 0 0

N ~ r-

- 0 0

O:QQ

.. N 0Minur_-t0) 0) co C'JNr- N co

000

1 N1

C0000-0O Ln 0 )

0 CO 0 0r. . . .

.U7U)3(

0.

II

-LAJ-

C'0

C-

'- 0'-U)L'

VN

W U)z _40 -j

U.z _0

Qie =1U 0

zL I

0Q U7U) 4

C ,

0.I

QI

0-.

000C',O

1N 00to 0-c( r

1 - 0 N

. . .

7 I004 04 I x U UD

LU LUJZ U)Z U70.0

LJU)

U Z=) 00. -

( 0.30.Cie0. >-Uj I-

11 U0.

I--02 J 0.Q -JL ..

0.I Clq'O N OI 0 I 0 7 = Z4U0xU 00(N

. _ f.

r

h

Page 108: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U-

0CLUJ

4-Jtn

000000000

M N N I00 00I~ A A I

* 0) a-0o0)* 0 LO a 0 0Coo* M co tM 04 a7

tqN r- IV r-C ) -II~ o'

LUC-)z

4Z

0) -- LUAl2113I- ZE

tL 0

L . z U)U U)CL CL2 L*

Z

00 O OM, ,

O

0zI=1

tn -I-J .Zz

I- 00.

CL 0:E U

-J

Oz0I--zz0U

OO

00~ .C') C,

M IN 0),-* It ** CD-t-

.

N 1Iu u )z

I mZ NCv) a) 0)

NO .1P- *Cv)CN(N (N (N CS),~.N b t

000)co8

00 i 0

8* 0* O00

~oovt 1 0-.r

v Cv) It

.0) coC _- .

i

I w N - %O0 )- q tqtso CD Ct C(N 0 t.MNO. .0)N N CD t -

*C)( 0 '

IZ :E

OOz z -1I 4'-'-ID 0 co w Un0 x(1, -jU)O CI tDJ VIOC)S JO *I I-a<

0

00Z 8

on O O

z-

CY)O n

0 0)

CO--, ! .f -

'N

CN Cr- t_-4

N N 0UC U)

0 O

0.

0.

zI-

0 La+ Z* 0* 44

0 0 tL

z >00.,Z >

J CL LL * Z U)0t* DO0* U-L t

-. LU IXW I3

CZU .0)Cz sn *mLJ W CtLy - >I- 0. - . a (A

J- 0t D -J

z *~ w Jo

tL O s- I- W: .Uo

*

U)I--J

ujCZ

*

0.sr II0. 0.U- I I

U E zJUJ LU LU

O tL _3 000>0 LU LU LU LU U

0. U D LU=O)ULI-UtL - 3 3 _LL -0. 0 tL t w

~4LUlo > -r 0l->OLo0)LU0

DCN

LUC,1

0.

z04 ZN O

IL. LI

0 0IT -i

O)

4-

LU --J ULU U

Lu2020U)

IzwL

4

tL

CL

tL

U,

0U1t i-I z

0.10.* C 0

U )

M Z

Z ~ZLU ** oI * a-l-UOWI-U)>

IU 11-t~ .I-r o4 tr .W 0.u-0I UZ Z- 00trJLU DI^CDtLt

. . . .

Page 109: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000

C,)(' (N'4IT00 00'* 1- 0 - - 0oh - U1 OC1 * D U 00 t O Ot-* 0 - O

N IV - - IV - mV -I - - V) NlW * - N CIN

M N00. WC-

Z - 0

C McN-O,~!

0-J

LnI--zz

(N v0 0~00~0-O L C: 0-T0 cn0 a; N

M Ny cn - O - v '- ( N N

N "" C,.

0 00l + 4

0 008 ..q0

* t C,.o 0 U c I-f oC.)

000. . .

·*0+

"'"Oo o101 cn o~Ol W_0 = M CM LOW cn Mm- cq

,?0)CD'

cc M0 ('2(_

00.X a O 0 IU

4 ZI mIa

I <_--

Z N 42 o JOI- W acoW(AI N- I (D J O (A>IUUUZIIUU4IIZ II-QQZ= z~~~~O 0U I

* 0* 1100 *0 -

+

· ~~~Mo F W

.n0 J

-C W WU. . zZ Znr- 4 zm *2 LI* a.OI CD

-4 114

W W WJz 00-42 U.0 ZZI.

I> X awr w - inZ-< I OwZ-I

nI i wI.W I-W > LL

O W W x ' 0 e4 0 -ZI 0 X

n*S* _I-(A4

* ICI-

Ln-I

- IT 0 0 'Ln - - t n,

0 t- IV y C co -cD CDe

NV _I Ia 0

n IV O C-) _

N . . .

00000 000I l l Il

0000~-000Iovo m I C ,00000000N 1 C) 0 1111 U t 0 -; - ;m a NMO-0 CD Nr- 0It - N

s 0 c....o , W ,o .- -,uC7 M Wmm WW co

X

-.4

W

W

0.-4

W

4 ZL 0 0

W un -40.CD I-1W cc -

oL la I >a1--1- 4 0.= mW 00OX>

WV vt t - N -00000000

t t N 0 0 m C n I Ix u c i rI000000000'- 0( - ?' N t ?L - - 0DCIL C O O . . .

I C'lt C O I'O O O IJN(NN D IQ IUU QZ I IO

r0N

LLIW0. U-

Li.

0W

4

Wtz

z0I--ZNO

U. W- CD

(n W i0 0

O('ITn-0 Ln m

W .J UJ2 OI

W-

-xI-uJW

Cl Zz4-J

IW

Z0 Z

tn

(LI ccwz zJ UjZ 00 ZU, -C

4o W

I ***4

z -O W

0o .> I

>LU 4Za. W4n W

C,

trJ

a-

>-C

CY. 4

I z n ce

CD IUn .'-w

.. .__~,CD (N W^,I -*CDD Z

~J CD '0O

D n I-

..4

CDZ~O unQQ-J gNL1i.

.*

Page 110: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

D CQ LO)

0 00N U 0 lto co (q ccM Ln 030 C CDCDCi .. i .O O Ove

· . . . . .

1 0 .

0"- ( 0.Cn C) -* Mq Mr _

0

O O0008 8Ou 00 - 0r- ,) . .

00

NN(N

C,

I

**C) *0+ .40 4

0 N -CD .qrCN.4

* -..-Q.D CY u:LnO C17 rII

* ..* CDI-

C_

L J -jC

z O "II <_

I-> :

-J-CL

0-J0V)

0z

:.4LUI.-U)coCD

Ia-CO0I 00 Z-

I I - < - 1.C ZL > Z I-

O :r W I- 0 Z

0. C 0i L u LU L i .- Z-J .4 I O O W LL >L Ix a i xs IX 0 .W W LuJ u0..SZ IL .L L D Y

o Lu X Z o- m3 i C) O " ODt u) n x uX vw

LO

N dCD

-u,.Y. N 4AX .1 f

0

08 co

. O' 0-r. . .

C . .GO -.0-0

0o

(O co a)

w it 0--C CT 0-U1 I C _-

000000

- - O 0) N -_- C) - D'-'!tD U'-cN r C'X...

***

I-.-J

CQ

0 muJ * IX * '-.I * " 3

:E --LA -co

XI..

COm

U)

0.a-

-.JOu0'r-.0.

wLu

I-Lw.4 C ztrD O

CZ = 1W 0a. -. 4= U. I- a-I-

LLu

0a1>O OI

C00cO0)

-. 4'- MAqi'I&

0

0 Nu0~LO CDN.. 1

N - CM

IT C C

IT c 0

. . .

("CD'-000M LO -

CD ' C')~0-00T,0 0co C') CN CCD . C,!0

NV - N Vt -0 0 0 0 000000(D I n : tvN -IV 0 I- I-0C00000C O t s O CD

C')

L9 ...7 .7 (C0)0-0 e i e. . .) C '0 ,

Ia. 0O C4 I N

ONOOXNZI

W

aLLL.U-

0

1-.4-JLUaZ

LU CDUI LI I

CM:Q

00'-

N .'

01) -*- 00()* r * 0 C')co

u (N'-:

CZ Cl00'O (D

CO O

. .

D '- C -C O 0

(N O -o~~~~~~'C

1s In LO IV IT

0) fD- CD'--cs 0c'0Crr. N - O- -O -'-'CD'

z0I-

4ZNOW _-

LU Li. Lu

V Y.Uj

0JIT az.4 COh

UW.40

.- WO I

Lu uMJ U

mr ,

LUz.4-j.4

OO,uz

Lu0z.4

.4

0Llu

zI-z0C.)

CXU)-Ju.

0)0Z-rI--JN0o

t J

CD

0O0r0 -160 0 -, C)

O

U.* z* LU* z00.

(oI0-JZ

z0 N I-:> Zz

Uo

NIL V

0 -0U-z t

Lu 0o O

..z Iu I0. JL I) .4.4 -jU.

CD(N4 DW0 0 N NCNC D

Z

0z0

X-XI-xr.- z - a w

U J CL J

. U..

X'- ZCl0

Lu 0.F n O

U I-

L J .

Lu Z crX ) 0.

I

Page 111: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000

* r- ;* * O cr[3U-U0).CO

-J

co

n 0cc a) 1wL r--

I-tn0 ~-, 0) Z -J *c4 0

m~U) ((n -jU) -

0

~00.r-U1 (D cO Cru OM 0 0)(0(0C'2

_ C . _

L 0 i 4' 1. _

C4.- .O11 ' . *

N

000'-. C',

'-0LO

CN

0 . . .

+000oC-Id 0) 0cm CD on

M nc's0O )C' .

0)0+

O -cO Iq,O0 c 0Ci. (0j .0- O4 -inC C - .

nZ_LUJzOZ a

X ~ ~~~ Z--I>0 I cCa N I-Zt Z (0(0 0

0 J-JD m W IZ C4 ( U)O I M . En )-Z II- ZIIoo 0 0Ca I""W -o z

0zU)Unz

00

O08§8

LbUL.

wI.La

4-jLU

- oo a LCN0 u t I- t) co

v d v0( (0. . . . . .I I I I i~Q~O

00CY (O co * O r-u a)

* O0 LO mo* ao 0 M o w

- .

**

I-

U)> z0 U

j4 LL-F u-0. ZIZ -U)x-n I* 0

* I 4 cc* U)d-0

L LU LU

U) I-Ca.3 4LCL (l O W

cc > 0. X cc .--2UW4W: .s cLLLo ZZJ J zE J~~~IL

wO X-D > t

LUz4-J.(

cna(N4 LUJ

Za LU-j-j z

C

nU)

4

C-iaI U) I

X o4LL

Lb >1-CN LUI U)eU) .. '-_

.J U) -

4LU 0.-J UJ CCfOF Z I-~I

IN F M >-.. U) I-aO Mn F

uxz cLA.- oU* *u .0

Or-o:! l(0C3)IO F

'-00I ._

o oI I

r-a Q Im (D qC

0 - 4 0 C ' *( 0 C '*J *CN'-CN ' 0

co

.U)!-* Z* LU* Z0

0.

20uJ-j4z0I.-zLU)

z0Ca

(O U z

0 000o t in 0~ 0CN IOC')(0M' CO CN0 or- (0'- -

. . . . . .

07)0+0

r- C0 0* .C u

0 -C -' I0 '] co 1

0'- CM 0 Cc c')-

0)0+

N 0 * mI'- C d 0)* *CN LU1

O O I

,, c: z l

Ca 0 '-ca IL

(D 0o uiV_:Z Z '2-X J -

No o m -i 0 I I U U 14 :E Lu0(0

0

0)C4

U.

tuI4-jLU

00oo0OOQ C

0uJ

z

0

.1

24:

Z0I-<Z NO

UU-LI.- 0U) Y

LjUa0 0"C -j

LO

,-h-

0ULJ

- o-r UIxm

cn.J

4-W0 U) U

z

U)4 ,

**

M0

0~o0

0-0U)L

-J

Za

Z 0 -J0U)

0z

4

W ZLUU)

0LUx

LU U) 'a a O'z a0 co

4 0

" 0- U) U01-E - O Z4CC

S 0 - IL Ca-.U)U

*

*

*

ICL m0I-'t C

a)0X LLI0. (0~U L

w uj X-JC C-ab >

C0.) -U) ' -

3 aa

. N - CY

Page 112: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0 N D-r-w C

Y In C. N0YO I ~

(NoCl0(NN

-. N-u,

CD00

x

r-o0

0 ~00*0 0-nCl - Ln qrc- CD Or-

-C 0 @wC. . .

0

0C14

LA.LA.

0wA

I-4ACZ

0

0g0t

V -q C1 D-00000M t (O N I N

*O- 0 -0 - 0 CD

. . . . . .

It Cl- M LO _000000, ; ", 000000

V N - - C- - D L)MN CY O

-N ( CD 2 t 0tL . . . . . !

0. 00 N t4 0 0 xC 1 NOIcN N ICIUc, o oZ IC

0.IN

O-QU--J

J1@

0.Q W

Q U)

..

nO

O -. IOU.Q V)

.aI-_N zQ.-0Q.

Z = OJQI Wa-0.

0.Wlx

000000000. . . . . . . . .

Ci0

o 0tr * I LO O- CD

(N (N iCW .4.

z4

m N0

oo(j 0

Z

o zoZ Z -I Iu - r -I t D

a1 C1 N

z 4 0

* Z 4*/ WU,* Z* -J4

zXN 0

A-

C40a

0N0r 0 o

( -00 '-* * CVq

00Cn o o0

-(N O t9r- 0 o0-ci. 0CD - O C

* . - . C)

(O

OZ O N N N Z I Ir C. U

C0to

U,O ON

000C00

0,00

Q .0CD t-OUcow t- 0 Ld , .lo40-

* o-o* O

' mO a.I CY - .

* Z* W0w * z

0 L+ c,r- . i-r-OC(D 4 0t 0 0 U

#'cM N- Q Lcqn D u

z a->- I

CL

C - C

IX - Zi4. ~ 0* IO .Ix m I* * z &. QN Iz u) .Q W *>n~ ̂ II~ C.).A > I D -D ZJ

) I- C0. J o Z X - > X Qf -C co co Q CZ QAJ LL 3-i _j j - 0 - U.C.* -__ < _J-0 W. J

co m WuI x LL j LL LL0,-i O~ U.'AJU U.!0 uQ. A o 4Z . W Q

CY.0. - W0 > W:CO"_~~I ~a-0u)

C

a

(N0

0O-co

O L

-§O00Ot M 46

N 0~d

z

CZOCno

J U)

00

J Oo I

'-Jo

,jLL3 c3in- .j

(/)m~

!jwc3 iJ

,,, i-

I-

=.Jz0ci

IM.-U.

**i$

*.===1* _AM

W Q mO I-4 L .c

Io.W Az -0 J

U.C

z -0 _l

IWL 0

Wj x

U) 4.4LA.

Q

3=l0,

Ico

a-AJLI.'r0.

Wlx

Ix= 0V) O

= OI--0~ 0. 0. 9-_09_--40.Q QW41 o >

Page 113: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U.

W

L.I-LAU0 I00

0(N

zI--z

a.

*

U)I--J

LUIni CL

U t z I)I0. * Na * I. I II- 0 Z( Z Z

L U L U. LU IW - UJ-0 C ::E

O L L L U L U C ,LAt U _

0 . 4- 4 LU 3 30000:OLUO LU W W L

0. a> 0 a( L

0.

z00

n (D (D- i-. ,-

! I I

0 o .,10 a en 0e*tW Ln VI

-(" c;; I 0

I

* 1 0 o 10o0*1- 0 0 O)*M D o 0((0)* IT N t 40 Ln(0

O 00

0z o4 o. '-J1 . -o.

4m0

Cn,

LU.z0 LUIz0 00 ZU

U)

U ...

_> oe N UJ

en.. _X UIU)

-<EW L* 1 C .)CZN LI .. U )

U.Z 0.~ 41N 1U0 .*: :L X) Z I: ZcN^-o U0 0

La.

4

O N~0e'0Z-D I- CZ vt Nz _j -

(0comj

U)I-

* Z* WU* Z0

0.a0U--4

z01S N

zI-zLUCN> xz0U

0 0 00CN (N coro ('210N N0 0' 1

2 -N 0-N GD O~ 00 0 0 0. . . .. .

I I i

cNoo r-0-0'- o. _ 0

0 0 (O '

(D O O r-(D 0 co -0 .- .

cN 0 IOO I z I4 U Q UZI:

cl0

8 00 00If1 0 0 - 0oo -.w

t~-o 0I +a0 . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~cv, cV qI-. tN . tD O O 0

r- *C'2t-O N 'T -e· . ( .-

I

C-o 0

+

0 0('n '2) r-

0 -.- C9) LOeC- -*c '2Ct-o 0 IT0N

C.rv J _ CZ CDO O O -I

o O I-001'z

I <--s(DOI0LUocI .-JU)< E I-

o( I . J 4

**

4--0I--I1.0.z

*

*

L ZZ 0

~ ~ Z~OOZZZ~a z z sLU I- < -- '

CZ c= u cr z °0. ) '..j X

mL ff Iu Wc: U)1-I-0ZI0oo-Z Z *C.LL LU LU 0.Q

- E. UJ C Q- '- > =" 0

3.0.40-0=-w10) 0 . ) *00

r

_. :3(A I-

U)

I--J

0.U)0-j0ul)

0z

tr4CZLuEn,I-

(0U')

xXT

c

LU

0.

zo

NO I~1 I-=-

L U

lU. IL U0

C CDa OI

-JoUO A

: Wz0z0U)nLU

zLUI0.U)41

Page 114: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

Cl00

(.O O.lf--CN *CUO ¢a

- N - UN C40U1Z

Y N (a a) C 0 -

IL

LU

.4-jLUJ

_4 CM0 000I

~o 0 0C U C D N

-CD 0 -U t-o. M V - Vr 0_ I -CX-ot 0'- . . ....

000000I I I I I I

0CaQ-CDC)

X ·

000000000. . . . . . . . .

aD 0 co (D In*1- OC ~0 ~* 1 0 N T 0 N

* 0 N O co t-0 f U- (O

uI N4 - - .'I 0 *i0U*~.. '

00000LO 1 n ceO0(DN co U co - 1D(1 'T r--n U'CDN 0) Or-((D Cl UZ CV ) a

. . . . . .

0 000

- (N IC CLo CO (N-zo C O~ 0- in 0 -In IT - C V 4 CL . . . .~ . I.

0. 0O N 4 O I cNCJIC.)COZIO.

0.O c.) I-tJ ( cj u~

> 0.000.. ~.C. UJ0I-

U)Q0. Z

4 L 0.LU ix0

W U) I- >CI-F U

1-0. 0.0.-0I0Ql

C.

zZ-j4

C,9

LUIz0zdU)(A4dI

0

ot/z -

Iz~JCN0

Z-j-zz

00O0o

0 0Cu

.- 0 00+D -0 C

t- Ic UM -. . On -

I

0

~0~~~m 8 w IM sn mN1 S 1 O (Oco ID aw) u) t-O

1g 0 I D- 0 __0..00C

0+'0

C1 . _Ct I0 C4

C- I

00. -- O CK

0 I U-J 0 0 -4 Z :E 1 >z 4mcoO.a -j -j -j-j.O :r 4-- - (D o m Iz O oxm OJUO-wUNOOICN"NCN(x.jo4Z

z 10 00 1

0000 0 0

r..000o,,

0VnInwU,

* 0.

* 0

* 0

ZC;I-~I

4 Z4 U 0 f LU L.

I n w w IC.4 ) U.0. 0. .. Uz u'

QJ _j 1Ix

- 0 -JQU) 1UJ u-'C)CJ- U Sy Z )-&l U.< LUCJ >) I Q01 - UJ

0.00O l 0-OQ zE

(N

LUJC

0.

Q0 0

co ©. , . ('IV U 0

N' ID .-

z0I--4ZNO

LA. LJCn FLU

00QA OQ aa

I

-JOuO V)lQ~U1

tu0 1Iu (A - UJQJ tY

0ILU

:Z

Z10

z0IL).

Ixbi'v

*

*U,I1--j

* I* -..* _.Lfl1

In -IL Q co

-

LLU

CZ

x

Uco

-j

aYJLaiLU,

inI0.

(7'..

. -I

t-z 0 -

z0. 1) .

iL.

LU

-LU

QX 00. W C

L SLU C,)

0 0. I :3ZLU 0 0 x>

A

Page 115: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

('

w

CLM

0 r

- _ _(D D D

C. .4 C

N IV IV

z0

CI--=ZNO

LL LUJ 0 _In) LUO.CL0.Uj = X

z zzaO Zu

..V)V): CL :E -J4 -- z j O_ I a CyVIC) OL Q LU

.i LL U c x

CZ CZ CZL c.)ZLU LU33-. 0LU 0.

z C CZ 0 000o oo0~~1 0.z 3a- Z OIn _LU

Z 0 Q 4C 1LU U ~ujz 0 sAJ tx CZ

u.L.

I

.JLUuun,

0)

(C I ',-Cl C

000000000

*. 00 U1 0 0q* 1 0 N IVt* M CD 0 ( a

* 0 U1 ( *0 ' *C'JW.11 0

LUJ (N -w-

z-Jm(0

II ImLA.

I. c

j -LUI*-z

LUJI-Z

J -t-U.

UZ.Q u I--z.U , w

..J .. 0<a-.j .J.nI 4 O (3>0

c')

C,cr 0 YZ Z -ID 0LWi _ W CIJIU OC

Q 0 0 r In-Z J N -(' 4 0

oC x m0 J

.n

* Z* LU* Z0

0.E0

C;)J4z0I-zLJ CYN 0

za0

a

(O. 0Z

C.) U)IC: I I 1zLU C. C) U)

4 Z

LU IIn-t Cie 0

I F - CCLr:a QCC V Fx 0. 0.

LL Z eZUZZ -'0O0.LUC,

(D nN4O

c0 r--(D-

I O 0 D nO cN

-sr -0. 0)- O ' '

(D

000(0OIm. . .

I

_ -0

I +a InCD -0'O ( *.Cr- Lf'~ '-

OcN 4tON* . C') -

00

toCN IV n 0

OIC CN CI C 9U U Z II U

0O -

(1 Cl I0.' . C )C 0 '0

C0r- c'It J jILU0rz O I4(0(0

I 4

-0

I IL o_ 0C >

Q.- I- U ' Z J( 0. - 0LI FW CZC Q4-Z

0. I n I -L U U4:I- E Q a 1s ~ ~ ( > LA. C

0z I Q Z I a LUW a. aE U) . IU _LU .- e _n l U ILOXZ>U3 L ccU ) C13 t.tL 4 0C0

C',000000

M ,I

OOO

O-o

o 800O O O.O

.1 N

o

a)Cl1-0+N0 C'

*

*

Q4-a0.

z

0LUI

IxIx

LU)

In C,*

Page 116: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

CN l

_P.

Y tO n

O Q CYN 0 - U)

L DCIl In T

0 V U:3 -

U.

I-4-iLU

N - CM0 0004 14L M M I0 000

W 0 0 0 ....' V- M V M 0OOOq !C -l'

00

1-

- 0" U7

X W

.0

z0 In

0 IfD

c0 -(""-U)o3 (t _NM IV (' . .

N - N

0 NoOO

C; t IT

N

. . .C-ITCY)000rl C

CLLI)33

0zO-N4

N4 - CM

000 X0 I(A t CD 3 LU

00 0- LO 0 r- x U)LUI-

~ ~~~~~ Z O. .

Z0LU

LU.X Z

F tn *-OiCld w m ~~~~I- N ~ ~ Z Ee4 'rI- U Zr U w LU0.

_ z ,s I0U I -O O N N I 1ulw: UUU; etZ I U L.J tL

LUZ 1 W0Z0 .

0 - -0 -00I Il i l lI

M0 00 0 0TI' IV '' 0 t M IV NO C' M 0o IV U0 OOO----q-

. . . . . . . . .

00 00I I I I

Q to* - 0)-* 11 M 0)* O C 0

Mt C_ V

LU

0z o4-j40O C'0(V tx 'LU 0DZ -4 0O w_U)r'0Z .4 .-

tnI--* z* Lu* Z

co

Z0U-J

z0I--ZWL N> 1z0Uot2~

0 a0 c4)c"I.-CNOO)'N 0 0 0-0) -)F CD-01

_ - z N

Nl NO O

I

O O

- 0,,0)000 C' C. ... *.

Lf IT a)v- co '-0 O0') ,0at( r tCn Nl (13

0

N N4 - C 3

0 IVOts az 01r (NCN'r-C')- N 0N CI40 =-'* l ') C

I00 0 lO ONZNNtOO u) uZ I Iuu

UcLOW0-0!0t100! N U1

Cl CD CDID-0 -

. . .

in aD

0N'cor-0 '- C"'

.o0

0Or- 0

t-N

Iz XI--- r

_J.=J U)~

-

0I--

C,zU)Ztx

C,000

0d

00+

00aC"C',0

O0

*

0 s I'q- J Cl4 0 .4

-A> CD F U.

>0 x* a- ZIZn -4UI Z 4

* 0

S0. LUU) I-C

t 0.0 Q Z'I .3 4ILL

D LU OLU

I- -I zIO W~- 0En I co0. LUi4LU4 0. u-Z ZI LU

z i 0 LU 1 .J E IJ-L X Z

0 0

C

LUC,14i

.IDC')0o-IA N - .a} ' M 0-

z0I-

4ZNO. 0Y U

-j tY

0n mVl U0

.n0 V.

U)J -j w 'i)UOf

z

00I-=

z0CZU.ul

*

*I* U)-U)

LU

* I

4 *---

LI 0.0w

.4z

'I

-J

aLU

Ul

4x0.

UJulLU I-z 40 LUI

z aZ _0-4 I-

U) .4wU I

-JJ_o' 1 > I

Z 40. L UJU) zCYab .U 0

0UJiu

u.LIN4

U l

C ZCY:O00 0LUU -t lW tY I-

0. oL LDJ L

O. O I >1- 1- 4 C0.=) L U 4w a00 >

0.LUU) <XLU LUZ Ut

0 0.U O

*. *W

A U. :, -ILX UX w z ~'r t Z >4 ZI.U .. 0 ~-

·I .iI-. O4U0.-iL *- E 0C I I -O

4 " 0 0.-ILL

, .

Page 117: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LL co co coU. 000

tnO0lLJ v IT cqU. 000> 0 os- '-.do_- r- LO 0

< N ClLuCY

M C400O-- CY O)

Z 3::n W a0 o co aac1(3 **- 0'C' ,*0 C )C cC" (N 0D

LU

z

0 00) > I I

Z I. to C0 Z -J -

4 0

0. LV

U) < 4U. U)

* z* LU

.. * z

C')IU)

-JU.

-j

0

-JUL.

0

0.0

-4

4z01-z N Oz0U

1 co - co r- 00 0 0 00 0000000I (N (q N c 0)D CD 0 0 0 0) an com IT 00

Ia) X-t ow )IT . . . . . .

(N '40I iOC1U tO00

0 0 O '( 1CD 0 Ita a.w - r ts O4 ' CY) t. * .(NC) (N c'

N 000000'-~ .IN .W

1T I r D - 1

.. . 4

'- U'N

IV 00 *0

C N

CDONO IT O IC o I N N N w O) NZ(I I D

n co Ln-00I ii

00 t-D -aa c

. . .

00+00 (D I

IV '- CN

CO i-r9 0 or- ol aI

0+0

att

Co IU! ) C4r9 0 cor- O a' -NCO C'

tYII D*'- 1-1

-j J cr

< m m ffi01J V 4 0 0 0.z -44--

In Ln)00+ +- aD 0-0 0-CD",'-0'-*C,)0

o00§ 0

03 . C, .000's-.'2 .C

-'-000C"4I

I--J

0.

0 0UU*~~~

* 0~~4

z o U zj en4~~~LU

I Z ~~O 2 .* x co Q -, c Q 4 0 LU L. 0 Q 0

DU wwoozfiU L

ZL > Z Z 0

2:~~~. z cr uZ OI-J Q- X I./I - - tLL, CY _ J tx z -C 4 -C 0 0 wZZ I-z

C F- U Z a _ F- I- "zroo o- U)zJ:

LU LU Z .J (A 0. uJ , LU* -z -u.,.0 -nu*L U- 1--]fl O QU~t) t, OW_:

4 LU 0. U x z Lo-

1L 0 ) CZ L a L ) Z-U. > Z -.LU1 4OZ-1Z-

0)0

0!-00("C')

0 0IT + +to -Q Q CD -CN C0 0) '- - T

O 7 _LO* * _-u

N' -0 0Q Q

-D 000(0 C')_- CI> .

*

I--4U)LU

***

0 l0 0

+

0~o } r- i

0 I

. 0M U) -tM C IN LO

0000¢tD N t I0000

~,'I 0 ,_ 0o r CS C1

N co - IV U,)X Ce . '!

CD0Zco

I1

.X .

U.m0. 0 -- -4

w - -o D- o

.4 LUL0~ 00 I

W 0 J 0--

0 > -0 .0 .1 - 0 J1 -1 - 4 0 . 1 -D :LUO -101 Q '- J

ul (N Uf)000I I I

000N 0) CDC C' (DUi N t-

LL) IT C1'l

+ I IO 0 0

.) .V 000~0o 0

0.'- *G-

*O) *Cm 00 0M.~.~

+ I I. . .C- cN --0 0 00

U, 0 CD ( tVC') CD 07) C'd0 00 0i ti iG

C c D0 0

CN (') 0 CD Ui iU i 0 0 . .

tD (N CU r -000000 0

9 r Doc c 0 c

- n N 0 N tM V Mq V

00 000 0,....

z CN I )ONO O" I N N N I IO Itu u uZ I x O

Ln

La,4x

z0I-'4ZNO

LLU U. la

UW 0l02

rJ

4

-J.LUJ

z0

z0

rUJ

<. >z0.I..4

Page 118: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

CD

waUCD U-

L

LJ

I.-

.4JL

IJJ

z0-4ZNOCY

IL

0.co zin IZ I

00 0112m Z

cD11 x I(

J C W0 0-I-

LUoI 1

UX x z 4- 0-1J C) 0-O -LW 4 UJ

z i00

LU z ~~I--

. . .LUin

LU 0

Z z

Q4<>-

Z Q-U 1-00- 0iLU trin) I-JoQ4t : a -

000000000

in mq M00 0i ,

00 0

C0~LUj0z

4 00 0* c CN IT D 00c 0t

w 0 w04*uo o c o aU7 0'- -z ~....z

o 0

Iin -Y a in * Z* UJ* Z

0 0o o

't U N -0 0tD in Lr0 Cq

0 -1 0 - 10. I 4 0

in 0

0 0I.)

.' N -C n 1 N )-U1 n r_ !~ "-#>* 'T . N4Q

CN0

Inccs-

00--· 0,

0 in0O* ..* 02 * O

*1Ln

0 00 in

C(D 0 CY -N

0 0CD.

*0 UN -

0

O IU ~ ~ ~ LJ-J 0 0 1~~~~~LJ-jIC)~Z

4 ZZN.

Z N4st O 0I0 iI..1 0 0 N N00 CDI J O z I-0 0U. I-

CDo (7 am a D

C'T0 IT( M(cM 0r 0 0CV00, - - N0_M OOOO

0Icl

* Z* LUJ* z

LUI

4 ., 4 t - -

CD O 0.D 0 inOc I- 0- a

Z 0->

* C in -* :70-* ILoQ

- LU

CZ .U9

'I tIIJ azF

I- 0- > 0_ ~,X X LI I io u.IL)0. > LU0 CZLUI

I- 0. mL

>- LJI- LU M

**

v)*

UXI--.JLU

I* s.

** I--U.

3r

.J .J

Z l -3

UJ 1x 0 I.. ~0.,

w -j CZN. LU I0 '-I-

w 3- ICL -iCieO 0-

Q (A >OcLUJ F

0m

tL Q: : II

in --- '-

LU LUJ LU LU C.LLI W W -E

cz m zu -CYn Y r -LU 33- -

Ix0 0iU.CL U

UU. J

0 U. Co U0.

04

I-

LU LUw. UI..

NNUi

Z

< W "'Om, I- -F- n >-U)

I-- Z-- 1-F- 0

i 9-Z - :rQ 1-

II-

LUuiI0L4uJII--4LU

iI-C

4LUzLUC,

Page 119: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

uL W Ln r-0___

. .. . , 0 0 0 . 0I I I I-?(D (D M70)1 0 co00 Co (D 0TOOOOO -cl)- O O-

. . . . . . . . . . . .

I

CN 0O

'-0 C'O 1) tM 04

* - 0 . (0r-* co t r- -u) '- r- *' )

* C ,, .j, MCY

r- 40 O O (.ur- * *cr,4 -C')* st *c

cN,0O

OD' Cn co U1I-I

r r I.~ .

r' O+ 9r a

88 8o~8 oo00 - -i n

c 0 uW 1 0" Q 0 CN-tD LO N S

- U) CD CO 0 '-aC) 0) ~ r- -

_x P - r L

ooO .LO0 00CU O O

0 +C-4 .1-CD C4

0m 0 CdI 0 0*.. -

It O coIN -(D t Y0N

0 N+00IV 4 (CrO_

. OI

00.

0 I X, >4 Z IN.s>z <c c 00

(D0CII 0 _Z N O m C -J I-

z 10 0U I-

*

I-3.* Ns

* .- 'FV) -

UL. > Z ZW - 4o = ° UW0U) a -J

U0. _J4 1-0w U LL CZFn L

0.0.40L uL L U. i

- W A X

*

*

U)

-J

U rWtY

* I* N.* -:

101-LL.(

00 0I I I

c a O-

_ C')0CN 0c- aw cn _- C 4

> . . . .

0

o~0~.0) ·a)m 0 D. *r r- rC_ C ._

CO O

0 00 (Daw D

. . .

(D U1 Ne ' r- -000000I I I000000

N t (D ) _- (N 0- CD C) - ! 0 N wD " tm--lC r N X . . . . . .

n,

mI0.J

mWuLJU)

40..J

ZZ

4W znW V -0.U I- Q Q 0

IL W

2 LA U

O O I >0. 0.- 01- 1-- 0.m m W 40 01x>

00W Qn

00 0 c. r·

- In. .

00I Ico

eD coc(Dto IVMUC 1S

C."0IT o

r 00 0nO (D

Ln r . . .

0 0 00 0N I I 0000 0O OOO Or- -- r ; r M C)0 n v- MC0 tD C) to g 00N D N C') 0 CD inN r N : - v. . . . . . .

I0M CD Oo cs oy a I csN C Wm I)OI000ZII00

C')

Wa40. I.LL

0

-JCY

0 0* -000q

* FD a co t* (D Cc * O D 0:-n 0 rcq 0

*CJO)Iz0

NO0

LLWLL

W O0 0

IT -JW"CD4CU 10-J 0

WOJ0

-J (WL UJ)

WC.)z4-J

(0

W zo W

z zZZI-Z 0o Z

4 U)I- 44 ~3I *

*

tM N0O00~O cn tO 0

Z- 0 (0I N )_J . .c0)co

-J

(A

zz

z .

0 WLz -

uz i0

/ I-,..Z <W cQ. WU) z(4 Z

CC

-J0C)N

4

.. OIWo >LL .N

CM N -ZQ -NW/ ,

4N < I-, uLJ CZ

IA n

'Z Z D fin o)C

4I-

rsWtU0.0I--NiW< U).J

Z0OI-0.0

I-e,W0.0CZM

.

*

h

Page 120: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

t (D0 (D c000-00IT r I C I _c0- 00 a

Ce D vU - t- to °

. . . . .I I I IC' ~0Cii i ico

z0I-<ZNO

(n,-Q) yLUC).J U

0no4

.J -30 L 0 LJ ogjU).4-

L LjtuO i

Qz4-C

0 0-) LUz z4* LU

Z O0 Z

_,l U)

Cl <CI

.4**

z C.

0z0(n 04tr I

, > az 4

0. 4U) 0.4 L

n

0 0 010O OI ! I I

* ~ O0 1 ~ ~0 oz*0 (D c-IT0 -= 0) *o F tD -o 1- r-

LU CN C'2 I C'

Cv)00

coD

Z-JI

-JI-z

z_j .

-I

00.I0

-jz0I--zz0U-

(N ( 4vol oo 0 00

! I (NOwr-I--(c° I *ln'-On tU)m rL rW-

. ~ .

r - IVID -. 4 0 ( C0 C 0

w N - *c .',C14. O

ID(N t W O IN 0 0I ( N 1 0 0 0U 1Z

o .

0'.0,r-

000co00r',

VIavI St

00+o

qrOoCS .e-

tD ,t C~IV CDO)OCNC- '- o~.. - .

Ix

Iex "- I-

z x I _< m to CL< _

Cl o W x Ii 0 < U < z :E LL

0

0oC(4

UC,4. IU-U.

0LUI

-4

-JLU

000cy 0rl)v IVX

0 r'. uf~LO ; MI'1 ',- IV!

I I

000I I I

0 c 0C',-n

o t. t_C4 CI. . .

Page 121: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

,io:

o

00

0 0 N

008 0000000~ ~~ 800ZZ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ OZ OZZ Oii4NO~~~~~~~ 0 O O O O 0

z0 Cn

I-. ~~~~~~~~z zz0 z z C Z 0 4. 0 Q 0 0 - Z ' -44-N 0 On 8 O OU ( ) O I0 Z ir,^,l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o In On O) O O O O O nv)I

4-- 08 U) 6OC,~~~~~~~ tnnu'lq 4 C

LLLI *.1 C'2NdID.- 3.- jf ((N 4C 0

0 4 IU. U.0~ ~ MZC.) I I-U0 : 4 2 0 0 Z 2 X

n 0 O U U U O U o U

CU a Ii_ CI O O U)OmwO' * '- 0 -N0(( C ( - -IuN s s4-- l U 'V * O iX z s X O ix O :E E 5I 0 Z C1Wil 0iL' * 0 tni C N Iti n 3C-J C.) - N 4 O-I

ww N * 4~~~~~~~~~~ .U.J L 0 C00J V 4 UC., >iC Ofl D Cf

LL ) '-"- -. J U' i Z WICU5 (nU. Z40 Z 40 I<0 CU 0 U)I-4 - -C 0 U)'-' - - N t I

U)nCLWO.I- 441-CU ULW. J 44-C 0IICI ~-OW iZ'-'C C. O-OCU 0 .- 'O U _ N0 CfC 0'--Z ) 40CU~ooaW<WQ -wo Z I- '-El

i I ofxM IUCUZL i ox.C m 1 Iw w x I I w 0 CIw In .fO) m 0.C/)> O )0U) 0.U ) I I o CZ L U I I-> 40. -In0.E ) 4>0. .0I- 0.2C) -IU) U. ) I^J il ixl * < -J - i 1

0. 4 Lil 0. 0In 0. Li. ZL in4 CU

U)

Page 122: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U.U.

I.-4-.1

~o§OOC O O 0)o ooocm

0§001000O88 388000. . .C .. ... __o

* 1

* X ! Z0Wl 0'-'-J x L)=) - 4(A7 2IxWi LL

II

* LJ -J* ce .* I-ItnmU)

a ll fu ll f11l11zzzzzzz0000000I-I-- I-I f- 00000004 < .4 S4 < -X 4

U. W W. LL L . LL

I- I- I--J J -J

0U) U)

I HI-J -J J

0. u 0. Ut

{ 0

, r co r- ID (D000000 0O)03C- 0 '(

r-tt m a : t- 0 c"M0 0 w "IW 0 cvI

0 r- I o; r-o cn 0 t1! . .! . . . . .~ 0000000,-coII I I I

1iiiii " lulllZZ0 0a " ^lI- I-

X U

z z- CY4,s .4

UJ-I--CZ .0.I-- t/I U

mCl)

zzzzzzz0000000< zr . <

. U. U. U. U. U. U.

I- I---~- I--I--*. , " " ". "

-IJ J J - -J J -Ja. a. a Q tL . a. t

_ _00 N IV u n I .n cs I n n I .

N "CNOOI"N NtDI N OOI N N WNm4I0. OICO ZIO I00uZII OLU I

UA> 11 N U U 11 1 11 U u n u n u au n u 0 N<ZZZZZZZZ JZZZZZZZZZ, ZZZZZ ZZZZZZZZZ

t~ z z zz z zteE EX s:EXs E 00000000 0000000000 iamammmma immamamlam<00000000 <oooo000000000ooo

W u) U)Cl)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i

0z0UN4

04.. a--'r> N

O <.4N N >

L Iu I

"'Z- (I J2cr2

4 I-

0. 0-L Z )U7 " 0

-[I--W

0.0 0zOW

--z0

I-,n,a.O0>.-

n,L0.00.

000000000. o . .. .. . ..

M N CS4 I00 00*1- 30 c 0)CD

* :2 O D D CN V) t-*O 0- c o Oc w)-CS Im - t- (D -_C 'q n 11:)U0 03l1 i -q1C'd ~0* -C' *10~11

0UJ(Jz4

CZ..Jm

z(30

zUdW

U)C)4

**

0 0tn X00mOZ"C"Z-0 (D

' I D 0I: CY atI-,4 M-

00o

-J

CAI-zz0M00-a

z0

IzWCNz0U

N ,tO0i I

'0

tD C,_Ut -- U-

.I !

tD ( 0cO NtD (Dr-

O . 0(0

O (D (

0 (0(co* C.--0N IOn 0

03

0 0 I c CN (00 Z I

0

w

U'O-i iIV

co m0 0~c0

+0O

to o~t- .I .*1-'

z0I-C 4Z

IL WWON 0U..

.~ J1/703D U

-JOUJO I

W0 -U) r ULU O

-J W WnK ,

0

zz0C.)Z0-J

N4

0+0)t-oCD

0

O0U 0IL70.

*- M(

'C-

-- II :O I-ZW-J>0z x N.1>

< m 4 - '-4

. -3J U)II I-J O e< ZU 2 .J lI

a-104Z04o

Page 123: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

WUC,40.

088888 co

w 000~~~~0~0 000I- o o Ln o r o o o

0 0 0 0 0

zIW OOZ ZZ 0 o 8~FoZ ..... ...

N 0UO V)) C 80U)En )) 0 Z

uW * cr~0 ~ ~ o

4Z Z -· ' ~ ~Z ~ ~Z(U) 0 L 4Lu I U 0.CDUJO - NOCCJDNtfU) U U I Z-i z o1 o on Cn ~~. 4'I O 0 U a U O O = " " O

W*- 0 * N - NLJU U * 4 N I-J4> U) - -

W Z U iU) 0 Ix UO 1- IL0.-* I-U. LO. "0U J) -j IL U. Z 40 IL Z 0 x

0 L 0 ) I--L 0 ) I- I-O-I z Z I IO U.L0. I-- 4 -LU LL *i 4 < C >* U~ ^40Iwa- Z U) _0 LU Z Zil

0 a WZ X 0 I W oILa im U )ILU)I L L Z )IL7 I' L x C i LL) ~ ~ ~ V -_ Lu EnCJL L V) _A _) 1x JU .1W1. -- 0

0 0.U)O) 0 U) *l A > .OU0U) 0.U *n > U) -I- xzIL0.4 ILZxZ Nz LZ.O>- �IZ I- )Z O <X4Ia~o U7UJM4ZILIL40 'z ILLU L 4-.0 I-.UJ 4I-0.Q . t 0.1U -CU)0. 4 ..J -j 0.U) N. IL IL t)

LUtY OC YD Iu t z D X a Y at s

Page 124: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

inin

N N

0 0

n U n n

zzzz00000 0 0 0

I-- I- I--_ _ OU

a aK CZL. LL L. U.

22220000I--I.--U CL C

L LL U. U.

I- I-I- I-- I- I- I-.i -J- - -J -J J J

; U) U) v) U) U U)

co0

U OOZ O NZNOOZZOu.U *u hutn

I t

o 0) 0 C C4

Ilnll66II I H H a U N

Z~~~ Z Z Z

w w _~WUI--I- I- ~t-4 4 LL. U. Li. IU6

4 I.-#"P". 1.4

U IL L C.0.inW

U)X h i it_ m CA Y rl

0Z00

. z L z. . .I-I- I- I-ILU. LA.U U.

I.- I-I--_ _.- _

0. 0. 0. 0.U) U) in In

xo0

N 0 0 C N Wz000z0IN # O II N H H I

4 - F- F- F- I F- F- I N F- tF I- 1F - F- F- F>ZZZZZZZZ 4ZZZZZZZZ00000000 00000000u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~W u WWu -WWWtU 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 * 0..0..0.00.0

400000000 400000000m) U

XN

ULPL.I-0O

'I

kUI-

40Lu

ix

*m* 00

u0z

4-J4

x.J :ILL. aCZ CZI LU0 ZZ-Lu Lu" CZ

E IZ -J 4t 0in m

E -IzI U). - .uW - 23 Lu LuI N U. in

-J oLu. Lu*

.4 U) 0

I- -CU) I--I- LIu .-J 0.

LuZ~De -J jE C'U > CX 1 0 0.-Ex

*

00000

In anI I

0 0ItO tt~ 0

i0) r-r an. . .

In co O)m l

N0 ~-I ti

t C In0 0-Cl I. in

I

0)00

0) P. 00 wco Cl o a-

at --

0) 0 0 -000000C -* '. pt. '-C'.

la C4o cN

0) 1')0000 of. 0 C †(.'. . . .O O OO OFO N..... 0~'O.

0)0o

00-Xo o--o_ -'-0'-

ZUZ0o z0~~~tL~~~~~~~ -- I 0 z >J. %.. I-r

Vs zox aso-I I OZ'

0 oI-O~nu)

ua,40.

U

z0I.-*I-4ZNO_1 .4.4

L LWJ

AU

O0q' _J4tn oCO -J Co

Lu 0 1

W-

LLI LufJ CKJ CK

0QLu

z.4

20O

0z0UN.4

**

U 0I- Lu-J x

LUce U24* Lu* 2* I-

CAmin

N

ZU aLt' "Z 0.0 Lu

UUz -0U) V9zILu l

0> a2 4

UI/I.

8kn § 80 §

Page 125: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

00000000. . . . . . . .

* -'* 0

*

*

0 s 4_LLI- IZ 0 4

Z Uo Q. ZI0t Z '-)0

ZU._, _j u, ,* O-3: * (/)1-0

-0. J U

U. W 0WX Q' u:E 0(I w c

'-4 2

W. z JQ U)I W 1-W4W

UI z X LLI W

W M04 z:E

zC-J4C

-C2~Q0~.W3~XHZ0* a

- w I_W1I2LI FU. U)N13 3

W Iin - UI

z 4

Q4 1-CJZ of

0.1 -W Z:U)'- 0

.41-

3W

WIn.0-3QxU)z00.0

Ixw0.00.

C,w zJZZ-

I0 z -J

4 0(I, J4U U c

f -

* z* i* z

00.00U

000

000

-J4

Z N0Z c~>100

z00

CD

0

. . . r-*1-

0 0* rF

0 0.0- C,

0000o0n

0

0l N 0 t co cq oC) 00OOOr- ON-O0 r- 00

0 X Qs Z o

co mmQI < _ (D o C W Ist~~~ I- Ju 00I'0~ 0I DI * O '--ZO Z I IO V < EIC N JW I.jo0 Z

Mv

uJ

a.

tl0 0cv,i

00

c;

U.

0IAJ

I.-

-LJW

zIn

tln inign-

I I I, 00C) iOi OOV- cr- NU O N -I4 o -.C . .

z0i-.<--CZ

Q 1Ul

i W

2 O-Juli0 0IV -iV oC

a V)U.J 0

Wl (A -WI--

wuji

z0zaI-.Quj

zLU,0.(I,4C

Page 126: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

8000000(y)

800

000000000

ujUJ

I.z0

Ut3

000* °8

44* o4f0

oi

0

0

0CD CCD~C

z z z 8" 4 P.. 0

U U V 0 oV) ) u) In- CN 4 - C.

0 0O0

000

C,O 0z

Ln 2

C..' _=i=O=U

8 Ut . _

CA OZZV VIV Ut_ ,_

C,,0

88

00n~

0.z4 0

C..'

* I-* L=* 3-

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ILJ

WL (Nq U. ZZ 0. CZ C3

0 W 0 L/) 4 Ut IL J 0.i -

z -x -_) UJ0 U) 0- U F-J CZ 0u)t a E W j VU cr .UJ truW Uv'tcUJ,. 0 0. ) U O )-- Fw ~ ~~~~ 2 Il E z V, vt CZ 4 = UJ I 0 F . > 4.4L <

U.

I-

U)U-a'LU LUI- I-44

LU - -< Vt VI'rww>- tu 0.V;.- x Y F CL

Xz LLU0 ~

40 LL Zz - 2-- OLU 0 Ut_

I- La. CZ U_ .-IZ Ut~ 4

*> 0. 0 I Z x l CY .

0 VI Uct OU . 10. >U.

Ut-ZU. 0.

4 0LULU = -I-ILa UF4F- UJL 22-C,

U J - " z O L U 4 4 - Z0 V) - *wIU04 U) V)0C

LU Zw O. LUVI 0. ) *>

>- LLJ X ZILU L Z <0

0. I- 0. 1 UX FGZo

I!z0P-

U

Ua.

(0Nl 0 0 NC' N' NOD II v V t Z P

0.U,

0LU (NX I

0 30- II_41( < S L <ix a LU

V)'-

0.En

uj40.

0

0

wI-4L0

00,m-

z0I-4ZNO

I.-In, --

U

tUma0,~ l

I0

uwot W ~t(l.--IJ

J IV,' VI '

'I30U.

0C)

IO.J nU

O-30.

m0J 1

< :3

-J Itl- IIin

uj L Ut I-

_J u)0x

Page 127: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LLu.

0Lu

-4-JLuJn,

CS

0 C'co CD 00 00w 0

o Zu 0

D U) 0'-Z - WI-

o W ccz n 110 LuJ LU4u-4,~z

w.J

4 CY

0. * LLu * 2O.U ) * I- U )3 U)

-C

02Ul N

Lu (N~ ~tU) I u

3Z(N LUJ

I.-4 40W O0Lu Ul

U)2

III

Z0

I.A. I--X 0--4Cz i:

IU.II

0."r U)

U1lI'

Z'011 114OCl

I<00CZLu

8

.0

It

z.00'-w -xU_ lx

LL

41=I. i ..

I-)C ll

iJIn

ZZco11CDU) 0

c(NI-3:z0N 0.

0

I--in

0)(0CD0)a)

0

a

z00I..

lWI-Xo-4U

4-4U )_ cLL

IIZln

IcoI)'rN

UJ3t

Luz0

11 0.S O0LUW)

* --* 0LuJUz4-jco

wUJzLJ

0z4

O U)

J 4 40M I- Z

0 Lu 0I.O U)

CZ~000 *.. N(NC *

~! LuLu U) U) U)4 Z

CZ L 0. UAJ w O C

U 0 0.

L)C,

000000000. . . . . . . . .

u,.C l . . .

N000000Z-_ IX",O O O O O-J . . . .. ......... . .mco

OzLu

C.J4z0I-zLuZz0I.)

i

OlU1tn

00)D

. . .I

co00

V 0 m tO (O uvI -C . '0 *0It 0 0

00() r-rIV. M I(D ·I

0 v0) (DCD C-

In IV0 - 0 ..C . .

CD0a

0 co Co 0

(O M tr tt IVC D *

Cl(OI~

I =z . I-I .- eCD

mD I0.-j -j -j-J

c o I co u 04 I O X C) >- V- 4J Z(NO 0IXNN"Wx..J04ZI.-0I Q Q ZI It) Ot Z E -

CL

Lu

4a.

co

0..

Lur-oo

I-

W40CZ4Z

(V)

JOWo WIn

-wrv, )..

udz0z0

InLU

zLC

4.-

Page 128: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LL

LUJ

I.4-iLUI

000000000

O 0I I

LUWC-,Z-J

mCD0LUzLai

0z

CDCDO 4n

I -UJ LU

n0. 0. *C O O *

.. *0 *

0t r- cN * ) a) 0 0-

* =) IT n IVt * f CD _" CD Dn 0C4NOW~~~~~~~~~~OO~N tNO z

N0

03)illq, rz '("r- t.IC

0co-J

(A

LJ^ C Iz 1'z00.x0m-S

z0

zLUN> XzCU

0LNID(DN

0oN O

0-0

N0

N4 O ) t0X0-O* N -

IVr-Oc

OWO

co0

0~C4

N

. .

1=+

00C'O OO O880. _, .,i~

00+0~CD r'.OC(D

O -1 (DO "CD0 -r-

0 0- C'2O'.

**

0' *00 <

Cy I'- o'r I-aw r- 0 F <

'CoN 08 -UL (8

o -rc, Io o - tqo l .* .54) C'- _ * 0.

I Zl_ I

* -%

cr

C"IN, I-

U 01x z - >-

N 4 L f l O I C - -c n ico IN CYtI 0 I Cl J (A 1-OOINN N IJOZ

0Q () t) Z ~~I -IOt

* U)0

.4-iL .

0.

Mi O

LA IxIa-Cw

U)U,OWU3 -0

CD

0o L

0 (CD

- v IY eD .O0

o00 00 0 0'0 Q

54 c

_~ F) O-

0+00 00W

- LO '. (~ , _0 0n5_-Cv. 0)

0qtC,,".ONW( t

- C -MI 0 ,

c',

0

0'-

z0

I.-ZNOa I-=r U

U. WJ

YLU U0O 0

,-' -j

l.4a Sn-jO

W.OlAJ W I-- U

LU L

.4I--4C0

z

N0CI'

co r.t'--X NXo. .U,C

Z

zI-,

--C0U

*

I-

***

r

Lu.C M

0LUJ

w

3lYLU4LUn(n

tn LU

,- O

0. 0. CL -J

. w LLZZ-,U o4.-vI/100

0.Ww --

> U.i . -d 0 z

, W U Z* -'IO 11o w4e X W FJ

x LU,

I-nn,SWllC

i/)l--LU

IaLUW

O uu0o.VI-43 a0.WLUU30.u

I-SnL

LU

z -0 LU

z _0_n 4U) -L

U I. > I

-jz <0. LZSn Z

0

N00

co tOCD L-_~ O? N

IIL . ,

0. OC'rCX IL)

. .I:

-j

LU

4x--S

IELtrr0x CZ z

W n -0.S U I--W U

I--aI-I- C0Q -- -C1-1-40>LLUOCI

I-FLu

z0I..0-0

I-

a.00C0

-C o

AJ I.LULSI-...I1

.- IW .. i'- 44W

I LUa

Z Cm-0I0u Z Z CN

.m-.j

-ZZD C.)

* LU UC-,IW J- z

., l5.-U~ 0-zLU LUL-U LiLJ X Z

. n

, . . _

-

Page 129: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

t O

_- : l

-CN 0_N Y N

v0

0. .

CD LIO -01.- *v C'0* r- .10 NCW - CNr_ .0M

N CNl 0 00I I I

0l 0 0 W ic0N 0 ( N to

(n Cn. - D CN1 r- NCIA st- N NC' C. . . . . .

0 L) N In O -0000000 U

0 IT toi c0F00

r-m n cn. . . .

N 0 a

) - IlX.

(D - ( D-000000. I I I 000000

O r am re Cm r-1 NW " ND NC'), 0'- W' ('I-- M -0

- O - 0 0_L . oo c -tq X

I0 0z N I t cn

N O a I N N I0e400uZ Iu

LL

U-0

wCZ

00

t r'* - 0 0* It to* f-CD

N NW

z

-Jco (N0

3 ZZ-V> Zr-

0 -NZ - .< 0n m

U) -JX~ 4 4o0 < < _

I U. 9-F_ a w . 0iI- 0. * Z< 0 * W* Z

w

X - Z

_ < -

L .d 9.4J 0U) I- C Z C-W WW .j 0.M ljI- 0 w z = C0 a0.

00.

z0UC.

z0zCLVU0

000000000

00

0 - --

inO-0 WD-

tolD CD0 0

, ,, C*i- eSIT N0 Oto'- .cO

(N00

1- N 0 U1 t U7LO I - O In00'-(0Uv - .b.u) O-totND O*'- -_ 0:-4-(.4O. 0 . - 0 - '

'-0!n I

O Q0It inn r-

0. .

I0CD -co 0 .tq'2-0

D Cn -

.N 0

(N ' 0C t-

__

IZN

< m -J~I __C1o o xm -JouC.0

to t

zU'Enl

O000

000

**

0+0 401 I0 U.

* 0. ZIz U

Z * 0* W * I.U-0m

I U.

m w 2 0.0-ZI 3 4O W O W

9- ChI XJ

co )- U2ICito

0. W4x4 0.L Z ZI Wu

'Z WO=aW J~ s Wo > m 0.x z

w0

0-O 0-M -00 C"N U1 D_ C"

z09-4Z NO

U. Ulst Jumm

Clw 00

J w

W cj cr

CU

Zui

zI--0

I-wI:

(n

U,

Cy*I* N.* - m

u P

u I-z <0 WIZ 0U) <

I-JIz 4

0. tU) Z4r CC ,A

. .

0

'rt--J

U,.4

!0.

9CL

< 0: zWn 6-Oauj ) 9-90.I-

- -0D 1) ̂

9 -- 40.D 0 1> 0 0r>

inUC. Z

I Iu

~ZI uI a_ 00.(N = .J

0.0.~ 0.z 0o N4Uie1W )- L<i 1 -

09U)

.

Page 130: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0

w~~~~~~~~~~LLJ< 0000000.. . . . . I . .

CN NqO~ C)d0 0

VI- N O mm 0U* _m0 N0 * t - N t*0 O-C *Fr *r--nF

I- ED IS t- N N O -

lJI - . -VS

0 00

_~ --r- C' V iLO inmq Ir- O N C.t c'q-t.Cy) (a v 41

0 .9 .I

(D Mq -

mON t-N1 CX) O00 o 0

* ITOm ~ci..,-

CN CN0 0

0 0:} O ILO N 0 1 w

t- F(D - N4 -§- CNI 0 t U 0 O-- CY0,CicO(D'0 Om_j . .- . z- t C.0co

CJ

010+0C0

0t

080+

,O 0CDCD

,4.,-

U)

zzZLuJ

(N O0.

.J

.4z0z> z0Z

oN4 l n C31 O I4 Cf N lOIuoo ZIcIO I

--I_m

X V) "I z Z. >

.4 -. 4

I--0

z.

d C0W a-z Ix

Z W0U 0

_Z

0.W (A

n,In cf

I-**

.. *

z0I--4 ZNO

U. LL

m

WOC0

(InS

ii0

J o

C I

U~JO ~UJF-.JOjUW

wz0z0uil

z

InU)

LU

IAII-

C

.4~oA-(A

Page 131: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LU

o

0.

0 000 0Z II

NO ~0 ~ - * g0 ZZ 0 0z Z z8z 0'- - -0 0 '- I- -oNo t-0 U) tn w 8 8 (A in )o,-, t ,- 0 ( 01)1 0 0 Q C 1n U) ( 1) 01* -- t-t)U t-tflIN *) _, t-,) ,_ tN )· ' . " _ CY .

U mM* ) z. Z 0 uZ 0Z - -l * cP M aw tjU- n C ')'

4 C) Z00 - 4

t J4 1 0cnra Z4 o I-

I _ 0~J0 Zi n uJ c< ,_, LU U 4LJ U 4LU1.- ';! * I-^ .^~J l * I ILW UJ - -, >_ .

LU -Z w Zsr 0 o = in o1- U- t~t 0. ,- Uo Q -t 0 0.U) __ -. J U)__ -- J LUJ

UJ CN UL Z 0 U - Z 4 0 XZ 0. e t O I a LU C-- 0 uj C- x t-t0 LU 0 U) t --t I- 0 (- O 0tt LU ZI z _Z =_ (1 U Z - E U -Lt - 4 4 LU 110' '1)~ Q 4Q' UI 1 u~ Z l QU Q I Om < - z I -M

- 0I-LU~~~~~0U)Itn-i-- *Lu L0I-LUx0U)I-I- * U

u) CI Q<MWLULUZa 0XMWULULUZ CuCZLa. UI m ) r 0 L U Q ) C m )r LUU)b W Z CI- I) w 0. LUXZ U) LU 0.4Z> LU Z I-LZ 4 M<X1 U 4ILLu 4 t)lUtIwL U U<o " Dw aI-0Q>0. -0QIC Q > - z -J E)0. 4. 0.

4 LU. iU)

Page 132: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LIC

0LUJ

--J

CY

818, . . o_m= _,- _-m-

**

U) a

-J X

* -LUj

4* I.* U

Inco

U)

10

oo0 O 8C

, .--

i u II n II II

zzz'- I-'

.U U

UL CZ II.LL LL I

'-I-- -. .J .

u. ix 0

ZZZZz z 2 z0000U U U

4 - <

U. L IL U.

I-- ~ --0. 0. 0.0.In u) u) )

0CY v U C

O~~

OI N II # # II

I-~~

>zzzzzzzCZ iL L 1L U U 11, - F- F- F- I F- F

zzzzzzz0000000II 0.0.0.cL 00.1111111140000000U)

0 ID

8 CY)

0OO),- d

II

z00ZX

2 lz

U.

-4 LU-

U).CD IEn)

II

Ul-z00-X U

J .4

U7-NLU-.mCZ

U)

M00 ')(N I-I -O-CK t 1U

Z Z0 0"'. '-Ir - II--i z 1-i zLU LUQz z0 011 0. 11 0.I1 II

40 40

*

UJ

z4-J

m

II-

0LUJIx

'- X a70 -

LU .

UJ

X-

I-

uZ_) LULU ZX I .4a-

I--' U· Q

z

tuO.* *OI-UX "1 '-I..0,

LU LU-J Q.-0

0 OO a.

000000

CZtu

Z j .z 0

In J_-4 0I* U)I-

* Z

*z 00.0U-J.4z0I,-

z> 1z0U

O

1t- IV vlql0 0 000o Q 000

ID 0 1- U CNCD 0 _ CN

0000000e .. . . . . , . . . . . . . , .I I

In coLO (a

_ N4*O co

Vt *C 3

If)

0000 * 0, . . . V ,

o0+00 D rO

co c.o tl"JCNI Cco tD U1co N MtCDCN C'C"._ -

,- v.1- 0)co

N' c 0DN CN Nc0 CCNM C) -

00r.CO(NU,

t"tlya~coi

tr- ICZ -I N.

C. O I-Z IE< im c 0.

I 4 '_ 400 ICN NN ( CD IJO4Z

0I--

0Uf)

LU

40.

zoCZNO

,1.m_ U

D CJ

J.=.CL LU.j (A(UyQ O0' I

-J o'O "' IWn ) D

J "o4.-

ZOZ

C.LUz0z0

zLUS0.t).4

,^0uji

z

IL)I-

.

C)CY

I-

(N0.

0I-C

4,.U.)lQ6Vfil

Page 133: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

ZzUAV).-

(420 000

08

*

_W

:!

Z < 00Z 4Z ZZ I- LLO D

.CL Z :X 0. ZIC Z LCI * 0I- * W W-v W- * (/)1-

U) CZ0Ir W0CD.3 4U- -W OW

-4 wI W <r C x X ~U-I-J D aWzz-I SLZWIW>Dt

F U- 0>a40 1- >Zo

LL.

U.

0

W

I-

--n,'J

* -* 0W,z-m4.<

0.

m w0L I--co W

4 Z

W * Of

W 0.-- U CZ 0I --W0I) F-

4 =1 tL CL

W Z m cxZ O CLwL.i-~

OCWZZ-w IZ -J .4 0

z(n mU) 0

U, XnI--

* Z* W* Z0

0.

00

000000000

000000. . . . . .

00

O coO. "

0

C.- IV.(C00000 *o0

... . .IC . '.)

-j4z0>10

> I- Zz0U,

to0

coO00

0 0 -. .

M00o 80o 8T .(00 .4 .cv

M0

C0 c (0 *0)

c C ) (~C - .i

(Dac N0.NN0

(N(NCC,"-~

I01

z 2 IIr m --I 4'-__

0O mU wn(N U O I' .. J OIN(NCN D o-JoOxZ"I I004uuzxxuuzzz

0

o0)0+oa

U,)coI070c]

i

*

4

0I--

0.Z

I* N.D

* en F

X J o<10. 0

W -C Z-I 00F

W CZ W Ix. . -Z W -IJ < I- C.)I t WW W

Z U. L 1 0U U -4-IW W 0.W W U- -4M W 3Oa XZ30.0.40:E C

L

W

40. 00 D

- Cy 0t mOa

(0D 0(NO

o~ o1 00o0c*'0ooo0

004t- . .7P.CNOCD'-U, 0)

z

<ZN o

w W

* U

0r ~J

uq aj(n 4

-JoWO IV) U} :)4 -W I-

W *u

Wz0z0

W

zW

(-.J,

U.IL

*

(No0CCN-0

..U)

I-U)

***L

IC

ILX u. I-n

UA. 0.0CI

CN00(q-

IL -U!-0)_O c c-_- a 1

I

0. E ° IO I U x

mCZ

.JI

0U-

LU

0.

i

U

0

W n

I-0(AI--:E W U

LL

o) O I >0.0.- 0114 0.M MW l0 01>

Page 134: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

w w m

o 0 In00- U )r- 0) ' 0ei IV co tl-co IC 0l) IV0 C) O IntO o o o o o-o n 0 o-

. . . . . . . . . . . .I

ULUf)

000000.. .. . . .

. 00Z-J . .0

to

-J

U)

zwzLZ0na.0UJ

UL

C-

0 0 0 0. .. .T

N ITZ0I =) ) U)ZMI

00 (0'*CNQ 00

o (O

.4C4

, C"0 CDN

(00 0(0*,Cl) cn

CItO C D

0o . CN

b001*cz tq O cO CD400

I 4 o co m w 1 I -. CyI t CD I cJO Q oU :

0

0D0+00)1r-c'J

0ICnIl)

(O

a)cM

**CD C0) *

0 I0+ I 3Cl 4 0 0

0) I-- ' ~.

>- gO~~~-

1 ~ 4s I U.I N 0 O.I Un0 1 I1 X

I Z 0.i 2'- O. I

0Ul* ,--

* II

* I-

O U)

4 I'. I : tI- 4I

,_ I- 0a. _ -J

wI 3- 0 U

W1 U.>- 4Ul 0

C4U)

w

a.LU.

0w

I--4-jLUn,,

II

wxl

* I-

* 0

LUC)

z-J4,0

'-0

Z0

r< o

I

- 0NdOw YuJ aJ a.40

4-La 0

W I-UJ

CK a:

ujy

0),,-tDo * -o* .6* 00

-la.

-I:

t,Ulaz0zU)

V)

***

(O0i-wUln

_OWl---azw-Z.

I- nO>.

I--U.0O.

°* I

~0a.' 0L wJ -J Z O., cr0 U

I

Q) 1-.ul -w w zc> *a.

"_, c aZ Utw I 0. 3 In.4 -jz

U

(O-j0004-J.U.

I0O.IIAI

.4I-I-<V)n

ina.I-0

In-.JEnUl'

CII

,<

Lu* I-* -.* j

aL.U)

X-JU.

1wwC Iu4Ul

-.-Zz01-zIAJ

)>0O.

I-U)

0a

OI--QU)z0

.aI-a.0

I-1

IQna.0C,n.

.. .. ZuO0w U

wC~C

LI-Ul. o

< Ul.

: )IU)n

I I-

Ul Z Dci-Z OUl~

Page 135: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000. . . . . . . . .

*~~~~~ w(0

0000000f'C'

000. . .

,I I- .CY) w c)0) (')0)

0'1. 't0.,, C.''-

00!0

0OO Ln

0 0I +

00O 0o . C.O- O-

c M - I t .

0)0

o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~t

toI.In

C',¢3

0'00

(0 N C' - CN

N N C n 0)r, O O UOO

000000 .0'' ' c M. . . . . . M . C'- .

(DO OI N N UUUZIIU

__

I O I'r< m-mX -i0-U<2 1-I 4'-"-

1--01-wu

*

CL-00.z

***

4 W

,- I

.,

. uW

..j .< er X 0. )1z LL

4 0-,Z ¢ ICW -

o W3 0.1-U)

0

.CZ J0.

0 ZZ4zOCZ~- U0.( J

wr X Z00CC .-'0. 1 -Cl uz W ~J

7u7 ->U.fW)< XZ. Ct 0O C70C101-)

0

-U)Wj

CZ Ct

IL 0.

Ct

J

CC _7 0

1 W 0WCL

0 CZ>,- - erC:3 3 CZeOO0.I

. IA.

I-

I--,4-4W.CZ,

I,Wfa-

Mq M0 0

O0i i°~8

0N In- a

_- 1

y. 0.

- o

'..1 0)_ - 0

..

00I-c0)_cn 0,

- )(; ..

· I--

* 0UL

z4-j

C,

ZZ-W CZ

'-r

_1Iz -* 0C W) j4

U)--* z* IL)* z

z0ZrsOI.-4ZNO

U LU

I z-J Cl)00 0I U - -4 1-L 0

..I C .)

JO (4 D

Z UL

LU CZZ 0zO W

Z Zz F-0K W

IW CY

zn Z0. W

C.CLx00

-JZ-z01-z

W N> 1z00)

CY,00i'-0

_cn 0)0- ')00I- OIL . ,

MC. O

0 X

U Ubc")OC'4I

I0.

-Jaco

lU

U

I-C..J

U)0OrILn-j

O WU)0.

NC.)

4t ZW *0I *- E -FCC O

.4 L CJ..~er C a4U4 0.

Z 0.uZIaZO

Page 136: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000. . . . . . . . .

N 0)

4~ 0 )'. .. . . C. ... 0... 000. t000000.*04

n,

0002-J

(AI-

* Z* U* Z0a

200.JAt

z01-ztU N O

z00

01nt-

07)00 0 Cl. . .

(DO)

Z;8'-~Ci

0+ O0 00§In L *C 'I

00+O

t- C -

( 0 IV0 MWm-. f .I~ ,=

00'~ +0w N P. ,f I-

C O) (D CD t-

IT4 Y 0) eqcr- ci m (' a(0 0 0 * 't IVO c'

~-. I--

N. O I-LU 0 )Z 2N. >

C4V o mmQw~

I O N " N D Ij O ZO0)Z :I--o~~~~ I-

*

4

I I-Dtlz

,_

S . .-J~ 00IL >ZZ

- 4Oo outL - -J

) " I tuLuI-I-03CZ0.441-I 0t-Zo) -2 LuX 3 f lO'-'O

OWWXtnZ

*

I-in-J

ULuI4r

**

00

,- C)"--.. 0)

.

cN00'-,-0)

,001-- 0)

trZt:

(" -IL 0. o

20.

-jI .LIu

LuIU)4L'ra.

LuCZ

Lu

u~ zn t ! 0 L u U ) -4a. U ) I -.2 Lu 0

-0.1-CZ= U.'- I--0(-(- 0.>tu L u 4Z

0 0Q 1 >s

ci00N,'

ITC,

0I,

0M LU Lu__ ox sr X VIL.. cia.

NOO-LU Lu -C z x utu * o

4 zIA *-0-

Lu u t.2-CZ

t I O -NI - Dea. 0 IU)~ 0.-C

Lu ZLuC,

LuJCD4a.

CD

0N.oo

LuI--.40

u.U.

0u

-J.Jiun,

* 0Cz0

I-S ZNO

YlU. Lu..JU)O04 Ua_0

UJ -iW CD

.I4-4 L--JO-Lu Lu

Lu

z4-J4CD

CDuz z0z4u)U)4Cx

t302LJFz00LO

If,00¢.

,.I.Lu

Lu I-z t0 LuIz _0_. F

Lr Luu I

-jz <a. U) z4 u

C,

Page 137: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000

000000 .04. . . . . . . . .r .000000 I0t. . .. I . C13 - M

-r0 0_.j . .

0m-J

-n

* Z* w* Z0

o.

z0-Jz0I--zLU04

0C)

CD CNCN ()a-4w 0,t- CN0000 0* . . .C . ,

000. .0 00

0.2

". Tan.@r1-an

00 0o oD

I' · .I I

0

a~0rb rto a) t-

IT 0 a- * rc' O ciC,-

(D a)*CD

C0C)'-

I

Ccoc=C--Z bN

D 0 m LU t1N o I -J

I-O n NN S IX0 Q Q e Z: II Q Us I-

* 0* Ul

0 *0 -+

2- I- LUI

2-4CI L* a.F - LUz

anan

* LU , Q- . a,* xa C,

*L u 0 V- an J0. ULL ZZI*1 1- s

4 Z !ZD a.L ro LU'-

C- - x sa.)>- 0W > U.

.J 4 s 1 C)' 10. s Io Z-n O. usWLU W IsZ IL Dn 4

UU -n^LU.o uanJ X.

OW W c s 30F 00. EQ

*

anI--J

an

* I* N.* _ D

11.0,

InLO

LUJ

0Cr

0

40' O'.

a-

IL

IL

Lai

cI-4tY

CD Ln0 0

N00NA uL a)

. .

* 0z0-NO 0s- _

Q )U. LUinJ0U)

a 0

4a' m-J o

LU I

-W I--J LU LU

LU

z

4-j40CZLzLUj

0z

in4x

CLUJ1ZI-

0rjC

C,

ILLU

xLUIz

N

N OO

- a, 01.01

40

-a- CO Im-u taI> Jr .m

CN0t.,-0a

- 0X . .

CN0C,,--0a

_- az c00LL. .

0. 0

O CC ~'rUrJ Ur

rz <0 LUI

0I I-

Z _an 4rL:UJLU I

z <LU C

LUan z4 LUJ

[1

0

0LUan

4

I-J

uLUJ

-LUO 4c 0. 0Wa n _oX a t-

W ) > s

a-a

0. 0.1- a- I- 40.0 L m

X

'nrz U)3 3 3 fr F-~IM I

..

Cy

-n

I-tn

I--LU

.jZ

E

a W-I I, LUL LU

30.3 0

LU

Za n: 3-oz41--*O.

IMOCZ 0

>-

uiLU-J CLI-J-I-00 .0 cMOA IA

Page 138: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000

IV CN D DD .0 -

C0 10 D0'-f,q' CY l0 *LU .q= -

z

4

-Jet4CDM IT C DZ Z (0 D· - In .D .

·

00 . ClZ -J .*i-

4 0J

* Z* LU* Z

0J Q~~~~~~a

0

0I coM C)I_ 0

ox Ln01.13

0 n

C. -

C,v c .- v Ln

*,i C (

C' C Dn o(N O O I c-I N NIc.)C )C .Z I I

1 0 0" 0\oCD.c|o o M * v .0

c r-

*w Lr

§ 0CS IV r

'-0Un (D

r-OO0a 00

Go

00to 0.q q..

- . .CD'

co00o

0 .0OC0 .in M D

. _ _

CD- .

'~I ACYZI x.X = m"I I-oU 0 X-z z -.>-

I w 0.e t - <

I 4 X '-'-4

I--0JO Z: I-<

CqztDtD

oo0 0

88

d

LLIA.

0LU

I.-4-jLU

10 In N

0000000 00

0000000-0 c - O. . . . . . . . . . . ,.

I

o*~ ~ 0

0I ( IT* I- D 0 - : C"* :3 M 0 nos-* ' -}O UnO-U LO U1Lf

11 .~ 4 _1 CtJ C~.*~.CLU ~.

X

Z I

I' ILa..zZ _ 'CD-3 J

Z LL

~OZ* 0 * LU.X a0LU LU

-3 4W LUCYI ~J0

L Z L4LU- LL. O-J ZUx

lU X Z0> 0

xCD3

IUJQ C4

L-3IL 3

N 3 i0 3LU I

UJn_ <n

C4 -I Uw CZCz I-

LU Z CD o 0

I-

U)0.0I-LUWCD

z0I-.

t0.0

I-

LUJa.0C,O.

z-.CD

>.

LUzLUJ

0znC)

*Z*7]E

CD-

_ CZ LO

0

.J-

zLUz00.20U.-jz

ItzLu Cl 0z0(J

00

CN D ; Ico t9- Cl0 *vOi

O 0, -f

.- i. O C-C. *CN

co0 o0 inax) o q-

(2 0I.

0~01sn 0 0 . * I rLn u: Cq7 O

M 0 r_ O..in

ID 0

CN4 T ZI 0 xN "c" w Iu.uzxxuuC.

o0+

co0

C.] 000.9*-C',inU10-(0 co IT

. CD0-LO F F-I-ID

Z C CD-XC.) 0 I'-z z -xC c 0.

-m , n 4

0< :

toU,

0

U.ILLu

-4-JLa.d

_.CM

zzI-

X

C=)33

LU.

z0I-4ZNO

tC>~UU) 00.r .dL

Jo.OIU CDCD~

-UJLULU

zw w

0 i0LjUa- LCD

4A

-j.4z0I-zz0USZ7,tu

1-

Page 139: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0

00 00ooooooo- , oo o N00 On 0 0 clo~0 0 0 OCN0oomoomovow 00O00O0404 -- 000000

~~~~o0~~~~~~~~0 0zI . I0 0- (O a Q ( a O 01- OZ ZZ 0 8 Z ZZ 4Z 0 O: Q 0

CY- 1 * - -4 w . " 0 e * cn 1 0 O 0 z 0

U..W * cN N

m CZ (A W 4r U.

a 0= zwz =coCD Qn Z

sn~~~ ~~ aN IT (n- 00 Z 4- 0 ILw 3 1--3CU' 0 N

C. - 3 _ _

* W -Z u HZ~~~~~W -v 2 CN0 ofI cr t oinr~~~o ~ U: CD zouozzz H O Cl 0 __ C, l , U) -U.J l J

WI- 3 * - 3 W Z O Z O

Z co LL. O U. z qx 0 -

O 0 0 3 I -Z z WW (N W 0 L- .. JC §- w L .J w O

4 IX - U W Z Z - U CZ C C.) W Z C C) ,,o u) < w z V = < lU _ U. z .- 0 If

CO o -'--6. W-O 'F-' .-- W. W < LaJ (N wU < 0 U. Z 40 )MLL <W<

2 2~~~~~~ CZ :) X Iu w Z & : w as ww er s uj ) w 0. Ui V) WL 0 tY W 0. WL U. 1 0> a.a 0 Lno - C- > 0. CVO Ion I- 1 >-U, I -Z w 0 < > 4 w x z Im 4i-<L> wXZ c0 4Z .4 w C c r j I u a < u W < W o -:w K Ca > o. y FC . z -C Ff > . Y O -.- *W 00..ni a. uW LU 0. COCOW0 CLUCL 0 L L0 .OC .C > 0L0O 0C > CC

C-WIU.>1( I04-L4 -C

Page 140: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

QIIQiIO 0 0IV ooa

a) . La. .--O--O

80r-0 o 0 o

o o

UH n If a

Z Z00U) 0 "6I- u. I--unt ~Y _

M P )-I -J X._Lu I..U.C nI.-

* w uL j* n0. 0.* I- U) U)

Ut)

U)

Z Z Z Z00001. P .

'-I- I-U. U. U. U

Z Z

I--I--0O 0

t U4 U. U.I- I- I-I- I-I.-

-J -J -- -J J0. 0. C. 0. L I(a in U) U) U) u

co _ o In

17 0 O t oq0 in O 00o0 0 0 000M- -- 0O. . . . . . .0000000

u.u.

LI-4aJ.4I-4-i

LI

a

0000too0n oo-

a D NH U a IHI

z~z- .4 4 4

U. U U."O -9 -

UO1- I -I_LL -. 1 -i

0. 0. 0.I ) U U )

U)

m)

2222'-II- I-

U. U. U. U

-c ---

-- I-J- l

0. a.0.0.CU) U) U) U)

Z Z0 0_ _I-I-

U. U.

I-I--- J0. 0.U) U)

I !.O

V)/Z)

( to oO ~ ~ ~ ( DN1' U) O I N~ ' UnO IC'4 10 0 2 1 1 10 0 0 2 1 0N # O I N N U N O O I I U II. Iu U -U -Z -- I- 3 I I-. I) I- Z I- I- l' _ a

4ZZZZZZZZ *ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ ZZZZZZZZZ00000000 000000000

400000000 4000000000I- I-Q Q QQ QQ uJQ Q Q Q Qc) U) u )

0.U)33-j

I-uJ011

I U)Q0. .0 ~

- I-

I , U e0. ILIz 2M 0tL _-0. -

33 -. -I J

0 0

- 0

0000000. . . . . .

to In-0040001 I(B N O

<0 c U I

NU Cs 1~z CO r-

0 -- o0U (0 1 .inI I I

aIn nC D 0 0 0IU oB C U)Z Z-1..N

4 0in .14~2

U)I-

* Z* Wu

Z* z0M.200

LU-i

z

00I-

In rvI I

o0

inr-I Io 0oIT N

000N - IVto. . ..0oV ( Nt

CI)01-~

0

CI)

C4 N In I 00 ZISmouu211

(a0l

IAIUJ

40

*

zot-t

I-2z

NO.4

IL. Lu

:DJ Ux-JU)wor,.

00U )~riWAO,U,,,d

Lu I--

-ioLu Lu

Luz02

0

U)

Lu,..z

U)4C

0

LU

2I..

I-

0

U

I-34M

cli0.LuU)

clI

0440.-

LuU)U)

0000

O~o

00+

.. . .t In 0cd~

z0t- In at °

0rI- -s

0Cl' in a- It t o

* I 0In N

LuJ0t. .00 I I O-

40.,-J-J-J-Nt. U t |

I-

0 CZU cc M atr z_

Page 141: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C2 0 0(t0 (D 0 8 Ur- 0(co co LO

r- 0 0 o!884N 8 D(p0

0.

* Z* LU* zL UJ

CL

- 4 0.Xz

0. _ _0. M -

_- I---

a. a 0.oL * V o * LL 0.I b- * tz 0

Q I

uj Q. ui

0. '-D 0.>- zL

0. 0 . > U .0 0 t0. M LL O

-10 LL W JLLU) LU LL LU

z*- L C

0. 0 .X>- L oU

0. I- 0.0 a0.J Q

*

U)-

LlUnOf0.

I* *%* I - 0 .0* LL IID Fz z zLU ZZ Z*-L" LU U4 -

4 I u - - -

U CL_3 000>

0 LU L L L UOJ I CZ Z Q: z0. U LU

: oW 39 3 0.~eL 33--I 0 0 ULLL I- 0. 0. -ui CZ Xff Lm

o. _j U W Lu 0- 0 LL QW *L 0

CDU,)

LU

40.

OZ Qu) o00

-0~1

§

* O

zaI.-ZO

Q WN 0

.t ~JMU

-IcOW a 0r J

zm-J

U OLJ LUJ

zn

.L. .,z

L

0U)4

Page 142: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0

(O

N

U.u0

Wz~~~~~z

o~~~~~~uI-J

Ci CZ Z <

Z ~ ~.~ ~o zz VIV 1 I

in J> b

VIUJ~~~~~~~~LWo fz

-J I - C C e -V W 0 u i

VJ0 VI Z V a X X

ZL LLI lL:):a n VI Vcrz z .n 4 uW 44 LU Z X ) Z L *.. LL u .

I- 04 1- 04 1Dz -x iz o uz e

Page 143: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

inCl 0

0q +

CLw w

(0cn C

0

.+OI- I-lowowo_ a1OI I t.

.4 1C-

CN C}

CI0 4a(N w 0OO I c.t-

Uj c-

w- CYax Ico

Q- lC F-

:E a-20 I-=

1 - O J I-wU)L- U )1. 0I

0.

z-Z0

qr oi-iF.-J C)

-Ja 0n LU< rv

Ua O4-LJ WI--w Q

wz0z0UJw

zw0.U)

cn

I

0CNi0

0

Page 144: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

o~~~lw 0C +

ix e- wITu. 4< 0Ixu w L 0

co

@ ZD O~(0(0~-lI-I-- co

(D0 UJ ) in(00WIW

r-oozz~ 0+0<< t~~(

sw W UJ~.0 u Xw

vI a

cx

C 4 U,

0r flu.ZI -o

. .w

LU

I -m I

W ,F- IOI- I-44WI.-

cx 4-W

(fi x O

N~(0

wja,4.

z0I-4N-z

~wII4tr o-wx e4-jm :E

WI-WccxI 4IV LU<r I

Page 145: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

x0 Z

eqI w elJwz -j >OZOD 0

LCN fLLO

0 ZO~ N"

U1 D C)t- N1 -

. 0

.- to 0m O C"I00100,

- - az) 0 t T

C1 07 l t- Ln-

0 co co U1 Cl . . . . . .

0 - N N t-O IT N -Olm _

V 0 - t- O N-Il0,0--00O. . . . . . . . .

0000,(0MO ts '-4

0EN L >0. Z 0OW 0 4

~O~Z~~ 0 ~0 1 0 U. V ) U a00~0 0

~x..JI> .Z0 0.Z 0'-:

LUJ

x~ >Z 1-4rXI-J> D 'z xo0z JX

LzOQ (flQJ

0

z *- .. ..< unw z (nt0 a <I-CZ0 J0 U. I- U

CrO X

-0.. 0

et

miNco S4 CW)

0)r,OOOOOmnO000000000000 0

LnM a}

c 0 0( 0 0O Un00r1

Utl 10000--00. . .C-- T ?

~000~0~0 0 N r C)I'0 O c (C 0 0 0cD- It001L 0-o 40s ooInoN N0OPI t

! OIV0C.'i0LO0

0t

0N 010(00, N ,

0(00-0

UZ0 ~ 0r~OO XN a) ( 8o t O O - w-00-0 -0"0 . . . . . . . .(D00044 -N -Cvr r-

a a] YC a Y tY a: a axxx xxxxxx

1I "I "I m a 1 I. m "I m m000000000-j -j -j -j --- -j -

i 0U01 0 N: OO OZI IX .1( 04

( 0 1 0)I-001-

0 0 0 -00 r'O+ In I 0 0400000

00 0 v 0. 4 D . ..~04

l4.' I

O O00 +O N.[t~

* t-

010'.sr rzN O UZo OO*§Qo+

0 O 41* ,

-J0(0

n F-J

ILO.(0z-a _3

0.4V I-

0. colILLJL: J ZI . tu

0,(D

C,

'Z0I-

N

.ou Z(OW

CZ -

In-JU.O

U) I IL

* c c a

I0

z0 0(Nz I>z

ul u0 0aZ I

_ U.UZ .4f 0:

v I S

0 -Vrt0 00 00 C) -00000'-0.0.'.-

(N

0 0t flt,0 O

'0(00'04

JIO

-J-

U. U.z >> -J u a r

Page 146: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

- NI I(< 3 3 >

'.W W Z

X m.0. U

I L

0 (A X LL i >inz Lz >3 1 ZIx tr 0 00. 0. m

> I I > aa~C3 I0u rZ u (DLL J . W t- NnI 3 > 2 ULZ J-0

Z O Q0. 0. 0. 0 Z)0 0

W 0 00)

ILCNJ :E Q ae.. _

3O Z 'u0eL N Jit C.) U N-C1W J L > M -

3 0 I-(00.0. ) 1U O)0

_ tr

aa .... ..4 (0W I U )ix 0 4(I)IL I- C.

V M - 0(0t- z O Ow a-Vo WM0V 0 (0

Or-q0)(0DO tC 0D 0 0 It -,

_ 000 00 w-

m I I r- '- w

_- c14 o -oNwos

LO PF co ). . . .In0) -

0.00~

0000~ o )n um -08 °°oC, . .

0) N - C)N In -

0) sr N

'-0- OO-'0('() f

- n ) r-0) r-

IC IT CY

00(N to ,(D r- N' t) C)0 mM O7 .r q

OL2'000('2000+O D O (0(')o0o. . .6 - LO

_ Cl" N I 0+1I0~~'-q~vme

0 ICD )D O 0 1

. . o. 00(C,) 00+f-cCr- 0C2(

oz C1 CY coCD 0i

OQ OOOLL'O 0000o 000 000 +0

-0 O O tN4 c N r- c

(o

s 0 0°

0-0,. .(0' tD O

mmmmmmmmmm-00000000000000000000

I I

) ( 04D O 0 CNsr (001(1C 10.'O ( I csNN 0IOU41 0 0O 2 1Z I 0 1 - I -

(0

.40.

n 0a0000000+ VLOm

N -

LO 00( q('2 0Ucl In IV

Cn· . .CS o

N'4

o a0 IL)00o~0 0)(0 CO - COnf0 0 C 0

O t C 6 . C. .: I.OT mOO0~

0 0' ('

'0(008 0 0: C; LO 6

N0)Oms0

0N

Z

I- L

, 4-z:::3-

1.1

..J ZI)

W (

UJO

3/Oj U

U) -JWO WIIZ O3S tYCZ IL

zCL)

W CZU.

0 Q 0o oa

-O z

tn-0c o0 C,) (+ 00!

(~00000os O

-I0

en I..JV -I

0.

CZ Z iL.. J >

(00)

o0)

0 0ON

0 0)0cc 0 00, . .sr O ",'i* s'

I, -J L

o :)

100 U

- >x

c o U% 0

4 CZ V

L Z u >-jJ a o-

Page 147: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

OW m o

C-In 0 C('ICM-02 (DOWM

'-CN 0

00o

Ct-

N4 Ln t-V na) r-

Ln (O 0· . .0D-002'-cn-o

(7 . 0

000I° ° c~C' 0 t- . . . . .I 0 0 n U1 F NI W 7 N _ I

M Mq

0(NO ,

0 0',-000'

co

NIWto

NC - C I CDO W t t Ito 07mc 0 IV t- +wowt-OOmmto o er r

* 0C CL7-0 O00O

~00~00('mIr-".10D000 M' 9- 0'- 0 IncD In - V _

N C2 CDM7 '2(

LUcCC ' 2 (N t t0 C',

0I- nCDC'201C-000NM - 1:-h0 0- Mr C

:) . . . . . . . . .Ct (N CD- 0 000

CD 02 0 02 In UnO m -

-0s

C C x CC CCOX X

LJ11 1"I11 1

CCm I srI"o~CIU2l N~co O ITCD 1 0 0 xZ

CCCC C :IIIIJ1 "J .. J 1

0 0 0 0 O 1 1 1

0 2 JJJ J

00§O0

OCN

t ,-

.. o§oLn0LfC4·It

o'0CNO'O, .Cl .N T I Sr

I 0 0

1. .co 0 -C N 4C, IerW

ix'I_11-J0

-cO CD-, ' U

-'to 0 0. I

U 0 I t z

x N U I -JC' DOI V V I-ZLC

C0 0 0 o r- C4 + Ln 1g 7 + 0 LfCD6

o CD ('

Lf3 'J 3 c'2.0 _ 00 0 -'-+ O 2 '-0

r CNN

o> Ino V lO 0-

+ N - N

) 0U C r- N

0 C +0 n ~ 000

)n O O t- c N) + t i+ 0 oo ..z-OCDCIe.00u20-0 0 ° i l

Ol

-i 8 I .J .JLL

0 08o-8

C. , 0 I- I- C

Z L. LL Z >LLLL > LUJ a > iU..L 0

tnCD

Lu

40.

N -

CD VI >e< N J OJ I ILL

NIn z

En U < UJ N u 00 I I1O

WD-IVCO

02 ('2

0200

('2In· .

Z 0 0

ai or- lrInztLO U)< - (DZ . .

0 O0-- O0~( J -Z U

N z0N

U.-'CC

LUJ~ 4

C

u(I-sj Ul.,co4-

I"--.IJ C.

0,

ta u4-JU7

20 0.

z 0.CC 3

CL 3U7 cC45 CL

-(N

VI -zN N O

IZDXU7 < _LLJ3 3 E>C C

I-VI V Z

U < co L3 3 < >

> CLr U

O.CO

VI-

V7 LL 1- U

Page 148: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

N -in 00 · 0 c

000

C0 · .0)-0)ca OC: O C

I - Cr-O N - wD

.00)0) 'D ( ILoO -m- owIt-0) P)- 0 CD

.4'-- M- rflZ-W l0 CO 0 t- O

(D06IV'CD I q, n00t.4orCY) CI T

00000000000000

zZ , 000>0

O (aU80+000)00 , 0N

. 0

I

',e 0 o~)(D 0,L +

- N a)!It 0CD!

O O O00 (0

.9 . ."CD (O Ootno N _ _ I 007 re

0CDD0000000)

0000000)c')

LUa W - 0 N .4 m V 0r- V -I- 0C-'

I-0.r-mmw4U))'- .4- ~(Ix l Wm

b000)D ( o. .N = NO

|n t V .

0000

000 -t- r- O D .4

CD

0

LOIol

C3 - - CO

.00.i4 (N 0) (Na (O'-.(.4 cII

0 0 . . .00D0)--0UL It CN 0) (N0 0) C') CD co0 ) ) N a)

Cl

0 C0O O0NO t-CD.4s00 ... 0

0...00 0 0 N4O- N0 Il8io

0 -O W0 CDOOr-.("Oq~ 00)

0 0O0(N

~J J LL

-0000000000 N .wwwwwwwwww 0 0.1-X-JJJJJJJJJ J4 L 0C-j

0) CN.4 U)0 C'2IOWi-CI-Z0m 00ZN tn(ox( l0l SZL L: ZW= N O O N N N D O Z L U Z w >OX U U; U- ) Zr I I ) - ~- 0. L > i LU O <

CDtD

0

0.

zI-U0 CLWLLJ LL EIuI Wl WZ

2 X . z

1 UX L >UO'x0

tr O!f-i U3mw>rr-zX0.0~XZ(n 0 co usJ3 :E 1 >

00.)Z

U) .4 ZC > 3 >Uc J Z

C 0 >1- '--IJi'o00.UZu)LflZWu>3 >3.Jzcx:o r tL )0.0

-J

z0

0

w

I-

Z0

N.W -.4~z

UJ gn 0

U W

~0* wtl- -

z 0U) ).4- CY

J ) 3W- 00 CZI-J0

LUenU)o .4Z 00 UU) 3

W CD

0.:

Un

0 -w -lz 4,,I '

Z

z00

0

.4 U)

Ix0 .4I- CZ0 jV) U- 0

Page 149: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

t N - Vb tM 1 tO

M O I 0 tN tLwo .s . . - o

- ) tw N ChtD !s N N0 ~o-o

r-0i ~

(N CD Cn

· , -- 07(N CD Cn

0 _. '

10 tl Cq)

W -0.-ct, . . .M 'no0,N )'Ne ioc IC4 ,CIO

( - U7 u7 - ) o0 CD N D

00w'. W0C')

Q 00 +

030uW 0

50?

00'-U)0 0 +O -Il C;-

I

0 OOC

oooooooo6 8 8 00.· 0., 00 .+

000000000 I 0 0aC O

P ~ ~ ~ ~ q, I t~~ 0q

i 1 It CY) t- C)Z - Ul I N 0

>0 O O NZ . . . .

.. 0 ILO

Wtfcc C) IV

-I-'-('1(Noc0 ("40-I-U7

cI I I0I1 1

x -° -° -Em a m

..W c J24IAJ

U0 rco N Nv IV 0 0UIX0 U

CD 0C2O C - Y r

!- CS0.'· N.')0'-00

-- O 0 O 0O-0 C'--000 00-401 C

0 0 (N V' C' 0) CC') (CNO)IA

c ) C0

' C IIJJJ.J .-J .J000.J -J -i0 O O immm2W co

.I I .3 XX -j -j -- j0 0 0 02 x2W0WCD0-j -j -- j

I-JW t 0 14

x I N N 1 oZ IIO04

8 O~ rvI CD0

I- N -gV Iq

co vo0(0 Onu

LO01)o0CDC')

O I ON0 0 N

0'-L0'-(0 , 0 C') 0? Cl

- 8Q m t- Ws oo + oC I T r- (D78 ~o CD N I

@ O0- 0X 0l W qIT cn>

I

(D O l n _LDO O U0 C)

IV ( C) q)(a) .0)- 0 I7 Nq q ItI ta° I

-j02W

U. 0.

0.-j0. UI

W 1-W CZzI- 0. W

'-0C N

W W

_1 M

I'1J U.

m02 Uco 1"'

m m. 0-0. 3

< Wn

> J W CZ 4

W40.

-j4z0

IVI 0.

l.L J W Z

39 V) M >3 30. x u

Ix UULL.. Z t

.30

U CLZ,LX ~Z3- 0 Ix -

0.. a :EZZ 0.Ww »Q Uo 02 JZ

.CO O0. -

I.-I '

QI U, LL W

J U,

C 0 -C

CZ0 .. .- U

Z0

N

.- zLL-

-Jo

V) W

-J 3wUo 2

k-(n U) WI.-.- IU U.<~ 3

F-

O LUZo .0

I-W I

> 2zUo &X0. 34

J

Page 150: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0 -

OL0

L 0 O t- O 0C) oo O C O O(C0000-C

0 0C'-cl)Cl) Cl)

0')0)VIC))('n N

0 N4 N OIID O~0C'g 0N

o0

Z I00.4J iz

Z O0. I> )Z a moU',

m0l

LO(0IC'._)

t aI ICN U,) 00 oN."ot(0.0w

C') CO(DWr- IV~0c') CV co

. . . .0W00-0 O C)

-C)C' C')

0coI--000 00. . . .-O 0

C v ' 0- 00 0 0

Nr-c NN t Vt VCN 0Q 0 ) -, 0 . . . -

I- N N

(8

0

~IN. §v o8T r-

m-tO0~

0. . .C' CN I-

0 f- 0

0) C')

O - o

C - Il_ n t-

Cl) I

W O. . . . N. N. N N. 0.

Im N1 n Um O3 I- zD1

(-4O-OI-N4N-4-4-4O-LU-0000000000ZI:ro IcII IIZI1

(D0 0-I DO QO It + (D -C4 O - -

o

00 O0 N c+ Uo IIl-(0 0 4 --OIt ID, C')

0o (CD -~00 wor0*~(DO O-(''01000 .... Co~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~M oL

al cl)

O 0 a)+ IC L

0l) O! o ;I .

O UzOLD0

0 +* N00C

02

_1I

,, i.- .0E.Ja.-44 0tn Ic .CZ Z LQ LU >

xX~Z

('a >x I >

1--ZU - - 0U. IA.

0

(,~OZI0>

U..0 0ZC U U

JJUOx IL IL >

_ LL

mL-U)3

_JIxa.-4

A.LU)3ofC-4

X Z

e X .U W 0

ZZhi->X,4ZWW0uwZ'Ir0

04N-zi Q

LL--J U

nujW01,b 4

LU J )<UXW X0~ I- 4 CX :E

U Ct

n rUJ0 U.U)U)4-- 0 CYx Ir LL.

_-C.,WAJ U.z >z U.O U)3U) CeCZ CL

W _~

z U.WU U)a. 34 a.

I.J

I--C7

I--U)

(00CD-(0 aCNIn IV NCO -0)

C') C')coi

00)t0 0) (0 m t- IV

I-

i LL10:o o tha

Q. 0 .I0-I

U. Z W>J LLn4

0

..

LU ¢3ceO U)UL

U)4

0 -4I- U

Page 151: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0000000000000000

O 0)(I N CDIT CD CO

'N (D0

_ 0

z0Z N CD N> 0 0 0rz .000u,

C.' 0

co Cy0 C M1 OCJCN

U)

-000.=.

cxLU

(0 C0 00U)0

4110I Uf) 0

400a0 : r-O-r

00000 00

00U)to)U* *C/ * Ut U0 0 '. IL) 1- 1-

11 - -N 4 (s(

OOC'2(O n o0034

I'2N

O(4)0( t-

00-0 -M0@-_ 2(1

I 1-ZD ~,t tM

W0 000)(00 00 O -0)C. . . .W_--C -X

ON'O OOO

." 1 I I 111 0000000i i mi mi m m mmJ JJ JJ JJ

xCD O

IT W CZ ICIlX 04 CN c OI ZZmuU

0(n0000O 0 0 0

0112 (12W(00)C..

WOO,0+

WOCDIc0 0

','- O OD" O+CY) o. t

1, _

WOO0 0+

N ' -* (D* 0+0

c C+ 4

N C N

U) U U)

L t FM X- 0 - 0 -1 O 11 C;(0W. .)

01O1200 (4

§ CY -_(0CN 4((

. . . .~ 1

T M

l-00cO(D ; ;

O OM L co

. . .~ .~ 1

0 - 0) -N

o ,,.0--0~I

O N In)O -CD0 -88o ~O'.-

cx

0 0 m1I I F.

J J .n ILLL a. m -

-jI-- l' wOruwn- - t.

0. > 2.-

to U O - Xx < -C o: cnI- 0 U1 -Y 3 coZ LL L. Z Lu >Lu > .J LU 0

0Co

LuC'.40.

ZOUX

Z>-)

0000zz t) L ZUt >

10wO0*C., 0>z7. C ZLu ZC.) CM Z

(D LuC O - >

LL w0

0.

a C 0. LIZ mr a >Ub W O LAI.

-iLL O-JU xz

zo

I-

N-z cxcU..F-

1C -UJ I.U

U aLuIJ 4U)Lu

4rc >

U.('l-UJ C:

Z Z

O 0.

4- C!

(n or

a. cxc > _

UJ O0L.

zS

NC'(O'cOn,. UI J

zX

~Z3 030U

04(0

C,M c0

0

4 Ucxo 4-x 0 -4f C -JWU. LL U C

Page 152: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

Oc,, a0 m00co 0o -c~0-CD0

.4r - cN(D: O 60

t.0~* t,-O00.~0LDO)D

q t co In o(D 04 2 0 +

. ., 4- ( Cc r -

O0000000000 OOOOOO6 11OO

-j.4z0I-zW

z0Cj

. .

W

I-

I-

UIx(J

O00)

UmC",

N N I

0 o r z

,o a tc 0 00 C(D In

. ..n OIV

0 z I.ZZ.Z.-WE VE W

'-000)0*'v O O I Cl0 - -'I CY0 a)I -coa at 04 t O4 00 O 0r-(N('-(NCt)C.'2 C"

0r-0

0 0 .0'-0

0 T 4 If) 0(0 N 0) 0 0 '-'3 00 0' O-ON - 0 01- .~ . .

a= tr c = tr crc N. "I "I I IX Ji J _J J i _J ~0000000

_j J J _J J _J

.4(LI

U)m CN V)

N N Nx:1o o e Z I

0O. . .n

0 N!

ZZZZZZ- Z- Z-

U U) 0 U) u0 i0 u- Mn p

(D eM v N co-(0 002 4- 0+ I r- n 01000 n . . . .

I o 07 04 -Un I. .

r- 4OO it,0 + . .R 7. .0 0I On LU U U

M a) 04 coIT r-

O ao8 o0o

· . .

_ o0C

r- - t- Q 00(NC'IN 0 +0O0 O D 0 N 0 0

C")J CD (N (0C2t

:I C II "I J J

z 2O

D O < Q

ICD I o w.

: I I I to m a 0 0 0~ ~

0J-o_j

"fI-

0.

V).4 <

w Z I IZ U.LI.0. WU> .j

0f..

00-Za .W(n I >NWWOU. X < Z< Z I U)

CL Z

X Un >UJX > Z> 3 wX~ZZw3O>Z3C.

0w

Wz

WUJ OzzC->

zC

N-ZnO

JC)U.I--LU

W.4 (A

It '-Z CY

C)

.-J 0 wo wlad uj.4 ~ LI.

WjI-- N.j C.) A4

W W Fujzwa U

w Wl-zO Odz z0

tn 0.LIx >-)

Uz(Ia 0.0. C-

Cy

((0 Z(L U WjU Ix ' >Ir L Z

c r Iu2Z

O02>IC) '1 UJZ

z .. .. ..0 LU x 0C0 4(A . I-C-)

a) mM .-t- ino-6 600

Or- r- r-r-

·. . n0-

.-O.

I- O 'nN 0

co

0

O 2

zW >uJ 04

Page 153: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

i n r- 00C -0 c oOOCO'OO0D O OcD O0 0OOOOO0OmwcOO

. . . . . . . . . . .OO cO r No D0D O CD O t 0 N U0O- D r (C co oII0 0 t--r- OO

N lw VI v

CD C r

0 t-0-0

co

O

OC r- 0

CD ( N C'

("'n0, n I I CUU 0D tOco(D rC -CD -· .

c D Un 0I I cn

_on (D to@ tD anw

19-m(0'-

0? 8mo o+ 00-

O0+ u

0

CN IO Q +(.D(D 0 C D..CD (c F IVMtn ac) t a

!

CD - 03 M N 0 V

04- 0 (0 0D 0 0O c o O 0O-O co, O O

N NCD0 LO0

Om c 0 00,,.,,,,,. .O . . . . .

0- Ow- ONO(N (C' tC'tC'b1c

co

W .- m . N .

x -j-j j -j -j j -j -j .1

'- 00 0 00 0

CDC CDC CDC CDCCDC

-J0co

CD-

0. o

0.-J40U

w I- OWaZ U.o. tu >

( CD -O n(o t,- ¢yC1 M3 L{3

N CNt

0I~(0 t0 0D0000, ' ITZ

O0Qo _ n

. . .! .~ C0 CD 14'0. 00~O (N

O D [- rl8 LOl tt

0 . (.

7 (D

O t- to tQT n (D000

CD0I -J .

m~

DJ~0 2 U

01-3

CZ Q Z !.U. Z U >,j JU

00CD

0-o

W

0

0- >ZN 3

-J 2 c

0 OZ~00ZNNNO> 0 >a tU ZrN N N < <

0

-J D N0

zoomZ -? oC>,

o0~cZ CD OUI- I I

I- oo

3 01 Cz n in 00 v

zOZI-

NCZ

UCflV)

<C LW cr( I-- Ncn 4

WO

Ui.- >..a aW

0uJUJU.

Z C

Z00) .o

Z' I

IuAJ ZcxZ I0. ILU 0

4 cz

NWNO=m

a ZU. 4 Zrs N I. Z

4. 4 Z< -c oZZ 0

0.4 sIX 0. ZI-W j0.WLX x

ZZZO.x 0.Z

20

(n . U c

Page 154: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0 O N4 IV N (t- 1- r-~0e~(

8 On 0o oinqoO 8 0 _8000 0D N lL0

u, 0 C)

000'-C t) '0 0-C; c -

0) r-t-OOw OCNOC')0 0) QO OmoD 0 0 00

0 V M00 000 0 CY) 0* *0 0.

in, ( gO O : O-C aat- f- ltn N4 -') Cl CN -

It, M0 1(

o e0D co00 0 000ooe N O00 0 0 0 O0 0 0 C) C'. .. . .. . .c. . -f' - -

Cl r- -: N

F- Z-0z I

00-LU

1-,. .

tr 00

.- 'NU-

:)0I 4N

U)OX" OE

Fi-j

I

O.00mo0 t' - O7 Ln INc.I (N I (DO O'_ . C, _

Nl N wD00 ..~ ..

0L 00 · . .0-0.-

:'00- 10 0

C0-C')

I aX - t- IV U1 N - U1 momo 0 C1

-i-04I-s1 o 0 MO N w Oo , MNr

000000000· . .~ , , o . .- - - - . - - -j U.

(N ' U)0OIJ OI(N N(N tD0: 00Z 11 =

-j0 40.M 1-I x o wU1- I-

0 D 0- L0 + O (DI )-O+0000 C ) ( 0O t- O-V- -

0) 0 ( N

O 1£1 0 D O (00 0 0 -r-O+ 00-C )000000*q1 (N qt

0+ IT _'1F -c 4

0.00N0- * .10 I C')X t n M c

(N

coII-m 1 0

0 ON.w. > a. . u» rs. 1 0.F-C t 1 3C4 00Z 0 . - ilZ J fiU)t 4Ix U )

erLU

4.

X Z

3 V Z3 -:> I U)

0 ZN 0. T w

I-LI)OZ3100In3 E1 0 1 U

000000000000

000000000000

-j4zIn

z0I-

N- Z

-OU.F--jU

ILU

ITC) :E

"-LUU)WwoLOcr4 -Lu- 3

(J0 W U :>C3Z C0 ULUI

z CD0 3-4 1U)

LU Z> 0Z N0.

U) N

0Z ZWjx 0.

Lu LU>uL. ()Z3330

Z Z X Zi0 2 >UC.) X Zrs N LL O4 ZNNLU0aZ0

Z X fO >0 2ZXLUNUIZ4N30

.4 U o.WI )

U0 4- Ix O-V) U.f -

Page 155: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

tn

000000'-00000048o ~ o 6666664t- U: Nt,'- :: (N to N-- 0 t 0 0 0 0CC4D009 .~ . . .~ 90 0 0 0 0 4q 00 0

N (D 14Q D . N~ 1

cZ C Z -jO O n1-0 4 0oo<~~~~ Xt' U N 0

Z (N CD (N0 XZ e0 0U. D z W > N U - > Z . . .CYZ 000 I -I C 0 CI-LI (. U

LUI

ae

0000cgoom . . .=x00 0

CIII000Ix O OCO4

1- ' 1

0 (Naz cr 2 O no IcI..~xxxJm m m

tn=CN 0 0u I

t'--I-· 0 ,

000CDCm0040(D O ax

0

ID) CD -

U: (D-C'0 0 C4

I t coeq0010- CY)N

N CD

0 (0r-)O0-

0 -r-ooco

0 0 0( 0 0) O CO C'~ O0000 L0 0 ( 0 U C'

r- - -C NC') C) - '-~~o 000~00_

:I I.~ .J _J0001010100 0 0_J ..J _J

I~ I- I 2 z IIIJ J.CCC10.1

Io tT 4C4C4(DCm

U I U)O UIIC'4Z I I N(Dc

t-

ctLUA40.

-I0

L Z- X Zas s 2 LLCY Cf x >F- Ir -I i 1u 0-i : z )

- U Zc n x x Dlt I -3 >1I3 0

88+o8 00-. ID -.0i

I-C + 04 00 10rl 0 +

t' O :(03) O tl tl OI a

'04oC40'-. .0 ' N N ,O C~ D..

., co

·o .It C4 - N I

_ I

cN

n r- tDr- vWU tD N

·N 0 0CE - N~4 C3i

r VCV2Q t'

· 0 0V0

X LU ZcD >

(D O sn

IDt' O Ot' +ce o rs004

co 00 +00 'It'n c,U1 CN0

Zz- z

en L0

Ut

LU

CZ Ix -14 4FQ LUJO F

('1-

U)-J

L.UCZ (fU -I

O *CI

zo 4No lA.!-

C,3)I-Z CtL :r'r'V0. 0U) I4. 'r

0Ct

X -C(nO30

zLU

0

-Ooo o10'- () (N 0)'-10'-C CD

0 0 N000'C~C Cl

'-1O04'-4100 04IV Cf)C-)IT(D rn I- co

CO a)N 0 N4T C',Il

o co V)

.. 0 0O- 8 n f 0

N0_00~C00~i

co~

M IL-:300.E3

LL LLZWA>> iJLU O4

0m~JZJoZ~

az ......C tLU~ EnZ =0 <-tn Li. -

-j= 0I =

2 m00~J -JO N.- L-0. CD

m mt

a.JJ

t- z u I_t- .Uw

Page 156: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

1r-

LUa4L

0

LUJo.

w

ZO --0

3) t

-J O

U.:2U.

UUz w

0 Uz

LUUJ D

> CY:

uz 24i 0

r ,.J ) e

>:J OwO s

ZU CL

0 U

4_ - 0

LU Q U

zr v

a:

I XZO S uJLJ I>

ZM uJ

Z

~00 u (D UJLU X J >a U. 0 0

X- J. Z

I x ·U u o o

--0. -io: 0 0.Z0 Dx W 2 *Zz: .

X Oa: w JI0Z0 z

w

04 uLU U.

000000000000006 6 6 6 6 O

CY

. C. . C. . . .0000000,.,..,'

-Jz0I--zUJ

z0U

000000000000

N C14O (DON N14 O O

VV O+0 00.1 . " D

O - 1s 0 ) ICD,0to (DC 0+0 MI J 0 O-co 0t O +

0 (IC13 0 N 0O~,00 Q

o..... MCYO aV cn o N M

(N ('3(00(0( (0M to a)F

. . . .

M03('O (4UIn IV a

O OO OO OO D ao

O O O O O N00

w w0000 00'-0wcn0000 00 10

wUJ U, V

1- (~0C) 000000 0 9

0 00000 1- (~N

C',

'-0000000004~~~~

cI IO 0 0 u20 mmmmmmmmmu20 J J J0J

(D c C00 t0-o 0 D-c.

M

O N t t

0 " O)(Dr- N. C,

7eNJ (D0G 0l

Q N -0000e~00t- ( 4o 0 N 0 Oc. . .O -D aa- N t

0 N7 coc (DcO N O

O - 0 0,,**CO 0tXhDG

0-T o iw-

00. .0OO NO, .0t n

!

cr o aNN 000000 +c*ON

0 D0) C14

N~ N

( N -Vt-

ICD40+(N00

a r '-001 0

· .w oL

(nv

-j0

J , V)

i JI- J. I- - 0.:- o- 0.t

I ~J J u.0 0m

,m D 2~J X13.- co

0. > >-LJ 0. 34000-e144crnZ1- 1-Z W>...JCLU04z

Page 157: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

4 1 Z

I-0 ZC CN 04 I 0

0 (000-0

o-D61 L~04

0 2to O 0o0 IZ 0 r-

Wu x n -(0L 3 >,IL OZ 4 3310 -

zoI-

N- Z

.U.

-t t

.J wUa UJ

01C 4w

in CF

WI- l-40 01

w3(Nla I-l

z0 1UOz

Z) 0wtr I

zwn 0

cr

N 0

iWtY U.

ZwZ0U

(N Z0(0-i l

2 0 CY Z(0wU- 0cc0 a

0O0J O004Z0

z0 O OwZ , O >OO(J

w

Z 0(0(0W O00

( 000 I-tr 00 = zooO o

0.... .

4 LI

cc0 4LI- CZ I-tnO ~

OI I

m0m0·..- 4.4

w0:i1

cn 'I, 4 W

U-

LI)03

U) I 0

N 0 2rl- co Ln4 '-(0TOOO -0

mN 0

0000r-00)

C ITN 0 0t- co 111v - w

O o o o c; O M, cn

C44IVN tn

I

00 0 U 0

.4LO tO

4't-LO +

0 O-

0 N 000000 0 O r- 0 0 ) 0 0 0. . . . . . .00000,00 0(O o o o n o a (n IV u

4 40,0,

: I I I00000*1 11"i j mj mmI0J0J0J0J

n, CZ of*"I I- "I

1000m CD m-J .d J

OOO030303-4-4-4n

m(O0

Z4 I I , mU0U N x x U U

00+O(N(00InO-i

O(0'-(0

0 C'2O .

00~03-

(0 0,O6 -: O - NwD tn

I

0 r-03(00 ( 00UcO N1 CD CY

0 0 - 00 0-O - ON.0...o co "a(O t 0N

'6 ., .~ .OT n

!R C

'I-~~ 0 0 Z

03 I- > -II ,- 0

1r-

wco

0.

- Or LO

0,LO 0l 0 0(N 0 cn ()

0,0cs O V rsn

N ) 0

0 0

- n

o r-n0 WN

r-

O D

qOO0. . .

It t- Mn1DD

00 Ln 000000 + Cto In -

0 0. 0 (6 W 0 t- UZ) O D

m Or-00)00

~0,0 O- FCN 0

·. . . 0w On X C D

_ N4OmO

Page 158: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

00000080

CVo

.- I I

O m6 tq" t0n m. . .-

Iq ur-_00(6C4 C;U,,

.N

0 U, Cn

-r -. . .00(0

.I J J.J1C0 0 0, q.s )

1ImmI000J

02 § 00I,00ao-

Ol

- §r'. '- O00 oq "r- O

. . . o

· n .CD . CD(D 0

- o0o r uCl CV

er un r- -cD CO CD t-

. . . .0cV CV

*: I I I00000: z CO O C C-IJ-IJJJ

ICDO

1 O N N 1 OZxIIJCUD

) {D N r- + 0M0

000~iDo o (a+ 0 C(3 IC CY -CD 0 0 r (D

0 O0 C-+ 0 Dc 0

co00D .....

~0~I--oco Co..CDO-0 _- I-C

CD C:

L

0.

0O ZCN X JUI - >0 ZZO 30< 30 u

s XZ0.0. ~M - UU) 0. z >3 , I ZJ

3CL0

0.= z U

Ul 3 0. >3 O Z3 0 03JI I m

z0I-

ZC O. I-

F0

..U)U)O er. 4-J

uw WM)'CZ4- §tY c-

LUJz0z0(A

L

zLU0.4

00-0

. . .

00-6 0

' 6

Z0

Z (W I I

0 c 0Q D q>0U2Zr

LUm.. . .

(Joa)

~o00

c I- CD C(

l ofua7 3:

co e

LU s

CDC4 LUJ I.ccCDm l LfIL

0(N

0014

U)331Cl)

33-j

a

IX

U)

.. .. ..1/)u'~

nn o0 4c 0 -JCL C- Q

I'rIJ-Ja CD U

..Jut0.

-J4jL0.-FL< .Vl

i- -I IX

0.-J4II--zLU

0. - 30 U 0 0 :Ecr < CZ tr I-ZCLL L Z w >> JL u <

Page 159: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

APPENDIX B

Absorption SectionSimulation

Page 160: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0

VC'C

(N U)Z 3

- u Q X I s t Z~~~~~L n f

IU u 3 >

X t ~ ZZX * ~~> a oN.

- 4 :sr 3 0 i: X0 00 z' 0 0 U)

> Z: W X - a(IZD J~ 3. = I o l I 3>: > 0 *1 O 0 . >

> Is 04 0. -1 I O O -:rO e 0 e n z

_ a s o a ILL. i, 3 I C -) CZ 3 CC ' * 3 . C NM ' Ul1 CO IL) U C u.3M

0Xm (N(0C')C') - 30L) :- .1 0 to 00.> O UI m '1(4 0 z o C-C V a q ZO00 I. " a.I '.O.DJ O-u)I U) 11 1 0oJ0.4 0.N. * 0. (Nn 00>--.J 0CJ I () N N

N .. . .O = :C O1 C' I C4a

: ' tL O I > it 0. 0 1I u O > :> 39 J t Q >- zE Y Ix(0 u U) 0 O a 3 O N . - 0.: 0 n -C U -i in t O.o nXIDX Z-WDz 0W Y O u n) I com1-) 0 WIEX39I 1 U. (0U)0 <e4(00 (fx 0 0 =23 3 .J(U.1 0. 7 00* 4LLJ (1) u.WrI F Q<ZwFCD zuf Il J a)..J I0'c~4--0. .J 0.WW000.J<0CNMJ 10.F 0 r o JW .i * J = m < I <' t0WI-1z X0=C00c . O. 0.

w I 0. tL C .S z i Ut Y xL Y 0. CL 0W w W 3 U 0 U0 0 c O Ix C 0 0 0 0a oeC z n CY -. o. o o CL. L .Z- I- .J .J .J J0.0.--^-'U U) U. m0 m0 m

0> 0

Zm'O~

~00 3 Z U)>- O0U )0.. J43 .J1N 0 zCZ e4 0 .1 U )UCL-V C' N -

I o0a

> >o-> 3 *N-N »0C ' ) * * WU. 0 (N O Ot-.Y > C tl m 3 1 M '2 00.1- W aW

00 0. 0.En UI 1 1.- U)000. E U I -

w 0U) ww J 0C I 00

U.LL.0 I.4 0w m

m0U)Ipq

O:N

ONIN.

(N

"Im -

CZZ0

Im CL

O C I I >Wn 0 O Q

C) O - 04 vuJ 040

a: w C4o 0 0 in,; " I Q-- En >1W I- ; '1O-

w c.Z 0 0U J0) - 0.

-wZ~ 0

Page 161: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

m

.4

0.9-.4

0 ~ ~ ~ ~ 0

z3cs~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~sCa) ~ *~f --- > 0. bt n aoo..... ... .... ....

OW 4 .. .o .

CO . - ....... ...

.40 IL)~ . 0 .. ·

O . . . . .. . . . C.) .3... .. .> . . .CZ I. . ex

SW U. .) .. . . IL>U U . U .... .J _ .Zu** ** ** - *uZ w o * **I m * ~ _j >

l *zzC (A * - - - * 0 -004co· Z ZO ~ · '- 0 . U

a -1 * * -Z * - -i. *) *Z3U -ow *mm * * - -. . . .~ 0 .49- 9-9-9- - . W.W W .t IWO ZOww- 0 . Z 10 0 W WW>wr= zW . 4 .-

e O ) *f l 4 0.0 0 U a *-- U m wn -9 *0z * . * WUI O 3 -W0 * OZW m > * * -I " a *0 1 33IIU.3 Q O LLZA m ZO0.0

Z 0 1LL U 0 . -

3 i~ ~ ~~n I WAW 0 O 0J *J Z Z I9-** _ .Wcz0 Z0

ZO

Ix LU ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4t, i|. -~

z ) QSWF C x 0* Z OF tJ U1AJlttJ U C LlZ0II1Jz

Page 162: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

X I

0 0 -J

LuL) - I

o r ua0 (0 WU) .J (NUI

I-3

) > C1

tY X' 0

US1n U) 0

aci 0 C >

Lu >o X'- 04-UI 0 ux~- I en

O CON Z

Z> x-J UJa z 0 L

I- 3 Z3 3o I 0. 0. I0

{L ) -J a. JICt 0 3 3 tn

U-IL

0LU

I-

-JLuc.c

-J0ILU)3 U)= 30 CZ

U) 0.

.J IL. U U)10 3 3

3 m CCC 0. GI J >

.J0-J VI

LL 3

3U CLU) CL >1- 0 0Lu UL. U) IL.-J 3 7Z 3 IX 3iB

IX *. m

Y X-

-J -C F (A

m Jco -IUCl I

* -*

~0Uz-JCI

LuI0z

:K ..Jz <

CY En0 I--Lu X( LuZ -U) 3 LU

-J 0 ] 0U*-J ,om tuZ U)~U) 00 ~)4 -J

- I IL.01 -J

ZU) -J

0. m.J cI OUL Lu

O LU >U) 0

- 0 0 M M

000

a o8§8 D Nc

0 8--00 N00*0 * .OO O'-4C* 0*C')

aZ4.. 0 80°880 ~1 ~0 C,0 .80 Z ,Z- I z- * *:r'~ 0 * O t

I-< _ * tZ J-1 Im t W) - N N~ 0* z(n c

* Z* 7* Z

0mz0c)-J4z0I-.z> xz0U

UI I

00n r- -0 U 0(D D o

N 0 (D

4-0-

0+0 *' -'-0)0)

()01'cN0

0 l-

000* (L C)1rv '

-- II

u - c mo O I-z z %>-

0 0OI (D0I0*0 0 0()Z 1I t0 0 4 1t L u 1

I-

z"'Z00

vUO W7 U)

< I JI V'U-J U'OJ U) Lur

L~ I I-

LU~0z 0

zsF z-W U'

LJu

z z

Ok: Z- 0Lu I-II-LuZ ZZ z

o. z

U) 4 IL.0I

Page 163: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

-4'-4

-J4

cr0Z (D LU C4qT inoxl

z

ZZ ZZC00 <ZZZZZZZZZa: in in u) U) u) n u) i. . . . . . . . .

a - - - -4-- --

Li.

La0.

N CtNV O O x_ I O- Oi 0

x(D0ZCOON - N D IZ I u O

ul

0.

LU

a-

z0I-

LL ui

eU)W

U LU4' I.-

OU-) ,<l-

JJ0.

-J O.0 <

u w QLI, t UX'4 -- IU C >LUItU C CL

UJz0

z0

U)

LU

zS 11

0.

Cl:a-400.M

I--LUU)

(A

zLuz00.m00

a0

0 n 3ZwLA

> 0. wo

V)I--LLIU)

z0I--0.0

Page 164: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C~0

XXXXxl11XX1IU)U > >

> - >Vx Vx

x-i x x XX X: > > >tL I a - 1

£S 0> - >Wn V >

x:E m >- > -J 3i > > E

xxx£x llz>-i > -Ifl> >

ri)<000O N -NX O O O-J z : > >s Y. a

£XXXxJz £ I :EY

040 N-CX O O O

zx

0-"XO Xz ..i 0,..

a X-

xzX -i10U).j ..4

010 . X '.

:XJ.j t..a Uxx-i

CU)3

- - 0-00-----XOO 0XXXXXXJ >8-8 0mD>-JZx--8880-i M M > -i > oj bx >L Ij > _

0o >-j

xx x zx > _ > x > > x > Y x: X > I > J > - > _ M m >

0-xO "01,-.A U)0 a -4

xOv nY U)J Z(3 _4

Y VU)

: C C4- N000000tX°X°X°X°X ONN N --:-0-0xI-000.Iaw>XX>Y

ixX X I) U) U) U) U) I U)U ) :) U) U U U) I: U U) U) U) U).IOw>XIVwY

C,

U

t

> >M L

O-0.>u) I> CL>0.

xX £ I>S

-Illx > ->a. m x0

F..4a

z0I.-

LU LU

0 )u, w

LU

~I C.I

04-LU V0>.

.j LU MLU M M

X X rl) Z :E - -> *j X..- I > CL CL I I

xI->Lu Io..0

8S888-ix xx xX X XX1 >0aI X 2 (

LUz0z0

tLzLUi

U)4

aWM

z.UzI-

vZ0vC.)

I-o0)z00.0

x0 z0 ..J X

U)W

Page 165: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

IL

IL

0

PI-

-jLLU

co M In IT co cota a a moa a O

0m N UN 0 0 UZ - c N0) - NOf r- r- - O

. . . . . . . .

ICoo0IU~o~O~C0'C

000000000*1.CCOO 09000co 00000*0 -tD **) *C o C.,

Uz

a ~ ~ a o- - *~ 1t rU- - 1£1t- m

V)> W 0 0 o ooo

U} _1(y K0 .*0 .~ V ts 3 3 - v L * C 4*---J Z 000000000- NN CD ~ s4~-..W O')

4 0inm<a V...L O4 4 .- .

W CnDO * Z30 * Ur * z0

0.z0U-iJ

4z01-zLU

z0U

) 11 010 IT

000~mOm

I CDac) Aaa a! Co JnD'qCDOCDtoC o aD.p-.q.CD

M00

8 §CXoC0 0

. .c - OIT * C . .

0a)00

;-I n tn0 'C-

-I

0ao

0N -0 -L - .I0Ci

i-'

-- II :)

z . I-001I -c

U0 M.* j OJ .. Jx 4 -'- 4co O LU V) ZDI

0

***

.4h-

C~

!-0.Zz

I"IJ* '*%* -4:* UI-

-JL. )

CI I--

IAI tL JII ) 'L U4O uOl

V) 0.I40. -LU

U. U.

aOLUWLL3 0. 0.1- U) (

I--JI..

CM

_10-i0v)

0z

ZiiLII--(AcoCD

(D - - N0 0000+ I I I I

N -: CD ' ( C C N) ) 0> *l if) t D)-a' * cD 11-0) '

- od CD 0 co eI (A Cl _ N CT N 0 C - -YV *" q C.) CO . ...

*C 00 N · 0C' ' ..I0O~O0mC,..

-Jv)LU

O CZLU * IX * .

54 * 54:

I V) I--L. 0. w

. .A~.L C-)D0O Z-ZZ 0ZZ,-

~ZZZFX Z 0O UJ L U 0.4

I Z ZC.. .4 U. C;

>Z Z-C

10 A CD CDUXZ O Jn mA. zCF o o 0 :Et)> nu

IiD1-4

-J

LU

LuV)4

-e

uZc0LUtu n 0.4

I 0

L D C

QCL 1 ~00.10 1- IL 0 L UD ̂ > 4I-0I-Z

0000000

0000000CC0DDIIIII I- N co C to C

~0~ ~~q.C- C v 0 CD Cl C. C lLO V X IT t- -

0 0 0 0 0a a a a a a-t CN D tD C, IT 8 UZ

C T tl- CD CD_V ND Ind t D

ur t C'~00000l l I {0

0000000a4 a a a aV al a

N CD 0v r CD 0 O

-N 0 0 - C C) C (.310Ni0111111

0. N( O eO 1 O N N N D 00 I: U~ U Z

-a

O Z0COo

co )

v0)4

0UW LCD om

i LUt i(O0 CD

C4<1J I

00

IUC a ~> o.Ul ,

I

W . C

C) U)<rX uI-.

LL,.3

0J .JC._

Z '-I0 4

LU O VD

Lu I C.

L

0.I-

uJ.4I-

LU C.

I-

I-0 U 0.0..I-00 C.

Page 166: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U)

LU

0.U-

LCLiJ_11,1.

LCI-0

ZnU0

im A.4.

U)

0 0LU U A

V uLU-)

Zz-J.1 co-J >,0

LL CZ

z.4

U ) # -a X.4- a/-] )cI-

J 14U.L U 9 - U ) U ) I-c Wz 033LUcr c cs I u w

O.0 .0..-J - 0.o

z ULUIW Ul U)Z (X- Z

t) ' I-a> I-. cc-' ' - uJ 4Z L -J 0,.

W (z -J - 0U0X "' ZI J QLU X )O9-

U)()

.4

000000000. . . . . . . . .

0

0 U) - 0)ew C N0 C) C'I1-U)U) - *U) C0

*~ * C')9 C ~4 C *v C'

r-.

ZZ ̂ {

*% CdJ -0-z-J

U)

z

z-

20

-J-4z0

>(z00

00

tD t N N 88 0Lo (7 if IT LI)o 0~r-I O w_l ct axN 8 oc rC-a ) u '- *U, £ * 0

* *C')C'*C'C'- *. *~ C) N4 N4 C

m(00N v 0 0 O N N N (D =0IOZxxuu 002Z10

(5ztnU)U)I

C')

0

£0) "0-Go U,

CD00o OO)-mr

0I-'o00D N

*

c00+~0 N 0 1 I0 U) .4 U)W -'V 0 <

-0O ) -J* o U-

_ Cz z t-* Q. ZIo. .

Z A* 0* w 0

IZ_4.411W

COZ L 0a- . LU

0 0. Z0 -4-- 0I .3 I -- JI o QLc O U

O O I- Ia .co

. . J J J <--< Q. Z Zco La >U U)U)Z-J n 0.- LU. IL UZ n L U U )I L U

-J o .Z W O0D

. 4 1 1 w :E 1 W0~~~~

IL

Ii-LU

CZ_1IJ.

0 00 0 0 0 0r-- 000

O O; N t I- 1 ! 0a 0 l ) co 0) 0) coU) U) C) ) 5 m (I 0)

CO - -IT N N N. . . . . . . . .MO -0 0 0 ( T Cl Fq

* D *C- 0 r * 0 o '-0) * *0 *C~ 0.O - - * ( C. (9 toN0M0'-O-C) * tDWMw -' C U) - - *

Uz ~.~

-Jm .4~.

Zn

LU

_ ~~~UX02Zn U)tQ Z

IO 0 .4 . . LU

O *.. > ~*_-' J I.

-- -0 0A

- , ) )0 LU

3 3 Z: Z-C 9 CL 0.

-Z 0 0> JC) - 0 .

-J 0.

tzLI

000)0 m- o o - 0 Zn t -f-Z.- . CO). .0 _ C) 0

-0- - *C' )0 N

0

-J

U)

0

Zw0.0I0

Z0(J-J

09.-

z I O 00

Q

Z I <__.- 9001 '21 I--.ui -J ce coU0m-4 Ca 0 .*-J. -J J -J

O Z I O -'.4

ZZOO W )

0

'-(9-OO a00 )

N CO O

l-

0),o,0

1' *L1)I-7

O GD O0cn- (n cq

.C.4

0r- .0--

( 0 ,,,·~ C~10

Oioa0(0C'U '

Page 167: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

to

ul

4

0~~~~~~ oo o 0.N 00 00000 00 00 0 0

woo-~oo--oNo6666 0066066666-066J~66 C; C 6 6 C~C

LU 0 U ta L0O0

0 0 00 00 00

mW u 0 000 C 00 ncco~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ gtng-~to 0l 88 8o°88 8 88 0 °IL,- a C - O o oi ) -A - O O -~mm* ~* ut O-- O-OmOOOOO- OOOO- O OZ 0 OZ ~~ N< ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I 4t

Y. 0 C u in i Z ~ 01ZS-a z Z0gn C. :) FU0 L 9 it 9. A La1-4 0 z * n 4 43 6 11ooc * 0. z o0.0.x inW4 a 0 Ws OO 0I- 0.0.4 .- L aco) - 0 W ..Coo 000.1-1-0 a IJ 1- 0 .- c 0 44 (n ( -< 0 -i co to

N O Z 0 Z C)4W lf1Cl I- .J.. ..J...J

110 I -.LU 0 W 0i 000z9 Z 4 UJWJ = 44 zP Wi -n b-t Z * 41 .0 -1 c- " .t O C. < 1c in

m) I O 0> ce U Sz1<t 0 Z Z -z " 0: zw z mw m z w U F 14Z-.J '-' C 0 00 LU I.-W0 0 4 i>I-in-- .0 0 -. C.* I- W (lIZ~0 U 0 . 0.000 -- U4 Z-.i44lI i U in -e.-.Z 8 -1-a z i- 0 woin 0 ozzzM001-Izo-o Onin 440 *m (in 0 I - W4 W 0 444 4..JW 0. 0000Z Z WO. Z ..J o. In.JC 0 0. IL 0-i Z0 I' * -w O O OZ Z- J 4 _ I00 _ Z * - . 0 4wuu010-'-' 4004 &< I- 0 w L

win. in-.~~~ * i M OWP0 0jo 0-.I-i..b Z W ZZO WZ ZZOZww in1 a.41- C 10O * JD J WO Z UI- 0 -Z 1. 0Z Z=-uI W.JMJ 10W000 0 O _ 4D- * 4 O O OO I O O WO OZZ 111-I- wD OiD*..JW In * I- U i z Z -WOW>o>0 0<n-JM U1..e-.) oW~ u 4 * In 0. W ZI- o ZZW 0 roz4W 00 zWWW o4 D

CZ In ..U0.Z ZOI"W-ZOO-J0W400001-ZZmW1-I-WJ.J>u * -= Jnn u0-4000 iau : 4oo nIn0.440 2<}uxfi 0 u.o 0o.Z * 0 * w wLu 40.0. 0<l-- UI- 0U0 -. z 00.000ZwzZCD0w4wu * I- * a *-0 < 000 0. t-ZU.-0.0.z0w4o0U W4Wt O lZO-0I -4-J * * 4 4CZ '-.00 tn00Z40 W00FI-JI- W33in0Doo330nfl"1I _- -0U m I 1-.J- Z ZO^I>OO W4 co.a0. U. U. Z J4 in in4r L ZZOI-IW-WZJ.J m0000~0 < o LuxO*>Lu U. z tWW0-.I- &W-I-00 Zin U.0-.JWW'-.WWWWU44Z i in eZ O 4 OOO- WxI- Z) -OZ0-WOeZi inOOW0.0JZOOOO4 0 4- W0 < Q. -4-.I ZOO4 0 4 0 .J.J ZZI OZZU>OOW W J-) -

Z .0 1 1-1-OCDW40CDOZ4Owin0.0.ZID10OOCDOO 00.Z 0.0 (1 -00 U.C0 o - W 1z -0WaZm.oZZO 0ommWU-rm0.U.z10 * aCO 0 0_L U 0. Q Uo-.34 a-.JI .- J __00o-Inn o 3 in zz o ..J n -QI- ._ 2-00 4W02o WQ2..oz sJ W4 00 < o0o0o o. 0 zQcJ o uW InZ W1s0Z4D0..-W0'Z-._000 *. 000 1-U...a0 u.-. a w0 m 0Z-O ZI-i:n 10 X -1- IL Q .. 0. Z XZ F1-1-Z Xa 0O- 00 0. 0.Qz a- * ZCx0canx I-In zX FC- Z-in un 22 - c 0 ca ._Z sx0oz * 0.z m * s inLu I- * =44..J0ZzWumz10:-4ZZZ000a-.2044W22.-44-.4 * 40W * LU I

0. 0 * Z124S 102zW0O Y42-Y O -.-. 0 U n o o1 IL 1aLOO J EZ1Z2 * > * I- 0.in 4 * * *U)4U.

Page 168: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

; ; ;z ; ; I I t N- -

u(n C) t V- C c)cs r D D CD

. .~ .~ . . 1.

000000000000Cl ( C0 ; 0 C)

Cd O1 '0' -) IV ) NN v t t I N

. .0) C CZC. .0. .

Or'-umL0 D It) U to

C') 00CD ') rl- ='n O 00 c' 4It U) - 0) . . .~ .

( D D wD (D

002(0'Cl ll Cl

CI co ( N

eIC1! .4C')N N C41 N C4

I0 I w w IV v

0. t- (A ) 0 1D -U)2 O .D -0 N -LW 0 I, t IVtI- . .....

a) a 0 a a aNXCl N 4?Tl I I I

-C C* IV I) (

C4 4 N C4 N N000000* c 000000* C4N C-C -

co co w 2r-

LU C 01 co U) 0

LL U . . .4 C4N0

0 000000a: a a a a a

000000c o a0 (P ON 0 C )

00000tO V 0 a c I IT* 00o 0* o a a} a a a} a

000000* 2 V) qC ' )0

0--000oar ar a au a0 °Cl C') at 'U U)U '-IC0DCD(0(0WDw 0 ..

4

**

I 0 '' 0 0°C' 'U' U' Uwa ) 0 0OO * f 0

X 000000 IIIIII00000* o I co N C1 l 0 0x 000000a a a a a C

* (0_2U)1'-0_0_0 C) N 0) co N* Cl ( 0-rmD V0) 0(e

a a~ a a aX a000000 C) t- ) C) C'I- C) _) _ tn

002g C) IV' CIV

co- C C U

0* 0* 02* q'0)

I Cro r

0

LL I co

Owi 0 2I C -00.a!

000000a a Ca a a000000

) 0 ) 0 0 0 0. . . . . .

N00

0)0zNZCD

oo N No C N

00000I I 0 I I

00000O-C')U It);Cl CL tq) NI< CS NmM0)0)0 m

CA am ) (I anID U) ID U) o

00000N--__

N C C 4 N

00000a a a a a00000 t 027r- r fl

COWzDQ

0)C01Fo)'--* OI 0)C'Cl'4')'aLO ) C C, N ) C)

* tn w w co CU*lL U) LO U2') )'* 022000* U0 If IU- )U)

't O 0 r0 0Cl0(_ '-O O0O

It _ ' U' 'U U' e

w

tn ' )(

esw0.C4

CD

.40

0 N

0 t c Cf 110 IV IC 0) I)C' C 0 C 'U'Ia a 0)0)a

7 T fp (040Cl V) (

L*

I--JU)

CtZ'" 0JO~

o o0 u ') ! I221-4 C. wL

(n 'c.i a Z02 I--a z

V) 0J I U00 _,

Wi U) a~(n .4 _

wJ CDI

IO-

oJoLI.M

m

3-0 J- OU mI CJ

U)U)

a

*']1')1

***

0 0mmmm0000*j I J J

30 3-" 0

-31L -J0 3 .

00 0.L - -. 000.0J>a 4

CY -0.-s->E t z - Fs CL

0 0000 02- co m- tom

uJ

-wI-

I-W:r Ct W

0.1-0LCt>CL 1

>- CZ

-CCL zO -0. -0 01- o

0_.i1^1 LLZ ILZ 00 O

Zz _0 I-UJ 4CL z0z. L

4 iIL.

U)

-iJ

_L.00.

# 03(n

Page 169: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

a

*

zo

m -0UU) WUuo C)

y

N 0m

I

-JlJtA

nao 0J wr) "J LU CZ

0uJwz.4

z0

m

4an

0w U..o

nn Z 00 -

n,

I--z0-. 0

z--0

w i-Ja. UEn <4 Cf

IL

LUO

L.0o.

o r o IT coCa4 a a C4 n m 0 U1

. . . .

* -a o)0 -WiU1> -00000a a0 a- a a

-al o amt

000000P. I in 8;D :>-* Do-oat @o-~~* I tOOOO-OOr-

* ." 0. . .

OWC4- f (0L 0) O-eC00i C 1wo00c aJ)(o4 o??TcT9OOOOOOO~ _ sctnt

OOn

Page 170: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0)

wja,x

0M

.-.

4a

o zU)'-O-.C4WnUL u

I-Z

I wZ

O >u', ) Zu n a4U U

SjLL

-J

Z ex Uo z4LELu

Z U.zo

Z I_0I-

¢3.U U

U, UJ4 L

z> Ul tuZXXozzIuO _,

UZX. .

U) U)U) J4 u ..

J c co

u9 u u9Lu U) U

Page 171: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

moa F M--WDO V-VO O O-vNo (-Ot.OV-O+ 0o cD N t VW O WCXZ 0 Wm" VJON O O F N ClO-vo0~e i -- : -o-)- 4 C WQ N N w C')

C 3 l I - I

!

N ¢N- t- O r- Vt t 0 0 0, W N 0 C40 c- 0 0- Z 't0 ~ IIa4) o +0

ux m ~uOaxurrOnm~o-uo34 < > * ..* - * * * *1:v) Z ' -- wo 00Uw D-..C40 Z000qU) O (> I M 000r-0c'4

u, 0 C-- ' V-'aN W) O -

r= 00 W O

Z Cz'-

C ')COC)U C--Z 00) 0 0 -LU c o-ao') a C'Cw 0)q~,~ 0 0 ) z'79 99 oom C-) 020 0.. .~ .~ .~ Ul

U! OX N- C.) CN

00 It ,)0 -a. o X -o _0~

o o u r- u7 ODoO§O -o oou

~ ~~0Uo c +0U, C, ) D to 0 0 0N l - IC CN 0.U.

O N C,) O -t if)U) W C ) Cc O+C')C')'a ~ a ' 0

IM-t C;lN 0Cl IV It0 Cc

CDC)U,'t- 8 O0C) a q ) C' o y 0Cl to tro o 0oC00o00' C 01%0.

. l. - -4 -4 coa) CI 0CD

X U .ot,., NO~ ~m~O~~~~~~~~

. In .

*000Cl'T C.)Dt co ( t-

tO)-N O

o C 0 d040 0N8 O1 c C4 . - C

C-) U,IM Ot

) 2tD

00000. . .* In 0

.4 Q L 14.

VI 0 0. a(a a:a4a.a:C0 VIOIIII IIII =: ~0xsctr co z I z I z Czz I I C. CH O OOOO ON-0000000000 N.~

LU N C x 0 u 0 . 2->t = J 4C 1)w> )o2CN O 0O I ClN2N 0WaI o L U. I ^ZLU ) L O I C Q Z I -0. W > J W 0

0C')U7

0Nl

39

C,At

0

LU

40.

-X Zv x m 4ZIx ( ~ z0. Cd 0 0CL O

4a

xx XU)-3 -j O

zLU

z0.)a:

cozU

to 0.-a

VfI-

4LUU)

LUJ- 31o1 a.o 0

1z Q.JL a:a:L.I

Ln 3LU M

z -0. V

VI'- UL 0.Z Ci0. U')U) 3CZ a:

0.

-j0 MZ

CL m aaL>))Z

0 -ZuL : c wU) Ul >3 .t cf) a _ N L I u

z .... ..U)Zcc0 =0

U C)LX U)a: o 4F -nU)L&I-C

Page 172: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0. 0

0 00)W

c u > 0 O O 0O O {9 OmXO< w J Z Q O Q OO.Q..D C.n o -z w o oo+ o-utnVI >o 000000000 oN c0I-*

0 C0 Z 1 0 0 0O

t (A Lo I 8 Q0t 0 o w0 o - P FOz~~~.~0 U 1 ~ D . .. ....... ....(A "^ a z z-0--"tt 0 t §0 0 0 + omO-u, a:- U. LU so w- I- cot tM-N Cq) c) § CS f 4W .. z O Oo-,

wt - J U.0/) 0 XZ===== 0oW> LU s co tom 0 0 I)- 0000000000 0C ',e.0Z (A X4>-JJZ JJ J J

n (A mmmmmmmmmm (f - I. coz 3 U)ZJ J JJ X m00O 00If00~ -Ju W z C 'I C. wt00 ( '> CL, >-Z0 c IC) I I-Xi -- 3

.fi 4/) I 0 0 0Z. (AQQQQU)Q 0 Q 0..... = < 0 4Dn. 3 0 3< m 0o 0O0o00 +0)0)Zo: 1 =O D 0ooNNNwIOMZEZ0>. 0 U UUOZYIUQFFXw>Jw

Page 173: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0<ZV2

C14~~~~~~~~3

C4~~~~~~~~~.o H(.1~~~~~~~~~~

O A

I cI n0(.4 (0U '

(.4 ID) "tON cq t

z

~~~~~~0 x V0..U7 z 0U > II I- co I

Z Z 0(.4 I OZ '. I

co "-. C ) 0(0ZO 0 Z> *01 .'t -1 (.d*)ID- " e0

-=00z0 00IN: )> * .-

i(.4 u. W 0 Lfls U)0a - r X(W O, I ) I 0 OIfl(40 X I(0) 0 0 4-3(.4) W (00. C')Oz z W Q: V) IY39O JV ' "> z-J 'aw Wvxnm- W 0. Wa

U). WC'4(A W 0. m)

L-zzc Z ZU)W Im C LWaU- o L W" v - Wu u-ON 0 W a (O 0 X W

IWZ 0 t0. Z-1 -0 O V 0. - " In

c0

',Q0)W

-

I( iuJ

1 CO

zU aW C)1- x3

o0 0C >

O W

< U)W 3Q 0l'- .) Iu.

U)(04

co-J

O

On)W0

o~inC3

01-0

U)

m a.vx(Acs

4_)3CZIL

zI.4 IL.V) 0

In

oN o:e'JIC'Zcno0CY CZ-m -Cs~II4( 0.0

1-Jco

0to

0 O> tW ¢ Z I

CZvZ H· '(m *o >04"- JU J I O z

>_ >

3tOn I I0 -0 (00 -o 0

0~ . Na' u 1/3,1- 11000 0.~ 000. .),-

Wu 0 () ..I W, 0. 0 L Z l:L 0,, a.0 U~-Jn L

Page 174: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

- - -- 4N q

.U).,.,..,.o.. .,..,.,..,.o.

. . ..U. .

. . .

. .u* 0* .- 0 *-

* tY oUU)L. z

ZZ**> >

*- .-LLU U 4 uiZ . ,

-I-o3:*9 3C ,CZ*Z -i-

L.O--

.:..

0~. · . I*.1. . .~

-ZC.. .11L. . .QU. . .4U. . z.L. . 0. . 0

1- . . .--L.-. Lcc (n1- h~J I-- tlJ UlA,~.ZU U)Zw * 0zz .0.00 C.U-*L 00.,-. OC.)

.I- .,400. U.U 0 LA...

uL

0

Q o 0O

oo

a

. .II=4CZ

U)C.U)

c. z

I LU

0U

ZNU 0 I O

w

* mo <(n 0 0-J w

z0

LUz0.U)4

*0

.U...- 0

.U

.3

U. .* >

Z* O

U Cet

tn W04

zo

I* ) U)

*3 ·

zo4.=JO

LU(-mo. U re,.J

Zn,

-

Page 175: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U.IL

0LuJ

I=-

.=1-JLu

mU/)En s9I-J

Luj

I-C,U0

0 0 - 0 0

a a O 0 sI 0 IC 0 CD I000000

rC t- - - C

N CN D N . . . .

I I I I

r-O)0* ID * CD*1- M )0 C

~.t* - --(D

UJ -t It

z-4CD

0UL

U) Zto Lu .

tn .4 0C-).. ¢A 3-J3 .,

Z Z U) -5-4 Lu .4 Lu

> U 3 Lu

I.ni-J 0 U).4 Lu 3Z U 0 = b-4 N IL

C4 I- uU)L f .4 I t m -JCJm F Z C Jio I - Z . -J

0. C : ) 4 toc I OI LumCO C4 oY'r w

1 o u >0 U) 0

0CZAz

z.4WU).4I

**

r- o

O ( C'),I-. 00to-

U)I-zwL~uz00.z00-_

z0I-zz00

0

000 o!

001w

000o o oU) oo9CD00

( 0 0· -0·Lfl ' -.p000

0000 it) 09 ( 0o-oor) -V .

cN N NIuuZuII

0

0 I .4u I U)

a CS;x

ID0

rClIM)

0

C*I0UO

O r-

IL) (/3 I0 (,' IW Cl

U) IIto' .Io1'I

UCZ V)ImUV).

-J

-J

U)0

mU)toC4

Ix

030CZ0-C Zj

~3Umou, tn LULc-t:U) C-

(N Lm z

uIji /I3O J :E

L0 nI I-.JLu U)o: >t

>-I-,=I-.

0z m0 0

L.o zZ Z

o Z- 0U) 0

Lu i-Lu

Z ILu U0. 3.. 0 0.41IL

00

to

0 0 .C' T CLn

00C. O- .10

Co Gto 0 0 0o0 * 0 0*CY) , LC n

Iq

u - I -

Z Z0z j -I

0 000LEto In u C

0I-

04 0

U)00) CC 3Ct o

LU N >

I-LuCS >CZ to -~wQ. 0D 4I 0o0U)I LuI Z00

Lu.4 Luu n rLu)U I -4ULC , 3 U

0> JI.

Page 176: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U)49

-J

0

LU= Zc*i

oC-jIx0LU.

wLU.0.>-.,

(D O0 = C4 C4C(DZO Z I u

: Z Z Z Z Z(Z(Z(Z ZZZZZZZZZZ6-4-6-46-66- -- 46-4"zzzzzzzzx

C.) C.)U C ). C) U )

coN vtt o IC 0 0 I CN (DO .Z4

U)i--II

ZaN Z

000

Lua,4

s0

Z0I-

LJ JLU

cr0 )En L4-

CZ

'0.N O.J J

CZI 00 4LuU)L)n cJU) - (A4

LU _

z0

U)Z-z0

0u

0-r

LII--0cx

0.X

U)LUl-Ja134I-

I--IiV3mUU) a0

0 F CZ

Z"'0OI--OUCWO

Page 177: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C.,'Cx00 V IV T q t It O C _

X XXX4XXXxX11XXxxaZ>>11X.I I C, C, U) U > I I Y

X xXX~_ _ _ _1 1 1 xI -JC, -

00N Cx

z x i x11:Y:3=3 z x

0

NX

:Ez x x -Jx x C,> -J.a V

Z,-CO ,,-000X)'J > Y O O

x xZX ZX » ZZ :XaJ

0000000 0 0X X X

I 1 1x z ,> - > 8Eon>XXXX1111r~

X X X : XX

x xo11XX> -J z

z Y

0x° 8

0 U) 0. -0

o o n L L :r

xXX 1XXXXX..>..> -J Z X X X -4J

I > J > J :X : >xxxzY YD a m mi

880000oo-0-0 000 0 > -J-J>-J > -J >-J >

C.0o0o

O - U_J - V O C

X

-J X

X Z_J '-'IU )X U) =

X X X X 0o1 N --000001111-00000U) U ) U I U) U U) tUnUC, U)> Y 0. I Co u)

U ) U ) U )t U I U U ) ) U ) U )

LUz0z0U)

LU

zLLUa.U)4 -

Cl

w

a.

"IN0O~

Z

0

CZ.)C W,U

m 0U)CD U) W

CZ

UJ

0 4nW.J.-

tUJC.)>--J IW U 0.CZ OCn:

XX

ICL CL

o.~.d0. >.-O....0-z O =U)

I IX

-x II.0.0

0*XI_J0U)

I-J

0

0W

zt-z0u

U)

z0I-0.0

8XO10-J x>

XO 0. 0 Xo..d>U)-

Page 178: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LL.

LL

0w

--JwL

z4

-Jmco

01CZLuJzru

0zr,- -D .4

4I- LuU)tLo.0I-Luw

zcr0I-0.0

C-

Lu0.00.

U) 0 U)UJ 0U

J w U) CO 9 a

- w V ) V, C D C , C ,U) U) U) U)

0 0

0 4 0 .0 2 L u 4z > 40..J

Z _ 0oI *z 0 J

w z -Z I-> I-0. C) U) 4

LL

0 0 0 0 0OO~OOO000000

N N II CD IVi~ C 1C! i!I I I o~ O ~l 00

*1- ' I0f 00* I.- U) O (DU) O O* * 1-* -F *: * -

0)000- 000Lu IT U- ItW- -

U)U)4Cz

Z

I--

0X-J_.1

zz0.I004z0

z>1

z00

O 'W_ -O00t- I r-r' tNo IVT(9 N[ r,.O C(D 'q'

I, . .M~ LI r.

01

0a

8o+V U) - lw0 0v n Mq8 Q OlC) i-N-lwt

Cl rC .

Im0+~o~§8 ~~(7 0 0 0 IT M U) * u

O D M) 0 0 0* 00I00 0 00I *l *) V * O C) -eld

'~ ~ ~ ~~ - I~

I

-J M o

00

el~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~UIX-I-z I -o co to IL0

Q tJ e Z =:I (v -J -J -J -J a o w(

w00.

0

a)

.w

I-

el

zwocr3.-.a0

U) uco VCU

4( uz

0U) CtrI (n

-J 00

Page 179: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

ULn

wC,40

co 00 000 0 0* 0 im10 11 00 0000 0 00 0N ~~~~00000000 00O000 0000 0000000 00000 88 8

10 0 00 0 0 0~o~-oo~~~o~ooooo-ouzooo o oaooo~o o o oo ~- , * 0 -OO N0m ,0'-0'-0000000 0 1 0 0 ZII w O - - O wO -O N Z O0 Z O OZ O O O O O O O O O O O - O O Ow 10100 00 0e400000'00000-N66-666600-000'-'00 -00 00 C~'

1- Cl- (O - ItD N 4 I M

N

CZZ LL

m~~~~~~~~~0 cc a. -

Q~ 1 * U7 d ~ Z" ~Z "~O < w O w w ~WOJ - 0 W O 00 Q Q UZ00 a 0Z w ~ 0 0 < w.

a ~~Z wX ZO~OZZO J O~OW O O O Q0 Cd 1n I 1 0 * 0 Z 0.O.4x = 4 0 Z CZ < Ul 1 J J *J i aJ

o00 Z F0 LU 0 00< WW <4 LU VZ I I 3-

CO a * 1 -MZLULo0 WW0ZZ LC-w. IT Z-J - 0 w I-WWW0< - > aa » O < 0004 I U. 0L

co z UJ U O C; a; m u <of < 40 ) Z Z - :Z I tr 11 1 < F 0 a L InZ 0 a0.000U.4 1.J4 Ua n~-W n ZZ 3-4 <U co co0 I- 0 I-I 0 O ZZ ZU-L U 400Io - -wuo oWtufln 44 .-J1o 0 m In 0 D - 4 U < 444 <-lW 0J o000Zw)Z .ZWCLw. Z .J o

0. _n 0 O J 0a -JM .- j 0 z Z-O...J 4 O. O Z W00 Z * I U. 0 0 <WUWom-< UU400 0. -iJ Z L (Z

W' Cl b4 * W o oC W 0 W-J.J.J3-40 zwmZZmwwmZZZwwwInWf In *L 0 000 Z 0000I-U>00w.-wmm..--.. oJM 41- 10 * (< Q - OO IJ Z .IO Z - -I-Z 0 O Z Z JE SEI i i0000 0WJ 4 * ( W Un 0 w Z :) -. Zo z > oZZ z E _ ID'-UJ c * In 0. D ZUI.J OZ0ZZw O Ztw J 00 UUJ JuL 49 OI in -J 0oIQoZO Z00C0WU- o O-J-wJZZWI-I-WJ.JJuw * I *

l .jtnn m0-00ou00 U OO nOnQs t< <0.440In Z * 0 * W WW <. QU-- C.)-0 00 J Z 0 Q OOZZOa' z W L * a * 0 0*- 0U 0 0.0 -ZU-MM0.0o Cr0oU wZ - *4* * 4 <

-~ w -00 sIn00Z40 w00I-QJI- W33I000330Intoom I-o 1 i -*J-J Z IoI>00 WuVJ0Q U O: Z u I n In.4 L ZZOW--WF-LZ-j.J> m<oooZtw0 .J-.> WWL U- m mLULo0-..-e uo L 0 2J WI-.JWW"WW>wwa44Zx In O zn

Z 0 4 000-W1-ZZ-OZUWo OZn I QW .c0o.WZWo U 0 4> LU0 4 0 0 4 woumInj-j ZZI - OZZLQ0> W *- - .Ja: mooInn in 47 Cz * * 0. tYI <- - OL J Z _ I- -ZO -ZOOW00ZCO n n0.0Q m.mwoooo ozz0 In - .i L0 m Dz w-Mwzo-ozzoo m 0 w0:L-U-co0 0000LU ' I0 0- 0 0. U-0'-43 0. Q."JI- J -O0-on 0o 3 I Z Z 0- -I in i X ZI tn F I CL * J Z0 Z >ini- Mo. -J JZOOZM -CN trO .J < 0 -J C CL I

I- - 1-01.zz CXCL <WOZW1..J 4 000 w J0 0Z CZ C -J 0 0 W In

> Z uJ 0014o .' L o-0 J 000 O O r W -. tw _ I L0 m oZ-I- n3 Cn 0 0 CL IL

Z * zXXonx<-I Z XZ-Ozxzx-<DQw-<xXXOZ * 0.1o0 * Inw I- * D a 4J0o4rZw10mZ m 4s-Z Z ZO0O0 - . 0 4sw 1 - 4 * 40ow * LuJ 0. 0 * z114101 w --.- Q0In O OJ1111 * >0z * I 0In 4 * * *4

U-

Page 180: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

IT C) N4 N- -0000002V 0 0 Ck

C O D U) )N4 t- - N4 N

1. . . . 17

000000a a I N aT aD

D cdCO- (D U) D U) U) v

N co co - )1! . .! . . C7I3 .

O IT L r ) LO U. 0LL IT N ) -0

Co m- r co N N N'CD CI D lCI

I3 %'

0. O

J J N 0000X l)clq Ct C q C-)C') C

U)U) 0 (D N 0t) _ N 0 U) f- -

0, . r--- -- N

M O C XC O toz r- l D 4 IVu N 0 tC')- U)

CD D D u)* ~~ III

aU-

-C C() V L D

N4 N c~N 4 NN000000* 000000* D C) O t co* v N UZ { D -* t-0)flC')--

C C N C1 -C N N4 CI NI N C

. . . . . .

LU-JU.00.

0000005 a a a a a00000

~0DI D Co 0 OD U)IN N L t v UXfO D U) C C cU C) U) D D LO C)

. . . . . .

N CN N N 4000000c a a a a atD N CN O U) q

* 0) C') 0 N * CD0)C', - 0 )* 0 o ft" -O e* o-a U)U)f l N* U o uL n ) UZ UZ

. . . . . .

P7 tq) Cl) C')mC')000000-C-u 0) {9' 0) C') 0) Un CD I

I cD ID CD C( CD. . .1 .~ .

LuIa)-N M vt WUc

Lf IV ,l Cl ,4 C000000C CO C) O

0 co u) TC) toU)1 q-C 0 CD )i i i i t9 i i~ ~ 0Z{

CN N N N N Of000000ab a a a- a a

I - 0 ; N M C D 0) Cl NC -O 1 IVC D to DC) C)N . 0000

ZC .D.D.D.D .

000000* 000000* t CDl N U) (D U* r- U It 0c f-* le cDC) N -

r IV r1 V U .l .~ .~ .~ 1.

*

w-JU.i,/.0

x

**

Lu-JU.0a:

000000a a a a a a

~00000o - 0 N-CO r- 0 0 T0 D CN Cl U)UC U) U 1)U7

. . . . . .

a) t- C 0 - cl* tD ITD O - N* C (DO r- b* o o aO a- 0 0 -* 000)0) uC I uD u

. . . . . .

I M C N - 0

OCDU)eDCD '-I I m N " N

. . . . . .

Lua - N C D 0I-U)

0)' rC D0V O N4 . - 0 D0 f- CD LO LON 0 0 l f - r-N N N N N

. . . . . .

Lu<5 - C ) V U) D

4

CD

u

40.

0

r-L )rITC') IV to 0)

Clt) -CCD tN U 0 M C1 t

r- IT D r Nca C' C0

C') C D D

Q Zu a

Wo COD0 0) 0 _-

mO (n al4 LuI

c =1

ClO0 "IyqI~ IVC Zm z

a a

o) U0 uU )a Cl4

41~- CD

I I:

*

U)I--JU)Lu

**

03 c c co111=0000U. U. ..J i - -i

Lu 3M 0 3) -J 0

1S 1. 3 LL Jt4 0 3 - L . -J -

40. ~U. 0D Z0JO 0.i 1 0 *. LL W 0: <

Lu . :-). 4>2 CL> <t >4

< >C

I- - - .000000I-co I- co I- o

0IL)

Lu. _.CZZ a0 4

CZzZ _..00

U) -

i-> z0z

JLu I-0. U

I < ccU.

****

U)uJ

U.00.

*L

Page 181: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

w(5

,i-

a-Q..4-

N

I

0

0CZcu Om wo

00U, Lu

COJ I(no(. OUJ 00

WUi.J LULU ,

****

p-0LU

Zzz0

C.4V)mC4mn

I

U

0 <

0 OZ -4 0

IAn <. - > zLU 0z0. U

In 4I 4

U-

LU

U.0ir

000000I . I I II000000I ~1 O N D O (AO (.4 (.4w;;; Ol ID at ; . v

LU - N C v 0 w

U)

Page 182: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C,4Go

I.,

IC4

C,

D zo, _0-

4Wm U< UJ

N

CZu.I j

0 >u-i ') -O

zrF

z UUJWo

O U

w CZ-- V)

Z Z4

inon 0

) z UJ0JW -

zZ)(w > Ul UJ

.. o

0n 4W U) )J z U)

w m. x (u(n gnCZ to c:E M

W ,) U

Page 183: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000000000

D Q O Q

0to OQ. . .

| U) -c

>- C

0D+

. O !9 O o u ( aCD

000 COO00 O

O O Ol U UI

0 0 o n 00* oz * 6 n C-4('IV N

00O0

co1 C')(

' 0D 000-0001 1 )

*It

I : De r Z

a X X : XLU 11- 1- "I, N "I-00000..- j-j -J- -xxzz

: tY : :IIII

CD CO C3-. J- J--

0-

_Ct0. . .~ -Q tlD c1O (D IT C1

CM )

CDN) Cl ;:

C LO '- tv qr N ( I ID

CD0O+C*)

(D0

C0C00U C) 0

0I 0 C4QD C)

0 D U)

0 ro 7 ax o . . . .

0l

00)qC-OV OOO D ) IVO m lw (O IV ol

In 9 l )

I I

000 o0 0 1Iq . .CDCl)

-J

I z0 1-mX -co C I-

IL . a. co

0.-JI J 400X txD Oi S O U) N Nr < O I = 4 <

OOx"NNWXCDOWMIZU.U.O IZII-1tD OL UZ>j

0- 0o

--0O0CV

~ImUCD Mz- 0

co 1-3,-az0

D )ZLU>mw 04

LU

0.

cU-a

-J0

U)Cm4

C4UCZ

Z >CO"rc

UZU) o1W3 4 >m C Z. = O

> I t

V)

0 4co UJ I

CD 0 ) D

U) o0

I-'CD 0 l

o CLU IN t->0r

O.- C- N

tr (I C

DO0-0 c 00V 0 0 'W x

zLUI

z0Uc)

zuJ

z0(

NixUJc z0 Cfl1-co U

4J uU)U)

CZ

0 I4 -uj U)0ZC4-i

zazLU).UtLU

U10

zLUa.V)4--

ClU)o

0n LAJ CO =

C(AU)DO41

nl

m

u130tL

C,U)OLUC

aI.

Cg' oo oo! .- --4 D -M 0 4(Al U. I- U

.U

I--mc :U) I

Page 184: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

APPENDIX C

Azeotrope ColunSimulation

Page 185: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0CI

I

v ~ ~~~~l C l0Z I

xnLU CNIO. I -0 -

OZ I0LU CNI MN z X

.4 ~ ~ ~ 11 C,)

O 0 > 10z I0 0.x

N Z >

oc~><J qC*. ' It N

Z ) I 00.4N0In"J 0 -X

L U. . OI- o0'40 U0N.10 InZ WI CD j-C 4 M0 0I0C - I-vLI 0 0 Uw N -C

J < fl LU CLO Q0O u -.1m M>Woc

(s> ML OUN J 1-0Z Z L UJ C) Z YU1-Ow -.100C# wool0LU CZ0 00 0.W0JLLI W . IL U o- I v 1 V) O - Z i- 0fO. W- > I z w Ix W-J Z z z Il (x u I- _n I Z X a o on z

WZs 0 .O z- Q -- IU CL 0.Q 0

Go

CD0

0C,,0C,,CDC!U)

IZ CI

o zCD U

O 0N C.) CIJ 0-J CC)

0 o

11 cli~1J 0

.-LU 00 - 0 I U O O~ 1 q. - J· 00 00

N a. -Col 0

I0 c0

1 * CS N o0U q~- U 11..7 ) .c0 0

'I I 0 13 < U.CM * < o w U Z 110U I- .4u w I InN 00 * . C o JN

Z L U (1) Z 03 LL 0 L ll)WO .4.J LUN-4Lfl

yC D1 I- 0.00.LA.

3 LA. 00 Ca0

.- LU..Ja *

0o0o:

00iD

N.4-o~J IO q

,- 1&a--> II'

:>1

U t,N-_ 6_ ~.0a 11OI>a0Z

Itn(f)

I L0 '.Jm00.

Page 186: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0(N

(N

In0

I-

0 u

o m_ o.I L

a) CZ0 C

a} c(N¢3

00 .Is J

CO)o0I.J

LUC-IL

L-I.

- 0 0'I I

C') In wo I ''-. CY) C -.O 0 In _

LU

Z I) O (N

000000000o o o o o o o I I i i I I i i ,

In -N Cd O W C-'-at:o -0 N 0 0 0' O In - C') t) N O) lw CD- In 0N In O C '-

N n N 0 n n v N -'C) C NN - - - - -

N (N (N (N (N CN (N (N (N

N N0 00 OC') (NAC) C')n C')

C')t0 O 0'O

(N N (N

to c OC4 C4 CI

O~ t NIn n 0')0l qr (C') C')r- In O

oN N

0 00D InIn t9

lw C')

N N

O C

0 0In C')0 (NIn 0J)C. N

Cl N N N l0 0 0 0 0

tD - -O'J t(N - O C' _UI Ir 0 co IIn 0- n C')t(N (N - - -

L . .

N N (N N (N N 'N 'N N 'N N tN (N 'N

0a~ ,- ,-

(N tC' s I tI 0 - O ) -0 N0IlN4 * . ** * *Y * - *0 Q . a.-I 0 0 00 L U U L Um~ o o oc 0 0 0

-4 -4 -4.J J _JCn a a In

Z I- - I- -k-O O Ua O CYl OZ I.-Q 0 0 0U5- * * *Z * * *1U * * *

* * * * * * * * ** * * * * * * * ** * * * * * * * *

O. a . . a. a. a. .0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.i _ UJ 1 .J .1 _ . Ul

L L LukU L L LU LU LUJ LU

0 0 0 0 0 ~~~~~~0 0 0 0-4 -4 -4 - 4 -4 - 4 -In In In In In In In In Ink- k- - k- k- - - k- k-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

C') t In In 1 In 0 O - N C' v In In1 V- -- - - (N N N N N N N

* * * * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * ** * ** * * * * * *· * * * * * * * * * * * * *a. a. . 0. . . a. a. a . a. a. a. .0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0..I J - .1 J .J ..i J -4 -J -J I _J -i

0 0-.4 -4n ,k- -0 0

* * ** ** . . * ** * * * * * * * * . * ** * * * * * * * * * *

L&U LUI LU0 0 0- -4 -4w w wn

k- k - k -0 0 0

LU LU0 0

U) r/)i, bl k-0 :

O

U0 0

. -O OVIn In

0 0

UJ LU LU LU LU0 0 0 0 0

-4 -4 -4 -4

o 0 0 0 0. ** * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * * * * i * ** * * * * * * * * * * *

(N

In,1D10i.

11

LLJ

:I-I-

0UN

O tO-,0 ID-J On +0

CY - r-o tc()

0LUt.1U-N4C

"IQ-In0

I

a.

za4N

L-JIM

LUV)0.I)Ck:4C-J0On;-.

uCZ(ZLU.. 4mk-z0I-JU3

OtLUz

LUnzCL-

* :E04-

Oj z

tZ

u 0n r-

- 011 *., 0

C Z

k- rv 0t.L k-

0 Z

'q'k -41- 4,w -.

UJ X O' IN

Z n

LU X

,X<t ,< N1

o aLU :3 04Z L In

0 ZI14 LZL

Page 187: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

. l

a)

0C),-.Cda0H

(901)

0a)

.O(D40a)(1%)000

rd o

Z l ozoo

IM0

00

0 NZ40U m* * .OW

N s Cl C, (l) C) C C, C) C, C, C. C, t) t Ji-O4 O4 O O O O O O Oa O O O O O -m )-o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I I I I * I I I I . I I I

o m 0 0o0 0 0 0 0 0 - to m 0r- c o n to In in m mN i n 0, 0 - o .- m - - O In tO O-J

0i'-

,,m-

z0I--

-.1* * 2

* If

0m.-

- 0 U) i T N V In tn 'N O) w 0 t- I -J Z_. - tin C tD In to ) t: N t 0 N - 0 -.· - ~ in

.. In w.1 I oC9 0 4 04 N ('4 4N CN iN N N N N N N MZ4 Y-O - 0 ZI- ~0 -J 4m 0 Ii 0~~

8 0 z z z UY0 - -w J Z Z*- 0t 0 t 4 C' v in , - O 0 C') a LJ(N (N Of C, 1( C C t C C CI M , ' t tt :E I m

D a 0 tOO Z > -> w 0 U 0

* * * * * * * * i* * * * * * > w w 0t 0 t 0 * * · * * * * * * * * * * * Z 0 Q000* * * * * * * * * * * * * * 0 Z I J0 w I - n0 CL 0I 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. CL CL Q. CL CL CL Z- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - 0 W in0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w n0 CA

t w w ti w.1 wt Ill Ill w wLI Ill w w L 0 Z -O Ot 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 : a 0 I- .J -.- I - -- - - - - - - - - -~ ~~~ ~~~~0 U. - cl co coin} i tn in (n in in in tf in In in in (n 0 aO 3 01-- .- - - I 1 - I ~1- l- I C t 4 4 OZO

D D D ::) :: : ~D M :) ) :) :) =) m w Q J1 l' z 1 z0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C0 0

* * * * * * * * * * * * * ** .J CL· * * * * * * * ** 4 W* * * _* * * * * * * * * * * 0 iw

n0C,14.1

0os u-

rr

*q 04*I f

in *

t

I--

w o0000in

in

-J >-

4- 0

t.L Q

in in in intz z mU LI)

OOOZ0 cr 0

w w w x-C4-Jw I 3Z

l'-

awI-4CZwz

I-

0CLw

** *

* *

* z*

*0** O ** I-**0** w ** )(** w ** *

* in ** ** wt ** O*

* 4** W *

*0** *

* ** z** C0** Q *

* 4** Z ** O *

* *

* z** w ** J ** i/**4** U** *

Page 188: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

- - - - C4N 'T 'T

*Zc

.)> W.,.,.,.. .0..0.

. . .

00,I-U..J.,.0.0..,.,.0..,.,.

* U - 0U .

. z z y

Z0043

OWWI

0 W O 4 -*n v Ic n h39 i-tC C.uU m

. .U.U* *

0L.

z.0*

I--. .--

W..0 0

U . 0 L

co co co O

< W

*Z u.. ... .... ... ..... .

. .... ...

.z* Z

-C U*~ m

NO0U. .

ZZ

0- 0

U) U * U 0

*CZ* 0 E *z

W

a.

0.,-

"IMn

a

Z0I-N )

I-

r- zZOU)

0U.

~13

0I-W<S uaD J-J <

Iu O -(A V)

i CZ

Page 189: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U-U.=.

---I.I

~~~~~~~C,i

'-II'0 N 0N-jLU0Z I>

O 100I 1700 NN LU

: >

, 0

x< 0wo LUIX= LUI- > LLV/ 0 ON

-Q <

U7

0._ I I 0

U7'e L U I * I0 >-

m

.-LUIx I--0 0 U0L wu LUU nN N Z

4. 44 z0I U

C II CI u)I- N 397 0 < F 0> Ix j

LL

r- r-aMt-W0 0000

-7 -0- NCl -C1 t IV

O O N O Om - -I I I 00 0000.. Y C 7.... ...

I II

0 0 D*~ I. 0) T Vc

0 7 *Zm r- 0v"T * - D *CY) -C01- 00701000 *00Tt- CUJ * N U)' )0z-44mo

wCYzLUZ0z4

U7In(AILUI0z

UJ z~-O Z <JLU m

Z . 0 I-14N LU .4 LU

4 U/7 3 LU'I.J ~ U7Z U0 Ot- LU 3Z 1 n 0 X

00 .:3 00 -0 H- Z LU -.=00 ~ LU.N .:.J LU . "3,D CZ133N 1 o* w< 0 U >0) In 0

Z-

I 00I

-t

U7

* z* LU* z00.z

U=J00-4.4z0(-zLUz0U-

00),-

0 * 0

(D '0 D

0O .07O t

0 t - * * CM C') O M

Ul Ors qD-0 0C) C~

· ,'- cO-n 00 n O v n

.cIO0M N OLw . 0

,m- ,. Ci 0

+

.t *0OUI-CD N'.a0oL~ (D t"

r'. O N

00IV .0

.~wC')O

r- IV co cr', - o

Cy_0 I

~00 ~ ~ ~O<Zs Xtr I MLU ..j cC co

<9 m us a.

CD0 0 U7 0 I7 UN J C1 IT (f N = M -7 I) J O<

I--0I Q t Q ZI I ) t)< I-

w

.

',Cl

0t

Z

L C

J V)

U)I-) .4

LJ JL

(n z

0z

0I--NZ-'0~r-4

- LU

z o

wui.41/

ZCLO--0... · LZilUz.

(/l)XIn

I-U7')>-03

I--

_..I .--

LUJ

z0UC)

LU:.)I

3uC)0-JU.

Page 190: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

Ut)

-J

0io

4ZZ'-4 I-.z<UZ ZJ O..j P.,= i,-

:E0 x tLrZU,.)IL

w 0N V U) 0 I I0 N N tD I0 O Z = I uO

O a: (

z A z- - -U) U) U)zZZ

)O U U

uc n 0 n utU) (A U) U)1 -4 .. 44

2 ZEX

0.> 0 0 0 0 0Q0

C1 U 0C' 0 0I=C,4 C4 a 1 0 0 0 2 1z) z - :

U)I-

(00AIC') 0(oO ZO n O

I D -: C .) ,.

Qt(0 1 0 0 O

WC,40.

co

ClN

I-

40

ZZO O0 0

NWLA- U

_j ..in W~J14UL )

OW .00.* 0w ix< 0.

La 0 >v) In o-444 U) CY. l/YWI-><j'ruD.WWJLU0.

z0z0U)

W

Z

U4x

0

W

0

0.

LUW-Jcom

I-i-

i-

W

0.-

00

02-Z I-- "' ou 0

0. U 3>-

Z W

=-.4>-0.

uOy

Page 191: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

99 C4 0XX VV KXOKON-N-X

Z J------XX-X- X sX X XX X

r X > -i > -i > Ji > -i m > -1 > _-i .

It X x xX Z J X X

W fiXX> I J>CXU> 0> .z YM >>-D 4'1 )

: x xz z0. 0.,

X x411tn I I0.0.0

C,

x-

O O W U > >

C.10 0 9V-lxxo>-J11 > 1 2

N~ q. XO0o0 0 1z 'C3-1 a 00011)

xx x z

ZZ00U)U)>>1ZXUO

88

-z"Z>a I

88g880-xxxxxxx1 1 1 1 1C1(A > 1

x01o.-ixxxxxxxxO-ZZZZZZZZtn > > - > J > i>) I m UW)> >(A

_ _xxOOlxxx.> J z z> S IJY11xx

0_- X)001x x -

X X a1 £ 100 _0)

88>o88888> z ,- J > - i

0-4.40 8 00 8 -m O >0 >8mx CII xo uO O; >0U ) 1 0Wr)> > Sx Y

xx x 1>-J11110'>-iZ> 1J 0 U >)0S £ S C X w J

*M S 1 >E y J m > D3 > t#> -AXIICXC t > -i S > y Y

Cd0- x Cd Cd- d 9-0100000._..mxxxxx0- 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 s-.z )U)U U)U

C'40C C C - --0 0000

I U) U) U) U) UI > Y

x-J V) X XX X X V)I aI ) t Z tl0 U wm t Io Ul> Y I ow> Y

Cm

LU0m

u-0

ZZ0 0'-4 4.

I--40 N~u

-elY

OJ U)

u Lun tn-LL u e_00...I 0

J-J I IJ0.W OOLu->En J I-- ~UI IfiJ O.-J uz

uwoIL

0u

z

uZI-1

zCUU")

0I-

0

Page 192: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

a) "0 C*H 0t12Io 1::; --4

oj0*C12

0

0 0

ro )

).0

~-40)¢)

0o >o~

E-i HO o;,--I o0 0 r. u H

QOw

0CL

coI-

< ZCD

NO0 z0I-

N Orn

um U LL W

,I. MOJUJ L

l UtY

w

W-j

-j UW W

0 W W J

N - < <Ile F w

0 (x w a

W U. W =Z a U > >0 e N o Z_ 4 N>0 0z - 0

mU I- U)

> Z ~ 0 w

. 0 6 U4 0

U

*** * *** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** U, ** z ** o ** - ** I- *L0U,) V * 4 *

- - * .. *

Z ZN Z * 0 *-I-Afl * > *

w UZCflu) u)O. * Y Z *0 * 00 ** 00 *- * I *

Wu * ms *U) * 0 ** ZZ *N Z * - *4000o * Z *~J O 2 * tZ *I- * o: *a. * tY *0 * CKo ** Wl *4 *

I- * *4 *

W * *a. * *0 ** 4***tL

U-UI.1.4oL&AW

I--4-JCZ

C-0O0

a)C,)OO3.O 0c4

o a0 00000

0 t a, I I !

0 )- _

. . . . . .0000I I I

0 (0 0(0* t- 0v * v

z*0 0 -.0 .~0~14-CcJm 0.0.aC,WzW

0z4LI)U)4

Z-.-4 y

.. ·

0o-:

I--* Z* W* zo

a.0x

0z0

I-z

o00

00)t-

0 * 00

00 * 0) -N1 C') C C

(0N VW O

O O I4 N n N N0 U Z O

I DO I-

Zj : CZ c00 Ir-z 2 -1 >-o m m m X <J

CO O W U ) II-JO4Z

< E uiI-0

00Clc

-n00 U) It N N! O

ItSN

I

0+C,,C4C,q * O

C') 0

*w co or-o Nr.-

0o00g0C,,0CN,Ic

UV .0(0

r- 0r-

Page 193: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

00

8 8 00 0o? -O 0

(D tDo 080

o ooo

0

OnO' °88o o* o )

U)

0008o800 U0 O§° o-

0

8 0 00 0OO 0

C,'T- a .C.. . . .

**

*~~

04 0

I- 0~~~~~~L40

LUI- 0 0* * * U) * L 0

000W0 0

t X Q* 4 Zu) 0 F FZOZ O I

-00W -0

* ~~<* Z44a*Z

4n000u

,~ u-JLn V)

UI

I-U) -0 O U. WOnW LU

0 0a) LLO Q0 CLI

0 0.

U)W ZZ

*n ix -ZOW1--42 .W

-44

Z ,E30404ZO X w

W cLU00L 000 0

Iz i-\Z I-0 LU

_z-2

Q OZ0000

a Z 'r0 I-I-- ". LW I- I--20.-s0U) 0.O :UZO'L Z 0 a. . _j

4 U

0 0.3-4) Z

u Z0,'-

Z Zet WJz r 044

00

C:Z . CZ 0zWC0 ZOO O0 0

0F- E Z ia.U 0.0 Z W0.00.

< C (o OZOL

X 4 0Z40U)COZX 2 0Zm- .. JI.10.O :

4U

LU0004Z OZcc -C W (n I.

0 )I-0 Z ) W IC.4 444~4 .U .L 0.

Z L Z WJz S < J UJ t

JZ Z o D LUOI-e.J-0 Z w Co > CM LL0Z)OZ Z _ L

-04Z0 ZW>0 vao0Z LUX CoZ <o0oLUU. Z0U. UI ~4

-J Z 0.00 C LL

0 L<U0J0O> c < 0t

ZU) .- J:U0 U) L J

Z oo o 00 0 -i 1w Z ) :E l

W < Q C

ZZZOOO"I---0.0.0.0

0.0.0 00 0O OJ JLU LU

0 0 ZZ Z k

_i"t00z-14 LU-JWz0Z-Z -LU LUt-I-LUJ

L W JC O 1 W 3 3 A

Z F-0 0m m LAJL L 1-

cU)39

U. U. U

Z x Z0 020

U) U)O204< 11 1M X X0. <

>> 00 <<oo 00 44» 0004ZZ Z LUIo0Luf) <<U00ZZ ZL Q Z:Z <0J 4

OUUZZ2LULUL0.Q0QLU-e-.O00.J IU)0 J U OZ OOIOmZZ 2O1* U L , *_J 0;00 LULU4LULULU4W W < - P U U Z Z W I-- -w J C I

.S40U)nU)00 Q tLZ22Z00-02wwI LU L L0 U Z - .-J000 33 0 U) m m

LL U. Z W mZX0 -J.-J>-;L W > W 4 Z

m>mmoooo<OZZLLOOU>MMMM-00 O0LLZZ0.U Z Z o I-

-C < x: m J -i -j 0 z c l -J

0 0 z L LL J0.' t1- Z X- 0 -

< e < 22 2 - <-<UwwwcOO Jxxxxz

WU040.

c.d0

Lai

0

0

00o8 o 8 00° o80cm L N

0

O 0800r o

O

I0

IT

000 00 000.

(DOT U)

Z0I- ZNO

U. LUCZ I-= USJ U)

wcj0

4(f m

.JoJUO IX

w)UJ1.EXIx

LU

2-Z'CI0,j:_.,

CLU.N4:

U)

L

a.

cLLUJ U.Z 00 .4

zz0

',' 4Z0z -0 0

U .44

LL.'S>> _

Q\ a)zn .

< t

mJJ

-JI--

*I4* o

* 0

-

U) -. U.4 I-LU J 4

. .-JO I I-- I.

0 l.44J 0 -Fw

0-i-I

* >LL*

*LU0

U)

-J

U.00.

0LU0.

0.*

Page 194: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

IMm~m000~m~mmv0Io . .0 .- N . . . .O . . .

00OV-0flOC.'I0-U00CO0O 0~C

'04C0i0'I

0~ 0CD~ 0D'~

1~ n, D' ~ I: f lC; ' ; (D~ AD-IT'* * -tou Nr-c P-C O N t' C o 0 I) 'o C' I r -7--N N N N N Cs N N N

cO az L o D U) (D Ul (J) M IVOr C ) a 0 ) D- c X-Ul0 CD0 0 **

O~~~~~ 0 a0OOOo b wOOo

04 0 CO U V e N f - IT 0

tOI (D (0 @ 0 r X co 0~ c c aw 0) cm0 C0) .'J.0~ ~ ~ ~~0oO'0

0. wCW'-0WlO0)wZ U0 )0COD0C 0CO N-tz mmm w O ov Ot -VFXU -. cW ~ - -1 N~ N~ N~ ' tN r; 4 U) 0N - N N N N C 4 Nl N1 Nl NI NN

-- N CI N4 Nl N4 N Nl NI N4 NV N

*

* ,* 0D

* ICCDOO N.,

W-J O

u-I00.

coi~

NmwC'0'-C lww0-00000 ----- C00 0000000000O~ O O O - - -~ 1- " - NN

I C N 0 0 0 0 r-- C D C 0c. . ! ! .! .' . . .U . . .1o 0o0 -N 0t -tD1

~ 0,0 7 L. .o- a a o o o.a . o o o o .0 -~ :ttttt tts )@0~~ 0* s vS ttt 0Sl vI

000000 -------Ct O CzO O O OO C -OO OOO

Cli W 0o ooC 0 oo U o ) * 0 0 0) coqv t- 0 0 N v O vtu N* I Dt-- qs-t1 -n

0) - N - L --- - N a Ca a Oa a .a O a a a a I N 0) r- C' 0l ( O- 0 I'4 ') -O U) N C000 . . . . . . . . . .o00000 0ooo0 U-0Cl ',c'

W

UC(n

CD

waa.

C.40

vO (7 I IV

1. . .;q 0 0 N- r-

tnDU) cI,, . . .

M r- I (D-u

M N4c 10_ C

I0

3 -0-J0

--oU. , n

3 -.0 -i-JoI'co-i -

**

z04ZNOIt -

. U

- yLa UwcJa 0

owo W-j J UCKI ,

- I - I xJJJIII0000'~cO Oo cO Co Coi :E -i D oI-

:)- J(nLUu,Wr

Cd

0LLU-pI-Z0C)

CDLJir4

*WnUA Um _

CL 13.

*UJ 3= 0

-J

IXAt0 3UJ U. -j40. M U.0z000LLJ <

< >LDUW - - t

. 0 - 0.0 0.co F- co 4 I-4<S4>4 4 4 Ci -01-01-

- 1-0.1-0. 10L00000O 1 a C o

C.)

W U_Z C)0 4z a0Z S00 C)Ln wIx I-.LlJ <r> z0

_ z I-

U) <

U.

30-JU.

00.4 >., Oc" --:< C) 4 0

I-Z~o0uc O O,. -o J

In-JU-

0.o

*(3I-

Page 195: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

40"

cnN

~00000~C4.~0 000000 -. .

0 0 0 0 0z

~~0Z4Z . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .*-I 0 0 ~ 000000 N > - t

~ ~~00~~N o*

..o - r00 ..... CZ X

wC.00 0 O O 00 O O - - -00 00 W 'q 9 D 0 0 t (D W r r-O * : Om o m 0 0- CM 0 FzDO

q -j 0 -C Z . . . . . . . . . . . . .r4 tZ I- 0 .J 0 >- O 000000 -Ij Y -C I I I I I I I I I

WOM ~ 000000000000

- 0 * XWW N *N ~ rN MV W M ot~~~~ Z C1 N CI 1 D 0 - N tt UM ts C0

C.0 0000000 --------lJJ O I t I I I I I I I I I I I I I

w 0 *z -sOVO WO -- o VM, Mt n0 oz~~~~~l IY 0 * N -tt-t r- M - N -0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .° °-. O ° nO O OO- - - N0 ]Oas C C O

O Q - Dl - -Nt D0 - 0> 4

zz' w0. Z t0 I { - 0: -Nt t

L.

Page 196: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0uiC.,QC.,'

0)I-.4z0I-..-o

Z~~~J ui

(f LU

w 0z

) wwJO .4 Z '

w W 0 - E U) UU

CZ cr u Z

O~~~~~~ w> w

) U) U)W Z V .C Z 4 n Z

- - z m? I C;w CZ CZ4 I- . > W?W .4. W Z C XF

i (U) U w U,) J W'- ) inU)r ) I U)c.4 I .4 I- a .4a v) U n 0 U) (A

Page 197: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

f..0

0 <LU 4 C4d

ON LU

IrI.t, 1

0+o F ~~,o ~-.

w 49 CUN U U)04t I '

0

CZ LU Um 0 <

CL) L ILU. I)

~...LU

I- Q:!

, a<I -a)

UI---r-V'UJuz

LU

0.

LU

a-

I-

N'-zLU

o

JQ3-j Uu,

0 zIV 4

V Lu

U ,V)-J

Lw o(flu'JC "z i0

LU LUI(..,Z

Zz0z0n)

Ziz

0.CL('

Page 198: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

O , N C4O I0 CQD mO

00 0 D 0 + 0O O r- O O c T O I O O c0

N1 r. M IV c Im O C, CqOt U,0cn cn r _

-J.4z

lN

000000 0 00InCN

I-

zLU> 10z.000 0U

0.'-i I o0 '"N-O

_ 03 CYOt-~C')C'd-

~I0-q o- o 00N0 0 00 003(0. . . . . .' 0

I 0 0 0 - N

LU

Z Z 0 C00 000o 00'-wI0 > . ...> Z I OO -OOONON 0 N> U U)

CZus "I-4

-

IU

IXU)

cCIU)

I I I a I a a0000000immmmmmm-I Ji Ji J i J J JJ

00 0

~t0~0I 0 ) N

(0 Int

0~0

coI I-..4 . 0.\N O N U)

If - N- C0t.o

0, - 0D UO a oL r r

N

0

.Ion CD En-i Oi OL

I-J(0 04 01 I JWIOLU

0 ,00 C, + o -n 0c

0 co -'T,- o U7

0 0 t...

00 '- U N

+000800

_ IiJ..LL0 0~00 * *

%... c- jO

I- -fI-. .j

0

04

UJ

IC0a Zw ww 0>. LZN NO< er U

O- le Nr-t _. _F O) CD

C'4 ( n,l 4 . .ON.O iQ

zUJ

0 >NLU Z

0: LUI0 >>LU ZON 0

.J

z0I-

N- Z

L. I--

VZ 0

LU

ITLUW<

U' I,_

LflU .J r,.

4.-

J.z <0

LULU

LU >

zIn 0

l ClU) >z

0

4 U,0 4I-i m -JInI&.-I-0

0.-i

< I C.)

CZ Z L LLU>J

>.>-0. i- 30 -9-ZOI.u ~'" ,Z >: U

Page 199: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

APPENDIX D

Methanol-Water ColumnSimulation

Page 200: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

X2 N

Z C -J 0O co; zQ ~~~U)LU C ClI- I _

4~~~~CI CX

3 -zIJ I Iz ci xZ CM X~~4 Z KI >

oU~ mO ~- "lo IU ZN V 1 N C'

./1 ~Z ~ * I X

~~Z 1 Z 1 z 0 mt IcZ 0 c 0 KOZK I ~Z

1-44D I stU. - - U 4 - X.< QN O.K QN 0 N4m 0tO>(Z 01: m0 - m 00 )-la In O uY z (D -

*-i LU 0.Cl N

-i<z - D 1t1 0sIL -I N CII J:03 LU00)rD.J0U4 t D N 04)

U) Z LU O -J4 0 I O 1 0- 1

0e I V) ' 00.4 tU X X ' C- 0

* CZ z 0 U GD W O. U J ~ I IL 0 0. O W

00I -' i>U)Oc ILfl ' UJ CI (D V7 0- 0 > I0 m0(1)1 - Z Z L. U V7 Z

/ Q K1 FU) 0l 1Z 1--*1- , K0 Z F0i

-J1 oI Z a oa J o.U ICwI- (fliU) ZK :lE Q0OU

l- 0-41 tZ0. *-0.Q '

0QOO J

iU 0.

I

))33

0

ClN

O U)IO

_ 1 IJ. .. Nw a'-UU .Cl3U 0)w C14t

3 0

z Na- .0zI0. LULU I-U) 33 00O 0

UK LLU.'I

10 33 L0Im s3 uJ I--.1 . -

0

0omC)

0 C

I~ O O .3Z i CZ

nO m 0~0J U) - - Nt U O cC1 >i X 0-1 3t Q

Zr-C ci >

> ' nJ -K .1 I-. II(A 0 0 N 0z o C) 0U

<W-<amaQtZo

3 Q f -' o U0001- c* l > UX -. 3l-L Ow'LLuK

.U 4 . U

L 0

* Um . .

Page 201: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

_ - - - N N *q-'q*

.U) U) o

.0. . ..-. .W

.4

* .. - *=-

ZZ * S 0 * IAJ - ...Zz *z

000200 0- Z.L..U W

uJ L U 44

0- 3 3 0. (Z* 0 0 2 J*i -i 0 >

* .LL UAn:3

0*ZZ

OU-Z9 LLF H1

0* · ·

LULI.CI.

xW I-ULLJ -a.0. (w0.00

.L-440.- .

;I ..L

.U.I

::a.*L.* UJ

.3*3

.

. v.U.

._0- -

. IO-

0-

0

I-O

4C; U

o CaL.I.0

CO co c 0 0

Uziz

0 0mmm O

CZo... .,.. . .. ... . .. . .

. . ..

.u . .11

.. .30.0. ''I-- * Z~-

.00'

mcO0>* 0LQI a

* U >*

* lO

wa,40.

coC4e4

N

.40

z0I-NI)Nt/3i"ZD XU I-

QM 04Z(n oLUJ

C:X LOU)

m4 W

W O I-

uI--U40Lu LU

LU

tYz

20z0

UJ

zLU0.(n.4

Page 202: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

'-4 ~ C I a a0 co 0 34 a) C i) ! o C- oU)

. . . . . . . . . . . .

0+0 0 0 00a) a) a)ClN'C-N

00000Or-00 0 t-"-C.) .C) .

U.uL.

I-iC)

,cx

*

0O+IZ 0 0 0O O C3M O a)

ZZ ( CD (O ' CUA .~

0 000000-O 0r-r-Z j . . . c . )C) -.4 0 In m

0=D

U)ZO

ZQ -I

X,>U I-Z Z DED0.z co c

0 t m n z wom _i o I >0

>=UQUZxmQUO4IWZ I-0 0

0u

GoWCL40

I-i- 00

NZ-o- W

utiU

._1_ XWXIC 3

O .U * w

C C >Un, 0C >=

az0 )

Z zO Z>.

WCZ IWJ. U)i w oI-"' I--0 LU

o z

3zLn 04 -j

LL.

C)z-J

iiI11I II

UXa a3M S I

0

UCZ0. M

n cnO0

C

l Cl

uun

I) I

M U WI0 3 (

Ur IV 3 S

I 04 0

0[zm00o

- 33

C: z

UnYU0-J>.co

> UJre- En U- C- Z

> UW Cy

I -. 3 LL

Z . 3zz -j0 <U Z0!- '=43M I--

x U 0. I-U) OiW o-0 o)3 x-J z 0U. U

usUz4c-J,co

I--I

uJ

0-JLU.

-J-I

C

0

En430C)3UV)D3M0 0.Z 3M U)3ui

Page 203: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C4

m

0.go

z zo oN~0

lL. L <

W

a CL ce4~0< CL C41 (no x I

zz

00 0CX ~ ~~ CD a O CO O C N D J z IV ~0 Z I 40~~~~W -U)

JO a LLLU 4 > L E ZI x 0 d

o z o

Oi Q O:Cl Cl40. W Nu O Ifl>

1/) E Zo4-U

Page 204: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C)

ui

· - N>l N O

0._ >xsx,~x :E--------XOOoo>0.0.ZZ»Z1ZZX0OX)

NU

0

"IIZzJz-zJ:z>JzzX X X

M>I>-XXX-XXXZNXXXZZ >XXII00ZZCf ZZ>0 )O0 _

.N w- .O

ClL L>I00> 0 0 fl» 0 0000O0

C, JL. XXMM V V V " N X-J ZZ-- -- - XXOOO Zs-) te I x > -J > -J > -J > -J = M > -J > -J-w0

41-4(>jX)X XX ZZ XX -

W-> W"IZzIOn»zz>y00In*OJCI 0-J LU 0. 0

0ClslU 0 _ N

0 " -0 o Z 88808800x _ _ ;;;;J108 0zooo00o 0sz ss rs>>E z -ZZ N-Z Z -JZ Z O" O O >-J O O -_ZEz z~ );EOO

Cx I > -J > _J > -J > *_J > _J > -J " X > -J > -J > -J > _J = D > *-I -u x 0 I 0 ux u= ux v ao _,

Z U0

Ul w X X Xn (n 0 1

4 .CI

Page 205: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U.

LU

.4-i'Ucx

* OD* 0U

zo~~~~-m4

0)'- t) - U)C* C 4

a.Ul 'U UJ Ul UJ Ul 4U1) 0000a0 I9-3<<z < < W

0

0 0 'U

U. b- Z

ax >3 cI -, 00 0 I-. U)

If I- a-

I- -04 0. Fcx~~~~CILCL

0:U.

m M

I Io o

co cs

. . . . . . .I

000 4'0)

00000or-* . . . . C.)

IC If-0CI( 0w 0

0t- ClI ILO(~I

i i

00oo~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4

0-00 - r

0(1 0t~c' .- 4w D Cl Nco)0 N 0 tr I.c (n _ .

0cx 0 0w' cl 0ZZ - 0) (

I 0) CD0 '%000000r-OcZ Ji . .. C . .4 0oIA mIn Ji4 '-

U)z (-* z* U* m

o.OCL.x

-J4z01- NI-z>I-z0U

CD

OOOZIIO I N J U U; Z I I U

I0C',xU

co0O-+

ICD o00

0t-r

ce N.- > Otrr =' I

'U -J cx Coz .-J -J - -Jto L ( m

(iU) I-

IO-0I~-

wLa4a.

CO

Cl"I

4a

z0I-<ZNO ci- -

n, I-D UU. .U

WO00 0oA o. IJ0 0

0. U)i _;

w JO4-.UW -a-Io

z0z0tntx'U

zUl

0.U)4

Page 206: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

cM n CD (D IV?'U ? 0? ?0 ?

888088go00 00 088oo8 . . . . . . .00000o-0ooo

* U)* 0* 00

0. .44 0

Z~~~

0 0

ZO~

4 -J 0:0 8-4

CZ m

L U)Z * ._. * U) D CW LU 0 0* C, I* 4 L * 9- LU U)* U) L0.

U)CC ~J UU) D

I- 00 0

ZZ<4 L ZZwc W c LUC 0Z z

CC - £U z - Ca * E)~)(C,* =44<i0* Z:£Z4m

*

LU

C W-J 0U) 04 LU 0.400 0

O 0LUOZ -lU00LUJ

UJ LA) a IL 24 ZL

CZ CL aL Z Z-I- U00-40000I O

0.0 z U)00Z40Z IOMOLWUI-- W I--

J 1L Mw rn-a OLUI-l-CL,Z CL-C4 0

C-J 4c J O 0.0LU 4000 OZI- C LZO a-8-4 CL - -J1

X CL t Ul D-JZO0-X 4 CL _ WJ

x F- zxz ) Z 4ZLUU2Z(0

WC)

W 0 Z~~Z~OOWOOZ ~ ,. Z J OZ- U 0 J - O 0CZ CZZ U I -< J J

0 0 0 W W 4 O4ZL ww n >> zJ<<sns - r U< . ULU

OZZ-00C1 Y ZZ Z<Wwom-< < U 4uiLULUJOWIs' 4004mw

6- - U- Z Z'I-- .J U) )JZ r0 ZLwZZO 0ZJZZLUX OZOLUW 0

) CLUI O0 1u. 0 4UU)0CL440 m u Wu M LCLOC <OL w J CtCC00 -J z0momooozzzWMMM.0M<40UL ULU.JK(LU

WOI.~..J-w33U)00010>00 LU0-JO. ILL lLUZ..J..J> W4000CZm=U00 U 0 LI-. WjW L LU>

< C O - J- J ZZI- 0J CL " -. <<< 44 n0<0U0M.MEWLU00C00mozzoo ommwwux>.0-I )00 0 3 U)0. _iZooUzmm -c4.4zLU'J JU4 01 0 0 -

0'-4Z8-4000 J 000L 0 '-'- -40 L CL C CL Z X Z 1 aX F Z-wwx m x S : "<nuu) 1

Z<:)ZZZOOO-xxO<

V) Uzn u

4 it

0. 0. <000.1 I-00 4-J -J -J

W Wz a z z

IZ Z l CL fIL Z,_J <

0. CLJ J CLU ) U)00 ZZZ0004

- X * CCZZ r1 g.4X1 4 C

00 -JJc

ZZLLUO

WMZOOOzz z i--i -ClJ J -LUX LU 4C LU LU LU 4C

oommm oocWI-U.0.OIL4U CC. CC 0J .

IZ U 4. ULU ZO00 IL ZZ J0C0

- z s * o J 00LU

Ln

LUJC,40.

I-40

O00_0 00~ _c*ljC) - C'

0iii0 o ,0000 o

(D0

8o 0oSd§ cs o o

0 0

00w-.

A0

C _* o o

000088I Iq

Oe'

0'0 ' )

z0!-.

NOCZ

Cm 0

U W-Ju (0 leW Ua0tnaoIt ca

c: CD

!-J

WC n U) .4-4WI--JUJ J L=r M

0Z

I.-

:3ZC.,I-

uJUl3

Ix

-J0-0-J uJ0.U)

CL0.

C)

z0-4 0

toeI, I I-

Z0U) CCC Z -LL I-.C

4 a,:LL.

- ULCN

*

WLUI-

-J

I--JCU)0

* I-

-J* 0* I--*

,n-

U) I-0I-FXI U)

0 0

* in.* 4* >

LUC,49I.-U)

U)LUI-J

iU.

CL00.

CCLUl.4I- .I- .<I-

X -J-J-I. U)

L i-a

0LU0.I(A

0.*

Page 207: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

c-Oo0 ,,. 0

_, C- cn

*

U(-U't

V)LUJn,

***

co co00+1 4

0 Dc 0 r* e - -

r- IC

IIIItcnz tmx mI I x: = aO 01: z z :3:co o mm o ~ s,w -i-i i m oc

LU 303m i i 0

Lu 3 LL1 .I- L 0 3 LI W L * CZ

<aoa a.Ixz o ffi mw. w _ " < ;I- m I- * > I. )-i1 OF 0. ILU - "-> <4). 0 =

4 4 n U LUI- - a0 0 0

o fai~aofazm0000000o 0000000owI- to - co - ) CZ

I3

J0-1

IC

3 '0--Jo.. J

LU -

n. t.

*

U)

tLU-I

0.

*

**x

*L

0C1 C1NC4 0 0

0 ) U) 0 t - C 0. C'.)' . . C. .,,,o,,o,mmm-Omo

mmmmmma Oazom

0- mCl0 r- Cl 00 D 0C O C' 00O-C') U1 (00 0

. . .! .9 .~ .~ .(0_-0N; VI

LOQ1. .ax0

0 c vOco (DD 0

r- Mm - - M -o waoD 04 0 r-u -'-r-00 o ) o r-0' tD co W(D w D

-0 ) 0 co IcI w t-r -t -a0 mm0 FFrF De

r- m O - c r-c-Cl L D 0 .(i .( ' .

NN N" N ' 'qmvvvvvvv t

C 0 cl o (0Cl U)

CN C CNIV It I

. ..C00o o a0- 0

LO-d

0- C0

(D rN.

C'4 IT'',

1. .

M Cn (D' ) t (Oo)M c

0M 0- u 00M'0MOWW0CE 44 4 4 4 4 L U

m 0 000000 ---- N..N-NNNNN -ENNNNN L

I-U)

T 0 0c-CI .1 .D . -

N C N 1 C'

~- )t0 0 )0 0'- C I C '00)' "- - -- - -- N N NC fC i('dN

*

LL

0CZ

x.

: C0 co (Dt-* 0 CUOL- * M r IN Cr-* I0o r-w IT* U a) 0 I0 0)

. . . .

tD CD al m roCO 0) 0) 0) (0

C') (x0 I0 0). . . co0)0.0.0.0.

000000I . c 000000Ca- an uzl cq-O se Nt rOCN tUO- D LO (D CfQ 0

C4 C4 t 0 co 00 (D L N- C4 i U) go -.. . ! . . . . .

Uia: N w UX D r- M M4I-c)

w0

N

01

LUt--03

Z0a-~Z

. _NO

" o--II/)D L. U

*j o

woI

(n 0 0q ..

W co

- ,LU UlaLuJm rv

C~1i)2:I-4zC)

a.LUU)32I

.o.

CLIa:

Lu U.Zi 0z C

cc

0z _,- 0U) -

a -LZ > zCY I

clzLU I-.0. .W a:

L.

Page 208: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

*

LU-J

UL.0CZ0.

'IlX ~~000* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~

*Otl (cc(0 mw vw lOmCl~~~~~~~~ M LnC VWW -MN M0I 1D-t 4 v O womom t-mO

Lf cn ) C W (D C Oa (7 D 0 - 1 C - IT FC* 4 mo <D cw P) ) 0 w Lo if uz if a 0s F w* OVOWOMMN--N-

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .00OIOC~4CIW0LflU o a ao-XtD tzDuwc

LU

O CIICO I- -- - -- - N NNNNNr )urr0ata . O . . -. . .

UO- rO-

*

-J

L OOb-I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I.

*.~~~~C IO~~S0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0

* CI Co ML Cou - 1- Un om vr-oma m to no V M W- aM N.* .. . .aD tD t 0 O w O* Q a O aU* . . . . . . . . .

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w m o c~w o tI I I I S I I S I S0000000000O---------n O >O -U) O r-O tD

L)- C CO L D aa 0 0 -s (4 cT uM WD t- M M O-C V t- ~ ~---------- 00 ON0U4 ~-.,.0,- Y ~ 0 * 4 *,

LUC,40.

uJ-0

z0--

4 tcKJ

.J ~,)

Ix -Ju,

O00:[ -Jnr-JU

-ho

dLUCZn,

LUI

I-za

ILt/23

Wz0z0U,

0.U)4

(3cxu.0

CZ0Ltr0I-

Ci,i

Page 209: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

z0

" Z

-i QI--NU) JW LUU

,~e40 -

UJ-Jw U) U1

W -J lUW W

z0z0U)

LUw

zWLUU)

ZWO LUX

UU)U) U

rIX n,- z C)

UJ0 UXU) 4F !- -U I CZ IZ Oi

U) U) U)

LU

0

C14

0)

"I

0

I--

uix

(040LU

-

.UimU1

_J)UJ

UC)

U7UJC

zU

z0

U)

.J-C

Fj

zLU)0Z0-I,-U

(zLU0

I--W9 <

:C I

.. ..U)

-i I-.I -4

L LUuJu

I-.- ~W (nU) U1

Page 210: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0.LUI-

v) 4

03 wLU

0 .0D3 LUc.:E

04

~u' . I- UEM0 LUI2 U)U ( L -

In

CO "IX I--I.- 03

4z4LU~-IX4<I- LUU) = O

LU

40.

aU

a

0+co,

el0

0.-O0-M

z0I--N'.ZLL-.i ()~ua= LU1) ALU

r 4( LU

.I-

uJ o-W VU)U)LU -.- wCLU LJ1. CZ~ev;

Luz0z0U7

LU

zLLU0.U)14

Page 211: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

a zLUi 0. L.LU LU>. )Z _.1LL ( z Ji3 30 .z:E £1o Z0

I-z0 Z wu1w > zI-Un Z 0tn3 0 U31. .

LU

zLU > 3mZ 3 0 z c3 0 1

> 0 U U)

O" O OOOO U'-

Od 0 _ O + UD GoCOOOOOOMQW OO O t000000~0~000'-'.c) o o o o o az 6 0 o oo 'D 0 0 0~ 0-0-r- N O C1 in -:: 7

Cr CO tl D C

00000000

IC) D O O (DN r- 000 +-

o~ ? o §ot-t-00m0r-w- _

0- -r-It--C') e) N

(

0000000000000'q-

C' nQ-QO OD

0 n 0 C oZ§ oO ~m go--ClC)) 0

00 CI Cl0 0Q ClD

IT-M 0C C _

C14 O c_c

0o=C. . .

I Cll'-*l~ ') m

a: a a a a a: w m c a

-000000000mmmmmmmmmm

. J....LUJ

I- I-JU ) ( 0 0o .4m ) C lI U ) 0I C 'D Cl00I >l "l @l WU)1000Z11001

0

LU

.40.

LUI-.40

z0.4

LLI-U) U)

mwu

I-

-iwo0

-Jo(LU LJ

LUz0z0(UI,

1.1.

0LU

3

I.330I331

0

.4 U)u z U)Q~O <- Z 0 .4(A IL I- U

-J1-4

-JU. 0 C3

-I

ZLU ~ZLm- a. >

I-J I&.

m~0

z ZWZN>1-1 0I-CD0. I- 30 0 -

uL Z LU >..jU a 4

Page 212: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

APPENDIX E

Hot Regeneration ColumnSimulation

Page 213: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0

Z \tNZJ I

O 0Z O- I XO "IZ N J

Qe Z 0

O Z sZZ I X

Zc >I- O N I0 N. X01-.J0 ~0 ')<Z

4 Z N0 0 >N Z 0 0 ZO 0 I In :1:Q 0 Q >I -4 II C IU. tv If N N.j4 < In * 00N.M U< aL C) ID -7 n Z "DI 0 < u)W L W 11.0 J m >0-0 cxw0N.C,0IO CZ'IJ LU Z (O U71

u) - CZ 0. 0 I t 3 .CZl"I C -40 0 -0(d ' -(< 1- O 'N.00.4-JO Q <N O 1

00 -J I > 0 )7 w CD (A CL Y4 0 > I0 U a <1 -ZZ W J I Z Y

I 0 .1 -)J o W Q' -1- U) 0Z0.01- Ql OU Z CZ xO

4 0 Z. cQ' O 11 Q Z 0 0. U I J i = - Q O~wa- 1 (Z .. (O Q. Q

oCl0CP

Z0

.0aooaa0 Z

In..I 0

C 0vs

~.~ # I-I eniI> 0 U000 00

O . Z00

0U. O- C-4~~~~~C

I ( I 00 N I O~ W0ZD 11 ~~~ -- o @'ee 0u >

3 Z CY0r0. 00; ul @, O W O CL X3 IteJ O C s- V)CI( .

" a I at I 20. 0. 00 O Z Q Q NLOCNCWJ 0i-|

ix 3 Z3 w- c0 0 1 0 10. 0-

UD. LA.- Cfwf 0IO I-i U .. ( t C.) a0Z I O 0 w

I- w . I 0.-J I- I- O ~ I O 3

*-.-U. O-O oc * t0cL CZ U. Q )uLZl Eq(JNb 0

a0CY

o

_ 110 a

Z3-n.00 1oNII 001-0II

a~i "- ,

(O Ji c (() U(N.0

0C Q LA.

Page 214: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LLJ

0.co

0gVV

_,oo _ c N #oo ooo,

@-... ....... : .. .. .W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ WI.-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~z

z~~~~~..ZZc 0 (A O0

*- - 0Z .. . . .

o 4i c co QILL . . ..

0W . . . .. .U. * U . . . .

CD- X ZC m7 * - *u.U. W *~Jf ** . 0* *U00S*CO - * z > xW *- - *

-4 Z0043 . ..

L 1 I-' 0-J (LFI- U - 0 0:Z I-- LA U - Z l L.I) 0-.- '. J

D OJ U L W 4 OW 0 0. 0

Ix-Cym 0 0 0.'- UU'I 00 0W00 O J@- Z . J Cfl* flV) *-

w -JJ > 4 00. c W W OX:r U. LAC ) U . U .L 0 * 0 (J >

Z CW 0 0 *t3 J -* Z / I*Z_ *m z. z 0 ,. . o 1oo )

z0L'

>

zW0.In.4

Page 215: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U.I.

0w

I--4CZ--Wq0

0

,

I-IY

I-izJJ.-J C

I-r Z31 IUz ~z> W 4

...J cD.-0 Z ^ 0 Int et -

-J O In4. t, 3Z I OO ~ ..0 -j0. U.

0. I - W mc..1 t?) .-Z?5. JW 4 I aJ

0Inx L I-- Z~~_jm? 0. flI m

W- > , WI 0 WL >er~~ In-

(N N N1

v.- .. p_o_ _

~O Ct CI I

'q" c,- 1',,._.- ,..'N

' 'N CN000 CeI. I.

(N000

*-00*M Om.0 0-Z

0 '88CN(N0-J

I 0m 0

Z0

W00ZZ0

z a.> 0z*Y W *U Oz

0 -0. < YO

-x J4zt0

* -

z00

)N0

)Ln

CY)0

I I I I

000

t o co C- cot~N- coN- NCe4C JCN.- C*eCN 04N N-0-

. . . . . .

I I

!

0000000 0)Ie 0

o r-wMn (a n o

LO 0)0 *OW-U~.~O00 0| O.O C~

00"0000

00Cm 0Ifl c 0 ;

I~o0 N O O0.o o Co t . (a

(D OCN n 0 3: )0 O I N N ( U U O Z~ I )

W-C4.

I I

I.t I'O-an

0.

I-"

C-,q.

qD'q-

!co00OCN

N tlDN N

Ifnco LO

m-

a0

W-0 0uJI-NZ

Lt

z O

I--N7OWt W

0 Iz

,<c/tzt r ty) tA

C3 4'. o ClI0 I - t-

tJ uJ t~

I-.

Wm i.,.zt Z - .O zt0 Z

CIn t0t

1"rlZ I-

tl 3tS Ct

u.,

WAJ 0.O W W I

OI In Io IY I

I I

4 -

i-I 3t/I 0O

0. UL~ C-

W I I l0 I- >

I-

. 0. >tx W _ca: nun I I-

0OOI W

I I ZCZ ui

et'- 0 WLU

V) X 0 > L) XY 3

uaIf

00

~'0 M

0 CO0M M

- .I

0+0U,oawLn O cqr-t .0

. Ck' -N04 It o aY)

IT -Ot0)0qq00--

I ~OO=mCZO I-00z "WIn:L) 1 -t

I- e IL

Page 216: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LJjO.4

o0

wLAJ-4

ZZ0 0I-- -NW

U.W 4LF-_F-

W W

~~D040 W C )0Icox01 x0ICNCNCrd I1 O000Z1004U = T O

Ln E MOO I M(

UiLJ ZU)U) _

WWO. -~<ZZZZZZ -UJ . . . . . . . . . .C

z ~~ U. LA CNOC zK WUZZZZZZZZ Z - -0 0. UUU))UUU)) V) tn I^- mL 0s )U)U U)U) U)U)0U U - 2W X 0 ~z E:E~ i- a.Z UW V) zo UZ W~~

o a.a 0 - 4 >000000000 :> QF-tU F- U) F- tOuj U) 1- O .)3WI F- W 1 0 -Z U ) Zw1W I OYZ Z tD O Z -e.4LU 0 C( e U)0OIC' 0N O - t0. 0. C400 IClCdN(OzDI .- >fiMU) E I 0O QOOZ I I - ILIO,< O _0 Y

Page 217: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

'N (N

*> -j 2

. z Yf

sX 3X 0 UX'-I>-.I I 9 9

0. 1

0 (n > >

0000wX -X-j > j P.Y a a V)

XX

0a~no>>JZxXX>

g N 4- N,X O O O

x sX XEO y Y C= >OO E X x

0. 0.1

X-J

U,

0 zx -x C

o Wn

X

xxxxxxxxxxzxxxxJ> _j > j > _j > _j M > X > -i II I O>>sz xxoo

3 0 0 ; 0 0 ;0004X40

Vn t > > S z Y

0000X0J0

> oj XxC9-40000

00-OQo0

-r>-0. I 3

X X

. X X X X X X X X x C C X . 0 0 J

X>-IOO~j>-n> j zm YY OC wx=>

00888C9 a Wi V > > :

(N00~00o oAx x

> -J - I fn (ny y n Qi 3 CD

.- (N ,-000Xu) X Vn n nin >

0In N C C - -" O O O O OU ) n n n0. I En > y

4

3 n n (n (A 0 S: n 0n (An LI) U)nxIO4 >YXSO>Uy

C,,

WjC,40.

X xZx

.4mI I'a0'

IV :0.n>0 -(OH> 0.u)

aD

0

OI-

4

z z0 0

I.--,x UNU Wn-(0)

..J i-.UJCO.In _J

C ix

0.-- ,X.J

WI-w I >SX Iw w .

X

.4 ~..4- -

(n :0 .0.0

C

2'I-

C.)zOX

8

-J

0.

O° 0 80 0 0 0x xx

m X(9 9

Wz0z

u)C

zWLin.4

U,%y)W

zCl

I-.0.O

00.0

U)

Page 218: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

WCD

4.Q

o0

-C

0

zo<Z-r zNO

. L

U U)

IT

co4UJ tlCD O

t 0

uj O tDS

LAJ O t

UZ0D LL(fSl IZ lWQ I CDzh CZ,

CZ C LW ~ LLOUJ I o

z0 41-Fc LUOW|

l..0 FZ F.-J"W ~-Z

U-L

0W

I.-4.JUUtY

v r- r- w wwN

0 0i i0

* o8 o8* o I* 0 0'- *ig2

N N4 O Un

z4-J4

~ ~~~~ Z^

00 u J

tu UU W tJ tJ S I z -j' - 0 '-0 4 0

* Zaa a0 * W2* z

: E. I-I

I

I-UU

z000O ,

I-

0U) >I- I-

1 ~ WI- Q

00.

0

OONO 00'-C N 0

00.0C.)-J

4z0I-zWU N O

z>tO00

0 0 0

0moLO . O

Cn0

000*C'

000 00LO -0co

..-M .on

IIQ :2I-

C. 0 =

< _- C O o oW V)c CI I O nOCD ) C Nj N NI-

0> t tJZ Ic < s;< zI u

0I ItD tO ( 0_T - LO O0 000N co

0 - C4 CN4i. . . . .

iIm00+

400 0 co 0 1fl,C*0o)00 0C'C',C'3 q'-i n|c

00cn+0L -NU Cl

C C)u' .O~ O N* tOO_

. . _

Page 219: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

o o

6 !8MV (A)0000 8

000-00--0C4 00000_ct,- 4

WD (0{00 0 0§ 00000 00 0008888I888 o 00o o-o u o o 8 8n o m

0 - 0 * Ln 0 0 N o t }I . . . . .. . .~ . . . .~ .000000000-000--

*

* .15~~~~~~~LO.

~WJ 0I- 0~~~I4

0(( LU

I,- 0. .

0. ( (AZ * I-- * (A D

* L 0

* 0

* 4 :* - LU* (A 0.

LU 4.0.- 00LU '-O0O

z 4 LU

I- I-I:Z

m 0

* EX)(* D 4 4*

(0.00-(LU

0-4 L

(Al 0L4 LU 00 ( 0

IC. 0 0.0 w LO 03000 I U. I

MOM-J o Z -LU0000

> (A 0Z4ZZOLU-oW Z : X (D M L - -1- u- z 0 w Z 3- 0..-'..JI -IIZ0 o Lu(3ZU.Z0

00.'-'< og 0z--(0>I( orz mz..Jm4ZLuro Z

z

0((Z LW0.0 C.)

Z0 z-UOLU>0zzI LU U0 00 WOJQ- Z

0.0 z0.OZOZ~(3~

0

_10.0 LU0~(3ZZ - z f-400z

: L -Z

3 ) Z)(1-oW4ZO

LUz4~0-IxCL fL

U lJ00

i- LU - J 00 0 U 1LU 44

mZ~oo-vDOOZ zLO O CI--4 < 4 U

1 C0 Zw ZZ~LULU I-O4ZZ'-.I flcI 4 z z " V) -j V- U ->I u moY J -< 00 Z'C0 ZZCLZZO 3

ZLUOL OZ 4LULU 000. 0CZ< l ~ L UZZ u

0 U.0 r~~~4r~~cn0. U. -J> ZOOO ZZ

OU LU40n.V)a a 0. LLzlO(OA -i OOlO-.0.00flo Z J Z Z- 0 4a < < r :5__ i ix c.

(A0.m z CD tro 0 0I O Q O CO CD=F W Z U- 7:J Z tY OO QO 0z O L ZI- FJf 3 3 ( a 10l~l~ LUt- Q(Ll, z un IL z J W W x ul w 00Lu o 0 - 00 0 0. Q & tr M Z Z I- a

J V ZX X - Q . Us L(3'-i4~0LUZZZ000-zo0<<W

'.4 0 U 0 .U .o a LL

to

0

cO0

L

0

00000 0.C .'O0O

0 008 0000 0O P ,e

000

(N

8OC 8Q~Uur2 o

z0. ZNOI _-

u.

wo0 m0

v i* co( w

(n Vn :).JW--

LU LUtr ce

C~0

.00

U

:r

00.

LUu0.n-0-0

(A2 0

11( X

a. a. c

00 <J aJ-J

a a <L QA

Z WZZ0 -Z ZLU

Z ULJ U < JLU LU L(AA0 0.

LU LU Z!3 3 0 (nioo Jz0 J

zz-

Z xZ

CY a 2 00Qz C:IuO O Z t, I-O.Z(ILI Z X

C):aL. U

Z C)0 4

orz0 a

Z 0If) I-0:LU <.U) L(A C

U.

Ut)

xn>(

I-

JtY

n, tU~LU 40 .ZLU L.

0 LU.u0.Zw

-4J*>

o >Z

zL0.0 0ZOI--'4xZ

X Q "Z( J=

o

"' (3

I.- I

IJ J

-JI--

* (0* I-* 0*

LU J 4

I 1-1-L

0 0 -J

* >oro e*

*

**

LU

4I-

(ALU

o.jL.0.

00.(A

0.*

Page 220: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0+

Ln 00 t- 00 C O -r IV0 O 0cX- '0_ 0S* 0r=0r00(0- 0 0 N0 0 0 0I'Cl 0) C4J CW

C 00M,

CIC Cx CZ Kmm

D J O0 3 ID

o o coa -U3 - I i j iW 3ZCZ0 3

= = a Z_

Y i 03Y iYi - 0 aWI-3L.- CZi- O i-O u.O| 40. :)uL.00 , i 0.

W w a-aZ , 4>Z00 I

I-4r4>4

- ,- m-m 100< >.I0I-(0000000oWI- I - co- CD U CZ

00000000O I t I It I I I 0000000000 0 0 0 r-0r t- r- 0 0 r L N O~w 0 0 WVDFC O Ds

0 0 N 11 LO U (0 (00 . - - - -

I IOI-------- I I I

3 %.0J-i.J0'(0I In> m

-0,, J-.C

, m.JJ

1(0

***

(A2LU-I

U.0C.a

*

*

o20 COR .. .

N T Nl U

0 0 0 e0

0 W 000 -0O~ N .~ . . . . . . .* O* O CS0n4(0O)nC') C' C' - Ct ' (N N

- W co co co 0 I0- 0N N t07 C M 0 ) Cl 0 M

i O0 t- MiUU _= O 'D OgY n 0'D 00. . .

("(C'

0. o4 C'2z 1- IT-

LU IT i-L CN (DC')_-_

INI-(AUs)

01- (MO0 m 0.-. Ln. . . .0t(t0 (MC )

( 0·. .) ') M44(0 O

(N(00-000 O , 00 0 u

I 0 W ,- O CD O* ( 0 0 2 0 2 0 0 0 0q. _(_ 3 _0_0_0_

g mn io 0 oo

0000000i- 0 0 m iD

. . . . . .

(0000

0~I4 I-0000(0 I-I-C4M M

. . . .

IVt Ln Ln Ln

0 O) -04N/CD Ln co

a o) C)o000IV04 004CINCN C..

In un i

000* 000* 0(0* U -e N* C9D 0Ico LO, C'

O00I c

0.. C, LO Cl

I sl N N0 0

(00I IT I

* (00)0)a* (e)1'Xt** 0 0 co* QlfU, Ut

0 . 0

0 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Z

0 1^ a

00 04

n , O0I.VN

00'-

I I I

·. __.000(004(0411)

I IN Q 110 C N (. . .

1Ln co l GO O

. D IT

I N N. . .

co IT If I4 IVO N N N Vi]0000000* ) o -n co ) t-c0 0 in LnW i' '

0 U) ,- ,- -Ln 04. . . . . . .

I I I i I I00000CD o o o o- t NiV-X ,n cl MIT

. . . . .(0 0 ( C ' ((0 ( 9 1 - 'C') .)(

00000CC ('0 -100.-c- N il-n- 0 - N(N N iD (N

. . . . .

uuI - Ni 0 20,I()

*

LiA-JLb00.CXX

I N Ln* 0 0) co* I 0 r-0* C.)0(m02

. . .

Ln ,n V00 0000il000

0 0 NN 0 0' N

. . .

0000; - ,n ,n ,)I I I() CD a 0) C 0

. . . .

0000( 04Ne1lO 0 t 0 _ 01 07 in2 C

. . . .(O0. , .oC'('

C ,-n o ,

) 0 1La ti'V 'D

.J coMo0o0o3o-o-o1. . .

I N CN N000In - I000

·. .

LU

iuI-(A2

wC40.

.-

.o0.0Z

z0I--<Zrs oNO

LUJUW

O0imWn IU 0 IC-j

-i oWC I-A

L LUIx Ix

*

I---I

L.Jw

*v

LuI-

Z

¢30

CLLU

£.U-,CCI--

ceC-,W; Ll.Z 0C0 4z _o~0 0., I-w -ui <> z0Z -,, I--0. C)u _.<(n <( I C

UI.

Page 221: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0~0co ooD0O

co [-; J'(A o (

C 1 00000

00

0,CD

000qD co --

O0O· ,- t04

C4 Cd4000Ll n 0000o

0

IV 1 ID IV 04 M00000000u! e,- 00

ID C- Cr-00 0

- CD.

·7 --.· .

0000I

0000O r- r- D(DD V~. .u. .

00000000I I I I I I I 00008000

M "0)OD vr-r-

00 0-00000000W0, CDI'- 0 0

(00 10) Ln w- U,) O

*

-jLA.0

Ix0. >- 0

*0~* 0 r- -* cq Ln0C'm* IV 0) co* Q (D cn -

* .

c "C in r-0 r=0)C INowmmvwmCD(CDCDDCDCCDCC-m0mmm0o0m0 0

0)0)0)0)0

voDC'dC"Mmv0000 --I l lI I I

.0000000.00v v DCD'- N N N w" wt- O-'-eOr-

LU

In

Lu

0.40.

0

o.

I-

0

I-4ZNO

0in

-JOWO LL LUJ

00

0'-'ZCN00. 00

U* (O~v

LU 0

t00-

0.>- 0

I

C

uJ

C)

I-.

I

.)a :

7 C0.I-.

zC C

7-I

C2z -a. Ciit) <.

U.

CD to i0000~00

0 (1I'-.D.

000000*0 ' Dc00' '-

000000000,4 I'-'-'-C0 0 0'-000'l- ;

-

In

Page 222: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

C,

0w

L-

z=. . 0I'-4N

ZlY O

UI---ICU

LLF Qn E

- ' LU .Sj z

) tl Oj )s% - 1: Uw* V ztUWLI-LU _)

C.C. 1-n En t

E1 < < UJ Z> X X LUJW En UJ E Oz~~~~~Z LI 44 1u Z)

Z LI, I LL C* Z*a 0 o En- En En EnEn Z' E Z En Ix C 4I 0n 4n z .juil - II

> F zZ Qra. . w3 S ~ ~~L 0, LA 0

Z~~~~~ M :E :x m coz -i -; UJ * =),n En *n En a E 0 n

a vU En o En Xnun

Page 223: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

0.LauU)C9CYOI-

nO0F-U0I

0

X ...... ~0 I- -j

0+04 -

LuI 0

r.0*

4 0LuJ Clx

LuF- e~

Im 3.co I.,

I UJ4Lu--

.- Luu( CY

LuIC,4CL

0

oL

I-4~

z0I-.4N

Oz

J LU= .. -UC) U

Lua

.a IT -%

J--Uo

W4'-W (A-J oL Lucr cx

LuIz0z0

LuJ

zLu0.WU

Page 224: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

000000

N N0o4 t o0 U)

4 00

LOOZ00

oZ -z I IO0I 0 U)0

C03 0) 0000 0

C0003cr-in .C.. .O- o- o a u

- ^ 0 Nn oo 00 o 00 0 oD

0 0 -0)'- c,* t( X3

- CqI)

I I

0

0 o

co(Or-C')'.'-.,

11-)0

0

r-r- 0LIN 0 0O

C) C' (D 1-0 0 t- O oo' r W,-(N

000

'.-0 (n 00)' ('C30U1) M0 - 0*010U . . ,In (N 0 0 o

-C) eNI

O .j -1 - I - -i - I -I'0000000002222222222

Lu

) . (D Om0 CNl t (lO" I(o x4 0 0 I N C CN C IU)I1000 OZ I IO t

o to o

0 . 0-WIVL

0 00 +000)· ,

CvC)0I'o +a

00

0. O (D0) ('3 0

o'o!tO +C) 0

0 0 CII OO

CZ.I02 -nm oI.J u. ff.

:co cnt03 U )-i4 0. --- O.1-1- 0.

0

Lua,40.

0.w z

> I U

0.0 WZi. CY, Z

C, 0I- I-U'"t0

0._ uj

nIx a'- LaI--n

0

I-> x

o 0CN

000.~. ! .' O O O-qtq0 0) Un 0 NCO cj 0 O) a)0 0 V 0 T

O N CS~mo~! C')

Q O 0 D C0

I . . . .

O-I-0'q cwq

uJ

0I-

N0 "z0 0

J ~O ~nWI )

uW4

O

LJ0

LU Ocr2

i.

O _C,- I

Z L)

1 1X l-rlII-CZLL"rzz0

U)

0 C D

o-0 ('0o0omo.~

zLui

z0U

z1.11

z00

0

2......4 Un

L u2 UnO 4- Ix -j

U) LL F

t-(D0

C')

9l'I--II -i1 .a 20

I- l- m.m -j

0. > >1 0. 34 U 00 0 0 -I < 4 r u)Ix L I- z Cl

Z LL U Z >L. > J 0 4

Page 225: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

APPENDIX F

Water Wash ColumnSimulation

Page 226: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

N N0 0I

O coe , 0D

O0 r C - oCl O 0)*Lfl 0) CN 0c Z Cl

O O Z Om

C o0 0 N0 z aCl Cl* Cl l ED N w JI Z O Z 10 - WC4 0 X * * - 3

: . o ~ * o >In C'C' (0 -~ .0 I0 .0 1Ol 0 3 U 3l x' ON t0 N 034I _ >. 4t OC) I=I 3X C 0 I cI 00 O

> to o LO -En I i 0 00 C Cl .- 0 "I U)N 1 EN.I I N.w ED 04E ClO -4N X . 0 * 0 O0 0 CD

U x '0 C) I r .U * * ) 1C ( l I * .(O I 3 - (0 U '-00 · i- C- .l I E , I 0 0 ·O n > I

0 IU 0 'a a0 U I

U Z N v >) - oZ -q > O ( 0N. t) N. 0(0 ID N1F- 4 0 - C4 C'- N I CUlE D t aN I It 00 O ' -E D 0 0 >0

tU En0 1 -0j 04< 40 ON. 0 2 M> O.CO NO Q NU O Cl1 4 41 ' n M Cl 0 * o (DO 0 :I a C'l- 4 0 *. C )- 0 c-lClE X> -X '' U f O O tn *Cl > En 0 t1 01 O I> I -0.o "- Nw * O 0Iu 3 1 0

I ox c0 UE NI IW NI . Cn L '-3 z uE/)J C a 0 O I xf0 o x x N. o. W v -c w o 40 O U ClI '-J N t) OROt- C f OC 3 ON . 0 3 (.) O..JO..4 C O 3O 3J 3. 1 0C ' 10N.-o I Cl N- 0O WC ' c4 0 o m ( X c )ODC' w 4 C' )C't 1-. u I I a n=I ' 4NmIu o Jsn* e uO *ClC'* *fl0U= *l- > 3 0- *

n Fo > 1: -U 0 n uzi ( ax *- um I uz o4 uz 3M cTZ- u o

W li z(Ayn I-O.>-CZ' 4U O. l10010030 3L U 0 O.0 0. 1-4 L)N..JnC Cl0 -C N'C100 UN *E~ NI sOOO O*R <U 43 W Cn D) a * ) O *CI-'-Ca *- -C) Z 4 '- -J3 IC0L 44 O0 I 0 0 u Z-UO . - R O WCt 00ED I-'- Q. En0 Q vnc' tn. Q 0O -t ON> >a W Q 0s ENN.40 1C~1ll-CNlNlE l Nl1CC Iu Os-. OW > - 0Cl FnO >IIwII a I I a aII I Xm a O J 0( 0N Ir I *0Cl3 I I 0OC-- 3 3 1 3 3 3 O z v U. 0. Q

E W U) C.0 CZO wO '- 00 Y a3 0 -a- CD >00E 4tfl.FJ (DJ 1 J ..J CD.J Cl.. t l 311431- wQ-3

1- ZZ C Z 3.z .P - P. I. Iu En 0. 0. XWI -E C L. -4--* ( 1 >. >J LI U) Q U. l m . 3. f y-.- >EW1-. 0 0 0 0 OW..J..JIO!wz taO 3 a-WZ- 0 IY 0 QZ 1-F 1 1- - J J -J10_-a 0 0.0--U'E En En En En it m *-

Page 227: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LU

C,44".

Cl - -- N It V l F t- X 0

N

U_ . . . . . .Z , ..... ... Z... .. ·.... ....OS *^* ... ...Z .. *. ..~ . . . . . . .. . .-. ..

. . . . . . . .<.. . . .

~ ~ ~~~ . . · · .~ .~ ·U 0 . . . . . . 3. . . ..N : · .. .LU LCl * * *-CI.

Z ~... . . ... . Z~ Q .

0 ~ ~~~~~ > 9 . , ,,) .* * Oz O * .

Ivw * P- m- - ... * a ~ - ..*o e < I) _ . .j . . . ... U) . .0 4-j z z = in .)(( *UL. CO z z -j U)3w ( (4 Z z * >-a * 3Z I z S U F -.z ..... . .

in 0 , 0, ..... -j . .U) -- IL -- * L -0 * i *X . O * * ..- .( Q- 3Z 3J (j) . ...- .U wow-JF 1 .. .I1 a > L.. Z. X O 1 3 U U U U . 7 *. 0 0 3 >4 20 0 3 i **4 0 * Cl W J 1- OQUZO I fl 1 3. Z(nO '- 0.J tYfI. U) I-) @O

LU'-'S UWL-U _ 0.ZV UJ ) Z O1-4XWu V U J Z Z

WO0, -Jv .JX I I lX t Z LYNLU 1- 3 3 L400Q O - W34

I:L LLLUO UUQO z LL Z0a3 >3 Ci) . L

LU 0 > 0 Z ..J I I I-0 LL Q. Li)z

z0LnAt

Page 228: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

U-U.L0

Ww

I-4-JUJ

UW33

F- U Ow~W 0O w3 WO~LL0 3I-U03034

I

N

4

WO Z> s S U-C z

w (A uJ u mI-U- Z 4WU)W W 10* 3 :*.43W 0 vZ C L CY U -

-6CL3 W 4 W>3 nU) 3 w

r 3=> cz, vt 4 W3 3Z 0 00 :C1 C4'-I ILLI- W

1 = 4 OX -IXU ) I Zt- -0-c3 3 W2 4-420 a. D3 Yo 3 C4 7(OX m03(4 N 03 W3I 0 W >

0 n) 0

* I-*0-0

s

Z4.41

00OOO00OOOONO____ . ____! I

00cocol

, I

I c I I I I I0000000r - r CD IV0(D - t- 0 LO-0 o co aO -

000 C' C) 0

q n F nC0 * (DN~ 00C,) C-) *. c C* t _ N

0W 0 NZZ O Ln

Z -I *'4 0S -4 '-

00co 0 0

T to OPI.00 .- r C r C'DU'10r-I

00

LO) 0 o o oC)0cn 8O o

CN 0 * D) 0-N - t

-- 0I I

otO C0 N9

r- 0OmmI I

000

O l. - (O

t C ,- r(D - .

OmoCO if)

T N 0(t 4C

I

z· Z· W

z Z0

0O \

Z 4000

z I-mC coomwm::Z N ~0~ O J F-Z I°0 0

0 F-

W

4M

I xI- XXV)U) I 1 -4 .39WI 200 3 3 433

W) I I I

C )I I I:)3 1 1 1001

z ns L o

u a n NVC 3 IF- _ C N atn U c. ox o

> > s10(4=

210

U)0a4C

F-4

z

o z

, O3 i (*S W-W u

31 3O

in0 U

-i (AJZ F

4) C

w u :u.Z I0 3I-I 0

I C)

S _J

U.

I I0u3 33x 33

wO IxU)I I

3 -a3I I020 IU 3

3 3=

240 C."-

W UJ LL 3I-U 3 . =U)3 -I>3-4»)

U0CO0

-

I-

zzc-

uiuI-30U.

Page 229: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

CN

Cl

Z OZzo-JO

OwOU)

31 J

t 6-03C. L N U)O ZO < ZZZUZZZZZZ -

0 U)

w f 0

oX 0. 0

0 0

Page 230: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

004 Cl

z 5 YXMO0X

_J > JW >

q, ..- ,e,m~..U3~>

0xx-JI> J :a LO

X xz xX xiXXXXXXxXIXX XXX-I I c 7 o v 1> Y

,uc O SC-

:ZXfXXXXJ0 0 C0I > J > J -*ZyCl)1WZZrS00u)

XXX XXXXXX)<XZZXXXX-

Jzzzzzz>-JzzzIJ > t!> - > :E = > _Y > _J mooow>>ZZXIcOO

xOO--> -J X O 55XX5' > -x x x

0088

). .

0-- X O0 0'o X -888 o

U)0.0.II>I>I>>>>CX o Q QI IO -> , , ..O0-> -J M:' > .

XXXXXX5IIZXXXx5J>X X X >XZXZ ).0." XX >-J

Cl00Z000000--JwXXXXXXWNNN-0O-ZZZZ-00000..J-. I ) U U ) ) ) ) )U)U

x

IV)y L Lx

xxxxtnXXZZ-,wwoomtInowowU U U) yU I U) U) U) U

C)

LIUC,

0.

JX

>. JQ Q .0 I

Ir x

0>0-'Owo IU)

_ :tX X C C):E z -I>iXX

= > QL Q :

CM)

w

CZZO: -J --UO1'ru W-wo w3 1-

O

0.

-l-I

z

L

aLI 0 U > >

0.

0II>. L I

8

Q. I I

w

zI-z0

0

0.0

888)

X0 zI> J>

Ch

Page 231: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

u.

I-4

CZ

000000000. . . . . . . . .

00a I0 0)o 0L 00 00* C)N q 0I)o UD O C

*0 o 00) -* U)N-N 0(D N COt-CI '-(1 0(10!-4 u -c - r

z>

m -00

C LU C)OCC')O1D 0 0O (1 O 9wO

:> N - N 0 l D 0 D 0 C,) . . C. ) .Z J. *-C -*.- .T.40

uxmUU 0

o w I- U)

Z* Z* LU+Z* z00.

O0U-J

z0O..

zLUOC>IUZ0U

'-0I !o

cliMID0)

NC

0. . .co00

*0 00 N 00-CS

a0-0 ·00

.a

0cCN-

CEIOI\Z I N400mm

.- j-J-J

(DO OLUU)LAI -i mo4~cIccI(OI.i0

UUZIIUU4IIE0 <--(D0w j(N e )0 -

O~vNWXjO

-zU)

I

C,,00

Cl0-

&

0 +

+04

< IZZIL) V)

Z ~0~'q' I U0* 0. ZI ZLLC

* O+ Wa-aCE* UI0

I -3 4

C LU z 0 w O: U)I F

I-J CE-DJUI 0UZI LU

-lU

IU)30C4IU

CEIL.04

-C

za-.I-Z0I-

U4CEL)

z

0

CLUzZLU

z

V)in

w uJ U L 4(5O L C5 00003-4444LUI-I-I-ItU)U) U) UUttL

0

LUNCC U)LU C 0LSM V)C.0 a4 3 Z30U303 3

I-I- 0a a 000U) >

Z O_-Oz.

L

LU

.J-rX

0000000~0OOOOOwOO-I I It I I Ul

I a I I IIll ll

00

+0 OQ - 0- ·O. (. C .- 0~'

0

0OOo 0 0(o 000OcmC )L)D 0 C')'

-4 .EO0 · . IV

o0-J

IU)I-

* Z* LU* Z

00.m0U-34z0cJ3-Z>1rz0U

-OD a

I t

ooa a0

-Dr

0 'I)t- o

o+o0 Uo0 i

CD

CElY eI D

Ui 01'CZ tz z m >4 o 00-i - -.

X o a X < O I (A N N m i J O ztwomCDOOLU )Iv0 0 1 C ' 4 C C W I .J 0UUUZIIUU4I

aI-

LU040

0C')N0)

0CEI-LU

40

C4

zI

-J Z

300IJO

3tUO40U )

a (ALU O

1IJ

CU

x

33 39CL:t:)

U uU.U)

30.3 0

LUz

I--

.. 0-O.I--I-000.

Z0 r0z x(n ce

o 4

I--Z U. LUZ

(A)_ 4 -

Page 232: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

tn000£60(, Q

VW¶-'-00--'O006cCI' O Q

(DO

00. . .-d 0

0o

0000000

80

8 8§880

0 d?11

000Oo-

v10

o 0§§I

C):0 0to Cs

0 00

* 0 WOO 0.0 -4

wL 0 00 Z4 WO O4 Q ztOZ w < >> 0 0 Z J JJJ

u 0 000 Z 0Z000-0>O0a"--mw ---Z O tO O O I C U < 0 UJ t W -J V7 0eX J at P U 1 Q ZLU z D 11) zwzzJ O ou

* I LOuz wl <Aw L. 0 lJ uZWOW>>0 0n .owI U* Cd 0 : Z-W 0ZuZZwa OZLLU 00 Lw4Luwww

LI) -. lm000ZO Zoooww mlcwZWZZWP-I-Lu..JOc ..JLI)U) =00000 w00 LL. M4(flM<044 OZ400 0w- 0 00 J ZOO OZ ZOO Zz*- 0 0 O 0.-ZU-lxo -40L ww..QMwwwZ"O.* w0O OOO IoOOO4 w0-M-- W3300033000mIIL - Z mom"0 o W J U. 4 I Z Z 1O

4 Z ZOW -WZ-1 OZJ> ( Z40000Zmw00 -A-_>-uW0CL U -I-0ZOZ Zf LuC WZ W- U> u 1 Zm4 000u,-ZzmOQZ0Luw IQ00LuQ00Z000Q00. Wa-" -41 - 4 4 O 0 0 J oJ-. ZZI- OZZU.OO>

I--ZU0 Z 000ZOwmmzwL000 oo0U.ZZ0MZ wI-cwZO0OZZOO OmmWWU.U3Z00J0 L.02I33- c4 -Q. cl-- Ja-O-00l-O) o 3 ( Z OI-Z O0 I '-0 - 1E JZ0OZ -4 0 -J4'-4 zx-0=J. <W0oLuz..j 4 000 _J00Zm .JM D"ZO- 4OOZI00QQ m wooO oozow OO

: DZ - so -ZO ~uOP wZIZw OO L .w-W>023 Q_0JL -- 0000 31 00

Z4XXx-0 Z XZ JJZmz'-<UW"4Zx0xZ44-JO 4 ZWOZ 'Z Z 0 ''000 J002QQ J- 4* = a < QS ~ w O J 0 > J* O I 0 - Q QQ X ~ O X

0

w04a-

a)O~

I-.40

z--z00I-

'r0 UV)Lw

3yUO

'r -- J403In

W J .(n

V)W -JiwO

a

I-z0

I30I

0

c 8c

U)00.CL

0.wCZ!Q'C

a iC 4

L) V)

000

Lu -I-

-J

0* --

* 0* I-

u

Z--Jw 0 -

40-u . 1-c

Q-

* < Ou0 .>.on* -0

00go

oOG0O

U.

vx

o.,1.

*

*

CY

Z 00 4z t

00Z _

Z> z0Lu I--

0 4w.

I-LIuJ.ikLuI-

L

0.(A

0.

Page 233: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

N (N N

NNN0000a ! I IC C C CCN q EPo ax0 0 0% F cN t ) rt

I--N-OC. . . .

0 0 0 -000'-I I I

fl C-U)C4 Co C

N SS ') OZ 0 ) -. . . .

0 in c) 00Co0.0 Cld ld 4 0

w CD CD co0000I I I I* 0000* C4 - c )

* 0 cD a)* IV to - N I

= CID c 0)ruL ux 1I a

i . . .

ICDLDQ 0000

DD LU ICC I I-

X 0000

N0)CC0 00 0O C~ O-0' 0) 0I O

LU UX D * O O r CDuzI IIn +U 0 tD U)CINNN C4 C4 lw IT (Om

M I- M C4 zi I) N I L- ....

co !- IV It0" t O O0 F pt

0000000) 0C 0 (D

NC 0 U)-INDC')C)

LUJW-N CP - C 4I-(A

tD

UJ

40.

co

C()N0)

I-40

CD '-N

OU. CD I

CDONC)

C-C -

(D -C0)0)'-') coCl )N

a IT a

N t0 0 oZ DYruO O O

ZCr r cr

Z

-. ZO O

I-

V) U

3C UWO

3u)

IJ

V 0LU ..LU I--LUO[z,

I

0-JO* 0LL.

'r3--0

, m

UcUJ,

uZ .CL0.

_ _ - C0000* 000 * C O O D* tOO

I - '-

*

I

V)

U,

11 11-~"

0000zzzzIco c Io-J- Ji

*}

Ci

Z'.IZ'C0_

3:1oI

*44

c0 tD ti

. . ..J N ,, (.) '0c0.

U7 L n CIt0000:D N N w

oN -'-ac-C!-ri C

,LC.)CO

*

}

*}

0000WO ) D O Da 0 a c

LL.

I 0 0 X 0000o wII 0I I00 c t ala'O ....X 0000C CD O0* cDcOcNc* IacDcO

* U N tCtC-

ID CD C') CD

LU04 . .

4 - N C").-NU)D3c

W 3P 03a O

Lu I- 31LU --9 0 3 9 t 4x 0 31-I- L . - CZ40. U.0CK CXO L

CL : >z O 0.zOo-LU >- a4 >. 4 >W-< ><

r < ),I-4-J4>4ce c z cx :E

I-OI- 0I-0I- I- IF-0.1- 0. 1- C --

000000o )F o

o,u.

Z Cz 0

I-LU 4

z0zu) 44 CZ

U.

U)

IAU.0Q

*

a a- aa) 0000C O )

* cD0oDC M* (O D CD* 0IT TIT-* o - -__

N N N( In0000O a a a:

'-O-C',N C 0

4 I---@U. . .wC9 - C

U)

C,

N NNw 000

* I CN- * 0D0 0-0* lD C-C Ct

0000

I- I IT0000

I iU0)

Page 234: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

LuJC,

Q.

Oco"I

C1

)m

I--

C4

zI

UZ403w

2i

i wIV) w_ Z(fO 0

4U) C

ZULU

;E

Q.

Io inO Ciin Z

Z -

0.

zwoo

ZZ

U U)C n

1) 4

.Iz .)UZU

WV)V)

Page 235: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

- O O DOW

000 0 0 00 0 '

cl4'C 0

C (DO r. (00 co 0 0

Cl0o9

gtm, td O'rOa0o1. .

-N XI

U)- w0t0-

o

Or((0 o 0 0

C')

I- D ,

Q O(

C)

OO O OMMO00(00010(0Iz I , r-, I D,) w 000o0ODO0V)3 > 00 *(0- * -30 Z tOMMo0t3Cl O 4C)< 1- - 1--JI 0 Z - C)- C'

ZOrnOwC- V)

Z 0 C )

up 0 - M10')

I-. U)

- 1

oO UCl0U

!

0 0 0 8D0 -

O t9l O0 ') s

0 T C ) 1-O O r- Ut

( I00107 a0) t-CDC)

C*D * cC Cd

C') -(0 0"- ') 0--C 0- I OWco 0 CO o

. C4

O D

Cl

m§ 8NOo cU) o 0 VQ)+C O t O 10

O O(D C'l

o Q10

I 0tOdC ' D

a OO

O. . .

010Z(D 0

O 00)(,

tYI -J .LL~~~P ~~ 0 0~

CZ I xI I r I C ES s s sus\ss m m sw0000000000 U)- -

Lu 0. >->z ~~~~~~.J 0.11 IJ O-U) ~ I (00.)44U)0 Cl D O XC')L-1W <r a: c t

00 N tDI O 1YZUILI 2uut)000Z100 IU tL>JU0

3IC'

040.

C. ZO XwJ ~ZU- 30> 3U

(D 0 (D O LO040 C C')co t to

C0 U) t 0 ). . 0 oO Cmf i -0c

a)(A

I.-

U3 LL Z

3 ->tL 30> 30

C U C o 0

r-00o ' O DO-)O

(A4 X3

-0 CI41< x

zuJ

ZOU

Cl

Z

-i00CZ

3 40OC

I U)

-tU)0

w

uJz0z0U)

wuJ

zU).4

0 IZ3LLOZ330

C4

J

IL

U.(rA

UC)3

33

40C.

u4LuLu

33

4LU

I-

. U

0 4Z O -j

U. I-

Page 236: Archives - dspace.mit.edu

o IZI 3>C OZ -J4 o10 Z2 Iu z0

z- Z

- ZZ 0I 30 0> 30 o

0000000 00O O 0 0 O c C

Cl Cl _

Cl c

0w

xZ t 04> L0) .-

N ZZ ~0)0'4 3 0 -C'3 30 I n) -

0

.4 VwI nc O 4

·0o

00

- C

* I000000

N000 00DCO;mClN0Cld w -0§+ ;9 9 .,vto .

W N. = N N 3. 0 c-a0000000000

mn (000.

InOOOZI1OOi

-J0o-i

-J

4 w. I--

*CL >

0 cO

t-O 0 (D

Cl

c 0o 0 cm0000000

000)

S C

100In-z 0

ia.1Zw.t.i OQ

W.40.

W.4

Zz-J0

o131-4U -3w

I3U

UZ

noI cn

< I-3 C

I I LI

< n

CZ

wz0

z0

in

wz0..4

0C-I

N.-1:3·