arctic research plan development workshop€¦ · 1:50-3:00 et/ 9:50-11:00 akt breakout session 4...

27
ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP September 14-17, 2020 Welcome! We’ll get started at 1 pm ET / 9 am AKT. 77

Upload: others

Post on 27-Sep-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOPSeptember 14-17, 2020

Welcome! We’ll get started at 1 pm ET / 9 am AKT.

77

Page 2: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Workshop Goals by Day

Photo: Danielle Brigida/USFWS

Day 1: Establish context for priority research areasDay 2: Define criteria and start step process for selecting priority areas (~12 priority areas)Day 3: Refine and reach agreement on 3-5 priority areasDay 4: Create a roadmap for inclusive and equitable implementation of priority areas

78

Page 3: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

DAY THREEGoal: Refine and reach agreement on 3-5 priority areas

79

Page 4: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

❖ Reviewed the priority area list & considered priority areas with the selection criteria

❖ Reviewed the list and shared insights and thoughts from priority areas discussions

Recap: Day Two

Photo: Lisa Hupp/USFWS

80

Page 5: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

❖ Recap Day Two and goals of Day Three

❖ Discussion of priority areas & goals

❖ Session 4: Refining and clarifying the priority areas

❖ Report out & discussion

❖ Wrap up

Day Three: Overview

Photo: Mario Hoppmann

81

Page 6: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Approach to Refining the Priority Areas

Larry Hinzman, Ph.D.Assistant Director for Polar Science, White House Office of Science and Technology Policy

82

Page 7: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Agreed set of three to five priority research areas for the next Arctic Research Plan

Workshop Goal

Photo: Bob Wick/BLM

83

Page 8: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

84

Page 9: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

85

Page 10: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Arctic Systems Change

Community Health, Community Resilience & Cultural Connectivity, Relocation

Sustainable Economies

Energy, Building, Communications, and Transportation Infrastructure

Refined Priority Areas

Photo: Charly Hengen/USCG

Co-Production of Knowledge and Indigenous-Led Research

Water and Food Security/Socio-Ecological Systems

Risk Management and Hazard Mitigation

National Security and Defense

86

Page 11: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Atmospheric Processes

Oceanic Processes

Permafrost Controls on Ecosystem & Climatic Processes

Ecosystems

Sub-Areas: Arctic Systems Change

Photo: NASA/GSFC/Jeff Schmaltz/MODIS Land Rapid Response Team

Land & Sea Ice

Global Linkages

Predictability

87

Page 12: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Areas: Community Health, Community Resilience & Cultural Connectivity, & Relocation

Photo: USFWS

Wildfire

Sustainable Economies

88

Page 13: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Areas: Sustainable Economies

Photo: USFWS

Emissions & Pollutants

Energy/Natural Resource Development & Shipping

Water & Food Security

Socio-Ecological Systems

89

Page 14: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Area: Energy, Building, Communications, and Transportation Infrastructure

Photo: BLM

Permafrost

90

Page 15: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Area: Co-Production of Knowledge and Indigenous-Led Research

Photo: Jim Miller (PolarTREC 2011), Courtesy of ARCUS

Community Resilience

91

Page 16: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Areas: Water & Food Security/Socio-Ecological Systems

Photo: Chelsea Arnold/USFWS

Cultural Connectivity

Community Health & Resilience

Ecosystem & Species Dynamics

92

Page 17: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Areas: Risk Management & Hazard Mitigation

Photo: Charly Hengen/USCG

Wildfire

River & Coastal Erosion & Community Relocation

Geography & Mapping

93

Page 18: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Sub-Areas: National Security & Defense

Photo: US Navy

Food & Water Security

Environmental Security

94

Page 19: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Photo: Joshua Strang/USAF

Data Management

Education

Monitoring, Observing, Modeling

Refined Foundational Activities

Technology

Indigenous-Led Research

Predictability

95

Page 20: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Photo: Neal Herbert/NPS

❖ Breakout session

❖ Refine and clarify the priority areas

❖ Create ~3-5 priority areas

Session 4: Instructions96

Page 21: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Photo: USFS

Session 4 Process Update97

Templates now updated with 8 priority areas

Time extended to 70 minutes

2 questions; create 4 priority areas

Kuba will send alert 30 minutes before close, to help group shift to creating priority areas

Approach:❖ 5 minutes set-up❖ 3-4 minutes per priority area to

address questions and consider subcategories

❖ 20-30 minutes before close to create 4 key priority areas with subcategories

❖ 5 minutes to close & rapporteur check-in

Readouts to include key insights & 4 priority areas

Page 22: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Refining & clarifying priority areas (Goal: ~3-5 areas)

1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT

Breakout Session 4 In Progress

Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS

98

Page 23: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

We are currently on a break

Photo: Jeremy Potter/NOAA

We’ll resume at 3:20 ET/11:20 AKT

Note: You can mute your mic & turn your camera off, but please don’t close out of Zoom!

99

Page 24: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Priority Areas

Arctic Systems Change

Community Health, Community Resilience & Cultural Connectivity, Relocation

Sustainable Economies

Energy, Building, Communications, and Transportation Infrastructure

Read Out: Session 4

Photo: USFS

Co-Production of Knowledge and Indigenous-Led Research

Water and Food Security/Socio-Ecological Systems

Risk Management and Hazard Mitigation

National Security and Defense

Simon StephensonColene HaffkeRoberto DelgadoJohn PearceNikoosh CarloLarry HinzmanMaija LukinMartin JeffriesElizabeth PowersRenu JosephMike FalkowskiCheryl Rosa

100

Foundational Activities

Data Management

Education

Monitoring, Observing, Modeling

Technology

Indigenous-Led Research

Predictability

Page 25: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Finalizing the Priority Areas

Photo: Mandy Lindeberg/NOAA

101

Page 26: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

102

Page 27: ARCTIC RESEARCH PLAN DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP€¦ · 1:50-3:00 ET/ 9:50-11:00 AKT Breakout Session 4 In Progress Photo: Benjamyn Limle/USFS 98. We are currently on a break Photo: Jeremy

Day 3 outcomes and review

Day 4: A roadmap for an equitable and inclusive implementation of priority areas

Wrap Up & Overview of Day Four

Photo: Zak Rickter/NPS

Action item: Think about implementation of priority areas & what room you’ll join in Session 5. Fill out the Google Form distributed after the workshop.

103