8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

1/115

Project Zero

!"#$"#% '#"%(")* +,-../ .0 1%(,")2.3

456 7.(3) 8(9(#3 +)#**)

:";9#2%54?@ A+8

Final Report submitted to

B#"$*#C* :2)D 8#*" E(9/2, +,-../C

by the

E#*C2%*3) "3% F*//.GC .0 !"#$"#% :.//*

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

2/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 2

TABLE OF CONTENTSACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................................................................................... II

CHAPTER1:OVERVIEW ........................................................................................................................1

HOW THIS REPORT IS ORGANIZED............................................................................................................... 2

INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................................4

CHAPTER2:THEARTFULTHINKINGAPPROACH .............................................................................6

THINKING DISPOSITIONS.............................................................................................................................. 7

THINKINGANDART ................................................................................................................................... 11

CHAPTER3:INSTRUCTIONALCOMPONENTS .................................................................................14

THINKING ROUTINES ................................................................................................................................. 15

Reasoning-centered routines:................................................................................................16Perspective Taking-centered routines: ..................................................................................20Questioning & Investigating-centered routines:.....................................................................26Observing & Describing-centered routines:...........................................................................29

Comparing & Connecting-centered routines:.........................................................................36Complexity-centered routines ................................................................................................42

CHAPTER4:TEACHERRESOURCEMATERIALS..............................................................................47

TEACHER STUDY GROUPS......................................................................................................................... 48

STUDY GROUP PROTOCOL ........................................................................................................................49

THINK TRACK DATA:ACASE STUDY .......................................................................................................... 50

INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTUREAND SUPPORT ................................................................................................ 54

CHAPTER5:ASSESSMENT.................................................................................................................55

STANCE ONASSESSMENT.......................................................................................................................... 56

ASSESSING THINKING:SIX CONTINUA ........................................................................................................ 59

CAAPASSESSMENT REDESIGN................................................................................................................. 60

CHAPTER6:RESEARCH .....................................................................................................................62

CONCEPTS OFART:IUSED TO THINK,NOW ITHINK ................................................................................... 63

STUDENT CONCEPT MAPS......................................................................................................................... 71

REFERENCES............................................................................................................................................ 86

APPENDIXA ..........................................................................................................................................89

THEARTFUL THINKING PALETTE ................................................................................................................ 90

THINK TRACK ............................................................................................................................................91

STUDENT CONCEPT MAP INSTRUMENT....................................................................................................... 93

APPENDIXB ..........................................................................................................................................96

FROM THINKING ROUTINES TO WRITING GOALS ......................................................................................... 99

IDEAS FOR USING ROUTINES IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE CLASS ....................................................................109

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

3/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 ii

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

"#$%&' ()*+,*+- *. / $#&'0 12''/32#/$*45 6#2751$ $)/$ 12&'8 +2$ )/45 )/665+58 9*$)2&$ $)5

12+$#*3&$*2+. 2% +&:5#2&. *+8*4*8&/'.; ?; H&'*5 G/&',+5#B 6#*+1*6/' 2% I2+- I/,5 ?1)22' /+8 >/:"'%*5#*B 6#*+1*6/' 2%

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

4/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 4

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

5/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 5

HOW THIS REPORT IS ORGANIZED

B-2C #*H.#) H#*C*3)C )-* H-2/.C.H-2*C= %*$*/.H*% ;")*#2"/C "3% #*C*"#,- 023%23

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

6/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 3

Appendix A 23,/(%*C )../C %*$*/.H*% 0.# )-* H#.

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

7/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 4

INTRODUCTION

U3 V,).9*# .0 5>>?= B#"$*#C* :2)D 8#*" E(9/2, +,-../C _B:8E+`= 23 B#"$*#C* :2)D=72,-2

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

8/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 5

B-*

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

9/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 6

I.

Works of art are good things tothink about. This simple premiseunderlies Artful Thinking, a programthat helps teachers regularly useworks of art in their curriculum inways that strengthen studentthinking and learning. Used byclassroom teachers across allgrade levels, as well as artspecialists, the program focuses onlooking at and interpreting art,rather than making art. Its goalsare twofold: To help teacherscreate rich connections betweenworks of art and topics they areteaching; and to use the power ofart as a force for developingstudents thinking dispositions.

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

10/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 7

THINKING DISPOSITIONS

7.C) *%(,").#C 9*/2*$* )-") 2)ZC 2;H.#)"3) ). )*",- C)(%*3)C ). )-23IK B#"%2)2.3"//D=

*00.#)C ). )*",- )-23I23< -"$* 9**3 "92/2)DO,*3)#2,Q B-*D 0.#*

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

11/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 8

]"#2.(C H#.>6`K

8#)C *%(,").#C "3% "#) *%(,")2.3 H#.>\` "#

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

12/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 9

CLAIM / SUPPORT /QUESTION

A Reasoning Routine

Make a claim about theartwork or topic.

Identify support for yourclaim.

Ask a question related toyour claim.

finding complexityK B-*C* %2CH.C2)2.3C -"$* 9**3 ,-.C*3 0.# )G. #*"C.3CK B-* 02#C) 2C )-") *",- .0 )-*

C2L #*H#*C*3) 0.#;C .0 )-23I23< )-") "#* H.G*#0(/ 23 )*#;C .0 *LH/.#23< "3% "HH#*,2")23< G.#IC .0 "#)K

B-* C*,.3% 2C )-") *",- .0 )-* C2L #*H#*C*3) 0.#;C .0 )-23I23< )-") "#* H.G*#0(/ 23 )*#;C .0 9(2/%23\`K :#2)2,"/ B-23I23< W2CH.C2)2.3C "C "3 V(),.;* .0 8#) 1%(,")2.3K Studies inArt Education:47 (3),215-228.

Y"3

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

94/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 91

E*#I23CK WK jK= T B2C-;"3= +K _5>>4`K W2CH.C2)2.3"/ "CH*,)C .0 23)*//2>\K

RD/*= 'K _4^6^`K The concept of mindK Y.3%.3Q !(),-23C.3 !.(C*K

+)"3.$2,-= dK 1K _4^^6`K R*,.3,*H)("/2M23< 23)*//2>\`K +)(%2. )-23I23[`K b"DG..% E(9/2C-23

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

95/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 92

APPENDIX A

The Artful Thinking Palette

Think Track Tool

Student Concept Map Instrument

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

96/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 93

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

97/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 94

THINK TRACK

Teacher name______________________________ School/ Grade level: _________ Date: _______

Thinking Dispositions: R*0/*,) .3 )-* H"C) G**IK i-2,- .0 )-* 0.//.G23< )-23I23< %2CH.C2)2.3C%. D.( )-23I D.(# ,/"CC#..; 23C)#(,)2.3 -*/H*% C)(%*3)C %*$*/.Hm _:-*,I "C ;"3D "C "HH/DK '2$* "double check ). %2CH.C2)2.3C )-") G*#*strongly*;H-"C2M*% )-2C G**IK`

Frequency of Thinking Routines: B-23I "9.() )-* H"C) G**I 23 D.(# ,/"CC#..;K !.G ;"3D#.()23*C %2% D.( )#Dm U3,/(%* "3D H"#)2"/ (C* "3%n.# ,.;923*% (C* .0 8#)0(/ B-23I23< #.()23*C "C G*//"C (C* .0 .)-*# )-23I23< #.()23*C D.(Z$* 23$*3)*% .# I3.G "9.()K

ttt> #.()23*C

ttt4O? #.()23*C

ttt6O\ #.()23*C

tttlO4> #.()23*C

ttt7.#* )-"3 4> #.()23*C

Use of Thinking Routines: Circle the routines you tried this week. Include any partial routines

and/or combined use of routines.

Questioning &Investigating ______

Observing &Describing _______

ExploringViewpoints ________

FindingComplexity_______

Reasoning _______

Comparing &Connecting ________

ttttti-") ;"I*C D.( C"D )-")m

ttttt:/"2; n +(HH.#) n S(*C)2.3

tttttB-23I E"2# +-"#*

tttttE*#,*2$* n d3.G n :"#* 89.()

ttttt:2#,/* .0 ]2*GH.23)C

tttttU +** n U B-23I n U i.3%*#

tttttB-23I n E(MM/* n 1LH/.#*

ttttt:#*")2$* S(*C)2.3C

ttttt1/"9.#")2.3 '";*

tttttb*

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

98/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 95

Integrating Art:W2% D.( (C* "3D "#) 23 D.(# ,/"CC#..; )-2C G**Im f*C 3.U0 D*C= G-") %2% D.( %.m :-*,I "C ;"3D "C "HH/DK

tttW2C,(CC*% "3 "#) 2;"

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

99/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 96

Name______________________________________________ School ________________________ Grade______

i-*3 D.( "#* %.23< D.(# 9*C) )-23I23

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

100/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 97

Concept Map Distribution Protocol

1) Today I have an activity to ask you to do. This activity is a way for teachersto know a little bit more about your thinking. Have any of you ever made a

mind map, or a web before?

(you can take an answer here from a student )8 G*9 -"C "3 2%*" 23 ,*3)*#= "3% /23*C ,.;23< .() 0#.; 2) 0.# .)-*# 2%*"C )-") ,.33*,) ).2)K

Today we want to find out your ideas about what kind of thinking you dowhen you are trying to understand somethingYou can use yourimagination, there are no right or wrong answers.

2) What kinds of things do you study in school?a. Students may answer Social studies, math, science, etc.

3) What are some topics within these areas that you study?a. Students may answer, the civil war, long division, weather, etc.

4) Id like you to spend a few minutes, quietly, thinking about a question Ihave for you and then I d like you do make your own mind map or webabout it. Display the question below (on chart paper).

When you are doing your best thinking, in order to understandsomething, what different kinds of thinking do you do?

5) Distribute the maps to students. Make sure to fill out your paper with:a. first and last name,b. date,c. teacher and graded. school

6) Read the concept map aloud with them and tell them that you would like themto do their own web or mind map.

7) Do not talk about it anymore as a group. Ask students to work on their own.They can raise their hand if they have a questionand you can answer basic

questions, however do not assist students in the task. Tell them to do theirbest and put down as many ideas as they can.

8) Collect the maps when most of the class seems finished.

Fill out Concept Map Probe Record Sheet

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

101/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 98

APPENDIX B

From Thinking Routines To Writing Goals

Connecting Thinking To Writing Goals

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

102/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 99

FROM THINKING ROUTINES TO WRITING GOALS

This document gives ideas for how specific thinking routines can support writing activities.

Routines are organized by thinking dispositions on the Artful Thinking palette.

QUESTIONING AND INVESTIGATING-CENTERED ROUTINES

See / Think / Wonder

This routine stimulates curiosity and helps students make observations.

U) ;"D 9* -*/H0(/ ). (C* )-2C #.()23* G-*3 D.( "#* introducing a research project.#

*LH/.#23< *LH.C2).#D G#2)23

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

103/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 100

i-*3 .#

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

104/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 101

EXPLORING VIEWPOINTS-CENTERED ROUTINES

Perceive/Know/Care AboutThis routine helps students to explore diverse perspectives and viewpoints as they try to imagine

things, events, problems, or issues differently.

U0 C)(%*3)C "#* 0";2/2"# G2)- %2"/.

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

105/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 102

B-* 1' #.()23* ,"3 9* (C*% ). -*/H C)(%*3)C /*"#3 ). give more information to their

writingK U3 *LH.C2).#D G#2)23

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

106/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 103

CONNECTING THINKING ROUTINES TO WRITING GOALS

General Prewriting (thinking and organizing ideas before writing)

Useful Routines:

See/Think/Wonder

Think/Puzzle/Explore

B.

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

107/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 104

Expository Writing (explaining an insight, informing the reader, expressing

emotion)

Useful Routines:

See/Think/WonderThink/Puzzle/Explore

B.

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

108/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 105

Think/Puzzle/Explore

!*/H C)(%*3)C .H*3 (H )-* ).H2, ). *LH/.#")2.3 9D -"$23< )-*; *3

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

109/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 106

.3 C)*

8/13/2019 Artful Thinking Routines

110/115

Artful Thinking Final Report, November 2006 107

A. CONNECTING THINKING ROUTINES TO WRITING GOALS

See/Think/Wonder

U3)#.%(,)2.3 ). #*C*"#,- "3% *LH.C2).#D G#2)23