asee and how standards classroom -...

45

Upload: ngokhanh

Post on 16-Mar-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion
Page 2: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASEE and How Standards

Find Their Way into the

Classroom William E. Kelly, Ph.D., P.E.

Director of External Affairs ASEE

September 18, 2013

2

Page 3: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Overview

• Standards in Engineering Education

• Sustainability in Engineering Education

• Standards AND Sustainability in

Engineering Education

• Where are we going?

• How can we get there faster?

• How can ASEE help?

3

Page 4: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Standards in Engineering

Education Drivers:

• Faculty initiatives

• Industry demand

• Engineering societies

• ABET Criteria

– Criterion

– Constraints

– Outcomes

4

Page 5: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Engineering Education

• ABET is a major driver of undergraduate

education in the U.S. and increasingly

internationally

• U.S. engineering societies (ABET is a

federation) working together define general

accreditation criteria that apply to all engineering

programs

• Engineering societies define program criteria

that apply to fields e.g. electrical engineering

5

Page 6: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ABET EAC Criterion 4

Curriculum • Students must be prepared for

engineering practice through a curriculum

culminating in a major design experience

based on the knowledge and skills

acquired in earlier course work and

incorporating appropriate engineering

standards and multiple realistic

constraints.

6

Page 7: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

American Society for

Engineering Education • Place to go to find out what faculty (E&ET)

are doing in the classroom

• Annual conference

– Papers

– Exhibit

– Workshops

• Regional conferences

• You can get an overview by searching

conference papers online since 1996 7

Page 8: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Search from

1996

To

2013

Page 9: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Introduction of Standards

• A number of ASEE conference papers on

this

• Workshops – national and regional

• Engineering societies and others e.g.

ASTM, ANSI, and SES working on this

9

Page 10: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

10

Search

“standards”

Page 11: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASEE Annual Conference 2003

11

Page 12: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASEE Regional Workshop 2004

12

Page 13: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASTM is

A

Corporate

Member

Of ASEE

And

Exhibits

At the ASEE

Annual

Conference

13

Page 14: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASTM

And

IEEE

Have

Been

Leaders

In

Supporting

Standards

In

Engineering

Education

14

Page 15: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion
Page 16: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASEE Annual Conference 2013

16

Page 17: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

ASEE Annual Conference 2013

17

Page 18: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Sustainability

18

Page 19: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Criterion 3

(c) an ability to design a system, component,

or process to meet desired needs within

realistic constraints such as economic,

environmental, social, political, ethical,

health and safety, manufacturability, and

sustainability (Bold and underline added)

19

Page 20: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

20

Page 21: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Challenges

Page 22: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

22

Page 23: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Standards AND Sustainability

23

Page 24: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

24

Page 25: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

25

Page 26: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

26

Page 27: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

An

Example

Of

A

Standard

That

Could be used

By

Students

In

Capstone

Design

Page 28: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

NSPE BOK (2013)

• Standards as an engineering tool

• Quality control and Quality Assurance

• Safety

• Legal Aspects of Engineering

• Public Policy and Engineering

– Explain how codes and standards are set and

how public policy affects their development;

28

Page 29: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Sustainability is an Evolving Area

for Engineering Practice

29

Page 30: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Reaching Students & Faculty

• Challenges in “practice areas” e.g.

standards, ethics, sustainability.

• Modules that faculty can easily incorporate

into courses

• Entire courses

• Student self study

• Strategy – students or faculty first?

30

Page 31: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

31

Page 32: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

This addresses concern raised in

IEEE survey – how to get the word

out? 32

Page 33: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

33

Page 34: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

34

Page 35: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

35

Page 36: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Teaching Materials

• Appears to be no shortage of teaching

materials on standards or sustainability

• Are they classroom ready?

• Are they ready for self study by students?

36

Page 37: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

37

Page 38: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

38

Page 39: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

39

Page 40: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

40

Page 41: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

41

Possible

Module

Page 42: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

42

Page 43: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

43

Page 44: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion

Summary

• You are making progress

• ASEE is a good venue both papers and

workshops national and regional

• How could ASEE help?

• Challenge to infuse “practice” aspects of

engineering into engineering curricula

• How to leverage other activities e.g.

sustainability?

• Other delivery mechanisms

44

Page 45: ASEE and How Standards Classroom - c.ymcdn.comc.ymcdn.com/.../resource/resmgr/imported/ASEEandStandards_Dr_Kelly.pdfASEE and How Standards Find Their Way into the ... ABET EAC Criterion