asro journal - sttal -...

28

Upload: others

Post on 14-Oct-2019

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with
Page 2: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 About the Journal | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about 1/3

ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

Search

ANNOUNCEMENTS CURRENT ARCHIVES ABOUT

Register Login

HOME About the Journal

ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL (ISSN : 2460-7037)

ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal  with the objectives to explore,

develop, and elucidate the knowledge of Operations Management, Operations Research,

Logistic Management, Policy and Strategic to keep practitioners and researchers informed on

current issues and best practices, as well as serving as a platform for the exchange of ideas,

knowledge, and expertise among technology researchers and practitioners.

ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL provides an opportunity to share detailed insights from different

understandings and practices associated with technology. It provides an international forum for

cross-disciplinary exchange of insights and ideas regarding value and practices for

dissemination. ASRO  Journal will publish your work to international society of practitioners and

researchers with interest in technology  and development from a wide variety of sectors.

AIM AND SCOPE

The objective of the ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is to provide an international forum for discussions of

advancements in Operations Management, Operations Research, Logistic Management, Policy

and Strategic Scope.

The Conference publishes high-quality research articles in all of these areas, and particularly

encourages articles dealing with international issues, practical experiences, pedagogical aspects

including case research, developments in the emerging nations, service management, and other

nontraditional and innovative areas. Purely theoretical articles should make significant

contribution to the existing knowledge.

 It is necessary that all parties involved in publishing process: the authors, the editor-in-chief,

editorial board, the peer reviewers, and the publisher agree to abide by the highest standards of

ethical behavior of research publication.

/

Page 3: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 About the Journal | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about 2/3

ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL is supported by INDONESIAN NAVAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY -

STTAL 

Journal Manager : Admiral Ir. Avando Bastari, M.Phil

                                  : Captain Navy  Dr. I Nengah Putra A, ST. M.Si (Han)

Managing Editor  : Dr. Ahmadi, S.Si, MT

Editor In Chief       : Dr. Okol Sri Suharyo, ST, MT

INDONESIAN NAVAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY - STTAL 

Bumimoro Surabaya Indonesia

Telp. +623199000583, Email : [email protected] ; [email protected] ;

[email protected]

 Indexed by Google Scholar

INFORMATION

For Readers

For Authors

For Librarians

CURRENT ISSUE

Page 4: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Editorial Team | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/editorialTeam 1/2

ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

Search

ANNOUNCEMENTS CURRENT ARCHIVES ABOUT

Register Login

HOME Editorial Team

Journal Manager : Admiral Ir. Avando Bastari, M.Phil

                                  : Captain Navy Dr. I Nengah Putra A, ST. M.Si (Han)

Managing Editor : Captain Navy Dr. Ahmadi, S.Si. MT.

Editor in Chief : Lieutenant Commander Navy Dr. Okol Sri Suharyo, ST. MT.

Editorial Team : Prof. Tutut Herawan (University of Malaya, Malaysia) ; Prof. Ir. Suparno, MSIE,

PhD (ITS) ; Prof. Ir. Budi Santoso, M.Sc, PhD (ITS)

INDONESIAN NAVAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY - STTAL

Surabaya Indonesia

 Indexed by Google Scholar

INFORMATION

For Readers

For Authors

For Librarians

/

Page 6: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Vol 9 No 1 (2018): International Journal of ASRO | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/issue/view/12 1/5

ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

Search

ANNOUNCEMENTS CURRENT ARCHIVES ABOUT

Register Login

HOME ARCHIVES Vol 9 No 1 (2018): International Journal of ASRO

Available Now

PUBLISHED: 2018-09-10

THE OPTIMIZATION OF MULTIPURPOSE BUILDING DEVELOPMENT ON PROJECTSCHEDULING USING PRECEDENCE DIAGRAM METHOD (PDM)

PDF

APPLICATION OF DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM FOR DETERMINING AMPHIBIOUS LANDINGBEACH IN WEST PAPUA INDONESIA

/ /

ARTICLES

Arica Dwi Susanto, Ahmadi Ahmadi, Okol S Suharyo1-7

Budi Setiarso, Udisubakti Ciptomulyono, Bambang Suharjo, I Nengah Putra, A K Susilo8-22

Page 7: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Vol 9 No 1 (2018): International Journal of ASRO | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/issue/view/12 2/5

PDF

RISK MANAGEMENT ON THE WARSHIP TASK OPERATIONS

PDF

PATROL SHIPS ASSIGNMENT MODEL IN EASTERN AREA OF INDONESIA WATER USINGSET COVERING

PDF

ANALYSIS OF MENTAL WORKLOAD WITH INTEGRATING NASA TLX AND FUZZY METHOD

PDF

RAILWAY AND PORTS INTEGRATION SYSTEM AS SOLUTION OF ISLAND TRANSPORTATIONPROBLEM (CASE STUDY SUMATRA ISLAND)

PDF

SELECTION OF ALTERNATIVE ENERGY SOURCES INDONESIAN WARSHIP PATROL CRAFT36 CLASS USING LIFE CYCLE COST (LCC) AND TOPSIS (TECHNIQUE FOR ORDERPREFERENCE BY SIMILARITY TO IDEAL SOLUTION)

PDF

SONIC LAYER DEPTH VARIATION ANALYSIS UTILIZING BIDE (BANDA ITF DYNAMICEXPERIMENT) ARGO FLOAT IN SITU OBSERVATION FOR UNDERSEA WARFARE TACTICALENVIRONMENT SUPPORT

PDF

Diksono Diksono, I Made Jiwa, Suparno Suparno23-29

Oyu Mulia S, Ahmadi Ahmadi, Okol S Suharyo30-36

Riono Riono, Suparno Suparno, Adi Bandono37-45

Satrio Teguh Amandiri, Ahmadi Ahmadi, Budi Santoso W47-51

Haryanto Wibowo, Ahmadi Ahmadi, Okol S Suharyo52-61

D Armansyah, N B Sukoco, W S Pranowo62-73

Page 8: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Vol 9 No 1 (2018): International Journal of ASRO | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/issue/view/12 3/5

ROLE OF THE INDONESIAN NAVY TASK UNIT TO SUPPORTING TECHNOLOGY TRANSFEROF SUBMARINE BY DSME SOUTH KOREA-PT PAL INDONESIA

PDF

SUPPLIER SELECTION AND ORDER QUANTITY ALLOCATION OF RAW MATERIAL USINGINTEGER LINEAR PROGRAMMING

PDF

QUALITY ANALYSIS OF EDUCATIONAL SERVICES ON STUDENT RESPONSE THROUGH QFDAPPROACH TO IMPROVE PERFORMANCE OF UNIVERSITY OF 17 AGUSTUS 1945 (UNTAG)BANYUWANGI

PDF

A GENETIC ALGORITHM APPROACH FOR SOLVING INBOARD OUTER FIXED LEADINGEDGE-DRIVE RIB 1 PRODUCTION SCHEDULING AT PT DIRGANTARA INDONESIA

PDF

THE DETERMINATION OF SUBMARINE TRAINING WITH FUZZY MULTI CRITERIA DECISIONMAKING APPROACH (FMCDM )

PDF

DESIGN OF SURGE AND ROLL MOTION CONTROL SYSTEM OF ITSUNUSA AUV USING PIDCONTROLLER

PDF

SCHEDULING OPTIMIZATION OF KRI ASSIGNMENTS WITH BINARY INTEGERPROGRAMMING TO SECURE THE KOARMATIM SEA AREA

Nurcahya Dwi Asmoro, Udisubakti Ciptomulyono, I Nengah Putra, Ahmadi Ahmadi, Okol S Suharyo74-85

Ika Deefi Anna, Putri Rani Fhiliantie98-105

Endang Suprihatin106-119

Ilhamsah Ilhamsah, Cahyadi Cahyadi, Yulianto Yulianto120-128

Wisono Setiawan, Okol S Suharyo129-138

Teguh Herlambang, Subchan Subchan139-142

M Agus Arif H, Budi Santoso W, Ahmadi Ahmadi, Okol S Suharyo

Page 9: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

61

SONIC LAYER DEPTH VARIATION ANALYSIS UTILIZING BIDE (BANDA ITF DYNAMIC EXPERIMENT) ARGO FLOAT IN SITU OBSERVATION FOR UNDERSEA WARFARE TACTICAL ENVIRONMENT SUPPORT

D Armansyah1, N B Sukoco1, W S Pranowo1,2

1 Department of Hydrography Engineering, Indonesian Naval Postgraduate School (STTAL),

Jl. Pantai Kuta V No. 01, Ancol Timur, Jakarta, 14430, Indonesia 2 Marine Research Centre, Indonesian Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries,

Jl. Pasir Putih II, Ancol Timur, Jakarta, 14430, Indonesia

ABSTRACT

Sonic Layer Depth is the vertical distance from surface to the depth where the speed of sound reach it’s local

maximum. Global Navy as well as Indonesan Navy operates in this kind of layers on a daily basis, wether it be

in an anti submarine warfare operation through its ships and aircrafts or in an anti-surface warfare operation

waged by its submarines. For the navy, the importance of knowing the exact value of the SLD is because it

determines the minimum cut off frequency and sound wave propagation above which sound tends to be trapped

and below which a shadow zone exist. This has a direct impact on where the navy operates its sensors and

places its platforms in the water column. The best way to estimate SLD is by performing own measurement on

the ocean using instrument such as expendable bathytermographs, which can be relatively expensive and time

consuming for an operational navy ships, furthermore such measurement may be impractical in the case of

mission planning or emergencies. Dedicated oceanography survey for the purpose of science and defense is

relatively scarce due to prioritization concerning to the budget available resulting lack of time series in situ CTD

observation which cover full annual cycle variation in Indonesia waters. Banda Indonesia Through Flow

Dynamic Experiment (BIDE) is multi institution and bilateral oceanography experiment led by Indonesian

scientist which utilizes argo float to perform in situ CTD measurement in Banda Sea to get an adequate time

series data that cover full annual cycle variation. The dataset is publicly available so defense community as well

may utilize the data for defense interest such as sonic layer depth variation analysis in Banda Sea.

Keyword : sonic layer depth, BIDE, argo float, undersea warfare, tactical environment.

1. INTRODUCTION.

Sonic Layer Depth (SLD) is the vertical

distance from the sea surface to the depth where

the speed of sound underwater reachs it’s

maximum value. The maximum value of sound

speed occurs at certain depth due to under a

condition when temperature and salinity in a layer is

constant, the value of sound speed will increases

with pressure/depth until generally temperature,

and therefore sound speed decreases. SLD is an

important phenomenon because it characterizes

the capability or potential of the upper ocean or

surface layer to trap acoustic energy in a surface

duct. Nevertheless, SLD is not commonly known

and researched parameter if compared to another

parameter called Mixed Layer Depth (MLD). MLD is

the thickness of a ocean surface layer that has

almost constant value of temperature, salinity and

density, therefore by definition is different with SLD

because MLD characterizes how the mixing of

upper ocean layer. SLD and MLD are frequently

coincide due to the condition that sound speed

International Journal of ASRO Volume 9, Number 1, pp. 62-73

January-June 2018

Page 10: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

62

increases with depth down to the MLD, where

generally the temperature declines resulting in a

local maximum sound speed. Previous reasearchs

shown that SLD and MLD are not always the same

because sound speed is substantially more

dependent to temperature than to salinity compared

to density. However scientists and practicioners

oceanographers often used MLD as a proxy or

substitute of SLD for scientific or operational

activities (Helber, et al., 2008).

Estimating the SLD variability is important for

understanding the acoustic properties of the upper

ocean that influence operational activities such as

navy operations related to hiding and detecting

marine underwater vessels (Urick, 1983). Navy

around the world has a vested interest in knowing

exactly where the MLD and SLD especially are

located. Global Navy as well as Indonesan Navy

operates in both layers on a daily basis, wether it

be in an anti submarine warfare operation through

its ships and aircrafts or in an anti-surface warfare

operation waged by its submarines (Rizanny,

2017). For the navy, the importance of knowing the

exact value of the SLD is because it determines the

minimum cut off frequency and sound wave

propagation above which sound tends to be

trapped and below which a shadow zone exist. This

has a direct impact on where the navy operates its

sensors and places its platforms in the water

column (Villareal, 2014).

One of the classical problem facing

oceanographers is the scarcity of in situ

observations to be used in estimating the

temperature and salinity structure of the ocean.

Traditionally, they rely on climatologies or collective

average derived from all available historical data

(Teague, et al., 1990). The other alternative is

performing own measurement on the ocean using

instrument such as expendable bathytermographs,

which can be relatively expensive and time

consuming for an operational navy ships,

furthermore such measurement may be impractical

in the case of mission planning or emergencies

(Fox, et al., 2001).

Fig. 1. An example of SLD

(Guest, 2014)

Scarcity of in situ physical oceanography

measurement is also a big problem faced by

oceanography community in Indonesia especially in

the Indonesian Navy. Indonesian Navy Hydrography

and Oceanography Centre (Pushidrosal) is the

institue responsible for the planning and execution of

hydrography and oceanography survey for the public

civil and military interests. However, historically at

present and possibly in the near future,

oceanography survey is remain to be only small part

of Pushidrosal operations since there is bigger

national maritime strategic development program

that must be supported because Pushidrosal is one

of the stakeholders who is responsible for providing

updated nautical chart for the Indonesia maritime

transportation. Nevertheless, Pushidrosal keeps

maintaining relations with other national

oceanography institution not only for the interest of

Indonesian Navy but also for the advancement of

national oceanography society and its further

contribution for national maritime sector. One of the

most recent ocenaography society national

collaboration is Banda Indonesian-Throughflow

Dynamic Experiment 2017-2018 which is led by

scientist from Institut Pertanian Bogor (IPB) and

supported by Ristekdikti, LEGOS (France) and

IFREMER (France). This experiment is not only

introducing Argo float as an advance data collection

Page 11: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

63

technology but also with this experiment time series

measurement data in Banda Sea will be established

for full annual cycle which is a huge progress for

Indonesia oceanography (Atmadipoera, et al., 2017).

The availability of full annual cycle argo float CTD in

situ measurement is a great opportunity for

Pushidrosal to analyze it for providing tactical

environment support to Indonesian Navy undersea

warfare operations especially in Banda Sea.

1. DATA SOURCE AND METHODOLOGY

1.1. Argo floats superiority as

oceanography data acquisition

system

Previous studies show that Banda Sea

plays a significant roles such as region of

high primary productivity and pelagic fish

resources, seasonal Ekman upwelling

around outer Banda Arcs and active ocean-

atmosphere interactions which forced by

monsoon winds, ENSO etc. Eventhough

Banda Sea plays such an important role,

adequate oceanography measurements is

never been performed to collect time series

data that will cover full annual cycle

variations. Based on this condition a

research team of IPB under coordination of

Dr. Agus Atmadipoera with the colaboration

and support from Ristekdikti (Indonesia),

LEGOS (France) and IFREMER (France)

initiated Banda Indonesian-Through Flow

Dynamic Experiment (BIDE). The experiment

is utilizing CTD argo float measurement that

was deployed on July 29th 2017 onboard

inter-islands passenger ship namely MV

Kapal Perintis. The argo float was configured

to perform daily CTD profiling from surface to

1000 m depth, scheduled for surfacing every

23:00 local time meanwhile it is drifting

depends on the surrounding ocean current

(Atmadipoera, et al., 2017).

Fig. 2 Argo float BIDE picture

(jcommops, 2017)

Fig. 3 Argo float BIDE trajectory as of July 2018

(Atmadipoera, 2017)

According to the research team report

there are three configuration changes since

the first deployment of the argo float.

Configuration setting 01 was used from July

to September 2017 with default configuration

daily profiling and surfacing, configuration

setting 02 was used from September to

October 2017 with the changing of near-

surface resolution and 2-day profiling and

surfacing and lastly configuration setting 03

was used from October 2017 up to now with

another changing of near-surface resolution

sampling while maintaing the 2-day profiling

and surfacing for prolonging the battery

lifetime.

Fig. 4 Argo float BIDE configuration setting

(Atmadipoera, et al., 2017)

Page 12: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

64

In order to download the argo float

measurement data for full annual cycle from

July 2017 up to July 2018 author accessed

the jcommops web site as directed by the

research team. There are several options

collection data prepared by IFREMER, NRL

and NOAA either in netcdf format or txt

(jcommops, 2017). For the purpose of this

research author chose to download data

prepared by NOAA in netcdf format (NOAA,

2018).

Before BIDE actually, there was joint

researh on global climate change impact

utilizing 2 unit of argo floats between Agency

for Marine and Fisheries Research under

Indonesian Ministry of Marine Affairs and

Fisheries and CSIRO Australia. This program

was recorded as the first involvement of

Indonesian scientist to a project utilizing argo

floats as the most preferable data acquisition

utility system by the International

oceanography society which are relatively

easy and less expensive compared to the

other system (Pranowo, et al., 2003). The

next two following years the acquired data

measurements were already available and

analyzed by the team for describing

upwelling event 2003 along South Java Sea

and Lesser Sunda Islands(Pranowo, et al.,

2005). Another best practices of argo floats

data utilization by Indonesian scientist was

published just recently which was studying

temperature and salinity stratification in the

Eastern Indian Ocean using argo float

dataset from 1999 up to 2016 with about

hundreds profiles per year which is difficult to

be matched by traditional data acquisition

system such as CTD measurement onboard

a research vessel (Purba, et al., 2018).

1.2. Description of Data Source

The data source was retrieved from

jcommops website with filename

nodc_6901746_prof.nc. According to the

the metadata, the file source was taken from

The Argo Global Data Assembly Center FTP

server at ftp://ftp.ifremer.fr/ifremer/argo.

Meanwhile the creator and the publisher is

NOAA therefore these data were acquired

from the US NOAA National Centers for

Environmental Information (NCEI) on July

28th 2018 from https://www.nodc.noaa.gov/.

There are three parameters that are

measured by the argo float which are

temperature, salinity and pressure.

Up to July 28th 2018 there are 215

stations observed that cover period of time

from July 2017 to July 2018 approximately

inside a box area limited by longitude 129.5°

E to 131.5° E and latitude 6° S to 4.5° S.

Fig. 5. Argo float BIDE distribution as of July 2018

Fig. 6 Argo float BIDE statistic as of July 2018

Page 13: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

65

Fig. 7. Argo float BIDE time series 2017-2018

1.3. Methodology of Research

Several academic studies and field

researh had been performed before to

answer the question of how to present

tactical environment support from

Pushidrosal to Indonesian Navy. As early as

year 2000 the first study of oceanographic

layer chart concept for underwater warfare

operation and exercise support was

conducted by Commander Dede Yuliadi

M.Sc during his Indonesian Navy staf and

command school student period (Yuliadi,

2000). Since then several Indonesian Navy

officers started gaining interest on this topic

of research study, with some resorded topic

such as layer determination and its

underwater detection application (Jatmiko,

2001), underwater acoustic positioning

system for the submarine (Marwoto, 2007),

active sonar transmission loss (Ludfy, 2007),

Tactical Ocean Data Geographic

Informastion System for submarine (Taufiq,

2007), underwater acoustic propagation for

submarine navigation and communication

(Wahyudi, 2007), and tactical oceanography

map for submarine navigation (Asryanto,

2018).

One of closely related study about

sound speed propogation underwater

regarding it’s impact on navy operation was

conducted by Tri Aji et al who analyzed the

seasonal variability of thermocline, sound

speed and probable shadow zone in Sunda

strait published in 2017. This research was

utilizing dataset from INDESO project with

daily temporal resolution and ½ degrees

spatial resolution. Further explained in the

publication that the study applied 0.1 deg C

gradient for the thermocline layer

determinantion during four seasons data in

2014. As the results thermocline layer depth

variability and it’s sound speed range

variability which estimated as the probable

shadow zones for each four seasons and

annual average was presented (Aji, et al.,

2017). Another research about shadow zone

and sound wave underwater propagation

properties for navy sonar operation was

conducted by Mario Marco Wainarisi in 2016.

In his final study report he explained that this

research is utilizing in situ CTD observations

from The Transport, Internal Waves and

Mixing in The Indonesian Throughflow

Region (TIMIT) and Its Impact On Marine

Ecosystem 2015 Cruise of Indonesian

Marine and Fishery Ministry and CTD data

from NOAA World Ocean Atlas. The

research uses simulation pattern of

propagation of sound waves from KRI Cakra

– 401 propulsion system detected by FMS

21/3 sonar with passive sonar mode. The

simulation applied polynomial fitting and ray

tracing methodology under matlab

environment. The average pattern of sound

wave propagation simulation results shows

the presence of shadow zone and surface

duct on each lane detected in Makassar

Strait (Wainarisi, et al., 2017).

Compared to previously mentioned

studies this research paralelly equivalent with

Tri Aji’s research methodology which will

Page 14: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

66

analyze the monthly average variations of

SLD parameter with further confirmation or

verification about the relation of SLD and

surface duct with polynomial fitting and ray

tracing methodology that applied by Marco’s

in his study. The use of CTD in situ

observation which cover a full annual cycle

make the study more realistic since generally

a full annual cycle analysis, especially in

Indonesia waters, can only be done from

model dataset because the scarcity of in situ

oceanography observations conducted until

now.

Technically the downloaded dataset

opened or imported into ODV software for

analysis preparation. Then sample selection

criteria is applied to filter the observation for

only the desired month to be processed. Two

derived variables of sound speed and depth

from pressure are added for station plotting

of temperature, salinity and sound speed. All

of measured profiles (temperature, salinity

and sound speed) are monthly averaged

using moving average methode that is

provided by ODV (Schlitzer, 2015). The

averaged value of sound speed for each

month then copied and saved in txt format.

This monthly average value of sound speed

then loaded into mathlab and investigated to

get the SLD using the alghoritm of searching

the depth of sound speed local maximum

(matlab, 2018) that is larger than any

shallower value and larger than the next

deeper value, which is usually coincide or

near to the MLD (Helber, et al., 2008). The

monthly average sound speed profile then

used to investigate the presence of surface

duct using the typical hull mounted sonar

source depth between 5 to 10 m applying the

previously mentioned polynomial fitting and

ray tracing methode. The confirmation will

not only indicating probable shadow zone but

more realistically simulate and produce a

graphical representation which reasonably

will give more assurance for the navy ships

on the sea.

Fig. 8 Sound speed profiles versus depth for (a)

standard, (b) multiple surface duct, (c) absent

surface duct, and (d) deep SLD cases

(Helber, et al., 2008)

Fig. 9 Flowchart of the research

Page 15: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

67

2. RESULT AND DISCUSSION.

2.1. Result.

In this study the full annual cycle dataset is

imported into ODV then two derived variables which

are sound speed derived from temperature and

salinity and depth derived from pressure are added

to the list in order to use them for plotting and

further analysis. This very first process will result 12

sound speed profiles for each 12 months which

needed for the next step of SLD estimation.

Fig. 10 Monthly average sound velocity profiles

variation for the full annual cycle

The monthly average sound velocity profiles

result from ODV then saved into text file to be used

for SLD estimation using the searching alghoritm

for local maxima in matlab software. Local maxima

is a data sample that is either larger than its two

neighboring samples. Additional confirmation

plotting is applied for each sound velocity profiles to

ensure the exact position of SLD. Once the SLD

confirmed then polynomial fitting and ray tracing will

be applied with the input so-called sound velocity

profiles to produce the ray tracing plot which will

confirm the presence of surface duct or not.

Page 16: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

68

Fig. 11 SLD estimated at about 16m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1543.30 m/s. Surface duct

simulated at about 0 - 30m depth

Fig. 12 SLD estimated at about 37m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1542.9 m/s. Surface duct

simulated at about 0 - 41m depth

Fig. 13 SLD estimated at about 59m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1542.86 m/s. Surface duct

simulated at about 0 - 44m depth

Fig. 14 SLD estimated at about 13m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1542.89 m/s. No surface duct

simulated

Page 17: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

69

Fig. 15 SLD estimated at about 14m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1541.5 m/s. No surface duct

simulated

Fig. 16 SLD estimated at about 24m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1539.03 m/s. No surface duct

simulated

Fig. 17 SLD estimated at about 40m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1537.73 m/s. surface duct

simulated at about 0 – 96m depth

Fig. 18 SLD estimated at about 22m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1537.87 m/s. No surface

duct simulated

Page 18: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

70

Fig. 19 SLD estimated at about 6m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1538.47 m/s. No surface

duct simulated

Fig. 20 SLD estimated at about 6m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1541.73 m/s. No surface

duct simulated

Fig. 21 SLD estimated at about 6m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1543.81 m/s. No surface

duct simulated

Fig. 22 SLD estimated at about 5m depth, local

maxima sound speed 1544.28 m/s. weak surface

duct simulated at about 0 – 60m depth

2.2. Discussion

The SLD estimation results monthly

variations in Banda Sea based on BIDE CTD

dataset. The deepest SLD estimation is in

march at 59m depth. The vertical distance of

SLD in March is paralel with the simulated

surface duct (0-44m). Actually March SLD

(59m) is deeper than July SLD (40m), but the

configured ray tracing simulation results

shows that July surface duct vertical distance

(96m) is thicker than March simulated surface

duct. Nevertheless, March ray tracing

Page 19: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

71

produce bottom propagation ray tracing which

cover water column under the surface duct

while the July ray tracing leaves water

column under the surface duct empty without

acoustic propagation wave. It is revealed that

the depth of SLD estimate is positvely

correlated with the formation of surface duct

but acoustic wave propagation simulation is

very complex process that is not only

influenced by SLD but also other factor such

as the sound velocity gradient before and

after the local maxima. SLD estimation is

prerequisite process to ensure the indication

of the presence of surface duct, but to verify it

acoustic wave propagation simulation,

through ray tracing for example, should be

done to further confirm how good is an active

sonar performance in the current condition.

The formation of surface duct is good

indication that an active sonar detection

range will be extended in the channel

covered by surface duct. This is teoritically

happen due to in a surface duct propagation

the spreading loss is cylindrical spreading

loss which is equal to distance (r) meanwhile

in the other propagation such as bottom

bounce the spreading loss is spherical

spreading loss which is equal to square

distance (r2). Due to this reason under

surface duct propagation acoustic wave

energy will have less transmission loss which

means a better probability of detection

((FAS), 2013).

Table.1 SLD estimation and surface duct simulation

in Banda Sea

3. CONCLUSION.

Based on the results and discussion above,

the sound velocity profiles of Banda Sea varies

monthly hence the SLD for each month will also

vary depends on the temperature and salinity

profiles which are two key variables the sound

speed derived from. Single process of SLD

estimation throuh the searching alghoritm of local

maxima will not adequate to verify the presence of

surface duct as the most favourable acoustic wave

propagation for the navy ship operating active

sonar to detect submarine operating in upper layer

of the ocean. Polynomial fitting ray tracing process

of acoustic wave propagation further ensure the

relation between SLD estimates and the formation

of surface duct. Generally deeper SLD will result a

deeper surface duct but in the condition that there

are enough sound speed gradient before and after

local maxima. Therefore to more precisely predict

how is acoustic wave propagates whether or not it

forms surface duct, simulation should be performed

utilizing the alghoritm and theory that has been well

established by underwater acoustic scientists such

as polynomial fitting ray tracing that is applied in

this study. Actually sound speed underwater is

unique even diurnally due to the influence of sun

light. That is why “afternoon effect” term is very

popular in anti submarine warfare. During the

afternoon, the sea surface temperature reach it’s

maximum resulting a very strong negative sound

speed gradient which degrades the sonar detection

Page 20: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

72

range heavily. The monthly variation analysis of

SLD will help underwater warfare operation analyst

officer in the navy to prepare and plan underwater

warfare operation without the need to perform own

in situ measurement which are again impractical

and relatively expensive for operational budget.

4. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.

The authors would like to thank to Banda

Indonesia Through Flow Dynamic Experiment and

NOAA (USA) from which the data source retrieved

for this study, Institut Pertanian Bogor (IPB),

Indonesian Ministry of Research Technology and

Higher education (Ristekdikti), LEGOS (France),

IFREMER (France) by whom BIDE conducted and

supported. All work has been done in Marine and

Coastal Data Laboratory, Marine Research Centre

(Indonesian Ministry of Marine Affairs and

Fisheries).

5. BIBLIOGRAPHY.

(FAS), F. o. A. S., 2013. Introduction of Naval

Weapons Engineering : Sonar Propagation.

[Online] Available at: https://fas.org/man/dod-

101/navy/docs/es310/SNR_PROP

Aji, T., Pranowo, W. S., Harsono, G. & Alam, T. M.,

2017. Seasonal Variability of Thermocline, Sound

Speed and Probable Shadow Zone in Sunda Strait,

Indonesia. 13(2), pp. 111-127.

Asryanto, L., 2018. Pembangunan Purwarupa Peta

Oseanografi Taktis Untuk Navigasi Kapal Selam di

Selat Sunda., Jakarta: STTAL.

Atmadipoera, A., 2017. Peta Trajektori Argo float

BIDE. [Online] Available at:

http://itk.ipb.ac.id/BIDE/index.php?floatid=6901746

Atmadipoera, A. et al., 2017. Early insight into CTD

argo float measurement in Banda Sea Indonesia,

Brest, France: Institut Pertanian Bogor.

Fox, D. N. et al., 2001. The Modular Ocean Data

Assimilation System. Journal of The Oceanography

Society, Volume 15.

Guest, A., 2014. Direct Path Propagation. [Online]

Available at: http://www.oc.nps.edu/-

bird/oc2930/acoustics/directpath.html

Helber, R. W., Barron, C. N., Carnes, M. R. &

Zingareli, R. A., 2008. Evaluating the sonic layer

depth relative to the mixed layer depth. Journal of

Geophysical Research, Volume 113.

Jatmiko, L. B., 2001. Menentukan Layer dan

Aplikasinya untuk Deteksi Bawah Air di Selat

Lombok, s.l.: STTAL.

jcommops, 2017. inspect platform 6901746 : about.

[Online] Available at:

http://www.jcommops.org/static/board/js/desktop/in

spect/ptf/index.html?iPtfRef=6901746#

jcommops, 2017. inspect platform 6901746 : data.

[Online] Available at:

http://www.jcommops.org/static/board/js/desktop/in

spect/ptf/index.html?iPtfRef=6901746#

Ludfy, L., 2007. Studi Pelemahan Pancaran Sonar

Aktif Type PHS 32 di Selat Makassar, Jakarta:

STTAL.

Marwoto, L. B., 2007. Studi Awal Sistem Penentuan

Posisi Akustik Bawah Air Bagi Kapal Selam Kelas

209 Tipe 1300, Jakarta: STTAL.

matlab, 2018. findpeaks. [Online] Available at:

https://www.mathworks.com/help/signal/ref/findpea

ks

NOAA, 2018. nodc_6901746_prof.nc. [Online]

Available at: https://www.nodc.noaa.gov/

Page 21: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

73

Pranowo, W. S., Hendrajana, B., Burhanuddin, S. &

Supangat, A., 2003. Akuisisi Data Temperatur dan

Salinitas di Samudera Hindia dengan

Menggunakan Argo Floats. Jakarta, Badan Riset

Kelautan dan Perikanan.

Pranowo, W. S., Philips, H. & Wiffels, S., 2005.

Upwelling Event 2003 along South Java Sea and

Lesser Sunda Island. Jurnal Segara, I(3), pp. 119-

126.

Purba, N. P., Pranowo, W. S., Faizal, I. & Adiwira,

H., 2018. Temperature-Salinity stratification in The

Eastern Indian Ocean using argo float. s.l., IOP

Conf. Ser. : Earth and Environ. Sci. 162 012010.

Rizanny, C. D., 2017. Merestorasi Kemampuan

'Anti Submarine Warfare' Kita. [Online] Available at:

http://maritimenews.com/meretorasi-kemampuan-

anti-submarine-warfare-kita

Schlitzer, R., 2015. Ocean Data View. [Online]

Available at: http://odv.awi.de

Taufiq, L. A. N., 2007. Studi Awal Pembuatan

Sistem Informasi Geografis Tactical Ocean Data

(SIG TOD) Untuk Operasional Kapal Selam Tipe

209/1300 (Studi Kasus di Perairan Selat Sunda),

Jakarta: STTAL.

Teague, W. J., Carron, M. J. & Hogan, P. J., 1990.

A comparison between the Generalized Digital

Environmental Model and Levitus Climatologies.

Journal of Geophysical Research, Volume 95.

Urick, R. J., 1983. Principles of Underwater Sound.

3 penyunt. Los Altos, California: Peninsula.

Villareal, V. A., 2014. Relationship between the

sonic layer depth and mixed layer depth identified

from US Navy sea glider data, Monterey, California:

Naval Postgraduate School.

Wahyudi, L. A., 2007. Propagasi Akustik Bawah Air

Untuk Navigasi dan Komunikasi Kapal Selam TNI

AL di Perairan Selat Makassar, Jakarta: STTAL.

Wainarisi, M. M., Kusumawardani, A. T. D. &

Brodjonegoro, I., 2017. Studi Lapisan Termoklin

Untuk Menentukan Pola Perambatan Gelombang

Suara Di Selat Makasar, Jakarta: STTAL.

Yuliadi, C. D., 2000. Konsep Penyediaan Peta

Layer dalam Mendukung Operasi dan Latihan

Peperangan Bawah Air, Jakarta: Seskoal.

Page 22: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 1/7

ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

Search

ANNOUNCEMENTS CURRENT ARCHIVES ABOUT

Register Login

HOME Submissions

Login or Register to make a submission.

Submission Preparation Checklist

As part of the submission process, authors are required to check off their submission's compliancewith all of the following items, and submissions may be returned to authors that do not adhere tothese guidelines.

Author Guidelines

1. SUBMISSION ADDRESS

We prefer submission or transmission by REGISTER in this conference's website. Any questions

/

The submission has not been previously published, nor is it before another journal forconsideration (or an explanation has been provided in Comments to the Editor).

The submission file is in OpenOffice, Microsoft Word, or RTF document file format.

Where available, URLs for the references have been provided.

The text is single-spaced; uses a 12-point font; employs italics, rather than underlining (exceptwith URL addresses); and all illustrations, figures, and tables are placed within the text at theappropriate points, rather than at the end.

The text adheres to the stylistic and bibliographic requirements outlined in the AuthorGuidelines.

Page 23: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 2/7

for publication should be sent electronically to:

Dr. Ahmadi ; Dr. Okol Sri Suharyo Indonesian Naval Technology College STTAL Surabaya

Indonesia

E-mail        : [email protected] ; [email protected]

Website    : www.asrojournal-sttal.ac.id

Telp        : +6231 99000583

2. STYLE GUIDELINES

File Format

Please send your paper as MS Word  for Windows™ document. In order to assure a smooth and

fast reviewing process and in order to avoid discrepancies in the printouts, we use the PDF-

Format for data exchange. Your paper can be published in higher quality if you follow the

guidelines below:

    page size of 210 mm x 297 mm (A4 size)

    resolution 2400 dpi (for PDF-file)

    top margin    : 30 mm

    bottom margin    : 30 mm

    left margin    : 30 mm

    right margin    : 30 mm

    line spacing    : single

    font        : Arial 10 pt

   The text/manuscript should be justified and give line number

   Submission of all types of manuscripts to conference  should be written in  English language

and prepared in accordance with the guidelines of the conference.

Please leave the header empty.

Copyright

The paper submitted should contain original unpublished work. The Editorial Office does not

accept responsibility for damage or loss of papers submitted. Upon acceptance of an article, the

author will be asked to give a non-exclusive copyright of the article to the publisher. Our aim is to

provide a decision on publication of articles within one-month period of reception in our editorial

office.

3. ARTICLE STRUCTURE

Title page

• Title. Concise and informative. Titles are often used in information-retrieval systems. Avoid

abbreviations and formulae where possible.

• Author names and affiliations. Where the family name may be ambiguous (e.g., a double name),

please indicate this clearly. Present the authors' affiliation addresses (where the actual work was

done) below the names. Indicate all affiliations with a lower-case superscript letter immediately

after the author's name and in front of the appropriate address. Provide the full postal address of

Page 24: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 3/7

each affiliation, including the country name, and, if available, the e-mail address of each author.

• Corresponding author. Clearly indicate who will handle correspondence at all stages of

refereeing and publication, also post-publication. Ensure that telephone and fax numbers (with

country and area code) are provided in addition to the e-mail address and the complete postal

address.

• Present/permanent address. If an author has moved since the work described in the article was

done, or was visiting at the time, a "Present address" (or "Permanent address") may be indicated

as a footnote to that author's name. The address at which the author actually did the work must be

retained as the main, affiliation address. Superscript Arabic numerals are used for such footnotes.

Abstract

A concise and factual abstract is required. The abstract should state briefly the purpose of the

research, the principal results and major conclusions. An abstract is often presented separately

from the article, so it must be able to stand alone. For this reason, References should be avoided,

but if essential, then cite the author(s) and year(s). Also, non-standard or uncommon

abbreviations should be avoided, but if essential they must be defined at their first mention in the

abstract itself. It should have not more than about 300 words.

Keywords

Immediately after the abstract, provide a maximum of five keywords, using American spelling

and avoiding general and plural terms and multiple concepts (avoid, for example, "and", "of"). Be

sparing with abbreviations: only abbreviations firmly established in the field may be eligible.

These keywords will be used for indexing purposes.

Introduction

State the objectives of the work and provide an adequate background, avoiding a detailed

literature survey or a summary of the results.

Methodology/ Experimental

Provide sufficient detail to allow the work to be reproduced. Methods already published should be

indicated by a reference: only relevant modifications should be described.

Results

Results should be clear and concise.

Discussion

Discussion must explore the significance of the results of the work, often in the concluding

paragraph, not repeat them. Avoid extensive citations and discussion of published literature. A

combined Results and Discussion section is often appropriate.

Conclusion

Page 25: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 4/7

The main conclusion of the study may be presented in a short Conclusions section, which may

stand alone or form a subsection of a Discussion or Results and Discussion section.

Acknowledgement (if any)

Collate acknowledgements in a separate section at the end of the article before the references and

do not, therefore, include them on the title page, as a footnote to the title or otherwise. List here

those individuals who provided help during the research (e.g., providing language help, writing

assistance or proof reading the article, etc.).

4. EXAMPLE FOR FIGURES

Please send your figures both embedded in your word file and in the original format (not

embedded). For printing a vector format is preferred. In case of photos etc. a resolution of 300 dpi

should be provided. Please make sure that all text in the figures is readable (font size >= 8pt).

Figures should be centered.

5. EXAMPLE FOR TABLES

Tables should be centered.

6. EXAMPLE FOR FORMULAE

Formulae should be numbered consecutively throughout the manuscript as (1), (2). In cases where

the derivation of formulae has been abbreviated, it is of great help to the reviewers if the full

derivation can be presented on a separate sheet (not to be published). Formulae should be

centered.

7. REFERENCES

Citation in text

Please ensure that every reference cited in the text is also present in the reference list (and vice

versa). Any references cited in the abstract must be given in full. Unpublished results and

personal communications are not recommended in the reference list, but may be mentioned in

the text. If these references are included in the reference list they should follow the standard

reference style of the journal and should include a substitution of the publication date with either

"Unpublished results" or "Personal communication" Citation of a reference as "in press" implies

that the item has been accepted for publication.

Web reference

As a minimum, the full URL should be given and the date when the reference was last accessed.

Any further information, if known (DOI, author names, dates, reference to a source publication,

etc.), should also be given. Web references can be listed separately (e.g., after the reference list)

Page 26: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 5/7

under a different heading if desired, or can be included in the reference list.

References in a special issue

Please ensure that the words 'this issue' are added to any references in the list (and any citations

in the text) to other articles in the same Special Issue.

Reference style

Text: Indicate references by number(s) in square brackets in line with the text. The actual authors

can be referred to, but the reference number(s) must always be given. References should be

indicated at the end of the text.

Reference to a conference publication:

Author, Initials., Year. Title of article. Full Title of Journal, Volume number (Issue/Part number),

Page numbers.

Author, Initials/first name., Year. Title of book. Edition. (only include this if not the first edition)

Place: Publisher.

Authorship, Year. Full title of conference paper. In: Editor or name of organization. Full title of

conference. Location, Date, Publisher: Place of publication

Author, Initials., Year. Title of article. Full Title of Journal, [type of medium] Volume number

(Issue/Part number), Page numbers if available. Available at: include web site address/URL

(Uniform Resource Locator) and additional details of access, such as the routing from the home

page of the source. [Accessed date].

Example :

Mettam, G.R., Adams, L.B. in: Jones, B.S., Smith, R.Z. (Eds.), (1994), Introduction to the Electronic

Age, E-Publishing, Inc. New York, p. 281–304.

Gang-Ji, Z., (2008), Hydrodinamics and water quality, Modeling rivers, lakes, and estuaries, Wiley-

Interscience, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey, USA.

Bruker, (2005), APEX2, SAINT and SADABS, Bruker AXS Inc., Madison, Wisconsin, USA.

Mamat, M., Kusrini, E., Yahaya, A.,. Hussein, M.Z., Zainal, Z., (2009), Synthesis and characterization

of Zn-Al-Anthranilate nanocomposites. In: Proceedings of the 25th Regional Conference on Solid

State Science and Technology 2009, Perlis, 2 December, Malaysia.

Other type of document and citation for a reference list, please refer to the Harvard System of

Referencing Guide.

8. REVIEW

Manuscripts will be reviewed anonymously by three independent experts. After the reviewers’

comments and recommendations to the editors the author will be informed about acceptance,

Page 27: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 6/7

acceptance with correction or rejection. The author(s) can freely proposed three name of

prospective referees to review the manuscript.

9. PERMISSIONS

It is the responsibility of the author to obtain written permission for quotations from unpublished

material, and for the reprinting of ill.

 Indexed by Google Scholar

INFORMATION

For Readers

For Authors

For Librarians

CURRENT ISSUE

Page 28: ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL - widodopranowo.idwidodopranowo.id/home/wp-content/...2018_IJASRO_vol-09-no-01_p-62-73.pdf · ASRO JOURNAL-STTAL is annual international referred journal with

15/9/2018 Submissions | ASRO JOURNAL - STTAL

http://asrojournal-sttal.ac.id/index.php/ASRO/about/submissions 7/7

     SUPPORTED BY INDONESIAN NAVAL INSTITUTEOF TECHNOLOGY - STTAL