atheism vs. theism a debate with no winner by jeffrey murico

8/2/2019 Atheism vs. Theism a Debate With No Winner by Jeffrey Murico

1/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 01%

234+5/*%6/7%84+5/*$%%

2%9+:;3+%3-%!(;?+*'>3%E5>B'(>%F>56+?/53G%

%!"#$%&'$$%845/%H;H+?%5>6+/35I;3+/%34+%*+3;H4G/5B;(%D+:;3+/%'BB)??5>I%:+3J++>%34+%K=+J%234+5/3/L% ;>D% K2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/7L% F35(5M5>I% 34+% J'?N% '@% ;>34?'H'('I5/3% 8;(;(%

2/;D-% 345/% H;H+?% 3?;B+/% 34+% J+/3+?>% B'>/3?)B35'>% '@% 34+% B;3+I'?G% '@% K?+(5I5'>L% 3'%

+OH(;5>%34+%J;G/%5>%J45B4%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%/):/B?5:+%3'%P;>D%B'>35>)+% 3'% H?'*'3+Q% ;% H?':(+*;35B% B'>B+H35'>% '@% K?+(5I5'>L% 3'% I?')>D% 34+5?%

?+/H+B356+%;?I)*+>3/7%84+%H?':(+*%5/%>'3%34;3%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%*5/)>D+?/3;>D% +;B4% '34+?R% ?;34+?-% 34+% H?':(+*% 5/% 34;3% 34+G% :'34% /):/B?5:+% 3'% ;%

J+/3+?>SB'>/3?)B3+D-%)>56+?/;(%D+@5>535'>%'@%?+(5I5'>-%J45B4%5/%B+>3+?+D%'>%B'I>5356+%

:+(5+@% ;>D% 5/% K/)HH'/+D% 3'% ;@@5?*% /'*+345>I% ;:')3% 34+% @)>D;*+>3;(% >;3)?+% '@%?+;(53G7L%

%(

)*+,-%.#$%>+J%;34+5/*-%;>;(G35B%34+5/*-%H'/3S*+3;H4G/5B/-%?+(5I5'>-%/+B)(;?%

%%

%

% 234+5/3/% ;>D% 34+5/3/% /++*% 3'% 4;6+% ;% ('3% 3'% 3;(N% ;:')3% 34+/+% D;G/7% 84+G%

?+I)(;?(G%+>I;I+%+;B4%'34+?%5>%D+:;3+-%34+G%;?+%H?'D)B5>I%/'*+%'@%34+%*'/3%H'H)(;?%

(53+?;3)?+%'>%34+%*;?N+3-%;>D%34+G%;?+%:+B'*5>I%4')/+4'(D%>;*+/%3'%:+%D5/B)//+D%;3%

D5>>+?% 3;:(+/% 34?')I4')3% 34+% J+/3+?>% J'?(D7% E'6+% 34+*% '?% 4;3+% 34+*-% 34+5?%

5>@()+>B+%5/%)>D+>5;:(+7%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/-%/)B4%;/%+%!?;5I-%"7C7%A'?+(;>D-%

;>D% "'4>%C'(N5>I4'?>+-% 4;6+% 6+?G% (533(+% 3?'):(+% /+((5>I%:''N/% '?% /+B)?5>I% 3+>)?+D%

H?'@+//'?/45H/% ;3% ?+/H+B3+D% )>56+?/535+/7% 84+% /;*+% I'+/% @'?% 34+% /'SB;((+D% K=+J%

234+5/3/-L%J4'%5>B()D+%>;*+/%/)B4%;/%#5B4;?D%9;JN5>/-%!4?5/3'H4+?%T53B4+>/-%U;*%

T;??5/-% ;>D%9;>5+(% 9+>>+337% 84+/+%=+J% 234+5/3/% ;>D% 2>;(G35B%84+5/3/% 4;6+% @')>D%

/)BB+//% @'?% 34+%/;*+%:;/5B% ?+;/'>$%34+G%'@@+?% ;?35B)(;3+%;>D% B?+;356+% ?+/H'>/+/% 3'%

J4;3%/++*/%3'%:+%34+%*'/3%5*H'?3;>3%V)+/35'>%5*;I5>;:(+$%K9'+/%W'D%+O5/3XL%'345>I% 5>4+?+>3(G% J?'>I% J534% ;/N5>I-% '?% ;33+*H35>I% 3'% ;>/J+?-% 345/%


2/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 0Y%

V)+/35'>-%:'34%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%34+%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%B'**53%;%/+?5+/%'@%B?)B5;(%

+??'?/% 5>% ;33+*H35>I% 3'% D'% /'7% Z'34% I?')H/% H(;B+% 345/% V)+/35'>% ;3% 34+% B+>3+?% '@%

K?+(5I5'>-L% :'34% ?+(G% '>% ;>% +//+>35;(5/3% >'35'>% '@% K?+(5I5'>-L%J45B4% 5/% B+>3+?+D% '>%

:+(5+@-% ;>D% :'34% *5/3;N+>(G% )>D+?/3;>D% 34+% V)+/35'>% '@% W'D% 3'% :+% ;% /B5+>35@5B%

4GH'34+/5/% J45B4% B;>% :+% ;>/J+?+D% I56+>% ;% B'??+B3% /+3% '@% H?+*5/+/% ;>D% H?''@/7%

F35(5M5>I%34+%J'?N%'@%H?'*5>+>3%;>34?'H'('I5/3%8;(;(%2/;D-%345/%H;H+?%J5((%3?;B+%34+%

J+/3+?>%B'>/3?)B35'>%'@%34+% B;3+I'?G%'@% ?+(5I5'>% 3'%+OH(;5>% 34+%J;G/% 5>%J45B4% 34+%

=+J% 234+5/3/% ;>D% 2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% /):/B?5:+% 3'% P;>D% B'>35>)+% 3'% H?'*'3+Q% ;%

H?':(+*;35B% B'>B+H35'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>% 3'% I?')>D% 34+5?% ?+/H+B356+% ;?I)*+>3/7% 84+%

H?':(+*% 5/% >'3% 34;3% 34+% =+J% 234+5/3/% ;>D% 2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% *5/)>D+?/3;>D% +;B4%

'34+?7% #;34+?-% 34+% H?':(+*% 5/% 34;3% 34+G% :'34% /):/B?5:+% 3'% ;%J+/3+?>SB'>/3?)B3+D-%

)>56+?/;(% D+@5>535'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>-% J45B4% 5/% B+>3+?+D% '>% B'I>5356+% :+(5+@% ;>D% 5/%

K/)HH'/+D% 3'% ;@@5?*% /'*+345>I% ;:')3% 34+% @)>D;*+>3;(% >;3)?+% '@% ?+;(53G7L,% 845/-% .%

;?I)+-%D'+/%>'3%H;G%?+/H+B3%3'% 34+%6;?5+3G%'@%H'//5:(+%+(+*+>3/%34;3%*;N+%)H%*;>G%

H+'H(+[/%?+(5I5')/%5D+>353G7%

% 5@5B;>3%H'?35'>%'@%345/%H;H+?%J5((%:+%D+6'3+D%3'%34+%+OH'/535'>%;>D%

;>;(G/5/%'@%3J'%D5/35>B3%I?')H/-%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%34+%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/-%>+534+?%

/+B35'>% /4')(D% :+%?+;D% ;/%;% B'*H?+4+>/56+% '6+?65+J-% '?%+//+>35;(5/3% D+H5B35'>% '@%

+;B4% H+?/H+B356+7% 84+?+% ;?+% B'>/5D+?;:(+% D5@@+?+>B+/-% @'?% +O;*H(+-% 5>% 34+% J;G%

9;JN5>/%;>D%T53B4+>/% (+6+?;I+%34+5?%?+/H+B356+%B?535B5/*/%;3%?+(5I5'>7%84+%2>;(G35B%

84+5/3/-%;/%J+((-%+*H('G%;%6;?5+3G%'@%3+B4>5V)+/%;>D%3;B35B/%3'%D+B'>/3?)B3%34+%'34+?7%

B+/%D+/+?6+%*'?+%H'5>3+D%\)/35@5B;35'>%'?%B?535B5/*%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%,%8;(;(%2/;D-%!"#"$%&'(")*&+*,"%('( -%PZ;(35*'?+%;>D%E'>D'>$%84+%"'4>/%T'HN5>/%F>56+?/53G%C?+//-%

,]]0Q-%10%


3/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 0^%

J5345>% 34+% B'>6+?/;35'>/% 34+G% ;?+% 4;65>I-% 345/% H;H+?% ;B3/% ;/% ;%J5D+?% (+>/-%J45B4%

?+6+;(/% ;% *+34'D'('I5B;(% +??'?% 34;3% 5/% /4;?+D% :G% ;((% H;?35+/% 5>% 34+% B'>6+?/;35'>7%

84+?+@'?+-%?;34+?%34;>%D?+DI+%34?')I4%+O3+>/56+%+O;*H(+/%;6;5(;:(+%'>%:'34%/5D+/%'@%

34+%;?I)*+>3-%345/%H;H+?%)35(5M+/%34+%J'?N%'@%'>(G%;%@+JR%>;*+(G-%#5B4;?D%9;JN5>/[/%

-."*!&/*0"%1)(-%!4?5/3'H4+?%T53B4+>/[/%!&/*()*2&3*!4"$35*;>D%+%!?;5I[/%

:''N%'@%B'((+B3+D%+//;G/%!&/*()*!&&/5*!&/*()*!4"$36*%

.>%J4;3%@'(('J/%.%4'H+%3'%D+*'>/3?;3+%34+%J;G/%5>%J45B4%34+%=+J%234+5/3/[%

B?535B5/*/% ?+(G% )H'>% ;% J+/3+?>SB'>/3?)B35'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>% 34;3% 5/% :+(5+@SB+>3+?+D-%

B'>B+?>+D% J534% /B5+>35@5B% 4GH'34+/+/% '>% 34+% V)+/35'>% '@% W'D[/% +O5/3+>B+-% ;>D%

B'>B+H3);(5M+% ?+(5I5'>% 3'% :+% ;% )>56+?/;(-% 3?;>/45/3'?5B;(-% ;>D% 3?;>/B)(3)?;(%

H4+>'*+>'>7%#5B4;?D%9;JN5>/-%@'?%+O;*H(+-%:+I5>/%45/%:''N-%-."*!&/*0"%1)(%J534%

;>% +OH(;>;35'>% '@% 34+% 353(+7% T+% J?53+/% 34;3% 34+% 7"#'1(#*8#'%().*0(93($4:% D+@5>+/%

KD+()/5'>L%;/%K;%@;(/+%:+(5+@%'?%5*H?+//5'>7L_%`(/+J4+?+-%4+%>'3+/%34;3%KD+()/5'>L%5/%

D+@5>+D% ;/% K;% H+?/5/3+>3% @;(/+% :+(5+@% 4+(D% 5>% 34+% @;B+% '@% /3?'>I% B'>3?;D5B3'?G%

+65D+>B+7L0%Z+(5+@%5>%;%/)H+?>;3)?;(%W'D-%;BB'?D5>I%3'%9;JN5>/-%5/%/'*+345>I%34;3%5/%

B'>3?;D5B3+D%:G%/B5+>35@5B*+65D+>B+7%T+%;I?++/%J534%#':+?3%A7%C5?/5I%J4+>%4+%J?53+/%

5>%45/%@;*')/%>'6+(%;"#*$#/*3."*


4/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 0e%

?+(5I5')/%:+(5+6+?/%J534%;%*'?+%;BB)?;3+%D+/B?5H35'>%'@%34+%J'?(D%/'%34;3%34+G%J5((%

4;6+%(533(+%B4'5B+%:)3%3'%?+>')>B+%?+(5I5'>%;>D%:+B'*+%;34+5/3/7Y%%

T+%@5?*(G%:+(5+6+/%34;3%?+(5I5'>%5/%+//+>35;((G%;%@;(/+%:+(5+@%/G/3+*%;:')3%34+%

>;3)?+% '@% 34+% J'?(D%;>D% B'/*'/-%J45B4%B;>% :+%:+33+?% +OH(;5>+D% :G% 34+% 34+'?G% '@%

+6'()35'>7% .>% '34+?% J'?D/-% 34+% V)+/35'>% '@% W'D[/% +O5/3+>B+-% 34)/% 34+% V)+/35'>% '@%

?+(5I5'>[/%6;()+-%5/%B'>35>I+>3%)H'>%K34+%W'D%TGH'34+/5/-L%+OH(;5>+D%4+?+$%%

K-."4"*">()3)*$*)1?"4.1@$#5*)1?"4#$314$%*(#3"%%('"#9"*A.&*/"%(B"4$3"%:*

/")('#"/*$#/* 94"$3"/* 3."* 1#(C"4)"*$#/* "C"4:3.(#'* (#* (35* (#9%1/(#'* 1)6%

845/%:''N%J5((%;D6'B;3+%;>%;(3+?>;356+%65+J$%$#:*94"$3(C"*(#3"%%('"#9"5*&+*)1++(9("#3*9&@?%">(3:*3&*/")('#*$#:3.(#'5*9&@")*(#3&*">()3"#9"*%:*$)*

3."*"#/*?4&/193*&+*$#*">3"#/"/*?4&9"))*&+*'4$/1$%*"C&%13( 7%!?+;356+%5>3+((5I+>B+/-% :+5>I% +6'(6+D-% >+B+//;?5(G% ;??56+% (;3+% 5>% 34+% )>56+?/+-%;>D%34+?+@'?+%B;>>'3%:+%?+/H'>/5:(+%@'?%D+/5I>5>I%537%W'D-%5>%34+%/+>/+%

D+@5>+D-% 5/%;%D+()/5'>R% ;>D-% ;/% (;3+?% B4;H3+?/%J5((%/4'J-% ;%H+?>5B5')/%D+()/5'>7L,%

%

W'D%+534+?%+O5/3/%'?%D'+/%>'3%+O5/37%F>D+?/3;>D5>I%34;3%*;>G%H+'H(+%@5>D%;%45I4%(+6+(%

'@%;*:5I)53G% 5>% 34+% +65D+>B+% ;6;5(;:(+% 3'%+534+?% /)HH'?3% '?%D+>G%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+-%

9;JN5>/%+OH(;5>/%3J'%3GH+/%'@%;I>'/35B5/*-%'?%3J'%H'//5:(+%J;G/%'>+%B;>%(''N%;3%34+%

W'D%4GH'34+/5/7%82C%P3+*H'?;?G%;I>'/35B5/*%5>%H?;B35B+Q%5/%34+%H+?/H+B356+%34;3%'>+%

J5344'(D/%4+?%H'/535'>%'>%;%V)+/35'>%)>35(%*'?+%+65D+>B+%5/%H?'65D+D7_%b'?%+O;*H(+-%

'>+% B')(D%:+% \)/35@5;:(G%;I>'/35B% '>%34+%V)+/35'>%'@%J4+34+?%'?%>'3% 34+?+% ;?+% ;>G%

:(;BN%/J;>/%5>%;%(;N+%5@%/4+%4;/%G+3%3'%/++%;((%'@%34+%/J;>/%P;>D%4;/%G+3%3'%@5>D%;>G%

:(;BN%/J;>/-%'@%B')?/+Q7%84+%H'5>3%:+5>I-%34+?+%5/%;%J;G%3'%D+3+?*5>+%34+%3?)34%3'%34+%

V)+/35'>$%'>+%B')(D%@5>D%;((%'@%34+%/J;>/%;>D%':/+?6;35'>;((G%D+3+?*5>+%J4+34+?%'?%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Y%.:5D7%K.@%345/%:''N%J'?N/%;/%.%5>3+>D-%?+(5I5')/%?+;D+?/%J4'%'H+>%53%J5((%:+%;34+5/3/%J4+>%34+G%H)3%53%

D'J>7L%%,%.:5D-%Y_%%_%.:5D-%^]Sec%


5/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 0d%

>'3%34+?+%J+?+%;>G%:(;BN%'>+/7%F>35(%/4+%':/+?6+/%34+*%;((-%4'J+6+?-%/4+%5/%+>353(+D%

3'%:+% ;I>'/35B% '>%34+%V)+/35'>7% .@-% 4'J+6+?-%/4+%N>'J/%34;3% 34+?+%;?+%+O;B3(G% 3J'%

4)>D?+D% /J;>/%5>%34+% (;N+%;>D% /4+% 5/%B+?3;5>% 34;3% /4+% 4;/% /++>%'>+S4)>D?+D% ;>D%

>5>+3GS>5>+%J453+%/J;>/-%/4+%B;>%H?+/)*+%J534%45I4%H?':;:5(53G%34;3%34+%(;/3%/J;>%

J5((%;(/'%:+%J453+7%%

U+B'>D(G-% 9;JN5>/% D+/B?5:+/% C2C% PH+?*;>+>3% ;I>'/35B5/*% 5/% H?5>B5H(+Q-%

J45B4%4+%/;G/%5/% K;HH?'H?5;3+%@'?%V)+/35'>/%34;3%B;>%>+6+?%:+%;>/J+?+D-%>'%*;33+?%

4'J%*)B4%+65D+>B+%J+%I;34+?-%:+B;)/+%34+%6+?G%5D+;%'@%+65D+>B+%5/%>'3%;HH(5B;:(+7L0%

84+%V)+/35'>%'@%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+-%9;JN5>/%B(;5*/-%K:+('>I/%@5?*(G%5>% 34+%3+*H'?;?G%

'?%82C%B;3+I'?G7%`534+?%4+%+O5/3/%'?%4+%D'+/>[37%.3%5/%;%/B5+>35@5B%V)+/35'>R%'>+%D;G%J+%

*;G%N>'J%34+%;>/J+?-%;>D%*+;>J45(+%J+%B;>%/;G%/'*+345>I%H?+33G%/3?'>I%;:')3%

34+%H?':;:5(53G7L1%.3%5/%B(+;?%34;3%9;JN5>/%@5>D/%34+%V)+/35'>%'@%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+%3'%:+%

)(35*;3+(G%;>/J+?;:(+%34?')I4%/B5+>35@5B%5>V)5?G7%b)?34+?*'?+-%9;JN5>/%;(/'%B(;5*/%

34;3% :+(5+@% 5>% W'D% 5/% ;>/J+?;:(+% 3'% 5>3+((+B3);(% ;?I)*+>3/% @'?% ;>D% ;I;5>/3% 34+%

+O5/3+>B+%'@%W'D7%

% K.% 4;6+% ;% ?+/H'>/5:5(53G-L% 9;JN5>/% J?53+/-% K3'% D5/H'/+% '@% 34+% H'/5356+%

;?I)*+>3/%@'?%:+(5+@%34;3%4;6+%:++>%'@@+?+D%34?')I4%45/3'?G7LY%.3%5/%;3%345/%H'5>3%34;3%

9;JN5>/% +>I;I+/%J534% 34+% 2>;(G35B/-% /)B4% ;/% 2V)5>;/[/% KH?''@/L% PK84+%F>*'6+D%

A'6+?-L% K84+% F>B;)/+D% !;)/+-L% ;>D% K84+% !'/*'('I5B;(% 2?I)*+>3LQ-% 2>/+(*[/%

K'>3'('I5B;(%;?I)*+>3L% P65;% C(;>35>I;Q-%;>D%34+%K;?I)*+>3% @?'*%D+/5I>-L% 3'%H?'6+%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%0%.:5D-%ec%%1%.:5D7%2('>I%34+%/;*+%(5>+/-%9;JN5>/%;(/'%>'3+/$%K.%/)II+/3%34;3%34+%+O5/3+>B+%'@%W'D%5/%;%/B5+>35@5B%

4GH'34+/5/%(5N+%;>G%'34+?L%Pe_QR%KW'D[/%+O5/3+>B+%'?%>'>S+O5/3+>B+%5/%;%/B5+>35@5B%@;B3%;:')3%34+%

)>56+?/+-%D5/B'6+?;:(+%5>%H?5>B5H(+%5@%>'3%5>%H?;B35B+7L%Pe0Q7%%Y%.:5D-%]]%%


6/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 0]%

34;3%:+(5+@%5>%W'D%5/%)>J;??;>3+D7%F>J;??;>3+D-%:+B;)/+%+;B4%'@%34+/+%;?I)*+>3/-%

;BB'?D5>I% 3'% 9;JN5>/-% 5/% :+33+?% +OH(;5>+D% :G% /B5+>35@5B% P*'/3(G% +6'()35'>;?GQ%

H?':;:5(53G7% b)?34+?*'?+-% 9;JN5>/% H(;B+/% 34+% KW'D% 4GH'34+/5/L% ;3% 34+% B+>3+?% '@%

?+(5I5'>7% .>% '34+?%J'?D/-% 5@% 34+% W'D% 4GH'34+/5/% 5/% @;(/+-% J45B4%9;JN5>/% B(;5*/% 5/%

5>D++D%34+%B;/+-% 34+>% ?+(5I5'>%4;/%:++>%D+;(3% 53/% @5>;(% :('J7%#+(5I5'>-%;BB'?D5>I% 3'%

9;JN5>/-%5/%)(35*;3+(G%;>D%)>56+?/;((G%B'>B+?>+D%J534%34+%/B5+>35@5B%V)+/35'>-%K9'+/%

W'D% +O5/3XL% T+% J?53+/-% K.@% 34+% ;?I)*+>3% '@% 345/% B4;H3+?% 5/% ;BB+H3+D-% 34+% @;B3);(%

H?+*5/+%'@%?+(5I5'>%f%34+%W'D%TGH'34+/5/%f% 5/%)>3+>;:(+7%W'D%;(*'/3%B+?3;5>(G%D'+/%

>'3%+O5/37L^%

% 9;JN5>/%5/% +OH(5B53%;:')3%45/%65+J/%'>% 34+% V)+/35'>%'@% W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+% ;>D%

J4;3% :+(5+@% 5>%W'D% ;*')>3/% 3'7% T+% 5/% (+//%D5?+B3-% 4'J+6+?-% 5>%45/% )/+% '@% 34+% 3+?*%

K?+(5I5'>7L%T+%3+((/%)/%34;3%4+%\)/3%N>'J/%34;3%53%+O5/3/%;>D%34;3%53%+O5/3/%+6+?GJ4+?+7%

U)B4%;%B'>B()/5'>%;//)*+/%34;3%?+(5I5'>%4;/%;%B'?+-%'?%+//+>B+-%J45B4%5/%?+D)B5:(+%3'%

:+(5+@% 5>%;% /)H+?>;3)?;(% W'D7e% T+% ;(/'% ?+(5+/% '>% 34+% ;//)*H35'>% 34;3% ?+(5I5'>% 5/% ;%

)>56+?/;(%H4+>'*+>'>%34;3%5/%3?;>/45/3'?5B;(%;>D%3?;>/B)(3)?;(7%T+%J?53+/-%K35;(5/3%;>D%

)>56+?/;(%B'>B+H35'>%'@%?+(5I5'>%34;3%I56+/%45*%P;>D%'34+?/Q%(5B+>/+%3'%:(;*+%?+(5I5'>%

@'?%34+%*;>G%5((/%'@%/'B5+3G7%b'?%+O;*H(+-%4+%:(;*+/%?+(5I5'>-%'?%34+%K#SJ'?D-L%;/%4+%

?+@+?/%3'%53%;3%35*+/-%@'?%;33;BN/%'>%;:'?35'>%B(5>5B/%5>%2*+?5B;-%'@@+>/+/%3'%J'*+>%5>%

34+% A5DD(+% `;/3-% B45(D% ;:)/+% 5>% 34+% !;34'(5B% !4)?B4-% B')>3(+//% ?+(5I5')/% J;?/-% +3%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%^%.:5D-%,ddS,d]%%e%.:5D%%d%.:5D-%,d]%%


7/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1c%

B+3+?;-%+3%B+3+?;7]%-%9;JN5>/%@5>D/%45/%;>/J+?%5>%J4;3%4+%)>D+?/3;>D/%?+(5I5'>[/%B'?+-%'?%+//+>B+%

3'% :+$% @;(/+%:+(5+@-% '?% @;5347% 9;JN5>/% J?53+/-% Kb;534% 5/% ;>% +65(% H?+B5/+(G% :+B;)/+% 53%

?+V)5?+/% >'% \)/35@5B;35'>% ;>D% :?''N/% >'% ;?I)*+>37% 8+;B45>I% B45(D?+>% 34;3%

)>V)+/35'>+D%@;534%5/%;%65?3)+%H?5*+/%34+*%f%I56+>%B+?3;5>%'34+?%5>I?+D5+>3/%34;3%;?+%

>'3%4;?D%3'%B'*+%:G%f%3'%I?'J%)H%5>3'%H'3+>35;((G%(+34;(%J+;H'>/%@'?%@)3)?+%\54;D/%'?%

B?)/;D+/7L,c%!4?5/3'H4+?%T53B4+>/-%5>%45/%:''N%!&/*()*2&3*!4"$3D*E&A*,"%('(*7&())*

8C"4:3.(#'-%5/%(+//%B'>B+?>+D%J534%34+%KW'DS4GH'34+/5/L%;>D%*'?+%B'>B+?>+D%J534%

34+%>+I;356+%?'(+%?+(5I5'>%H(;G/%5>%')?%/'B5+3G7,,%

% T53B4+>/[/% J'?N% D+*'>/3?;3+/% 34+% +O3+>3% 3'% J45B4% /)B4% ;% 34+/5/% B;>% :+%

B;??5+D%')37%.>%'34+?%J'?D/-%45/%B'>B+H35'>%'@%?+(5I5'>%5/%+OH(5B53(G%+//+>35;(5/3%;>D%

)>56+?/;(7%T+%B'>B()D+/%45/%@5?/3%B4;H3+?-%J45B4%;B3/%;/%34+%:''N[/%5>3?'D)B35'>-%:G%

/3;35>I%34+%@'(('J5>I$%K2/%.%J?53+%34+/+%J'?D/-%;>D%;/%G')%?+;D%34+*-%H+'H(+%'@%@;534%

;?+%5>%34+5?%D5@@+?+>3%J;G/%H(;>>5>I%G')?%;>D%*G%D+/3?)B35'>-%;>D%34+%D+/3?)B35'>%'@%

;((% 34+% 4;?DSJ'>% 4)*;>% ;33;5>*+>3/% 34;3% .% 4;6+% 3')B4+D% )H'>7%,"%('(* ?&())*

"C"4:3.(#'6L,_% A)B4% (5N+% 9;JN5>/-% T53B4+>/% ?+(5+/% '>% ;>% +//+>35;(5/3-% )>56+?/;(-%

3?;>/45/3'?5B;(-% ;>D% 3?;>/B)(3)?;(% B'>B+H35'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>% 5>% '?D+?% 3'% (+6+?;I+% 45/%

;33;BN/7%#+(5I5'>-%;BB'?D5>I%3'%T53B4+>/-%5/%;>%+OH5?+D-%K*;>S*;D+L%J;G%'@%345>N5>I-%

J45B4% 5/% H?+D5B;3+D% )H'>% H+'H(+/[% K@+;?% '@% D+;34L% ;>D% ;B3/% 3'% KN5((L% '?% KH'5/'>L%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%]%.:5D-%0,eS00^%,c%.:5D-%01eS01d%,,%T53B4+>/%D'+/%+>I;I+%J534%/'*+%'@%34+%;?I)*+>3/%@'?%34+%+O5/3+>B+%'@%W'D-%4'J+6+?7%T+%4;/%;%

B4;H3+?%353(+D-%K2?I)*+>3/%@?'*%9+/5I>-L%;>D%;>'34+?%B;((+D-%K84+%#+/5/3;>B+%'@%34+%#;35'>;(-L%J45B4%

@'(('J%;%/5*5(;?%(5>+%'@%34')I43%3'%9;JN5>/7%T5/%)/+%'@%345/%;?I)*+>3;35'>-%4'J+6+?-%5/%5>3+>D+D%3'%

?+6+;(%34+%H+?>5B5')/%B'?+%'@%K?+(5I5'>7L%%,_%!4?5/3'H4+?%T53B4+>/-%!&/*()*2&3*!4"$3D*E&A*,"%('(*7&())*8C"4:3.(#' -%P=+J%a'?N$%T;B4+33+%Z''N%

W?')H-%_cceQ-%,0%


8/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1,%

+6+?G345>I% ;>D% +6+?G'>+7,0% /[/% *'?+% ')3?;I+')/%

B(;5*/%;>D%J'?D%B4'5B+/-%4+%B'>/5/3+>3(G%+V);3+/%K?+(5I5'>L%J534%K+65(7L%%

2BB'?D5>I% 3'%T53B4+>/-% 34+%*'?+%?+(5I5')/%/'*+'>+%5/-% 34+%*'?+%+65(%45/% '?%

4+?%3+>D+>B5+/%:+B'*+7%UH+;N5>I% ;:')3% ./(;*5B%65'(+>B+%;>D%+O3?+*5/*-%T53B4+>/%

J?53+/-% K84+% 3?)+% :+(5+6+?% B;>>'3% ?+/3% )>35(% 34+% J4'(+% J'?(D% :'J/% 34+% N>++7L,1%

UB'?+/%'@%A)/(5*/%J')(D%/)?+(G%D5/;I?++-%>'35>I%34+%6;?5+3G%'@%./(;*5B%;HH?';B4+/%3'%

H5+3G7,Y%2I;5>-%T53B4+>/%J?53+/-%K84+%J'?/+%34+%'@@+>D+?-%34+%*'?+%D+6')3%4+%3)?>/%

')3%3'%:+7L,^%845/%*;G%;HH+;?-%'>%34+%/)?@;B+-%3'%:+%;%B'??+(;356+%3?)34%3'%34+%;6+?;I+%

?+;D+?R% 4'J+6+?-% /)B4% ;% B(;5*% H?+/)HH'/+/% ;% /B;(+% '@% ?+(5I5'/53G% 34;3% B;>% :+%

*+;/)?+D%5>%/'*+%J;G7%.>%'34+?%J'?D/-%J4'%5/%3'%/;G%34;3%;>G%I56+>%H'/535'>%5/%*'?+%

?+(5I5')/% 34;>% ;>'34+?X% C(+>3G% '@% (5:+?;(% !4?5/35;>/% J5((% @5>D% `6;>I+(5B;(%

b)>D;*+>3;(5/3/%3'%:+%(+//%?+(5I5')/-%;>D%65B+S6+?/;7%%

E;/3(G-% 5>% 45/% /)?6+G% '@% K;((% ?+(5I5'>-L% T53B4+>/% @;B+/% ;% H?':(+*% H'/+D% :G%

`;/3+?>%3?;D535'>/7%T+%)>D+?/3;>D/%34+*%3'%:+%D+B5D+D(G%(+//%65'(+>3%;>D%'@@+>/56+7%

T'J+6+?-%4+%*)/3%;BB')>3%@'?%J4G%34+/+%`;/3+?>%?+(5I5'>/%S%Z)DD45/*-%T5>D)5/*-%

;>D%U45>3'%S%*5I43%>'3%@53%5>3'%45/%*'D+(%34;3%;((%?+(5I5'>%5/%+65(%;>D%65'(+>37%b5?/3-%4+%

H'5>3/%')3%34;3%T5>D)5/*-%D+/H53+%')?%%)>D+?/3;>D5>I%'@%53-%4;/%;B3);((G%4;D%

;%@;5?(G%65'(+>3%/4'J5>I7%T+%?+*5>D/%)/%'@%34+%65'(+>3%;B35'>/%3;N+>%:G%34+%8;*5(/%

PJ4'-% 5>% ?+;(53G-%B'>/5/3% '@%;% 6;?5+3G%'@% ?+(5I5')/% 3?;D535'>/% :)3%;?+%H?+D'*5>;>3(G%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%,0%.:5D-%e-%,_S,0-%,Y%%,1%.:5D-%0,%,Y%C'5>35>I%')3%34;3%T53B4+>/%?+(5+/%'>%;>%+//+>35;(5/3%>'35'>%'@%?+(5I5'>%D'+/%>'3-%4'J+6+?-%+OB)/+%34+%

6;?5')/%?+(5I5')/%H+'H(+%J4'%;(/'%/):/B?5:+%3'%+//+>35;(5/3%;>D%)>56+?/;(%D+@5>535'>/7%.3%5/%'@3+>%34+%

B;/+%34;3%?+(5I5')/%:+(5+6+?/%34+*/+(6+/%;?+%34+%*'/3%+@@+B356+%5>%H?'*'35>I%/)B4%;3353)D+/7%.3%J5((%

:+B'*+%+65D+>3%34;3%34+%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%+O;*5>+D%5>%34+%@'(('J5>I%/+B35'>%P*;5>(G%+%

!?;5IQ%;?+%+V);((G%I)5(3G%'@%/)B4%'@@+>/+/7%%,^%.:5D-%,]_%


9/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1_%

T5>D)Q-%34+%/'B5;(%5>\)/35B+/%34;3%?+/)(3%@?'*%34+%B;/3+%/G/3+*-%+3B7%U45>3'-%(5N+%i+>-%5/%

J?533+>%'@@%;/%;%KV);/5S?+(5I5'>-L%34+?+@'?+%4;?D+?%3'%H5>%D'J>7,e%Z)DD45/*-%T53B4+>/%

>'3+/-%B;>%+534+?%:+%D+/B?5:+D%;/%K>'3%;%?+(5I5'>%;3%;((-L%'?%D+/B?5:+D%;/%5??;35'>;(-%

*5>D(+//-%;>D%;3%35*+/-%65'(+>37,d%84)/-%Z)DD45/*%5/%+534+?%(+//%65'(+>3%:+B;)/+%53%5/%

(+//%?+(5I5')/-%'?%53%5/%*'?+%65'(+>3%34;>%J+%345>N7%`534+?%J;G-%T53B4+>/%*;N+/%53%@53%

5>3'% 45/% /B4+*+7% 84+% `;/3+?>% 3?;D535'>/-% @)?34+?*'?+-% ;?+% D+@5>+D% ;/% K?+(5I5'>/L%

)/5>I% ;% % B'>/3?)B35'>% '@% 34+% 3+?*7% 23% 345/% H'5>3% 53% /4')(D% :+% B(+;?% 34;3%

9;JN5>/%;>D%T53B4+>/%?+(G%'>%;3%(+;/3%34?++%*5/I)5D+D-%J+/3+?>SB+>3?5B%D+@5>535'>/%

'@%?+(5I5'>$% P,Q% ?+(5I5'>%5/% H?5*;?5(G% ;:')3% :+(5+@-%P_Q% 34+%V)+/35'>%'@% :+(5+@% 5>%W'D%

/4')(D%:+%B'>/3?)B3+D%;/%/B5+>35@5B%4GH'34+/5/%;:')3%34+%V)+/35'>%'@%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+-%

;>D%P0Q%?+(5I5'>%5/%;%)>56+?/;(-%3?;>/45/3'?5B;(-%;>D%3?;>/B)(3)?;(%H4+>'*+>'>7%%

%% 84+%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%+*H('G%34+%/;*+%*+34'D'('IG%;/%34+%=+J%234+5/3-%'>(G%

3'%H?'6+%34+%'HH'/53+%H'5>3$%W'D%D'+/%+O5/37%#+(5I5'>-%;BB'?D5>I%34+*-%5/%D+@+>D;:(+%

34?')I4% ;>;(G35B% ?+;/'>5>I-% /B5+>35@5B% 5>V)5?G-% ;>D% 6;?5')/% H?''@/7% +%

!?;5I%;>D%!4;D%A+5/3+?%B'S+D53+D% !&/*()*!&&/5*!&/*()*!4"$3D*F.:*G"%("C(#'*(#*!&/*()*

,"$)$B%"*$#/*,")?)(B%"5%;%:''N%'@%+//;G/%34;3%H?+/+>3%6;?5')/%;?I)*+>3/%@'?%34+%

+O5/3+>B+%'@%W'D7%.>%34+%5>3?'D)B35'>%3'%34+%:''N%!?;5I%J?53+/-%K2/%G')%?+;D%34?')I4%

34+% @'(('J5>I% H;I+/% J+% B4;((+>I+% G')% 3'% B;?+@)((G% J+5I4% 34+% ;?I)*+>3/% ;>D%

+65D+>B+/%'>%:'34%/5D+/%'@%34+/+%5//)+/%;>D-%;/%2)I)/35>+%+O4'?3+D-%@'(('J%34+%3?)34%

J4+?+6+?%53%(+;D/7L,]%#+(5I5')/%8?)34-%;BB'?D5>I%!?;5I-%B;>%:+%@')>D%J5345>%34+%(;J/%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%,e.:5D-%_c0%,d%.:5D-%,]]S_c1%,]%!&/*()*!&&/5*!&/*()*!4"$3-%`D53+D%:G%+%!?;5I%;>D%!4;D%A+5/3+?-%P.((5>'5/$%.>3+?&;?/53G%

C?+//-%_cc]Q-%,c%


10/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 10%

'@%H4G/5B/%;>D%('I5B%;>D%B;>%:+%;?I)+D%J534%+65D+>B+7%.>%+@@+B3-%J4;3%J+%4;6+%4+?+%5/%

;%B'*H+3535'>%:+3J++>%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%B+>3+?+D%'>%34+%V)+/35'>%

'@%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+7%!?;5I%J?53+/-%%

Kj)?%H?5*;?G%':\+B356+%5>%B'*H5(5>I%345/%:''N%5/%3'%;>/J+?%B4;((+>I+/%;D6;>B+D%:G%34+%=+J%234+5/3/[%J?535>I/%;>D%'34+?/%?;5/5>I%':\+B35'>/%

3'%:+(5+@%5>%W'D%;>D%!4?5/35;>%@;5347%9+/H53+%')?%'6+?;((%5*H?+//5'>%'@%

34+% =+J% 234+5/3/[% J?535>I/% ;/% @?+/4% H;BN;I5>I% @'?% k35?+D-% J+;N-% ;>D%?+BGB(+D% ;?I)*+>3/[% P3'% :'??'J% ;% H4?;/+% @?'*% 2(5/3+?% ;>D% "';>>;%

!'((5B)33%ABW?;34[/%;//+//*+>3%'@%9;JN5>/[/%-."*!&/*0"%1)(Q-%34+G%;?+% *;N5>I% *)B4% *'?+% 4+;DJ;G% J534% 34+5?% *+//;I+% 34;>% *;>G%

?+(5I5')/%:+(5+6+?/%;?+%J5((5>I%3'%;D*537L_c%%

%.3% J')(D% :+% '>+% 345>I% 5@% 34+% 2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% D5/?+I;?D+D% 34+% =+J% 234+5/3/%

;?I)*+>3/%;/%K*5//5>I%34+%H'5>3-L%'?%K>'3%?+(+6;>3%3'%V)+/35'>/%;:')3%W'D-L%:)3%34+G%

D'% >'3% D'% 345/7% #;34+?-% 34+G% H?'B++D% :G% B'>/3?)B35>I% ;?I)*+>3/% 34;3% ;HH+;(% 3'%

/B5+>35@5B% ?+;/'>5>I-% ('I5B-% ;>D% H4G/5B;(% +65D+>B+7% 2/% !?;5I% H'5>3/% ')3-% 34+G% 4;6+%

D?;J>%)H'>%34+5?%K(+;D5>I%345>N+?/%?+H?+/+>35>I%;%J5D+%?;>I+%'@%+OH+?35/+%f%@?'*%

B'/*'('IG-% ;/3?'H4G/5B/% ;>D% :5'('IG% 3'% =+J% 8+/3;*+>3% /3)D5+/-% 34+'('IG% ;>D%

H45('/'H4G%f%3'%\'5>%5>%?+/H'>D5>I%3'%34+/+%;?I)*+>3/%;>D%B(;5*/7L_,%2BB'?D5>I%3'%

34+% 2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% @;534% 5/% >'3% 3'% :+% )>D+?/3''D% ;/% )>@+33+?+D% :+(5+@% 5>% 34+%

5*H?'6;:(+%;>D%5>+OH(5B;:(+R%@;534%5>%W'D%B;>%:+%3+/3+D-%;?I)+D-%;>D%\)/35@5+D%J534%

+65D+>B+7%#+(5I5'>-%34+?+@'?+-%5/%;%*;33+?%'@%4;65>I%34+%B'??+B3%:+(5+@/7%%

% .%J5((%:+%)/5>I%'>(G%'>+%+//;G%5>%345/%B'((+B35'>%3'%/4'J%34+%J;G/%5>%J45B4%34+%

2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% ?+(G% '>% 34+% /;*+% >'35'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>% ;/% 34+% =+J% 234+5/3/7% 8'%

D+*'>/3?;3+% 34+% B'>/5/3+>BG% '@% 34+/+% 34+*+/% ;B?'//% 34+% +//;G/% 5>% 34+% B'((+B35'>-%

3;N+%>'3+%'@%/'*+%'@%34+%353(+/$%K`65D+>B+%'@%;%A'?;((G%C+?@+B3%W'DL%:G%C;)(%l7%A'/+?R%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%_c%.:5D-%]%%_,%.:5D-%]S,c%


11/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 11%

KW'D% ;>D% C4G/5B/L% :G% "'4>% C'(N5>I4'?>+R% ;>D% KW'D% ;>D% `6'()35'>L% :G%A5B4;+(% "7%

A)??;G7% .>% +;B4% '@% 34+/+% +//;G/-% 34+% ;)34'?% ;HH+;(/% 3'% +534+?% /B5+>35@5B% +65D+>B+-%

?+;/'>-%'?%('I5B%3'%H?'6+%34+%+O5/3+>B+%'@%W'D7%+%!?;5I%+>I;I+/%45*/+(@%

J534%#5B4;?D%9;JN5>/[/% ;?I)*+>3/% ;I;5>/3% 34+% +O5/3+>B+% '@%W'D% 3'% /4'J% 34;3% P,Q%

9;JN5>/%5/%J?'>I-%;>D%P_Q%34;3%34+%+O5/3+>B+%'@%W'D%B;>*:+%H?'6+>%)/5>I%34+%/;*+%

*+34'D/%'@%;?I)*+>3;35'>%P;>D%;//)*H35'>%34;3%:+(5+@%5>%W'D%5/%B+>3?;(%3'%?+(5I5'>Q7%%

% +%!?;5I[/% +//;G%K#5B4;?D%9;JN5>/%'>%2?I)*+>3/%@'?%W'DL% 3;N+/%

)H% 34+% V)+/35'>% '@% W'D[/% +O5/3+>B+% 5>% ?+/H'>/+% 3'% #5B4;?D% 9;JN5>/[/% -."* !&/*

0"%1)(%9+/B?5:5>I%J4;3%*;N+/%;%I''D%;?I)*+>3-%!?;5I%J?53+/-%%

KZ)3%:+@'?+%J+%(''N%;3%/H+B5@5B%;?I)*+>3/-%J+%>++D%3'%:+%B(+;?%J4;3%

*;N+/% @'?% ;% I''D% ;?I)*+>37% ZG% ;>% ;?I)*+>3% .% *+;>% ;% /+?5+/% '@%/3;3+*+>3/% PB;((+D% H?+*5/+/Q% (+;D5>I% 3'% ;% B'>B()/5'>7%8'%:+%;% I''D%

;?I)*+>3-%;>%;?I)*+>3%*)/3%*++3%34?++%B'>D535'>/$%P,Q%53%':+G/%34+%

?)(+/% '@% ('I5BR% P_Q% 53/% H?+*5/+/% ;?+% 3?)+R% P0Q% 53/% H?+*5/+/% ;?+% *'?+%H(;)/5:(+%34;>%34+5?%'HH'/53+/7%U'%D+@5>+D-%;?+%34+?+%I''D%;?I)*+>3/%

@'?%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+XL__%%

!?;5I[/%;>/J+?%5/%KG+/7L%Z)3%45/%;>/J+?%5/%'@%(+//%B'>B+?>%3'%)/7%#;34+?-%345/%H;H+?%5/%

B'>B+?>+D%J534% 34+% *+34'D/% 4+%)35(5M+/% 3'% B'*+% 3'% ;>G% ;>/J+?7% !?;5I% 65+J/% 34+%

V)+/35'>%'@%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+%3'%:+%;%B+>3?;(%?+(5I5')/%V)+/35'>7%.@%345/%V)+/35'>%J+?+%

>'3%B+>3?;(%3'%45/%:+(5+@/%;:')3%?+(5I5'>-%4+%J')(D%(5N+(G%D5/*5//%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%@'?%

*5/)>D+?/3;>D5>I%34+%*+;>5>I%'@%?+(5I5'>%;>Dm'?%34+%KB'>B+H3L%'@%W'D7%Z)3%4+%D'+/%

>'37%T+%@5>D/%*)B4%?+;/'>%3'%J'??G%;>D-%34+?+@'?+-%D+D5B;3+/%*)B4%35*+%;>D%/H;B+%

3'%?+/H'>D7%%

% !?;5I%B'>B+56+/%'@%W'D%;/%:+5>I%5>+O3?5B;:(G%5>3+?3J5>+D%J534% 34+%>;3)?+%'@%

?+;(53G7%.@%W'D%+O5/3/-%4+%B;>%:+%+OH(;5>+D%J5345>%34+%(;J/%'@%H4G/5B/-%'?%>;3)?+7%T+%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%__%.:5D-%,1%


12/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1Y%

:+(5+6+/%345/%/'%@5?*(G-%34;3-%5@%W'D%5/%H?'6+>%:G%/)B4%(;J/-%4+%:+(5+6+/%;34+5/*%*)/3%

:+% H?'6+>% J?'>I% :G% 34+% /;*+% (;J/7% j>% 34+% =+J% 234+5/3/% P+/H+B5;((G% D5?+B3+D% ;3%

9;JN5>/Q-%4+%J?53+/-%K8'%/)II+/3%34;3%345>I/%B')(D%\)/3%H'H%5>3'%:+5>I%)>B;)/+D%')3%

'@%>'345>I%5/%3'%V)53%D'5>I%/+?5')/%H45('/'H4G%;>D%3'%?+/'?3%3'%*;I5B7L_0%84+%2>;(G35B%

84+5/3[/%;>D%34+%=+J%234+5/3[/%H'/535'>/%*)/3%:+%I?')>D+D%5>%?+;(53G%f%?+;(53G%J45B4%

5/%5>@'?*+D%:G%/B5+>35@5B%+65D+>B+-%('I5B-%;>D%45I4%H(;)/5:5(53G7%F>/;35/@5+D%J534%34+%

=+J%234+5/3/[%+OH(;>;35'>%@'?%34+%:+I5>>5>I%'@%34+%B'/*'/-%!?;5I%H'/53/%34+%34+5/35B%

/3'?G-%K84+?+%/++*/%3'%:+%'>(G%'>+%J;G%')3%'@%345/%D5(+**;-%;>D%34;3%5/%3'%/;G%34;3%

34+% B;)/+% '@% 34+% )>56+?/+[/% :+I5>>5>I% 5/% ;% H+?/'>;(% ;I+>3% J4'% @?++(G% B4''/+/% 3'%

B?+;3+%;%)>56+?/+%5>%35*+7%gnh%B()D+*34;3%;%H+?/'>;(%!?+;3'?%'@%

34+% F>56+?/+% +O5/3/-% J4'% 5/% )>B;)/+D-% :+I5>>5>I(+//-% B4;>I+(+//-% 5**;3+?5;(-%

35*+(+//-% /H;B+(+//% ;>D%)>5*;I5>;:(G% H'J+?@)(7L_1% P.3;(5B/%*5>+Q%845/%+OH(;>;35'>-%

;BB'?D5>I%3'%!?;5I-%5/%*'?+%5>%;BB'?D;>B+%J534%34+%(;J/%'@%>;3)?+%;>D%H4G/5B/7%%

% =+O3-% !?;5I% (''N/% 3'% 34+% K*'?;(% ;?I)*+>3/L% @'?% H?''@% '@% W'D[/% +O5/3+>B+7%

Z+B;)/+%;>%5>SD+H34%+OH'/535'>%'@%+;B4%'@%34+/+%;?I)*+>3/%J')(D%3;N+%)H%3''%*)B4%

/H;B+-%.%J5((%+>D%345/%/+B35'>%/4'?3(G%:G%/)**5>I%)H-%'>B+%;I;5>-%34+%*+34'D'('I5B;(%

;HH?';B4%?;34+?%34;>%34+%5>3+?>;(%;?I)*+>3;35'>7%84+%*'?;(%;?I)*+>3%:+3J++>%34+%

2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%;>D%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%@'?%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+%5/%>'3%;%*;33+?%'@%D+I?++%

'@% I''D>+//% 3'% ;% I?+;3+/3% I''D-% :)3% ?;34+?-% ;:')3% 34+% K':\+B356+% ?+;(53G% '@%*'?;(%

6;()+/%;>D%D)35+/%3'%34+5?%@')>D;35'>%5>%?+;(53G7L_Y%84+?+@'?+-%53%5/%>'3%34;3%2>;(G35B%

84+5/3/% 4;6+% +534+?% :+33+?% '?% J'?/+% *'?;(/R% *'?;(53G% 53/+(@% 5/% +534+?% ;% 34+5/35B%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%_0%.:5D%_1%.:5D-%,e%_Y%.:5D-%,]%%


13/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1^%

B'>B+H35'>%'?%;>% ;34+5/35B% '>+-% :'34%'@%J45B4%*)/3% @5>D%I?')>D5>I% 5>% 345/%J'?(D7%

!?;5I[/%*'?;(%;?I)*+>3-%'@%B')?/+-%5/%B'>/3?)B3+D%3'%H?'6+-%65;%('I5B-%34;3%W'D%D'+/%

+O5/37_^%%

84)/-%J+%/++%34+%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/-%*)B4%(5N+%34+%=+J%234+5/3/-%/):/B?5:5>I%3'%

+//+>35;(5/3%B'>B+H35'>/%'@%?+(5I5'>-%J4+34+?%53%5/%;/B?5:+D%3'%34+%'34+?-%'?%D+@+>D+D%

;/% 53/% 'J>7%-% 34+% 2>;(G35B%

84+5/3/%@'B)/%'>%K34+%!4?5/35;>%b;534-L%J45B4%'BB)H5+/%34+%/;*+%/H;B+%34;3%K?+(5I5'>L%

4'(D/%5>%=+J%234+5/3%B?535V)+/7%84;3%5/%3'%/;G-%;(34')I4%34+%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%*;G%>'3%

@++(% B'*@'?3;:(+%B;((5>I%34+%!4?5/35;>% @;534% K?+(5I5'>-L% 34+G% D'%?+/H'>D%3'% 34+%=+J%

234+5/3% ;33;BN/% '>% ?+(5I5'>% ;/% 34?+;3+>5>I% 3'% /'*+345>I% B+>3?;(% 3'% 34+5?% @;5347%

K#+(5I5'>-L%:+%53%34+%K!4?5/35;>%@;534-L%'?%K?+(5I5'>%5>%I+>+?;(-L%;BB'?D5>I%3'%:'34%/5D+/-%

5/% ;% *;33+?% '@% B'I>5356+% :+(5+@% 34;3% 5/% /):\+B3% 3'% 5>3+((+B3);(% ;?I)*+>3;35'>% ;>D%

/B5+>35@5B% +65D+>B+7% 84+% >+O3% /+B35'>-%J45B4% (''N/% 3'% 34+% J'?N% '@%8;(;(%2/;D-%J5((%

H?5*;?5(G% @)>B35'>% 3'% D5/;II?+I;3+% 345/% )>56+?/;(% ;>D% B'I>5356+% :+(5+@SB+>3+?+D%

D+@5>535'>%'@% ?+(5I5'>%34;3%:'34%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%?+(G%)H'>7%.>%

'34+?%J'?D/-%:G%3?;B5>I%34+%B'>/3?)B35'>%'@%34+%B;3+I'?G%'@%K?+(5I5'>-L%53%J5((%:+B'*+%

+65D+>3%J4G%34+%;@'?+*+>35'>+D%B'>6+?/;35'>/%4;6+%B'*+%3'%345>N%'@%?+(5I5'>%5>%345/%

J;G-% ;>D% J4G% 53% ?+*;5>/% 5*H'?3;>3% 3'% B4;((+>I+% /)B4% >;??'J-% ;>D% (;?I+(G%

)>?+H?+/+>3;356+-%B;3+I'?5B;(%D+@5>535'>/7%

% 8;(;(%2/;D%:+I5>/%3?;B5>I%34+%D+6+('H*+>3%'@%34+%*'D+?>%>'35'>%'@%K?+(5I5'>L%

:G% (''N5>I% 3'% +;?(G% H'/3S+>(5I43+>*+>3% 34')I437% #+(5I5'>-% ;3% 34+% 35*+-% J;/%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%_^%!?;5I[/%A'?;(%2?I)*+>3$%KT+?+[/%;%/5*H(+%*'?;(%;?I)*+>3%@'?%W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+$%P,Q%.@%W'D%D'+/%>'3%

+O5/3-%':\+B356+%*'?;(%6;()+/%;>D%D)35+/%D'%>'3%+O5/3R%P_Q%j:\+B356+%*'?;(%6;()+/%;>D%D)35+/%D'%+O5/3R%

P0Q%84+?+@'?+-%W'D%+O5/3/7%3%/'%H'J+?@)(%5/%>'3%'>(G%34;3%53%5/%('I5B;((G%

5?'>B(;D%:)3%;(/'%34;3%H+'H(+%I+>+?;((G%:+(5+6+%:'34%H?+*5/+/7L%.:5D-%,d7%%


14/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1e%

)>D+?/3''D%3'%:+%;>%K+;?(G%4)*;>%B'>D535'>%@?'*%J45B4%*'D+?>%(;J-%/B5+>B+-%;>D%

H'(535B/%+*+?I+D% ;>D% :+B;*+%D+3;B4+D7L_e% D+?/3''D%3'%:+%5>%(5>+%J534%34+%5>B?+;/5>I%+*H4;/5/%'>%?;35'>;(53G%

;>D% ('I5B-% ?+(5I5'>% J;/% 34')I43% 3'% :+-% 5>% ;% J;G-% (+//% *;3)?+7% T'J+6+?-% *;>G%

B4;((+>I+D%345/%>'35'>-%5>/5/35>I%K?+(5I5'>%4;/%;>%;)3'>'*')/%+//+>B+L%J45B4%B;>%:+%

D+@5>+D%K;/%;%3?;>/45/3'?5B;(%;>D%3?;>/B)(3)?;(%H4+>'*+>'>7L_d%2/;D%H'5>3/%')3%34;3%

/)B4%)>56+?/;(%D+@5>535'>/%'@%?+(5I5'>%;?+%>'3%3?)+%3'%34+%C$4(&1)%@'?*/%'@%K?+(5I5'>L%

34;3% 4;6+% +O5/3+D% '6+?% 35*+% ;>D% ('B;35'>-% ;>D% @)?34+?*'?+-% 34;3% 34+% 6+?G% ;B3% '@%

KD+@5>5>IL%?+(5I5'>%5/%53/+(@%;%45/3'?5B;((G%D5/B)?/56+%H?;B35B+7%T+%J?53+/-%%

K.3% 5/% H;?3% '@% *G% :;/5B% ;?I)*+>3% 34;3% /'B5;((G% 5D+>35@5;:(+% @'?*/-%

H?+B'>D535'>/-% ;>D% +@@+B3/% '@% J4;3% J;/% ?+I;?D+D% ;/% ?+(5I5'>% 5>% 34+%*+D5+6;(% !4?5/35;>% +H'B4% J+?+% V)53+% D5@@+?+>3% @?'*% 34'/+% /'%

B'>/5D+?+D%5>%*'D+?>%/'B5+3G7%gnh%AG%;?I)*+>3%5/%34;3%34+?+%B;>>'3%

:+%;%)>56+?/;(%D+@5>535'>%'@%?+(5I5'>-%>'3%'>(G%:+B;)/+%53/%B'>/353)+>3%+(+*+>3/%;>D%?+(;35'>/45H/%;?+%45/3'?5B;((G%/H+B5@5B-%:)3%:+B;)/+%34;3%

D+@5>535'>%5/%53/+(@%34+%45/3'?5B;(%H?'D)B3%'@%D5/B)?/56+%H?'B+//+/7L_]%%

.>%'?D+?%3'%I?')>D%45/%B(;5*/%5>%45/3'?5B;(%H?;B35B+-%2/;D%@'B)/+/%'>%!(5@@'?D%W++?3M-%

J4'-% (5N+% *;>G% '34+?/-% 4;/% '@@+?+D% ;>% +//+>35;(5/3% ;>D% )>56+?/;(% D+@5>535'>% '@%

?+(5I5'>70c%C;?3%'@%*G%;?I)*+>3%5/%34;3%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%4;6+%

?+D)B+D%?+(5I5'>%3'%34+%B'I>5356+%V)+/35'>%'@%:+(5+@%5>%W'D%5>%J;G/%34;3%D'+/%>'3%H;G%

?+/H+B3%3'%34+%6;?5+3G%'@%H'//5:(+%+(+*+>3/%J45B4%*;N+%)H%'>+[/%?+(5I5')/% 5D+>353G7%

2/;D% ;I?++/% J4+>% /H+;N5>I% ;:')3% W++?3M[/% D+@5>535'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>$% K!'I>5356+%

V)+/35'>/%;?+%*5O+D%)H%5>%345/%;BB')>3%J534%B'**)>5B;356+%'>+/-%;>D%345/%*;N+/%53%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%_e%2/;D-%_e%_d%.:5D-%_d%_]%.:5D-%_]%0c%W++?3M[/%D+@5>535'>%'@%?+(5I5'>$%#+(5I5'>%5/%KP,Q%;%/G/3+*%'@%/G*:'(/%J45B4%;B3%3'%P_Q%+/3;:(5/4%

H'J+?@)(-%H+?6;/56+-%;>D%('>IS(;/35>I%*''D/%;>D%*'356;35'>/%5>%*+>%:G%P0Q%@'?*)(;35>I%B'>B+H35'>/%

'@%;%I+>+?;(%'?D+?%'@%+O5/3+>B+%;>D%P1Q%B('345>I%34+/+%B'>B+H35'>/%J534%/)B4%;>%;)?;%'@%@;B3);(53G%34;3%

PYQ%34+%*''D/%;>D%*'356;35'>/%/++*%)>5V)+(G%?+;(5/35B7L%.:5D-%_]S0c7%%


15/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1d%

D5@@5B)(3% 3'% 5>V)5?+% 5>3'% 34+% J;G/% 5>% J45B4% D5/B')?/+% ;>D% )>D+?/3;>D5>I% ;?+%

B'>>+B3+D%5>%/'B5;(%H?;B35B+7L0,%84+%H?':(+*%J534%@'B)/5>I%'>%:+(5+@%'>(G-%;/%34+%=+J%

234+5/3/% ;>D% 2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% D'-% 5/% 34;3% *;>G% '@% 34+% H?;B3535'>+?[/% B(;5*/% ;?+%

;:/3?;B3+D% 3'% ;% D+I?++% J4+?+% 34+G% >'% ('>I+?% *;N+% /+>/+7% C?'65>I% 34+% ?+;(53G% '@%

3?;>/):/3;>35;35'>% D)?5>I% 34+% `)B4;?5/3-% @'?% +O;*H(+-% B;??5+/% (533(+% 3'% >'% J+5I43-%

J4+>%D5/;//'B5;3+D%J534%;((%'@%53/%'34+?%P>'>SB'I>5356+%:+(5+@Q%+(+*+>3/7%%

% K.3%5/%;%*'D+?>%5D+;-L%2/;D%3+((/%)/-%K34;3%;%H?;B3535'>+?%B;>>'3%N>'J%4'J%3'%

(56+%?+(5I5')/(G%J534')3%:+5>I%;:(+%3'%;?35B)(;3+%34;3%N>'J(+DI+7L0_%84+%:')>D;?5+/%

:+3J++>%34+%?+(5I5')/%;>D%34+%/+B)(;?-%5>%'34+?%J'?D/-%4;6+%>'3%;(J;G/%:++>%D?;J>%

5>% 34+% /;*+% J;G7% b'?% B+>3)?5+/% 34+% ;)34'?53G% '@% 34+% !4)?B4-% J534% 53/% D'B3?5>+-%

H?;B35B+/-% ;>D%B?++D/-% ?+*;5>+D% B+>3?;(% 3'%D'*5>;>3%B'>B+H35'>/% '@%J4;3% ?+(5I5'>%

B'>/5/3+D%'@700%2%/45@3%'BB)??+D-%;BB'?D5>I%3'%2/;D-%J45B4%;(3+?+D%H?+S#+@'?*;35'>%

B'>B+H35'>/%'@%?+(5I5'>%3'%*'?+%H'5>3+D%D+@5>535'>/%'@%?+(5I5'>7%T+%J?53+/-%K.>%(;3+?%

B+>3)?5+/% gnh% D5/B5H(5>+% P5>3+((+B3);(% ;>D% /'B5;(Q% J')(D% gnh% I?;D);((G% ;:;>D'>%

?+(5I5')/%/H;B+-%(+335>I%k:+(5+@-[%kB'>/B5+>B+-[%;>D%k/+>/5:5(53G[%3;N+%53/%H(;B+7%G13*3."&4:*

A&1%/* )3(%%* B"*#""/"/*3&*/"+(#"* 4"%('(L01% 845/%>++D%3'%D+@5>+%?+(5I5'>%J')(D%3;N+%

/4;H+% D)?5>I% 34+% `;?(G% A'D+?>% H+?5'D% '@% `)?'H+;>% 45/3'?G-% J45B4% B4;*H5'>/%

?+;/'>-% ('I5B-% ;>D% 34+% >;3)?;(% /B5+>B+/7% 84)/-% J+% ;?+% H?'65D+D% J534% ;33?;B356+%

D+@5>535'>/%'@%?+(5I5'>%34;3%;33+*H3%3'%?+B'>B5(+%34+%/H4+?+/%'@%B4)?B4%34+'('IG%;>D%

H'/3S >(5I43+>*+>3%34')I437%845/% (+;D/%3'%;>%+*H4;/5/%'>%:+(5+@-%2/;D%/;G/-%J45B4%

K*+;>3%34;3%4+>B+@'?34%?+(5I5'>%B')(D%:+%B'>B+56+D%;/%;%/+3%'@%H?'H'/535'>/%3'%J45B4%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%0,%.:5D-%0cS0,%0_%.:5D-%0^%00%.:5D-%0]%01%.:5D%


16/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% 1]%

:+(5+6+?/% I;6+% ;//+>3-% ;>D% J45B4% B')(D% 34+?+@'?+% :+% \)DI+D% ;>D% B'*H;?+D% ;/%

:+3J++>%D5@@+?+>3%?+(5I5'>/%;>D%;/%;I;5>/3%>;3)?;(%/B5+>B+7L0Y%%

ZG% 345/% 35*+-% 4'J+6+?-% *;>G% '34+?% ?+(5I5'>/% 4;D% ;(?+;DG% :++>% 5D+>35@5+D%

;?')>D%34+%J'?(D%;>D%>'3%;((%'@%34+*%4;D%/B?5H3)?+7%845/%*;D+%53%*'?+%D5@@5B)(3%3'%

B'>/3?)B3%;% )>56+?/;(% D+@5>535'>% '@% ?+(5I5'>% 34;3%J')(D% 5>B()D+%6;?5')/% K?+(5I5'>/L%

J45(+%/35((%)H4'(D5>I%34+%B+>3?;(%;)34'?53G%'@%/B?5H3)?+7%84+%5D+;%'@%/B?5H3)?+%:+B;*+%

(+//%+//+>35;(% P'?%>'>S+//+>35;(Q% 3'%D+@5>535'>/%'@% ?+(5I5'>R%34+?+@'?+-% ;>'34+?% /45@3%

'BB)??+D7%W'D[/%J'?D/%P/B?5H3)?+Q%J+?+%>'%('>I+?%'@%45I4+/3%;)34'?53GR%?;34+?-%W'D[/%

J'?N/% P>;3)?+Q% K:+B;*+% 34+% ?+;(% /H;B+% '@% D565>+% J?535>I-% ;>D% +6+>3);((G% 34+%

5>D5/H)3;:(+% ;)34'?53G% @'?% 34+% 3?)34% '@% ;((% /;B?+D% 3+O3/%J?533+>% 5>% *+?+(G% 4)*;>%

>;3)?+7L0^%K=;3)?+L%:+B'*+/%34+%)>56+?/;(%+65D+>B+%@'?%3?)34%J45(+%/B?5H3)?+%*+?+(G%

B'>3;5>/% 3?)34-% :)3% 5/% )(35*;3+(G% /):\+B3% 3'% +??'>+')/% 4)*;>% 5>3+?H?+3;35'>7% 845/%

:+B'*+/% *;3+?5;(5M+D% 5>% 34+% B'>6+?/;35'>/% :+3J++>% =+J% 234+5/3/% ;>D% 2>;(G35B%

84+5/3/-%J4'%B'>/3?)B3%34+5?%;?I)*+>3/%5>%?+/H'>/+%3'%@)>D;*+>3;(%?+;(535+/%;:')3%

>;3)?+7%%

845/% *+34'D'('IG-% 4'J+6+?-% D'+/% >'3% >+B+//;?5(G% D+6+('H% 5>% ?+/H'>/+% 3'%

@)>D;*+>3;(% 3?)34/% ;:')3% 34+% J'?(D-% :)3% ?;34+?% @?'*% H;?35B)(;?(G% !4?5/35;>%

H?':(+*/7%2/;D%+OH(;5>/-%K.%J;>3%3'%+*H4;/5M+%34;3%34+%5D+;%'@%=;3)?;(%#+(5I5'>%J;/%

;%B?)B5;(%/3+H%5>%34+%@'?*;35'>%'@%34+%*'D+?>%B'>B+H3%'@%?+(5I5')/%:+(5+@-%+OH+?5+>B+-%

;>D%H?;B35B+-%;>D%34;3%53%J;/%;>%5D+;%D+6+('H+D%5>%?+/H'>/+%3'%H?':(+*/%/H+B5@5B%3'%

!4?5/35;>% 34+'('IG% ;3% ;% H;?35B)(;?% 45/3'?5B;(% \)>B3)?+7L0e% % +6;>I+(5M5>I%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%0Y%.:5D-%1cS1,%0^%.:5D-%1,%0e%.:5D-%1_%


17/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% Yc%

34?')I4')3% 34+% J'?(D-% !4?5/35;>% *5//5'>;?5+/% J'?N+D% ')3% '@% 34+% ;//)*H35'>% 34;3%

K?+(5I5'>L% /4')(D% :+% ;:(+% 3'% K;@@5?*% /'*+345>I% ;:')3% 34+% @)>D;*+>3;(% >;3)?+% '@%

?+;(53G-L%'34+?J5/+%53%/4')(D%:+%B'>/5D+?+D%H(;5>%K>'>/+>/+7L0d%2/;D%B?535B5M+/%W++?3M%

@'?% B'>3?5:)35>I% 4+;65(G% 3'% 34+% >'35'>% 34;3% ?+(5I5')/% 34+'?G% ;>D% H?;B35B+%*)/3% :+%

+//+>35;((G%B'I>5356+-%J4+?+:G%?+(5I5'>%B;>%:+%B(+;>(G%D+@5>+D%;>D%5D+>35@5+D70]%U)B4%

;% B'I>5356+% B'>B+H35'>% '@% ?+(5I5')/% :+(5+@% 5/% ;% 45/3'?5B;(% D+6+('H*+>37% !4;>I+/% 5>%

:+(5+@%4;6+%'BB)??+D%'6+?%35*+%;>D%:G%('B;35'>-%34)/-%2/;D%5/%B'??+B3%3'%/;G-%KJ4;3%

34+%!4?5/35;>%:+(5+6+/%3'D;G%;:')3%W'D-%(5@+%;@3+?%D+;34-%34+%)>56+?/+-%5/%>'3%J4;3%4+%

:+(5+6+D% ;%*5((+>>5)*% ;I'% f% >'?% 5/% 34+%J;G% 4+% ?+/H'>D/% 3'% 5I>'?;>B+-% H;5>% ;>D%

5>\)/35B+%34+%/;*+%>'J%;/%53%J;/%34+>7L1c%%

b)?34+?*'?+-% 34+%B+>3?;(%;)34'?53G% H(;B+D%'>%:+(5+@% 5/%)>J;??;>3+D-% @'?-%;/%

2/;D%>'3+/-%K:+(5+@L%P+/H+B5;((G%34+%J+/3+?>SB'>/3?)B3+D%B'I>5356+%@'?*%'@%:+(5+@Q%5/%

>'3% ;% B'**'>% B4;?;B3+?5/35B% '@% ;((% ?+(5I5'>/71,% Z+(5+@% 5/% ;(J;G/% ?+(;3+D% 3'% '>+[/%

/'B5+3G%;>D%34+%/+3%'@%H?'H'/535'>/%34+%/'B5+3G%@)>B35'>/%)H'>7%K23%;>G%?;3+-L%2/;D%

+OH(;5>/-% K.% 345>N% 53% 5/% >'3% 3''% )>?+;/'>;:(+% 3'% *;5>3;5>% 34;3% k34+% :;/5B% ;O5'*[%

)>D+?(G5>I%J4;3%W++?3M%B;((/%k34+%?+(5I5')/%H+?/H+B356+[%5/%#&3%+6+?GJ4+?+%34+%/;*+7%

.3% 5/% H?++*5>+>3(G% 34+% !4?5/35;>% B4)?B4% 34;3% 4;/% 'BB)H5+D% 53/+(@% J534% 5D+>35@G5>I-%

B)(356;35>I-%;>D%3+/35>I%:+(5+@%;/%;%6+?:;(5M;:(+%5>>+?%B'>D535'>%'@%3?)+%?+(5I5'>7L1_%%

.3%:+B'*+/%')?%?+/H'>/5:5(53G-%34+?+@'?+-%3'%B4;((+>I+%34+%*'D+?>%B'I>53565/3%

>'35'>%'@%?+(5I5'>-%J45B4%5/%+/H')/+D%:G%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%;(5N+7%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%0d%.:5D-%10%0]%.:5D-%11%1c%.:5D-%1^%1,%.:5D-%1d%1_%.:5D%


18/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% Y,%

#+(5I5'>%B;>>'3%:+%+O3?;B3+D%@?'*%53/%(56+D%@'?*R%34+?+@'?+-%J4+>%J+%/H+;N%;:')3%

?+(5I5'>% J+% *)/3% /H+;N% ;:')3% 4'J% ?+(5I5')/% /G*:'(/% ;?+% B'>/3?)B3+D% ;>D%

5*H(+*+>3+D% J5345>% ;% /'B5;(S/3?)B3)?+% ;>D% H/GB4'('I5B;(% H?'B+//7% 2/;D% +OH(;5>/-%

J4+>% 4+% J?53+/-% K#+(5I5')/% /G*:'(/% f% J4+34+?% '>+% 345>N/% '@% 34+*% 5>% 3+?*/% '@%

B'**)>5B;35'>%'?%'@%B'I>535'>-%'@%I)5D5>I%;B35'>%'?%'@%+OH?+//5>I%+*'35'>%f%B;>>'3%

:+% )>D+?/3''D% 5>D+H+>D+>3(G% '@% 34+5?% 45/3'?5B;(% ?+(;35'>/% J534% >'>?+(5I5')/%

/G*:'(/7L10%%

84+?+@'?+-% J4+>% =+J% 234+5/3/% ;>D% 2>;(G35B% 84+5/3/% (+6+?;I+% B?535B5/*/% '?%

/)HH(G% \)/35@5B;35'>/%@'?%;>D%;I;5>/3%K?+(5I5'>-L%'?% K:+(5+@-L%J+%*)/3%V)+/35'>%34+5?%

@')>D;35'>;(%;//)*H35'>/7%84+%?+(+6;>3%V)+/35'>%3'%;/N%5/%>'3%K9'+/%W'D%+O5/3XL%:)3%

?;34+?-%J4;3% D'+/% :+(5+@% '?%D5/:+(5+@% 5>%W'D%*+;>% 3'% 34'/+%J4'% @5>D%6;()+% 5>% 34+%

V)+/35'>7% .3% 5/%*G%B'>3+>35'>% 34;3%H+'H(+%@5>D% ?+(5I5')/%*+;>5>I%')3/5D+%B'I>5356+%

:+(5+@7%84+G%@5>D%6;()+%5>%H?;B35B+%;>D%?53);(-%5>%+OH+?5+>B5>I%34+%J'?(D%34?')I4%;%/+3%

'@%)>V)+/35'>+D%;//)*H35'>/7%%;/N+D%J4;3%?'(+%?+(5I5'>%H(;G/%5>%H+'H(+/%(56+/-%

.%J')(D%:+%/)?H?5/+D%3'%4+;?%;%?+/H'>/+%34;3%?+@+?+>B+/%34+%('I5B;(%/')>D>+//%'@%34+%

'>3'('I5B;(%'?% 3+(+'('I5B;(% ;?I)*+>3% @'?% W'D[/%+O5/3+>B+7% .% ;*%>'3% B'>65>B+D% 34;3%

H+'H(+% @5>D% 6;()+% 5>% 34+5?% ?+(5I5')/% (56+/% :+B;)/+% 34+% /B5+>35@5B% +65D+>B+% 5/%

H+?/);/56+7%E5N+J5/+-%.%V)+/35'>%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%5>%34+5?%;HH?';B47%'3%+O5/3-%;?+%H+'H(+%5>%I+>+?;(%(;?I+(G%)>B'>65>B+D%3'%(+;6+%34+5?%@;534X%

C+?4;H/%53%5/%:+B;)/+%H+'H(+%;?+%>'3%?+(5I5')/%'?%5??+(5I5')/%@'?%34+/+%?+;/'>/7%.3%5/%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%10%.:5D-%Y0%


19/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% Y_%

>'3%34;3%34+%=+J%234+5/3/%;>D%2>;(G35B%84+5/3/%4;6+%34+%J?'>I%;>/J+?/R%?;34+?-%34+G%

;?+%/5*H(G%;/N5>I%34+%J?'>I%V)+/35'>/7%

%

%%

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

((

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

((

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

((

(

(

(

(

(

(


20/20

!"#$%&'()*+%,-%.//)+%,% Y0%

/0"10-2%&34+(

%%

2/;D-%8;(;(7%!"#"$%&'(")*&+*,"%('(D*0()9(?%(#"*$#/*,"$))*&+*7&A"4*(#*H.4()3($#(3:*$#/*I)%$@7%Z;(35*'?+%;>D%E'>D'>$%84+%"'4>/%T'HN5>/%F>56+?/53G%C?+//-%,]]07%

%!?;5I-%+7%K#5B4;?D%9;JN5>/%'>%2?I)*+>3/%@'?%W'D-L%.>%!&/*()*!&&/5*!&/*()*

!4"$35%+D53+D%:G%+%!?;5I%;>D%!4;D%A+5/3+?-%,0S0,7%.((5>'5/$%

.>3+?&;?/53G%C?+//-%_cc]7*

%9;JN5>/-%#5B4;?D7%-."*!&/*0"%1)(%=+J%a'?N-%=a$%b5?/3%A;?5>+?%Z''N/-%_cc^%;>D%

_ccd7%%

W++?3M-%!(5@@'?D7%-."*I#3"4?4"3$3(*&+*H1%314")7%=+J%a'?N-%=a$%Z;/5B%Z''N/-%,]e07%

%T53B4+>/-%!4?5/3'H4+?7%!&/*()*2&3*!4"$3D*E&A*,"%('(*7&())*8C"4:3.(#'7%=+J%a'?N-%

=a$%T;B4+33+%Z''N%W?')H-%_cce7%%%

%%

%

%%

%%

%

%%

%

atheism vs. theism a debate with no winner by jeffrey murico

Documents