b structural concept design report (ttw 2014)
TRANSCRIPT
©JBS&G Australia Pty Ltd | 52304/105953 Rev 1
Appendix B Structural Concept Design Report (TTW 2014)
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 148
concept design report
Walsh Bay Arts Precinct 131646 Concept Structural Design Report
Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd Page i © 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
TABLE OF CONTENTSSection Page
1.0 BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................. 1
2.0 STRUCTURAL ASSESSMENT & MAINTENANCE ...................................................... 1
3.0 SUB-STRUCTURE ......................................................................................................... 1
4.0 PIER 2/3 LEVEL 1 & 3 .................................................................................................... 2
5.0 PIER 2/3 LEVEL 2 PERFORMANCE SPACES ............................................................. 2
6.0 WHARF 4/5 BANGARRA SPACE ................................................................................. 2
7.0 INFORMATION PROVIDED FOR THE FINAL BUSINESS CASE ............................... 2
APPENDIX A
APPENDIX B
© 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
Walsh Bay Arts Precinct Concept Structural Design Report
for Bates Smart
26th February 2014
Job No. 131646
Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd Consulting Engineers ACN 113 578 377 48 Chandos Street St Leonards NSW 2065 PO Box 738 Crows Nest 1585 T 61 2 9439 7288 F 61 2 9439 3146 [email protected] www.ttw.com.au
This document is copyright and is the property of Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd and must not be used without authorisation. © 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
Structural
SYDNEY CANBERRA MELBOURNE QEC 22375
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 149
concept design report
Walsh Bay Arts Precinct 131646 Concept Structural Design Report
Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd Page 2 © 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
and tanks could be below the water level.
4.0 PIER 2/3 LEVEL 1 & 3
The new mezzanine floor structures will need to be of lightweight construction to minimise the additional load applied to the existing columns and piles. The new mezzanine construction could be similar to those added to the Shore Sheds about 10 years ago which consisted of steel floor beams, steel joists and a topping slab. The drawings of the Shore Sheds mezzanine structure are enclosed in Appendix B.
5.0 PIER 2/3 LEVEL 2 PERFORMANCE SPACES
Acoustic requirements for the performance spaces will require new concrete jack-up slabs to be constructed over the existing L2 floor structure. The additional load from these concrete slabs will require additional jack-up piles to be installed. In addition where new mezzanines floors are being added resulting in increased column loads, additional jack-up piles will be required.The existing central row of columns in Pier 2/3 supporting the roof trusses will need to be removed in the performance spaces. The plans enclosed in Appendix A show the locations of the columns to be removed. For both the Bell Rehearsal space and ACO Auditorium it is proposed to retain the existing timber trusses. A new steel supporting beam will be provided above the Bell Rehearsal space and a new steel truss above the ACO Auditorium.
6.0 WHARF 4/5 BANGARRA SPACE
For Studio 2 it is proposed to remove an existing column at Ground level. A new steel beam and jack-up piles will be required as shown on the drawings in Appendix A.
7.0 INFORMATION PROVIDED FOR THE FINAL BUSINESS CASE
Information has been provided for costing of the structural items in the Final Business Case. This included advice regarding pile replacement; new mezzanine floor structure; performance space floor slab to achieve acoustic performance; typical truss design where columns are to be removed; and typical structure for waterfront square.
Authorised by: TAYLOR THOMSON WHITTING (NSW) PTY LTD
David Carolan Director
P:\2013\1316\131646\Reports\TTW\140226 Concept Design report for SSDA_DRAFT.doc
Walsh Bay Arts Precinct 131646 Concept Structural Design Report
Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd Page 1 © 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
1.0 BACKGROUND
The existing structures in the Walsh Bay Arts Precinct, namely Pier 2/3, Pier 4/5 and the Shore Sheds are all timber structures originally constructed in the 1920’s as cargo wharfs and storage sheds. The original structures have undergone various alterations, upgrades and repairs. The original two-level structures were built entirely from hardwood timber. They consist of a sub-structure of piles, headstocks and girders supporting a concrete deck around the perimeter of the Piers and a timber deck inside the building, and a superstructure consisting of floor trusses and roof trusses.
2.0 STRUCTURAL ASSESSMENT & MAINTENANCE
Detailed condition surveys and structural assessments of both Pier 2/3 and Wharf 4/5 have been carried over the last decade. This work has been carried out for NSW Public Works with TTW acting as their consultant for Pier 2/3 and GHD for Wharf 4/5. TTW issued their final “Preliminary Structural Assessment” report for Pier 2/3 on 24th November 2010. For both Pier 2/3 and Wharf 4/5 the results of the condition surveys of the sub-structure and super-structure has been used to carry out a structural analysis of the piers for gravity and lateral loads (wind and earthquake) for compliance with current Australian Standards. The results of the analysis and design checks has enabled repair work to be specified and prioritised. Technical Specifications have been prepared by TTW for Pier 2/3 (issued May 2013) and by GHD for Wharf 4/5 (issued November 2010). The condition surveys consist of visual surveys plus termite monitoring and inspections. From 2011 until now detailed surveys of all of the piles, headstocks and storey posts have been carried out. Structural Maintenance specifications have been prepared for Pier 2/3 and Wharf 4/5 which detail the requirements for pile repair & replacement for piles, headstocks, girders, storey posts and other miscellaneous items. The structural maintenance work required for the piers has been documented by TTW and GHD including priorities on the importance of the repair work. A 10 year maintenance program is now in place which has both preventative and planned maintenance items. Preventative items include ongoing condition surveys (including pile surveys) every 4 years and termite control. Planned maintenance is the repair/replacement work documented by TTW and GHD. The majority of this work is the repair of timber piles and the replacement of timber piles with jack-up piles in cases where the pile has degraded beyond the point of being repairable. Other maintenance items in the 10 year program consist of repair/replacement of non-structural items such as drainage, doors & windows and weatherboards.
3.0 SUB-STRUCTURE
The original timber piles are set out on a 10ft by 10ft grid in the Piers. In the upgrades and repairs carried out on the Piers many of the piles have been regarded as redundant and not repaired as the live load for the recent use of the Piers is much less than the loads required for its original function as a cargo wharf. The opportunity now exists to add jack-up piles to in these redundant pile locations to provide extra footing capacity to support the additional loads intended for Pier 2/3 as described below. The proposed new lifts in Pier 2/3 will require pits below deck level. There may also be new water storage tanks located under the deck. Both the lift pits and water tanks could be reinforced concrete structures supported on the timber piles. If required the base of the pits
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 150
concept design report
B
30
B
WAT
ERFR
ONT
SQU
ARE
NEW
STE
EL T
UBE
PILE
S W
ITH
HIGH
BUIL
D EP
OXY
PAI
NT D
RIVE
N TH
ROUG
HSE
ABED
TO
BE F
OUN
DED
ON S
ANDS
TONE
BED
ROCK
EXIS
TING
TUR
PENT
INE
PILE
S
APPR
OXIM
ATEL
Y 18
0 NE
W
JA
CK-U
P PI
LES
APPR
OXIM
ATEL
Y 4
NEW
JACK
-UP
PILE
S
APPROX 15m
TYPI
CAL
STEE
L JA
CK-U
P PI
LE D
ETAI
L
EXPO
SE E
XIST
ING
TIM
BER
PILE
.CU
T BA
CK T
O SO
UND
TIM
BER
STUM
PRE
MOV
ING
ALL
EVID
ENCE
OF
MAR
INE
BORE
R,SC
OUR,
ROT
AND
DAM
AGE.
REM
OVE
EXIS
TING
STE
EL O
R CO
NCRE
TECO
LLAR
WHE
RE V
ISIB
LE T
O EX
POSE
SPL
ICE.
EXIS
TING
PIL
E SE
GMEN
T AB
OVE
SPLI
CETO
BE
REM
OVED
STEE
L JA
CK-U
P PI
LEW
ITH
HIGH
BUI
LD E
POXY
PAIN
T
BACK
FILL
AS
REQU
IRED
EXIS
TING
HEA
DSTO
CK B
EAM
S
SEAB
ED L
EVEL
VAR
IES
MUDLINE
APPROX
Tayl
or T
hom
son
Whi
tting
(NS
W) P
ty L
td
A.C
.N. 1
13 5
78 3
77
Con
sulti
ng E
ngin
eers
A00
12
35
46
78
910
Arch
itect
Auth
oris
ed
Dra
win
g N
o
Scal
e : A
0
Job
No
Rev
isio
n
Shee
t Sub
ject
Proj
ect
Rev
Desc
riptio
nEn
gDa
teDr
aft
aylo
rTho
mso
nWhi
tting
Dra
wn
T
This
dra
win
g is
cop
yrig
ht a
nd is
the
prop
erty
of T
AYLO
R T
HO
MSO
NW
HIT
TIN
G (N
SW) P
ty L
td a
nd m
ust n
ot b
e us
ed w
ithou
t aut
horis
atio
n.
48 C
hand
os S
treet
St.L
eona
rds
NSW
206
5T:
+61
2 9
439
7288
F:
+61
2 9
439
3146
ttw
syd@
ttw.c
om.a
u
THIS
DR
AWIN
G T
O B
E R
EAD
IN C
ON
JUN
CTI
ON
WIT
HAL
L R
ELEV
ANT
NO
TES
ON
DR
AWIN
G N
O. S
001
WAL
SH B
AYAR
TS P
REC
INC
T
As indi
cate
d
27/0
2/20
14 9
:49:
55 A
M
27/02/2014 9:49:55 AM
P.S.
HD
.C
1316
46SK
1
PILE
LAY
OU
T PL
AN
P121
.02.
14IS
SUED
FO
R IN
FOR
MAT
ION
P.S.
HD
.C
P227
.02.
14FI
NAL
DR
AFT
ISSU
EP.
S.H
D.C
P2
PLOTTED BY: P.S.H ON
PREL
IMIN
ARY
PILI
NG
LAY
OU
T PL
ANSC
ALE
1:25
0
Walsh Bay Arts Precinct 131646 Concept Structural Design Report
Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd Page 3 © 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
Appendix A Structure Plans
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 151
concept design report
NEW
STE
EL F
RAM
ED S
TAIR
AND
BAL
CONY
.NE
W S
TEEL
COL
UMNS
LOC
ATED
OVER
EXI
STIN
G PI
LES
UNDE
R G
ROUN
D FL
OOR
NEW
CAN
TILV
ERED
STE
EL F
RAM
ED B
ALCO
NY.
NEW
800
DEE
P ST
EEL
BEAM
EXIS
TING
HAR
DWO
ODCO
LUM
N UN
DER
TO B
ERE
MOV
ED
200m
m T
OPPI
NG S
LAB
200m
m T
OPPI
NG S
LAB
+ 10
0mm
JACK
-UP
SLAB
250m
m T
OPPI
NG S
LAB
KEY
LEG
END
CONC
RETE
: 32
MPa
REIN
FORC
EMEN
T : 1
40 kg
/m3
AREA
- SH
ARED
REH
EAR
SAL
RAIS
ED A
CCES
S FL
OOR
ON R
ESIL
IENT
MOU
NTS
TOAC
OUST
IC E
NGIN
EERS
DET
AILS
200m
m T
OPPI
NG S
LAB
OF FLOOR BOARDS EXISTING DOUBLE LAYER
EXIS
TING
HAR
DWOO
D JO
ISTS
TYPI
CAL
SEC
TIO
NS
SCAL
E 1:
20
AREA
- AC
O A
UD
ITO
RIU
M
200m
m T
OPPI
NG S
LAB
OF FLOOR BOARDS EXISTING DOUBLE LAYER
EXIS
TING
HAR
DWOO
D JO
ISTS
AREA
250m
m T
OPPI
NG S
LAB
OF FLOOR BOARDS EXISTING DOUBLE LAYER
EXIS
TING
HAR
DWOO
D JO
ISTS
100m
m JA
CK U
P SL
AB
EMBE
LTON
JAC
K-UP
MOUN
TS O
R EQ
IVAL
ENT
Tayl
or T
hom
son
Whi
tting
(NS
W) P
ty L
td
A.C
.N. 1
13 5
78 3
77
Con
sulti
ng E
ngin
eers
A00
12
35
46
78
910
Arch
itect
Auth
oris
ed
Dra
win
g N
o
Scal
e : A
0
Job
No
Rev
isio
n
Shee
t Sub
ject
Proj
ect
Rev
Desc
riptio
nEn
gDa
teDr
aft
aylo
rTho
mso
nWhi
tting
Dra
wn
T
This
dra
win
g is
cop
yrig
ht a
nd is
the
prop
erty
of T
AYLO
R T
HO
MSO
NW
HIT
TIN
G (N
SW) P
ty L
td a
nd m
ust n
ot b
e us
ed w
ithou
t aut
horis
atio
n.
48 C
hand
os S
treet
St.L
eona
rds
NSW
206
5T:
+61
2 9
439
7288
F:
+61
2 9
439
3146
ttw
syd@
ttw.c
om.a
u
THIS
DR
AWIN
G T
O B
E R
EAD
IN C
ON
JUN
CTI
ON
WIT
HAL
L R
ELEV
ANT
NO
TES
ON
DR
AWIN
G N
O. S
001
WAL
SH B
AYAR
TS P
REC
INC
T
As indi
cate
d
27/0
2/20
14 9
:49:
56 A
M
27/02/2014 9:49:56 AM
P.S.
HD
.C
1316
46SK
3
LEVE
L 2
PLAN
P121
.02.
14IS
SUED
FO
R IN
FOR
MAT
ION
P.S.
HD
.C
P227
.02.
14FI
NAL
DR
AFT
ISSU
EP.
S.H
D.C
P2
PLOTTED BY: P.S.H ON
PREL
IMIN
ARY
LEVE
L 2
PLAN
SCAL
E 1:
250
B
30
B
WAT
ERFR
ONT
SQ
UARE
TYPI
CALL
Y HA
RDW
OOD
PLAN
KS O
N HA
RDW
OOD
JOIS
TSON
REI
NFOR
CED
CONC
RETE
HEA
DSTO
CK B
EAM
S ON
STEE
L TU
BE P
ILES
EXIS
TING
HAR
DWOO
D CO
LUM
NTO
BE
REM
OVED
NEW
GRI
LLAG
E OF
STE
EL B
EAM
STO
SUP
PORT
NEW
CON
CRET
E LI
FTPI
T UN
DER
DECK
Tayl
or T
hom
son
Whi
tting
(NS
W) P
ty L
td
A.C
.N. 1
13 5
78 3
77
Con
sulti
ng E
ngin
eers
A00
12
35
46
78
910
Arch
itect
Auth
oris
ed
Dra
win
g N
o
Scal
e : A
0
Job
No
Rev
isio
n
Shee
t Sub
ject
Proj
ect
Rev
Desc
riptio
nEn
gDa
teDr
aft
aylo
rTho
mso
nWhi
tting
Dra
wn
T
This
dra
win
g is
cop
yrig
ht a
nd is
the
prop
erty
of T
AYLO
R T
HO
MSO
NW
HIT
TIN
G (N
SW) P
ty L
td a
nd m
ust n
ot b
e us
ed w
ithou
t aut
horis
atio
n.
48 C
hand
os S
treet
St.L
eona
rds
NSW
206
5T:
+61
2 9
439
7288
F:
+61
2 9
439
3146
ttw
syd@
ttw.c
om.a
u
THIS
DR
AWIN
G T
O B
E R
EAD
IN C
ON
JUN
CTI
ON
WIT
HAL
L R
ELEV
ANT
NO
TES
ON
DR
AWIN
G N
O. S
001
WAL
SH B
AYAR
TS P
REC
INC
T
1 : 2
50
27/0
2/20
14 9
:49:
56 A
M
27/02/2014 9:49:56 AM
P.S.
HD
.C
1316
46SK
2
GR
OU
ND
FLO
OR
PLA
N
P121
.02.
14IS
SUED
FO
R IN
FOR
MAT
ION
P.S.
HD
.C
P227
.02.
14FI
NAL
DR
AFT
ISSU
EP.
S.H
D.C
P2
PLOTTED BY: P.S.H ON
PREL
IMIN
ARY
GR
OU
ND
FLO
OR
PLA
NSC
ALE
1:25
0
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 152
concept design report
Walsh Bay Arts Precinct 131646 Concept Structural Design Report
Taylor Thomson Whitting (NSW) Pty Ltd Page 4 © 2014 Taylor Thomson Whitting
Appendix B Information for FBC
Existing Shore Shed mezzanine drawings
BEAM
SB1
TRUS
S T1
EXIS
TING
ROO
F LA
NTER
NSTO
REM
AIN
1 -
DUCT
ABO
VE R
OOF
NEW
STE
EL F
RAM
ING
FOR
PLAN
T PL
ATFO
RM IN
CEI
LING
SPAC
E
NEW
STE
EL F
RAM
ING
FOR
PLAN
T PL
ATFO
RM IN
CEI
LING
SPAC
E2 -
SCAL
E 1:
200
SECT
ION
1 - T
YPIC
AL S
ECTI
ON T
HROU
GH A
CO A
UDIT
ORIU
M
LEVE
L 2
GROU
ND
SCAL
E 1:
200
TRUS
S T1
ELE
VATI
ONSC
ALE
1:20
0
SECT
ION
2 - T
YPIC
AL S
ECTI
ON T
HROU
GH B
ELL
REHE
ARSA
L SP
ACE
NEW
HAR
DWOO
DPU
RLIN
SNE
W S
TEEL
TRU
SSNE
W S
TEEL
TRU
SS T
120
0 UC
46
TOP
& BO
TTOM
CHO
RDS
150
UC 3
0 W
EB M
EMBE
RS
EXIS
TING
HAR
DWOO
D CO
LUM
NSB
1NE
W 8
00 D
EEP
STEE
L BE
AM
Tayl
or T
hom
son
Whi
tting
(NS
W) P
ty L
td
A.C
.N. 1
13 5
78 3
77
Con
sulti
ng E
ngin
eers
A00
12
35
46
78
910
Arch
itect
Auth
oris
ed
Dra
win
g N
o
Scal
e : A
0
Job
No
Rev
isio
n
Shee
t Sub
ject
Proj
ect
Rev
Desc
riptio
nEn
gDa
teDr
aft
aylo
rTho
mso
nWhi
tting
Dra
wn
T
This
dra
win
g is
cop
yrig
ht a
nd is
the
prop
erty
of T
AYLO
R T
HO
MSO
NW
HIT
TIN
G (N
SW) P
ty L
td a
nd m
ust n
ot b
e us
ed w
ithou
t aut
horis
atio
n.
48 C
hand
os S
treet
St.L
eona
rds
NSW
206
5T:
+61
2 9
439
7288
F:
+61
2 9
439
3146
ttw
syd@
ttw.c
om.a
u
THIS
DR
AWIN
G T
O B
E R
EAD
IN C
ON
JUN
CTI
ON
WIT
HAL
L R
ELEV
ANT
NO
TES
ON
DR
AWIN
G N
O. S
001
WAL
SH B
AYAR
TS P
REC
INC
T
As indi
cate
d
27/0
2/20
14 9
:49:
56 A
M
27/02/2014 9:49:56 AM
P.S.
HD
.C
1316
46SK
4
RO
OF
MAR
KIN
G P
LAN
P121
.02.
14IS
SUED
FO
R IN
FOR
MAT
ION
P.S.
HD
.C
P227
.02.
14FI
NAL
DR
AFT
ISSU
EP.
S.H
D.C
P2
PLOTTED BY: P.S.H ON
PREL
IMIN
ARY
RO
OF
MAR
KIN
G P
LAN
SCAL
E 1:
250
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 153
concept design report
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 154
concept design report
Walsh Bay arts Precinct 155
concept design report
©JBS&G Australia Pty Ltd | 52304/105953 Rev 1
Appendix C Historical Aerial Images
Source: Base Image - © Department of Lands
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_1930
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 1930
Source: Base Image - © Department of Lands
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_1951
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 1951
Source: Base Image - © Department of Lands
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_1961
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 1961
Source: Base Image - © Department of Lands
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_1970
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 1970
Source: Base Image - © Department of Lands
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_1986
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 1986
Source: Base Image - © Department of Lands
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_1999
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 1999
Source: Base Image - © SIX Maps www.maps.six.nsw.gov.au, Imagery Date: 13/04/2011, Accessed: 26/02/2014
A4
Rev0
DescriptionOriginal Issue - Aerials
Drn.LL
Date:26-02-2014
Scale:
Client: ARTS NSWProject: Walsh Bay Preliminary Site AssessmentJob No: 43329 File Name: 43329_2011
© 2014 JBS&G0 50 10025
m
Datum: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 56 - AHD
Legend:Approximate Site Boundary1:2,500 Figure: Walsh Bay - 2011