bangladesh-psychological-operations.pdf
DESCRIPTION
psy opsTRANSCRIPT
Restricted
PSYCHOLOGICAL OPERATIONS
INTRODUCTION
1. Psychology is something indispensable to every rational being and hence
psychological persuation by one rational being to impose his will on the other is also a
normal affair in all kinds of human activities thus the interaction between husband and
wife, teacher and student parents and children, sellers and buyers, political leaders or a
public speaker and their followers or audience or two diplomats from two different
countries-all fall in the broad spectrum of psychological persuation, if not psychological
warfare. The addition of the work ‘warfare’ or ‘operations’ with psychology in place of
persuation only adds a new dimension with the flavour of conflict between two
opponents, to an otherwise innocent concept.
2. However, the term psychological operations (psyops), which is often used
interchangeable with the term psychological warfare, does not solely relate to a war
situation or environment of hostility. Neither its nature and scope involve only two
opponents fighting each other. It’s scope and application is much wider with far reaching
impact in national perspective covering peace as well as war time. In a generic sense it is
one of the four instruments of statecraft, the other three being political, economic and
military instruments involve considerable efforts and resources, psychological means is
less expensive, as it requires human intellect much more than material resources. The
developed countries are fully aware of its tremendous potentials and also exploit it very
skillfully. We fell, it is more important for u s, the people of the third world countries, to
u understand and appreciate its value to compensate our deficiencies in other areas.
AIM
3. To examine the potentials of psy ops in Bangladesh context and recommend a
concept for its effective implementation at both national and military levels.
Restricted1
Restricted
SCOPE
4. Following will be covered:
a. Psy ops- A Conceptual overview
b. Bangladesh- Threats and National Strategy.
c. Psy ops concept for Bangladesh.
(1) National perspective.
(2) Armed Forces Perspective.
(3) Psy ops in CHT.
PSY OPS-A CONCEPTUAL OVERIEW
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE CONCEPT
5. Sun Tzu said in the 5th Century BC, “ Supreme excellence consists in breaking the
enemy’s resistance without fighting.” The message is very clear-why to employ resource
and energy in fighting if objectives can be achieved through a less expensive way.
Clausewitz much later in 19th Century emphasized on breaking enemy’s will to fight for
military victory to be completed or fulfilled. Liddell Hart also talked of and indirect
approach for achieving the military objectives. Then we know of Chengizh Khan’s
employment of agents for spreading rumour in the enemy camp about enormous size of
his forces. In India, Kautilya in his “ Arthashastra” advised on how to destroy enemy
morale by planting agents in the enemy camp to spread rumour about her certain defeat.
In World war I, opposing forces made extensive use of propaganda for achieving the
military objectives. In world war II, Mass propaganda campaign waged by German
propaganda Minister Goebbles is know to all of us. The consequent allied efforts to
counter German propaganda, have given propaganda ware a new dimension and charcter
altogether. Allied propaganda campaign came to be known as political warfare in Britain
and psychological warfare in USA restored the image of propaganda war by rescuing it
from blatant lies of Goebbles style. Churchill’s speeches in 1940 were classic examples
of psychological persuation which inspired the British people to live through the crisis.
Restricted2
Restricted
After world War II in almost all wars namely, Korean War, Sino- Indian conflict of 1962,
China-Vietnam War, Arab Falklands War and the Latest Gulf War, Psy ops played very
important role. Besides, during the protracted period of cold war psy ops war the key
weapon that has been exploited by both the power blocks to undermine each others
ideological strength as well as morale of military force and the people.
6. While ‘psychologicla warfare’ (psy war) and psy ops are often used
interchangeably, the former i.e. psy war was first used in 1920 and psy ops in 1945. Sir J
F C fuller is believed to have been the one who first coned the term psy war in 1920,
when in his treatise on tanks he prophesied that ‘traditional means of warfare (as then
know and understood), might in time be replaces by a purely psy war, wherein, weapons
are not used or battlefield sought …… but (rather) …. The disintegration of the moral
and spiritual life of one nation by the influence of the will of another is accomplished.’’
Though fuller used the term first, the British preferred to call the same activities as
denoted by psy war as political warfare. American used the term psy war in world war II.
However, later on, they have replaced this word by psy ops, as an all inclusive term in
common use. American preferred the word ‘ operation’ to ‘warfare’ to de3scribe an
activity that is directed to friends and neutrals as much as or more than to hostile or
potentially hostile people. It must be mentioned here that since world War II the British
also started using the term psy war or psy ops instead of political warfare.
7. Now let us see how these terms differ from each other:
a. Psy War. The planned use of propaganda and other psychological
actions having the primary purpose of influencing the opinions, emotions,
attitudes, and behaviors of hostile foreign groups in such as way as to support the
achievement of national objectives.
b. Psy ops. Those operations include psy war and, in addition, encompass
those political, military, economic and ideological actions planned and conducted
to create in neutral or friendly foreign groups, the emotions, attitudes or
begaviours to support the achievement of national objective.
Restricted3
Restricted
c. Propaganda. The planned use of communications to influence the
attitudes and behavours of the target audience to achieve national objectives.
8. Some other terms which are important for understanding the subject, will now be
discussed:
a. White propaganda. Source is clearly stated i.e., true.
b. Grey propaganda. Source is not specifically identified. It’s maxture of
ture and false information’s.
c. Blac propaganda. Emanates from a source other that the true one.
d. Target Audience. That group of people towards which a propaganda
message is directed in order to obtain or influence a specific behavior pattern.
e. Strategic Psy Ops. Psy ops directed at military forces, people and areas
in their entirety, designed to further board, long term objectives.
f. Tactical Psy ops. Psy ops directed at military forces and populations
which is designed to exploit psychological vulnerabilities in support of tactical
operations.
May Psy ops
9. Let us now see, why Psy ops should be exploited system atically as a modern
weapon:
a. Setting all issues by brute force of arms alone may not always provide the best
solution.
b. Psy ops is a force multiplier, which aims at achieving the objectives by
influencing rather that killing.
c. Persuading people/opposing force is far cheaper than killing them, as worda
are far less expensive that bullets, let along shells, bombs or missiles.
d. A weapon that can be used skillfully during protracted period of peace time,
without causing direct hostility.
e. A weapon that is effective to undermine the adversary’s potentials at the same
time strengthening morale of own people and armed forces.
f. Extensive physical violence and loss of men and material can be minimized.
Restricted4
Restricted
g. Modern communication media is extremely useful in conducting Psy ops
utilizing existing resources of a country.
h. Advent of modern psychological and behavioural sciences, has given psy ops
a very high degree of sophistications and subtelety enhancing its chance of
success.
i. Signal most important reason for Psy ops is that it can achieve national
objectives substantially thereby reducing the possibility of direct confrontation.
Offensive Vs Defensive Psy ops
10. We have already identified that the target of psy ops need not recessarily be
people or armed formces of potential need not necessarily be people or armed forces of
potential adversary. It could be own people or armed forces as well. Should we call it psy
ops when directed against own people or armed forces? Here the question of offensive
and defensive psy ops come in. Measure taken to safeguarddown people and armed
formces from hostile psy ops measure are defensive in its essence and spirit. The means
and techniques of offensive and defe3nsive psy ops are more or less similar, only
language varies.
Third world perspective
11. The third world countries, embroiled in own economic backwardness, population
problem internal troubles, insurgency in some cases, religious feuds and factionalism,
border disputes with neighbours, need to look at Psy ops from a diffeent angle. Can they
afford to have good network of Psy ops from a diffeents angle. Can they afford to have
good network of psy ops system targeting the hostile audience? It’s a very difficult
proposition for them indeed. When they need to target the audience in the land of
potential adversary, their primary focus will be, perhaps, to set own home in order so
that hostile psy ops cannot have detrimental effect on own people. Therefore, countering
hostile psy campaign, check internal dissensions and subversion will be the main cncern
of an underdeveloped country. The Psy ops, therefore, have to go into psyche of the own
people and armed forces to chech in ternal ailment of a nation. For a third world country
the following may be the objectives of psy ops.
Restricted5
Restricted
a. Building ‘national will’ to survive.
b. Building national pride in own people and armed forces.
c. Make people (including armed forces) aware of national aim, objectives
and interest.
d. Forge national consensus, common outlook on major national issues.
e. Build national morale, a national fiber to develop strength and resilience.
f. Counter hostile subversive propaganda.
g. Put forward own cause in the world forum strongly and earn attention,
sympathy, support and assistance of world community to achieve own national
interest.
h. Established own credibility in the world community particularly in the
countries of immediate concern serving immediate interests.
i. Limited offensive Psy ops targeting people and armed forces of the
potential adversary.
Methods and Techniques.
12. How is it conducted i.e. what are the methods and techniques followed? It is an
objective communication with a view to persuading selected target audience to comply
with the will of the initiator. The four components make the whole process complete:
a. Initiator.
b. Message.
c. Recipient i.e. target audience.
13. The basic essence of psychological operation is ‘credibility’ of the message. If the
target audience suspects the truthfulness of the massage the whole purpose of
psychological operation is bound to be defeated. Goebbles once said- ‘ In propaganda as
in love anything is permissible which is successful’. Goebbles’ propaganda failed in the
long run as it lost its credibility. Credibility must be estaboished and the message has to
be composed with very subtle fine art and sophisticatin, so that objectives are achieved
without arousing any doubt about the intention. In Broader sense the message or
Restricted6
Restricted
communication may not be exclusively a written i.e. printed or spoken message. If we
remember the definition, psy ops measure also include actions. Simply a psysical
presence can also have a psychological impact in addition to physical action.
14. How effective role the present mass media can play in influencing the behaviour
of the people can be understood by the commercials and publicity campaign fro
commercial goods run by radio, television, news paper. The techniques in peace-time and
techniques in war time will have difference, though certain things will be common. In
peace-time a country can utilize the following.
a. Radio/Television (TV)
b. News paper.
c. Foreign Mission (diplomatic channel).
d. Government information service.
e. Drama, Cultural programmes.
f. Films.
g. Publications.
During war time the following may be usefull, in addition to the above:
a. Leaflets.
b. Using prisoner of war for influencing other members in the enemy camp.
Concept of Psy ops organization
15. Psy ops whether military or not, is one among many tools available to assist any
government in the effort to achieve its national strategic or tactical objectives. To
overlook the necessary subordination of Psy ops to national objectives is to misconstrue
the nature and role of Psy ops completely. It is within the dynamic of national security
decision making pattern that psy ops organization must be seen. Nationa security
management is again concerned with the control and integration of the efforts of the
ministry of defense (including armed forces), Ministry of external affairs and various
intelligence organizations. Works of various organs of the Government working to the
attainment of Psy ops objectives must be coordinatied at the highest level to reduce
overpaps and gaps and to systematize inter-agency coordinatin. Policy must be set at the
Restricted7
Restricted
highest level by the national body concerned with national security. Basing of that policy
a central coordinating body. Preferably part of the highest body concerned with national
security, will workout Psy ops strategies and will allocate responsibilities to different line
agencies e.g various interlligence organization, diplomatic missions armed forces,
government information agencies etc. Finally various line agencies will resort to various
media to disseminate their proggammes to the target audience.
16. Personnel. Personnel to be involved at various levels and department
connected with Psy ops are to be drawn from various backgrounds. There has to be a mix
of the following:
a. People with innovative ideas-;Idea Men;.
b. Service personnel connected with defiance planning background.
c. The Technicians
d. The creative men-artist, writers
e. The area experts.
f. Anthropologists, historians, social scientists.
g. Media men with media resources.
h. Intelligence people (Research and analysis).
i. Administrators.
Bangladesh-Threats and National Strategy
17. What is our threat? Who is our adversary? What is our Natinal Interest, objective
and strategies? We must have the answers to these questions is order to determine our
Psy ops objectives and priorities.
Threat Analysis
18. Geo-politically, other than India, Bangladesh shares only a small land and river
frontier of 283 kilometers with myanmer (Burma). Logically the country surrounding
Bangladesh on three sides can be considered major source of potential threat. Now the
Restricted8
Restricted
question arises how this giant neighbour would like to tackle her own national security
concerns as far as those relate to us? Militaryly or economically we do not pose any
threat to this neighbour. But that does not mean, she will not have any strategy for
dealing with us. She may not contemplate any military aggression against us , as this
would noly complicate her existing internal problems especially in her estern part. The
alternative open to her is obviously a long term psy ops strategy. This strategy would in
all progbability include various measures to undermine Bangladesh’s potential in
political, cultural, social and economic fields with a view to crippling us from within, to
neutralize us without resorting to any expesiive military measures. If a nation can be mae
culturally and morally bankrupt, industrially and economically backward, intellectually
nad academically corrupt and above all devoid of any values and ideology, it does not
require to be conquered militarily. Poples’s will and spirit is the main strength of a
nation. If that can be destroyed, i.e national pride, national will to resist foreigh
aggression can be damaged, they can be easily made to comply with the adversary’s will.
While analyzing threat, we must consider external threat in relation to internal
vulnerabilities of the country. Following aspects explain the degree and nature of external
threat in relation to our socio, cultural, political and economic vulnerabilities.
a. Cultural Threat. Because of common historical and cultural
background Bangladeshi are susceptible to our neighbor’s cultural and literary
activities of subversive nature. Through literatures, Cultural programmers, movies
etc. our adversary’s efforts to destroy the core value of society is sure to achieve
success unless appropriate countermeasures are taken.
b. Political and Economic Subversion. Political subversion is aimed
at installing loyal political regime that would follow subservient policy and
comply with will and making our country a good market for the industrial
products of the adversary can be achieved by instigating industrial laborers for
creating prolonged restlessness. The sign and symptom inside the country is
indicative of such attempts.
Restricted9
Restricted
c. Subversion against Armed Forces. Strong armed forces and
healthy civil military relation is a pre-requiste for attaining desired strength of the
nation. Sub-versive propaganda aimed at destroying the loyalty of the members of
the armed forme is a threat to be considered. Our armed forces is particularly
valuerable to such threats as the effects of our cocial restlessness and disorder are
also affecting the armed Forces.
d. Threat Against Education System. The present self destructive
process in the educational institutions may have covert involment of interested
foreign power. Our students community can be a target of hostile psy ops efforts.
e. Fifth Columnists. Fifth columinists form various background and
shades of our society can help the adversary achieve her objectives. When fifth
columnists exist in intelligentsia community, damage is inevitable and deep
rooted. If we are careful, we cannot but notice such indications in our society.
f. Threat Against National Integration. Lack of national consensus
on allmmajor issues in the main characteristic of our socio-economic and political
lifr. An almost entirely homogenous population in terms of religion, language.
Culture in divided on the question of very basic issue like national and cultural
identify. Our neighbour’s interest in perpetuating such schism is quite
understandable. Insurgents in CHT, minority communities are special target of the
adversary’s propaganda besides many other socio-political cultural organizations.
National Interests and Strategies.
19. Our national interest lies, in a word, in our national development, We are not in a
race for military supremacy or acquisition of shphisticated weapons with any country.
Neither we are in the race of asserting our role and status on regional basis. Our foreign
policy is friendship to all and enmity to none. Our national objective is achieving self
reliance in all fields, a homegenous economic development for our people, ensuring their
Restricted10
Restricted
basic need. If this is the national objectives, national strategy is supposed to be
formulated to attai this objective. To achieve the national objectives we need our own
home in order, we need political and social stability social order and discipline for
economic development ot take place unhindered, uninterrupted, we need cooperation of
our neighbours, We need friendly relation with all the countries. We need good bilateral
relation with all the countries. We need good bilateral relation with individual country
and need to establish our position, project our problems and establish our credibility in
the international forum. However, we need to solve our bilateral problem with
neighbours through amicable steelement; but if that is not possible, we need to draw the
sympathy and attention of friendly countries to our cause. Our national objectives,
national interests and national strategies can be summarized as under:
a. National Objectives. Ensure basic needs of the people and
attain a self reliant economy.
b. National Interest.
(1) External help, economic assistance.
(2) External Support to own cause.
c. National Strategy.
(1) Ensure internal stability
(2) Earn Good relation with and sympathy of friendly countries.
(3) Assert own cause and establish own credibility forcefully in the world
community.
PSY OPS CONCEPT FOR BANGLADESH
20. Having identified source and nature of threat and national objectives, interests and
strategy and having understood the concept of Psy ops in general, we are now in a
postion to develop spy ops policy concept fro Bangladesh. First thing we need to do is
deciding upon psy ops policy or objectives.
Restricted11
Restricted
21. National Policy on Psy Ops. If we keep in mind our national objectives it
should not be difficult for us to formulate our national policy on psy ops. We propose that
all psy ops measures should be directed to:
a. Immunise own populace and armed forces from subversive anti-national
propaganda and hostile psy ops measures.
b. Guard against the propaganda or activities of antistate or anti national
elements inside the country.
c. Earn sympathy and support of the world community in general and proven
friendly countries in particular to own cause.
d. Soften up the populace and armed forces of our adversary, so as to make them
understand the futility of their governments hostile efforts.
e. Isolate insurgents in CHT and win the hearts and minds of the pople of CHT.
f. Forge National intergration through achieving national consensus on all
fundamental and major national essues.
Identifying Target Audience
22. Identifying target audience also becomes easy once policy is formulated. To fulfil
above objectives we need to target the following as audience of our Psy ops efforts. First
let us sea target audience inside the country as target of defensive psy ops measures:
a. Own people. When own people is considered a target audience should
we call it Psy ops? The answer to this we discussed earlier that the offensive Psy
ops measure of the hostile country can be countered by defensive psy ops
measures. When Psy ops effort is directed to immunize own people, it is nothing
but defensive Psy ops measures. What we call it is immaterial, since organization
Restricted12
Restricted
and techinique should essentially be the same. Communicating to own people
through mass media or other means is the answer to hostile psy ops measures.
b. Own armed force. Own armed force must be protected aginst hostile
propaganda and subversive activities. For that correct motivation of armed forces
personnel is very important. The motivation should be aimed at building up
confidence and convication amont the member of armed forces, so that they can
themselves identify the hostile psy ops efforts or subversive actions.
c. Minority Communities. Minority communities are also covered,
when we mentioned own populace, but we fell a separate mention is necessary
just to distinguish it as separate target audience. The reason is that they are very
susceptible to hostile psy ops measures, Theire feelings can be easily exploited by
hostile psy ops because of their imagind inferiority complex.
d. Dissidents/Anti-National Elements. Every country has dissident
gourp or anti-national elements. We may call them fifth columnists. We don’t
want to identify them here. But they aremoer or less known, They should be made
specific target of Psy ops measures in order to change their attitude.
e. Insurgents and people of CHT. We shall discuss it separately.
23. Now let’s look at ht list of foreigh target audience. :
a. Government and people of friendly foreigh countries.
b. International community at large.
c. People and armed forces of immediate neighbours.
Organization and Measures
24. National Level. We have already discussed how various organs of the
government get involve in Psy ops functions and in that we have talded about the need
Restricted13
Restricted
for policy making at the highest level. Who does it and how coordination of psy ops
efforts is to be done has been also discussed. If you may recall those aspects, it would
now be easier for us to propose a psy ops organization at national level. A proposed
organizational structure is given at Anx A.
25. Gharger of Duties of Psy ops directorate. Proposed directorate for Psy
ops may have the following as charter of duties:
a. To prepare frame work of psy ops goals and objective within the
Government policy and its strategy. To support strategic plans, it will require to
coordinate its efforts ith the various ministries shown in the organizational chart.
b. During peace time and period of preparation, carry out studied of target of
countries (as established from the angle of Psy ops) prepare programmes for
publicity/propaganda and disseminate them through various media in consultation
with concerned agencies.
c. To study and evaluate the publicity and counger propaganda material for
anti subversion.
d. Prepare special motivational and industrial literature for maintenance of
moral of people and armed forces.
e. To plan and devise suitable efforts in Psy ops against insurgents in CHT.
f. To continuously carry out trials and evaluation and updating of methods,
media and techniques of Psy ops.
26. Mass motivation programme should be undertaken to achieve Psy ops objectives
enumerated earlier through the use of mass media like radio, television, documentary/
feature films, publications, books, pamphlets etc. Question may be raised that this short
of government publicity already, we experience everyday, Is it Psy ops? The answer is
Restricted14
Restricted
‘Yes’ it is a kind of Psy ops aimed exclusively at bolstering named and fame of the
existing government. So the danger of Psy ops organization and intelligence organization
being used for parochial interest of government and government party remains which
must be guarded against to ensure exclusive national interest above every thing.
27. At international level Psy ops measures would include:
a. Exchange of cultural groups and prgrammes with friendly countries, to put
forward own problem and views, earn friendship and sympathy to own cause.
b. Significant role played by our diplomatic missions in international forum
and concerned countries about national view point on various issues.
c. Well thought our and designed foreign language programe of Bangladesh
Radio keeping in mind the psy ops requirements.
d. Guiding Radio/TV programme and national news medias for skillful Psy
ops against the people and armed forces of our immediate neighboring countires
without giving out such intentions.
28. Armed Forces Level: Now let’s see what we can do at armed forces level
for organizing Psy ops. Armed forces would receive necessary guidance and direction
from national Psy ops organization through Ministry of Defence and Supreme
Commander’s Headquarters. A proposed Psy ops organization at armed forces level and
organization of Psy ops unit are given at Anx B and C respectively.
29. Functions of Psy ops unit : The proposed Psy ops unit should be raised under
army Headquarters and it should be s]o organized that it can work centrally as a unit and
carry out Psy ops programme as directed by AHQ. It should also be able to detach small
detachments to perform certain functions at formation level to augement formation Psy
ops efforts. Movies, publications, poster, leaflets (War time or now in CHT) etc. can be
lplanned prepared and distributed by this unit, formation can have their small Psy ops
Restricted15
Restricted
unit in the similar line. However, we propose initially a unit to be resised on experimental
basis under AHQ and later on depending on its effectiveness and utility small unit may
be reised in the formations.
30. Psy ops Measures at Armed Forces Level. The Psy ops measures that
should be undertaken at armed forces level are given below.
a. Troops motivation Programme.
b. Instilling national ideals among all ranks.
c. Creating awareness against hostile subversion and Psy ops measures
d. Motivation propramme among population to ensure better officers intake
for Bangladesh Military Academy and better recruits for arms/ Services.
e. Oranizing armed forces cultural team and arrage visit abroad to establish
goodwill and rapport with friendly countries and their armed forces.
f. Programmes like ANIRBAN and DURBAR to be redesigned keeping in
mind Psy ops requirement i.e. better civil military relations.
g. Arrange quality publication, Journals, literatures for such motivation.
31. Psy ops Training at Armed Forces. The following are suggested:
a. Train commanders at all levels on Psy ops.
b. Train units on psy ops measures and programmes before moving to CHT.
Restricted16
Restricted
c. Train selected officers junior- Commissioned officers, Non-commissioned
officers at Armed Forces Psy ops Training Centre on languages and Psy ops
methods/techniques.
d. Armed Forces Psy ops Training Centre may run two types of courses for
various levels. One is language course and the other is psy ops course covering
the following block subjects:
(1) PSY OPS concept (to incl defensive and offensive Psy ops)
(2) Use and exploitation of modern communication Means.
(3) Motivational Theories and Concept.
(4) Psychological persuation-its need and importance for Armed Forces.
(5) Culture and Society.
CHITTAGONG HILL TRACTS
32. Insurgency problem in Chittagong hill tracts (CHT) demands special attention
with regard to Psy ops measures to be undertaken there. The reason is that the whole
battle is abut winning over hearts and mind of the people for which Psy ops is the answer.
Let us first identify present psy ops efforts in CHT, its shortcoming and then we would
recommend measures to overcome the present shortcomings.
Present Psy ops Efforts in CHT
33. Organization Set up. In Fact there is on organizational set up to prosecute
psychological operation in CHT at national level. The Foreign Ministry has a cell to
monitor activities of insurgents and their front men in international forums. Through this,
the foreign Ministry projects our case and counters insurgent propaganda in these forums
with the help of our missions abroad. The Ministry of Informational has placed the
television team located at Chittagong at the Disposal of Headquarter 24 infantry Division
to cover activities of CHT and project these through Bangladesh Television. Headquarter
Restricted17
Restricted
24 infantry Division carries out psy ops to a limited scale through use of indigenous
means and resources.
34. Pay Ops objectives in CHT. The objective set by the HQ 24 infantry
Division for conducting Psy ops in CHT are as follows:
a. Diplomatically neutralizing international agencies and countries
sympathetic to insurgent cause by presenting our cause to them through
diplomatic channels and by diplomatic manoouvers.
b. Keep People informed about the steps taken by the Government to
improve the lot of the people and arrive at a solution to the problem.
c. Win over and maintain the support of the people.
d. Counter insurgent propaganda.
e. Create public opinion in favor of the Zilla local Government parishads.
f. Effects surrender of Insurgents.
g. Develop confidence of the people of CHT on the security forces and make
the security forces the friend of the people.
h. Project atrocities committed by the insurgents against both the non-tribals
and tribals.
i. Create rift in insurgent leadership and generate frustration among
insurgent ranks.
Restricted18
Restricted
j. Develop greater harmony and atmosphere for coexistence of tribals and
non-tribals.
k. Encourage return of refugees from across the border.
l. Project the anti-people activities of the insurgent leaders.
m. Enhance morale of the security forces.
35. Means and Methods Adopted. The means and the methods pre sently
identified are as follows:
a. Organising regular mess contact prgrammes in important places of CHT at
all level.
b. Motivating the people by friendly discussion/talk whenever possible.
c. Distribution leaflets inside CHT and across the border at regular intervals.
d. Declaring general amnestry to the insurgents from time to time.
e. Organizing visits and briefing of foreign diplomats foreign visitors,
member of various human right organization from time to time.
f. Ensuring regular media coverage of all development activities undertaken
for CHT and the steps taken by the Government to resole the problem.
g. Undertaking pacification and civic action programmed regularly and
continuously.
h. Publishing/broadcasting interviews of tribals on matters of CHT.
Restricted19
Restricted
j. Organizing media coverage of activities of the security forces and local
administration.
Problems and Shortcomings
36. As it can be seen from the foregoing, measure i.e. means and methods have been
rightly identified . But the main problem lies in the lack of organized efforts. In the
absence of policy guidance and coordination at the highest level, the efforts are disjointed
and the main brunt of the efforts are on 24 infantry division, who neither has any
dedicated organization for conducting Psy ops nor has necessary expertise and skill for
the task. There are no personnel trained on Psy ops. We may recall here that the
command and control organization for counter revolutionary warfare set up in Malaysia
during their fight against communist insurgency. Had psy ops committee organized at
every level. Due to this lack of proper organization the military commander and staff
concerned with CHT Perform the task of psy ops in addition to their normal operational
tasks based on their own experience and individual competence. As a result, some do
better than other and continuity of efforts cannot be maintained. For example, a military
commander responsible for a zone may have achieve substantial progress and gains
achieved so far, due to his inexperience or lack of understanding of the psy ops aspects.
Uhus occasional lapses may jeopardize the gains made so far and long range
psychological objectives. Chittagong Hill Tracts Commission, an international
organization formed to investigate human right violation in CHT Vested CHT in
November 1990. One of the Photographs published in their 127 page report has shown
the presence of a policeman with demonstrators displaying banner we love Bangladesh.
The caption of the photograph We love Bangladesh under the watchful eye of the army.
Is enough to damage the gains made in the international forum by our diplomatic
missions. A Small lapse causing big damage. The means and methods that have been
rightly identified are only partially implemented due to lack of organization and skill.
Insurgency in CHT is a regional issue and as such the national broadcasting medias
(Television and Radio) cannot devote worthwhile time on regular basis to cover CHT.
Thereby two very important tools for psy ops which could reach the insurgency even
Restricted20
Restricted
across the border is not utilized. Besides, population mostly being uneducated and
reaching published materials to the insurgents across the border being difficult
propaganda value of printed materials is limited. The other major failure is that our
diplomatic missions have not been able to create a Bangladesh lobby in India to bring
pressure on Indian Government to withdraw support from the insurgents and return for
the refuges. The diplomatic missions also could not impress upon various would forums
like Amnesty International and other bodies that the atrocities done the so called ‘shanty
Bahini’ is much more that astray incidents committed by the local settlers. The problems
of conducting psy ops in CHT can be summarized as under:
a. No dedicated organization and organized offort.
b. Lack of continuity of efforts.
c. No policy guidance and coordination at national level.
d. Lack of trained personnel, expertise and skill
e. Limited value of printed publicity as people are uneducated.
f. Minimal coverage by radio and television.
g. Lack of understanding of the problem by the intelligentsia of the country.
h. Inadequate press coverage of the Government development activates in CHT.
37. To overcome the shortcoming and deficiencies that we have identified we
recommend the followings:
a. An organizational set up at local levels. i.e. at 24 infantry division and 3
regions.
b. These organizations at local levels would receive policy guidance from the
highest level organization that we have already discussed.
c. 24 Infantry division should have its own psy ops unit or a big slice of psy
ops unit to be raised under AHQ (Discussed earlier) should be allotted to 24
infantry division.
Restricted21
Restricted
d. Civil experts, technicians, artists, cartoonists, writers etc. should be
recruited for the local organizations thus set up.
e. Radio transmitters, printing machineries and film projectors should be
arranged for local psy ops organizations to ensure effective and adequate
communications independently.
f. Use of existing TV transmission facilities during idle period.
g. 24 Infantry division and the brigades under it should have their own
dedicated psy ops staffs.
38. The Army Psy ops resources must be utilized in conjunction with civil Psy ops
resources which should be held in 3 hill districts, with local civil administration, civil
resources can also be similar like army’s. Use of TV transmission during idle period,
radio, transmitters and mobile cinema section of Psy ops unit will be highly effective in
reaching large audience in their own language. The whole day programme can be
arranged this way broadcasting cultural programme of Chittagong Hill Tracts, arranging
interviews with tribal leaders, surrendered insurgents and motivation lectures by them.
RECOMMENDATION
39. After examining various aspects of Psy ops in Bangladesh context our
recommendations can be summarized as under:
a. National policy on Psy ops and national level organization to be set up.
b. National security council to be set up and it should control Psy ops efforts
should be basically defensive in nature.
c. Psy ops efforts should be basically defensive in nature.
d. Limited offensive Psy ops should be undertaken to enhance vital national
interests.
Restricted22
Restricted
e. Armed force should have its integral Psy ops resources (Psy ops
organization and equipment).
Conclusion
40. While impending physical damage can be sensed, psychological damage occurs
silently; it creeps into the national psyche and eats up the vitals of the concerned society.
It is more important to keep ourselves safe from such damage by making our people and
armed forces aware on such threat. Therefore, our Psy ops should aim at countering
hostile psy ops efforts which have already threatened our society in a very big way.
41. It is said offense is the best defence. From this perspective we should also
undertake limited Psy ops efforts to put forward our views and get the people and armed
forces of our relevant neighbors or potential adversaries convinced about our cause vis-a-
sis the futility of their Government’s hostile attitude towards us.
42. We must do our best to establish our cause at the international forums, through all
kinds of means targeting friendly and neutral countries. Psy ops efforts whether aimed at
domestic audience of friendly/hostile foreign audience must be well integrated through a
common policy at national level, we fell a materially weaker country like ours can
compensate its shortfalls substantially by undertaking planned psy ops measures. We are
hopeful that our awareness in this regard would certainly take turn into a positive
direction soon.
Restricted23
Restricted
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
1. Balfour Machael, Propaganda in war 1939-1945, rouledge and kegan
limited London 1939.
2. Farago Ladislas, War of Wits, Greenwwd Press Publishers Connecticut
1954.
3. Daugherty William E. In Collaboration with Morris Janowitz, A
pshchological Warfare Casebook, the John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, 1958
4. Mclaurin RH Military Propaganda Psychological Warfare and Operations,
Praeger publisher New Your 1982.
Journals
5. Bhadram R Major Psychological Warfare in Combat Journal The college
of Combat Mhow India August 1989.
6. Khanduri Chandra B Brigadier, Psychological warfare-A case for Detailed
Analysis an organization in combat Journal , Mhow India April 1989.
Restricted24