banks and regulators in fintech: results of 2016 and trends for 2017
TRANSCRIPT
Vladislav SolodkiyManaging Partner @ Life.SREDA VC
Banks and regulators in 2016
Life.SREDA I Life.SREDA II Asia Banking on Blockchain Fund
Moscow Singapore London
2012 2015
2016
2014
13 investments(US, UK, Germany, CIS)
A new venture fund dedicated to investing in the blockchain ecosystem7 successful exits 8
investments(South East Asia)
Research & Vision
Influelce on the whole infustry trough own blogs fintechranking.com and
semi-anual Fintech research “Money of the Future”
www.www.fintech-research.com .com
Bank-as-a-srevice and open API playAccelerator in Singapore
Taiwan
SME-lending
& FactoringPOS-managment
system &
tablet based
cash-registers
-
Online-tra
ding
Online-
lending
P2B-lending
Crowndfunding
& Crowndinvesting
Online-
remittances
PFM&PFP
Insurtech
ddleware
mPOS-acquiring
Online-lending
for students
First BaaS-platform for Asiais very necessary for the future
fintech development
Life.SREDA is supporting a strategic fintechproject: open API Pan-Asian platform BAASIS
Life.SREDA VC Executive summary
and become the most active strategic partners and potential buyers for FinTech startups
WHY BANKS INVEST IN FINTECH:
They buy (for up-sell\cross-sell)
«Outsource» R&D and new products development
To buy talents and drive internal changes
To buy knowledge and access to new complimentary industries
To buy a for their brands
Jay ReinemannThe head of BBVA ventures
“Invest in insights Banks are interested
For now it looks morelike play and PR, notthe real business
Experience of large banks like Goldman Sachs and BBVA shows huge potential
43%
20%
7%
10%
Startup programs to incubate FinTech companies
Partnering with FinTech companies
Setup venture funds to fund FinTech companies
Launched own FinTech subsidiaries
AcquiredFinTech companies
20%Banks
&FinTech
~30% banksinvested via their ownventure instruments
– VCs, accelerators, incubators
Banks are getting more and more active in FinTechBarclays, Goldman, CITI, Santander and BBVA are leading the show
Major Bank Investments to VC-backed Fintech Companies
-2015 -2016more companiesfunded by banks
in 2016
+61%
Top South-Asian banks are starting to follow Chinese/HK/Japanese/Korean megabanks
with playing active role in FinTech: DBS, OCBC, UOB, Siam Commer-cial Bank, Mandiri, RHB, MayBank, CIMB, KasikornBank and others
laucnehd a bunch of initiatives related to fintech
Leaders are mainly from developed
fintech regions
US, UK, Europe.
No
te/s
ou
rce
: So
urc
e: M
atte
rmar
k,
Life
.SR
ED
A V
C a
nal
ysis
, Cru
nch
b
23
15
13
8
3 3 3 3 32 2
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
17
97
64
6 6 5 5 54 4 4 4 4
3 3 32
1 12
1 1 1 12
Bar
clay
s
Go
ldm
an S
ach
s
Cit
i Gro
up
San
tan
de
r
BB
VA
We
lls
Farg
o
Co
mm
erz
ban
k
Mo
rgan
Sta
nle
y
HSB
C
Cre
dit
Su
isse
BN
P P
arib
as
Mit
sub
ish
i UFJ
Miz
uh
o
JP M
org
an
Cap
ital
On
e
Ch
ina
De
velo
pm
en
t B
ank
UB
S
Sbe
rban
k
Ch
ina
Co
nst
ruc
tio
n B
ank
Cre
dit
Ag
rico
le
Soci
ete
Ge
ne
rale
ICIC
I
Siam
Co
mm
erc
ial B
ank
OC
BC
Man
dir
i Ban
k
however partnerships in 2016 seemed to be saferand more convenient for banks
Banks’ partnerships with financial technology start-upsare developing,
Enable Citi card members to use their Citi Cards with PayPal online, in-app and in stores
P2P payments, provides making payments via the social networks
Offering investing advice and data-driven recommendations
P2P-lending. Enables local SMEs to borrow short-term business loans
Study and test blockchain technology to enable payment transactions
Provides direct financing to SMEs
To contribute to the acceleration of the rollout of its digital strategy
Online wealth management platform
Automotive pricing and information website for car buyers and dealers
Offering its clients access to equity crowdfunding opportunities
Use Fincast to advise customers on the types of financial products they need to meet their investment goals
To offer a TD and Westpacbranded spending app
An extensive interest was shown by banks and financial institutions partnering with robo-advisors, digital wealth managers;
In addition, there is a growing tendency by banks to partner with crowdfunding companies (Santander, UOB, Belfius Bank, Alfa Bank, etc);
Asian banks are widely partnering with Fintech accelerators in order to pilot new products with fintechs residents;
Many pilots were initiated in 2016 between blockchain companies and banks worldwide(SG, SCB, Barclays, etc)
Venture/debt investments and acquisitions from banks
Q4 D N/A
Q4 A $8,3M
Q3 A $8,3M
Q3 undisclosed
Q2 A $14M
Q3 $19.67M
Q2 $33MD
Q2 $56M
Q2 D $75M
As mentioned earlier,partnerships and investments are closely linked, however, investments primarily focused on realizing returns;
Investments generally go from venture instruments of banks:VCs, accelerators, debts financing;
Asian banks are getting involvedand investing through the partnerships with accelerators(StartupBootCamp Fintech, Nest, etc.)
Q4 $100M
Overall trend
In order to achieve leading positions on the market banks should shift a strategy from «competitive with Fintech» to «collaborate with Fintech»
Increasing customer requirements for banking services along with growing pressure fromthe Fintech startups will shift bank’s strategy to «if you can’t beat them, join them» approach.
Collaborative Fintech investmentsvs Competitive Fintech investments ($ Bln)
The expectations of clients are higher than ever,and are broadly consistent across various sectors and contexts
Efficient. Users want processes to be streamlined andcohesive, with key functions ‘bundled’ for userconvenience.
Real-time. The trajectory of digitalization has led tonear-instant transactions and up-to-the-second visibilityover cash-flows.
Integrated and flexible. Users expect a one-stop portalwith seamless reconciliation across their user profiles.
Accessible. Users expect channel convergence and accessto services on multiple devices through a user-friendly andinstinctive interface.
Individualized and contextually relevant. Users expectadvisory services, information and suggestions reflectingtheir transaction and activity history and other user-specificdata.
1 2
71% 56%
29%
2014
Collaborative
Competetive
0.0
4.0
8.0
12.0
16.0
20.0
2015
44%
+15%
Banks and Fintech. For what reason?
Clearly, not all of today’s banks will survive. The survivors will be those that reimagine relationships with their customers and partners.
Fintech offers banks access to technologies, brings new ideas to market at speed,enables to add value from bank’s data and changes bank’s culture
SuccessfulPartnership
Why banks need FinTech?Acces to ideasAcces to new technologyAcces to agility: speed to marketAcces to expertise around dataExposure to different culture
Acces to customers - trust, inertiaAcces to clearing and Central BanksettlementAcces to in-depth payments expertiseAcces to dataAvoidance of regulation
Why FinTech need banks?
Key areas of development in a traditional retail bank
Mobile and digital
Digital customers are already thereTechnology is accessible to allFocus is to attract new young generation
Services based on customer behavior:Prior to payment transaction (predictive)At the moment of transaction (instant)After payment transaction
Partnering with Big-tech?Partnering with Schemes?Partnering with Fintech?Joint venture with GP
Operational excellence and digitalizationCost reduction and optimizationAreas of synergy
Data-rich solution:Dynamic business steeringBehavior-driven marketingData-rich consumer and applications
Data monetization and analytics
P&L - Internal Processes
Value Added Services (New revenues)
New Business Models
Key Areas for RetailBANKS
Development areas
OperationWho will control and develop?
How to integrate? How to invite foreign projects?
E-w
alle
ts
Ne
ob
anks
mP
OS
On
line
acq
uir
ing
Cas
h r
eg
iste
r /
PO
S so
luti
on
s
Cro
wd
fun
din
g
Cro
wd
inve
stin
g
On
line
len
din
g f
or
ind
ivid
ual
s
P2
P lo
ans
SME
Le
nd
ing O
nlin
e s
cori
ng
Trad
ing
We
alth
man
age
me
nt
Re
mit
tan
ces
Pri
ce c
om
par
iso
n
PFM
/ P
FP
Insu
rTe
ch
Re
gTe
ch
Aco
un
tin
g
Blo
ckch
ain
BusinessWho will possess clients / startups?
ValueHow to help partners to expandto other markets?
Fin
tech
sfo
r re
tail
for
SME
it is expensive it takes time it is not main business / KPI
Banks’ pain
Pri
ceco
mp
aris
on
Re
mit
tan
ces
We
alth
man
age
me
nt
Trad
ing
On
line
sco
rin
g
SME
Le
nd
ing
P2
P lo
ans
On
line
len
din
gfo
r in
div
idu
als
Cro
wd
inve
stin
g
Cro
wd
fun
din
g
E-w
alle
ts
Cas
h r
eg
iste
rP
OS
solu
tio
ns
On
line
acq
uir
ing
mP
OS
Ne
ob
anks
Re
gTe
ch
Aco
un
tin
g
Insu
rTe
ch
PFM
/PFP
Blo
ckch
ain
Bit
coin
There are more than 20 verticals in Fintech and more than 20 leaders in each vertical(about 5K Fintechs total)
How to connect?
Banks’ pain: With whom to work?
Strategies for Banks to survive the coming change
How can traditional banks move fromtraditional banking to the digitaldistribution of data in a globalizednetwork?
Do large incumbents have to partner withFinTech or will FinTech companies eat thebanks’ lunch?
Change the technical architecture and theorganisation to become a customer centricdigital platform or launch a new bank withdigital as core. While the majority of bankingexecutives may feel comfort today, this mayrepresent the calm before the storm as somevery tough structural decision will be requiredaround investment in systems, distributionand new innovative products. Being big andstrong may not be enough to win the battle forthe customer in the future. Speed and agilitycount just as much…if not more.
Independent commentator on the financial markets and fintech,author of the bestselling book Digital Bank & ValueWeb, contributorto BBC News, Sky News, CNBC and Bloomberg and was voted one ofthe most influential people in banking.
David is a FinTech Strategist, Speaker, Scholar & Writer, who iscontinually voted as one of the most popular business and FinTechinfluencers. He spends his time these days helping banks, regulators &governments be better. David is CEO of 11:FS and was most recently theGlobal Director of Digital Banking in Gartner.
The most significant trend of 2016 onwards willbe the ‘platformification’ of banking, where bothexisting banks and startups begin a strategicshift towards becoming banking platforms, muchlike how Amazon is a platform in retail. Aplug-and-play business model that allowsmultiple participants (producers and consumers)to connect to it, interact with each other andcreate and exchange value. Banks will use ITcompanies to build a FinTech marketplace andtake care of the partnership model, becausebanks have not been successful in the pastmanaging partnerships.
Chris Ckinner David Brear
India
Sri Lanka
Bangladesh
Myanmar
Malaysia
Philippines
Indonesia
Australia
South
Korea
North
Korea
Thailand
Hong Kong
Laos
Cambodia
Singapore
Taiwan
Japan
Bhutan
SME-lendin
& FactoriPOS-management
systems &
tablet based
cash-registers
Online
acquiri
Online-tra
ding
Online-
lending
P2B-lending
Crowdlending&
Crowdinvesting
Online-
remittances
PFM&PFP
mPOS-acquiring
Online-lending
for students
It enables banks to evolveand vital for fintechs as a helperin overcoming regulatory barriersas well as optimizes timeand money consumption beforegoing to market.
is very necessary for the futurefintech development
First BaaS-platform for Asia
APACSouth Korea permits for banks to invest in FintechsCurrently financial laws, financial institutions are allowed to buy stakes only from companies in the same business sector. The FSC have included fintech companies in the scope of the financial industry. #banks #2016
Sou
th K
ore
a
MAS establishesa dedicated Fintech OfficeMAS and the National Research Foundation opened a dedicated FinTech Office to serve as a one-stop virtual entity for all FinTech matters and to promote Singapore as a FinTech hub. #opportunity
Sin
gap
ore
MAS establisheda regulatory sandbox.To allow more flexible application of the regula-tions, while maintaining safeguards to protect consumers and the wider financial system.
Sin
gap
ore Financial Sector Technology
& Innovation schemeMAS committed $225M ($166.48M USD) under the “FSTI” scheme to provide support for the creation of a vibrant ecosystem for innovation. Si
ng
apo
re
6 P2P Lending Licenses Granted in MalaysiaSix P2P lending licenses were granted in Malaysia recently, making them the first authorized platforms in the ASEAN region.
#p2p lending #license #2016
Sou
th K
ore
aM
alay
sia
Korea has launcheda platform for banksThe platform allows financial institutions to build services that automatically populate financial information for new customers.#banking #2016 H
on
g K
on
gHong Kong to launchbanking fintech 'sandbox'
Ho
ng
Ko
ngHong Kong establishes
a Facilitation OfficeHK Monetary Authority established the FinTech Facilitation Office to facilitate the healthy develop-ment of the FinTech ecosystem in Hong Kong and to promote Hong Kong as a FinTech hub in Asia.
#opportunity #2016
P2P Firms Regulationin Indonesia The draft regulation proposed that a Fintech company is required to have Rp. 2 billion in working capital and is required to show Rp. 2.5 billion applying for a business license.
To help maintain Hong Kong's competitiveness asa financial hub by supporting the development of fintech in the banking sector
Ind
on
esia
Malaysia issues the Fintech Regulatory Sandbox To experiment with FinTech solutions in a live controlled environment which is accompanied by the appropriate safeguards
#opportunity
Mal
aysi
a
Establishing an infrastructure
Regulation activities in the APAC and AsiaMost of activities are focused on establishingan early stage infrastructure and development
Sou
rce
: Fin
tech
ran
kin
g.c
om
Key message
APAC EMEARegulation activities in Europe
Most of activities are focused on controllingand regulation of existing regimes
UK sets out open banking API frameworkAimed for the creation of an open banking standard that makes it easy to share and use financial data, arguing that the move would improve choice for customers, promote competition;#regulation #bank #UK O
pen
Ban
kin
gThe cohort of the regulatory sandbox closed 69 firms from a diverse range of sectors, geogra-phies and sizes have been accepted. 24 applications met the sandbox eligibility criteria and were accepted to develop towards testing#regulation #opportunities #UK
San
db
ox
A specially created“Fintech” licence Plans to encourage crowdfunding and the market testing of new technologies. FinTech firms, with a minimum of $300k in capital, are allowed to accept funds from clients, up to $99m, which remain outside the depositor protection scheme and are not subject to the same regulations, auditing and the capital requirements applied to banks.
#Implementation #Switzerland #EU #2016
Ban
kin
g
Standardized mobile andinternet payments (PSD2) in EU
PSD2 enables bank customers, both consumers and businesses, to use third-party providers to manage their finances. In the near future, customers may be using Facebook or Google to pay bills, making P2P transfers and analyse spending, while still having money their safely placed in current bank account.
#Announcement #Payments #Global #2017
Pay
men
ts Solvency II is a programme for insurance regimeIt introduced a new, harmonised EU-wide insurance regulatory regime. The Solvency II programme is divided into three areas, known as pillars: Financial Requirements (Capital Requirement and etc), Governance & Supervision (Own Risk & Solvency Assessment) and Reporting & Disclosure (Insurers required to publish details of the risks facing them).
#Implementation #Insurance #EU #2016
Insu
ran
ce
Controlling & Regulation
Sou
rce
: Fin
tech
ran
kin
g.c
om
Introducing a European Standard for e-InvoicingThe European Commission announced the e-invoicing directive require all 28 EU member states to use specific e-invoicing standards for all B2G e-invoices by November 27, 2018. Europe’s current e-invoicing adoption rate of 24 percent is expected to rise to 95 percent by 2024 and accrue savings of approximately 64.5 billion euros ($72 billion) per year for businesses.
#Announcement #e-invoicing #EU #2018
e-In
voic
ing
Key message
EMEA USAIn May, the third and final part of the 2012 JOBS Act, Regulation Crowdfunding, went into effectRegulation Crowdfunding allows any American startup or small business to raise up to $1 million from friends, family, and followers on debt and equity crowdfunding platforms registered with the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC).
During the course of the year:
21 debt and equity crowdfunding platforms were launched and one, Ufunding Portal, shut down by the SEC because it seemed to be missing some of the statutory requirements required of a funding portal.
Investors committed $19 million to the 186 campaigns and transfered $17.9 million to the 79 funded campaigns.
Over 21,000 individual investments were recorded for 2016. The average investment was $833, and the average number of investors in a funded campaign was 331
The average valuation for a funded campaign was $5.3 million.
#crowdinvesting #results #USA #2016
Cro
wd
fun
din
g Financial technology start-ups to get a licenseto bankThe Office of the Comptroller of the Currency are planning to create a new type of banking license (for example, trust banks and credit card banks) that will allow upstart financial technology companies to expand more quickly across the country. A special purpose national bank must conduct at least one of the following functions: fiduciary activities, receiving deposits or lending money.
The licenses from the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which oversees many national banks, will be available to companies like Square and Lending Club that accept deposits, facilitate electronic payments or lend money.
Many technology firms have been pushing for some sort of new regulatory system that would allow them to cut through the patchwork of state and federal laws that govern financial activities and make it hard to expand nationally.
The OCC acknowledged that Fintech companies’ business models vary widely and that therefore each application should be reviewed individually.
#p2p #license #USA #2016
Ban
kin
g
Shaping certain sectors
Regulation activities in the USMost of activities are focused on shapingcertain sectors within an industry
Source: Fintechranking.com
Key message
Key initiatives in bank-as-a-serviceand open banking areas
BAASIS, launched in 2016 in Singapore, is an open-API Bank-as-a-Service platform, aimed to connect banks and FinTech startups across Asia Pacific region. Currently is in integration phase with several banks on different markets.
In 1H 2016 was launched solarisBank, banking-as-a-platform startup with a full banking license in Germany. It provides account and transaction services, compli-ance and trust solutions, working capital financing, and online loans for fintech startups.
Bancorp – industry leading US-based largest bank-as-a-service platform, hosting 100+ non-banks with processing volume of $200+ billion USD annually. Different clients of different size, including google wallet, PayPal, T-Mobile, yodlee and others
In 4Q 2016 Citi launched global API Developer Portal aimed to open architec-ture to facilitate collaboration with FinTech companies. APIs includes account management, p2p payments, money transfer, rewards, investment purchases and account authorization.
Otkritie, the biggest privately-owned bank in Russia, through the process of integrat-ing with leading digital bank for SMEs Tochka, developed its own modern API-platform, that was later used to integrate with fintech startups, including mobile bank for retail clients Rocketbank.
In 2H 2016 BBVA launched its API market-place, aimed to offer other companies a way to leverage BBVA’s capabilities to build their services. Fintech startups has an access to such APIs as PayStats, Connect, Accounts and Cards
The UK government in 2016 has set up the Open Banking Working Group (OBWG) in order to create an open banking standard that makes it easy to share and use financial data. It includes development of open API to enable services to be built using bank and customer data
In Q4 2016 the Korean Government launched an open banking platform for financial institutions (16 banks) that will allow them to build services that automatically populate financial information for new customers. The platform will essentially serve as database of consumer financial informa-tion that is accessible via API.
In 4Q 2016 The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) published 12 sets of data from MAS’ Monthly Statistical Bulletin as APIs. MAS is encouraging financial industry players to publish open APIs on their datasets, to allow users to connect information and offer innovative solutions
Startups and tech companies Banks Government initiatives
APIs and Open Banking will start to shift the banking landscape with more traction in Europe and Asia, but we’re likely to start seeing the gap between leaders and laggards widen
William Sullivan, Head of Global Financial Services Intelligence for CapGemini
Open banking and API are all the rage
The hype around banking APIs will increase, even overtaking cryptocurrencies. Major banks will launch public API platforms
APIs are arguably one of the biggest topics in the industry.The business model for profiting as a platform is key here, and many are still struggling with it
Global regulators will embrace fintech competition and regulatory concessions …Africa will embrace APIs … financial inclusion will become a mainstream and actionable topic … and the US will embrace change in the regulatory and political system
2015 was all about blockchain. 2016 saw an explosion of interest in machine learning and artifi-cial intelligence. 2017 will be the year of open marketplaces and platforms.Platforms support the rapid cycle deployment of microservices into a financial marketplace...any bank with old legacy technology will start to look like a dinosaur
Shamir Karkal, Head of Open APIs at BBVA
David Brear, CEO and Founder of 11:FS
Chris Skinner, Author and CEO of The Finanser Ltd
Simon Taylor, Co-Founder of 11:FS
www.fintech-research.com